Quentin Tarantino: Worst to Best

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 321

  • @treytison1444
    @treytison1444 10 місяців тому +169

    This is one of the wildest takes I've ever heard on Kill Bill from a Tarantino fan.

    • @alexbaker9578
      @alexbaker9578 10 місяців тому +15

      I don't think you can really call him a fan

    • @myronsanders4563
      @myronsanders4563 9 місяців тому +1

      My views on the 2 films are in reverse. Part 2 bored me to death. Outside of the fight in the trailer w/ Uma and Daryl Hannah and the "Superman" Monologe by Bill at rhe end it did nothing for me. Part 1 I liked a lot. Yea, it's basically empty calories but it's a lot of fun to watch

    • @MLawrence-z9k
      @MLawrence-z9k Місяць тому

      I'm a OG fan from 1994 ever since I was a 8 year old kid eating pan fried chicken & coliflower while watching Pulp Fiction on VSH when it first came out & I honestly think Kill Bill is extremely overrated ASF & so is Inglorious Bastards

    • @matteobeach4261
      @matteobeach4261 7 днів тому

      He didn’t even bring up the stuff I didn’t like about kill bill like bleeping the brides name or making the bride seem inevitable to any kind of blows to the head, plus the whole bit where Beatrix can’t get the sword which is just a time killer.

  • @lakimball
    @lakimball Рік тому +84

    As a Tarantino worshipper let me defend Landa's character a bit. It makes sense for Landa to decide to make a deal with the U.S. and turn himself in. He's just an opportunist. I feel as if he's only a Nazi officer because that was the job that would net him the most power. The guy believes in nothing but himself, he's a fraud. The only thing he probably truly has in common with Nazis is that he's evil as shit. I expect he isn't as nationalistic as most SS officers. I don't think its out of character for him to betray the Reich on such a whim. He tells the French farmer that he loves his "Jew Hunter" moniker, but tells Aldo Raine with contempt that it's "just a name that stuck".
    He only wants power and recognition and does not seem to care all that much from which world power he receives it from, be it Germany or the United States. I think he's smart enough to realize that Germany would not end up winning the Second World War and decides to take the opportunity to end the war for the U.S. and let himself be lauded as an Allied hero. It's his insane hubris that makes him seem kind of foolish to think he'd get away from Aldo scott-free. He was being silly to believe Aldo would accept his surrender unconditionally, even if the U.S. General told him to do so. Still, I think it's a decision that makes sense for his character.

    • @thecozykinoshow
      @thecozykinoshow  Рік тому +14

      Okay, fair enough, I guess I just don't see sufficient evidence for the characterisation you're talking about. You seem to be assuming stuff about Landa instead of the film showing these things. But I'm willing to accept I'm wrong on this as most people think he is an all-time movie villain. I'll give the film another go in the near-future. Thanks for the comment :)

    • @lakimball
      @lakimball Рік тому +4

      Yes most of what I said are inferences.@@thecozykinoshow Thanks for the video. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood... is sneakily becoming my favorite Tarantino. Gets better every viewing.

    • @TMThesaurus
      @TMThesaurus 10 місяців тому +5

      @@thecozykinoshow Anyone in his position who wasn't blinded by ideology could see that Germany couldn't possibly stop the Soviet Union by that point in the war. I think you can use Landa's changing position on his "Jew Hunter" nickname as (weak) evidence of his opportunism. That being said, the reason he's considered a great villain is because of Waltz's portrayal, not the writing.

    • @Mightbeloony
      @Mightbeloony 10 місяців тому +4

      @@thecozykinoshow Just to add another lens this scene can be viewed from. During the final days of the war, the US did a lot to pretty much smuggle high ranking Nazis in an effort to get a leg up on the coming conflict with the Russians. Operation Paperclip is the best example of these efforts. So when I first viewed the scene, much like Lakim, I thought this was just Landa acting in self preservation and Raine rejecting Landa his happy ending. Landa never would have dreamed Raine would have the audacity to brand him.
      At least thats my take. Great vid.

    • @mcultras
      @mcultras 10 місяців тому

      What about Operation Paperclip desu?

  • @mendyhamou-6899
    @mendyhamou-6899 10 місяців тому +102

    Folks I think he ranked kill bill last on purpose as a distraction, so we won't pay attention to the fact that he ranked Jackie Brown higher than Django. Genius.

    • @myronsanders4563
      @myronsanders4563 9 місяців тому +24

      Jackie Brown is a better film then Django......

    • @i3ar310
      @i3ar310 8 місяців тому +6

      @@myronsanders4563agreed

    • @kingeatking
      @kingeatking 6 місяців тому +1

      ​@@myronsanders4563 yup. Unchained just dragged near the end.

    • @MLawrence-z9k
      @MLawrence-z9k Місяць тому

      ​​@@kingeatking actually it's dragged in the middle not the end
      The iconic 20 minute dinner scene is the best part of the entire film followed by the extreme shootout but then after that I agree it gets a little downhill

    • @EJD339
      @EJD339 Місяць тому

      I recently rewatched both and I was lukewarm on Jackie brown and enjoyed Django quite a bit but then I ended up loving Jackie brown and Django just didn’t seem as good to me even though I still enjoyed it.

  • @nkilian83
    @nkilian83 Рік тому +325

    Your hatred for Kill Bill is blasphemous

    • @Tyguy719
      @Tyguy719 Рік тому +18

      He’s based for sute

    • @davidpaulweaver7792
      @davidpaulweaver7792 Рік тому

      For real. What a schmuck.

    • @MrZackTyler
      @MrZackTyler Рік тому +15

      Yeah nah disagree heavy with his take

    • @akshaynair3080
      @akshaynair3080 11 місяців тому +2

      Agreed

    • @deadthimble5014
      @deadthimble5014 10 місяців тому +7

      No its not....its actually quite fair... still think deathproof is worse.... and maybe jackie brown and django should be higher...but yeah...kill bill...a bit bad actually...

  • @davidbutler1622
    @davidbutler1622 10 місяців тому +26

    As a kid I skipped Jackie Brown because it wasn’t as hyped. I watched it for the first time about 10 years ago and was blown away by how good it was. Definitely his most underrated film. I love telling people who haven’t seen it to go and watch it straight away. They always send me a text afterwards.

  • @HecticNova
    @HecticNova Рік тому +82

    Video starts at 16:30. Everything before that are just strange words I can't understand over awesome kill bill clips.

  • @BRinMilwaukee
    @BRinMilwaukee 10 місяців тому +10

    good to hear someone else actually loved The Hateful Eight, which is my favorite Tarantino movie

  • @Kevinwink4real
    @Kevinwink4real Рік тому +23

    As a Big Tarantino fan, it was interesting to hear your opinions on his filmography. While I didn’t agree with some of your takes I totally understand where you came from and that made me think of them in a different way. Very well done video!

  • @studioseppuku9454
    @studioseppuku9454 10 місяців тому +33

    Hans doesn't 'surrender' in Basterds, he thinks he can leverage the situation to cash out just at the right moment as the Reich falls to gain the most in the deal. It ties in perfectly with his character thinking that he is always the cleverest man in the room who always outsmarts his opponents. Perfectly summed up in his line 'Let's make a deal'.
    Even though he has studied the Basterds and knows how they mark people his ego thinks he is above that, being very German and believing in the hierarchy of leadership ie Aldo's General gave an order so it will be followed.
    Just sucked for him Aldo has been chewed out before and thinks it's worth it.

    • @michaelwcrosby
      @michaelwcrosby 10 місяців тому +4

      Yes, I agree with you. The Landa character is one of extreme arrogance. A psychopathic narcissist would believe that he is so clever and in control, that he could waltz out with complete immunity and safety. He operated for so long with everyone around him in total terror of his every whim and mood, that he could not grasp the willingness of anyone else being willing to disregard a general's orders and slice him up because of their complete and utter contempt of him. Also, when he included the Bastards in the negotiations for some token benefit, he would think that the Bastards would be appreciative and that he would be arrogant enough to believe that such would keep him safe.

    • @huskymajin
      @huskymajin 4 місяці тому

      Facts, that's what I was gonna say.

    • @MLawrence-z9k
      @MLawrence-z9k Місяць тому

      Hans isn't even really a bad guy & Inglorious Bastards is by far the most overrated film ever made😂

    • @kommi7658
      @kommi7658 29 днів тому

      ​@@MLawrence-z9k the SS officer isn't really a bad guy? Explain

  • @peakips
    @peakips Рік тому +19

    great video, I disagree with a lot of the positions but yeah man, along with ur PTA video I've been liking this channel a lot

  • @kennethconnally4356
    @kennethconnally4356 10 місяців тому +22

    Some other movies that reveal the ending (or its aftermath) in the opening scene:
    Citizen Kane
    Fight Club
    Portrait of a Lady on Fire
    Saving Private Ryan
    Sunset Boulevard
    In literature, Romeo and Juliet begins with a prologue that tells us the "star-crossed" lovers will die, ending the feud between their parents' families. The most famous episodes in Homer's Odyssey take place in a 4-book-long flashback narrated by Odysseus himself, whom we know will survive while all his men will die. The Great Gatsby is one of a jillion classic novels narrated retrospectively that begin with a glimpse into the narrator's life and attitude after the story's events.
    I guess a lot of writers share Tarantino's nihilistic streak and deliberately ruin their own stories.

    • @alexbaker9578
      @alexbaker9578 10 місяців тому +1

      I was yelling at the screen when he started making that argument 😢

    • @gregoryhenry8464
      @gregoryhenry8464 4 місяці тому

      American Beauty is another great example

  • @AGETheGawdYT
    @AGETheGawdYT 10 місяців тому +4

    NO ONE talks about Jennifer Jason Leighs performance in the Hateful Eight. One of my favorite and most meorable cinema performances for me personally.

  • @peterstayne9
    @peterstayne9 10 місяців тому +25

    how do you only have 2000 subs? your writing, editing and voice work are spot on. keep up the good work and you'll be crushing it in no time!

    • @alexbaker9578
      @alexbaker9578 10 місяців тому +1

      Probably because he has really bad takes that he tries to mask as him being extra clever when really he probably because he has really bad takes that he tries to mask as him being extra clever

    • @NounOzlos
      @NounOzlos 2 місяці тому

      @@alexbaker9578 Cope

  • @BBQ_Jackfruit
    @BBQ_Jackfruit 10 місяців тому +9

    I also thought I was the only person who didn’t care for Kill Bill

  • @nicholasrosebush6182
    @nicholasrosebush6182 10 місяців тому +17

    I honestly don’t think Inglorious bastards holds up very well as a whole. Specific scenes are brilliant but by the time the theater scene rolls around it kind of falls apart.

    • @Zed-fq3lj
      @Zed-fq3lj 5 місяців тому +1

      Agree. It has three magnificent scenes, peak film-making and that's it, on the whole, weak.

    • @ManiacMayhem7256
      @ManiacMayhem7256 5 місяців тому +1

      I like that film. It also has two extremely contradictory messages that hurt the film

    • @underrated4499
      @underrated4499 5 місяців тому +2

      The bastards need way more scenes in the movie

  • @weewer3369
    @weewer3369 10 місяців тому +6

    Hans was smart enough to see the changing tides with the regime, so he decided to cut loose there and take this easy opportunity to bail out before it all came crashing down.

  • @JJJackson777
    @JJJackson777 10 місяців тому +14

    Jackie Brown remains QT's most slept on film

    • @jiza76
      @jiza76 7 місяців тому

      Agree 100%

  • @sweakerthan
    @sweakerthan 9 місяців тому +16

    Blade Runner as style over substance is a jarring take

    • @wezzuh2482
      @wezzuh2482 9 місяців тому +1

      Blade runner is one of those rare instances where the style IS the substance.

    • @nolanscripture
      @nolanscripture 5 місяців тому +4

      Blade Runner is equal parts style and substance. Remarkable film.

    • @hoophypecasperheck8157
      @hoophypecasperheck8157 5 місяців тому +1

      Yeah the amount of subtext in bladerunner makes it absolutely insane to call a style over substance especially since it not even a homage to a style it basically created the cyberpunk style

  • @robertmarginean164
    @robertmarginean164 7 місяців тому +27

    Kill Bill sits in the lower half of my ranking, but my God, if you wanna make the point that it's hollow and simplistic, comparing it to Fury Road, a movie that's basically one chase scene from A to B and back to A for 99% of its runtime ain't gonna help getting that across

    • @nolanscripture
      @nolanscripture 5 місяців тому +2

      Thank you. I don't get the love for that movie at all. The only things I liked about it were the cinematography/visuals and Tom Hardy's performance. Everything else was either middling or downright bad imo.

    • @MNIDDM
      @MNIDDM 3 місяці тому +1

      I Understand his Point but He's comparing it To one of the Most Boring, empty, and loud movies ever.

    • @yggdrasil2
      @yggdrasil2 3 місяці тому +2

      It is a lot more than that if you are willing to look at it critically.

  • @kameronbelcher
    @kameronbelcher Місяць тому

    While watching this I think I realized you and I enjoy Tarantino for extremely different reasons, which is okay! I like that Tarantino doesn't cut out the fat, that he's indulgent. The scenes you showed and suggested trimming when you mentioned that were almost all scenes that I love and enjoy.

  • @967evil
    @967evil 10 місяців тому +4

    Landa is smart and was looking ahead. He realized Germany would lose and he’d have to pay for his crimes. He found an alternative.

  • @adrianphillips2136
    @adrianphillips2136 10 місяців тому +7

    10. The hateful eight (The Thing is my favourite movie and this movie feels like a blind person tried to copy Carpenters homework) 4/10
    9. Once upon a time in Hollywood (overindulgent, doesnt offer proper resolve rather than spectacle) 6/10
    8. Kill Bill volume 2 7/10
    7. Death Proof 7/10
    6. Jackie Brown 7.5/10
    5. Inglorious basterds 8.5/10
    4. Kill Bill volume 1 8.5/10
    3. Reservoir Dogs 9/10
    2. Pulp Fiction 10/10
    1. Django Unchained 10/10 (for me it was the most emotionally resonant)

    • @duckpin
      @duckpin Місяць тому +1

      Murder mystery in snow = The Thing apparently

    • @javiermedina9392
      @javiermedina9392 26 днів тому

      Who let you in the Kitchen?

  • @soapeydudd.93
    @soapeydudd.93 10 місяців тому +20

    The kill bill rants should be classified as hate crimes

  • @mrkgrmn3
    @mrkgrmn3 10 місяців тому +1

    I thought your analysis was spot on. Thanks for inspiring me to watch a couple of Tarantino films I never got around to.

  • @ryanwilliams4223
    @ryanwilliams4223 Рік тому +6

    Once upon a time in Hollywood is my fav of his. I watched it 11 times in 11 days once everyday just smoking weed and drinking and stuff never got bored of it was obsessed with it despite its faults I love it.

    • @Zed-fq3lj
      @Zed-fq3lj 5 місяців тому +2

      Same 😍, it's the last great movie made in Hollywood before the ''death of industry'' - suitable epitaph to movie making.

    • @ryanwilliams4223
      @ryanwilliams4223 5 місяців тому

      @@Zed-fq3lj Very true this hopefully he makes one final great movie before he retires 😀

  • @bgko91880
    @bgko91880 5 місяців тому +3

    To be honest, I'd much rather him try to improve on something he liked growing up than just carbon copy it just because it was popular. That's how I feel about remakes: remake something that could have been good, but wasn't, and make it... good.

  • @fabianmontero5174
    @fabianmontero5174 Рік тому +3

    good video! disagree with the ranking, but your analysis is pretty thorough :) congrats! hope the channel does well!

  • @rileylallier429
    @rileylallier429 10 місяців тому +5

    1. Kill Bill A+ - I get not being a big fan but I love the movie so much and it's so damn entertaining. I rewatch it all the time and I love how crazy and overblown it is. However it's also a great exploration of Vengeance. And yes I think it's better than Mad Max Fury Road. And I prefer to view the 2 volumes as one film.
    2. Pulp Fiction A+
    3. Django Unchained A+
    4. Reservoir Dogs A
    5. Inglorious Bastards A
    6. Once Upon A Time In Hollywood B
    7. The Hateful Eight B
    8. Death Proof B
    9. Jackie Brown C-

    • @smockfn
      @smockfn 10 місяців тому

      hateful eight and jackie brown are top 5

  • @JasperBelson
    @JasperBelson Рік тому +6

    I also find the end of Inglorious Basterds to be possibly comparable to No Country for Old Men, but in a good way. Landa and Anton have a similar almost unknown outlook. They don’t have normal villainous morals or principles. Landa doesn’t really believe any of the Nazi crap, he just wants to manipulate people and survive with excess. That’s how I see it at least.

    • @stevenbatke2475
      @stevenbatke2475 10 місяців тому +2

      Landa is a cat, who wants to eat, but prefers toying with the prey before he kills. The playing and toying is the goal. He enjoys the emotional torture.

    • @fuckgoogle8661
      @fuckgoogle8661 10 місяців тому

      Two movies I never want to watch again.

    • @smockfn
      @smockfn 10 місяців тому

      why@@fuckgoogle8661

  • @Chilidolff44
    @Chilidolff44 10 місяців тому +1

    Im pleased with your listening, probably would of swapped 9 & 10 around but hey ho? Just great to see someone appreciate Tarantino's greats being higher on a list, except for the obvious, the hateful 8 and Jackie brown are always underrated in most peoples lists. Exceptionally great editing and really enjoyable list. Thanking you kindly

  • @samuelmondragon5925
    @samuelmondragon5925 2 місяці тому

    I was shocked and almost mad that he out Kill Bill last, but I gained a new perspective on Tarantino after hearing his thoughts and I like that.

  • @SwisstedChef2018
    @SwisstedChef2018 6 місяців тому +2

    I cant believe you put INGLORIOUS lower than the Hateful 8, it is one of the best movies ever made

  • @KidFresh71
    @KidFresh71 10 місяців тому +31

    Horrible take on Kill Bill. Calling the iconic anime backstory sequence "padding" is objectively a jejune and uneducated take.

    • @KidFresh71
      @KidFresh71 10 місяців тому +6

      @user-otzlixr His whole takedown of Kill Bill was an emotional, illogical scree. Not based on facts, but feelings. Kind of like your straw man argument about me getting "emotional."

    • @Navaneeth-hv9sh
      @Navaneeth-hv9sh 8 місяців тому +1

      ​@@KidFresh71I mean,it's a movie so its hard to call it objective.

    • @edgarmoule9825
      @edgarmoule9825 7 місяців тому

      I agree espeas a second before he said that she was a npc (which she isn't) cus shes got a compelling backstory and character traits

    • @Navaneeth-hv9sh
      @Navaneeth-hv9sh 7 місяців тому

      @@edgarmoule9825 espeas?

    • @strangedays871
      @strangedays871 Місяць тому

      Kill Bill has zero depth. It's for people who are entertained by action and bright colors.

  • @deathbymazda
    @deathbymazda 8 днів тому

    Putting Hollywood that high and Kill Bill that low is crazy

  • @JCSmith717
    @JCSmith717 6 місяців тому +5

    The Inglorious Basterds take is absolutely insane haha. It’s probably the most brilliantly written and directed film he’s made

  • @Bluntsmoke501
    @Bluntsmoke501 10 місяців тому +4

    Inglorious basterds at 5 is insane

  • @FatherTime89
    @FatherTime89 Рік тому +14

    Mad Max Fury Road is operating on the same level of depth as Kill Bill 1. I'm not the person who came up with this observation but it has the depth of a road runner cartoon.

    • @YelløwKing666
      @YelløwKing666 Рік тому +2

      Fury road is miles better

    • @onylra6265
      @onylra6265 10 місяців тому

      That's the point of the comparison? I'm not crazy about Fury Road, but it's not sarcastic trash...
      Kill Bill is intentionally shit in a way you can't even enjoy it ironically like you could some bootlegged D-grade HK flick from the 80s you found on VHS at a flea market 30 years ago.

    • @Navaneeth-hv9sh
      @Navaneeth-hv9sh 8 місяців тому

      ​@@onylra6265I doubt tarantino made a film that was intentionally shit.he clearly puts a lot of effort into the colour scheme and lighting.i don't think the film is shallow,it definitely fumbles the revenge driven mess b becomes aspect of the film but I do think it is drawn out to the audience atleast in the end and certain things tarantino does does with her character does show us that.
      I think it's more or so the conflicting genre and theme of the movie that muddied the water of the idea

  • @Persuasions
    @Persuasions Рік тому +7

    Reservoir Dogs is always my favorite.

  • @Jezzascmezza
    @Jezzascmezza 5 місяців тому +1

    42:00 - No one would consider Four Rooms Tarantino's debut in any event because it came out three years after Reservoir Dogs.

  • @wagnerstefan601
    @wagnerstefan601 9 місяців тому +1

    Tarantino's biggest problem is, that he made his by far best movie at the beginning of his career - Pulp Fiction. I love Kill Bill 1 but in all honesty, there's more c/p in that one than in all of his other works combined, just watch Urami Bushi and see where he got his inspiration from.

  • @tomtracy605
    @tomtracy605 5 місяців тому

    @44:38 it caused many people to walk out, talking about the violence, the only scene in a Tarantino movie that ever made me feel uncomfortable was the dogs ripping an escaped slave apart, but he paid it off later when Christoph Waltz's character, Dr. King Schultz, used it as a point of reference as to why he couldn't forgive Calvin Candy's behavior, hence the great line, "I just couldn't help myself "

  • @pompeymonkey3271
    @pompeymonkey3271 10 місяців тому

    I totally agree that "The Hateful Eight" should be up there. I absolutely love it.

  • @gerbermack
    @gerbermack 10 місяців тому

    I loved the video.
    Your analysis prompted me to reconsider my thoughts about some of the films.
    Some of the rankings we saw eye to eye on. A couple of them, we certainly did not. Here was my ranking before listening to your presentation.
    (note: I didn’t initially include Death Proof. As I recall, Tarantino doesn’t consider this one of his catalog of films.)
    10. Kill Bill 1
    9. Hateful Eight
    8. Death Proof
    7. Kill Bill 2
    6. Reservoir Dogs
    5. Jackie Brown
    4. Inglourious Basterds
    3. Once upon a time in Hollywood
    2. Django Unchained
    1. Pulp Fiction

  • @PixelatedSpirit
    @PixelatedSpirit 5 місяців тому

    The problem with making a list, at least for me, is that my opinion changes from day to day, year to year. Depending on mood and life experiences etc that changes as life goes on.
    I'll come back to this ytchannel in ten years and hope you'll redo this, and i'm sure the list (and your self) will have matured and changed a lot. Looking forward to it. ✌🏻😂

  • @AGETheGawdYT
    @AGETheGawdYT 10 місяців тому +1

    I fucking LOVE the Hateful Eight

  • @TheEmzBemz
    @TheEmzBemz Рік тому +6

    With Priscilla coming out, I'd love to see a Sofia Coppola best to worst next?

    • @RatatRatR
      @RatatRatR 10 місяців тому +2

      (1) Lost in Translation
      (2) her other stuff

  • @eversosleight
    @eversosleight 10 місяців тому

    I'm not a big fan of Basterds but that film intro is top shelf stuff! Probably one of the best intros of all time.

  • @JoJoJoker
    @JoJoJoker 5 місяців тому

    @38:50 that shot was *AMAZING* in Super Panavision 70mm.
    Once Upon came at a time right before the “New Normal” pandemic chaos. The timing couldn’t have been more perfect.

  • @willmatson3103
    @willmatson3103 Місяць тому

    Regarding Landa's defection towards the end in Inglorious Basterds: Unlike you, I actually think it makes total sense and is consistent with his character. The last part of the film is set in 1944, where it was obvious that the fortunes of the Axis Powers was heading towards the worse -- commonly, historians point to the 1942 Battle of Stalingrad as the turning point, and things were looking even more dire for Germany's prospects 2 years later.
    While he was a Nazi officer, Waltz's character didn't come across as an ideologue who actually bought into all of the propaganda -- I got the impression that he was too smart for that. Landa's pragmatism led him to seize this great opportunity: be entered into history books as a central player of Operation Kino, (which in Tarantino's version of history) led to the overnight ending of the war, *and* be set up for a very comfortable life in a country who was now on a meteoric rise in terms of economic and political power. His hubris might have made him not consider the likelihood of Pitt's character doing what he did, but really, if we are to assume that he survives his branding and that the terms of his conditional surrender are in fact carried out, he is still making it out like a bandit. Yeah, he has a gnarly scar, but so what? There's the option for plastic surgery, and besides, what does he care while living on Nantucket Island with full military honors and benefits.

  • @plasticweapon
    @plasticweapon 4 місяці тому +3

    1. pulp fiction
    2. reservoir dogs
    3. jackie brown
    skip everything else

  • @joaofonseca2331
    @joaofonseca2331 10 місяців тому +16

    Finally someone with a sober view on Kill Bill. Nice list

  • @littleredruri
    @littleredruri 2 місяці тому

    Kill Bill is literally my favourite movie of all time right now 😭😭

  • @SoupyBill
    @SoupyBill 4 місяці тому

    There’s a lot here unpack.
    Sitting here in my kitchen at 5:00am with the best part of a bottle of whiskey behind me.
    A lot of this feels blasphemous.
    And working out why is our problem.
    peace

  • @TheEmzBemz
    @TheEmzBemz Рік тому +1

    Great video and interesting list - I think given you might love jackie brown more than you realise - you spoke about it with so much love despite its middling ranking. Love the reservoir dogs recognition, a perfect film

    • @thecozykinoshow
      @thecozykinoshow  Рік тому +2

      Maybe on a different day I would swap Jackie Brown and Basterds around, they were definitely the two spots I mulled over the most. I guess I just feel like Basterds is technically superior and more important in Tarantino’s career.

  • @Jezzascmezza
    @Jezzascmezza 5 місяців тому

    12:20 - that's a really unfair comparison. Likening Django and Broomhilda riding away from the scene of the climax (like, it's one of the final shots of the movie, if not the final shot) is not the same as showing The Bride driving towards the destination of the climax, which is what Kill Bill Vol. 2 does. It would be fairer to compare it to a scene of Django on his own approaching the plantation before the final confrontation, which I think (while still potentially spoilery) is very different. If you rearranged Kill Bill 2 chronologically, I feel like that opening scene where she's talking to the camera would take place at a point where there are still 20 to 30 minutes of movie left. With the Django and Broomhilda shot, that's more like 20 to 30 seconds of movie left.

  • @IriaChannel
    @IriaChannel Місяць тому +1

    I agree with you. I think Kill Bill is trash and his worst work. The inspiration for it "Lady Snowblood" is so much better, if you go into Kill Bill having knowledge of that series it feels like a bootleg 80's bollywood movie version..

  • @yggdrasil2
    @yggdrasil2 3 місяці тому

    I agree with you on Kill Bill lol. Always thought the tone was a bit off.

  • @pluckinmageetar
    @pluckinmageetar 10 місяців тому

    Oooh the venom.
    How DARE you, sir!!!😂
    You address many of the incongruencies in Tarantino films that most of his fans will dismiss, deny, avoid....
    Most of us feel these missteps but are so hopped up on the hyper-violent adrenaline, visually stunning set pieces, nostalgic soundtracks and spiffy dialogue, that the uneven pacing, structure and holes in the story are barely noticeable.

  • @felixschwab9850
    @felixschwab9850 10 місяців тому

    I really really enjoyed this ranking. First off, finally someone who dislikes the Kill Bill movies as much as I do. You will get a lot of flack for it, but I agree with every word. And second, you managed to express why I love Once Upon A Time In Holywood as much as I do a lot better than I would be able to. I will go as far as to say it's my all time favorite feel good movie for the very reasons you mentioned

  • @danielbarrero2815
    @danielbarrero2815 10 місяців тому

    Great vid! I disagree with some of your takes but enjoy your thoughtful explanations

  • @onormalsssss
    @onormalsssss Рік тому +5

    my ranking is:
    9 Jackie Brown
    8 Once Upon A Time In Hollywood
    7 reserve dogs
    6 kill bill 1.2 (I like it lol)
    5 django
    4 The Hateful Eight
    3 death proof
    2 pulp fiction
    1 inglorious bastards
    The first two were very difficult, but today I chose inglorious bastards

    • @SeanSalata
      @SeanSalata 8 місяців тому +1

      Worst list I’ve ever seen

  • @thesmellofadventure5370
    @thesmellofadventure5370 2 місяці тому

    10. Death Proof
    9. Jackie Brown
    8. Kill Bill Vol. 2
    7. Reservoir Dogs
    6. Pulp Fiction
    5. Kill Bill Vol. 1
    4. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
    3. Django Unchained
    2. The Hateful Eight
    1. Inglourious Basterds

  • @Killer...
    @Killer... Рік тому +1

    enjoyable video! i disagree with a lot of your negative points, but i do appreciate Reservoir Dogs being so high

  • @erikscream
    @erikscream 10 місяців тому +11

    First choice kills the whole list, you don’t know cinema

  • @4gillman
    @4gillman 10 місяців тому

    Kill Bill is pure cinema. Film can be both entertaining and edifying, but great schlock, B movies, pure genre films, what have you, their greatest virtue is taking the aspect of entertainment and pushing it to its heights. Grindhouse is entertainment unchained, and Kill Bill is a worthy successor to that tradition.

  • @studioseppuku9454
    @studioseppuku9454 10 місяців тому

    Quentin's most trusted ally and massive contributor to his visual style, his editor Sally Menke passed away just before Django which is why the editing feels weird and not as tight. It's like he didn't know what to do without her. Coming from his previous films and very familiar with is style this felt very jarring in the theater however thanks to the superb acting has won me over since then.
    Hateful is garbage.

  • @kredonystus7768
    @kredonystus7768 10 місяців тому

    I think the Landa point is more that Landa thinks the only reason he was able to deny orders and move to the other side is because he was so intelligent. Without his superior intellect no-one would ever be smart enough to manipulate or betray orders. He thinks so little of the Basterds that he assumes they'll follow orders no matter what and thats his downfall.

  • @Zed-fq3lj
    @Zed-fq3lj 5 місяців тому

    Fairly good list. Great points, informative video dude! I too consider Kill Bill (both) to be the weakest of all Tarantino movies, but after Death Proof; Kill Bill is so overrated. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood (The last truly great movie from Hollywood, serving as a wonderful epitaph to movie making. is probably on par with Pulp Fiction as the best.
    Quentin Tarantino Movies ranked imo:
    1.Pulp Fiction - 1994
    2.Once Upon a Time in Holywood - 2019
    3.Reservoir Dogs - 1992
    4.Jackie Brown - 1997
    5.Django Unchained - 2012
    6.Inglourious Basterds - 2009
    7.The Hateful Eight - 2015
    8.Kill Bill - 2003-2004
    9.Death Proof - 2007

  • @edvawa
    @edvawa 10 місяців тому +2

    Kill Bill was genius, Mad Max Fury Road was not. That movie hardly has a story, it is just 1 extremely long car chase scene and nothing more.

  • @SoupyBill
    @SoupyBill 4 місяці тому

    He surrenders because thats his best option at the time! he always looks out for himself in every way and that’s just an extension of that!!!!

  • @TheKnown-Unknown
    @TheKnown-Unknown 6 місяців тому

    Thank you for giving The Hateful Eight the love it deserves, but never gets!

  • @domcoke
    @domcoke 9 місяців тому

    I saw Reservoir Dogs at the cinema when it came out.... and I am so with you on Kill Bill - SO with you. He's better than a bloody cartoony exploitation flick. And you sum that up beautifully. I was fully prepared for this list to culminate in Kill Bill, or Inglorious Basterds, or Once Upon a Time... to be top - but to see what I think remain the greatest Tarantino films in your top 2 is extremely encouraging. Given that you sound pretty young. And you are bang on. Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction are absolutely him at the peak of his powers. Before he started to believe his own hype, and get more and more indulgent. They are lean, fresh, visceral, funny, and human.

  • @pjvalentin
    @pjvalentin 8 місяців тому

    Agree with this ranking. I remember feeling alone when Kill Bll 1 came out and everyone was loving it. Also it is very true that Tarantin'os films are worth less than the sum of their parts. And it remains true for his best ones, like reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction.

  • @Spencer13_
    @Spencer13_ 7 місяців тому

    9 - Death Proof
    8 - The Hateful Eight
    7 - Jackie Brown
    6 - Reservoir Dogs
    5 - Once Upon a Time in Hollywood…
    4 - Kill Bill (both Vol. 1 & Vol. 2)
    3 - Django Unchained
    2 - Inglourious Basterds
    1 - Pulp Fiction

  • @71meshuggah
    @71meshuggah 10 місяців тому +2

    I’m the 2,240th person to rant about your Kill Bill ranking! Where’s my free cake?! 🍰🎉🎊🥂

  • @aidanscorner847
    @aidanscorner847 5 місяців тому

    I can’t complain about your kill bill take cuz I lowkey feel the same about Django, fun action and charismatic acting, but missing the soul and look of a great western

  • @BLUEDELUCA
    @BLUEDELUCA 10 місяців тому

    FURY ROAD is a great film but its basically “lets drive down this road, now lets drive back”. I will never argue against how a film makes someone feel. There are only a small handful of films i would feel compelled to defend, Kill Bill isn’t one if them.

  • @Tyler.the.contentcreator
    @Tyler.the.contentcreator Рік тому +4

    Kill Bill Vol 1 is my favorite Tarantino movie, but it was really interesting hearing why someone didn’t like it. I’ll definitely have to rewatch it with these criticisms in mind

  • @edsmith4821
    @edsmith4821 10 місяців тому

    Ive always seen the Kill Bill series as "pulp fiction " which is generally what everthing that Tarentino has made

  • @LarryKnipfing
    @LarryKnipfing 10 місяців тому

    Ha! I agree with you on all of them except for Grindhouse which I loved from beginning to end.

  • @xtrafunk
    @xtrafunk 2 місяці тому

    tarantino favoring scenes over movies perfectly describes inglorious. from my POV it's his most overrated movie despite featuring tons of individually cool moments (the introduction, the bar scene, etc). on some level it's just a fundamental mismatch between what i personally enjoy in fiction and what this movie is, because ultimately I just don't find absurdist plots very easy to care about or become invested in

  • @shirleebusch1459
    @shirleebusch1459 10 місяців тому +1

    The only thing that we agree on is Pulp Fiction being his best film.

    • @RatatRatR
      @RatatRatR 10 місяців тому +1

      There really isn't any other credible choice.

  • @kredonystus7768
    @kredonystus7768 10 місяців тому

    I think I'm the only person who will argue Once Upon a Time in Hollywood would have been better if it was longer. We needed more from the Manson gang. They felt completely jammed in at the end so Tarantino could get that violent end. It relies upon your knowledge of the real story to fill in the gaps, so I think we needed at least some short scenes as set up for the eventual culmination.

  • @MrSatampra
    @MrSatampra 10 місяців тому

    It's interesting to me how few films Tarantino has made in the thirty-two years since Reservoir Dogs. Compare his output to that of, say, Scorsese or Spielberg, and just seems to me there should more to his filmography. I also wholeheartedly agree with your assessment of the Kill Bills.

  • @ThePapranazi
    @ThePapranazi 8 місяців тому

    Just wanted to pipe in here to say that, while I heavily disagree with parts of your list, particularly the reasoning, I think that's great: I didn't want to watch a video that merely just echoed my own thoughts back to me, where's the fun in that? I already know what I think and I don't need my opinions to be validated.
    Good stuff.

  • @cinegoth4144
    @cinegoth4144 10 місяців тому

    The two Kill Bill films being of volumes and chapters are supposed to be like Mangas. It’s appropriate and interesting.

  • @marcusduran4399
    @marcusduran4399 9 місяців тому

    YES! I’m so glad to see someone who likes Hateful 8 as much as I do

  • @wiktorz8524
    @wiktorz8524 3 місяці тому +1

    5:40 I despise Mad Max series so much. I wanted to gouge my eyes watching fury road, i hate this movie with passion.

  • @yellow4525
    @yellow4525 7 місяців тому +2

    You imply that Blade Runner does not have substance and that is just wrong

  • @kenplant91
    @kenplant91 5 місяців тому +1

    You stated everything great about kill bill and then said you hated it for those very same reasons. I think you need to dig a bit deeper on it's inspirations/predecessors.

  • @TWHueyGuitar
    @TWHueyGuitar 10 місяців тому

    1. Django Unchained 2. Inglorious Basterds 3. Pulp Fiction 4. Reservoir Dogs 5. The Hateful 8 6. Jackie Brown 7. Once Upon a Time... 8. Death Proof 9. Kill Bill-I flip-flop on 1, 2, and 3 all the time, from the human triumph of Django to Inglorious Basterds' anti-critic diatribe or the sheer mastery of Pulp Fiction. The slow burners of Dogs, Hateful, Jackie Brown, and Once Upon a Time are all also masterpieces. Death Proof is easily Tarantino's most misunderstood and underrated, and I wish he'd do another horror film. For me, Kill Bill only works cohesively as a single film, and then an anti-climatic ending hits. As a standalone, the ending to Volume 2 doesn't have the impact needed to bring the story to a proper close. I know Tarantino says his next film will be his last and it looks like it'll be another love letter to Hollywood, but the dude really needs to make a foot fetish porno already and just get it out of his system.

  • @LeonardoIdono
    @LeonardoIdono 10 місяців тому

    I recently watched kill bill vol. 1 for the first time and didn’t like it nearly as much as his other films I’ve seen and thought I was insane because everyone else seems to love it so much but I kinda just felt nothing. It has nothing that I like about Tarantinos films. It has great direction and action sure but that’s not enough for me when I don’t care about what’s really going on. Now I haven’t watched vol. 2 yet but I hope it’s better than the first one.

  • @brandonhamaguchi
    @brandonhamaguchi 8 місяців тому

    What is the joke on the Bruce Lee scene? I forgot

  • @Shah-of-the-Shinebox
    @Shah-of-the-Shinebox 11 місяців тому

    9. Deathproof
    8. Jackie Brown
    7. Kill Bill 1&2
    6. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
    5. Django Unchained
    4. Reservoir Dogs
    3. The Hateful Eight
    2. Inglorious Bastards
    1. Pulp Fiction

  • @strangedays871
    @strangedays871 Місяць тому

    Completely agree with this list. Both Kill Bills are the only Tarantino films I would say to just skip.

  • @cybernetennis
    @cybernetennis 10 місяців тому

    Mine
    1.) Pulp Fiction
    2.) Jackie Brown
    3.) Kill Bill Vol. 1
    4.) Reservoir Dogs
    5.) Death Proof
    6.) Kill Bill Vol. 2
    7.) Django
    8.) Inglorious Bastards
    9.) The Hateful Eight
    10.) Once Upon A Time In Hollywood
    I really would love for him to make a Star Trek movie under a new name like Kirk Tarantino hehe

  • @jadecooper9049
    @jadecooper9049 5 місяців тому

    overall, I am happy with where he keep hateful 8 at

  • @FatherTime89
    @FatherTime89 Рік тому +3

    The ending to Inglorious Basterds doesn't seem out of character to me. IIRC Hans said/implied in the beginning he's only hunting Jews for the Nazis because it pays well and he's good at it, not out of dislike for Jews. So it gives his character a sel-centered mercenary vibe, with no strong loyalty to the Nazis. Him turning on them for a full pardon and a cushy retirement paid for by the Allies seems like something he might do if he seriously thought the Nazis were going to lose the war anyway.

  • @シャローム
    @シャローム 9 місяців тому

    10. Kill bill volume 1
    9. Deathproof
    8. Kill bill volume 2
    7.Jackie brown
    6. One upon a time in Hollywood
    5. Danjgo unchained
    4. Pulp fiction
    3.resevior dogs
    2. The hateful eight
    1. Inglorious basters

  • @bjrnbrynemo9059
    @bjrnbrynemo9059 10 місяців тому

    3:45 Exactly. Not caring about the characters is boring. In Pulp Fiction, you really care about Uma not od'ing. Here, I don't give a shit.