Why Sonic Games Suck

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
  • In this... Half serious video, we'll be talking about the blue blur, Sonic the Hedgehog, and how over the past few decades how he slipped from being one of the most iconic gaming mascots...
    And into being one of the most decisive in recent times.
    Also, why is he groping Arin Hanson? I dunno.
    Original upload: • Why Sonic Games Suck (June 21, 2020)
    Wanna contact or support me?
    Patreon: / mangakamen
    Twitter: / manga_kamen
    Deviantart: flairnightz.dev...
    Discord: / discord
    G-Mail: MangaKamen@gmail.com
    #sonicthehedgehog #sonic2 #sega

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,1 тис.

  • @marshallseldon4200
    @marshallseldon4200 3 роки тому +450

    This actually makes me respect Somecallmejhonny more since while he does have issues with some 3d sonic games he does not bash on people who like them and will point out the positives/stuff he likes on the games (hell when he re-review black knight he was more positive on it than he was in his first review).

    • @CanterlotCrusader
      @CanterlotCrusader 3 роки тому +108

      Yeah, Johnny has commented saying his earlier reviews were meant to kinda emulate the AVGN style with his brother, but now that more years have come by and times changed, he found his own groove.
      He's stated numerous times he hates the game for the controls and such, but he does at least give it a fair shake in his reviews and explains why he feels the way he does. I don't care if a reviewer disagrees with me, but it's essential they back up their claims with logic and explain it to the audience.
      Been a fan of Johnny for years. My fav youtuber.

    • @jouheikisaragi6075
      @jouheikisaragi6075 3 роки тому +56

      Johnny has among the better SA2 reviews as he's not biased against nor in favour of it(his personal preference does show and his issues with the story are either mistranslations or him not getting it). People say his review ruined the game's reputation, but all I see is folks taking off the nostalgia goggles and seeing the flaws.

    • @edgyzackyt-edgelordzackari4889
      @edgyzackyt-edgelordzackari4889 3 роки тому +45

      Honestly speaking, a bunch of games from the Dreamcast, 64, PS1 era didn't age well. Sonic just gets the raw end of the deal because of critics like Egoraptor

    • @jouheikisaragi6075
      @jouheikisaragi6075 3 роки тому +19

      @@edgyzackyt-edgelordzackari4889 he has enough clout to murder franchises if he felt like it.

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +17

      yeah somecallmejohnny is a great youtuber.

  • @Heroshii15
    @Heroshii15 3 роки тому +252

    Can we just kill that “This person’s angry and unlikeable personality is a character” thing, please? Bury it next to Channel Awesome’s grave.

    • @pokuhmoo9415
      @pokuhmoo9415 3 роки тому +4

      Yep

    • @mattwo7
      @mattwo7 3 роки тому +6

      I buried my own instance of that around three episodes into my own review show. Mostly.
      With the much deserved exceptions of MLP Newborn Cuties, See Me, Feel Me, Gnomey (a classic Powerpuff Girls episode that I didn't realize when I made the review was _after_ Craig left the show and the seasonal rot started) and Alpha's Magical Christmas (MMPR holiday special) (not counting the joke when I used Where the Dead Go to Die as an example of why I wouldn't go below 1 on my rating system because I'd have to watch it to actually rate it and that will _never_ happen) I haven't gone below a rating 3/5 ever since my first review. In fact the rating I've given the most is six 4/5s, followed by five 3/5s, four 5/5s, three 2/5s, two 4 point 5/5s and one each of 1/5 (Newborn Cuties) and 3 point 5/5.
      My first was a review of the Power Rangers Turbo Pizza episode after Linkara glossed over it. I made *_so many_* mistakes on that I eventually made up for when I reviewed the Carranger counterpart of it, though I had some audio issues that I covered for with UA-cam's captions. Honestly, Database Ranger did a FAR better job of reviewing it than I did and his show is really good, if you like Power Rangers, I highly recommend it.

    • @setsers1
      @setsers1 3 роки тому

      We don't talk about that

    • @Super_Suchi
      @Super_Suchi 3 роки тому +18

      The only person that I think does the “angry persona” character right is AVGN. And even then, he does it in a way that makes it endearing to the character. He also avoids reviewing games with polarizing reputations and more focused on things that are unanimously seen as bad. It’s a really smart move on his end.

    • @mattwo7
      @mattwo7 3 роки тому +8

      @@Super_Suchi Thankfully there will never be a shortage of those, even if he has to start going newer than the 90s at some point. Oh, he's already reviewing PS2 games.

  • @MILDMONSTER1234
    @MILDMONSTER1234 3 роки тому +398

    It's depressing how Arin has basically abandoned the newgrounds community and rejected what made him great

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +64

      Ironic, considering his old username.

    • @yunikohh
      @yunikohh 3 роки тому +11

      @@ChiefMedicPururu what's his old one?

    • @PepperKatLancer
      @PepperKatLancer 3 роки тому +57

      @@yunikohh EgoRaptor

    • @kirbythekirb59
      @kirbythekirb59 3 роки тому +1

      shut up and go back to the juckyard

    • @jordanboyd5587
      @jordanboyd5587 3 роки тому +23

      @@kirbythekirb59 Shut it and suck it up, Kirbo.

  • @kirbyinhalesjotaro4471
    @kirbyinhalesjotaro4471 3 роки тому +323

    It’s funny how you title this video “Why Sonic sucks” and then you’re actually really fair and reasonable to the series.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +67

      He did this so that the UA-cam algorythm wouldn't fuck him over.

    • @Temzy
      @Temzy 3 роки тому +28

      Gotta get them views somehow

    • @DarthJoshReturns
      @DarthJoshReturns 3 роки тому +10

      Kind of makes the title a bit click-baity.

    • @Wimpyfox
      @Wimpyfox 3 роки тому +8

      The point explained

    • @gayanudugampola8973
      @gayanudugampola8973 3 роки тому +16

      "UA-cam is completely balanced as all things should be" - TheSpiffingBrit before exploiting the community tab.

  • @zangetsu134
    @zangetsu134 3 роки тому +482

    What gets me about the grumps is how even his fans don't defend Arin's takes on Zelda, yet everyone agrees with his takes on Sonic.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +96

      Which is a bit hypocritical.

    • @edwardrobinson5470
      @edwardrobinson5470 3 роки тому +55

      Ya a bias possibly.

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +17

      i agree with his takes on zelda.
      but the sonic thing i will never understand.

    • @mmvmiguel
      @mmvmiguel 3 роки тому +19

      because sonic games usually suck

    • @jetblazethunder3596
      @jetblazethunder3596 3 роки тому +38

      Hey what’s with Arin and his...........opinions
      Spoilers for danganronpa
      (chihiro is not trans his a cross dresser)

  • @NekoBoyOfficial
    @NekoBoyOfficial 3 роки тому +141

    Arin in general has gone downhill. He's become the saltiest UA-camr I know, especially on Twitter. I'm glad Jontron's doing his own thing. He seems way happier.

    • @ImmaLittlePip
      @ImmaLittlePip 3 роки тому +46

      I'm kinda glad Jon is more successful even with his blunder in 2017 he still manage to come out of that on top and is bigger than ever

    • @solarium7988
      @solarium7988 3 роки тому +6

      Sooner or later, something similar to Persona 3's "Charm Salt is real" will happen.

    • @starmaker75
      @starmaker75 3 роки тому +11

      Well jontron had his own bad downhill, not in video quality,bull well....that an another story

    • @Pooky1991
      @Pooky1991 3 роки тому +1

      Yeah...Jontron had his own rabbithole that alot of people haven't forgotten, but who knows how his thought processes may have changed.

    • @hideofreakingkojima5457
      @hideofreakingkojima5457 3 роки тому +5

      ​@@Pooky1991 Even then he got right back up and he has been doing fine ever since. I believe that every person can change until it's proven otherwise, I mean I think that's what we should be doing instead of latching onto this one narrative on Jon for so long and telling people he will never change.

  • @battybuddy
    @battybuddy 3 роки тому +145

    Only real issue I've ever had against Sonic was that it seems nobody really remembers what people actually liked him for, and everyone has a different opinion on what that is.
    Think about that, it explains why a lot of the games are shit on- especially as of late.

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +18

      i mean it's kinda dumb to blame the fan for not being unified and having only having one opinion.

    • @jouheikisaragi6075
      @jouheikisaragi6075 3 роки тому +29

      The best way I can sum up the underlying identity Sonic has is that his games are all about flow and style(it isn't about going fast, it's about not stopping and you have to look cool while you play).

    • @battybuddy
      @battybuddy 3 роки тому +7

      @@merasmurry1460 Wasn't what I was saying. Just "not being unified and having more than one opinion" isn't "nobody really remembers what people actually liked him for and everyone has a different opinion on what that is."
      I've had people starting arguments over nitpicking the movie to hell and back. That's not having "More then one opinion" You have people who go with the Archie Sonic, people who go with the Sonic Team sonic, people who go with the Sonic Boom sonic, etc etc etc, and they all say that the other viewpoints are what is "bringing sonic down" You have the people who think Sonic was only good in 2D, the people who think Sonic is only good in 3D, and everyone has a different character that hasn't been featured in a game in 10 years that they claim is the reason for Sonic sucking now.
      And it's ALWAYS "MY opinion is the only opinion that matters"

    • @battybuddy
      @battybuddy 3 роки тому +2

      @@jouheikisaragi6075 I sort of describe Sonic as a roller coaster car that can jump.
      And yeah, I think that fits your underlining identity.

    • @Chiakiandmikanarebest
      @Chiakiandmikanarebest 3 роки тому

      @@jouheikisaragi6075 his best games are about maintaining the speed, you can make it through most of the games going really slow but the games are meant to be replayed over and over until you get really good on each stage, it’s why I’m thankful for the ranking system

  • @kamira4417
    @kamira4417 3 роки тому +43

    it's really annoying to see people bashing on sonic, saying the games and the fandom suck. haters/critics have to say that sonic had a rough history ever since he went 3D, say that sonic sucks now, bring up sonic 06, complain about sonic's friends, the fandom and mocking the fans. like jesus christ i get it. and also, it's so annoying to see let's players mess up on purpose and complain about it, like what did you expect?!

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +2

      so people aren't allowed to critics the fan base or the characters because people already have?
      also i never understood the hate for 3d sonic games adventure 1 & 2, colours and generations are all great game.

    • @e1iteyoshi998
      @e1iteyoshi998 3 роки тому +12

      And lets; not forget IGN's infamous review of Sonic Unleashed as an example.

    • @kamira4417
      @kamira4417 3 роки тому +5

      @@merasmurry1460 no, people are allowed to. i just get so annoyed when haters/critics need to say that how the it is the worst fan base even though every fandom has shitty fans, bring up the fan art, say it's cringy and focus so much on the toxic/weird side even though the fan base can be great too. and say that sonic's friends should be removed and misrepresent them. i guess i get tired from seeing it.
      also, agree. they are great games, so it's sad to see how people say 3d sonic is bad.

    • @kamira4417
      @kamira4417 3 роки тому +4

      @@e1iteyoshi998 oh, i remember that one. people got rightfully pissed. hated how he messed up, complained and such.
      also, sonic unleased is great game

    • @dragonmaster3030
      @dragonmaster3030 2 роки тому

      @@kamira4417 yeah, like mania, if we were such a terrible fan base I don't think that game would exist, or how about the dozens of quality fan games 3d and 2d, hell even that banger orchestra they held was partially due because of the great fan base, if people think it's bad because of certain art pieces then
      1. Their clearly missing all the great pieces
      2. Literally every fucking fan base has art like that

  • @jaymatsu2367
    @jaymatsu2367 3 роки тому +50

    I feel just how arin react from sonic, I noticed his reaction between this clip and and his recent danganronpa vids, his reaction from playing the class trial he has a hard time because he doesn't bother checking the controls and (spoiler alert)
    never listen the characters talking about the case, they thought it was clearly byakuya who killed sakura, just because of his reaction

    • @e1iteyoshi998
      @e1iteyoshi998 3 роки тому +25

      This is kinda why i stopped watching Game Grumps altogether. Arin to me just doesn't feel like he cares about what he plays anymore. He just treats it as that one job he doesn't want to go to but has to because it pays him well.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +12

      Because he doesn't give a shit.

    • @SleepyDonnnn
      @SleepyDonnnn 3 роки тому +13

      Also his whole thing on danganronpa being transphobic despite there being an explanation it's just forgetting the trial and not dying was top priority

  • @tanyaharmon6739
    @tanyaharmon6739 3 роки тому +99

    His sonic adventure playthrough depresses me

  • @heroesunited2686
    @heroesunited2686 3 роки тому +58

    It doesn’t just effect the Games it’s effecting the comics and tv shows... Most of the critics that aren’t sonic fans are killing the series.

  • @jordanboyd5587
    @jordanboyd5587 3 роки тому +139

    Lemme guess, this video's gonna talk about UA-camrs like Arin Hanson who makes stupid arguments as to why Sonic games suck, isn't it? (I'm judging it by the thumbnail, btw)
    Edit: I knew it. Good video, bro.

    • @jordanboyd5587
      @jordanboyd5587 3 роки тому +35

      @@Mangakamen One or the other is great.

  • @Total_Malarkey
    @Total_Malarkey 3 роки тому +11

    What makes me angry is that Sega will pander to assholes like Arin who don't even like Sonic meanwhile they'll completely alienate the hardcore fans who actually purchase their products.

  • @AbhorrentRose
    @AbhorrentRose 3 роки тому +59

    Sad seeing a guy make a walkthrough for other peoples benefit only to get lambated by a herd of people. A perfect metaphor for the extremist people who hate these games and its fans.

    • @AbhorrentRose
      @AbhorrentRose 3 роки тому +11

      @Declan McKenna Doesn't surprise me that Arin and Dan both had a collective stroke and couldn't process the guide.

  • @miguelescobedo5112
    @miguelescobedo5112 3 роки тому +83

    Normally I blame Sega USA and Sega Japan for always fighting with each other and making super bizarre and dumb decisions also I think Sega is confused and don't know where to take the Sonic franchise/series anymore but I can't wait to see the doomsday when the new voice for Sonic is announced anyway back to playing Citizens Unite Earth x Space have a nice day or night everyone.

    • @e1iteyoshi998
      @e1iteyoshi998 3 роки тому +12

      It's weird cause usually i hear the opposite and hear people blame the fanbase instead for not deciding what they want in a Sonic game.

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +13

      @@e1iteyoshi998 well it is a large fan base so there going to be many different opinions that a lot of the fans have so blaming them for not having only one opinions is stupid.

    • @1685Violin
      @1685Violin 3 роки тому +14

      @@e1iteyoshi998 Could be a combination of both.
      We have to ask why the _Mario_ franchise and fanbase remain relatively high quality and united respectively while the _Sonic_ franchise and fanbase remain in disputed quality and very divided respectively?

    • @PipeGuy64Bit
      @PipeGuy64Bit 3 роки тому

      @@e1iteyoshi998 It's obvious It's mostly Sega of Japan's fault since they are the reason they ended up becoming 3rd party to begin with. Also its clear they have meddle with development of Sonic games in the past especially forcing Sonic Boom to be a Wii U game instead of being on the PS4 and Xbox One all because of some dumb 3 games on the Wii U exclusivity deal they made with Nintendo.

    • @CosmicSponge2004
      @CosmicSponge2004 3 роки тому

      The voice thing is an enigma
      ▪When Ryan was Fired - People wen't crazy. Some weirdos even sent death threats to the next voice (only a very small minority of people)
      ▪When Jason was Fired - A Mixture of not caring, hopes for the future & celebrating
      ▪When Roger was Fired - People are *EXTREMELY* Sad😭
      What's next!?

  • @e1iteyoshi998
    @e1iteyoshi998 3 роки тому +66

    Yeah even as a huge fan of Sonic myself i can say that I haven't been into the series as much as i once was. My last game i played was Sonic Mania and that was the last game i considered good from this franchise. Forces wasn't as bad as some of the community made it out to be, but it suffered majorly in the writing department. Characters who were as seen powerful beings like Infinite were reduced to memeworthy edgelords and Tails was reduced to be cowardly despite learning how to be brave without Sonic before.
    I think that Sega's restructuring of their team is a step in the right direction to hopefully get Sonic back on track to being good, but i feel like letting go of a majority of the main cast at the moment (well with the exception of some) is a little too extreme. I didn't want to see Cindy Robinson or even Roger Craig Smith go. I know that they haven't been received well by some fans but overall i do think that they did very well with what they were given.

  • @323starlight
    @323starlight 3 роки тому +120

    This video should've been titled "How the Game Grumps ruined Sonic"

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +15

      no it was sega who ruined sonic.
      the game grumps didn't make all the bad sonic games, sega did.

    • @Kiko_mirai
      @Kiko_mirai 3 роки тому +25

      How *arin* ruined sonic

    • @thevioletskull8158
      @thevioletskull8158 3 роки тому +25

      @@merasmurry1460Sega made the bad games and Arian made the decent to good games look bad

    • @husariuspl117
      @husariuspl117 3 роки тому +6

      Or "Why people think Sonic Games Suck"

    • @byronlyons3548
      @byronlyons3548 3 роки тому

      Would've been too obvious, and you know how their fanbase would be if they found out this video easily because of that.

  • @generalflux2344
    @generalflux2344 3 роки тому +11

    Loved the vid Manga. As someone who likes these so called "bad games of the franchise" (06, Black Knight, 3D Blast, etc.), I really appreciate you pointing Arin out on the shit he's done, as well as the other big channels that put the series into such a negative light.

  • @friendlycryptid6797
    @friendlycryptid6797 3 роки тому +15

    "If SoNic ThE hEgEhOg WaS nEvEr GoOd WhY iS iT cElEbRaTiNg iTs 30th AnNiVeRsArY?!"
    Seriously though this was a fair and valid retrospective.
    -Not to mention your music choices was rad. STH doesn't get enough love.-
    I feel like I should mention I actually LIKE Shadow the Hedgehog & Forces. Are they bad? Yeah but I can find enjoyment in them.

    • @lpfan4491
      @lpfan4491 3 роки тому +5

      I actually think Shadow is decently good. It has a lot of good qualities to it, just that it also has some pretty bad parts mixed in. Forces meanwhile is a diffrent story.

    • @TheChildofAuraReborn
      @TheChildofAuraReborn 3 роки тому +5

      @@lpfan4491 I honestly don't think people should shit on Shadow the Hedgehog too much, it was a necessary game to re-establish Shadow's part in the timeline now that he was brought back after going missing in SA2 and showing up in Heroes without his memory. It ties everything back in nicely AND we got an extra game out of it.

  • @jbpiano5313
    @jbpiano5313 3 роки тому +12

    Gotta love how Arin chooses the worst vesion of Sonic games to play

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +2

      We all know why.

    • @Masonia_
      @Masonia_ 3 роки тому

      He said he does it because it makes it more funny, he knows there is better versions of the game.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +2

      @@Masonia_ And yet, his fans believe that this is how the games are.

    • @generalflux2344
      @generalflux2344 3 роки тому +3

      He has to get joy out of this whole experience. Think about it, Arin singlehandedly trained thousands of people, who treat him like some sort of deity, to shit on a franchise they've never even played themselves.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      @@generalflux2344 They're morons.

  • @edgelord8337
    @edgelord8337 3 роки тому +13

    In my opinion sonic games suck because fans are happy for mediocre games and the critics basically trash sonic games and say they've always been bad.
    I'm not surprised because these days everyone just take someone else's word and take it as the truth.

    • @DENVERRIOGRANDEMAN21
      @DENVERRIOGRANDEMAN21 3 роки тому +1

      Well I mostly agree

    • @joaquindiaz3621
      @joaquindiaz3621 3 роки тому +4

      Ok not all fans are just gonna go with mediocre games , because of course they are gonna get tired , i like forces but i know is not perfect, and Sega and Sonic Team needs to take more time to planning their games and have good level designers

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      @edge lord wut? How does that make sense?

  • @jacobtheorangeyoshi8710
    @jacobtheorangeyoshi8710 3 роки тому +26

    The modern Sonic fanbase is the very definition of: well its fun and that’s why I like it. Even with games like 06, that argument is perfect. It doesn’t need any backing.

    • @novelty_thief
      @novelty_thief 3 роки тому +13

      Yeah.
      It's borderline pedantic cruelty to demand fans to defend every nook and cranny of their favorite franchise only to be mocked as brainwashed babies.
      Thats narcissicism in it's purest form is what people like Arin show.

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +4

      when people say "it's fun for me" they mean they like the gameplay, not "the game is broken and borderline unplayable sometimes but i enjoy laughing at it so it's fun"

    • @PDS350
      @PDS350 3 роки тому +8

      @@merasmurry1460 and that is why people think sonic is fun, because they like the gameplay.

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +1

      @@PDS350 hell yeah.

    • @generalflux2344
      @generalflux2344 3 роки тому +2

      @@merasmurry1460 I'm a guy who loves 06. Why? Because it's fun. I love the story, the music, the stages, it's always been one of my favorites. According to Arin however, these aren't fair defenses and I'm just an idiot who likes a bad game. It's funny how opinions work nowadays.

  • @mangleman25
    @mangleman25 3 роки тому +6

    You know, it's really funny. When I saw you upload this video, Kamen, I thought to myself, "oh great, not him too." I thought you were going to do the popular thing to do, that being, to rant on about Sonic's "rocky transition into 3D", "too many characters", "REMEMBER SONIC AND ELISE KISSING??", and all that repetitive bullshit because it's Sonic's 30th anniversary and it'd give clout.
    Thankfully I was wrong.
    As someone who grew up with and still likes a lot of Sonic games from the mid-2000s (his supposed "dark age") I honestly think his true "dark age" arose with Lost World, when the games not only dropped in quality, but also scope, ambition, and heart. It's an era of Sonic entirely defined by self-deprecating humor, working alongside those who slandered the series where it's misplaced, and just putting out either garbage or mediocrity with no true identity or passion.
    If leaks are true and the series is taking the direction it was going with the Adventure games once again, then I'm sure Sonic is leaving this slump of a decade, which, I'm being real with you, I've been waiting for since Sonic Colors killed the series self-respect.
    Edit: and what I mean by Colors killing the series' self-respect, I mean them up at Sega doing dumb shit like hiring people like Ken Pontac and Warren Graff as scenario writers despite them not knowing literally anything about Sonic as they wrote the script.

    • @sayer4148
      @sayer4148 3 роки тому +1

      Even if the leaks weren't true it's clear that Sonic is getting an overhaul with voice actors being replaced and the new show that (from what I've heard) will have a tone similar to some of Man of Action's popular series like the original Ben 10.

    • @lpfan4491
      @lpfan4491 3 роки тому +1

      I hate the bullshit too. I actually found a video recently that was the same tired old points that Colors is what Sonic is and all that nonsense. Worst part is that it wasn't even a pretender or nonfan, they really seemed to like the series in concept but just hated the serious stuff the series was literally built around. It just tells me that people don't get Sonic anymore...or they just never got it.
      I almost feel like the weird freak accident of a fan that got into the series with lost world and went back to the dreamcast and dark age-eras when he liked the serious and dark aspect of that game. And it was luck too, I just selected multiple games from the club nintendo-wiiu mariokart promotion back then because I could not decide what to pick. And the Internetconnection gave me the lost world-code.

    • @mangleman25
      @mangleman25 3 роки тому

      @@lpfan4491 Man, your first Sonic game was Lost World? I find it a miracle that you even gained any interest in the series and went on to play his actually, non-ass games.

    • @mangleman25
      @mangleman25 3 роки тому

      Also yeah, people still touting Colors as the direction the series is about don't understand what it was ever about and what this series needs momentarily. Just like how they cried about Sonic being too serious, it's about time we got back Sonic taking itself seriously and about time Sega ignored the outcry from people who never had any real interest in the series to begin with.

    • @lpfan4491
      @lpfan4491 3 роки тому

      @@mangleman25 I mean, I was a kid and pretty easy to convince as long as the general idea of a game vibed well with me. Though I still overall find Lost world to be the least bad of the trio of it, colors and forces.
      Ironic twist tho, I also liked the story of black knight as a kid(Never owned or played the game, just watched it), but now I kinda hate it.

  • @JaxonHex
    @JaxonHex 3 роки тому +22

    So, your bad at a game and that makes it bad? So, since I'm bad at Dark Souls and Cuphead, those games are just the worst things ever.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +11

      That's the logic used by some "critics", yeah.

    • @JaxonHex
      @JaxonHex 3 роки тому +14

      @@ChiefMedicPururu Their Logic is terrible and they should feel bad.

    • @shadowpaine1
      @shadowpaine1 3 роки тому +1

      @@JaxonHex honestly I've argued with someone who thought the souls series were bad just cause he didn't like the stamina bar, didn't like the fact I pointed out he just couldn't manage his resources properly and just wanted to spam attacks

    • @emerl298
      @emerl298 3 роки тому +1

      @@ChiefMedicPururu Yep, most game “critics” suck at games, unfortunately.

    • @JaxonHex
      @JaxonHex 3 роки тому

      @@shadowpaine1 I was bad at that too, but that's not the games fault. And i know i got into a fight with a friend of mine over Borderlands 2 because he said, "The villain is to funny, it takes away from his personality."

  • @EndThusIAm
    @EndThusIAm 3 роки тому +5

    Popular Gamers: WHERE ARE THE LIGHT SHOES! THE BUTTON DOESN'T WORK!
    Me as a child: -finds them easily first time playing without the help of internet-

  • @CeceliaIsAWeeb
    @CeceliaIsAWeeb 3 роки тому +7

    As a huge Sonic fan... God bless you for this video. I won’t deny that plenty of the games have flaws, but to say that they are all bad is just silly. And plenty of the flaws are way too focused on. Like the camera in Adventure ain’t the best, but it’s not like Mario 64’s camera is that much better.
    Also I hate when Sega sucks up to people who hate on their games and pander to them. I’ll never forget when they invited Egoraptor to visit their headquarters in Japan or something like that, and that felt like they were spitting on the actual fans who love and support the series. Sonic fans are enough of a punching bag as it is, so Sega saying basically implying that they care more about haters than they do fans only hurts more.

  • @brunolinares604
    @brunolinares604 3 роки тому +2

    This went from a why Sonic sucks video to a why Game Grumps sucks vid halfway through.
    A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.

  • @AllenPhoenix
    @AllenPhoenix 3 роки тому +17

    This video was awesome! As a Sonic fan that grew up with the games as a kid I whole hardly agree.
    I blame Screw Attack mostly for the hate Sonic got because they almost everytime shit talked him like he was the worst thing (with one of the only time being Death Battle before Rooster Teeth bought the rights). I honestly didn't know Arin bashed Sonic that hard and makes me sad. (Makes me glad Jontron got out of there while he did).
    I remember one time there was a youtube game reviewer named Jimmy and he bashed Sonic Adventure 1 and he did in an Assholish way as he was harsh than normal (much on the same level of Projared if not harsher) and when people called himself, he deflected say the fan can't take criticism or some other smug remark (it's been a while so I can't remember). I unsub from him after words because he just became an asshole...
    Anyway great video and I really hope Sonic new game is good. I loved Mania but really hope the 3D title can pull it through for the little blue blurr. Hyped for the 2nd movie! 😎

    • @byronlyons3548
      @byronlyons3548 3 роки тому +5

      Yeah, and one thing people bring up is this one clip during him and Jon's playthrough of Sonic 06. With Arin trying to argue the Adventure games were bad, where as Jon says they aren't. Honestly him pulling this stuff with those two games is if he was trying to spite Jon. Which him making that bad criticism video that he calls sequelitis, based on Ocarina of Time, just as Jon talked against him making it the way he did, also proves how dumb and spiteful Arin is being.

    • @emerl298
      @emerl298 3 роки тому +3

      At least Jimmy’s getting less and less traction. Hopefully the same happens with Screwattack/Rooster Teeth and Game Grumps someday.

  • @LordTyph
    @LordTyph 3 роки тому +10

    Being fair on Sonic Forces, the team that made it was apparently pretty new so it lead to the level design being a lot more basic and bland, plus other issues.
    Still not that good (and doesn't explain much on the writing missteps) but all things considered, it could DEFINITELY be worse.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +4

      Too bad the script is goddamn inexcusable.

    • @LordTyph
      @LordTyph 3 роки тому +1

      @@ChiefMedicPururu eh, it was popcorn material for me but I'm more charitable as a rule.

  • @aerostrafe1075
    @aerostrafe1075 2 роки тому +4

    I hate those moments in metal harbor from critics. If fucking ten year old me can piece this together then there is no excuse a grown fucking man can't.

  • @aja6328
    @aja6328 3 роки тому +10

    Look I love Arin but he should pay attention to what he’s talking about. Because he’s gonna spit the sonic fanbase in two again. I think the only sonic gameplay he’s good at is sonic 06 because he’s having an hard time and seen like having fun.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +2

      He won't. You should know.

    • @aja6328
      @aja6328 3 роки тому

      @@ChiefMedicPururu Yeah you’re probably right.

  • @Yeayeayeayeayeayeayeayea
    @Yeayeayeayeayeayeayeayea 2 роки тому +2

    Subtlety. The foreshadowing with the Title and Thumbnail. Probably the most clever uses of it I've ever seen. Props to u man

  • @MCPhatman
    @MCPhatman 3 роки тому +3

    Egoraptor definitely hams it up most of the time, but its usually still an extension of himself.

  • @StarOutlaw9
    @StarOutlaw9 3 роки тому +2

    Second thing I will say; it seems like a lot of the critics in the 2010s were Gen x Nintendo fans who probably grew up with some resentment towards Sega in general and/or Sonic specifically.

  • @rabidguineapig
    @rabidguineapig 3 роки тому +1

    6:21 I'm so glad someone remembers two stupid dogs! Me and my brothers still quote that guy to this day!

  • @theAlchemyst11
    @theAlchemyst11 3 роки тому +2

    I’ve only seen a few of your videos and only recently discovered your channel at all, but I like what I’ve seen so far. In the few videos I’ve seen you’ve made me feel better about liking things when the entire internet is telling me it’s bad and I’m bad for liking it. This isn’t specifically about sonic mind you but this video definitely helps give those vibes. Looking forward to seeing what you’ll do in the future!

    • @theAlchemyst11
      @theAlchemyst11 3 роки тому +1

      @@Mangakamen I totally agree. It's rare I see anyone on the internet that thinks that way but when I do it's a real breath of fresh air.

  • @thelastwindwaker7948
    @thelastwindwaker7948 Місяць тому +1

    10:00 Ineptitude is one thing, but a lot of Arin's problems with games are self-inflicted, but he still acts like he does nothing wrong. It's the same thing with Zelda. He'll say that his refusal to use a shield is his "unique experience" and then turn around and lecture the audience when it doesn't work out for him, taking it personally that they don't think the games are terrible.
    At this point I just assume he's trolling... especially since he outright admitted in the Sonic Generations play-through that he blames the games to get a rise out of people.
    18:39 Because their former social media manager was a game grumps fan. As soon as he moved out of that position, they stopped associating with Arin, which he would then go on to blame Sonic fans for.

  • @egghead2003
    @egghead2003 3 роки тому +2

    THANK GOD I FOUND THIS VIDEO .
    in the last few years I've stumbled across many videos that address the sonic franchise, but this one right here is the best one so far. Most of the videos I saw were usually just dissing the franchise and it's fans, and as for the ones that actually gave kind of a fair criticism they all glanced over the self proclaimed ''game critics'' because to put it simply their fan bases are too strong and that would get these people into trouble. To be honest I am a follower of channels such as the game grumps and PPG, while they offer me a great deal of entertainment I don't agree with their takes on a handful of games (or in Sonic's case franchises) and especially Arin Hanson considering how he literally makes mistakes sometimes that are on purpose to create this image of the game to make it seem bad so that the impressionable audience thinks the same about that game. I like how in one of the episodes of game grumps (probably from the mania play through which by the way they did not complete because the game was actually good and not frustrating Arin and Dan said something along the lines of:
    ''sonic generations is that game most people liked, should we play it ?''
    ''nah, because it will be boring''
    And Arin said this or something close to it because he knew that the game is actually good and he even admitted having played it and enjoyed it , plus the time when they literally said that they picked the Wii version of sonic unleashed because it was and I quote ''the shittier version'', which solidifies the fact that they intentionally poke holes in the franchise to make sonic look like a joke, and I hate the fact that Sega themselves are making fun of their own franchise just to appeal to these type of people. And being that I am a sonic fan I am not afraid to address the problems that these games have but I hate it when people make trashy opinions on sonic just for those views and likes.
    sorry if the comment had any errors, English isn't my first language.

  • @NataliaNeeSama
    @NataliaNeeSama 3 роки тому +11

    Yeah, I agree with the video. Also not liking the 3D games is fine, but saying "no game in the whole franchise was ever good" is being a hipster. Franchises aren't usually born out of sequential bad games, and those people should know that at the very least.

  • @amirgarcia547
    @amirgarcia547 3 роки тому +2

    As a huge Sonic fan, it’s a shame that there’s such a negative stigma surrounding then games nowadays. I won’t pretend that the 3D/modern games are perfect, since as much nostalgia as I have for Sonic Heroes due to it being the first Sonic game I owned along with Sonic Riders, I won’t ignore the flaws it has that keep it from being a great game. Nonetheless, my personal favorite Sonic game is Sonic Colors, because for me, (almost) everything that game set out to do, it did consistently well, to the point where I enjoyed it all the way through and still do to this day. But as you said, people (both fans and critics alike) like to hyperfixate on the games’s flaws and ignore their good qualities almost entirely, to the point where it almost feels as if they don’t exist.
    As for Arin from GG...I don’t think he’s a bad person either, but he has such an ADD mindset where he just rushes through a game without bothering to understand its mechanics even if they’re outright spelled out for him. This isn’t bad on its own, but it causes frustrations and with the inability to realize he’s bad or at least subpar at the game, he’ll call the game itself bad and further drag its reputation through the mud. You could argue that he’s just doing it for the sake of comedy, but when you intentionally misrepresent a game, you’ll spread the stigma that it’s bad upon (many) impressionable fans who are most likely kids or teenagers who’ll take his word as gospel, like with Dunkey. The worst part is that a lot of the people who criticize Arin/GG are just seen as “butthurt fanboys,” even if many people are aware that there’s criticisms that can be made about the Sonic games. Just that Arin and plenty other videogame “critics” go about it in the worst way possible.
    So tl;dr, while I hope the next Sonic game is one worth writing home about, I just hope this annoying stigma that’s permeated the series since the mid-2010s soon dies down.

    • @pizzatime9261
      @pizzatime9261 3 роки тому

      Well there's a stigma around the 3D games due to their track record. The 2D games don't get nearly as much hate and are generally well accepted as good games.

  • @kyburn6195
    @kyburn6195 3 роки тому +2

    You and RadicalSoda helped clear the fog about Sonic for me.
    Sonic was never bad, but he's defiantly gotten a poor reputation.
    It also doesn't help that his games seem to lack direction for the past 10 years, excluding Mania.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      Too bad RadicalSoda kinda clickbait a lot.

    • @EA-bv8zk
      @EA-bv8zk 3 роки тому +1

      @@ChiefMedicPururu how though?

  • @heehooobsessor7907
    @heehooobsessor7907 3 роки тому +2

    I watched the video and I generally agree with you. If Sonic was bad from the beginning, then why the hell is his games so beloved, especially the classic/adventure era?

  • @speed_queen
    @speed_queen 3 роки тому +2

    It’s not just Sonic either, their Danganronpa play through gets progressively more frustrating to watch as the episodes go on, it’s absurd.

    • @speed_queen
      @speed_queen 3 роки тому +2

      @@Mangakamen yes, and Arin is just as oblivious playing that as he does any other sonic game. They’re occasionally funny though I’ll admit.

    • @novelty_thief
      @novelty_thief 3 роки тому +6

      @@speed_queen Oh fuck no. Not another franchise!
      I swear if we didnt have people like Kamen or Jay Exci criticising critics, at one point in the future some overbloated communities around an overly smug asshole would be able to nuke whole franchises.
      And worst of all they would be smug and dishonest about it

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому

      @@Mangakamen Yep. And he re-opened a old debate from years ago, while calling the game transphobic.

    • @SleepyDonnnn
      @SleepyDonnnn 3 роки тому

      @@ChiefMedicPururu what old debate

    • @ImmaLittlePip
      @ImmaLittlePip 3 роки тому

      You should watch their zelda playthroughs
      Especially the n64 ones

  • @rightleft4509
    @rightleft4509 3 роки тому +2

    I want to bring this up because I see this a lot, but just so you know I was born in 2005 and never played played sonic adventure for myself so take this with a grain of salt. “Sonic had a rough transition to 3D.” No? No they didn’t. A simple google search will tell you that their first 3D game was sonic adventure for the Dreamcast, which was considered a good game when it first released. “But it’s graphics are bad!” Yes, to our current day standards, it may seem bad. But this game came out back in 1998 and was their first 3D game. It was never going to look good by our current day standards. If a kid saw that game back when it came out, they would have been amazed at seeing sonic in 3D. We can’t look at older games with the same standards we have now or even back in 2011. As those games will rarely appease to such.

  • @agreedboarart3188
    @agreedboarart3188 3 роки тому +6

    I'm a big Sonic fan. Have been all my life.
    I've been disappointed for a decade and a half because Sega refuses to make good Sonic games. They listen to these fucking morons who say "Sonic was never good" and keep making trash that isn't Sonic at all. Sonic Colors was the game that truly ruined the legacy of Sonic though, and Lost World was such a disgrace, but I wasn't even surprised at that point. I had seen just how little Sega actually cared about the blue blur. The series is just dogshit now, and you have idiots like Arin who still perpetuate this dumb idea about Sonic always sucking to this day.
    The reason people go so hard on the modern Sonic games is because the older games were actually great.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      And his fans deserve to be shit on as well for enabling him ("you're fucking right").

    • @zeroxenoverse9251
      @zeroxenoverse9251 Рік тому

      At least Gens, Colors DS, and Mania was good. Also now in recent years, Frontiers.

  • @pippo17173
    @pippo17173 3 роки тому +2

    Out of all the over the top hatred for this series, the only thing that has a merit is how the new games change the formula so many times that it never stay's consistent.

  • @maytalacedo20
    @maytalacedo20 Рік тому +1

    " if it's so easy then what's the problem? Your findings says to complain in that regard."
    Thank you for that I wldve said the same thing to someone who doesn't understand the story and the game mechanic.

  • @maytalacedo1284
    @maytalacedo1284 Рік тому +2

    sonic does not deserve this much hate. it may had it's good moments and it's bad moments but I don't think all sonic games are that bad. I think the problem of this is they overcriticized it to the point they believe it's what it's become and didn't take a step back and really look at the game in general "were there at least good points from the 'so called bad games'?"
    - sonic adventure and sequel were great because of it's soundtrack, good gameplay and the story with it's interesting characters altogether.( the chao garden too)
    - sonic 06 had at least the awesome soundtrack, shadow's storyline is amazing and have the best character development, sliver was interesting, and the villain metaphasis was a great threat and very scary enough to make the hero's shake. it may have bad mechanic's but there were some good moments.
    - sonic generations was a love letter to the sonic fans.
    and they say "sonic games are bad" BLASTMAMY!

  • @maytalacedo2942
    @maytalacedo2942 Рік тому +1

    " I just want a good Sonic game is that too much to ask?"
    That's me who just want to have fun with the game Rather than overthinking and over analysing everything.
    And that's why I love the Sonic games.

  • @Mello-Nova
    @Mello-Nova 3 роки тому +2

    Bro I've been saying for years now that ProJared fucking sucked at the game and he was just finding reasons to hate it. I love it when people are actually aware that he's just spreading misinformation and aren't just following his opinion.
    Very good video man nice work

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      Ruby of Blue also called him out.

    • @Mello-Nova
      @Mello-Nova 3 роки тому

      @@ChiefMedicPururu ik that's a great video as well

  • @drawnborn5896
    @drawnborn5896 3 роки тому +3

    Surprisingly the only game critic(Which ironically barely does any gaming videos anymore except for that boat video) that's actually at least valid is JonTron.
    He critiques the games through the game's mechanics,story,the developers/company's choices etc.
    He makes it entertaining to watch.
    And he doesn't spread hate as of were(Even tho it may seem like it).
    And sometimes he even makes a parody about them. Like from his retrospective videos(I think that's what is called) of Sonic Colors and Sonic Generations. They maybe funny,but even then he thinks that they're enjoyable to play through. Although he doesn't like the Sonic Boom games,which is understandable why(I mean those games are horrible).
    Long Story Short: I too wish for a good Sonic game that's awesome to play,that has a cool,and interesting story,and it doesn't had to appeal to the biased/"Lacking Self-aware"/Harsh critics who thinks that ALL Sonic Games are horrible.
    I do hope that this year that The Sonic Team actually can create an awesome Sonic Game(Or Games,if they're ambitious) that many people can enjoy.
    And if read through all of this,then thx for reading this. You're awesome! 😊
    But if you haven't,or just don't care,and just scroll past mine,then I can't blame you.
    Either way,I hope you all have a good day,afternoon,or night! And stay safe. Much love and care to you all! 😊
    (Except for bullies,trolls,and assholes)

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      Kinda sad that Arin has pushed him under the bus.

    • @drawnborn5896
      @drawnborn5896 3 роки тому +1

      @@ChiefMedicPururu Ikr?
      And much like Grant from Treesicle,I REALLY do wanna know why JonTron leave GameGrumps?
      There might be some answers,but idk if they're true or not.

    • @pizzatime9261
      @pizzatime9261 3 роки тому

      I think somecallmejohnny is probably my favorite game reviewer since he gives the games he plays a fair chance and goes pretty in depth with stuff like story and gameplay without getting overly nitpicky most of the time.

  • @breloopharos1919
    @breloopharos1919 3 роки тому +2

    To be fair, sonic adventure games doesn't really incentivize explore the individual levels, of course knuckles stages you do cause the levels are built around exploring. At least in sonic level, you just hold up and run till you cross the finish line.

  • @critchelite262
    @critchelite262 3 роки тому +6

    Sonic may not have had the most graceful jump to 3d but hey if it did we wouldn't have legendary moments like Robotnik pissing on the moon to flex on Obama.

  • @Bob-op1ue
    @Bob-op1ue 3 роки тому +1

    @8:17, would you ever consider making a video about dunky’s octopath traveler video?

  • @ChampionRevilo
    @ChampionRevilo 8 місяців тому +2

    I do think Sonic always sucked aside from the Adventure games. I don't get why people even like the 2D games. How are you supposed to go fast when you cannot see 5 feet in front of you? It's dumb design. Most of the levels also make you wait for platforms to move or make you go slowly in water. There is no speed even if it's marketed as a fast game. Also, Sonic 1 has a glitch on the TITLE SCREEN. What foreshadowing. But yeah, Arin's definitely not a good source to base anything on, anyone with more than a double digit IQ could see that.

    • @zeroxenoverse9251
      @zeroxenoverse9251 6 місяців тому +4

      Cause Sonic is about momentum. Not speed, and don't expect to learn the level right away or anything. As for Arin, he is kinda a representation of how to not play a game.

  • @nerobiblios4086
    @nerobiblios4086 3 роки тому +3

    Is the rivalry even still a thing? It just seems like Mario doesn't really give a shit.

    • @lightgivemepower6425
      @lightgivemepower6425 3 роки тому +7

      No the rivalry between Sonic and Mario stopped a long time ago... But people often keep bringing it up.

    • @lpfan4491
      @lpfan4491 3 роки тому +1

      The rivalry stopped when SA2 was ported to gamecube. The entire point of it to begin with was to sell more Sega-consoles. I still feel as if Lost world could have restarted it, but the game messed it up and the concept is dead. And we should let it stay dead.

  • @masterofkh265
    @masterofkh265 3 роки тому +1

    The section with the light dash shoes was kinda weird. Didn't see the point why you needed to go up the zipline just to get the shoes, could of just been right there by the rings. Either way, it was kind of silly why they didn't explore around the area when they realized they couldn't do the light dash.
    While that doesn't exclude the fact that these people aren't exactly in the right for hating cause of things like that. It is most certainly inconvenient at times.

  • @aerith2709
    @aerith2709 3 роки тому +3

    I think this just goes to show that you should only listen to criticism from people who are actually fans of any property. At least they're being genuine and aren't just saying that a game is bad due to a preconceived bias.

  • @aureliodeprimus8018
    @aureliodeprimus8018 3 роки тому +2

    From the mainline games i only played the First Sonic Advance games on an emulator, the first Sonic on an old Genesis and Sonic Unleashed, Sonic and the Black Knight and Sonic Generations. And the only game from the mainline i finished was Unleashed, cause with the others i lost the motivation half-way. Other than that, i finished Sonic Battle, Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood and Shadow the Hedgehog.
    My opinion is, that Sonics greatest strengths lies in the character cast and writing, a strength that is rarely used due to the writers not interested in it.
    But in terms of Gameplay, Sonic has in my opinion one of the most redundant and restrictive gameplay i ever seen.
    Redundant= I know two myths pertaining to the creation of the gameplay flow in Sonic. The first one is that it was inspired by the movement of Pinballs and the other one is that the creator looked at people speedrunning the first levels of Mario Bros. and wanted to put the emphasis on that.
    Both have their issues.
    The main appeal of Pinball machines is to keep an uncontrolable ball going without losing it. I would like to know, who ever thought "I want to be the ball in a pinball machine."
    And the speedruns on the first Mario Bros levels were not something people liked to do, but have to do, since Mario Bros couldn`t save progress. I mean it is commendable to try to turn misery into a virtue, but both factors result in most games feeling like i am getting tossed around the stage with no control over it, something very detrimental to a platformer.
    Restrictive = Sonics basic trait is being able to run fast. This restrict the gameplay at so many levels.
    First Sonics abilities: While Mario got a new jump almost every game, Sonics abilities remained pretty stagnant, being the Spin Dash in Sonic 2, Homing Attack, Sidestep and Light Dash from Adventure and the Boost and Slide from Unleashed. The problem is, making new abilities around running is pretty much impossible except from running even faster.
    The stages: Well remember how after Green Hill Zone you got into Marble Zone? It is pretty much the main problem with Sonic Stage design. You completely have to build it around Sonics ability to run fast, because precision platforming and being fast contradicts each other on an fundamental level. The same goes about collectibles, which were completely random placed in early titles until the 3D titles placed them directly in Sonics way and tried to use them to guide to alternate paths to go. I also remember how Sonic and the Black Knight had side objectives and NPCs to talk to on the stages, which are very easy to miss, due to being so fast. Basically if you want to design a functional Sonic map, you have to design a A to B racetrack with splitting paths, which also runs the danger of being repetitive. (This is the main reason Sonic games bore me to death, because the gameplay gets really repetitive, if you aren`t into speedruns. I may be one of the few, who actually liked the Werehog in Unleashed as bringing an alternative gameplay style to cycle through.)
    In my opinion a good Sonic game should take some pages from Adventure and utilize the cast to give every character a gamemode on its own, Sonic the classical A to B-running, Knuckles a 3-d map to explore, etc. etc.
    Building on its strengths and bringing some variety in the gameplay. But sadly it won`t happen...

    • @DapperFella
      @DapperFella 3 роки тому +1

      I agree for the most part. The boost gameplay has gotten very stale to me, it essentially is just holding a button to see a cutscene of the stage you could've been actually playing. They've focused too much on the speed and not enough on what made the speed fun in my opinion, momentum. What's fun about going fast in the 2d sonic games is that you have to find ways to build it up in most cases, which makes the speed feel like a reward rather than base gamplay, which is why the boost is kinda lame to me. There's also the issue of having to design levels to be way longer because of boosting. Though they don't actually take more time, in fact they usually end up taking way less time, which is why forces is so short. And all of that effort for scenery you can barely see thanks to going at mach speed. And the characters... There are so many of them, and yet they are almost never used at all, and when they are used they're cardboard cutouts of what they used to be. Tails is now a coward who can't do anything without Sonic, even though in past games we've been shown this clearly isn't the case.

  • @ddjsoyenby
    @ddjsoyenby 3 роки тому +1

    honestly they need to stop assuming them sucking at games is the games fault.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      Too bad the majority of Lovelies are brainwashed.

  • @ninjapotatolorf6237
    @ninjapotatolorf6237 3 роки тому +1

    I've never seen Sonic as being a particularly polished or well-made game from a purely technical perspective, but I've enjoyed almost every Sonic game I've played.
    Yes. Even Sonic Lost World for the 3DS.

    • @Orange_Swirl
      @Orange_Swirl 3 роки тому

      I hope one day Sonic reaches its fullest potential

  • @wednesdaygeckok.7899
    @wednesdaygeckok.7899 2 роки тому +5

    Sonic is bad! Screams people who routinely pretend the N64 zelda games and Mario 64 are genuinely perfect.
    Hot take: the N64 has one of the legit worst game libraries ever

  • @dave9515
    @dave9515 3 роки тому +1

    You would love to hear how sega restructured themselves after forces and really seem to want to meet fans expectations for once then.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому

      We'll see this with next game.

    • @therandomheavy4570
      @therandomheavy4570 3 роки тому +1

      Tbf Sega really don't need Sonic anymore the Yakuza games have become more popular in the west and east to a point that Sonic may as well not exist.
      Well that's until Sega do something massive with Sonic that boosts it's popularity back to were people stopped hating it just because it's cool to.

  • @andersonsansonowski5644
    @andersonsansonowski5644 28 днів тому +1

    when it comes to ProJared's review...... SA2 fans will say karma is real..
    you know what i'm talking about....

  • @theguy1303
    @theguy1303 3 роки тому

    I really like your video manga. They’re great and well made video with some good opinions. Also I hope you get better soon I just read your comment and I understand to a certain extent what you feel.

  • @Kumaclaws
    @Kumaclaws 3 роки тому +4

    Haha what if I were to pronounce someone’s full name to “prove I’m using a real walkthrough” (for levels based around randomly generated spawn points) then when my fans find their email and tell them to commit not alive, I’ll apologize on Reddit. I’m sorry guys, that wasn’t cool of me! Anyways I didn’t dox him and people just need to forget about it, I’m the real victim here

    • @merasmurry1460
      @merasmurry1460 3 роки тому +1

      it's not his fault that his fans harassed that guy. he didn't say "go harass this guy". also the guy put his name on the guide and posted it on internet so his name was already out there for anyone to see.

    • @Kumaclaws
      @Kumaclaws 3 роки тому +2

      @@merasmurry1460 did they advocate for harassment? Of course not. Do they enable their fans and not call out shitty behavior? Yes. The fact is that a fan quoting “god damn it Ross” was given more shit than fans hassling someone for a walkthrough made in 2004

    • @byronlyons3548
      @byronlyons3548 3 роки тому +1

      @@merasmurry1460 They still gave out too much information, and whether intentionally or not, they still talked of the scenario of their fans giving the guy a bad time. Also like was said, they never reprehended their fans for doing that thing, and instead just did one re-upload and called it a day. Acting as if it was not a big deal.
      This isn't the only time they doxxed someone either. As a matter of fact, the next time was more heinous than this one, as they did in fact advocated for it directly, and it being worser that it did near irreparable damage.

  • @leonlegend
    @leonlegend 3 роки тому +2

    I wish people would stop blaming Egoraptor for Sonic's reputation. He's been more open about it recently, claiming that he is a Sonic fan. It's been over a year now, but I remember him rather enjoying Sonic 2 & Mania. Sonic's main reason for being hated is because a lot of people can't let go of the past (2006) & his fanbase. People really want to distance themselves from it by any means. Yes some people are fickle lemmings but should we really bother paying them any attention?

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +4

      "It's been over a year now, but I remember him rather enjoying Sonic 2 & Mania"
      And you would be wrong. He was bored as fuck with those games. Also, he has lied about being a Sonic fan. FUCK, even Manga shows you the proof that he's not via a clip.

    • @leonlegend
      @leonlegend 3 роки тому +2

      @@ChiefMedicPururu Episode 3 of their Sonic 2 playthrough 3:50 he says that the top, good route is fun & admits to being bad at the game.
      Either way, your missing the point in my comment. I just wish people would stop solely blaming Arin for Sonic's reputation.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      @@leonlegend And you ignored my post totally. Unless you believe he has 100% Majora's Mask in the past, yet that doesn't fit with what happened during the MM LP.

    • @leonlegend
      @leonlegend 3 роки тому +2

      @@ChiefMedicPururu What part am I ignoring? What does MM have to do with anything?
      Are you deliberately being nebulous?

    • @hideofreakingkojima5457
      @hideofreakingkojima5457 2 роки тому

      @@leonlegend I know that he isn't the sole reason of ruining Sonic's reputation, but he's definitely a big contributor of it. Why do you think Sonic Twitter had been "self aware" of their short comings like Sonic 06 over and over for the past 7 years? It was funny at first but there's a point where it just gets desperate and sad.

  • @Yunglex313
    @Yunglex313 2 роки тому +2

    GO PLAY SONIC PROJECT 06! IT'S PROOF THAT 06 WAS A GOOD IDEA, THAT GOT FUCKED BY SEGA TIME CONSTRAINTS, AND A WEIRD ASS STORY, IT'S AWESOME, YOU WILL LOVE IT. Yes I am ensuring that every bad Sonic game video I watch, to plug that game, it's flipping great. Look it up.

  • @aerth6946
    @aerth6946 3 роки тому +3

    These guys are literally unworthy of any attention.
    They shouldn't ever be used as a criteria, they're a joke.

  • @GunFuMasterHS
    @GunFuMasterHS 3 роки тому +1

    Gave the video a like for the sole reason that I ALSO really don't like Arin Hanson.
    But all the nice editing was the cherry on top.

  • @tobinfromfireemblem9742
    @tobinfromfireemblem9742 3 роки тому +2

    Of course Sonic does it again, he does this crap all the time.
    You know, since I was considered a Nintendo character, they let me be apart of the crowd watching the Olympics contest that Italian plumber and blueberry colored hedgehog had. You know what that smurf of a Erinaceinae did at the final event? He caused a damn nuclear explosion. I just barely survived because I somehow used a warp staff on myself. Wasn't too far away, but far enough for me to hijack a empty car and get away.

  • @SonicHedgehog1991
    @SonicHedgehog1991 2 роки тому +2

    I don't like how when idiots can't play the game correctly, they call it bad and attack whoever like it. Like, you aren't the center of everything, don't treat your opinions as if it's facts.

  • @RenjiMaili
    @RenjiMaili 3 роки тому +4

    Game Grumps and their garbage tire "humor".

  • @theotherky
    @theotherky 3 роки тому +2

    I never understood why it suddenly became a problem when part of a game or the entire game is easy. I get that people want a decent challenge, but does every game need to be one from start to finish?

    • @CosmicSponge2004
      @CosmicSponge2004 3 роки тому

      Imagine them playing Kirby

    • @theotherky
      @theotherky 3 роки тому

      @@CosmicSponge2004 Yeah, but for some reason it seems like Kirby is always immune to criticism when it comes to difficulty. It's like that's the only game that's allowed to be "for kids".

  • @TheAutistWhisperer
    @TheAutistWhisperer 3 роки тому +8

    Oh this is going to be good.

  • @Alien--Bunny
    @Alien--Bunny 3 роки тому +2

    Those playthroughs killed me. When I was little and played Sonic Adventure 2, I knew where to look for the speed shoes... on my first playthrough. Yeah, some of the Sonic fan base doesn't like Arin. The fact that SEGA had him to promote a Sonic game... yeah... SomeCallMeJohnny is like the best for Sonic games at critics, but even then, some Sonic fans don't like him, so take things at a grain of salt. I think also the Completionist is good too. However just asking a Sonic fan and playing a Sonic game is the best way. I suggest Sonic Adventure 2 just for the Chao Garden, and Sonic Force for character ideas.
    However Irish the Hedgehog was cute, it got lots of cute fan art (within the Sonic fandom).

  • @LordTyph
    @LordTyph 3 роки тому +2

    Got a compilation for the gameplay failures?

  • @duskyer2391
    @duskyer2391 3 роки тому

    In your next video can you use the gif of Dan Kuroto spamming the keyboard if you haven't already?

  • @hornie_pie_7861
    @hornie_pie_7861 3 роки тому +7

    Wow, great video! It’s about time someone finally tells off the sheep about their “idols”. Ive hated being patronized for years for my opinions, constantly having to lie to myself about what’s good and what isn’t just so I wouldn’t get made fun of for their sake.
    Thankfully this generation of sonic fans have grown up now and can actually hold their own opinions against people like Arin and PBG. Hopefully our voices are heard loud enough so Sega can quit taking Arin on tours pretending like they like him.

    • @hornie_pie_7861
      @hornie_pie_7861 3 роки тому +1

      @LeoUltima a lot of fans were young back then, so when you looked up to someone as funny as and also mostly kid friendly as PBG, it was kind of like you were expected to agree with him. He isn’t a bad person but he has always talked down about the sonic franchise and it’s fandom.

  • @shakefan1484
    @shakefan1484 3 роки тому +7

    They gonna drag you, man.

  • @livingdoubt54
    @livingdoubt54 3 роки тому +5

    imma just say it
    the game grumps are not funny and they never were funny

  • @Thekoodie
    @Thekoodie 3 роки тому

    Great vid Mangakamen! I wouldn't worry too much about Game Grumps stans hating in this video: I don't know when this vid was originally posted on your secondary, but it's pretty widely accepted by most of the GG audience that Arin is terrible at games and a HUGE hypocrite when it comes to how games should offer tutorials/instructions. But that's kind of just what makes him Arin Hanson: he IS the "Grump" part of GG after all

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +6

      Doesn't excuse him for his bullshit, tho.

    • @Maloz-se1rf
      @Maloz-se1rf 3 роки тому +1

      The only problem with this is that people are passing off that behavior as 100% the truth when he's constantly screwing everything up and not paying attention, this "character" is what creates that stigma and he doesn't bother to say that just a character he says it like if it's really him

    • @emerl298
      @emerl298 3 роки тому

      There’s still too many people in the fandom that think a game sucks because Arin’s gameplay was terrible.

  • @ScythGrizz
    @ScythGrizz 3 роки тому +8

    I don't think we'll ever forget IGN's laughably bad Sonic Unleashed review.

    • @EA-bv8zk
      @EA-bv8zk 3 роки тому +1

      That review will forever be cursed!

  • @nickdeyoung6197
    @nickdeyoung6197 2 роки тому +3

    sonic sucks so hard..... so cringe in every aspect

  • @stardusttodorki2679
    @stardusttodorki2679 3 роки тому +1

    I played a game that I can’t say on UA-cam saga Japan

  • @eldiegollador7271
    @eldiegollador7271 3 роки тому +4

    I wish Danny and John were the GameGrumps. Arin wouldn't be so bad only his incompetence wasn't accompanied by his entitlement.

  • @dreamcastdazia4753
    @dreamcastdazia4753 3 роки тому

    Think the video should be retitled "Cancelling Arin"

  • @gregtitizian2760
    @gregtitizian2760 3 роки тому +5

    Game grumps on purpose plays the worst version of each sonic game. That’s why they played the wii version of sonic and the wherhog. They want the game to be as bad as possible to have content.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +7

      And yet, most of their fans gulp it up.

    • @draggleangelgarrison9555
      @draggleangelgarrison9555 3 роки тому +3

      @@ChiefMedicPururu very sad indeed

    • @lynxfresh5214
      @lynxfresh5214 3 роки тому +3

      Yup I don't even blame Arin (I've never watched Game-Grumps and I didn't know who he was until recently).
      So from my POV some "fans" have been cognitively reprogrammed by some internet funny guy. I'm sorry but if you're going to hate on a franchise as well as it fans because of someone else's "oPiNIoNs" please kindly fuck off and congrats you're NOT a Sonic fan but a NPC.

  • @SleepyDonnnn
    @SleepyDonnnn 3 роки тому +4

    I felt braincells commiting suicide watching those clips

  • @BlackRaveBow
    @BlackRaveBow 3 роки тому

    Let me take a guess:
    -They can't keep a consistent playstyle.
    -They change gameplay.
    -People grow attached to one playstyle and when it gets changed they feel disenfranchised.
    -The fandom eats itself because they can't agree which of the 20 gameplay styles they should stick with.
    -SONICTEAM can't stick to a single playstyle because they made a fandom that can't decide what it wants so it's a never ending cycle.
    -SA1/2 are the best Sonic games

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      Why don't you actually watch the video?

    • @BlackRaveBow
      @BlackRaveBow 3 роки тому

      @@ChiefMedicPururu I did. He makes it seem like it’s an outside problem but really it’s an inside problem

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +1

      @@BlackRaveBow Except the outside make it worse. Right now, the fanbase ISN'T the main issue.

    • @BlackRaveBow
      @BlackRaveBow 3 роки тому

      @@ChiefMedicPururu I disagree at the end of the day game grumps isn’t making bad sonic games it’s SONICTEAM that’s making bad sonic games. The way they interact with the fandom that they themselves divided by never sticking to anything is the issue.
      Fix the internal issue, and the external will be fixed.
      Sonic made its own bad track record, the lets players just dog piled on it.
      The issue is internal.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому

      @@BlackRaveBow "I disagree at the end of the day game grumps isn’t making bad sonic games "
      Wow, you really missed the point of the video, then, because that's not what Kamen said EITHER.

  • @StarforceOnAir
    @StarforceOnAir 3 роки тому +1

    Can we just agree that Arin needs to be kicked out of GameGrumps? He's an active detriment to the show and everybody around him.

  • @stancowski2687
    @stancowski2687 Рік тому +2

    Dude just look on the bright side for once. Sonic IS good now with sonic frontiers

    • @gavinelrod6307
      @gavinelrod6307 Рік тому +1

      this was made before sonic frontiers

    • @stancowski2687
      @stancowski2687 Рік тому +2

      🤓

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu Рік тому +3

      Not only was this made before Frontiers, but the title is kinda bait, lol. He doesn't consider the series to be bad. Rather, the Internet reception to the series.

  • @dancingvalkyrie
    @dancingvalkyrie Місяць тому

    I dunno man, maybe Sonic Team should just stop making buggy and glitchy games and make something actually good. Maybe blaming youtubers isnt the way to save a bad franchise 🥱

  • @genemelendez8157
    @genemelendez8157 3 роки тому +390

    People give Omochao a lot of shit, but players like PeanutButterGamer and Game Grumps show why Omochao is needed. Some people need instructions spelled out to them

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +60

      And that's still not enough, sadly.

    • @YoshifreakZX
      @YoshifreakZX 3 роки тому +63

      Ngl, when I first played Sonic Adventure 2, Omochao actually did help me on certain stuff. I really can't hate on Omochao a lot because of that

    • @edwardrobinson5470
      @edwardrobinson5470 3 роки тому +18

      Yep. Especially if a player just flat out ignore instructions.

    • @ImmaLittlePip
      @ImmaLittlePip 3 роки тому +36

      I'll at least say austin blames himself when he fails
      Can't say about Arin "dsp 2.0" Hanson

    • @mattwo7
      @mattwo7 3 роки тому +2

      You say that and yet...

  • @FireroseNekowolf
    @FireroseNekowolf 3 роки тому +257

    It's genuinely so good to see people call out Arin on his bullshit. I really wish more people would. For a channel of their size, they have a surprising amount of influence, and he and people around him, and his company, has caused so much shit. Like it's stuff not as bad as, say Cosmodore or MiniLadd or Anton, but there has been some bad shit, however the sheer *amount* of what they have done basically completely under the radar, it deserves to be talked about.
    Even if this is just about Sonic, it's still something, at the very least. I just wish more people would publicly call out Arin and bring into question stuff he's done, Game Grumps has done, and actually put a spotlight on it. Stuff like DD, like his sheer hypocrisy, that Summer "garage sale" that was shut down, like his exploitation of artists, or his current editor, Ben, who's still employed by him after the stunts he's done.

    • @ImmaLittlePip
      @ImmaLittlePip 3 роки тому +14

      The problem is any time someone does.talk about game grumps drama their rabid fanboys dislike bomb the video without watching it and then leave comments calling the person a hater or anti semetic
      It's because gg is still a big channel and the only one who calls them out on their bs or at least Arins bs are the small guys

    • @FireroseNekowolf
      @FireroseNekowolf 3 роки тому +8

      @@ImmaLittlePip Right? Seen it happen again and again. Or they just straight up dismiss everything and pretend all of it is a "over reaction" because of some nonsense like "well they're comedy UA-cam channel." That doesn't even mean anything.

    • @TheChildofAuraReborn
      @TheChildofAuraReborn 3 роки тому +15

      I was mad after he publicly dragged one of his fans for making a "Dammit Ross" joke (something they profited off of), and the same fan went onto a stream, donated money, and apologized. He STILL tore into her and said "I can do it because he's my friend uwu". How rude do you have to be to receive money from a donation and an apology, and then you pretend to give a morally righteous lecture?
      I mean I'm mad about a LOT of stuff but he's a toxic guy.

    • @FireroseNekowolf
      @FireroseNekowolf 3 роки тому +11

      @@TheChildofAuraReborn Ah yeah, that was during the first Skyward Sword stream. She was harassed by the Lovelies to the point she left Twitter, iirc.

    • @TheChildofAuraReborn
      @TheChildofAuraReborn 3 роки тому +11

      @@FireroseNekowolf Oh great, now I'm even MORE pissed.
      This is how I know their "loving tolerating" personality is a facade. You don't fucking berate someone after they've apologized, ESPECIALLY WHEN THEY DONATE MONEY TO YOU. It's like they're obsessed more with their image than they are actually treating someone like a fucking human being.
      I pray she's okay, wherever she is.

  • @kingbash6466
    @kingbash6466 3 роки тому +556

    Literally every video game critic: Sonic had a very rough transition into 3D.
    Sonic fans: ALRIGHT I GET IT!!!

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +84

      Critics: No, we'll continue to say it, because it's totally true, right?

    • @icantstopsparkling7450
      @icantstopsparkling7450 3 роки тому +64

      It's so boring. Do these guys not realize that everyone- especially Sonic fans- are PAINFULLY AWARE of how bad Sonic is?

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +18

      @@icantstopsparkling7450 wut

    • @funsies8107
      @funsies8107 3 роки тому +34

      @@icantstopsparkling7450 what are you? IGN?
      Also it's "I can't stop Twinkling"

    • @Eminster
      @Eminster 3 роки тому +9

      @@icantstopsparkling7450 lol try again troll

  • @commonsense5199
    @commonsense5199 3 роки тому +190

    Arin Hanson: all sonic games are bad
    Sonic Twitter gave Arin cupcakes.

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +35

      The guy in charge of the account was a massive Game Grumps fan.

    • @succubastard1019
      @succubastard1019 3 роки тому +32

      Sega is infamous for sucking the dick of people who make fun of them to make it look like they are "learning from their mistakes".

    • @livinglie5598
      @livinglie5598 3 роки тому +10

      @@succubastard1019 that would be Aaron Webber

    • @hideofreakingkojima5457
      @hideofreakingkojima5457 3 роки тому +6

      SEGA: Let's invite him to sing "I'm Big the Cat" for Sonic Team Racing
      Me: Do you have no shame?! Where is your pride, SEGA!?

    • @thrasher9534
      @thrasher9534 2 роки тому +1

      @@succubastard1019 Sega of Japan don't care about the game grumps fool

  • @lordquastheonly
    @lordquastheonly 3 роки тому +88

    This is why i like somecallmejohnnys reviews due to him not overreacting to slight issues in games

  • @JetblackJay
    @JetblackJay 3 роки тому +175

    You forgot when arin looked for a glitch in sonic deliberately and got called out

    • @biscoitomolhado3641
      @biscoitomolhado3641 3 роки тому +3

      Yeah he kinda messed up

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +38

      @@biscoitomolhado3641 Messed up? Feels like that was planned.

    • @juliantorres3495
      @juliantorres3495 3 роки тому +14

      If you’re talking about sonic adventure dx then I know what you’re talking about. But at the same time I also got the glitch as a kid a never knew why. I thought that the game somehow had a game breaking bug. But that didn’t stop my enjoyment sonic adventure even if it’s not the “right” version to play

    • @ChiefMedicPururu
      @ChiefMedicPururu 3 роки тому +2

      @@juliantorres3495 Still, if you get the Steam version and use mods, it's the best way of playing it.

    • @juliantorres3495
      @juliantorres3495 3 роки тому +1

      @@ChiefMedicPururu well you see I played the GameCube version this was before I had a pc to play the game with mods. So I’m kinda talking on the hardware it was released in.