Why Pakistan’s Auto Industry & Electric Cars Are Falling Behind | Pakistan vs India |

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 117

  • @rajatrao
    @rajatrao День тому +68

    Home grown Mahindra and TATA are making good cars in India 🇮🇳

    • @uk4490
      @uk4490 День тому +4

      K

    • @premnegi8596
      @premnegi8596 День тому +2

      Yes agreed

    • @protagonist9716
      @protagonist9716 21 годину тому +1

      I would not buy a Tata because they are compromising on Safety. British Mechanical engineer Hazard Denali who worked for Tata Group was fired by Tata Group recently for raising concerns on improperly designed components on the Vehicle chassis by the Tata Group engineering team. US authorities are currently investigating as Tata also designed chassis for Vinfast sold in USA. " In a crash scenario these cars will be completly unsafe" he quoted.

    • @AKumar-co7oe
      @AKumar-co7oe 20 годин тому

      So safety tests are all useless, white guy is correct​@@protagonist9716

    • @Fgghhnh2345
      @Fgghhnh2345 20 годин тому

      ​@@protagonist9716but hey tata car was designed by Mahindra 😂

  • @76prayag
    @76prayag Годину тому +2

    Greetings from India 🇮🇳. FYI. As wrongfully pointed out by Mr Munj. Petrol ⛽️ isn't the reason why cars are very cheap. There's no logic in this at all. I mean it's no rocket science. He had also mentioned the same on Pakwheels sometime ago. Petrol ⛽️ in my state cost ₹ 103 for the last 6 years. Petrol ⛽️ prices did go up by 53p this year. One must understand that ₹ 103.53p. Isn't much for us Indians. Do I wish it would be cheaper? Of course! I do. And I fall under the middle-class category and this doesn't hurt my wallet. The reason why cars are very cheap in India 🇮🇳 is that all the cars, bikes, lorries Trucks to tractors 🚜 are manufactured completely in India 🇮🇳 both Indigenous (local) and international automobile companies. Every component (tyres, battery 🔋 and all) is manufactured in India 🇮🇳 by Indian vendors and is also exported as well. Both local and international automobile companies have a full presence in India and their respective manufacturing plants in India 🇮🇳. Both local and international auto brands manufacture both for domestic and international markets. In fact, you will find many MADE IN INDIA 🇮🇳 cars in every country on this planet. Either Indian or international auto brands. And unlike Pakistan 🇵🇰 (where cars are welded together and painted) we manufacture (body panel stamping, dashboard and the major and critical parts and all the bolts 🔩 and nuts too). All auto brands must have proper showrooms, services and spares and honour warranty claims and warranty on the services or warranty of parts and work carried out on the car. Indian auto companies like Tata Motors India Ltd, Mahindra Motors and Force Motors, Hero Motorcorp, Bajaj Motors, TVS Motors and many others are present all over the globe. Mahindra is thrashing the global competition in Australia 🇦🇺 and South Africa 🇿🇦 (one can UA-cam this fact). And all the international automobile companies are present in India 🇮🇳 with their latest global models. We have global launches in India 🇮🇳. Our Auto Expo is a global event and it lasts for 20 days. It's on par with the Geneva Motor Show, Tokyo Motor Show, Paris Motor Show, Munich Motor Show, Detroit Motor Show and Sydney Motor Show. Mr Munj was also wrong about Chinese auto brands not being present in India. MG Motors India Ltd has been in India for 7 years now. MG has two manufacturing plants in India. BYD too has full presence in India with all their global models available like MG. The real reason for Chinese companies are not allowed in India is simple. You have to have 70% localisation from the start no importing of components and safety of data issues. I'm posting some links to some global auto portals and Indian car portals for fair comparison. I humbly request all car lovers to subscribe to any of these channels to see the latest cars and bikes launches India. ua-cam.com/video/7wTSruA3KYw/v-deo.htmlsi=tdQsxWqxS73fUu1m . ua-cam.com/video/1fCGvkGZnZY/v-deo.htmlsi=-O-58MlHGxhL4GT9 . ua-cam.com/video/aELOLRdGhbw/v-deo.htmlsi=4das3lOTnEaCcUGA . ua-cam.com/video/3XsVJP7j-OU/v-deo.htmlsi=gNI8TGjx1rpRhveX . ua-cam.com/video/4k3XXCoEI_g/v-deo.htmlsi=501HQpaJcrtuY59O . ua-cam.com/video/E6sNBLP4FSQ/v-deo.htmlsi=zWEMfZiKyIh8Fu-3 . ua-cam.com/video/0mITJ8zBVR0/v-deo.htmlsi=eqVaCOrfhJlpILOk . ua-cam.com/video/K5E5Xq2Y9pU/v-deo.htmlsi=UcOINszaId0nhcoW . ua-cam.com/video/a2xc_Wrbg_k/v-deo.htmlsi=D7Z_SD8YasOUdCrY . ua-cam.com/video/a2xc_Wrbg_k/v-deo.htmlsi=D7Z_SD8YasOUdCrY . ua-cam.com/video/1uOJcgolVaM/v-deo.htmlsi=EYvny2Sl4Q2QBvBw . ua-cam.com/video/1uOJcgolVaM/v-deo.htmlsi=EYvny2Sl4Q2QBvBw . ua-cam.com/video/K5E5Xq2Y9pU/v-deo.htmlsi=UcOINszaId0nhcoW . ua-cam.com/video/LV91chihPmI/v-deo.htmlsi=9poitihen85764sJ . Regards and best wishes always. Cheers.

  • @zaf7794
    @zaf7794 23 години тому +12

    I don't know from where Suneel is talking about their is no brain drain and skill and educated people have left Pakistan. Suneel sahb is delusional when it comes to country economics and what is happening. Mang tang k mulk chal rha hai and he is saying all is fine

    • @muhammadsufyan974
      @muhammadsufyan974 17 годин тому

      @@zaf7794 i don't want to sound rude but it seems like Suneel bhai is disconnected from the reality as i recently didn't come across people whether from Elite class or middle class who deny this brain drain phenomena. I even heard some businessmen who are very much sympathetic to PMLN party showing concerns about the brain drain

    • @farazmasood4374
      @farazmasood4374 17 годин тому

      Munj is a hard-core patwari. What would you expect. 😂

  • @RakaDev-uu9rk
    @RakaDev-uu9rk 15 годин тому +10

    Yaar koi batao inko
    Soch... soch.... soch alag hai... dono mulko mein
    Baaki toh hai hi... Rahan sahan khaan peen,
    Soch....alag hai....insaano ki tarah sochte hai hum Indians,
    Jalan nahi rehta...kon aagey kon peechey....!!
    Hum apne kaam aapney progress ko hi focus karte hai....!!!!

  • @user-f9u
    @user-f9u 20 годин тому +14

    Pakistan’s Auto Industry & Electric Cars ? ufffffff....... la la... khana ko nahi daana...but nuclear bomb hai naa !!

  • @bestofsatish
    @bestofsatish День тому +7

    This guy does not understand macroeconomics. He is trying to extrapolate microeconomics to macroeconomics which does not work. Issue are present at how economy is managed. Issue with pakistan is low savings rate. In pakistan's case, it has to come from reduced imports. But reduced imports means pakistan will disintegrate because pakistan has no production facilities. it is kind of chicken-egg issue. Pakistan fulfills investment requirement through imports. So to increase savings pakistan has to reduce imports meaning falling investment. No investment means falling production leading to low savings rate and again the cycle starts again. Only countries which has overcome such issue is china, where they increased savings rate by Inflation, channelling inflation to investment making household share less and less. Dont think pakistan can endure such pain

    • @Photon-1927
      @Photon-1927 23 години тому

      Can you record a vlog with ur point of view. It will be good anti thesis.

    • @bestofsatish
      @bestofsatish 23 години тому +1

      @@Photon-1927 I am not elon musk to start a thread so that other follow. These are centuries old theory which i am repasting. I am not saying anything new. There are great insights you can get from Michael Pettis.

    • @Photon-1927
      @Photon-1927 22 години тому

      @ will check the economist you mentioned. Hope you are running a successful Busniess also. Please share which business you are running and annual turnover as compared pak wheels.

    • @Photon-1927
      @Photon-1927 22 години тому

      @@bestofsatish will check the economist you mentioned. Hope you are running a successful Busniess also. Please share which business you are running and annual turnover as compared pak wheels.

    • @netherdrake436
      @netherdrake436 4 години тому

      The media and government also trying to portray that there is stability, where is stability? Our GDP growth rate is 2-3% due to slashing of imports. With how fast our population grows, it should be 6-7% atleast if we want to develop. Such low GDP growth rate with high population growth rate means that theres going to be significant increase in jobless people ever year. The GDP per capita would decrease too. The country has a dead economy. We need investments but only a buffoon would invest in us.

  • @muhammadsufyan974
    @muhammadsufyan974 19 годин тому +4

    9:20 sorry to say but that's a very stupid thing to say, that too by an Expert, "gaarian mehengi horahi hain likin phir bhi Rush barh raha hai sarkon per", like comeon, Pakistan has one of the lowest "cars per 1000 people" ratio in the world, and the cars just don't disappear after 1 2 year, it survives on roads for good 25 to 30 years, main benchmark is the sales of NEW CARS which are Extremely Low in Pakistan given the size of Population we have. And what you expect people to do when Petrol gets expensive? Sit at home? Not go for work? Unfortunately not everyone is Elite enough to afford that luxury

  • @premnegi8596
    @premnegi8596 День тому +8

    Mr. Manj - Is Pakistan primary steel producer ? Or they produce auto grade steel?

    • @bestofsatish
      @bestofsatish День тому +3

      They melt scrap and produce rebar. They dont have even blast furnace

  • @premnegi8596
    @premnegi8596 День тому +8

    India has facilities for crash testing

    • @AshishSharma-sd8fn
      @AshishSharma-sd8fn Годину тому

      Crash testing is available everywhere in Pakistan. Road accidents are happening

  • @bumbhir
    @bumbhir 22 години тому +5

    BYD has already setup factory in Thailand it's biggest right hand drive market.. So don't think it would set up in Pakistan for right hand drive worlds..

    • @bhupeshkumar2537
      @bhupeshkumar2537 4 години тому

      Only mentally unstable country will open any manufacturing unit in Pakistan

  • @vaibhavsrivastava2507
    @vaibhavsrivastava2507 День тому +5

    Manufacturing means all the parts used made in that same country.
    May b not by same manufacturer but all the parts r manufactured for a particular model with all the agreements by the primary manufacturer.

  • @nehabalapure5365
    @nehabalapure5365 День тому +14

    Fake expert like fake PIA Pilots, in India, interstate public bus transport has already started both by Government and private transport companies.

  • @gulbadinkhan8339
    @gulbadinkhan8339 21 годину тому +2

    Raftar you are Boss of Media.
    Thanks for bringing the great content

  • @ahmadbilalsh
    @ahmadbilalsh 20 годин тому +1

    Very mature and good discussion. Suneel Munj Rocked. Bravo

  • @dr.cooper5909
    @dr.cooper5909 19 годин тому +8

    When someone talks about "manufacturing vs assembling", they mean that most car components (especially key components like engine or transmission) are manufactured locally within the country, including the raw materials like steel that are used to manufacture those components. Obviously, then the components are brought to the assembly line and assembled in a plant. Suneel doesn't seem to understand this nuance.
    Secondly, on the point of comparing Alto prices in India vs Pakistan (btw Indian Alto is 1000cc compared to Pakistan's 660cc and also Indian Alto is a much bigger car), it is not simply unit economics that causes such massive difference in selling price in the two countries. That may be a small part of the cost difference, but the answer again lies in the local manufacturing aspect.
    Let's take the example of engine. In India, the Alto's engine is manufactured locally from the ground up using mostly local raw materials, as is the case for most cars. In Pakistan, I doubt that is the case. Even for legacy cars that have been around in Pakistan market for a long time, I believe core car components like engines are still imported, forget about sourcing raw materials locally and producing the engine in Pakistan. That can be inferred from the fact that even a 70cc bike engine isn't manufactured locally in Pakistan.
    Edit: For any Pakistani who believes it's because of taxes that cars in Pakistan are costlier compared to India, I would like them to check for themselves the taxes on automobiles in India. GST on cars in India is higher than Pakistan for every segment of cars, plus Indians need to pay advance road tax equivalent to 5-10% of the price of the car, and then purchasing car insurance is also mandatory by law.

    • @4th_Disciple
      @4th_Disciple Годину тому

      Thats not what manufacturing vs assembling means. Manufacturing means building product for one own company.
      Assembley means building products for another company.
      Ravi motors is an assemble because they build cars for Toyota.
      If Ravi designed and started to build their own caar e.g Ravimobile 1. Ravi motors would now be considered a manufacturer as opposed to a mere assembler.

    • @dr.cooper5909
      @dr.cooper5909 Годину тому +1

      @4th_Disciple you got it wrong I'm afraid. Even the original company can have an assembling plant in a country to import CKD kits and assemble the car. Whether the original company does it themselves or their local partner, that's not the point here.
      Manufacturing would mean that the original company themselves or their local partner would have manufacturing plants/local partners who would manufacture the components locally in the country of sale, and then assemble them finally and sell it. For example in India, many of BMW's engines are manufactured locally in India by an Indian company Force Motors, who then supplies them to BMW's assembly line. The point is that the manufacturing is happening within the country of sale, regardless of who is responsible for assembling the car finally.

  • @manishkotnala9301
    @manishkotnala9301 День тому +8

    Can somebody ask him about his view over Mumbai terror attack ?

    • @nikhildeshmukh6221
      @nikhildeshmukh6221 21 годину тому

      Bhakt ho kya

    • @hamzaalikhan9872
      @hamzaalikhan9872 20 годин тому

      pagal ho kia tm???? ajeeb bewaqoof aadmi

    • @Trilok_world
      @Trilok_world 17 годин тому

      ​@@nikhildeshmukh6221 tujhe kya dikkat hai. 😒

    • @Indusworldz
      @Indusworldz 12 годин тому

      ​​@@nikhildeshmukh6221bsdk teri gand kyu fat thi he agar koi ek attack 🔫👊ke barre me bat kare 100 percent Tu uni halala ki pedais hoga ?.?

    • @DspSaurabhSinha
      @DspSaurabhSinha 8 годин тому

      ​@@nikhildeshmukh6221 Tum darbari ho kya

  • @nitinsaklecha3262
    @nitinsaklecha3262 20 годин тому +3

    Light to he nahi PAKISTAN me to EV ka kya karegi

  • @premnegi8596
    @premnegi8596 День тому +2

    @ Manj - Pakistan is very big market for auto industry but due to shrinking purchasing power of individuals it is small market.

    • @bestofsatish
      @bestofsatish День тому +2

      Big Market depends on purchasing power. by that definition Nigeria is a bigger market. Population size does not mean anything to define what market is. Economics 101

  • @GPSIASP-t5l
    @GPSIASP-t5l 2 години тому

    Please answer why they make shortages in any field with out any problem?

  • @muhammadsufyan974
    @muhammadsufyan974 18 годин тому +1

    13:35 it's not a bad management issue with Suzuki, but it's an Accounting thing to transfer most of the Profit out of Pakistan to their Parent Company in Japan through purchase of Expensive Raw materials. Why? Probably because the corporate tax rates are extremely high in Pakistan, 39% income tax plus 15% dividend tax. Situation is different with honda and Toyota as they both have Local partners(Atlas and Indus) unlike Suzuki where japanese company is the only major owner

  • @miguelsramon4702
    @miguelsramon4702 23 години тому +4

    the caption is wrong, Pakistan is not falling behind, Pakistan never had a decent industry to begin with, race mein the hi nahi jo peeche reh jaoge

  • @raamcaash
    @raamcaash 23 години тому +1

    Suneel seems to be the Dilip Chabbria ( DC) of Pak … good man

  • @ssmujoo
    @ssmujoo 15 годин тому +1

    Wrong statement - BYD is Tesla killer. Very pure quality. Power / Battery management is poor is a cause of frequent fires. Moreover, now allowed in two major markets USA and India.

  • @naeemsubhan5846
    @naeemsubhan5846 День тому +2

    پاکستان میں جب تک کمیشن کا رواج عام ہے کوئی بھی کاروبار نہیں چل سکتا
    سوزوکی نے عوام کو کیا دیا چار ویل انجن باڈی
    نہ ریڈیو نہ ائر بیگ نہ اینٹینا نہ آلائ رم جاپان میں سوزوکی ڈبہ انسانی سیفٹی کو دیکھتے ہوئے فیل ہو گئ تھی
    سوزوکی ڈبہ کے ایکسڈنٹ میں اگر سامنے سے حادثہ ہو موت یقینی ہے

  • @prashantjaiswal6451
    @prashantjaiswal6451 21 годину тому +3

    Sunil on huj???

    • @fadyNUFC
      @fadyNUFC 18 годин тому +1

      Hes Muslim only his name is suneel

    • @DevendraSingh-dp9qu
      @DevendraSingh-dp9qu 4 години тому +1

      Pure podcast Mai , mai soch raha tha ki ye hindu ho ker hajj ker raha hai . Auto industry ki baat sunna hi bhul gaya .

  • @farhanqureshi1565
    @farhanqureshi1565 14 годин тому

    Bhae toh phr import karwana hi theek hai if car produce locally is expensive... Quality of imported car is much better than local car....

  • @premnegi8596
    @premnegi8596 День тому +1

    Stock market is not indicator of development

  • @AR-Distributors
    @AR-Distributors День тому +1

    Faisal aik hi shirt phen kar podcast karnay ka mashwara farhan bhai ka hai tou ideal hai kyn k atleast is tarha hi discussion main rahengain ... lol .. you are such a nice podcaster , I love it !

  • @You00009
    @You00009 6 годин тому +5

    Aaj tak 70cc kaa engine nahi bana sake....car kya ghanta banayenge😂😂😂

    • @hamzaalikhan-us6hl
      @hamzaalikhan-us6hl 2 години тому

      ab banate hain bhai chinese bikes jo ha super power unique honda prince inka engine pakistan maen banta ha

  • @TheSanjaykdas
    @TheSanjaykdas 23 години тому

    God Bless Sunil ji with long long and happy life...

  • @MuhammadNadeem-gn4in
    @MuhammadNadeem-gn4in 21 годину тому

    Informative Discussion hay.

  • @tyrant_hermit
    @tyrant_hermit 22 години тому +1

    Toys for boys 😂 is so suss

  • @premnegi8596
    @premnegi8596 День тому +2

    @Harshal - it not easy to Pakistan

  • @ajav110
    @ajav110 23 години тому

    Excellent answer to the second last question Suneel Bhai 😊

  • @bakuldada7838
    @bakuldada7838 21 годину тому

    can u do a video on pharma , hospitals state in pakistan

  • @ss1646
    @ss1646 8 годин тому

    @Raftarnow I am surprised by this expert"s comments. Key reason of high prices of cars in Pakistan is you don't produce locally. Its.not really a case of numbers alone. When you assemble and import, of course the prices are going to be higher. Had that been the case, everyone would have imported and assembled. You need to localise and produce. There is hardly any hard goods industry in your country. This expert is completely out of touch on the logic of business and economics

  • @harshalmehta8281
    @harshalmehta8281 День тому +1

    Would EV disruption be beneficial for Pakistan

    • @bestofsatish
      @bestofsatish День тому +1

      Eventhough EV prices have come down below ICE, Pakistan can never bring EV into its country because of dollar outflow. Eventhough EV will be beneficial, Pakistan has structural issues not allowing them to have one. This guy says Pakistan does not have Charging facilities, Power shortage. These are not problems of EV. These are countries economic woes. THing is that Pakistan needs dollars to produce electricity which will be very acute in summer.

  • @premnegi8596
    @premnegi8596 День тому +1

    crashes testing is the way to of airbags testing

  • @zaf7794
    @zaf7794 День тому +1

    Secondly, their is no such thing as a killer. It is just speculations. All chinese products are low price replicas of what Toyota and western automakers alreayd produce.

  • @mashhad2722
    @mashhad2722 22 години тому

    Byd should introduce their hatchback

  • @AnwarRana-q4g
    @AnwarRana-q4g 2 години тому

    Mulk una di waja no chal rya

  • @shakeelkoraie111
    @shakeelkoraie111 18 годин тому

    Suneel sarfraz genius munj❤

  • @SleepyMonsterTruck-pk8yx
    @SleepyMonsterTruck-pk8yx 19 годин тому

    Our cost of production is high bro

  • @ranababarali7070
    @ranababarali7070 День тому +2

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @nehasharma-yy3st
    @nehasharma-yy3st 7 годин тому +1

    Kisi maulvi mufti se.. fatwa le...car manifacturing halal hai ya haram

    • @You00009
      @You00009 6 годин тому

      😂😂😂 right question

  • @YaSallam365
    @YaSallam365 День тому

    Suneel said no new car he has . . .

  • @sasnad3
    @sasnad3 День тому +1

    Manj saab ko b le aya hai Faisal bhai. Great

  • @RakaDev-uu9rk
    @RakaDev-uu9rk 15 годин тому

    Yeh koi naya keeda hai kya....medicine feild mein.....jo inn padosi mulk me paya jataa hai (sirf),
    Naya keeda.....CWI
    (Compare with india)
    Baaz nahi ayenge..... don't care kon hai kya hai....!!! Yeh keeda hota hi hai inke andar.

  • @S00rabh
    @S00rabh 5 годин тому

    I have seen few video of this Suneel guy and is he either delusional or outright lying. And that's the same thing in all the videos.

  • @murtazarasheed7189
    @murtazarasheed7189 22 години тому

    Why did you call this stupid

  • @constant.035
    @constant.035 17 годин тому

    Bhi kindly jo banda Pakistan mai kam krrha hai ossy mat poucha kry Pakistan ka business Q low hai , ossy pouchy jo Pakistan sy business khatam krky bahir chala gae hai , eo apko behtar resions bata dengy 😂

  • @MuhammadAhmed-vq9tv
    @MuhammadAhmed-vq9tv День тому +3

    Suneel Munj AKA Cars Encyclopedia ❤🔥

  • @ashishsehgal296
    @ashishsehgal296 19 годин тому

    Aap ke faujiyon ke paas kitni gaadiyaan hai

  • @MohinKMoh_Kamran
    @MohinKMoh_Kamran 22 години тому

    Please don’t get a Joker like this guy, he has no clue. Understand MACROECONOMICS first, and then come to an interview.

  • @premnegi8596
    @premnegi8596 День тому +1

    @Faisal - auto market of Pakistan will be declining and will decline continue

  • @bakuldada7838
    @bakuldada7838 21 годину тому

    cheen pakistan ki madad karega

  • @Rath944
    @Rath944 5 годин тому

    😂😂

  • @marijali9541
    @marijali9541 20 годин тому

    Bhai Basheer Qureshi Documentary please sindhi warrior

  • @uk4490
    @uk4490 День тому

    Enjoyed the vlog ♥️

  • @aminraja5383
    @aminraja5383 21 годину тому

    Make him prime minister

  • @Indusworldz
    @Indusworldz 12 годин тому

    Pakistan honda cd 125 2024 model vs indian honda sp 125 2025 model deklo pata chal jayega ki kon kya kar raha hai 😶‍🌫..

  • @nehabalapure5365
    @nehabalapure5365 День тому +1

    Electric Buses

    • @bestofsatish
      @bestofsatish День тому +1

      They dont have electricity. So no electric bulbs or fan either

    • @Amuse-tj4tp
      @Amuse-tj4tp 18 годин тому

      @@bestofsatish isme do teen laughing emoji ki kami hai.

  • @marijali9541
    @marijali9541 20 годин тому

    Bhai Basheer Qureshi Documentary please sindhi warrior

  • @marijali9541
    @marijali9541 20 годин тому

    Bhai Basheer Qureshi Documentary please sindhi warrior