i miss them together so much!!!! they were the groups that introduced me to the experimental sound of kpop. truly ahead of their time and leagues ahead. they weren't afraid to always try different concepts and adapt to it well.
@@bdounionbank7112 lets leave Jessica to her own career, why do we always gotta make her a member when she left 7 years ago, and is doing fantastically on her own. Obviously we love and respect the time she was in SNSD, but now we should love and respect SNSD & Jessica separately.
f (x) and SHINee are the experimental groups of the sm that means their songs are totally different from what is usually in kpop, this song talks about the sewol ferry tragedy, it's a criticism of how the authorities and the captain handled the disaster, honestly shows that SM groups are not afraid to show their discontent through their music
F(x) is one of those groups with the most potential to become super successful, but turned out to be most mistreated by the company. Glad to see you exploring them 👍.
This song was actually a direct critique of the sewol ferry tragedy. They're telling us in a sarcastic/ironic manner to listen to the authorities and that will keep you safe, when that is ultimately what brought on the horrible tragedy due to the authorities major negligence in saving those on board. It's honestly a wonderful song and I respect SM for making such a stand against the government and the authorities that caused this tragedy to happen.
I remember reading the news as it was happening. I was in my high school library and just felt surreal that it was happening since the victims were around my age and everyone was confused on why and how it was happening in the first place.
@@thekeytomyheart_ madness I tell you. I read the entire thing on Wiki after watching a video. They changed sm on the ferry infra wise and also flouted a lot of safety norms. It was so upsetting to see content shared by students in their last moments. Was anybody punished?
*Sorry but this really isn't the meaning of Red Light, they cleared that up in the end. The korean producer for this song development only said that after the ferry disaster had taken place, some months after Red Light album was released. The in house producer had left, he said this to get some clout and guess try to give f(x) a bad name. This album, and song in particular was in production way before the sewol ferry disaster. The lyrics in the song have no relation to ferrys, the sea or sinking. Its really just a stretch at this point from the lyricist, producer and news outlets. If you read the korean you will know the true meaning. SM ent had also released a statement at that time during promotion to clear up the skewed meaning. ^^*
this is not true. sm never confirmed this. their songs are made months, even years in advance, and the time frame was too short for it to be a direct criticism of the event. it's merely a coincidence that the song's lyrics had a slight relevance to it. celebrities/entertainment companies in korea for the most part are the last group of people who will call out the government.
FX'S DISCOGRAPHY WERE SO GOOD ITS WAY AHEAD OF ITS TIME!! IT'S STILL GOOD AFTER ALL THESE YEARS. THEIR PINK TAPE, 4 WALLS AND RED LIGHTS ALBUM ARE ONE OF THE BEST ALBUMS IN ALL OF KPOP
F(x) was an experimental group although I’d say every SM group changes concept every comeback which is the nice thing about SM f(x) was a group ahead of it’s time when it came to their sound
Yeah Kpop back than always release female and male version - Suju & SNSD : Pop, Dance, Fun (expert on entertaiment) - Bigbang & 2NE1 : Swag, Hiphop - SHINee & F(x) : Dance Electronic, Experimental They have similar concept and always together everywhere
I would even say SM has continued with that structure because I find EXO and Red Velvet very similar with their versatility and harmonies (tho I could just be equating them because they are my favorite bg and gg). And then NCT and aespa. (and I just want to clarify that by mentioning versatility and harmonies in regard to EXO and Red Velvet, I'm not saying those are not elements of other groups, especially under SM. Those are just traits I find very prominent for them.)
YEESSSS SHINee's sister contemporary group!!! Thank you, Ivy!! My girls never got the recognition they so well deserve. Just as they were reaching wider recognition a other SM gg came along and SM's focus shifted entirely. I'll never forgive SM for that, among...other things. A lot of the other group's sound was....very similar, and for many of us their early songs were straight up f(X) songs. There was some bad blood amongst fans for Reasons. All members are soloista, although both Krystal and Victoria are focusing on their acting careers. Luna and Amber are still pursuing solo singing careers. Sulli was an actress and singer after leavong the group. You can see her with SHINee's Minho in drama To The Beautiful You (Minho is a much better actor tham this drama suggests). I hope you react to more f(X), as like SHINee, no one else sounds like them. 🙂
I'm not a fan of fx but I used to watch amber from fx said that there was a reason why they cannot make a comeback. As you know they already famous and most of them have individual career and to re-comeback they need to reschedule their schedule with sm schedule. But I agree that it seems like they are the forgotten one in sm and I think they are the experimental group (but the project didnt get too much attention like they thought so they cancel the project ). And I think you should not put blame on other group in sm tho . Its not their fault .
@@syamirarahim7186 Yeah exactly... But the thing is you can hardly blame another GG for the mistreatment of the label , don't you think? For example just take JYP with Miss A.. they were one of the best fractions of 2nd gen Kpop.. But somehow down the road JYP started seeing Suzy as a cash cow and forgot the rest of the members who were way more talented in singing than Suzy... And with Twice gaining all the SNS fame, it was just like a trump card to put away Miss A for good, once and for all.... But none of that was really Twice's fault too 🤷🏻♂️ It's all just their labels' fault for seeing the idols only as cash cows
Their International success might be debatable BUT their domestic success is NOT. They were in the forefront of second gen in a way. Like we all know, 2nd gen was crazy in terms of legendary girl groups produced. Despite that, they still gained a lot of a fame domestically through, NU ABO. But I agree that compared to what they deserved (like Girls Generation kind of deserve fame), their company didnt utilise their success well. But yeah, let's not forget how they blew up SKOR with ther concepts. Their footprints are still there. Red Velvet's experimental side came from them. And it's like a hidden info between MeU's that some of F(x) scratch songs were given to RV
Some information: F(x) as you know debuted in 2009. They were known for being the experimental group of SM. So VERY different sounds and songs for a kpop girl group at the time. There are 5 members in the group; Krystal, Amber, Victoria, Luna and Sulli. We lost our beautiful angel Sulli in 2019
they were called as shinee’s sibling group coz both groups experiment a lot with different genres and they are also very close irl, I guess it’s normal coz they trained together and only shinee and f(x) debuted out of all the trainees during their time. It’s sad that SM wasted their group. I got to know shinee through them coz I stanned them before I became a shawol. They have good songs hoping to see more reactions about them ^^
SHINee supported F(X) above everyone else because F(X) was their sister group and they were supposed to be the female version of SHINee. So everything about the two groups was supposed to mirror each other. They were so close because F(X) was created to have the same dynamic as SHINee. Each of the members of both groups were very similar, with similar roles and personalities. For example, Onew and Victoria were the leaders and they both had more of that mature, gentle personality; Jonghyun and Luna were vocal powerhouses that had similar traits; Minho and Amber were the main rappers, but they are also amazing vocalists and contributed just as much vocally to their groups, plus they had similar personalities; Key and Krystal have that sassy personality and had similar roles in their groups; and Taemin and Sulli were definitely the babies of their groups and had similar quiet and shy personalities, including that they both followed almost the same path as trainees -- i.e. they started young and debuted young. That's why they got along so well because they were so much alike. They understood each other and were family.
The first time I heard F(x) was just so unbelievable for me, their music is so different from others groups. At the first time I'm very confused about that but now I really love all their songs. They're so amazing 🤩. Thanks for your reaction ☺️.
She was soo young at the time as well... I think 16 or 18? I feel she's naturally gifted physically. Even on the athletic TV shows, you can see shes a very fast runner.
f(x) is one of the iconic groups in Kpop industry. They're the group who I respected so much because of how amazing they are. Not all people will like f(x) sound because of how experimental they are but I can confidently say that they're one of the greatest of Kpop and they are ahead of their time. If it is possible, I really hope that they will return as a group soon.
f(x) is my second favorite after Red Velvet, they have so many awesome songs. And they were not afraid to experiment, I admire them. Also the bridges in their songs are filled with crazy good vocals and Luna is probably my favorite female vocalist.
They practically have a different concept in each mv, that makes them unique I hope you can react more to them, 💞 they deserve much more recognition ❤️
@dear dahlia yes, well, I mean that f(x) doesn't follow a line or a story between their mv's like most groups, I feel that you can see one mv and then another and think that they are a complete different group something that (maybe just me) don't usually see in other groups ♡
@dear dahlia for f(x), it not just about the concept but the music and each and everysong in the album are different. Most of the sóng still sound very trendy. Their music is literrally ahead of their time.
Thanks for that reaction, Aaron. 😌 f(x) is a really good group and I think they are mostly the female version of SHINee. They are all very close. Very happy that you are listening to one of their songs. I miss Sulli a lot, she was a nice and talented girl. 😢
forever a bop 💜💜💜 f(x) is considered the sister group of SHINee just like how Girl's Generation and Super Junior considered to be sister and brother group. they have also JUST celebrated their 12th anniversary!!!
F(x) twins of SHINee . This two group is contemporary group for concept, they always try every genre, SM make SHINee n F(x) just like a real twin, they have 5 members, contemporary group, Jonghyun n Luna vocal really awesome!!! Taemin really close with Krystal before, amber n minho really good together, Sulli, Minho, Jonghyun really close to each other , Even Key still support Amber to go out from SM , and dont forget our strong leader Onew n Victoria. Hmm till the end Jonghyun n Sulli together in heaven now :"
There's this song called "Chocolate Love" where both SNSD and F(x) did their own versions to it. It would be so interesting to see your reaction on both versions. Thank you so much for this reaction btw. I swear, you could never go wrong with F(x)! They have flawless discography!! ❤💜
Yay f(x)! Thanks to the patreon that requested it! My fave songs are Rum pum pum pum and Nu ABO 💜 F(x) and SHINee are the original experimental groups ^^
Fun fact : 1. f(x) members debuted in the really early age. 4 of fx members are younger than Irene of RV. 2. Krystal of fx is the younger sister of SNSD Jessica
I'm so happy that you listened to f(x)! They are my favorite kpop group ever and they are known for their experimental sounds and interesting lyrics. I highly recommend looking into the Red Light album, the Pink Tape album and 4 Walls as well.
I've been literally SO addicted to the Red Light era. Right up my alley🙌 and it's still one of my favorite videos of all time. SM had a dark phase back then (style wise). Red light and Taemin's Danger are both from 2014.
f(x) is SHINee's sister group and the female experimental group of SM while SHINee is the male experimental group in SM. f(x) is one of the few groups who could make many different genres their own just like SHINee could. That's why all the experimental things went to them. f(x)'s pink tape is one of the best albums ever.
F(x) our electronic girls. F(x) music make edm trend to Kpop world. F(x) & Shinee is like TWINS group. Aron, you need to react Shinee View & F(x) 4 Walls
f (x) and SHINee are the experimental groups of the sm you should watch another : 1. electric shock 2. rum pum pum pum 3. lacatha 4. pinnocio 5. hot summer 6. 4 walls and theres a lot song from fx is masterpiece
F(X) are the female version of SHINee, so like SHINee, F(X)'s concept is all about being very experimental with their sound and style. And "Red Light" is one of the best examples of that. F(X) is always coming out with something that has never been seen or heard before. They are the girl group who is always one step ahead, who is always paving their own path in the Kpop industry. Nothing they ever do will be expected or simple, it's always meant to push boundaries. And their sound and style can never really be defined, because it's always changing.
Wow wow wow, mad props to the sponsor of this video. F(x) is definitely sitting on my top 3 girls groups of all time. They are so versatile and fun, I hope you get to react to their discography and live stages. They aren’t really NCT female counterparts, they are more SHINee’s sibling group. You got to react to their 4 walls (their lives are a must too- it showcases the choreography), All Mine, Hot Summer, and their albums are solid gold. Unfortunately, SM didn’t promote and managed them well so they ended up leaving the company. They deserve so much more!
f(x) was known for making really good albums. For example their second album Pink Tape was on fuse’s list “41 best album of 2013”. At that time, kpop groups were not even considered in western end year music lists. But f(x) managed to do that. red light and 4walls also were well received by critics.
Welcome to f(x) music world aaron This is just the start i hope u continue reacting to all of their comebacks and then when you're done with the titles u can check out their bsides, u really need to because they are one of the groups with the best bsides. You're gonna hear a lot of uni sounds in this group music but for real you are gonna enjoy it because each song from them is just different. And even tho they stopped releasing music since 2015 but their songs still sounds fresh and new seriously. I really really cant wait to see more reactions from u to my favorite gg in kpop
f(x) have been known as THE experimental group for a long time. The word they were most associated with was "unique", as you said. Their discography is excellent and they really were so far ahead of their time. The concept of Red Light was so shocking when it first came out because no one- especially not girl groups- had done anything like it. Even now, it stands out in the kpop scene for how Dark and gritty it is
SM Entertainment experimental songs 1. SNSD - I Got A Boy 2. f(x) - Red Light 3. Red Velvet - Zimzalabim 4. aespa - Next Level 5. ShiNEE - Ring Ding Dong and all are bops and addictive
All of f(x)'s music was experimental. Their lyrics were always riddle like and they added quite a bit of quirkiness and uniqueness to the music scene. They were the little sister group to SHINee and literally the little sister group to SNSD because Krystal is Jessica's little sister. ^_^ I miss them so much and wish they were treated better by SM...
Red Light actually reminds me of Next Level, i need to listen several times so that i could get used to the beat in the chorus. And i swear to god the bridge is soooooo fucccinnngggg gooooood and addicting!!!! THEIR FREAKING HARMONIES ESP AMBER’S VOICE!!!!!!
Thanks for the reaction Aaron! 💜 I’m so happy with this comment section. I feel like everything f(x) related gets flooded with “rip Sulli 😢” comments when fans just want to celebrate her life, and the art she gave us! Sulli is more than her death ppl!
ikr, I get angry everytime I see this kind of comments under any f(x) or shinee related videos and photos. just by these comments you can tell who is a fan and/or respects these groups and who dgaf and just pretends to care
On another note I highly recommend you listen to Galaxy by Ladies' Code it's a beautiful song and tribute to the 2 lost members, Rise and EunB (RIP). The song itself is amazing and really didn't get the recognition it deserved, I really think you would enjoy it!
Oh I love f(x) so much!! I'm a huge SHINee fan and them and f(x) are my favorite groups and I struggle a lot to find another ones that make me feel all the feelings that I have while listening their music and watching them live or their music videos. It's kinda safe saying that SHINee and f(x) are the most experimental groups of SM and I find that very true because I enjoy them equally. Thanks for this reaction! I hope you can listen to 4 Walls by f(x) it's a true masterpiece, a song that is sister of SHINee's View (told by the composers themselves). This music video reminds me a lot about the book 1984, a society ruled by an authoritarian government that brainwash people with it discourse (the scene where a lot of "people" are watching that man on the screen) and the girls seem like a group of rebels fighting against it. The lyrics make sense with that interpretation too. A producer from SM said that is about the sewol ferry tragedy... But I like mantain my own perspective too. Anyways is one of my favorites Kpop MVs, the aesthetics are awesome as well as the message.
Here, too, they made a trend for Idols, which is face text makeup, eye band, hair accessories and face. They are trend queens. As Victoria said we are not following the current but the one who follows us✨💜
Ah... my ult group, my obsession, my love f(x).. There's no one like them, they really ahead of time. Pink tape still the best album to me. I love them and will always love f(x). I think the trajectory towards experimental music get stronger every new group from SM. The first group would be shinee, and then f(x), redvelvet, NCT, and now aespa. Like you said, f(x) like female NCT, no wonder I loveee NCT muahahahaaha (actually f(x) like female shinee though :))
f(x) is one hell of a total packaged group SM debuted. They got everything. - Vocals, Rap, Visual, Actresses, Musical actress, Models, BEST DISCOGRAPHY
fx is that kind of group that you can't compare with any other 'cause they are unique and I miss them so much by the way, I really think you should do more previous gens groups reactions like this, there are so many bops that were underestimated at the time
F(x) (imo) is the group sm used for experimental songs, rythems, and beats the most. They reaaaaaly influenced the sounds of this generation of Kpop even though hardly anybody ever talks about it. Electric Shock, Rum Pum Pum, Hot Summer, and 4Walls are the next title tracks i'd check out :]
Yesss...f(x) is my second favourite sm girlgroup group after Red velvet.I know almost every one before getting into the group.But they didn't get the recognition.
Ahhh miss them.I think they were really good in terms of music. At that time, they showed very different music to everyone.They are all so talented.They broke up while waiting for their comeback for years. They went through very difficult things and only Shinee supported them in this process. SM spent them, i'm still mad about it. Please react to f(x) -4 Walls
This song is in my top 10 favourite K-pop songs. The instrumental is absolutely insane ♥️ The bass just makes the music so cool. Gosh I miss f(x) so much...
f(x) was known as possibly the biggest and best experimental girl group that (in my opinion) never had a bad comeback until Red Velvet come into the works and debuted. Often they're referred when talking about SM and their shortcomings since everyone saw how much potential the group had but since SM is more interested in their boy groups, or at least they were like that back then, f(x) never reached their full potential. They don't even have a lightstick and they had exactly one concert and that was after a member had left the group. To be honest, for me it's hard to listen to any of their songs now because of all I've said and due to what happened with Sulli.
You picked a hell of first song of fx to react to. This was their I got a Boy, ZimZalbim. SM in its creative experimental mode. I hope you do other reactions to fx. Many feel they have one of the best discographies in kpop
f(x) is one of my favorite groups in kpop along with shinee, red velvet and exid. red light is my favorite release by f(x), i think i’ll never get tired of this song
F(X)- SME most Revolutionary Group and SME most experimental music of kpop! PINK ALBUM THE MOST SUCCESSFUL ALBUM of kpop during their time and that's F(X) Album!
F(x) and shinee were the revolutionary groups of the second generation. The most original of that time.
i miss them together so much!!!! they were the groups that introduced me to the experimental sound of kpop. truly ahead of their time and leagues ahead. they weren't afraid to always try different concepts and adapt to it well.
FACTS
Krystal is actually SNSD's Jessica younger sister!
"former" SNSD member😉
@@bluetimee7165 ot8
yesss
@@meow1023-ph ot9 😂
@@bdounionbank7112 lets leave Jessica to her own career, why do we always gotta make her a member when she left 7 years ago, and is doing fantastically on her own. Obviously we love and respect the time she was in SNSD, but now we should love and respect SNSD & Jessica separately.
f (x) and SHINee are the experimental groups of the sm that means their songs are totally different from what is usually in kpop, this song talks about the sewol ferry tragedy, it's a criticism of how the authorities and the captain handled the disaster, honestly shows that SM groups are not afraid to show their discontent through their music
F(x) is one of those groups with the most potential to become super successful, but turned out to be most mistreated by the company. Glad to see you exploring them 👍.
This song was actually a direct critique of the sewol ferry tragedy. They're telling us in a sarcastic/ironic manner to listen to the authorities and that will keep you safe, when that is ultimately what brought on the horrible tragedy due to the authorities major negligence in saving those on board. It's honestly a wonderful song and I respect SM for making such a stand against the government and the authorities that caused this tragedy to happen.
Well I learnt of the tragedy earlier this year. Extremely sad. And had no idea this connection/reference existed. Thanks!
I remember reading the news as it was happening. I was in my high school library and just felt surreal that it was happening since the victims were around my age and everyone was confused on why and how it was happening in the first place.
@@thekeytomyheart_ madness I tell you. I read the entire thing on Wiki after watching a video. They changed sm on the ferry infra wise and also flouted a lot of safety norms. It was so upsetting to see content shared by students in their last moments. Was anybody punished?
*Sorry but this really isn't the meaning of Red Light, they cleared that up in the end. The korean producer for this song development only said that after the ferry disaster had taken place, some months after Red Light album was released. The in house producer had left, he said this to get some clout and guess try to give f(x) a bad name. This album, and song in particular was in production way before the sewol ferry disaster. The lyrics in the song have no relation to ferrys, the sea or sinking. Its really just a stretch at this point from the lyricist, producer and news outlets. If you read the korean you will know the true meaning. SM ent had also released a statement at that time during promotion to clear up the skewed meaning. ^^*
this is not true. sm never confirmed this. their songs are made months, even years in advance, and the time frame was too short for it to be a direct criticism of the event. it's merely a coincidence that the song's lyrics had a slight relevance to it. celebrities/entertainment companies in korea for the most part are the last group of people who will call out the government.
They were truly ahead of their time. I'll never stop repeating that.
For real
For real
i'm still angry whenever i remember what sm did to them
do not stop, keep repeating THE FACTS.
FX'S DISCOGRAPHY WERE SO GOOD ITS WAY AHEAD OF ITS TIME!! IT'S STILL GOOD AFTER ALL THESE YEARS. THEIR PINK TAPE, 4 WALLS AND RED LIGHTS ALBUM ARE ONE OF THE BEST ALBUMS IN ALL OF KPOP
PINOCCHIO TOO!
Truuuth.
F(x) was an experimental group although I’d say every SM group changes concept every comeback which is the nice thing about SM f(x) was a group ahead of it’s time when it came to their sound
before red velvet FX was Sm's main experimental group they did all kind of music styles
Yeah Kpop back than always release female and male version
- Suju & SNSD : Pop, Dance, Fun (expert on entertaiment)
- Bigbang & 2NE1 : Swag, Hiphop
- SHINee & F(x) : Dance Electronic, Experimental
They have similar concept and always together everywhere
I would love to add Beast and 4Minute too. Love the old bg and gg siblings interaction.
I would even say SM has continued with that structure because I find EXO and Red Velvet very similar with their versatility and harmonies (tho I could just be equating them because they are my favorite bg and gg). And then NCT and aespa.
(and I just want to clarify that by mentioning versatility and harmonies in regard to EXO and Red Velvet, I'm not saying those are not elements of other groups, especially under SM. Those are just traits I find very prominent for them.)
YEESSSS SHINee's sister contemporary group!!! Thank you, Ivy!! My girls never got the recognition they so well deserve. Just as they were reaching wider recognition a other SM gg came along and SM's focus shifted entirely. I'll never forgive SM for that, among...other things. A lot of the other group's sound was....very similar, and for many of us their early songs were straight up f(X) songs. There was some bad blood amongst fans for Reasons.
All members are soloista, although both Krystal and Victoria are focusing on their acting careers. Luna and Amber are still pursuing solo singing careers. Sulli was an actress and singer after leavong the group. You can see her with SHINee's Minho in drama To The Beautiful You (Minho is a much better actor tham this drama suggests).
I hope you react to more f(X), as like SHINee, no one else sounds like them. 🙂
Why do i feel like you're blaming Red Velvet for SM's sh*tty behaviour? 😒
I'm not a fan of fx but I used to watch amber from fx said that there was a reason why they cannot make a comeback. As you know they already famous and most of them have individual career and to re-comeback they need to reschedule their schedule with sm schedule. But I agree that it seems like they are the forgotten one in sm and I think they are the experimental group (but the project didnt get too much attention like they thought so they cancel the project ). And I think you should not put blame on other group in sm tho . Its not their fault .
@@syamirarahim7186 Yeah exactly... But the thing is you can hardly blame another GG for the mistreatment of the label , don't you think? For example just take JYP with Miss A.. they were one of the best fractions of 2nd gen Kpop.. But somehow down the road JYP started seeing Suzy as a cash cow and forgot the rest of the members who were way more talented in singing than Suzy... And with Twice gaining all the SNS fame, it was just like a trump card to put away Miss A for good, once and for all.... But none of that was really Twice's fault too 🤷🏻♂️ It's all just their labels' fault for seeing the idols only as cash cows
Their International success might be debatable BUT their domestic success is NOT. They were in the forefront of second gen in a way. Like we all know, 2nd gen was crazy in terms of legendary girl groups produced. Despite that, they still gained a lot of a fame domestically through, NU ABO. But I agree that compared to what they deserved (like Girls Generation kind of deserve fame), their company didnt utilise their success well. But yeah, let's not forget how they blew up SKOR with ther concepts. Their footprints are still there. Red Velvet's experimental side came from them. And it's like a hidden info between MeU's that some of F(x) scratch songs were given to RV
Victoria also had her solo debut album last year in 2020. She has an offical YT channel, VictoriaSongStudio. Please support.
Some information:
F(x) as you know debuted in 2009. They were known for being the experimental group of SM. So VERY different sounds and songs for a kpop girl group at the time. There are 5 members in the group; Krystal, Amber, Victoria, Luna and Sulli. We lost our beautiful angel Sulli in 2019
they were called as shinee’s sibling group coz both groups experiment a lot with different genres and they are also very close irl, I guess it’s normal coz they trained together and only shinee and f(x) debuted out of all the trainees during their time. It’s sad that SM wasted their group. I got to know shinee through them coz I stanned them before I became a shawol. They have good songs hoping to see more reactions about them ^^
Dracula is a fun song by them.... always appreciated SHINee always choosing them as the girl group they supported over many girl groups
SHINee supported F(X) above everyone else because F(X) was their sister group and they were supposed to be the female version of SHINee. So everything about the two groups was supposed to mirror each other. They were so close because F(X) was created to have the same dynamic as SHINee. Each of the members of both groups were very similar, with similar roles and personalities. For example, Onew and Victoria were the leaders and they both had more of that mature, gentle personality; Jonghyun and Luna were vocal powerhouses that had similar traits; Minho and Amber were the main rappers, but they are also amazing vocalists and contributed just as much vocally to their groups, plus they had similar personalities; Key and Krystal have that sassy personality and had similar roles in their groups; and Taemin and Sulli were definitely the babies of their groups and had similar quiet and shy personalities, including that they both followed almost the same path as trainees -- i.e. they started young and debuted young. That's why they got along so well because they were so much alike. They understood each other and were family.
@@milindawilson9175 it's so damn sad they were tossed aside by SM
@@mariposasabia Agreed. Never understood why they were so neglected.
@@milindawilson9175 low key think bc of Krystal being Jessica's sister
The first time I heard F(x) was just so unbelievable for me, their music is so different from others groups. At the first time I'm very confused about that but now I really love all their songs. They're so amazing 🤩. Thanks for your reaction ☺️.
Krytal is super talented and she even knows figure ice skating. Her performance in a competition were just impressive.
I watched some of Krystal's Kdramas as well
Right. My bias is Sulli but I fell hard for Krystal because of that skating competition. Also, the fact that Queen Yuna was one of the judges.
She was soo young at the time as well... I think 16 or 18? I feel she's naturally gifted physically. Even on the athletic TV shows, you can see shes a very fast runner.
She won the competition too..
High jump in couple dream team with minho,, and for herself/girl jump 1.95 m..
f(x) is one of the iconic groups in Kpop industry. They're the group who I respected so much because of how amazing they are. Not all people will like f(x) sound because of how experimental they are but I can confidently say that they're one of the greatest of Kpop and they are ahead of their time. If it is possible, I really hope that they will return as a group soon.
f(x) is my second favorite after Red Velvet, they have so many awesome songs. And they were not afraid to experiment, I admire them.
Also the bridges in their songs are filled with crazy good vocals and Luna is probably my favorite female vocalist.
Indeed whole f(x) album issa bop, my fav Pink Tape !
Luna's voice is crazy ! I'm sad her solo albums/releases never got that much recognition :(
Suju - SNSD, SHINee - F(x), Big Bang - 2Ne1
This is one of a kind famous bg gg couple
They practically have a different concept in each mv, that makes them unique I hope you can react more to them, 💞 they deserve much more recognition ❤️
@dear dahlia yes, well, I mean that f(x) doesn't follow a line or a story between their mv's like most groups, I feel that you can see one mv and then another and think that they are a complete different group something that (maybe just me) don't usually see in other groups ♡
@dear dahlia for f(x), it not just about the concept but the music and each and everysong in the album are different. Most of the sóng still sound very trendy. Their music is literrally ahead of their time.
They are really one of the most UNIQUE groups of all time
hope you will react more to this group
Thanks for that reaction, Aaron. 😌 f(x) is a really good group and I think they are mostly the female version of SHINee. They are all very close. Very happy that you are listening to one of their songs. I miss Sulli a lot, she was a nice and talented girl. 😢
forever a bop 💜💜💜 f(x) is considered the sister group of SHINee just like how Girl's Generation and Super Junior considered to be sister and brother group. they have also JUST celebrated their 12th anniversary!!!
F(x) twins of SHINee . This two group is contemporary group for concept, they always try every genre, SM make SHINee n F(x) just like a real twin, they have 5 members, contemporary group, Jonghyun n Luna vocal really awesome!!! Taemin really close with Krystal before, amber n minho really good together, Sulli, Minho, Jonghyun really close to each other , Even Key still support Amber to go out from SM , and dont forget our strong leader Onew n Victoria.
Hmm till the end Jonghyun n Sulli together in heaven now :"
There's this song called "Chocolate Love" where both SNSD and F(x) did their own versions to it. It would be so interesting to see your reaction on both versions. Thank you so much for this reaction btw. I swear, you could never go wrong with F(x)! They have flawless discography!! ❤💜
Please!
Yay f(x)! Thanks to the patreon that requested it! My fave songs are Rum pum pum pum and Nu ABO 💜
F(x) and SHINee are the original experimental groups ^^
These songs are my favorite too))
i will never let fx go. i will see them comeback! i’m manifesting it!
Fun fact :
1. f(x) members debuted in the really early age. 4 of fx members are younger than Irene of RV.
2. Krystal of fx is the younger sister of SNSD Jessica
what a song to get into them with lmao. f(x) has to be my fave kpop gg of all time though not another group like them.
I felt like MeU and Shawols should unite to sponsor Aaron for F(SHINee) deep dive reactions 😂
YES
Yess
f(x) truly one and only, and they are the one that introduce this unique sounds into kpop world. F(x) was ahead of their time
f(x) was the reason i got in kpop at 2009 they're legends
I'm so happy that you listened to f(x)! They are my favorite kpop group ever and they are known for their experimental sounds and interesting lyrics. I highly recommend looking into the Red Light album, the Pink Tape album and 4 Walls as well.
F(x) it was so iconic in kpop while it lasted, I'll never forgive SM for disposing of the group as if it were garbage.
I've been literally SO addicted to the Red Light era. Right up my alley🙌 and it's still one of my favorite videos of all time.
SM had a dark phase back then (style wise). Red light and Taemin's Danger are both from 2014.
f(x) is SHINee's sister group and the female experimental group of SM while SHINee is the male experimental group in SM. f(x) is one of the few groups who could make many different genres their own just like SHINee could. That's why all the experimental things went to them. f(x)'s pink tape is one of the best albums ever.
F(x) our electronic girls. F(x) music make edm trend to Kpop world.
F(x) & Shinee is like TWINS group.
Aron, you need to react Shinee View & F(x) 4 Walls
f(x) is the definition of ahead of time. Like you can find this kind of music and concept in nowdays group.
What kind of concept do f(x) have?
f (x) and SHINee are the experimental groups of the sm
you should watch another :
1. electric shock
2. rum pum pum pum
3. lacatha
4. pinnocio
5. hot summer
6. 4 walls
and theres a lot song from fx is masterpiece
F(X) are the female version of SHINee, so like SHINee, F(X)'s concept is all about being very experimental with their sound and style. And "Red Light" is one of the best examples of that. F(X) is always coming out with something that has never been seen or heard before. They are the girl group who is always one step ahead, who is always paving their own path in the Kpop industry. Nothing they ever do will be expected or simple, it's always meant to push boundaries. And their sound and style can never really be defined, because it's always changing.
Wow wow wow, mad props to the sponsor of this video. F(x) is definitely sitting on my top 3 girls groups of all time. They are so versatile and fun, I hope you get to react to their discography and live stages. They aren’t really NCT female counterparts, they are more SHINee’s sibling group. You got to react to their 4 walls (their lives are a must too- it showcases the choreography), All Mine, Hot Summer, and their albums are solid gold. Unfortunately, SM didn’t promote and managed them well so they ended up leaving the company. They deserve so much more!
f(x) was known for making really good albums. For example their second album Pink Tape was on fuse’s list “41 best album of 2013”. At that time, kpop groups were not even considered in western end year music lists. But f(x) managed to do that. red light and 4walls also were well received by critics.
Welcome to f(x) music world aaron This is just the start i hope u continue reacting to all of their comebacks and then when you're done with the titles u can check out their bsides, u really need to because they are one of the groups with the best bsides. You're gonna hear a lot of uni sounds in this group music but for real you are gonna enjoy it because each song from them is just different. And even tho they stopped releasing music since 2015 but their songs still sounds fresh and new seriously. I really really cant wait to see more reactions from u to my favorite gg in kpop
f(x) have been known as THE experimental group for a long time. The word they were most associated with was "unique", as you said. Their discography is excellent and they really were so far ahead of their time.
The concept of Red Light was so shocking when it first came out because no one- especially not girl groups- had done anything like it. Even now, it stands out in the kpop scene for how Dark and gritty it is
SM Entertainment experimental songs
1. SNSD - I Got A Boy
2. f(x) - Red Light
3. Red Velvet - Zimzalabim
4. aespa - Next Level
5. ShiNEE - Ring Ding Dong
and all are bops and addictive
Tvxq’s Triangle and Rising sun too. And Sherlock is more experimental than RDD.
All of f(x)'s music was experimental. Their lyrics were always riddle like and they added quite a bit of quirkiness and uniqueness to the music scene. They were the little sister group to SHINee and literally the little sister group to SNSD because Krystal is Jessica's little sister. ^_^
I miss them so much and wish they were treated better by SM...
Red Light actually reminds me of Next Level, i need to listen several times so that i could get used to the beat in the chorus. And i swear to god the bridge is soooooo fucccinnngggg gooooood and addicting!!!! THEIR FREAKING HARMONIES ESP AMBER’S VOICE!!!!!!
The one you know is Sulli, she was in Hotel del Luna!
Thanks for the reaction Aaron! 💜
I’m so happy with this comment section. I feel like everything f(x) related gets flooded with “rip Sulli 😢” comments when fans just want to celebrate her life, and the art she gave us! Sulli is more than her death ppl!
ikr, I get angry everytime I see this kind of comments under any f(x) or shinee related videos and photos. just by these comments you can tell who is a fan and/or respects these groups and who dgaf and just pretends to care
@@universe986 Exactly!
f(x) has one of the most interesting discography in the whole kpop if not, one of the best. They are so unique.
On another note I highly recommend you listen to Galaxy by Ladies' Code it's a beautiful song and tribute to the 2 lost members, Rise and EunB (RIP). The song itself is amazing and really didn't get the recognition it deserved, I really think you would enjoy it!
Ok i upvote this, Galaxy issa BOP !
I agree
Oh I love f(x) so much!! I'm a huge SHINee fan and them and f(x) are my favorite groups and I struggle a lot to find another ones that make me feel all the feelings that I have while listening their music and watching them live or their music videos. It's kinda safe saying that SHINee and f(x) are the most experimental groups of SM and I find that very true because I enjoy them equally. Thanks for this reaction! I hope you can listen to 4 Walls by f(x) it's a true masterpiece, a song that is sister of SHINee's View (told by the composers themselves).
This music video reminds me a lot about the book 1984, a society ruled by an authoritarian government that brainwash people with it discourse (the scene where a lot of "people" are watching that man on the screen) and the girls seem like a group of rebels fighting against it. The lyrics make sense with that interpretation too. A producer from SM said that is about the sewol ferry tragedy... But I like mantain my own perspective too. Anyways is one of my favorites Kpop MVs, the aesthetics are awesome as well as the message.
Here, too, they made a trend for Idols, which is face text makeup, eye band, hair accessories and face. They are trend queens.
As Victoria said we are not following the current but the one who follows us✨💜
Ah... my ult group, my obsession, my love f(x).. There's no one like them, they really ahead of time. Pink tape still the best album to me. I love them and will always love f(x). I think the trajectory towards experimental music get stronger every new group from SM. The first group would be shinee, and then f(x), redvelvet, NCT, and now aespa. Like you said, f(x) like female NCT, no wonder I loveee NCT muahahahaaha (actually f(x) like female shinee though :))
F(x) is (was?) SHINee's sister group in a sense that they are also very experimental. Love both.
the blonde one is krystal she's the younger sister of jessica from snsd and they're kind of the iconic kpop siblings since i can remember
Fun fact:
Krystal, the one in blonde long hair is actually SNSD (Girl's Generation) Jessica's younger sibling.
Victoria was in the reality show "We got married" with Nichkhun from 2PM
IT FINALLY HAPPENED?!?!?
CURRENTLY SCREAMING
CRYING THROWING UP
One good thing about groups from SM, their songs sound refreshing even years later
f(x) is one hell of a total packaged group SM debuted. They got everything.
- Vocals, Rap, Visual, Actresses, Musical actress, Models, BEST DISCOGRAPHY
This is my all time fav f(x) song and 4 walls as well. They are just different
This is the depressed mother of Zimzalabim and Next Level!!!
fx is that kind of group that you can't compare with any other 'cause they are unique and I miss them so much
by the way, I really think you should do more previous gens groups reactions like this, there are so many bops that were underestimated at the time
F(x) (imo) is the group sm used for experimental songs, rythems, and beats the most. They reaaaaaly influenced the sounds of this generation of Kpop even though hardly anybody ever talks about it. Electric Shock, Rum Pum Pum, Hot Summer, and 4Walls are the next title tracks i'd check out :]
Yesss...f(x) is my second favourite sm girlgroup group after Red velvet.I know almost every one before getting into the group.But they didn't get the recognition.
f(x) and shinee most legendary
I'm waiting for more f(X) here. F(x) is everything ♥
Happy 12th anniversary to f(x) !!!!♡♡♡♡
Ahhh miss them.I think they were really good in terms of music. At that time, they showed very different music to everyone.They are all so talented.They broke up while waiting for their comeback for years. They went through very difficult things and only Shinee supported them in this process. SM spent them, i'm still mad about it.
Please react to f(x) -4 Walls
This song is in my top 10 favourite K-pop songs. The instrumental is absolutely insane ♥️ The bass just makes the music so cool. Gosh I miss f(x) so much...
If I remember correctly, the news articles that came out prior to f(x)’s debut referred to them as SHINee’s sister group or something along the line.
F(x) is my best girl group ever.. thank you so muchh
THANK YOU WHOEVER REQUESTED IT OMGG THANKS
F(x) is like SHINee girl version
Their is experimental group from SM
YESS thanks for reacting to older kpop songs/groups! Kpop is what it is now but boy when I tell you 2008-2014 was the GOLDEN era.. which I so miss 😭
omg , fx really , am i dreaming , i miiiiiiiiiiiiss those girls and their music
I’m so glad you finally saw f(x)
Thank you! I miss fx so muchhh
this song was way ahead of its time .
f(x) was known as possibly the biggest and best experimental girl group that (in my opinion) never had a bad comeback until Red Velvet come into the works and debuted. Often they're referred when talking about SM and their shortcomings since everyone saw how much potential the group had but since SM is more interested in their boy groups, or at least they were like that back then, f(x) never reached their full potential.
They don't even have a lightstick and they had exactly one concert and that was after a member had left the group.
To be honest, for me it's hard to listen to any of their songs now because of all I've said and due to what happened with Sulli.
2 days ago was their 12th Anniversary 💜💜💜💜💜
finally! more f(x) mv please?
I miss them so much😭😭😭😭😭
You picked a hell of first song of fx to react to. This was their I got a Boy, ZimZalbim. SM in its creative experimental mode. I hope you do other reactions to fx. Many feel they have one of the best discographies in kpop
every f(x) title track have a different sound. i think you better dive to their b-side because they have many noise b-side
omgggg F(x) AHHHHHHHH
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
HAPPY 12TH YEARS ANNIVERSARY f(x) !! 💞💞
OT5 forever, congrats also for all meU out there ~
thank u so much for reacting to f(x)'s song. Looking forward a lot more f(x) reaction in the future
Aaron reacting to legends got me like 😭❤️
Wow didn’t expect this at all I love f(x)
I Miss F(X) So Much.Thank .
This MV is the MV with the most beautiful visual in the world for me, F(X) is legend, they're so amazing and deserved more.
SM had everything they needed to take over the world with f(X), but they somehow managed to let them go
F(x) always had an experimentental sound to them in comparison to other girl groups at that time. Always unique and had great albums!
f(x) is one of my favorite groups in kpop along with shinee, red velvet and exid. red light is my favorite release by f(x), i think i’ll never get tired of this song
Dude, thanks for reaction my girls, they have many good song, mv + bside. Please reaction f(x) more, you Will be suprise.
Oh Thank you😝 I really hoped you watch this. Thank You. Also you must watch 'f(x)-Pink Tape Art Film'
F(X)- SME most Revolutionary Group and SME most experimental music of kpop!
PINK ALBUM THE MOST SUCCESSFUL ALBUM of kpop during their time and that's F(X) Album!
Good job with notching the legendary one side makeup