Galaxy A54 VS Galaxy S23 Video Stabilization Test

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 бер 2023
  • The Samsung Galaxy A54 can record in 4K30 but it doesn't get electronic video stabilization at that resolution, so it has to relay completely on OIS. The Galaxy S23 is way better.
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 432

  • @storyanaksekolah2
    @storyanaksekolah2 Рік тому +935

    comparing $400 vs $1000 phone is criminal 😂

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому +125

      comparing a $500 phone to a $850 phone more like it :D

    • @storyanaksekolah2
      @storyanaksekolah2 Рік тому +43

      @@RedskullPro in indonesia a54 5g starting at $420-450. the s23 starting at $910-1000

    • @storyanaksekolah2
      @storyanaksekolah2 Рік тому +6

      @@nicolasbrizuela4938 then did it to prove

    • @AA-gh5zv
      @AA-gh5zv Рік тому +8

      ​@@RedskullPro now a54 has stabiliizion on 4k 30 fps

    • @ZoroIsLostAgain
      @ZoroIsLostAgain 11 місяців тому +1

      I saw the s23 on amazon for 570 bucks

  • @JB-nr5fo
    @JB-nr5fo Рік тому +289

    Overall, A54 is still the best midrange phone. Great camera, software updates, dual stereo speakers, overall experience, etc. Vivo V27 Pro would've been a great phone with stereo speakers and good haptics. Samsung should've continued A74, it would've been the perfect upper midrange phone.

    • @siddestroyer
      @siddestroyer Рік тому +4

      No it's not. Pixel 6a is MILES BETTER

    • @JB-nr5fo
      @JB-nr5fo Рік тому +19

      @@siddestroyer Unfortunately it's not available in all regions. So yeah, A54 is the best overall.

    • @youssefaouaj9523
      @youssefaouaj9523 Рік тому +2

      ​​​@@siddestroyer not in tern of software

    • @youssefaouaj9523
      @youssefaouaj9523 Рік тому

      Better than s20fe?

    • @siddestroyer
      @siddestroyer Рік тому

      @@youssefaouaj9523 lol. Honestly you can't mean that. Difference between 6a and A54

  • @ninoabz
    @ninoabz Рік тому +20

    A54 already has new fitur of OIS update, a week ago. and the stabilizer working smoother now..

    • @ridzuand.monkey272
      @ridzuand.monkey272 Рік тому +2

      Super steady mode is awesome.. Even better than mostly Chinese brand flagship

  • @jashanaarleenvlogs7909
    @jashanaarleenvlogs7909 Рік тому +33

    I was confused to which one I should buy it
    So I got it S23 today

  • @trueman7249
    @trueman7249 Рік тому +216

    But camera quality and colour reproduction is better in A54

    • @XXXMUXICISLIFEXXX
      @XXXMUXICISLIFEXXX Рік тому +28

      That's only if you like the over saturation which not everyone does. Yes it might give the sky more color but more than likely it overselled. The s23 is most likely more accurate to the real colors.

    • @jhasaketansahoo5021
      @jhasaketansahoo5021 Рік тому +2

      😂😂

    • @MsMRkv
      @MsMRkv Рік тому +5

      ​@@XXXMUXICISLIFEXXX none of them are accurate. If you want accurate a true to life colours, go for a dslr, not a phone.

    • @valiantwarrior1988
      @valiantwarrior1988 Рік тому

      ​@@MsMRkv dslr with lense, they're often under saturated without it. Moreover mobiles phones will eventually catch up with dslr cameras :)

    • @MrModikoe
      @MrModikoe Рік тому

      ​@@MsMRkv lol dslr...do they still exist?

  • @discosweet9665
    @discosweet9665 9 місяців тому +19

    The colors in A54 are popping..so colorful..🎉

  • @Hamish-yi8ie
    @Hamish-yi8ie 10 місяців тому +22

    We are not cameraman for running athletes so a54 is the answer

  • @normie1549
    @normie1549 9 місяців тому +6

    EIS + OIS works on 1080P only
    but, only OIS works on 4K

  • @anivalbp8909
    @anivalbp8909 Рік тому +52

    I got the s23 and it's amazing

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому +7

      Nice! Enjoy your new phone

    • @mSuraj1999
      @mSuraj1999 11 місяців тому +1

      ​@@RedskullProHow's the battery? planning to buy

  • @02Channels
    @02Channels Рік тому +27

    🤔 I heard that there is a recent update for the Samsung A54 stabilizer camera, so it doesn't shake anymore 👍🏻

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому +16

      Yes, correct, there was an update about 3 weeks ago that added EIS to 4k recordings

    • @LynyrdSkynyrd859
      @LynyrdSkynyrd859 8 місяців тому +4

      Yes it is true i have update on my a 54 and video stability is ok

    • @farahfarrouha5410
      @farahfarrouha5410 8 місяців тому +3

      ​@@LynyrdSkynyrd859 what can I do please to install this new update on my A54 phone??

  • @Potato-po3px
    @Potato-po3px Рік тому +5

    Samsung made them look so similar, but this is where the corners are cut

  • @1AlexS
    @1AlexS Рік тому +262

    Imagine selling a $500 phone that records in 4K but no video stabilization 🤣

    • @Moyaiville_Productions
      @Moyaiville_Productions Рік тому +89

      This is Samsung cutting corners because the A54 is a midrange.. The S23 is supposed to be seen as better..

    • @lol-ivan7500
      @lol-ivan7500 Рік тому +36

      Nah this is
      Eis+ois
      Vs
      Purely just ois

    • @Youtubewat6h3rg
      @Youtubewat6h3rg Рік тому +18

      False, there was stability on galaxy a52 and 53

    • @Unknownuserhtps
      @Unknownuserhtps Рік тому +6

      Exactly, even the 200$ iPhone se from 2020 has really good stability close to the s23😂 why is Samsung cutting so many corners??
      Just make it out of plastic and invest the saved money into a better chipset first off
      Then a better camera

    • @Shan_Shah
      @Shan_Shah Рік тому +7

      ​@Galaxy rock Studio the a54 is glasstic back not glass back which is a fancy plastic it's false advertisement. The a54 should have the SD 870 which is miles ahead of any 7 gen 1 or 2 chipset while the exynos 1380 gets beaten by 4 year old flagship processors, put the s22/s22+ camera sensors, slim down the bezels and put an ltps display which goes down to 30hz or 48hz while removing the silver camera ring around that selfie camera cutout. Phones that cost $400 or more should have 1-2 year old flagship hardware and they should've added spen support because since the note 10 lite samsung never gave us a cheaper alternative to people who want the spen. They are already not giving us wireless charging, reverse wireless charging Samsung dex, the fastest transfer speeds, ultra sonic 3D finger print scanner and the s23/s23+ display on paper they are same quality but thr a54 uses a cheaper super AMOLEd panel which isn't anywhere near as sharp as s23/s23+ or even compared to s10e from 4 years ago. They are already cutting these corners so why not give us SD 870 with s22/s22+ camera sensors and the software features plus the spen support as a cheap alternative to people who want the spen but can't afford $1199 it's a missed opportunity they can throw in a non active spen meaning no air action and I'm pretty sure this will move so many away from apple since their a series are sold the most and if they integrate it into their top a series people will see that it's more than a simple note taking machine or an art machine and people who make fun of stylus unless in a smartphone will realize that the spen can be used for so many other things and isn't just boring like apple pencil on the iPad.
      And slim down the bezels a bit more like they don't have to make it as slim as s23 but maybe make it as slim as something like an s21 fe

  • @elmanxasiyev4808
    @elmanxasiyev4808 7 місяців тому +1

    Just yesterday I bought S23 FE, very nice and professional

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  7 місяців тому

      Much better phone than a54

  • @ZMRoshan95
    @ZMRoshan95 Рік тому

    Super comparison 👍👍👍

  • @zidanetribale7729
    @zidanetribale7729 Рік тому +5

    No need to compare, the price says it all. Nobody will buy S23 IF the camera result is the same LOL, it's marketing!
    Try to compare the phone with the same price

  • @FieryFlame42631
    @FieryFlame42631 7 днів тому

    after update on samsung A54 Video stabilization Working on 4K 30FPS Nice!

  • @Ahmed-mt1pb
    @Ahmed-mt1pb 8 місяців тому +7

    A54 always the best

  • @Uxz-iu8re
    @Uxz-iu8re Рік тому +6

    Can you test the a54 again ??? , samsung added 4k video stabilisation on it with may update , which is cool feature tbh

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому

      Unfortunately I didn’t keep it 😅 but if they added video stabilization for 4k recordings is awesome

    • @Uxz-iu8re
      @Uxz-iu8re Рік тому +1

      @@RedskullPro I visited the nearest Samsung store, the phone is faster, it never gets hot, and the video stabilization option is available on 4k quality!!!!! , I am grateful for this decision because the price of the phone is high

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому +1

      It should have launched like that to begin with 🤷‍♂️

  • @karimamine1973
    @karimamine1973 Рік тому +4

    Compary flagship Vs normally phone. Of course s23 best

  • @malsh1nov
    @malsh1nov Рік тому +4

    И где у A54 стабилизация? Одно название. Нужно не дышать наверно во время движения, чтобы стабилизировать хоть немного сотрясения от шагов.

  • @maxchopin409
    @maxchopin409 Рік тому +4

    Very bad pricing. In my country it is more expensive than s20fe and not much cheaper than s21fe. Both are much better options.

  • @justicejirgba3929
    @justicejirgba3929 10 місяців тому +2

    A54 is a great mid range phone and with great camera but the stabilization is better on the s 23

  • @tomlinch4622
    @tomlinch4622 Рік тому +5

    Me watching this in 480p 👁👄👁

  • @adarshvibhutihalli1654
    @adarshvibhutihalli1654 4 місяці тому +1

    Overall a54 is budget King in camera..

  • @Spiderman_-lx5od
    @Spiderman_-lx5od Рік тому +1

    I have the a54 but I wish it records videos in 4K at 60fps but only records 60fps in 1080p the rest of of other resolutions are at 30fps

  • @lailawati
    @lailawati Рік тому +1

    of course this two phone in the different Class,.that not fair to compare this

  • @TheUltimateWarrior92
    @TheUltimateWarrior92 Рік тому +5

    Yeah but the A54 has OIS with Full HD

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому +3

      OIS = Optical Image Stabilization. That’s a hardware feature and works at all resolutions. 1080p30 gets EIS (electronic image stabilization).

    • @Melodie_Info3
      @Melodie_Info3 7 місяців тому

      Even if it does have ois its not super steady then s23. As I tested cheap socks

  • @marcm.official
    @marcm.official Рік тому

    well, a52s will never be beaten, that phone was a beast from the a series

  • @RazaSohail-rh8no
    @RazaSohail-rh8no 11 місяців тому +1

    Both are best

  • @gerardotovar5690
    @gerardotovar5690 Рік тому +3

    Thanks Korea.❤

  • @yaseenalshaikh1553
    @yaseenalshaikh1553 10 місяців тому +1

    Actually both are good

  • @bostonlierca4720
    @bostonlierca4720 Рік тому +13

    Color looks better on a54

  • @orangkaya4932
    @orangkaya4932 8 місяців тому +1

    detail for A54
    stability for S23

  • @user-gx1ge8fh5r
    @user-gx1ge8fh5r 6 місяців тому

    There is a price, there is a look, it looks the same at first glance but the lens bullets are different. 😊

  • @imjeff4739
    @imjeff4739 Рік тому +11

    Will there be an update to add EIS?

    • @andrew007s
      @andrew007s Рік тому +1

      Never will be. A53 is the same. No stabilisation.

    • @archie7288
      @archie7288 Рік тому

      Its trash exynos can't handle eis on 4k 😂 what do u expect

    • @Uxz-iu8re
      @Uxz-iu8re Рік тому

      Samsung a5x had no eis 🙁 , only on 1080p you can find it which is bad honestly , the only phone from a5x that came with 4k eis was the a52s

    • @Uxz-iu8re
      @Uxz-iu8re Рік тому

      @Surya Baja1234 can you record a video using it , i want this phone over the s22 because the bigger battery and the 6.4-inch display are for less price, but i was wondering about the 4k video stability , so if you could help me i would be thankful 🙏

  • @jeyaseelansuthan3850
    @jeyaseelansuthan3850 7 місяців тому +1

    I am going to update my mobile after 4 years.. Which one i should buy Samsung a54,s23fe, s23....? Pl give me a conclusion

  • @kingslin6047
    @kingslin6047 Рік тому

    Clear show 🎉

  • @Hamza-tu4fd
    @Hamza-tu4fd Рік тому +1

    the video quality on the a54 is surprisingly better. s23 footage is very oversharpened.

    • @MrModikoe
      @MrModikoe Рік тому

      nah you just hyped by the oversaturated mess..

  • @annfajardo1764
    @annfajardo1764 Рік тому +4

    if video running is not better to a54.... so dont run...just walk😂

  • @gersonreyes8374
    @gersonreyes8374 11 місяців тому +1

    El A54 tiene sus poderes va.

  • @TheAjanaz
    @TheAjanaz Рік тому

    Sound?

  • @beatinformatica
    @beatinformatica 11 місяців тому

    Top é top.😊

  • @Red-ws6qw
    @Red-ws6qw 3 місяці тому +2

    S23 ❤❤

    • @luandriiguez
      @luandriiguez Місяць тому

      Também achei melhor

    •  13 днів тому

      claro linha S é a linha premium

  • @mustafaozdalyan913
    @mustafaozdalyan913 Рік тому +4

    Why is the A54 shaking so much even though it has OIS?

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому +12

      OIS barely compensates your hands’s shakiness when taking a picture. As soon as you start moving it’s game over. It needs EIS and OIS for best results

    • @mustafaozdalyan913
      @mustafaozdalyan913 Рік тому

      @@RedskullPro I understand. Thanks for your comment.

  • @AbdumajidMirzaaxmedov-md9gz
    @AbdumajidMirzaaxmedov-md9gz Рік тому +3

    I think All galaxy A models can't over The S series.

  • @apiztshah8299
    @apiztshah8299 Рік тому +6

    Compare to a53

  • @anakiftiah1028
    @anakiftiah1028 10 місяців тому

    Makin bersyukur punya a34 karena warna kamera nya mirip sama s23 masyaallah

  • @eliasferreira6310
    @eliasferreira6310 8 місяців тому +1

    É impressão minha ou o a54 saiu melhor?

  • @akshaychaturvedi5997
    @akshaychaturvedi5997 6 місяців тому

    A54 smooth
    & Perfect 👍

  • @KillAllRimuruSimps98
    @KillAllRimuruSimps98 Рік тому +3

    Ahhh yes, in Romania it's par on par with the S23 at price 💀

  • @jerrypc9038
    @jerrypc9038 6 місяців тому

    Una duda son del mismo tamaño?

  • @russellpoot93
    @russellpoot93 Рік тому

    The comparison is unfair one if from media range vs high range phones, but A54 it's a really good option due to is a lot cheaper and A54 camera it's good according what are you paying for.

  • @bredcooper
    @bredcooper 8 місяців тому

    Пользуюсь S9Plus , старичок ещё может 💪😄

  • @dollayx8
    @dollayx8 Рік тому

    flagship : camera with phone
    non flagship : phone with camera

  • @N.Looping
    @N.Looping Рік тому

    S23: Calm down 🤝

  • @dhamxx
    @dhamxx Рік тому

    do you record it with handheld? can you try with gimbal? never seen any 4k test on a54 with a gimbal

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому

      It was handheld. At the time of this video I didn't have a phone gimbal..now after i sold the a54 I got 3 gimbals...

  • @omarbarrientos4684
    @omarbarrientos4684 7 місяців тому

    Q diferencia del estabilizador s23 muy buena

  • @riderninjaselatanrnsvlog658

    Price never lie..

  • @ihidemy
    @ihidemy 4 місяці тому

    you need to go to the settings and press the stabilization button.

  • @armandimban4616
    @armandimban4616 10 місяців тому

    4k 30 fps or?

  • @nkmills5847
    @nkmills5847 Рік тому +1

    Flagship things

  • @SilviaGarciaStupervitta
    @SilviaGarciaStupervitta 7 місяців тому

    Incrível 👍

  • @sanyak458
    @sanyak458 7 місяців тому

    На а 54 нужно 1080р ставить 60 кадров,и стабилизация будет тоже хорошей.

  • @user-nf6sl3sd4z
    @user-nf6sl3sd4z 8 місяців тому +2

    Хочу а 54 себе.

  • @hokenmedia
    @hokenmedia 10 місяців тому

    A52 has best video stabilisation if turned on

  • @funside7662
    @funside7662 Рік тому

    A Series phones support stabilization only in HD mood not in 4k

  • @arnoldmbuthia2687
    @arnoldmbuthia2687 Рік тому

    Very similar

  • @John-ji1ly
    @John-ji1ly Рік тому

    What should I buy between this 2? Because the new s23 is very similar with a54. If I want a54 I want the one for sure with 256gb in Europe is around 539 €

    • @MrModikoe
      @MrModikoe Рік тому

      it should be an obvious choice if budget is not a problem..

  • @user-yz3de8pk4o
    @user-yz3de8pk4o 5 місяців тому

    У А54 стабилизация есть только при съемке в FHD формате, в 4к (UHD) её - нет

  • @SteveneS
    @SteveneS 3 місяці тому

    Sekarang penasaran sama si A35-nya

  • @ydcjydcj1724
    @ydcjydcj1724 Рік тому +2

    Can you compare both phones at 1080p60?

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому +1

      The A54 doesn’t have video stabilization at 1080p60

    • @agassifams9925
      @agassifams9925 Рік тому

      @@RedskullPro do you have xiaomi 12T, if yeah, would you like to compare it vs Galaxy A54

  • @Maira_001
    @Maira_001 Рік тому +2

    you should've recorded some human pictures or selfies and compared
    ultimatum today's times is getting clearer pictures of yourself more!😂

  • @thiagokraven
    @thiagokraven Рік тому

    S23 perfect

  • @fruirkful
    @fruirkful 10 місяців тому

    alguien graba videos largos en su celular?

  • @mahmudjon4660
    @mahmudjon4660 Рік тому

    S23👍🏻

  • @gillesfalonebanz4473
    @gillesfalonebanz4473 5 місяців тому

    Samsung for life 😇🙏🏾

  • @dogvesz_
    @dogvesz_ 8 місяців тому

    A45 looks way better even tho it doesn't have stabilization, i would still recommend it over S23 if you don't really wanna record stuff

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  8 місяців тому

      So, about a month after this video the A54 got an update that brought video stabilization to 4k recordings

  • @tribeadel4038
    @tribeadel4038 Рік тому

    Do the a52s vs S23 plz

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому

      Don’t have that a52 🤷‍♂️

  • @surumbinho3577
    @surumbinho3577 10 місяців тому

    my opinion on a54 its that it is a small phone on hands.

  • @DEVIL85555
    @DEVIL85555 6 місяців тому

    👌🏻👌🏻

  • @SammyBoyATP
    @SammyBoyATP Рік тому

    Unfair Test because: On A54, Stabilization is only available up to 1080p 30fps. Therefore, there was absolutely no stabilization present on your A54 test. Retest @ 1080 30fps 🤓

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому

      I was trying to make a point :)
      Samsung didn’t add EIS for 4k on purpose.

  • @he-elmagamer3179
    @he-elmagamer3179 Рік тому

    yeees

  • @mariokoti7970
    @mariokoti7970 8 місяців тому

    And when Samsung released A54 it wasn't cheap. I don't understand the philosophy of all brands that built phones for $450-$500 without stabilisation. It should be up to $600 to get in the game 😒

  • @user-lh8jn3ig2m
    @user-lh8jn3ig2m 8 місяців тому

    Moço se vc não for mais usar o A54 da ele pra mim por favor 😢

  • @HirRoable
    @HirRoable Рік тому

    A54 vs Xiaomi 12 lite vs S23

  • @timhawkeye1975
    @timhawkeye1975 9 місяців тому

    Im going with the s23

  • @cjever6625
    @cjever6625 Рік тому

    Not a decent comparison, since you are testing stabilization (OIS+EIS) not resolution. A54's EIS kicks in at 1080p.

  • @King_Roshan138
    @King_Roshan138 Рік тому

    Samsung A73 Review Pleease Sir 🎉🎉🎉❤😢😢😢😢

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому

      It’s a bit old now… it wouldn’t get views :(

  • @vincentli3331
    @vincentli3331 Рік тому

    In this video,A54 is using old software,try using at least may security update and test again😉

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  Рік тому

      This is from the week the phone was released

  • @gamingwithengineer6943
    @gamingwithengineer6943 8 місяців тому

    I also have samsung s23

  • @user-fs6ty4zs1b
    @user-fs6ty4zs1b 10 місяців тому

    Same same I thing😊

  • @krisboats
    @krisboats Рік тому

    A54 camera isn't as good, it's not very noticeable in daylight but soon as you hit low light or a scene with a large colour saturation (blue fish tank lights or music venue) and the colours are completely blown out. Fish tank showed all blue and slight green, sensor couldn't capture red colour channels at all. Missed out on loads of detail and looked horrific. My old galaxy s8 did a better job when using both phones in pro mode with same iso, white balance, shutter speed etc.

  • @firdausanuar4053
    @firdausanuar4053 5 місяців тому

    Ikod poket la brade.. 😂😂

  • @user-zf1iz9ot9q
    @user-zf1iz9ot9q Рік тому +7

    Ibwill get s23 plus in a week🎉🎉🎉😊

  • @rajeshdas8034
    @rajeshdas8034 8 місяців тому

    S23❤❤❤❤

  • @gevorgzhamharyan1413
    @gevorgzhamharyan1413 Рік тому

    Of course S23's camera is WAY BETTER!❤

  • @jamagno7
    @jamagno7 9 місяців тому

    is the EIS automatic apply or need to switch on manually??

    • @RedskullPro
      @RedskullPro  9 місяців тому

      at the time of this video EIS wasn't available for the A54.

  • @living_full_live_guy
    @living_full_live_guy 6 місяців тому

    Bro in samsung s23 looks like you stars walkung in moment when you run

  • @AlbertoGean-us4jg
    @AlbertoGean-us4jg 2 місяці тому

    Calmaa e um da linha A contra um da linha S, a melhor

  • @avazxonmominov
    @avazxonmominov Рік тому +1

    Galaxy s23