The Best Category, they're all just really good. Tough choice but Simon did the right thing, none like few other judges decisions. Hopely the wild card goes to Aidan Talia or Jack & Joel
So happy I was proved wrong with the new girl band, thought the fact they were put together would give them an edge but really sad for lemonade, they are good enough for the lives. I would have picked them ahead of the Price brothers. Good line up for the groups.
Never thought the groups will be this strong this year. I have same list as Simon... They’re all likeable, current and have talents... Though, I too, love Jack and Joel... How I wish there will be a wild card for every category...
Mario Enumerables I thought the same too. Simon made really good choices with the groups, but I wish Jack and Joel would have a spot in it as well. There's a wildcard for each category though! So they will add 4 contestants to the current 12. Let's hope J&J come back as a wildcard.
Simon is the only judge that seems to get his category right! He took the same 3 I would've. Sharon was mad letting Alisah go home and Nicole was out of her mind to let the oldest black girl leave just cuz she her goofed her lyrics for a minute.
I think I would like Rak Su more if they lost the guy with the beard. He doesn't sing and only does awkward shuffling each performance. Maybe I'm being harsh but I feel like he's holding them back a bit.
I agree so much because he doesn't sing and I'm late so this year in 2018 when they came to perform there song I want you to freak he didn't sing once even when it was his verse everyone was like sing
Darn Anthony, I noticed you are almost at 1 million subscribers. So... here's a pre-congratulation. I'm thinking you'll hit that number in the next few weeks, easy. Thanks for all your hard work on this channel.
Nobody is interested this crap anymore. Lemonade is out, New Girl Band is out, Scarlett is out, Alisah is out, Georgina is out, and Anthony is out. Except Kevin and Rai-Elle, all others have nothing special or interesting. And what those other Finalist has the common ? They sounds like the ordinary radio-voices, each personality are kind of artificial products, nothing passion except hunger of money and celebrity, boring non-talent low-going performances. No more of this shit.
The new girl group were not very good. There was just a really detached and tacky feel about them. Maybe it was their tacky clothes, over the top make-up and silly lip fillers. Simon was right to boot them. The Cutkelvins, ( I have a feeling their name may be changed to something else at some point) will be in the top three of the live shows. They may just take the win.
i dont get it so he hated on J&J ( theyre not my fav) and then put the horrible busker boys through? one screams when he sings and the other one stands and smiles like a dork playing the guitar. i agree with his other two though!
Serbian G exactly my thoughts, he has never been like that before. Especially when telling “The new girl band” his decision. I mean he just uttered it without showing any emotion. It sounded almost cruel to be honest, but he also acted like that around other groups that didn’t make it through... I mean, everyone’s used to how assertive he is, but there’s a difference between that and just being straight up heartless. Seems like he is going back to his old bad manners to me. 😓🤔
Enrico Martin wtf. they were individuals not a group so yea im happy that people who really deserved it got through. the ”new girl band” would have not been a band after xfactor.
public should try to bring back lemonade. The two college dudes would shine as youtube cover stars, but simon was dead on when he said he didn't see much recording artist potential in them.
The Year that Simon wont Win. come on this group category is kind of a joke, CutKelvins cant sing, the girls is the only actually one can sing. then the brothers are okay and this Rak-Su only 2 can sing and they are not even that hot as they make look like. We all know by the History of this show that groups put together always end up well. Little Mix, One Direction and 5Harmony are exemples. now why not give a chance for these girls when we can see that there are so much more talent and potential to be unfished. I Always been a fan of Simon's decisions but this is the first yr where am NOT rooting for him. My only home is if Alyssa come back. otherwise for the first yr ever I wont be watching The X Factor UK. Tchau!
Eh...he should've put though Lemonade instead of the average teeny bop singers Sean and Connor. Their voices are not that good...but they are cute, teenage boys and we all know the main demographic that votes in this show...teenage girls.
Imma say that Simon went for all the safe choices imo. I liked all the acts that didn't get in way more than the ones that did. But yet again, I'm no Simon Cowell so meh
They will become boring during the live show. They keep doing the same thing over & over, one sing the other the beatbox thing. You won't notice that now but in 3rd week or the 4th it would be so obvious..
Imagine him being depressed or something and commiting suicide after your comment. We don't need negative people like you, Enrico Martin, who tell people to "go die".
julio escareño yeah exactly, they made it big but the market for groups like these are saturated now. Nobody wants another group. It's so much harder to connect with groups. I've just never been fond of this category.
ago HI Sharon Osbourne I hope you read this . I will educate you X factor means not to see base on physical looks but internal genuine beauty of voice and purpose this X factor symbolize of respect of uniqueness, acceptance, fairness, and real justice for what we say a real WIN is a people VOTES and not only base on your JUDGE this is a combinations of nations decision then I hope you feel good in your heart for your real decision to the top 3 you choose. We respect but I hope you know in your heart who is a real WIN? thank you.
I love the fact that simon makes it quick and not dramatic😂
Diana Rawks True you can't cry in front of Simon's face 😂😁Lol
Agree... I love his expression everytime he says NO.. He wink his eyes with his lips and tilted head🤣🤣🤣🙄🙄😏😏
The Best Category, they're all just really good. Tough choice but Simon did the right thing, none like few other judges decisions.
Hopely the wild card goes to Aidan Talia or Jack & Joel
There will be a wildcard for each category
I might be an Irish girl, but I still wish Jack and Joel went through over the Price brothers.
i'm sad for lemonade, they were so talented. hopefully they get the wildcard!
Too bad it was given to the filipino girl
Omggg yesss, exacatly what I wanted...Simon has a killer line up!
So happy I was proved wrong with the new girl band, thought the fact they were put together would give them an edge but really sad for lemonade, they are good enough for the lives. I would have picked them ahead of the Price brothers. Good line up for the groups.
Totally agree
I completely agree, Why Lemonade was left out ?
Never thought the groups will be this strong this year. I have same list as Simon... They’re all likeable, current and have talents... Though, I too, love Jack and Joel... How I wish there will be a wild card for every category...
Mario Enumerables I thought the same too. Simon made really good choices with the groups, but I wish Jack and Joel would have a spot in it as well. There's a wildcard for each category though! So they will add 4 contestants to the current 12. Let's hope J&J come back as a wildcard.
Kiiara05 yay!! J&J as wildcard!! 🙏🏻
Simon is the only judge that seems to get his category right! He took the same 3 I would've. Sharon was mad letting Alisah go home and Nicole was out of her mind to let the oldest black girl leave just cuz she her goofed her lyrics for a minute.
I think I would like Rak Su more if they lost the guy with the beard. He doesn't sing and only does awkward shuffling each performance. Maybe I'm being harsh but I feel like he's holding them back a bit.
He did the choreo, music and beatboxes.
He's the brain, if you get rid of him, not sure you'd be that fond of them any more
I agree so much because he doesn't sing and I'm late so this year in 2018 when they came to perform there song I want you to freak he didn't sing once even when it was his verse everyone was like sing
I agree with Simon's decision. They are my Top 3 as well.
LEMONADE IS SO GOOD!! They better get the wildcard!
Simon really know how to make money.
From all the groups that will go to the live shows, there is only one girl.
Happiest I’ve ever been with Simon’s choices!!
Jack & Joel for the wild card please !
i want jack and joel back theyre way better than some of the ppl who got thru ugh. guys pls vote for them as wildcard!!!!
Darn Anthony, I noticed you are almost at 1 million subscribers. So... here's a pre-congratulation. I'm thinking you'll hit that number in the next few weeks, easy. Thanks for all your hard work on this channel.
Nobody is interested this crap anymore. Lemonade is out, New Girl Band is out, Scarlett is out, Alisah is out, Georgina is out, and Anthony is out.
Except Kevin and Rai-Elle, all others have nothing special or interesting.
And what those other Finalist has the common ? They sounds like the ordinary radio-voices, each personality are kind of artificial products, nothing passion except hunger of money and celebrity, boring non-talent low-going performances. No more of this shit.
Laodicea you're wrong about Holly Tandy . Her voice is pure gold
Rak Su
Holly have a really good voice but for me her performance is too cold, but that's only my opinion
ohhh we really need a wildcard here, i just want jack and joel back please!
It will be a wildcard in each category
ooh in each category? Yay, excited for this!
I'm not even complaining at his choices! No brainer! Good job Simon!
I can't believe my top 3 made it to the live shows!
Same here
Same! Grace Davies, Sean and Connor, and Kevin Davy for me
Simon really knows what we want..
Same! I was really torn between rack-su and lemonade though.
Same
The final 3 groups shoulda been
1. New Girl Band
2. Rak - Su
3. The Cutklevins
Nah I think it’s should’ve been Lemonade rak su and cutkelvins
I would have kept New Girl Band, Rak-Su and the Cutkleins
I would replace new girl band with lemonade tbh
I really love all the groups💕 they are all amazing!!
Simon made the best decision, the brothers are likable yet both can surprise you everytime , the CutKelvins & Rak-Su are quit unique..
Omg I really would have picked the lemonade grp ohh no...they're gud
I think Rak Su could probably win the show this season
And they did I knew they were winning from the start as well lol
My picks would have been
•The CutKelvins
•Lemonade
•Rak-Su
Catherine Flores RIGHT
Catherine Flores well thats why ye ain't judges ! Sean and conor for the win wooooooo
Totally agree
Mine toooooo
Mine is the same as Simon's
The new girl group were not very good. There was just a really detached and tacky feel about them. Maybe it was their tacky clothes, over the top make-up and silly lip fillers. Simon was right to boot them. The Cutkelvins,
( I have a feeling their name may be changed to something else at some point) will be in the top three of the live shows. They may just take the win.
Simon made a good choice, happy he did
the groups, holly, and spencer are the best i can't wait for live shows
i dont get it so he hated on J&J ( theyre not my fav) and then put the horrible busker boys through? one screams when he sings and the other one stands and smiles like a dork playing the guitar. i agree with his other two though!
Nooo way. Lemonade deserved to go through. Do not like the decision at all
hi anthony
Just pleased Rak Su are through. Great guys
Why is Simon so cold to those that did not make it. Shoukd have hugged them all!
Serbian G exactly my thoughts, he has never been like that before. Especially when telling “The new girl band” his decision. I mean he just uttered it without showing any emotion. It sounded almost cruel to be honest, but he also acted like that around other groups that didn’t make it through... I mean, everyone’s used to how assertive he is, but there’s a difference between that and just being straight up heartless. Seems like he is going back to his old bad manners to me. 😓🤔
I'm my mind the Final 2 acts will be the Cutkelvins and Holly!
My favorite Group:Rak-Su
My favorite Girl:Rai-Elle
My favorite Over:Kevin Davy
My favorite Boy:Sam Black
ohhh i’m so happy that the new girl group didn’t make through!!!!
carnivalfobia nice positivity u spread there. the world need more people with positivity like u
Enrico Martin wtf. they were individuals not a group so yea im happy that people who really deserved it got through. the ”new girl band” would have not been a band after xfactor.
So true
@@carnivalfobia at least they tried
How can you say no to Sean and Conor? Good job Simon.
X FAVORITE FACTOR 2017
public should try to bring back lemonade. The two college dudes would shine as youtube cover stars, but simon was dead on when he said he didn't see much recording artist potential in them.
I think Simon already knows that the public is going to bring back Jack & Joel, that's why he gave Sean and Connor another chance
If I were Simon I would choose New Girl, Rak-Su and Lemonade
On "SIMON" and THE GROUPS.....kinda messed up because he said THE NEW GIRL GROUP didn't work out. But Simon created that Girl Group. 🤷♀️🤦♀️😬🤧
Yes! Grace Davies, Sean and Connor, and Kevin Davy my faves all in top three
The Year that Simon wont Win. come on this group category is kind of a joke, CutKelvins cant sing, the girls is the only actually one can sing. then the brothers are okay and this Rak-Su only 2 can sing and they are not even that hot as they make look like. We all know by the History of this show that groups put together always end up well. Little Mix, One Direction and 5Harmony are exemples. now why not give a chance for these girls when we can see that there are so much more talent and potential to be unfished. I Always been a fan of Simon's decisions but this is the first yr where am NOT rooting for him. My only home is if Alyssa come back. otherwise for the first yr ever I wont be watching The X Factor UK. Tchau!
I feel really bad for lemonade they are really amazing but it's good
Eh...he should've put though Lemonade instead of the average teeny bop singers Sean and Connor. Their voices are not that good...but they are cute, teenage boys and we all know the main demographic that votes in this show...teenage girls.
I really liked the new girl band, wish they would've made it through
6:42 Miles fell in Love with the girl that spoke from Lemonade 😍😘
Simon made the best decisions out of any judge. All three choices are spot-on perfect.
I think the winner gonna be from this group
is Simon sexist not one girl group went through and girl groups do better the boy groups on he radio these days
100% agree with the decisions, great!
Lmao the bros fot through wtf. It was supposed to be the guys, cutkelvins and lemonade.
If only JBK were half Brits.... maybe they got the chance.....
I hope all participants leave xfactor. unfair judges' decision
Imma say that Simon went for all the safe choices imo. I liked all the acts that didn't get in way more than the ones that did. But yet again, I'm no Simon Cowell so meh
Good choices Simon, for me you are right.
Cutkelvins have a good look but I really, really don't see it. I hate the entire category honestly
Great choice simon.. well done..
Unsted of Shawn and his brother lemonade should have made it thru Simon you made a bad disgin
thats who I would have picked tho you could argue about a girl group and the two brothers
I would choose raksu, lemonade and cut kelvins
Well there ratings are obviously gonna go down
NO. I wanted lemonade through
Lemonade should’ve won..
Lemonade is so STRONG 😕
jbk was better than them. Its sad they lost to them
Cringe the nude pink velvet T-shirt
It was better without ash
WHAT ABOUT LEMONADE THOUGH?!?!?!?!? They were soooo good! I wish they would have gone to the live shows
I never liked lemonade
Interesting.
Finally a judge who doesn't torture the contestants! Straight to the point, unlike Granny O. Appreciate that.
Saimen..... Bravo
I've never seen what they see in CutKelvins, I know J&J can sell records tbh
SAME
They will become boring during the live show. They keep doing the same thing over & over, one sing the other the beatbox thing. You won't notice that now but in 3rd week or the 4th it would be so obvious..
The best choice.Simon:10/10
How the hell did Sean and Connor make it through? They sound like whiney Ed Sheeran knock-offs. Lemonade should've gone through.
Nick Waters Let’s see you try to out-perform them.
I'm so sorry for you but they are really great and they made it, not Lemonade, oopsis
I could auto tune a burp and out-perform them.
Imagine him being depressed or something and commiting suicide after your comment. We don't need negative people like you, Enrico Martin, who tell people to "go die".
They're my favourites - so I suspect because people have different tastes. Go figure!
The two brothers should not have gone through! It's obvious that at least one girl band has to go through...
Wtf Sean and Conor over Jack and Joel? That P!nk cover is horrible
Don't care about groups- it shouldn't even be a category anymore. No group will ever win the show, it's pointless. They are just all boringggg
Shraddha K you forget to one direction and little mix they did not win but they have done a lot of things
Didn't little mix win it already?
julio escareño couldn't agree more
basboosa911 I forgot they won and they are the more famous girl band in the UK
julio escareño yeah exactly, they made it big but the market for groups like these are saturated now. Nobody wants another group. It's so much harder to connect with groups. I've just never been fond of this category.
ago
HI Sharon Osbourne I hope you read this . I will educate you X factor means not to see base on physical looks but internal genuine beauty of voice and purpose this X factor symbolize of respect of uniqueness, acceptance, fairness, and real justice for what we say a real WIN is a people VOTES and not only base on your JUDGE this is a combinations of nations decision then I hope you feel good in your heart for your real decision to the top 3 you choose. We respect but I hope you know in your heart who is a real WIN? thank you.
jiro osaka I think Sharon did well for first time ever with her picks... She kept my fave among all... Grace
sharon did well. oh i know u talking about alissah ? there may be a wild card for that
I wanted lemonade to go through :(