It's a shame that constitutionalism is considered "conservative." Interpreting the Constitution as in its original meaning isn't conservative or liberal. It's originalism and textualism.
Him and Milton Freidman are the two greatest exponents in the popular world of Conservative and libertarian ideas Such genius doesn't come asking too often
let me guess..... was his death suspicious? maybe the old doorknob sexual thing, thermite inspired hole under the drivers seat, double gunshot suicide or similar???? just wondering?
A true intellectual giant. I believe that the late Justice Scalia was probably one of the best minds to serve on the court in recent history, if not THE best.
Here the Senator embarrassed herself. The Justice merely pointed out the most basic 8th grade civics lesson: that while the 14th applies to both sexes, the 14th amendment applies to government discrimination as do all the Amendments, limitations on government action; not private action.
When life is so good that we fight over public toilets. This is like the line from The Dark Night Returns: "Soon you will have us chasing down overdue books "
the fact that people get angry about gridlock blows my mind....the federal government only does 1 of 2 things: they are either expanding their power/complicating the laws more, or theyre in gridlock and if i had it my way id prefer them to be in gridlock for the rest of time
I would be interested to hear if anyone out there disagrees with him for reasons other than not supporting their policy. Scalia is sound in logic and communicates it very well. Follows the law as it should be. The epitome of Judgeship
I am what one might call a progressive liberal, however I really appreciate his view and intellect, even if I don’t agree with it completely. A conservative genius that can’t be replicated. Hope he is resting peacefully.
Only a true judge would avoid pontificating by espousing his own views regarding whether something should be illegal or not. Scalia was one of the greatest judges because he judged cases in accordance with the constitution and the views that aren’t explicitly stated within it but nevertheless undergird its principles.
It’s interesting to think Scalia would have supported NFL player’s right to kneel during the national anthem. He would disagree with their method but he would never deny them their right. That’s what happens when you have a man of principle. I don’t agree with him on a lot of things. But you can see how someone like Ginsburg could be such good friends with him. They really are the best among us.
@@fernie51296 a private party can, and always has had, the ability to fire someone for the words that come out of their mouth or their actions. The first amendment does not mean you cannot be fired for protesting. That is crazy talk.
Antonin Scalia was an exceptional mind that I appreciated. Although, he might not have agreed or liked a certain thing written in the US Constitution, he saw that the value of it was in the text and that the law should be bound in the text and context in which it was written.
He had absolutely no understanding of the role of money in politics. Literally none. It’s nice to decide all these cases playing judge and all but the oligarchs ultimately rule. And that’s in at least small part due to him.
Worth remembering that it is still the case that the most common symptom of coronary disease is sudden death. You can appear totally healthy then 'boom', gone. Often the same is true with stroke. Clearly he had risk factors, as we all do, that in his case included chronically overweight/obese and a punishing work schedule. I have no idea about his family history and what that might also tell us; has he a heritage of 'early' deaths in male relatives over generations, for example? I'm not accusing YOU of doing it, but so many of the "he was murdered" crowd seem to have no idea about just how common it is for such deaths to occur; they 'need' it to be a murder as they appear to see everything in wildly partisan terms. They also seem to forget that his closest personal friend was Justice Ginsburg. In other words, he certainly didn't adopt wildly partisan views the way many of the "he was murdered" crowd clearly do. My guess is they project their own political extremes into a situation in which the most likely explanation has nothing to do with politics. Cheers
He was visited by Obama two days later, he is dead... No autopsy and then cremated. ..An catholic italian guy. ..Yeah ok! ! He was going against Obama saying that Obama care is a violation people's constitutional rights. .. Then once Obama is not president it's found unconstitutional in federal court.. I think he was murdered.
It's too interesting that Feinstein has to read from her material to cite provisions of the Constitution, considering how most dumb truck drivers like myself can cite the Fourteenth Amendment without even looking at it.
And the fact that she is a United States Senator sitting on the JUDICIARY committee. I'd be memorizing the constitution 20x over if I sat on that committee whether neccessary or not, you look like a moron stumbling as you question the brightest Attorney's this country has.
Wow...Scalia crushed Feinstein. Even Breyer agrees, and he's as far left on the court as we have right now. I'm on the "living constitution" side (cultures and civilizations must evolve to progress through the times they exist in, not on historical notions), but Scalia was still a very brilliant man.
luis manuel they could. Pretty sure one did. But generally they won't. They like being outside of politics and get guaranteed life terms. More common was becoming a justice after being President (Taft)
Yes, and it's happened before. They would have to resign I'm sure, but yes, there's nothing stopping them from running. There are multiple examples of this, such as Salmon P. Chase and William O. Douglas, but no Justice has ever made it past the primaries.
Even with abortion I think most women would want to keep the child I mean in my belief I think its best if its rape incest or could affect the health of the mother I can see that but sometimes the health of the mother they might have the kid too.
My opinion if Scalia was around today he would have told Clinton, Obama, Harris, Durbin, Feinstein, and Others all where to get off. If he saw what they were doing to Kavanaugh.
11:45, Piers Morgan talking as though abortion was unknown in the 18th century. It is said Benjamin Franklin wrote about a technique to induce abortion, known at the time. Abortifacients existed in the ancient world, so the concept was hardly unknown to the framers of the Constitution. Abortion was mentioned in the classic Hippocratic Oath. The historical dispute can be whether Hippocrates opposed all abortion, or opposed using a pessary to induce abortion. As in, other techniques might be OK.
Citizens united stance makes no sense by his own standards. More money in politics =/= representation of free speech.... therefore my money says prostitution should be legal, and hiring of hitmen is justifiable, and my money says I shouldn’t be imprisoned for a violent crime. Et cetera ... you clearly see how this is problematic in this defense.
HES RIGHT!!! A WOMAN IS A PERSON!!! YES THEY ARE!!! ABOLUTELY!!! BUT WE ARE EQUAL IN THE OPPORTUNITIES WE ARE GIVEN BUT IF PEOPLE GIVE YOU MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND SOMEONE ACTS ON IT AND DOES A GOOD JOB THEN THAT PERSON MAY HAVE A BETTER LIFE WOMAN CAN DO IT TO BUT WE HAVE TO PROOVE IT!!! If women want to be as strong as men work as hard as them DO I THINK WOMEN CAN YES I THINK SO BUT ITS THEIR CHOICE IF NOT THEN THATS ON THEM!!! YEAH I HAVE NEVER BURNED THE STARS AND STRIPES!!!
I think freedom of speech with regards to the flag requires more analysis, with each situation, circumstance and time in history. During the 1960's desecration of the United States Flag was not allowed. It is certainly more than financial as well as more than a superfluous pretense at loyalty. A Public and freedom of speech allowing access by media for the public to know, but what is the answer in the U.S. when the public domain is everywhere observing and the media is excessively intrusive in the individuals life, yet there is no attempt to give the individual their freedom of speech separate from those in that public domain and those using media rights...
These idiotic interviewers are embarrassing. I would be extremely intimidated by Scalia but I would try to do my homework and try to bring something to the table.
Scalia was a titan among infants when he sat on the court. A truly great man who is missed terribly by all who value freedom.
Such a shame we’ve lost such staunch constitutional proponent.
Says hes pro-life. dies anyway
It's a shame that constitutionalism is considered "conservative." Interpreting the Constitution as in its original meaning isn't conservative or liberal. It's originalism and textualism.
Sandra Long Yes sandra but the court has long been driven by pure idealogy. The abundance of 5 to 4 decisions make this unfortunate fact true....
HE WAS MURDERED
Interesting… and why was he murdered?
Him and Milton Freidman are the two greatest exponents in the popular world of Conservative and libertarian ideas
Such genius doesn't come asking too often
Kayman Fani why he was murdered. Our way of life is under attack.
And Thomas Sowell, who joined Freidman many times,in destroying the progressive, socialist, Marxists promoters.
@@markhughes2386 Agreed Mark, Sowell is absolutely fantastic as well
I’d have to disagree. Friedrich Hayek was the best.
A BRIT TRYING TO ARGUE THE CONSTITUTION WITH A SUPREME COURT JUSTICE... *LMFAO!!*
And not just any justice. Friggin scalia. Morgan is a pompous ass
I really miss this guy! Such a brilliant mind. A constitutionalist.
I’m tired of the judicial activism that’s forced upon us now.
We were blessed with this man.
Antonin Scalia is the wise, didactic grandfather or uncle we all wish we had.
He's an ugly pig though
let me guess..... was his death suspicious? maybe the old doorknob sexual thing, thermite inspired hole under the drivers seat, double gunshot suicide or similar???? just wondering?
Holy fuck, you really think that? The "We all" in your group is a very very specific and tiny constituency.
God I miss Justice Scalia. Feinstein trying to go brain vs brain with Scalia is like a toddler trying to box Mike Tyson.
Piers Morgan... how exceptionally unable to deal with Scalia's rational argument. Appalling.
Matthew Smith pies you mean😂😂
Morgan doesn’t possess the tools to have an effective and intelligent conversation with Justice Scalia.
too english I suppose and not American enough!
A true intellectual giant.
I believe that the late Justice Scalia was probably one of the best minds to serve on the court in recent history, if not THE best.
This is excellent and bittersweet. Justice Scalia was brilliant.
We are reminded why Piers Morgan was an intellectual lightweight.
Antonin Scalia was a great man. Is a great man.
What a loss to this country.
What an amazing human being and
Excellent example of intelligent thought
involving just Law for everyone.
You are missed Judge Scalia ❤🙏
Its a rare pleasure to listen to intelligence, regardless of whether with his content.
The fake "generic european accent" when he said "gridlock" was worth a million.
He was a brilliant man worthy of our honest respect.
Here the Senator embarrassed herself. The Justice merely pointed out the most basic 8th grade civics lesson: that while the 14th applies to both sexes, the 14th amendment applies to government discrimination as do all the Amendments, limitations on government action; not private action.
When life is so good that we fight over public toilets.
This is like the line from The Dark Night Returns: "Soon you will have us chasing down overdue books
"
"The 14th Amendment is simple."
t. Someone who immediately confuses the meaning of the 14th Amendment
What an incredible patriot Justice Scalia was. Rest In Peace your honor.
He was assassinated
the fact that people get angry about gridlock blows my mind....the federal government only does 1 of 2 things: they are either expanding their power/complicating the laws more, or theyre in gridlock and if i had it my way id prefer them to be in gridlock for the rest of time
I would be interested to hear if anyone out there disagrees with him for reasons other than not supporting their policy.
Scalia is sound in logic and communicates it very well. Follows the law as it should be. The epitome of Judgeship
Recall that Limbaugh said if he had to pick someone else's brain to have, that brain would be Antonin Scalia's . This guy was brilliant .
Wow, do I miss this guy.
Gina Sigillito
Truly, truly.
I am what one might call a progressive liberal, however I really appreciate his view and intellect, even if I don’t agree with it completely. A conservative genius that can’t be replicated. Hope he is resting peacefully.
A very wise, educated, and patriotic man. RIP Nino...
Piers Morgan arguing with Scalia is like arguing with a child that can't read over what the label on the box says.
This channel is underrated. It has the best compilations on UA-cam.
Piers Morgan sounds like such an amateur when talking about the Constitution.
He's a Brit, of course he wouldn't understand freedom from Government.
Did you hear Megan Kelly talking to Putin? It was triggering to the left. She looked like a child
He certainly hates our Second Amendment.
I miss him so much.
So glad George Mason's Law School was named after him despite fervent opposition from self-egrandising left-leaning intellectuals.
"Learn to love the gridlock.." Amen.
Only a true judge would avoid pontificating by espousing his own views regarding whether something should be illegal or not. Scalia was one of the greatest judges because he judged cases in accordance with the constitution and the views that aren’t explicitly stated within it but nevertheless undergird its principles.
It’s interesting to think Scalia would have supported NFL player’s right to kneel during the national anthem. He would disagree with their method but he would never deny them their right. That’s what happens when you have a man of principle. I don’t agree with him on a lot of things. But you can see how someone like Ginsburg could be such good friends with him. They really are the best among us.
I hope you realize Scalia would also be okay with trump saying that the players protesting should be fired
Patrick Carey he’s support his right to say it, but not with it actually being done. You can’t punish people for exercising their free rights
@@fernie51296 where's the punishment? the nfl that's totally different because they work for a company you are under contract.
@@fernie51296 a private party can, and always has had, the ability to fire someone for the words that come out of their mouth or their actions. The first amendment does not mean you cannot be fired for protesting. That is crazy talk.
From 18:40 to the end of the video, when he mentions The Federalist. Absolutely beautifully put, Justice Scalia.
Truly a brilliant mind.
Rest in peace good sir.
2:00; the guy who says “yes” after Scalia cracks me up.
SCALIA WAS MURDERED !!!!!
she called him mr.justice
Brilliant Man
That 60 minutes segment will come in handy.
Justice Scalia was a very good man and judge....
Antonin Scalia was an exceptional mind that I appreciated. Although, he might not have agreed or liked a certain thing written in the US Constitution, he saw that the value of it was in the text and that the law should be bound in the text and context in which it was written.
To all those who watch Better Call Saul, justice Scalia eerily reminds me of Chuck Mcgill.
He had absolutely no understanding of the role of money in politics. Literally none. It’s nice to decide all these cases playing judge and all but the oligarchs ultimately rule. And that’s in at least small part due to him.
God bless this man.
Brilliant mind!!!!
Brian Lamb one of few the Justice’s peers.
I'm not convinced he wasn't murdered, his personal physician said he was in good health then out of nowhere dies in his sleep...yea ok
Worth remembering that it is still the case that the most common symptom of coronary disease is sudden death. You can appear totally healthy then 'boom', gone. Often the same is true with stroke.
Clearly he had risk factors, as we all do, that in his case included chronically overweight/obese and a punishing work schedule. I have no idea about his family history and what that might also tell us; has he a heritage of 'early' deaths in male relatives over generations, for example?
I'm not accusing YOU of doing it, but so many of the "he was murdered" crowd seem to have no idea about just how common it is for such deaths to occur; they 'need' it to be a murder as they appear to see everything in wildly partisan terms.
They also seem to forget that his closest personal friend was Justice Ginsburg. In other words, he certainly didn't adopt wildly partisan views the way many of the "he was murdered" crowd clearly do. My guess is they project their own political extremes into a situation in which the most likely explanation has nothing to do with politics.
Cheers
Look at the place he died also. Very strange
He was visited by Obama two days later, he is dead... No autopsy and then cremated. ..An catholic italian guy. ..Yeah ok! ! He was going against Obama saying that Obama care is a violation people's constitutional rights. .. Then once Obama is not president it's found unconstitutional in federal court.. I think he was murdered.
It's too interesting that Feinstein has to read from her material to cite provisions of the Constitution, considering how most dumb truck drivers like myself can cite the Fourteenth Amendment without even looking at it.
And the fact that she is a United States Senator sitting on the JUDICIARY committee. I'd be memorizing the constitution 20x over if I sat on that committee whether neccessary or not, you look like a moron stumbling as you question the brightest Attorney's this country has.
You are smarter than most of the senate
JazzTruckin she shouldn’t have trusted the inadequate law review of her clerks.
Brilliant and reasonable mind. RIP Sir.
He stood in their way so they killed him.
No wonder he was wacked, he makes all the other justices look like idiots
A pillow over his head was worse than any banana peel.
Picking an intellectual fight with Scalia. Let’s see how this end. 😂😂
This guy loves the gridlock
What a wonderful justice.
Wow...Scalia crushed Feinstein. Even Breyer agrees, and he's as far left on the court as we have right now.
I'm on the "living constitution" side (cultures and civilizations must evolve to progress through the times they exist in, not on historical notions), but Scalia was still a very brilliant man.
Executive vs Legislative vs Judicial is a feature, not a bug.
i love this man his wise and maculate
what a great man
I’m fairly progressive, but I loved watching him speak.
One of the last great defenders of the constitution
8:10 great comments on the death penalty
The Laws of Physics. Explains the Edits.
Diane Feinstein trying to outsmart Scalia on the Constitution? What was she thinking?
🥀Held in the highest regard🎩
Piers Morgan a powerful wealthy entertainer; still embarrassed for him talking to the Justice.
This man was murdered
" We have gone off the rails "
Can a judge of the Supreme Court run for President?
luis manuel they could. Pretty sure one did. But generally they won't. They like being outside of politics and get guaranteed life terms. More common was becoming a justice after being President (Taft)
Yes, and it's happened before. They would have to resign I'm sure, but yes, there's nothing stopping them from running.
There are multiple examples of this, such as Salmon P. Chase and William O. Douglas, but no Justice has ever made it past the primaries.
luis manuel yes they can run
Not worth it. Lifetime position on the judicial branch, and salary for life beyond 65, whether you retire or not.
@@MalloryMinerva What about Charles Evan Hughes?
0:51 "You know where I am going." Yes he did know, to bad you did not.
Highest Court. What was wrong on This day in history that his speech changes? Years ago.
I am grateful that Neil gorsuch replaced him but he is no Antonin Scalia
"BICAMERALISM OR FIGHT!"
"The premise of democracy is that the people are intelligent"
Yeah, unfortunately people prove this false with astonishing frequency
Best justice
Even with abortion I think most women would want to keep the child I mean in my belief I think its best if its rape incest or could affect the health of the mother I can see that but sometimes the health of the mother they might have the kid too.
My opinion if Scalia was around today he would have told Clinton, Obama, Harris, Durbin, Feinstein, and Others all where to get off. If he saw what they were doing to Kavanaugh.
Pieaaace Mawwwwwgunn
11:45, Piers Morgan talking as though abortion was unknown in the 18th century. It is said Benjamin Franklin wrote about a technique to induce abortion, known at the time.
Abortifacients existed in the ancient world, so the concept was hardly unknown to the framers of the Constitution.
Abortion was mentioned in the classic Hippocratic Oath. The historical dispute can be whether Hippocrates opposed all abortion, or opposed using a pessary to induce abortion.
As in, other techniques might be OK.
Citizens united stance makes no sense by his own standards.
More money in politics =/= representation of free speech.... therefore my money says prostitution should be legal, and hiring of hitmen is justifiable, and my money says I shouldn’t be imprisoned for a violent crime. Et cetera ... you clearly see how this is problematic in this defense.
Umm.. hiring people for sex is different from your business being allowed to express support/disdain in speech for a political candidate.
Should women be in charge of what they think their destiny is YES they should but like I said earlier you must prove it!
Sometimes not always but Men can be stronger than women but the other way too at least I think so!!!
HES RIGHT!!! A WOMAN IS A PERSON!!! YES THEY ARE!!! ABOLUTELY!!! BUT WE ARE EQUAL IN THE OPPORTUNITIES WE ARE GIVEN BUT IF PEOPLE GIVE YOU MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND SOMEONE ACTS ON IT AND DOES A GOOD JOB THEN THAT PERSON MAY HAVE A BETTER LIFE WOMAN CAN DO IT TO BUT WE HAVE TO PROOVE IT!!! If women want to be as strong as men work as hard as them DO I THINK WOMEN CAN YES I THINK SO BUT ITS THEIR CHOICE IF NOT THEN THATS ON THEM!!! YEAH I HAVE NEVER BURNED THE STARS AND STRIPES!!!
hahahah I see I see what you mean feinstein
I think freedom of speech with regards to the flag requires more analysis, with each situation, circumstance and time in history. During the 1960's desecration of the United States Flag was not allowed. It is certainly more than financial as well as more than a superfluous pretense at loyalty. A Public and freedom of speech allowing access by media for the public to know, but what is the answer in the U.S. when the public domain is everywhere observing and the media is excessively intrusive in the individuals life, yet there is no attempt to give the individual their freedom of speech separate from those in that public domain and those using media rights...
And that's why this loyal constitutionalist suicides him self by suffocate..
no violation of the PEOPLE rights WO DUE PROCESS...! RED FLAG LAWS...!
2:07-2:10 LMAO!
This was in the Reagan era? Sen. Feinstein looked old then.
eminent domain?
These idiotic interviewers are embarrassing. I would be extremely intimidated by Scalia but I would try to do my homework and try to bring something to the table.
Kavanaugh is being guided by individuals like Scalia😇😍
i will tell you what it means today.because im the only one that can interpret it. ill tell you what the constitution means from how i interpret it
IS FEINSTEIN STILL WASTING OXYGEN?
10:15
scalia's "greatness" is negated by the fact that he thought the devil was a real person