sm is a scumbag true it’s like we know she’s very stunning but imagine how annoyed she is hearing over and over again “she’s so pretty” instead of focusing on her hard work and talent.
Kwon JiYong you don’t need to produce your own song to be considered an artist. An artist is someone who efficiently expresses themselves artistically, which they do.
@@kwonjiyong73 let me give you an example in artist i terms of painting, you just need to make a masterpiece from your favorite style, you don't need to create your own canvas or create your own paint
Pink Gangsta ngl, when you have the artist sm has being minimalist in terms of production is not a bad thing. Yeah we would appreciate a little more but it also doesn’t take away attention from the artist. To me this is far from being minimalistic. If we talking in terms of choreo this is literally one of the hardest anyone can do. They just make it look easy lol but in terms of stage I see what you mean lol
agree, but i think naughty won't win anything though in award shows, because it doesn't do really well digitally ... BUT, hope they will win with best dance performance
In any _reasonable_ universe "Naughty" would have gone super-viral and Irene and Seulgi would be worshipped worldwide as the goddesses they are. As it is, in our imperfect world, we still have Red Velvet...which is pretty awesome.
it's not only irene & seulgi who worked hard for this sub-unit but also the backup dancers, the producers of the songs, and the choreographers!! *so thank you all for making this wonderful subunit possible!* MONSTER ERA HAS ENDED TODAY BUT ITS IMPACT WILL FOREVER LIVE
I agree to you, they really worked hard . :) I hope they will be more successful. P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
same here... I really love their songs so much, it's perfect for jamming... P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
I am curious who the haters are??? They didn't win (just one win) although they deserved much more for monster and naughty performance they did and the song is really good. how? I can't understand.
Seulgi's Lipsyncing? HAHAHAHAHA Seulgi's vocals is one of the cleanest in Kpop industry. P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
What I notice this debut, Irene's vocals is unexpected, and her dancing skills. Seulgi's variation of her dance, well I always notice her vocals ever since :) P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
This is their last stage and promotion, cheers to more aseul comebacks in the future!! You did well girls💛❤ luvies who work hard day and night for voting and streaming thank you💓
Waiting for the RV's comeback, I miss the OT5 already. Wendy, please comeback T_T P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
This is such a breath of fresh air. K-Pop is increasingly becomes homogenic powerful dancing esp in boy groups. Naughty's Irene, Seulgi and choreographer Spella and Shim Jaewon just shows the industry that difficulty and awesome choreo doesn't mean you have to snap your backbones, and that there's a lot of techniques and genres waiting to be incorporated to K-Pop.
I still can't believe this is their goodbye stage. ASeul has been constantly feeding us with their vocal, dancing and visual. This sub-unit is everything to me, a dream comes true. Thank you for your hard working Irene & Seulgi
I'm glad thr camerawork is so okay, compared to music bank. I just want to focus on the choreo and i want them to focus on the hand movements. Coz the entire choreo is the main point
![Monster - 레드벨벳 - 아이린&슬기(Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI) [뮤직뱅크/Music Bank] 20200710](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3tYJTkdQMgA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Monster - 레드벨벳 - 아이린&슬기(Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI) [뮤직뱅크/Music Bank] 20200710](/img/tr.png)
At this point they don't have to be scared to get wrong move because we'll never know anyway
Loool my point
why did this make me laugh so hard 😭
Ikr!!!
i cracked up reading ur comment 🤣🤣
unless your the weird aliens that can do this
As an Irene stan, it’s so satisfying to see Irene prove people she is more than just a visual.
She proved it to me 5 years ago when I first became a fan 😁😁😁
she proved it since then, some are just dumb to notice
sm is a scumbag true it’s like we know she’s very stunning but imagine how annoyed she is hearing over and over again “she’s so pretty” instead of focusing on her hard work and talent.
Didn’t u get this comment from the Mv. Lol
Stan Red velvet or else I’m sorry but I don’t know what comment your talking about in the M/V 😭
They just proved they're not just idols, but artists! Can't get over how much justice they gave to the choreo.
I agree to you co-luvie... P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
But they dont produce their own song :(
Kwon JiYong you don’t need to produce your own song to be considered an artist. An artist is someone who efficiently expresses themselves artistically, which they do.
@@kwonjiyong73 let me give you an example in artist i terms of painting, you just need to make a masterpiece from your favorite style, you don't need to create your own canvas or create your own paint
I think red velvet proved that long ago.
Even if you’re not a minimalist, you’ll appreciate everything
I really appreciate everythingg... P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
this is more brutalist, my fav design
I'm a minimalist, so I love the set design and the black & white outfits. Seulrene's power! 😍
Sometimes SM is so SM. SUPER MINIMALIST 😂
Pink Gangsta ngl, when you have the artist sm has being minimalist in terms of production is not a bad thing. Yeah we would appreciate a little more but it also doesn’t take away attention from the artist. To me this is far from being minimalistic. If we talking in terms of choreo this is literally one of the hardest anyone can do. They just make it look easy lol but in terms of stage I see what you mean lol
Naughty deserves more wins in award show and Naughty itself deserves to win the best dance performance
agree, but i think naughty won't win anything though in award shows, because it doesn't do really well digitally ... BUT, hope they will win with best dance performance
also with their Monster :( P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
TOTALLY AGREEE
In any _reasonable_ universe "Naughty" would have gone super-viral and Irene and Seulgi would be worshipped worldwide as the goddesses they are. As it is, in our imperfect world, we still have Red Velvet...which is pretty awesome.
아니 이거 진짜 재평가되어야함 아니 평생 이건 kpop 안무에 한줄을 그음 제발 놀이 모두 다 알아야됨
그냥 후속곡으로 남기에는 너무 아까움 ㅠㅠ K-pop 역사상 최고의 안무인데
몬스터보다 놀이가 더 좋음... 더 고급진 느낌
고급진 느낌 ㅇㅈㅇㅈㅇㅈㅇㅈㅇㅈㅇㅈ흐응륵그듣듀ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
약간 에펙스 4 walls같은 고급짐
몬스터는 데모곡이 너무 좋음
@도라미 아놔 진짜 컴눈명 나와주길 ㅠㅠ 나오면 울듯 감동해서
이 곡 너무 좋아요
it's not only irene & seulgi who worked hard for this sub-unit but also the backup dancers, the producers of the songs, and the choreographers!! *so thank you all for making this wonderful subunit possible!*
MONSTER ERA HAS ENDED TODAY BUT ITS IMPACT WILL FOREVER LIVE
I agree to you, they really worked hard . :) I hope they will be more successful. P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
As they said.. but Monster lives forever
Aseul give their back up dancers Air pod + album with hand written letter
😭
Honestly this era need to be appreaciated more.
놀이 무대중에서 제일 내가 생각했던 이미지랑 맞는 무대인듯 의상도 그렇고 무대도 놀이 그자체야
저도 놀이 무대중에 이게 제일 좋았어요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@99즈-p8e ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
1:21
@@99즈-p8e 갑질 뇌절좀 그만해라.... 질리지도 않나
@@99즈-p8e 진짜 까고싶어 ㅈㄹ을 한다ㅋㅋㅋ
대박 ... 아슬은 전설이다 놀이 따로 활동한 거 신의 한수 .. 스엠 맨날 욕했지만 이건 칭찬해 그러니까 완전체 빨리 컴백시켜
메이저 여돌을 이런 컨셉으로 컴백시키는 패기는 진짜 슴밖에 없다 대단
뭐야 인가인데 왜이리 엠알제거급으로 생라이브야 ㄷㄷ 근데 개잘하네 원래 이정도 생라이브는 뮤뱅 본방무대의 전유물이었는디
녹음에이알같은디
@@secfvn3025 음 떨리는게 들려서 라이브는 마2는고 같아요
@@qwerty_key_board 요즘은 숨소리나 목소리떨리는거 섞어서 녹음해요 음방용으로
@@secfvn3025 ar 아니에요~
요즘은 세갈래로 갈림 아예립싱크,목소리 약간 깔린mr에 노래하는거, 숨소리까지 한꺼번에 녹음해서 립싱크
이런거보면 진짜 아이돌 돈많이번다고해도 아무나하는게 아니다..연습엄청했겠네
애초에 데뷔하기도 하늘에 별 따기..
데뷔한다해도 연예계에서 살아남기도 힘듦..
안무 들어가기 전에 기본 트레이닝도 꽤 오래했다고 하더라고요ㄷㄷ
ㅋㅋㅋ와 진짜 옛날에 레드벨벳 팀명도 있기 전 루키즈 공개 영상 중에 아이린슬기 비내추럴 영상 처음봤던 그 충격때가 떠오른다.. 그느낌 그대로긴한데 더 발전한느낌
엌ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저랑 완전 똑같은 생각하셨네요ㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 루키즈때 아슬모습이 생각나던,,
그쵸 저도 그 영상보고 충격...
ua-cam.com/video/rkZ9je4xSIY/v-deo.html
헐 진짜진짜요 ㅠㅠ
I just wish more people would learn about irene & seulgi.
GGChoColat all schools need to replace their math textbook with a red velvet textbook
@@sarah4839 omg it would be so beautiful like their albums.
@@sarah4839 That way, being a student would actually be fun. And I would finally ace tests.
1:31
@@sarah4839 haha good one
놀이 무대중에 이 무대가 의상도 심플하고 텃팅도 유독 쫀득해서 제일 집중됨
카메라 좋다 춤 잘 잡아냄
ㄹㅇ 이제까지 본 음방중 거의 뮤비만큼 잘잡아냄 뮤비감독이 직접 찍었다해도 믿을만큼 아티스트랑 호흡이 척척맞네
놀이는 음방 카메라 거의 다 잘잡은듯,,
ㅇㅈ 디테일한 동작 나올땜 줌으로 보여줌
와 뒤에 그림자 비쳐서 더 멋있어 보임
i searched for "irene & seulgi" on youtube almost everyday ever since monster came out lol. love them so much
same here... I really love their songs so much, it's perfect for jamming... P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
Sameee
Same. I'm addicted with their collaboration. Diamond personal fave.
I wonder if you still do it up until now...🤔
아이린 진짜 예쁘다.. 이건 ㄹㅇ어쩔 수 가 없네
@@정말이-w6l 왜 저래
@@정말이-w6l ?
음중 인가 무대 보면서 느낀건데 둘다 흰색이 더 잘 어울리는듯 흰색이 더 눈에 들어와서 그런것도 있겠지만 음중 볼때는 아이린한테 시선이 갔는데 인가는 슬기한테 눈이 계속 감ㅌㅋㅋㅋ넘 찰떡
뒤에 그림자 거꾸로 잡히는 것도 넘 좋다 무대가 진짜 예술 그 자체
Seulgi in high ponytail has always been my favorite...but seulgi in RED HIGH PONYTAIL is definitely my weakness 😭
You should make her on stage series with naughty too!
Same ponytail Seulgi is my weakness I can't 😭
They fit it so muchhh... P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
seulgi in red high ponytail is just *chef's kiss*
각 맞는거 보면서 희열 느낌..
아이린슬기 조합이야 딱 맞는 유닛 다른 멤버는 이런 케미 안나옴
이둘만 소화할수있는...몬스터와 놀이..
갠적으로 몬스터도 조은데 이 무대가 더 좋음 쎈데 우아한 느낌도 있어서 ㅋㅋ 도도한 여신 같음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 몬스터는 걍 쎈캐 시크 느낌이고
Kang Seulgi is everyone's crush
Yaaaas
Yeahhh, she's a crush material. no matter gender it is. P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
레드벨벳과 가장 인연이 안 좋은 방송사이지만 ,,,,, 이번 놀이 무대만큼은 스브스가 가장 세련되고 이뻤어 ,,,
놀이 무대는 엠비시가 젤 멋있게 나왔는데
아놔 생각하니 또 ㅂㄷㅂㄷ
The tutting still amazes me.
They nailed it!!!
Wdym of tutting?
Lady Aya the style of dance of the choreography
We call it vogue-ing
개인적으로 놀이 듣고 보아 선공개곡인줄 알았음
그만큼 sm 2000대부터 2010년 초 고유색깔같은 곡 오랫만이라 너무좋고 안무도 모두 좋았음 ㅠㅠ
오오 진짜 보아 느낌난다
ㄹㅇ 허리케인비너스 copy&paste game camo 이런 보아노래 생각났음
아이린한테는 몬스터보다 놀이가 훨씬 더 잘어울린다 안무도 그렇고 특히 보컬이...
놀이에서는 원래 아이린 음색 그대로 나와서 듣기 편하고 또 곡이랑 잘 어우러지는데 몬스터에서는 억지로 목소리를 까는 느낌이었음..
놀이는 진짜 안무가 볼 때마다 감탄이 나옴..
슬기 춤은 뭐 말할것도 없이 각이 제대로인데,
아이린은 부드러운듯 하면서 독특한데 느낌이 남다름
하 너무 멋있어...진짜 노래 춤 얼굴 몸매 예술이다
카톡 프로필 뮤직 naughty 할머니될때까지 안바꾼다
과연..
저도 카톡 프로필뮤직 놀이예요... 너무 좋음ㅜㅜ
이 무대 제일 좋아.. 카메라 진짜 잘 잡아주고 무대 세트도 고급지고 세련되면서 잘어울리고 의상도 좋고 아슬 포니테일 짱이야 ㅜㅜ 놀이 진심녀 벅차오름..
진짜 이 무대만 보면 슬기 곰같이 보이지 않고 존나 고양이 같은 아라 꼬리 높게 그려서 그런가 언니 사랑해
Haters keep barking, RV Irene-Seulgi keep slaying! YASHH they slaps the haters every stages with their perfect performances~~~
let them bark because of insecurities. P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
I am curious who the haters are??? They didn't win (just one win) although they deserved much more for monster and naughty performance they did and the song is really good. how? I can't understand.
I haven’t seen any hate comments yet
@@minigirl we aprobably are talking about the number of dislikes in all Irene&Seulgi videos
둘 다 얼굴 표정을 참 잘 쓰네 춤이 어려워서 집중하다보면 자기도 모르게 무표정 될 수도 있는데 미묘한 느낌으로 잘 쓰는 듯 역시 잘해
놀이 퍼포먼스는 걸그룹 역사상 세손가락 안에 든다고 확신함
진짜로,, 몇년째 느끼는 부분
1:18 쯤에 슬기가 옆으로 살짝 보는거 넘 이쁘다ㅠㅠㅠ
와 이걸 라이브로 했어....ㄷㄷ
아이린슬기 또 유닛활동 해줘요~~
와 대칭맞는거봐 예술이다 예술
whoever said girl groups dance are easy clearly haven't seen this masterpiece.
난 이래서 여그룹이 좋아…레벨 최고 역시 레벨은 노래랑 매력이 오져버리는거같아 매번 느끼지만 이거 진짜 선공개곡이였으면 좋았을걸 레전든데
진짜 잘찍었다 스엠영상이랑 투톱으로 안무 잘 살린 음방...
You thought seulgi's lipsyncing? Oh dude you're wrong. Hahahahahahahaa She's eating CD
Seulgi's Lipsyncing? HAHAHAHAHA Seulgi's vocals is one of the cleanest in Kpop industry. P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
이 노래 슬기 그 자체 아니냐...둘다 개쩐다
진짜 레전드인데
THESE TWO IS NOT JUST A VISUAL....
BUT AN ALL ROUNDERS!!!!
STAN RED VELVET!!!
What I notice this debut, Irene's vocals is unexpected, and her dancing skills. Seulgi's variation of her dance, well I always notice her vocals ever since :) P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
@@leeyanofficial you are literally under every comment, lol😂
슬기 목소리랑 찰떡이다
100만 기념으로 아슬이 놀이 보러왔다 ^♡^
Irene's visual + Seulgi's abs = Chefs Kiss!
And Irene's abs + Seulgi's visual = Chefs kiss !
누가 이런 음악이 나올거라 생각하겠냐고 진짜 놀이 넘 좋다 심장이 떨린다 스엠 진짜 미쳤어
졸라 미니멀하고 세련된 느낌 너무 좋아.. 존멋
헤메코 미쳤죠 진짜
I know this comment is everywhere but they definitely deserve to win best dance award
Gosh. The live vocals!! No bactrack just pure live vocals!!!!
완벽한 무대...안무 진짜 개좋아..ㅠㅠ
아이린 텃팅 동작 너무 깔끔하다
아이린의 무대를 좋아하던 사람으로서 항상 그냥 항상 아쉬움
This is their last stage and promotion, cheers to more aseul comebacks in the future!! You did well girls💛❤ luvies who work hard day and night for voting and streaming thank you💓
whaaat?? last? ㅠㅠ i want more seulrene performances!
Really??? I also wanted more perf of this. I'll end up missing them too
Waiting for the RV's comeback, I miss the OT5 already. Wendy, please comeback T_T P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
It's so short WHYYYYY
최고의 유닛 조합👍👍👏👏❤❤
동감이다
올해 컴백한 모든 곡중 내 베스트!
This could have been the song of the year if the promotions didn't stop.
It has that unique flavour to be SOTY.
this duo will forever be iconic. such queens
Indeeed
아웅 언니들 최고야... 레드벨벳 컴백까지 돈 모으는 중...
This is such a breath of fresh air. K-Pop is increasingly becomes homogenic powerful dancing esp in boy groups. Naughty's Irene, Seulgi and choreographer Spella and Shim Jaewon just shows the industry that difficulty and awesome choreo doesn't mean you have to snap your backbones, and that there's a lot of techniques and genres waiting to be incorporated to K-Pop.
진짜 연말에 한번 나와서 우리 기죽여줘ㅠㅠ 몬스터나 이거나ㅠㅠ
라이브 진짜잘한다..
솔직히 처음엔 놀랐지만 이젠 괜찮으니 제발 컴백좀 해줘.. 고딩때부터 기분 안 좋아도 레벨 보면 기분 좋았단 말야 ㅜㅜ
미친 ㅈㄴ 멋있어
와 연습 얼마나 했을까..
이거 문명특급 컴눈명으로 나왔으면 좋겠다 너무 아깝다 안무랑 노래랑 세련됐는데
Who said that Red Velvet doesn't have a stage presence?? Aseul is just the 2/5 of the group but look how they burn the stage 🔥🔥
the fact that they are singing practically everything live
최고대존엄 아슬;;;연말무대 찢을듯 ㄹㅇ
그림자까지 멋있어
Haters: Irene is just a visual
Irene: What I can't hear you I am singing and finger dancing
AHHAHHAHAHAHHA a big slap to her haters... P.S Reveluvs, I hope you will check out my 'Monster' Dance Cover on my channel. :)
와 무슨 논란이고 뭐고 잘하는 건 인정이다..
저걸 어케 외우짘ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I love how Seulgi smiles at some point and also how they're vocals are really stable, the reason I stan them
I absolutely love the Ying and yang concept❤❤❤
아니 근데 몬스터랑 놀이만 봐도... 유영진이 공들인 앨범이란건 지나가던 이수만도 아는 사실..
근데? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 갑질ㅋㅋ 응 ㅋㅋ 갑 ㅋㅋ질ㅋㅋ
@@prussian_b 엿
@@99즈-p8e 뭐 어때 그렇다고 해서 이 앨범이 흥했단 사실과 여기에 들인 노력이 사라지는게 아닌데 아이린이 갑질한거만 비판해야지 같이 활동한 슬기하고 이 앨범제작에 노력한 사람들까지 욕보이지마
@@99즈-p8e 얜 진짜 뭐하고 살지 궁금하다
@@99즈-p8e 꼭 말빨딸리면 엄마찾더라 ㅋㅋ
The Yin Yang. Seulgi and Irene.
Perfect pair. Great chemistry as well.
Seulgi's body proportions are insane
Irene seriously kill it with seulgi🔥🔥🔥🔥
인가 너네는 진짜 양심이있으면 이번 연말무대때 레벨 무대 퀄 보장해야한다... 아슬놀이특별무대+레벨퀸덤 최소 이정도는해라...
I love that they promoted Naughty. It's a great song with great choreography. It's incredible. The moves are so sharp, precise, and difficult.
퍼팩트한 무대
whenever i see the dancer that always makes Irene laugh, it makes me happy too!
노래랑 춤이 고급지다
진짜 독특했어
무대디자인도 진짜 잘뽑았다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 모던 그 자체
i think this might be the biggest serve in all of kpop
Irene fits this concept soo much! So sad that this is their goodbye stage :(
Irene and Seulgi will go down as one of the best units ever!
아슬은 전설이다
The Queen of concepts and musicality. I’m so proud to be Red Velvet’s fan.
We all know the choreo is insane, but Irene and Seulgi's on stage charisma and confidence are other-worldly. Rulers of the Universe.
I still can't believe this is their goodbye stage. ASeul has been constantly feeding us with their vocal, dancing and visual. This sub-unit is everything to me, a dream comes true. Thank you for your hard working Irene & Seulgi
I'm glad thr camerawork is so okay, compared to music bank. I just want to focus on the choreo and i want them to focus on the hand movements. Coz the entire choreo is the main point