@@riyadey5783 Varun Dhawan dies, kunal khemu stabs him, baki sex toh ho hi gaya tha alia nd adi k beech so they live happily ever after like a husband wife🤣🤣
This review is really polite . This film is the worst. I was being impatient through out the movie. Although I agree with Kunal khemu's and aditya roy Kapoor's performance
Simply karan wanted Alia to do a period drama to prove a point to the world that she can be the next Deepika, PC, Ash in a Bhansali movie, he wanted to do a lw budget Bahubali and a combination of SLB movies, in between he wanted to add few other characters so that Alia would be the highlight of the movie yet people loved Adi and Kunal ....
Hahaha ofcourse IAM a big fan of her and I also accept the fact that movie is not upto the mark..and it is not watchable at all..but you have to admit that no producer makes a high budget film just to increase the stardom of a single actress..it's not a short film bro..whole lifes are invested in a single movie..
I'm so happy I wasn't the only one who noticed how weird it was in that song where both Madhuri and Alia sang in the same voice... Never in a SLB movie
Bhansali had used Kavita Krishnamurthy for Madhuri's voice and Shreya for Aishwarya's voice in Devdas. And Pinga? Could anybody tell me if Pinga was sung by only Shreya?
They did not sing in the same voice. The part where both the actresses lip sync the jugalbandi, one voice is of Shreya Ghoshal, and the other is of Vaishali Mhade.
@@nayanparabat1426 exactly my point, but it is strange how these people don't acknowledge the singing of other singers people don't even know that this song is sung by someone other than shreya as well... Strange
@@rohanshetty2343 I was asking a question, Mr. Shetty. People are not allowed to ask questions? It was not a rhetoric question that you accuse me of "not acknowledging " other singers.
Kjo uncle just wasted my Madhuri Dixit, Forget the Sanjay-Varun scene, it was so difficult to see Madhuri just standing and not dancing on Ghar more song but only Alia...Very Painful.
He had Madhuri - THE Madhuri, a supertalented actress and dancer who was kind enough to replace Sridevi, and yet, against all logic, he chose to highlight a mediocre actress who can't do classical dance, just because she is his protegee. Johar sabotaged his own film. Narcissistic moron.
Ikr!!!!! I was thinking the same while watching... Ash was so apt for that song bcoz it synced well with her character in the hddcs.. but here with alia it flopped, no connection at all...
I remember on koffee with Karan when Karan asked Abhishek Bacchan about who is better Deepika or Alia he said that depends on the genre of the movie . Alia is not capable of doing drama films due to lack of grace. Grace is not her cup of tea!
@@Finnola I am not a huge Deepika's fan but when she did Ram Leela Deepika was 27.Alia is 27 too..how much time does she want to grow up? It's been 7 years she has been working as an actress.
@@Finnola yes she doesnt fit for period drama but dude she has talent....kjo is putting her towards something shes not fit for...but that doesnt mean she hasn't grown up..like cmon have u seen her performance in raazi!just becz one film if hers is a flop doesnt mean shes immature or whatever......failure comes to everyone:)
@@archanasalunke2170 it's not about acting talent... It's jt some role requires something extra and for a period drama one needs certain amount which alia lacks nothing else... By d fan of both but a bit bias towards Deepika
@IamDon9999 Hello mind your language okkk itni jealousy wo bhi ek artist ke bare shame on your thinking yrrrr fuckkk😠😠😠😠😠😠tum jaiso ke muh me kide padenge ek ladki ke baare me itni ghatiya baate sade huwe eggs tere life me honge 100%tum jaise log iss jahan me kalank ho yrrr shrap lage tumko 😠😠😠😠😠😠😠
It's more like slb movie in kjo imagination. He only make this movie coz for past three four year period movies is earning good money, so he can also make quick money riding this wave. Second to make alia next queen.
Fukat ka net mil gaya toh kuch bhi bhokne ka idhar huh..konse angle se bahubali inspired lagti hai ye movie..no wonder moron like u exist in this country and kjo sells his shitty movies to people like you
@@chaitanyagawade9663 Are bhai itna dil pe kyu lerahe ho_ the grandeur and visual appeal of the movie is similar to bahubali. uspe ek bull fight bhi of sasta Bhallal Dev all does bring back memories of Bahubali.
It will sell tickets indeed and audience should be blamed for this more than Bollywood. People don't go to watch movies like Sonchiriya or Why Cheat India and then they complain Bollywood doesn't make good movies.
KJo (and their PR team) has actually made us into believing that shes indispensable. But like Kangana had a foresight, and of course we are a bit late to the party - Alia too isnt that versatile after all. Nothing can take away her past performances which were great, but right from Raazi, where I first started to see her pattern, I realised why Kangana is that much appalled with the kind of lobbying uncles like Kjo. Alia gets the best film even before the writers thought of someone. This is downright snatching of work from more deserving ones. Alia was atrocious in Kalank. The role demanded someone experienced. Bad biased casting.
I agree to this 100% .The dailogues were so horrible , don't even bother to understand. Also, Alia's expression were very weird during "Ghar mere pardesia".Not at all graceful.The movie tries to copies many scenes from Sanjay Leela Bhansali films like Alia's entry scene with kite is very similar to Aishwarya's in Hum Dil de chuke Sanam
What's with introduction scenes whether it's aishwarya or alia. Don't they do laundry or go to work in the fields. Anything other than damsel in distress singing, saying poetry, dancing, looking good, falling in love, married. The End.
Fact is Karan Johar promotes nepotism along with mediocrity. And this below average actress Alia is being touted as talented. This is lowering the bar for Bollywood movies. She has given similar expressions in all movies. No versatility at all. Bollywood is creating it's own narrative through PR.
Rubbish. Watch udta punjab and highway. Just bcoz she is mahesh bhatt's daughter and kjo's protege doesnt mean she is not talented. And rightwing kangna fans have to diss her.
I don't understand why people don't see how Sonakshi's part is key. She's the one who brings Roop into this world and family. I've been waiting to see one review that actually recognised that her part, even if she gets so little screen time, is key. And she's too underrated which makes me sad, her acting was brilliant considering the pain her character goes through in the film. (And Sona and Adi's chemistry is killing me!!!)
The film is soo soo slow.. n soo boring.. at last ending alia ask.. kya yea mohabbat hai ya tabhai something.. or log uth k bolne lage.. toture tha.. only sona n adi had done well act
"This is not Raazi or Titanic!" 😂 Love her one liners! Haven't seen the movie, but I think from comments that this review is better than the movie itself. Lol
Everyone (generally) complaints here that she is bashing the movie without much reason. Why is no one complaining now that is not bashing the movie enough. It was sheer garbage and utter waste of time (Bhai aaj kisko time h 3ghanta ka kabarda PVR me dekhne Ka). And don't come to me with the "visually stunning movie"; for that I can watch bajirao again, GOT or even better endgame is almost here!
Possible story plot hole: If Dev & Roop didn’t see each other’s face during the marriage, how on earth did he put the sindoor on her forehead and through her hair?... But then according to Dharma Productions Rajasthan has snowcapped mountains so what do I know 🤷♂️
Truly biased review ...I think much more better than Anupama Chopra Mam.....she has said most bad things about the film...for 5 mins....you would expect ohkk she will give 1 or 2 star....and at last she shocks by giving 3 stars.... Very nepotism supporter..... bas kro mam andha samjhi ho ka..!! We are also that much intelligent... ohkkk....so be unbiased...but I loved at least not a movie review and Rajeev Masand for not being biased..!!
Flim Campaion have two shows i.e. Anupma's review & Not a Movie review..so they are balancing the act.. It's called Flim Marketing.& you can't find Anupma's review harsh as she has always supported nepotism & illogical contents by illogical Directors & biased Producers.
Was expecting a lot more bashing though, I was literally pulling my hair out watching this ridiculously exhausting movie PS...did anyone else wonder, so many blue men came from inside the water, only to shoot burning arrows at ravan?
Let me just say that just because you can get the money... doesn't mean you can get the essence.... abhishek berman has tried very hard to match Sanjay leela bhansali elegance and opulence, especially from devdas, but he cannot match the vision and the heartbreak that each scene gave us.... in fact maar dala and kahe chedd mohe still gives a better feeling than any of the songs of kalank .... the only saving Graces are arijit and shreya
Yes but even SLB can't live up to his own greatness of Devdas. I can say the exact same about Bajirao Mastani and Padmavat. They're both so soulless and empty on emotion and story.
@@kbg12ila there definitely is a bit of a gap between these two and devdas , however I feel that the madness that was portrayed in the live of bajirao and mastani definitely moved the audience , and so did khiljis in padmaavat. Somewhere, I think that abhishek missed out on the the feel completely
@@mannatkapoor812 Yeah. I'm still watching Kalank because I've booked the tickets. Plus hearing those songs on the big screen will be worth it. I just wish we got films that had the heart of Devdas. Kal Ho Na Ho. DDLJ. With the scale and epicness of Kalank and Bajirao.
@@kbg12ila Devdas had Chandramukhi played by Madhuri. THAT was the soul of the movie. In Kalank Madhuri was underutilized because Johar wanted the focus on his pet, Alia - an actress with an average range and looks. They even wasted the opportunity they had with Madhuri and Sanjay - you have legends like these two and you don't give them enoug hscenes. Thats how stupid those people are. Kalank will flop badly, like other Dharma projects in the coming year, and that's because he is a mediocre producer who hires mediocre crew and casts mostly nepokids. Karma will get Dharma.
@@vissou2797 I just finished watching it. It does have problems but I don't care about certain actors getting scenes because they are legends. If the story doesn't call for it they shouldn't get it. Madhuri was by far one of the best things in this movie. I really felt her character doing what she can to redeem her past that was full of such heartbreak. The song Tabaah Go Gaye really brought things together. No song in any SLB movie has been able to heighten the emotions of the stories since Devdas. This did that with Tabaah Go Gaye. That scene ended so well. Overall I feel the movie had hollow moments but I felt more emotion with the characters in this than in Bajirao and Padmavat. Which both gave absolutely no time to develop anything in the story. I don't care about all this politics that you and so many others care about. I want a good film. This wasn't great but it wasn't as bad as some people WANT it to be.
Wahiyat movie.. not at all good editing and although the whole movie feels very stretched but the last 15 mins is worst.. I hate to say Alia is totally disappointing this time.. 1 star bhi just for the Arijit Singh kalank title song
P Trivedi haha on point, she’s considered a good actress in Hindi film industry because they have set the bar so low that even something Okayish is branded as larger than life.
@@dollysingh007 that's why most of the star kids hates kangana because she reminds them what a real actress are without any support from fellow bollywood stars her movie collects 100 crores.
Look at alia after soty she got all meaty roles under good directors who has the capability to bring out the best of anyone. But make her work with a mediocre director and see her inner Kareena Kapoor come out. Overrated af.
@@SOMYArockzz I think she was really good in a few movies like highway, udta punjab, and raazi. I think she does better when given fiesty, underestimated characters rather than regal characters. Plus this movie was just horrible. Even Madhur Dixit was underwhelming in this.
I don't understand why people cannot judge a movie by its trailer and still waste their time and money on such a nautanki of a movie. This was always going to be a disaster by the looks in the trailer. I'm just waiting for Sacred Games 2
pichle kuch saalo mein movies ka standard bhut neeche aa chuka hai.... Hollywood mein bhi aur bolly mein bhi.... ab achi movies nhi bnti.... Quality ab zero.... har movie mein varun dhawan same hi acting krta hai.... alia bhi same.... aditya roy toh kre na kre ek hi baat hai aur sonakshi ka toh kehna hi bekaar hai.... koi excitement hi nhi hoti movies ko dekhne ke liye ...
Yes it has two singers but I think in between Shreya voice is on alya and Madhuri both , Shreya sings for Madhuri also and Alia also and in between vashili sings .why so inconsistent
Why no review on The Tashkent Files? Such a magnificent movie. Btw guys go and watch it if its there near you, it definitely deserves more screens than this senseless movie. Only 250 screenings across India.. Not fair!
Better story telling and performances, no unnecessary plot twists; straight facts but screenplay is very good ,it keeps you invested till the end. Surely worth a watch.
By seeing the trailer itself I knew that it is again going to be superficial all show and no substance type movie... A bollywood movie with numerous cast is usually a khichdi the writers don't deserve to be called writers because I don't think they are even passionate about their work.. and rely hugely on the framework and clothes and magnificent set pieces.. the thing which I don't understand is why do they drag it to 2- 3 hrs.. just finish it in 1 hr... atleast then it might gain some positive reviews.
@@tanukul in the beginning I think Madhuri or Alia had tweeted mentioning both of them. But in subsequent promotion only Shreya was mentioned. This happened even with Pinga from Bajirao. Vaishali is indeed very talented and has different vocal texture... :)
there's a thing going on in Karan to prove alia is better than Deepika. He even asks this question to his koffee guests. But one thing is sure... Deepika carries a grace from om Shanti Om time... Alia is far away from that.
I saw Anupamas review before yours and was a little confused but having seen your take on it I can very well relate to the way you felt through the film. Thank you for saving my money and my time Sucharita! You're a true treasure. f For some reason I can always gauge how I will feel about a film because of your reviews (even if we might have slightly different opinions at times).
So I saw Kalank today. It's not half as bad as people are making it out to be. Its engrossing and its stunning to look at. See it on the big screen..definitely a solid 3/5.
I’m very disappointed as well. I have great reviews of it otherwise, too bad film companion didn’t give it any publicity. Movies like those should be promoted more than kalank
I would not accuse or assume bias here. Film like Tashkent files though not exactly great film, an insight from professionals and some comparison with JFK etc would be great since the film is partially a documentary . I was an ardent fan for Sucharita and was very disappointed
Why are people so crazy about Alia. She isn’t even a good actress. Don’t quote Highway, Udta Punjab, Raazi and Gully Boy as examples of her talent. These movies worked for their scripts more than because of Alia. She had these films offered to her on a platter thanks to her mentors, parents and PR. Even Shraddha Kapoor is better than her but doesn’t get these kinda films because no KJo to dictate the terms for her career. She has definitely improved as an actress but any one would with such a variety of work being offered to them. She mostly plays herself in most films and has shown very little range. There are much better actresses than her in the industry who struggle to get the same limelight. I want to but I just can’t like her.
Ok forget Shraddha, what about Parineeti? She is definitely better than Alia, she just doesn’t get the right projects or doesn’t choose the right projects. I’m not sure which 1. Her talent is being wasted in movies like Kesari etc
Alia is given all the best films any actress can pull. She is same in all the movies such a below average actress. Kangna would have pulled off the role excellently
Oh please don't promote that attention seeking megalomaniac Kangana. She is toxic and no this is not a role for her. These are roles made for more elegant actors like Madhuri, Aishwarya, Priyanka or Deepika
@@Stephensofceea I am not promoting kangna but saying that she could pull any role given to her with utmost perfection as she is the best actress of the current lot
ANMOL JAISWAL you read my mind bro I always tell People she is just average look wise and acting which any actress can do hence proved she fails miserably when tried to be deepika or aishwarya as she lacks grace
Great review, Sucharita. Candid as always and I so agree with some points that u made. Like using Shreya's voice for both characters followed by the illogical dialogue. And having item numbers just for the heck of it even though they don't fit and Varun dancing and emoting the same whether it is a film based in 1940's or present era. Wonder why these vastly experienced film makers who have even studied film making can't see such obvious flaws in their work. Can't imagine Sridevi signed up for this!
The worst thing is that after acting all high and mighty and marrying Dev on her own demand, Roop acts like a bichari as if she was forced into the marriage and does not even try the least to resist Zafar's clear flirting from the beginning. Being realistic, when the husband is so handsome, successful, and nice, I don't know which girl will fall for another man. BTW am I the only one who found Alia_Adi chemistry stronger than the Alia_Varun chemistry? I really want to see them together again.
@@sudeshnapodder5876 if you say will watch it but before this, can you tell me when you see evolution in Bollywood except some nawazuddin films all are rubbish So I decide to move towards Hollywood !!
Rohit Singh i agree with you but since an year we got some good movies from bollywood. Im in the US and people discussed about andhadhun even in office. Uri, manikarnika, pink, badhai ho, badla... atleast some people are trying to break the stereotypes. Yeah, i dont support nepotism and hate KJ. Many good movies wont get released in my place but this trash is released in multiple theatres here. Btw did you see haider? Worth watching. Its older though. Im a big fan of rajkumar, nawaz, irfan, ayushmann, vicky, kangana, tabu and radhika.
@@sudeshnapodder5876 fine you talked about haider I watched it but did you try to know what's its base, its base is hamlet man William Shakespeare's novel there is no other idea and imagination in it on their own. Uri and manikarnika are true events I think it's base is clear to you. But andhadhun yeah its imbd top 250 I appreciate that and badhi ho too. But keep consider these films in my some film as exception that I mentioned before ...
@@sudeshnapodder5876 sorry I fail to mention that I am also a big fan of nawaz and Irrfan too and Vicky is little nawaz for me and ayushman is on his way to nawaz like actor ..😆😆😆
Sucharita, I look up to you for any film reviews and as always you are doing an awesome job, irrespective of the film's fate.... Keep Rocking... Keep Reviewing... Keep Entertaining.... Cheers
Also was the art director fired from SLB pictures...and the slo mo was painful...aaaaaannnndddd why was everyone talking like they are some philosophy professor....
Only Madhuri did justice n she was damm good in the film. But again length of the film made it sink terribly. Wherever Madhuri came specially the scene in which she stops Varun n the scene when she says she won't leave the place as she has hindu girls with her. Was just fab.
Why do you comment on things that you don't know? Kathak? That's not even beginner's Kathak let alone be flawless. Don't be that naive to comment things like that.
I am enjoying your reviews so much off lately. Earlier I would see it for fun and maybe sometimes forget it. These days it holds a lot of value in my movie-going choices. More power to you Sucharita :)
Her acting is as mediocre as your english /grammar! Alia and kunal khemu were really good performance wise! U need to change ur standards of what u consider as acting
Actually the song घर मोरे परदेसीया sung by two singers Shreya-90% 10% vaishali made U know vaishali made? She is the 1 who can sing so wisely but u cannot recognise her voice in that particular song .same like' pinga' song. Btw alia's सरगम part sung by vaishali made.
I agree with everything you said....the movie was nostalgic to me....not in a good way though...the bull fight sequence reminded me of Alif Laila... remember from bachpan!!!
They hired another singer ma'am... Vaishali Mhade... Who does the sargam but it seems that nobody noticed her. She is the same girl who gave her voice for Pinga(Bajirao Mastani)along with Shreya Ghoshal, maybe everybody missed her there too. Please give her some credit. She is a talented singer too with amazing skill.
2:43 - Ghar More Pardesiya has been sung by Shreya Ghoshal and Vaishali Mdahe - Ghoshal sang Madhuri Ma'am's part and Mdahe sang Alia's part. FYI these two singers have earlier collaborated for Pinga. Get your facts right!
Ur reviews r becoming a bit more serious and technical and less of the comedy show that we have come to adore. Koi baat nehi. Change is good. I'm with u.
I think the song Ghar Mere Pardesiya is sung by Shreya Ghoshal AND Vaishali Mhade, the same two singers who sang for Deepika and Priyanka in Pinga (Bajirao Mastani). They have similar voice textures which is why it sounds like the same singer. Not that I am not in agreement with your review of the film, but just wanted to point out that 2 singers are credited for the vocals on that song.
Good you mentioned titanic even if while pointing out the need to have a narration in the movie because while watching the film I did feel the director was on a trip of making his own version of the 'titanisque' type of love. Why do you think the partition track even exists, it resonates the parting of Jack and Rose. Also, notice the romantic theme playing in the background every time varun and aalia appear on screen. It sounds like a twisted version of the song 'my heart will go on' on the flute. All said and done this film proves that very few film makers make movies to transcend the audiences into a fantasy world. Most are just venting out their inspirations.
So basically the movie was so bad that sucharita wasn't able to find even sarcasm to troll it! That is why it took long😂
sucharita is sold to kjo & put kalank on her review
Sach may bakwass movie hai, I saw yesterday, its a hedache
@@shrutiathghara964 end me kaun marta he aur kaun zinda rehta he yeh bata do behen.😂😂😂😂
Dhawan marta hai. Sab rote hain. Lol
@@riyadey5783 Varun Dhawan dies, kunal khemu stabs him, baki sex toh ho hi gaya tha alia nd adi k beech so they live happily ever after like a husband wife🤣🤣
This review is really polite . This film is the worst. I was being impatient through out the movie. Although I agree with Kunal khemu's and aditya roy Kapoor's performance
Yashika Chhabra ending kya thi ?
Can u pls tell me the whole story? Pls
@@funcreations6341 Jake movie dekbna
As if Varun's and Alia's performance was bad.
RIP for you 😂😂😂
Simply karan wanted Alia to do a period drama to prove a point to the world that she can be the next Deepika, PC, Ash in a Bhansali movie, he wanted to do a lw budget Bahubali and a combination of SLB movies, in between he wanted to add few other characters so that Alia would be the highlight of the movie yet people loved Adi and Kunal ....
1 number bola bhai....
Bro!!! So according to you the whole 100cr budget movie is just made to highlight one single actress?? What a point man 👏
@@anudeeputhejthaduri7530 fan boy alert ....... who cannot take criticism 😁
Well u r 100% correct
Hahaha ofcourse IAM a big fan of her and I also accept the fact that movie is not upto the mark..and it is not watchable at all..but you have to admit that no producer makes a high budget film just to increase the stardom of a single actress..it's not a short film bro..whole lifes are invested in a single movie..
I'm so happy I wasn't the only one who noticed how weird it was in that song where both Madhuri and Alia sang in the same voice... Never in a SLB movie
Bhansali had used Kavita Krishnamurthy for Madhuri's voice and Shreya for Aishwarya's voice in Devdas. And Pinga? Could anybody tell me if Pinga was sung by only Shreya?
@@WoSarvatraHain pinga was sung by Shreya Ghoshal and Vaishali
They did not sing in the same voice. The part where both the actresses lip sync the jugalbandi, one voice is of Shreya Ghoshal, and the other is of Vaishali Mhade.
@@nayanparabat1426 exactly my point, but it is strange how these people don't acknowledge the singing of other singers people don't even know that this song is sung by someone other than shreya as well... Strange
@@rohanshetty2343 I was asking a question, Mr. Shetty. People are not allowed to ask questions? It was not a rhetoric question that you accuse me of "not acknowledging " other singers.
Alia has no grace.She doesn't fit in period drama.Johar wanted to be Bhansali and make Alia look like Deepika but obviously this was an epic fail 😏
Exactly!!
And He will never be able to match Sanjay Leela Bhansali , that's for sure.
Yes so true! When I saw Alia's dance performance in kalank I started liking Deepika way more in all her bhansali movies..
Alia has a baby face, we try to find a more "Womanly " face in period drama.
Only Madhuri nailed trust me.
Kjo uncle just wasted my Madhuri Dixit, Forget the Sanjay-Varun scene, it was so difficult to see Madhuri just standing and not dancing on Ghar more song but only Alia...Very Painful.
In last line, you wrote my heart out.
And alia was moving like chalkri 😂
@@gyansahu2894 The contrast was painful :(
He had Madhuri - THE Madhuri, a supertalented actress and dancer who was kind enough to replace Sridevi, and yet, against all logic, he chose to highlight a mediocre actress who can't do classical dance, just because she is his protegee. Johar sabotaged his own film. Narcissistic moron.
@@gyansahu2894 lol you told my heart out😂
Alia’s patangwala scene was completely Copy of Aishwarya from Hum Dil
👌👏❤️👍
Even I felt it.
Ikr!!!!! I was thinking the same while watching... Ash was so apt for that song bcoz it synced well with her character in the hddcs.. but here with alia it flopped, no connection at all...
Aishwarya has that physique of a lady, this girl looks like a girl child of 12
I remember on koffee with Karan when Karan asked Abhishek Bacchan about who is better Deepika or Alia he said that depends on the genre of the movie . Alia is not capable of doing drama films due to lack of grace. Grace is not her cup of tea!
She's what 10 yrs old, give her time to grow up.
@@Finnola I am not a huge Deepika's fan but when she did Ram Leela Deepika was 27.Alia is 27 too..how much time does she want to grow up? It's been 7 years she has been working as an actress.
@@Finnola yes she doesnt fit for period drama but dude she has talent....kjo is putting her towards something shes not fit for...but that doesnt mean she hasn't grown up..like cmon have u seen her performance in raazi!just becz one film if hers is a flop doesnt mean shes immature or whatever......failure comes to everyone:)
@@archanasalunke2170 it's not about acting talent... It's jt some role requires something extra and for a period drama one needs certain amount which alia lacks nothing else... By d fan of both but a bit bias towards Deepika
Agreed
Kalank is Alia's audition for SLB film! Inshaallah...LOL
and guess WHAT?? she got the role ;)
@Neeti K So what yrrr movie script not okk alia ki acting best hai ok dufferrrrrrrrrrrrr 👎👎👎👎alia is best actress 😚😚😚😚😚😚😚
😂😂😂
@Neeti K I know but don't blame alia 😠😠😠😠
@IamDon9999 Hello mind your language okkk itni jealousy wo bhi ek artist ke bare shame on your thinking yrrrr fuckkk😠😠😠😠😠😠tum jaiso ke muh me kide padenge ek ladki ke baare me itni ghatiya baate sade huwe eggs tere life me honge 100%tum jaise log iss jahan me kalank ho yrrr shrap lage tumko 😠😠😠😠😠😠😠
There is a reason why this movie was named Kalank !!
😂😂😂
I can actually see the visual in my head, Anupama saying to Sucharita before making this video - "Go easy on this."
Hahaha
9815758598
I also felt that the songs doesn't look like from that era especially First Class and kriti Sanon Song..
I disagree ,it's 1940's not a completely different era dude
Kriti Sanon song was useless there...faltu my lambi movie banai h
Alia had something missing in this movie.....I felt Sonakshi was better than her in terms of acting skills
Tushar Tyagi Alia is in love, she forgot acting.
@@sudeshnapodder5876 Kuch bhi ?
Manik people become blind when they fall in love 🤗 after highway and razi s good acting, what else can i say when i watched kalank.
Tushar Tyagi sonakshi is great actress it's just that she didn't get a chance to show this side of her......
Sonakshi is so underrated
Bollywood's version of Bahubali in a Karan Johar imaginative partition era without any storyline.
This is nothing like Bahubali, there are no kings, no war with gigantic armies and no kingdom politics
It's more like slb movie in kjo imagination.
He only make this movie coz for past three four year period movies is earning good money, so he can also make quick money riding this wave.
Second to make alia next queen.
Fukat ka net mil gaya toh kuch bhi bhokne ka idhar huh..konse angle se bahubali inspired lagti hai ye movie..no wonder moron like u exist in this country and kjo sells his shitty movies to people like you
@@chaitanyagawade9663 Are bhai itna dil pe kyu lerahe ho_ the grandeur and visual appeal of the movie is similar to bahubali. uspe ek bull fight bhi of sasta Bhallal Dev all does bring back memories of Bahubali.
Hope they never make an avengers version even in their imagination 😂
It's par time Bollywood understand pretty faces won't sell tickets.
It will sell tickets indeed and audience should be blamed for this more than Bollywood. People don't go to watch movies like Sonchiriya or Why Cheat India and then they complain Bollywood doesn't make good movies.
@Bikash rak
Nepotism sells tickets apparently.
@@ankurbaksi6502 bhai cheat india bi bakwas thi sonchiriya gjab thi
Ab avengers aag lagayegi
@Shlok Chitnis zee5 par hai bhai
KJo (and their PR team) has actually made us into believing that shes indispensable. But like Kangana had a foresight, and of course we are a bit late to the party - Alia too isnt that versatile after all. Nothing can take away her past performances which were great, but right from Raazi, where I first started to see her pattern, I realised why Kangana is that much appalled with the kind of lobbying uncles like Kjo. Alia gets the best film even before the writers thought of someone. This is downright snatching of work from more deserving ones. Alia was atrocious in Kalank. The role demanded someone experienced. Bad biased casting.
What else do you expect from Karan Johar? Him and his nepotism 🤦♀️
AMEN
Aditi rao hydari would have much much better cast
Although what you said is true but it should also be noted that writers editors and director is also at fault here.
@@shravs734 definitely. Too much to criticize actually.
I agree to this 100% .The dailogues were so horrible , don't even bother to understand. Also, Alia's expression were very weird during "Ghar mere pardesia".Not at all graceful.The movie tries to copies many scenes from Sanjay Leela Bhansali films like Alia's entry scene with kite is very similar to Aishwarya's in Hum Dil de chuke Sanam
What's with introduction scenes whether it's aishwarya or alia. Don't they do laundry or go to work in the fields. Anything other than damsel in distress singing, saying poetry, dancing, looking good, falling in love, married. The End.
Alia ka ek expression 😑,
Rajasthan Sr cut to ladakh
True .... when i saw that it was really that epic part o hum Dil de chuke sanam
I felt each and EVERYTHING.....you said while watching the movie.. it was a Senseless movie 😖
'Upside down pyramid shaped body'.... Funniest compliment ever read😁😂😁
Fact is Karan Johar promotes nepotism along with mediocrity. And this below average actress Alia is being touted as talented. This is lowering the bar for Bollywood movies. She has given similar expressions in all movies. No versatility at all. Bollywood is creating it's own narrative through PR.
Right
Rubbish. Watch udta punjab and highway. Just bcoz she is mahesh bhatt's daughter and kjo's protege doesnt mean she is not talented. And rightwing kangna fans have to diss her.
And gully boy
@@sulaganabiswas4801 Go back to school. You're incoherent illogical moron. I'm expressing my opinion & I don't have to be someone's fan for that.
@@sulaganabiswas4801 And you Anti national naxal? Name Bengali. You must be belong to the extinct left party😆
I don't understand why people don't see how Sonakshi's part is key. She's the one who brings Roop into this world and family. I've been waiting to see one review that actually recognised that her part, even if she gets so little screen time, is key. And she's too underrated which makes me sad, her acting was brilliant considering the pain her character goes through in the film. (And Sona and Adi's chemistry is killing me!!!)
The film is soo soo slow.. n soo boring.. at last ending alia ask.. kya yea mohabbat hai ya tabhai something.. or log uth k bolne lage.. toture tha.. only sona n adi had done well act
😂
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
My review
Watch it for Aditya and sonakshi or else skip
Yeah true
I love you sucharita. I wish I was as confident as you. It looks like you live your life to the fullest. You are doing your dream job.
Aren't you happy we have no goras in Kalank after thugs of hindostan? XD
haha! Yes isko edward sonnenblick se childhood dusmani hai.
😂😂😂😂
"This is not Raazi or Titanic!" 😂 Love her one liners! Haven't seen the movie, but I think from comments that this review is better than the movie itself. Lol
Everyone (generally) complaints here that she is bashing the movie without much reason. Why is no one complaining now that is not bashing the movie enough. It was sheer garbage and utter waste of time (Bhai aaj kisko time h 3ghanta ka kabarda PVR me dekhne Ka).
And don't come to me with the "visually stunning movie"; for that I can watch bajirao again, GOT or even better endgame is almost here!
Please don't compare got to this shit.
@Nakul Garg Bhai hum culture ke baare me bole kya? I was specifically talking about visually stunning, which EVERYONE knows endgame is gonna be😄😍😍😍
@@pranshuanand4560 kitne rs. lgenge endgame ko? Should i watch in theater? In 3d?
@Shlok Chitnis kitna lgega imax me
@Shlok Chitnis hm thanks mai friday ko jaunga.
Possible story plot hole:
If Dev & Roop didn’t see each other’s face during the marriage, how on earth did he put the sindoor on her forehead and through her hair?...
But then according to Dharma Productions Rajasthan has snowcapped mountains so what do I know 🤷♂️
I was imagining your review while watching the film 😂
😂😂😂
aap zinda wapaas aagye cinema hall se?
@@gauravmishra8561 bro i am in hospital.
@@paobalaji1748 now your medicine cant reach before 26 april
Yeah, gonna get it from thanos baba himself
Sucharita 's face in that thumbnail says it all. I am writing this before watching review. Let's see if I am a good expression reader or not.
Was waiting for this review since the beginning of the day......your reviews match my taste
Try tongue cleaner
Truly biased review ...I think much more better than Anupama Chopra Mam.....she has said most bad things about the film...for 5 mins....you would expect ohkk she will give 1 or 2 star....and at last she shocks by giving 3 stars.... Very nepotism supporter..... bas kro mam andha samjhi ho ka..!! We are also that much intelligent... ohkkk....so be unbiased...but I loved at least not a movie review and Rajeev Masand for not being biased..!!
Flim Campaion have two shows i.e. Anupma's review & Not a Movie review..so they are balancing the act.. It's called Flim Marketing.& you can't find Anupma's review harsh as she has always supported nepotism & illogical contents by illogical Directors & biased Producers.
But nobody can top anupamas intro 😂😂 Sanjay peels bhansali movie not directed by slb
Anupama Chopra rated Befikre at 3.5 out of 5. If you rely on her reviews after that, you need help!
Atleast sucharita gave it 1 out of 10 :v
If she is unbiased then why didn't she review Tashkent files yet? All of them are hypocrites and chamchas of Bollywood. Shame
Was expecting a lot more bashing though, I was literally pulling my hair out watching this ridiculously exhausting movie
PS...did anyone else wonder, so many blue men came from inside the water, only to shoot burning arrows at ravan?
True true
Karan finally proved Deepika is best and now stop comparing Alia with deepika
Deepika isn't the best dude
She is pretty mediocre and overrated
i knew this film wouldnt work when i saw that damn fake CGI bull .....like come on
martha solomon me too I don’t even waste time to watch it at home
Kunal khemu is one under rated actor 😐
Let me just say that just because you can get the money... doesn't mean you can get the essence.... abhishek berman has tried very hard to match Sanjay leela bhansali elegance and opulence, especially from devdas, but he cannot match the vision and the heartbreak that each scene gave us.... in fact maar dala and kahe chedd mohe still gives a better feeling than any of the songs of kalank .... the only saving Graces are arijit and shreya
Yes but even SLB can't live up to his own greatness of Devdas. I can say the exact same about Bajirao Mastani and Padmavat. They're both so soulless and empty on emotion and story.
@@kbg12ila there definitely is a bit of a gap between these two and devdas , however I feel that the madness that was portrayed in the live of bajirao and mastani definitely moved the audience , and so did khiljis in padmaavat. Somewhere, I think that abhishek missed out on the the feel completely
@@mannatkapoor812 Yeah. I'm still watching Kalank because I've booked the tickets. Plus hearing those songs on the big screen will be worth it. I just wish we got films that had the heart of Devdas. Kal Ho Na Ho. DDLJ. With the scale and epicness of Kalank and Bajirao.
@@kbg12ila Devdas had Chandramukhi played by Madhuri. THAT was the soul of the movie. In Kalank Madhuri was underutilized because Johar wanted the focus on his pet, Alia - an actress with an average range and looks. They even wasted the opportunity they had with Madhuri and Sanjay - you have legends like these two and you don't give them enoug hscenes. Thats how stupid those people are. Kalank will flop badly, like other Dharma projects in the coming year, and that's because he is a mediocre producer who hires mediocre crew and casts mostly nepokids. Karma will get Dharma.
@@vissou2797 I just finished watching it. It does have problems but I don't care about certain actors getting scenes because they are legends. If the story doesn't call for it they shouldn't get it. Madhuri was by far one of the best things in this movie. I really felt her character doing what she can to redeem her past that was full of such heartbreak. The song Tabaah Go Gaye really brought things together. No song in any SLB movie has been able to heighten the emotions of the stories since Devdas. This did that with Tabaah Go Gaye. That scene ended so well. Overall I feel the movie had hollow moments but I felt more emotion with the characters in this than in Bajirao and Padmavat. Which both gave absolutely no time to develop anything in the story.
I don't care about all this politics that you and so many others care about. I want a good film. This wasn't great but it wasn't as bad as some people WANT it to be.
Finally it's here! Your review seems more genuine ❤
Karan Ahuja Anupama Mam se to better hi h....at least not supporting nepotism
KALANK is a poetry in boredom.
Wahiyat movie.. not at all good editing and although the whole movie feels very stretched but the last 15 mins is worst..
I hate to say Alia is totally disappointing this time..
1 star bhi just for the Arijit Singh kalank title song
4:15 you can say... *cough* alia's mediocrity jumped out *cough*
P Trivedi haha on point, she’s considered a good actress in Hindi film industry because they have set the bar so low that even something Okayish is branded as larger than life.
@@dollysingh007 that's why most of the star kids hates kangana because she reminds them what a real actress are without any support from fellow bollywood stars her movie collects 100 crores.
Look at alia after soty she got all meaty roles under good directors who has the capability to bring out the best of anyone. But make her work with a mediocre director and see her inner Kareena Kapoor come out. Overrated af.
@@SOMYArockzz I think she was really good in a few movies like highway, udta punjab, and raazi. I think she does better when given fiesty, underestimated characters rather than regal characters. Plus this movie was just horrible. Even Madhur Dixit was underwhelming in this.
@@radmoonable they were good scripts,alia was okay in all of them!
a kalank on the film industry
I don't understand why people cannot judge a movie by its trailer and still waste their time and money on such a nautanki of a movie. This was always going to be a disaster by the looks in the trailer. I'm just waiting for Sacred Games 2
Me too😇
Wahi yr mtlb ab soty2 bhi dekhne jayenge trailer dekhne k baad bhi 😂😂😂
@@mansithakur3705 absolutely.. that's another movie you should completely avoid
Sh Mu me too
Flop year started for kjo.. Kalank.. and SOTY 2 also will be flop
He has some fantasy sci-fi movie coming up as well as another historical movie. Trying to give an answer to China's Wandering Earth.
brahmastra also
expect 10 minutes i slept in hall.
0:38 Hair and abs always on point. 😂😂🤣🤣🤣 you should write dialogues, pehle hi minute me tabaahi. 👍🏼
DKsays_ 😂😂
I think Alia has requested KJ to make period drama movie to compete with deepika.
🤣🤣
deepika was the first choice for the film. she rejected it.
😂😂😂😂
@@mustaquimahmedtanbeer2437 Was Deepika really approached first? I wonder why she rejected?
@@AishwaryaNet yes. dont know why she rejected it.
pichle kuch saalo mein movies ka standard bhut neeche aa chuka hai.... Hollywood mein bhi aur bolly mein bhi.... ab achi movies nhi bnti.... Quality ab zero.... har movie mein varun dhawan same hi acting krta hai.... alia bhi same.... aditya roy toh kre na kre ek hi baat hai aur sonakshi ka toh kehna hi bekaar hai.... koi excitement hi nhi hoti movies ko dekhne ke liye ...
Netflix, Amazon aur UA-cam mein films dekh bhai. Badiya content.
Try mollywood films , it has got content n am sure u wont be disappointed.
Agreed.
There's no excitement for movies these days.
Uri ya Queen ya Piku ya Gully boy ya ..... dekhi hai bhai ki so rahe the aur Alia Varun k alava Kuch aur nahi dekhte
Watch Andhadhun
Ghar more Pardesiya is sung by Shreya Ghoshal and Vaishali Mhade ... and the aalap in question has both singers singing ..
Unfortunately it was out of syllabus for the reviewer...:D
Yes it has two singers but I think in between Shreya voice is on alya and Madhuri both , Shreya sings for Madhuri also and Alia also and in between vashili sings .why so inconsistent
But 2 singers ga rahe hain toh voice ka difference toh pata chalna chaiye.
@@fida80 Yes, I think that was part of the problem. I don't blame Sucharita; it is confusing.
Why no review on The Tashkent Files? Such a magnificent movie. Btw guys go and watch it if its there near you, it definitely deserves more screens than this senseless movie. Only 250 screenings across India.. Not fair!
Better story telling and performances, no unnecessary plot twists; straight facts but screenplay is very good ,it keeps you invested till the end.
Surely worth a watch.
It seems to have been left out.Too political I guess.
These people are hypocrites. They won't review Tashkent files. Shame on such people.
Anupama gave 3/5 but I have faith in you and you proved it...thank u sucharita... boring movie 😖
Karan has always been jealous of bhansali. He wanted to do that kind of movie from a long time. So now he can say it's off the bucket list 😂😂😂
She speaks so fast .. like she is missing a train. Slow down babe. Raazdhani express.
I think review is better than the movie itself
I watched it thrice
I like the girl in the video
Her speech is mersmerizing
By seeing the trailer itself I knew that it is again going to be superficial all show and no substance type movie... A bollywood movie with numerous cast is usually a khichdi the writers don't deserve to be called writers because I don't think they are even passionate about their work.. and rely hugely on the framework and clothes and magnificent set pieces.. the thing which I don't understand is why do they drag it to 2- 3 hrs.. just finish it in 1 hr... atleast then it might gain some positive reviews.
Sucharita Ghar More has two voices. Shreya and Vaishali Mhade... :)
only Shreya is credited as the singer on all platforms.
@@tanukul thats very sad truth about this industry
@@tanukul in the beginning I think Madhuri or Alia had tweeted mentioning both of them. But in subsequent promotion only Shreya was mentioned. This happened even with Pinga from Bajirao. Vaishali is indeed very talented and has different vocal texture... :)
It does have two voices but Alia lip syncs on both 😂
@@subhan_amir Alia must be very happy to revisit the SOTY days back on the set of Kalank😂
why can't they work on the story. They just keep serving disappointments. BTW you sucharita are amazing. On point and never disappointing
there's a thing going on in Karan to prove alia is better than Deepika. He even asks this question to his koffee guests. But one thing is sure... Deepika carries a grace from om Shanti Om time... Alia is far away from that.
Anyone else think Alia’s intro scene was completely a copy of Aishwarya from Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam?
Plz....just let SLB sir make epic movies.
What a waste of money n time.
How brave of stars to promote such a hopeless movie..!!
I saw Anupamas review before yours and was a little confused but having seen your take on it I can very well relate to the way you felt through the film. Thank you for saving my money and my time Sucharita! You're a true treasure. f
For some reason I can always gauge how I will feel about a film because of your reviews (even if we might have slightly different opinions at times).
Kalank ek kalank movie hai. Big cast and big set only. Torture pls dont waste ur money like me.
So I saw Kalank today. It's not half as bad as people are making it out to be. Its engrossing and its stunning to look at. See it on the big screen..definitely a solid 3/5.
*Being in the kalank theatre*
We're in the Endgame now...
yes bro we are going to watch end game now
I am disappointed with Film companion that there was no review of Tashkent Files ....
I’m very disappointed as well. I have great reviews of it otherwise, too bad film companion didn’t give it any publicity. Movies like those should be promoted more than kalank
I would not accuse or assume bias here. Film like Tashkent files though not exactly great film, an insight from professionals and some comparison with JFK etc would be great since the film is partially a documentary .
I was an ardent fan for Sucharita and was very disappointed
Propaganda movie
Can people just admit Alia is just lucky with the movies but not really a great actress. Bollywood should stop pushing her on audiences.
Why are people so crazy about Alia. She isn’t even a good actress. Don’t quote Highway, Udta Punjab, Raazi and Gully Boy as examples of her talent. These movies worked for their scripts more than because of Alia. She had these films offered to her on a platter thanks to her mentors, parents and PR. Even Shraddha Kapoor is better than her but doesn’t get these kinda films because no KJo to dictate the terms for her career.
She has definitely improved as an actress but any one would with such a variety of work being offered to them. She mostly plays herself in most films and has shown very little range.
There are much better actresses than her in the industry who struggle to get the same limelight. I want to but I just can’t like her.
She has too many eggs in her basket.
I agree on every part except "Shraddha Kapoor" as a good/better actress! Like really??!! Shraddha is even worse than her! 😅😂😂😂
Ok forget Shraddha, what about Parineeti? She is definitely better than Alia, she just doesn’t get the right projects or doesn’t choose the right projects. I’m not sure which 1. Her talent is being wasted in movies like Kesari etc
@@Sonakshi111 Fine Parineeti is better.. 😊✋
U spoke my words!
Alia is given all the best films any actress can pull. She is same in all the movies such a below average actress. Kangna would have pulled off the role excellently
ANMOL JAISWAL yassss
Oh please don't promote that attention seeking megalomaniac Kangana. She is toxic and no this is not a role for her. These are roles made for more elegant actors like Madhuri, Aishwarya, Priyanka or Deepika
@@Stephensofceea I am not promoting kangna but saying that she could pull any role given to her with utmost perfection as she is the best actress of the current lot
ANMOL JAISWAL you read my mind bro I always tell
People she is just average look wise and acting which any actress can do hence proved she fails miserably when tried to be deepika or aishwarya as she lacks grace
As Kangana says see my talent and KJo's movie lol
Bollywood doesn't have that global standards of filmmaking... That's why Hollywood is superior...😔
But south India does
That's why..I said bollywood...a small part of Indian cinema...jiska koi global standards nahi hai...
Used to think Hollywood has it's fantasy and entertainment films. But even those kinds of film better than bollywood junk movies like this one.
Hi Sucharita, I'm one your subscriber and I admire your movie reviews.
Can you please reply why you didn't reviewed Tashkent files?
Karan johar kalank was "wanna be " of SLB Master piece.
By the way for your kind information there were 2 singers in ghar more pardesiya song shreya and vaishali 😐
Correct
Vaishali only sang the sargam part.... rest was all Shreya
@@rahularora1930 ohh really 🤔
@@Prasadchavan24 yes ...you can even check that on internet
Who the fuck even cares koi bhi gaye vahi chutiyapa songs h bollywood ke
Ghar more pardesiya is sung by Shreya Ghoshal along with Vaishali Mhade...
So i believe there are 2 vocals..
Thank God I never liked Alia...just mediocre product of nepotism.. finally this movie shows a reality check to her fans!
Same here😂😂 but at least she is better than her generation
I knew this will be a disappointment the moment I saw the trailer for the first time 😑😑😑
finally the comment i was looking for , same with me .
Great review, Sucharita. Candid as always and I so agree with some points that u made. Like using Shreya's voice for both characters followed by the illogical dialogue. And having item numbers just for the heck of it even though they don't fit and Varun dancing and emoting the same whether it is a film based in 1940's or present era. Wonder why these vastly experienced film makers who have even studied film making can't see such obvious flaws in their work. Can't imagine Sridevi signed up for this!
I knew it is another stupid movie from Karan johar.
The worst thing is that after acting all high and mighty and marrying Dev on her own demand, Roop acts like a bichari as if she was forced into the marriage and does not even try the least to resist Zafar's clear flirting from the beginning. Being realistic, when the husband is so handsome, successful, and nice, I don't know which girl will fall for another man. BTW am I the only one who found Alia_Adi chemistry stronger than the Alia_Varun chemistry? I really want to see them together again.
Avenger endgame will blow this movie out !!!
Rohit Singh watch taskent files. It’s a gem.
@@sudeshnapodder5876 if you say will watch it but before this, can you tell me when you see evolution in Bollywood except some nawazuddin films all are rubbish
So I decide to move towards Hollywood !!
Rohit Singh i agree with you but since an year we got some good movies from bollywood. Im in the US and people discussed about andhadhun even in office. Uri, manikarnika, pink, badhai ho, badla... atleast some people are trying to break the stereotypes. Yeah, i dont support nepotism and hate KJ. Many good movies wont get released in my place but this trash is released in multiple theatres here. Btw did you see haider? Worth watching. Its older though. Im a big fan of rajkumar, nawaz, irfan, ayushmann, vicky, kangana, tabu and radhika.
@@sudeshnapodder5876 fine you talked about haider I watched it but did you try to know what's its base, its base is hamlet man William Shakespeare's novel there is no other idea and imagination in it on their own. Uri and manikarnika are true events I think it's base is clear to you. But andhadhun yeah its imbd top 250 I appreciate that and badhi ho too. But keep consider these films in my some film as exception that I mentioned before ...
@@sudeshnapodder5876 sorry I fail to mention that I am also a big fan of nawaz and Irrfan too and Vicky is little nawaz for me and ayushman is on his way to nawaz like actor ..😆😆😆
Sucharita, I look up to you for any film reviews and as always you are doing an awesome job, irrespective of the film's fate.... Keep Rocking... Keep Reviewing... Keep Entertaining.... Cheers
Also was the art director fired from SLB pictures...and the slo mo was painful...aaaaaannnndddd why was everyone talking like they are some philosophy professor....
Only Madhuri did justice n she was damm good in the film. But again length of the film made it sink terribly. Wherever Madhuri came specially the scene in which she stops Varun n the scene when she says she won't leave the place as she has hindu girls with her. Was just fab.
Why do you comment on things that you don't know? Kathak? That's not even beginner's Kathak let alone be flawless. Don't be that naive to comment things like that.
I am enjoying your reviews so much off lately. Earlier I would see it for fun and maybe sometimes forget it. These days it holds a lot of value in my movie-going choices. More power to you Sucharita :)
Alia again proofs that she is mediocre actress in comparison to kangana.
Vishal Bose she is in love, she forgot acting. Lol. Turned blind.
But her behaviour is better.
Her acting is as mediocre as your english /grammar!
Alia and kunal khemu were really good performance wise! U need to change ur standards of what u consider as acting
Tu sikhayega acting chl bhaag 😂 well u uneducated brat my English is far better than yours.
Sucharita, you literally spoke my mind about Aditya LOL. MY BOY IS FIIINNNEEEE 🔥🔥🔥
Honestly I saw anupama Chopra review recommendation but I was still waiting for your review
You know you're a GENIUS +Sucharita 🙏🏼
She was little a bit short on bashing the movie as i thought and as the movie deserved. Such a bad movie it is.
Actually the song घर मोरे परदेसीया sung by two singers
Shreya-90% 10% vaishali made
U know vaishali made? She is the 1 who can sing so wisely but u cannot recognise her voice in that particular song .same like' pinga' song.
Btw alia's सरगम part sung by vaishali made.
I agree with everything you said....the movie was nostalgic to me....not in a good way though...the bull fight sequence reminded me of Alif Laila... remember from bachpan!!!
It was too cartoonish to watch😒😒
They hired another singer ma'am... Vaishali Mhade... Who does the sargam but it seems that nobody noticed her. She is the same girl who gave her voice for Pinga(Bajirao Mastani)along with Shreya Ghoshal, maybe everybody missed her there too. Please give her some credit. She is a talented singer too with amazing skill.
Watching anupama's review of kalank & suddenly got notification of yo review. Clicked on it with lightning speed
2:43 - Ghar More Pardesiya has been sung by Shreya Ghoshal and Vaishali Mdahe - Ghoshal sang Madhuri Ma'am's part and Mdahe sang Alia's part. FYI these two singers have earlier collaborated for Pinga. Get your facts right!
Ur reviews r becoming a bit more serious and technical and less of the comedy show that we have come to adore. Koi baat nehi. Change is good. I'm with u.
Ghar more pardesiya is sung by 2 different singers. Your review is on point Sucharita. You are awesome!!
Bakwasss movie haiii....Mt dekho baki marzi ...
I think the song Ghar Mere Pardesiya is sung by Shreya Ghoshal AND Vaishali Mhade, the same two singers who sang for Deepika and Priyanka in Pinga (Bajirao Mastani). They have similar voice textures which is why it sounds like the same singer. Not that I am not in agreement with your review of the film, but just wanted to point out that 2 singers are credited for the vocals on that song.
where's review of "The Tashkent Files" in Film companion ?
Good you mentioned titanic even if while pointing out the need to have a narration in the movie because while watching the film I did feel the director was on a trip of making his own version of the 'titanisque' type of love. Why do you think the partition track even exists, it resonates the parting of Jack and Rose. Also, notice the romantic theme playing in the background every time varun and aalia appear on screen. It sounds like a twisted version of the song 'my heart will go on' on the flute. All said and done this film proves that very few film makers make movies to transcend the audiences into a fantasy world. Most are just venting out their inspirations.