Are you dependent on UA-cam and social media to gain Islamic knowledge? Download the Thaqlain App today by visiting app.thaqlain.org Also, if you found this content beneficial, please take a moment to donate at thaqlain.org/support.
I agree to all the points but the circle that only if Allah wills you change, you can change yourself. Isn’t that somehow coreect and defines the concept of Taufeeq, which is mentioned in numerous duas/munajaat of Sahiffa e Sajjadiya 😀. Looking forward for a reply. Thanks JazakAllah Great work!!!
@@Thaqlain No i mean if on the Lahw al Mahfudh the final things are written, then even if bad'aa takes place there will be no change on the Lahw al Mahfudh, right? It is not that someone lifespan was written 80 years on the Lahw initially, then AFTER that person did goods deed God erased that and rewrote a longer lifespan, right? That's why i was asking does anything in the writing on Lahw change? If the answer is NO, then what is changing we cannot know right?
So if i correctly understand, lets say God has decreed someones life to be 80 years, now this can change to be more if that person does good deeds? But as God already foreknew is, than what is actually changing?
Are you dependent on UA-cam and social media to gain Islamic knowledge? Download the Thaqlain App today by visiting app.thaqlain.org
Also, if you found this content beneficial, please take a moment to donate at thaqlain.org/support.
mashallah🎉🎉❤
I agree to all the points but the circle that only if Allah wills you change, you can change yourself. Isn’t that somehow coreect and defines the concept of Taufeeq, which is mentioned in numerous duas/munajaat of Sahiffa e Sajjadiya 😀. Looking forward for a reply. Thanks JazakAllah Great work!!!
The concept of Tawfiq is covered to some extent here: thaqlain.org/guide/how-to-be-a-person-with-tawfiq/
Are the asharis/hanbalis according to the Shia in fact hidden jabariyyah?
So as per Badaa' situation, what is written in the Lahw al Mahfudh?
Things that won't change no matter what :)
@@Thaqlain than what is changing :))
Things that are destined by Allah to be based on the actions of his creations.
@@Thaqlain No i mean if on the Lahw al Mahfudh the final things are written, then even if bad'aa takes place there will be no change on the Lahw al Mahfudh, right?
It is not that someone lifespan was written 80 years on the Lahw initially, then AFTER that person did goods deed God erased that and rewrote a longer lifespan, right?
That's why i was asking does anything in the writing on Lahw change? If the answer is NO, then what is changing we cannot know right?
Does this mean that according to Shia creed the human has a effective will that is created by himself?
Indeed.
So if i correctly understand, lets say God has decreed someones life to be 80 years, now this can change to be more if that person does good deeds?
But as God already foreknew is, than what is actually changing?
The difference is in Allah knowing and Allah making it a decree. There are things that are not fixed by Allah. Age is one of such matters.