WELL this was exhausting! Keep in mind, it’s a OPEN STYLE ranking. This took me almost 5-6 days? 😓 ALSO, some parts of this video are muted because they kept getting the video blocked! 😤 Keep in touch with my dance document to know for any updates! docs.google.com/document/d/1oiIblgTcOX0dmO2edqZ_yk6epR_E4bAOgva2f7n9CwY/edit
@@Minty_Sana Once again, you're showing off, how stupid you are! My comment had NOTHING to do with hate, but with facts. I have no idea, out of who's cock you sucked your "opinions" to each dancer, but it was so obvious, that you don't have the slightest clue about dancing...
@@Azza-cg7ri big3 3rd gen ggs being in bottom3 but their main dancers being in top3 lol i think 3rd gen was more balanced in the sense that they had amazing main dancers and main vocalists but not every member was decent in dancing nor vocals but in 4th gen almost every member is decent in dancing but there's rarely amazing vocalists
Aespa is improving day by day. Karina started off as a HT7 dancer and is now a HT6 dancer. AMAZING!! so aespa is now: Karina- HT6 NingNing- MT6 Winter-LT6 Giselle- HT7 right? And bp is Lisa- MT5 Jennie- HT7 Rosé- MT7/HT7 Jisoo- LT7
@BP-tm6ye Minty said Jennie is low tier 6 since she showed lots of improvements in the tour en Also her mantra performance i can see her improvements
@BP-tm6ye Rose is Ht7 but pretty low in ht7. She has best techniques of fluidity and her musicilaty is good. She has impressive footwork. Her placement the hitting style is powerful and shes energetic. So she is High tier 7 and Jennie is low tier 6😊
It pains me to see how unexplored Seulgi’s potential is. Do you think she will eventually improve to climb the ranks? It’s impressive how she auditioned as a vocalist and trained as a dancer from scratch and she still managed to rank this high
The main thing holding Seulgi back is her flexibility. She's the least flexible member in Red Velvet (Irene being the most flexible). So that stops her potential a lot.
honestly ningning gets overlooked a lot when it comes to dance but she improved sm and always had sm potential! thank god center one are focusing on the hip hop aspect for aespa cause look at their improvement!
In fact, even though NMIXX is a rookie group, they are doing a very good job. Moreover, Kyujin and Jiwoo are the maknaes of the group, but they still managed to leave most idols behind. Respect
Many of JYPE dancers lack the groove but some still can excel in open style, I think it's because their famous basic dance. I remember it was changed in Haewon (4th gen) era to be able to put more groove onwards since their 3rd gen dancers are literally sharp clean. Even their choreos contributed to such.
@@m.tahjulreyhan6976 Yeah and that's a niche in JYPE, if you actually review all of their idols. That's why I put in my statement, starting 4th gen idol, they are changing their styles from choreography into more of open style and laid back hiphop.
thank you for your rankings! been watching your videos since 2021 and you're becoming more objective with time and i really appreciate it just wanna say that i love how skilled are newjeans in dance and they're so young... i can't even imagine what they can show us in 2-3 years plus im so happy for aespa! i was so shocked and proud seeing how high is giselle cause she was heavily criticized 2 years ago for her dancing skills. it's so good for them!! their stage presence improved so much for me as well, this trick or treat + drama performance at mma was crazy. they're fantastic
all of aespas improvement is amazing! ningning and karina will be able to reach higher levels I'm sure of it lesserafim, newjeans, aespa this three groups growing all members together I think that's why their performances are getting more and more perfect.
@soyeonvsveggies regardless tho, they prioritize energy over actually skill, and I'll let u think that i know "nothing," but the reason I made the comment because someone is disregarding someone's skill just because they don't put as much energy into it
I'm gonna say this as someone who has been dancing to hip-hop for 10 years. I think you under evaluated the itzy girls a lot. First you used a very old video of them to show your examples, second you ignored some key points like ryujin potential for locking and popping, and yeji amazing footwork, isolation and power projection, you reduced them to idol dancers when in fact yeji used to be an street dancer before before being an idol. She also has shown she can dance big she just chooses not to do it on itzy choreos. Anyway I would yeji higher them hanni and kyujin for exemple. Hanni lacks fluidity, kyujin has a lot potential but still lacks body control.
Wow very detailed analysis. Really appreciate your work here. Can you tell me how you analyze each idol. I wanna learn it too for myself. I am a Visharad Kathak Dancer and beginner Hip Hop dancer
both Giselle and NingNing favorite genre is RnB/HipHop that why they shine in Armagaeddon i think ! in a recent interview Giselle said that when it come to music NingNing resonate With her because they have the same taste and i don't know if you know the youtuber Jeff Avenue(it's youtuber that do videos reaction and used to be dancer i believe) but once he said that NingNing have a hiphop/RnB base in her approch when she dance while for Karina she have more a ballerina approch
@@Minty_Sana i want to ask you compared to RV and GG for aespa is there a big different when it come to cohesion? for the vocal aint other fan said that for GG and RV the cohesion was the more important, but when to come to aespa the idivituality is more important so each member have a unique tone and her own style and approch would you say that it's the same for the dance section ?
😂😂😂😂😂 it’s such a shame because she can do splits and is a good singer but sucks at dancing . In the next comeback, she needs to be on the end and in the back permanently!!
I thought the same seeing Asa in her pre debut era that she should be higher. But nobody told me the reason . I am glad at least you told the real reason
i love how u used tons of examples instead of just talking about their dance. the people who are saying your rankings are wrong even though u have tons of experience in dance is stupid. fans need to stop acting like they are all these experienced dances and know everything. (not all fans obviously)
Addressing more points that I think were a little off: - Yunjin doesn’t have natural groove nor good shapes. It’s obvious that she didn’t have good groove in Easy and alignments have always been a major issue for her. - I would put Chaewon above Sakura because Sakura still has torso and hip stiffness, and her groove in Easy was underwhelming.
@@Minty_Sana the reason why I mentioned alignments is because you said in the video that Yunjin has good shapes, which she does not. It is a problem for her. I don’t know about you, but to me, Yunjin was super awkward in Easy. The tension in her torso was blocking her natural groove, and her long torso added further to that awkwardness. Eunchae imo was the only one with natural groove, with Chaewon and Kazuha trailing closely behind thanks to their light connected executions which almost resemble groove.
@@hieulannguyen7172Lol, Groove doesn’t need to be heavy -ass groove like Ahyeon. It can as small as bopping your head. Yunjin ‘Over-arches’ her back, which isn’t a problem in Hip-hop or when considering Open. Her arm and lower body alignments are decent.
@@Minty_SanaI disagree, especially when you said none of the members in Itzy has groove, yet you consider Yunjin when the tension in her torso is very evident. If Yunjin has groove, then Yeji also definitely does as well.
I agree but I think Yeji is better than hanni as I experienced 8 years in dancing yeji has so flexible moves where hanni have tight moves I know 10 types of dances that's why I am saying in depends of my experience we also can see the boy is mine challenge where yeji moves is so smooth but hanni moves is tight it just my opinion
I mean there’s a tier difference to begin with. Also. She would have to acquire groove and dance big to even get there. The advantages Hanni’s has above her are evident.
Why is it that momo is #1 in this video but when u compared twice and blackpink, jihyo and lisa were higher ranked than her? I’m happy that momo is first tho
hi! i was wondering if you’ve watched iland 2 and if you could rank the girls that made it to semi finals dance wise! you make wonderful points and are very subjective while also giving critical thoughts! i would love to see your opinion on those 12 girls! 🩷
What do you think about some UA-camrs who always rank ahyeon 5,6 at dance ranking in beamon i mean if we are rank ahyeon above than Chiquita and rami in dance we are being biased.
Ahyeon's dance is great,they're dragging down her in dance just because of her messy choreo for 2ne1 mashup. How can we blame somebody's dancing skills with their choreo?
Like lol that's what I thought. I always considered ahyeon as the third best dancer. Rami and Chiquita were not as good as her . I thought Asa was second due to her pre debut skills. I hope YG give her chance to show her actual style 😭 He shouldn't waste her and Ruka + Ahyeon potential
aespa is already such an all rounded group but if karina gets to strong skillset, giselle gets to show her rapping skills (i can't even say what she needs to improve on cause we barely have her rapping) and ningning gets her mix to be less heady, they will be one of the most all rounded groups ever.
Interesting to see how these rankings change from channel to channel. Hopeflakes would put Iroha above Lisa. Lisa would be below Seulgi. Chiquita would be much lower etc…
Lisa and Seulgi are pretty much interchangeable. Iroha’s analysis NOW would not be the most accurate of anyones’s (me included) She heavily lacks materials. We have no idea what more she is capable of or if she has more problems.
@@Minty_Sana i agree with you, too early to even say shes good than lisa. I can't imagine putting iroha against lisa. Iroha is talented in dancing but at this early stage of her career its too early to just compare right away
@@Bangpink1201 haven't you seen her posts about Big3 in her community? I have also trusted her but When I have seen she is a blind and toxic Hybe Stan and Big3 hater..I have started unfollow her and her content
I agree with all your analysis but besides i wnat to put my analysis and make a new analysis As you give the explanation after that I will like Momo≥Seulgi>Lisa
There is so much missed information here. Yeji’s power has always been highlighted by actual pro dance directors as one of her strengths, one of the few idols who is able to be clean, sharp and can deliver accents. Also, she is not your average idol dancer. She was a dancer before joining jype. I wouldn’t mind if you actually pointed her flaws but what you listed goes against what professionals find as her strength.
No really, Power projection is one of her strengths. But, even the top notch dancers can sabotage their own strengths at times. That doesn’t make their strengths completely weak.
Tbh I love hearing how much she improved her stability, it just makes me proud to see her improve and become less insecure about her voice, so I don’t agree.
@@Verowinday777 tbh it depends because she was always confident about her rapping! If you see a japanese misamo interview she said she was happy to rap more recently, as she feels more confident as a rapper
But Giselle and Jennie are at the same level? Seriously? I am not their fan or anti but...? I think Giselle got an exaggerated ranking as she was commented as worst of the 5th gen(comprehensive) and worst dancer in aespa, a group whose dancing is not considered a strength.
@Minty_Sana maybe i do maybe i dont ur rlly not at the level to assume that i copy paste when ur not any better it would benefit you to not assume and rank right or not rank
what placement would Jennie be if she was consistent and giving the same amount of energy as in 2016/17 tho? Bc many times she is able to outshine even Lisa, and even do some moves more correct. Interestingly at their most recent performances (Born Pink Tour, there were times where she was giving so much energy that she made the other 3 her background dancers for a monent)
Jennie locks and pops are nics tho. Footwork is her main issue. Grooves are also pretty much good. With decent isolations. The point you said about chill music is soo right but she has like the energy in some other song too. Chill type of dance : Shut down,Pink venom,Crazy over you. Energetic : dkwtd,how you like that etc. But we will see her improve more def in next comeback of bp
Por que ponen a jeongyeon en baile tan bajo?, jeongyeon siempre fue increible bailando solo miren las fancam de yes or yes o tt etc, solo que ahora no tiene mejor movimiento por su problema.
WELL this was exhausting!
Keep in mind, it’s a OPEN STYLE ranking.
This took me almost 5-6 days? 😓
ALSO, some parts of this video are muted because they kept getting the video blocked! 😤
Keep in touch with my dance document to know for any updates!
docs.google.com/document/d/1oiIblgTcOX0dmO2edqZ_yk6epR_E4bAOgva2f7n9CwY/edit
Please rank hybe groups in dancing as well would love to see it...
Exhausting? It only showed, that you don't have the slightest idea, what you're talking about and made you look stupid. It's worth SHIT...
@@danielhirt4252Seriously, Dude. You don’t have anything better to do in life than hate? 🙎🏻♀️
@@Minty_Sana Once again, you're showing off, how stupid you are! My comment had NOTHING to do with hate, but with facts. I have no idea, out of who's cock you sucked your "opinions" to each dancer, but it was so obvious, that you don't have the slightest clue about dancing...
@@danielhirt4252You sound like a femboy with no facial hair who’s mad about it. How about you focus on yourself?
The top 3 is still suelgi,lisa and momo🎉This trio is just 💯💯
and can't believe quite a few members of the predecessors Big 3(BP, Twice, RV) ranked as the bottom, the gap is tremendous
I need a Haewon and Ning Ning collab stage performance so bad, it would be the serve of the century
this is so real, love both of my main vocalists
Open style dance ranking
Ranking group, highest member
1. NewJeans 16.2 #6
2. Nmixx 21.5 #4
3. Itzy 23.4 #9
4. aespa 24.5 #11
5. Le sserafim 25.2 #22
6. Babymonster 27.29 #13
7. Illit 28.6 #7
8. Black Pink 34.75 #2
9. Twice 36.22 #1
10. Red Velvet 38 #3
3rd gen being last is no surprise as they focus on singing and rapping unlike later 4th/5th which focuses on dance and looks like dancers
@@Azza-cg7ri big3 3rd gen ggs being in bottom3 but their main dancers being in top3 lol i think 3rd gen was more balanced in the sense that they had amazing main dancers and main vocalists but not every member was decent in dancing nor vocals but in 4th gen almost every member is decent in dancing but there's rarely amazing vocalists
@@mimi_imfatnope baby monster, nmixx , asepa is better as a vocal group than their senior so you are wrong
@@mimi_imfatPREACHHHH!!
@@demonicfly07 i didn’t say there is NO amazing vocalists in 4th gen, i used RARELY
Aespa is improving day by day. Karina started off as a HT7 dancer and is now a HT6 dancer. AMAZING!! so aespa is now:
Karina- HT6
NingNing- MT6
Winter-LT6
Giselle- HT7 right?
And bp is
Lisa- MT5
Jennie- HT7
Rosé- MT7/HT7
Jisoo- LT7
I always knew ningning had a lot of improvements just by looking at her at the start. Right now she’s just as good as I expected. Girl can do anything
Jennie can be LT6, and rosé still LT7/MT7
Sabes que en el video está todo mal verdad??
@BP-tm6ye Minty said Jennie is low tier 6 since she showed lots of improvements in the tour en
Also her mantra performance i can see her improvements
@BP-tm6ye Rose is Ht7 but pretty low in ht7.
She has best techniques of fluidity and her musicilaty is good. She has impressive footwork. Her placement the hitting style is powerful and shes energetic.
So she is High tier 7 and Jennie is low tier 6😊
It pains me to see how unexplored Seulgi’s potential is. Do you think she will eventually improve to climb the ranks? It’s impressive how she auditioned as a vocalist and trained as a dancer from scratch and she still managed to rank this high
The main thing holding Seulgi back is her flexibility. She's the least flexible member in Red Velvet (Irene being the most flexible). So that stops her potential a lot.
honestly ningning gets overlooked a lot when it comes to dance but she improved sm and always had sm potential! thank god center one are focusing on the hip hop aspect for aespa cause look at their improvement!
and winter really improve since debut
@@BP-tm6ye love that for her but i’m talking about ningning here☺️
One day we have the Maknaces of Nmixx ranked higher than the top 3 main dancers and then the chaos will be big.
Aespa's dance is really underestimated 😭✨
They have 3 devoloped dancers & 1 above avg
Aespa improved day by day we got high 7 giselle low 6 winter mid 6 ningning and high 6 karina❤❤ hope to see karina in strong skills set in the future
Sabes que en el video está todo mal verdad?
Sep, puso un montón de bailarinas T7 en T6, ni chae, ni ningning, ni y una, ni ahyeon tienen buenas fundaciones para estar tan alto.@@melibort7617
we got strong karina!!
as an itzy stan i love that you don’t just hate on the dancing of these idols but you also answer the reason why they are lower
Poner a Itzy tan bajas es un pecado
Kyujin caught my eye so much in dice I’ve been obsessed ever since.
In fact, even though NMIXX is a rookie group, they are doing a very good job. Moreover, Kyujin and Jiwoo are the maknaes of the group, but they still managed to leave most idols behind. Respect
Many of JYPE dancers lack the groove but some still can excel in open style, I think it's because their famous basic dance. I remember it was changed in Haewon (4th gen) era to be able to put more groove onwards since their 3rd gen dancers are literally sharp clean. Even their choreos contributed to such.
Jiwoo from nmixx is literally dancer that always scream groove in her dance
Groove is a must in open style though
@@m.tahjulreyhan6976 Yeah and that's a niche in JYPE, if you actually review all of their idols. That's why I put in my statement, starting 4th gen idol, they are changing their styles from choreography into more of open style and laid back hiphop.
I have heard that Tzuyu's habit of bending is due to her height, so she needs to bend to look better as a team
That’s true, She does that to make the choreography look
More leveled and synchronised.
@@Minty_Sana But do you think it is a big issue for her dancing or just a minor one?
It’s not really noticeable for the most parts, It does affect her lines tho.
@@Minty_Sana Icic, thanks for amswering!
Momo queen 👑 seeing her at first place is a must guys, she’s too good
Ning ning in 19 place!!! Whoaa ning ning really improves!!
thank you for your rankings! been watching your videos since 2021 and you're becoming more objective with time and i really appreciate it
just wanna say that i love how skilled are newjeans in dance and they're so young... i can't even imagine what they can show us in 2-3 years
plus im so happy for aespa! i was so shocked and proud seeing how high is giselle cause she was heavily criticized 2 years ago for her dancing skills. it's so good for them!! their stage presence improved so much for me as well, this trick or treat + drama performance at mma was crazy. they're fantastic
3rd, 4th, and 5th gen all in one vid omg I love that
the introduction was kinda savage tbh
all of aespas improvement is amazing! ningning and karina will be able to reach higher levels I'm sure of it
lesserafim, newjeans, aespa this three groups growing all members together I think that's why their performances are getting more and more perfect.
Sabes que en el video está todo mal verdad??
Top 3 are the BIG 3 of 3rd Gen
My holly Trinity ❤
No
Can you make ranking "bad villan, illit, kiss of life, babymonster, unis & young posse (5nd gen ggs) in dance next please
Bad villian and Young posse are too good tbh 😭
I mean Emma alone would need a Emma tier since she’s not just miles above the ggs but also the bgs 😭
@@crystalspear8896 Seriously that girl outdanced all industry by a mile
And xin too
@@DeepakSingh-bu4yhAria is a good dancer 😭!!
Jihyo deserves Mina’s position
No she doesn't, mina is factual better than jihyo at everything except energy Jihyo is 8.90, Mina is 9+
@@ThatGurl.00 the way this video provides detailed explanations and you still go by meaningless tiers, i bet you don’t know a thing about dance lmao
@soyeonvsveggies regardless tho, they prioritize energy over actually skill, and I'll let u think that i know "nothing," but the reason I made the comment because someone is disregarding someone's skill just because they don't put as much energy into it
@@ThatGurl.00 maybe next time try watching the video before commenting?
@@ThatGurl.00Energy? When did I ever claim “Energy” is the only thing keeping Mina back?
Are you trying to put words in my mouth?
the explanation is good
Tzuyu is so tall - she often has to bend her knees so that it doesnt look like she is towering over everybody else during the dance
I'm gonna say this as someone who has been dancing to hip-hop for 10 years.
I think you under evaluated the itzy girls a lot. First you used a very old video of them to show your examples, second you ignored some key points like ryujin potential for locking and popping, and yeji amazing footwork, isolation and power projection, you reduced them to idol dancers when in fact yeji used to be an street dancer before before being an idol. She also has shown she can dance big she just chooses not to do it on itzy choreos. Anyway I would yeji higher them hanni and kyujin for exemple. Hanni lacks fluidity, kyujin has a lot potential but still lacks body control.
I cant believe the amount of work you put into this & how long it took 😭❤
Took me 6 days!! 😵💫
This is such a fun and informative watch!
Thank you for your hard work. : )
55.Lia
54.Jisoo
53.Wonhee
52. Yeri
51.Joy
50.Jeongeon
49.Dahyun
48.Tzuyu
47.Mina
46.Pharita
45.Rose
44.Chaeyoung
43.Wendy
42.Sana
41.Irene
40.Yunah
39.Giselle (my bias)
38.Jennie
37.Nayeon
36.Lily
35.Sollyoon
34.Rami
33.Rora(my bias)
32.Bae (my bias)
31.Kazuha
30.Chiquita
29.Winter
28.Yuna(my bias)
27.Minju
26.Eunchae
25.Hyein
24/23.Yunjin(my bias)
22.Chaewon
21.Sakura
20.Asa
19.Minji
18.Ningning
17.Danielle
16.Haewon
15.Moka
14.Chaeryeong
13.Ruka
12.
How proud I am of all the skills of the NMIXX members
Wow very detailed analysis. Really appreciate your work here.
Can you tell me how you analyze each idol. I wanna learn it too for myself.
I am a Visharad Kathak Dancer and beginner Hip Hop dancer
I agree Momo is best. Also I want to see with BADVILLAIN.
LOVE THIS RANKING
Be honest... we all expected Momo to be first
i expect moka to be first
I was expecting Seulgi tbh
@@chaeekalgirl what-💀
@@PixieDiamondDewlol
@@chaeekalshe’s not even the best dancer in her group
I loved the video, I wish the reasoning for each person were wayyy more consistent
I did plan to make this video a lot longer, But my college’s starting I couldn’t extend the editing any longer.
both Giselle and NingNing favorite genre is RnB/HipHop
that why they shine in Armagaeddon i think !
in a recent interview
Giselle said that when it come to music NingNing resonate With her because they have the same taste
and i don't know if you know the youtuber Jeff Avenue(it's youtuber that do videos reaction and used to be dancer i believe) but once he said that NingNing have a hiphop/RnB base in her approch when she dance while for Karina she have more a ballerina approch
Karina definitely leans more towards commercial!
@@Minty_Sana
i want to ask you compared to RV and GG for aespa is there a big different when it come to cohesion?
for the vocal aint other fan said that for GG and RV the cohesion was the more important, but when to come to aespa the idivituality is more important so each member have a unique tone and her own style and approch
would you say that it's the same for the dance section ?
@@NingKook000pretty much
POV Lia: 55 POV The rest of ITZY: over ^Above Average
ikr the gap is so big 😭😭😭
Kinda the opposite with red velvet
😂😂😂😂😂 it’s such a shame because she can do splits and is a good singer but sucks at dancing . In the next comeback, she needs to be on the end and in the back permanently!!
i actually love her body and arms line but she is meh in dancing i hope she improved
Please rank Hybe groups in dancing since they have the toughest choreographies, I would love to see it!!!!!
girl this is probably the most in depth k tube video ive ever seen omg
your editing is amazing as well omg
new sub :D
NMIXX are so good!
Momo #1 dancer, I love Momo's style and confidence when she dances, she dances so effortlessly ✨❤️✨❤️✨❤️✨
Thanks for this video❤
My pleasure 😊
@Minty_SanaTbh, as someone who wants to improve dance skills this video has really helped me look for my weaknesses and strengths
Idk I wouldn’t say ur ranking open style but more of a combination of all. Idol open and commercial
Certainly, But open was my main focus.
@@Minty_SanaWinter is the best commercial dancer of aespa and Karina best open style dancer right?
@@cutesweetdadi9495commercial: winter&karina / open: karina&ningning
i think
@@user-ot5pl7rl3n Winter is a better commercial dancer than Karina and Karina is a better open style dancer than Ningning
I thought the same seeing Asa in her pre debut era that she should be higher. But nobody told me the reason . I am glad at least you told the real reason
i love how u used tons of examples instead of just talking about their dance. the people who are saying your rankings are wrong even though u have tons of experience in dance is stupid. fans need to stop acting like they are all these experienced dances and know everything. (not all fans obviously)
Can you do next Ranking IVE (G)-IDLE
And Kiss of Life in Dance (in Details)
And in Long video not in YT shorts
I like this ranking and I'm sure that illit will improve in the future especially woonhe
Can you do the same ranking with boy groups?
Addressing more points that I think were a little off:
- Yunjin doesn’t have natural groove nor good shapes. It’s obvious that she didn’t have good groove in Easy and alignments have always been a major issue for her.
- I would put Chaewon above Sakura because Sakura still has torso and hip stiffness, and her groove in Easy was underwhelming.
- Yunjin groove IS good in easy, and the most natural. Alignments are not looked upon as important in Open Style.
- You do you, They are extremely close.
@@Minty_Sana the reason why I mentioned alignments is because you said in the video that Yunjin has good shapes, which she does not. It is a problem for her.
I don’t know about you, but to me, Yunjin was super awkward in Easy. The tension in her torso was blocking her natural groove, and her long torso added further to that awkwardness. Eunchae imo was the only one with natural groove, with Chaewon and Kazuha trailing closely behind thanks to their light connected executions which almost resemble groove.
@@hieulannguyen7172Lol, Groove doesn’t need to be heavy -ass groove like Ahyeon.
It can as small as bopping your head.
Yunjin ‘Over-arches’ her back, which isn’t a problem in Hip-hop or when considering Open. Her arm and lower body alignments are decent.
@@Minty_SanaI disagree, especially when you said none of the members in Itzy has groove, yet you consider Yunjin when the tension in her torso is very evident. If Yunjin has groove, then Yeji also definitely does as well.
Hey can you do it with pop singer like Britney Spears, Beyoncé and more ? 🥰
I agree but I think Yeji is better than hanni as I experienced 8 years in dancing yeji has so flexible moves where hanni have tight moves I know 10 types of dances that's why I am saying in depends of my experience we also can see the boy is mine challenge where yeji moves is so smooth but hanni moves is tight it just my opinion
Hanni is…tight?
@@Minty_Sana Means her moves is not that much flexible and I think Yeji also has clean moves compared to hanni
Hanni’s moves are clean too.
@@Minty_Sana Yeah but Yeji is better it just my opinion
I mean there’s a tier difference to begin with.
Also. She would have to acquire groove and dance big to even get there. The advantages Hanni’s has above her are evident.
Why is it that momo is #1 in this video but when u compared twice and blackpink, jihyo and lisa were higher ranked than her? I’m happy that momo is first tho
Ahyeon is the best..akhirnya yg tau dance menghargai bakatmu..bukan netizen yg ga tau apa2..😂😂😂
Nmixx Queens in 4-5 gen
Yay! You finally posted!
hi! i was wondering if you’ve watched iland 2 and if you could rank the girls that made it to semi finals dance wise! you make wonderful points and are very subjective while also giving critical thoughts! i would love to see your opinion on those 12 girls! 🩷
I would once they make an official debut
In terms of dance which tiers goes along with momo?
Strong Skillset dancers are Tier 5 dancers.
It was fun watching this
What do you think about some UA-camrs who always rank ahyeon 5,6 at dance ranking in beamon i mean if we are rank ahyeon above than Chiquita and rami in dance we are being biased.
The only thing I can say is they don’t know anything about dance. Or they are ranking by Idol dancing.
Ahyeon's dance is great,they're dragging down her in dance just because of her messy choreo for 2ne1 mashup. How can we blame somebody's dancing skills with their choreo?
Like lol that's what I thought. I always considered ahyeon as the third best dancer. Rami and Chiquita were not as good as her .
I thought Asa was second due to her pre debut skills. I hope YG give her chance to show her actual style 😭 He shouldn't waste her and Ruka + Ahyeon potential
I think rami is better in open style and idol both and better than ahyeon,rora, Chiquita
she’s not that great in idol dance, but this list is open style, same thing with Mina from twice
aespa is already such an all rounded group but if karina gets to strong skillset, giselle gets to show her rapping skills (i can't even say what she needs to improve on cause we barely have her rapping) and ningning gets her mix to be less heady, they will be one of the most all rounded groups ever.
off topic kazuha looked drop dead gorgeous in the picture you used for her
Momo is number one. We cheered 🎉
Please ranking 5 gen idols in different categories
i skipped a bit ahead and saw jiwoo as jisoo and nearly had a heart attack
Lol
Can you please make a boy group version of this video?
Interesting to see how these rankings change from channel to channel. Hopeflakes would put Iroha above Lisa. Lisa would be below Seulgi. Chiquita would be much lower etc…
Lisa and Seulgi are pretty much interchangeable.
Iroha’s analysis NOW would not be the most accurate of anyones’s (me included) She heavily lacks materials. We have no idea what more she is capable of or if she has more problems.
@@Minty_Sana i agree with you, too early to even say shes good than lisa. I can't imagine putting iroha against lisa. Iroha is talented in dancing but at this early stage of her career its too early to just compare right away
Hope flakes will rank anyone against Big3 upper
@@hiitsmesahiya she has ranked Iroha above Lisa, Momo, Seulgi.
And Natty and Lisa are interchangeable but She said in her opinion Lisa is better.
@@Bangpink1201 haven't you seen her posts about Big3 in her community?
I have also trusted her but When I have seen she is a blind and toxic Hybe Stan and Big3 hater..I have started unfollow her and her content
I agree with all your analysis but besides i wnat to put my analysis and make a new analysis
As you give the explanation after that I will like
Momo≥Seulgi>Lisa
LISAMO>>>>
Her last video :(
There is so much missed information here. Yeji’s power has always been highlighted by actual pro dance directors as one of her strengths, one of the few idols who is able to be clean, sharp and can deliver accents. Also, she is not your average idol dancer. She was a dancer before joining jype. I wouldn’t mind if you actually pointed her flaws but what you listed goes against what professionals find as her strength.
No really, Power projection is one of her strengths. But, even the top notch dancers can sabotage their own strengths at times. That doesn’t make their strengths completely weak.
what would T4, T3, T2, and T1 be called? like T7 is Average, T6 is developed, T5 is strong.
T4 is very strong, T3 is Excellent, T2 is Proficient.
@@lucas-z3gemma
MOTHERR❤JIHYOOOOO
I prefer Momo only as dancer not idol sns
What does this mean?
She’s a good idol rapper and she can write
Plus her stage presente is amazing, she eats the stage, she was born to be an idol
@@YousofatubeSome people may prefer her dancing skills over other ones she has to offer
@@filipmarinkovic6281 because her dancing is her main talent, just like jihyo’s main talent is singing, but that doesnt mean she can’t dance
Tbh I love hearing how much she improved her stability, it just makes me proud to see her improve and become less insecure about her voice, so I don’t agree.
@@Verowinday777 tbh it depends because she was always confident about her rapping! If you see a japanese misamo interview she said she was happy to rap more recently, as she feels more confident as a rapper
But Giselle and Jennie are at the same level? Seriously? I am not their fan or anti but...? I think Giselle got an exaggerated ranking as she was commented as worst of the 5th gen(comprehensive) and worst dancer in aespa, a group whose dancing is not considered a strength.
Moka and Chaeryeong... am I insane or the world?
Anyway I believe you have your stance but it's way too far from the popular opinion, like even the recognised group position
Yuna below Eunchae and Hyein???Do you really mean Yuna dances bad?(No hate)
She’s not strong when it comes to open style. Did you ignore the discussion at the very beginning of the video?
She never said Yuna's a bad dancer
How is Lisa better at dancing than Seulgi?
Please explain this to me :|
They are interchangeable
@@Minty_Sana But still, in my opinion Seulgi is better at dancing than Lisa.
@@samanthagardner330same
@@Minty_SanaLMAOOOO Lisa is terrible even Emma is better than her . She should’ve been placed in the 30’s .
Ahyeon better than ruka??😂😂 lol wtf
Momo dancing machine 💖
Iroha is deff a better dancer than hanni , watch r u next or her as a kid
Oh yeah, because I definitely watch the only two dance practices on repeat, right?
@@Minty_Sana sarcams is not sarcamsiming , hanni is low T5 iroha is Mid T5
Sarcasm**
It would benefit if you learn to spell, instead of copy pasting what you’ve seen in other videos.
@Minty_Sana maybe i do maybe i dont ur rlly not at the level to assume that i copy paste when ur not any better it would benefit you to not assume and rank right or not rank
You made no sense, Yet you THAWGHT! 😝😝😝 LAWLLL!
Yaji❤
bro does NOT believe in commas
What gave it away? 😭
what placement would Jennie be if she was consistent and giving the same amount of energy as in 2016/17 tho?
Bc many times she is able to outshine even Lisa, and even do some moves more correct. Interestingly at their most recent performances (Born Pink Tour, there were times where she was giving so much energy that she made the other 3 her background dancers for a monent)
Same Level as Winter, Yuna.
Bro 1st ofc Lisa, isn't momo
Where is Sound 😢
Is your phone volume on? 😭
I play 3 times and the sound finally here 😭
@@thiyammanglemba3564maybe the video was still processing
Lisa is only over hype
Momo is a better dancer than her
How the F did momo beat lisa in dancing💃 like I don't get it?
I'm not saying that Momo is not a good dancer but I think lisa is a better dancer
Momo is better no big gap but Momo is better dancer, the wrong ranking here is from 15 to last
They both are on the same level...ppl can have opinion in putting them 1st and 2nd
Both good
Momo's has smooth moves
Lisa got natural Swagy moves
Momo dacnce queen 👑💕
can u do ranking rv and aespa idol dance?
Irene
Winter
Karina
Seulgi
Joy
NingNing
Wendy
Giselle
Yeri
How about Irene, Mina, Rosé, Yuna, Winter? @@Minty_Sana, who is better in idol dance?
Yuna’s better
Rami at 34 and rora at 33?? (This is very wrong, since rami is from the dance line and rora only dances more than pharita (sometimes
Jennie locks and pops are nics tho.
Footwork is her main issue.
Grooves are also pretty much good. With decent isolations.
The point you said about chill music is soo right but she has like the energy in some other song too.
Chill type of dance : Shut down,Pink venom,Crazy over you.
Energetic : dkwtd,how you like that etc.
But we will see her improve more def in next comeback of bp
My baby Nayeon at 37 SLAY QUEEN
Lia & Jisoo's energy>>>>
Can they even project energy??
@@Verowinday777 Yes
@@itsmeits1999 I doubt that tbh.
Itzy❤
For me Lia is better than Jisoo but anyway Jihyo ❤
Can you ranking bm in tiers i want to know there tiers
Did you read the intro and watch the video? Because everything’s in there
@@Minty_Sana oh I'm sorry I think I skipped the intro
Por que ponen a jeongyeon en baile tan bajo?, jeongyeon siempre fue increible bailando solo miren las fancam de yes or yes o tt etc, solo que ahora no tiene mejor movimiento por su problema.
So twice are
Momo mid 5
Jihyo high 6
Nayeon and sana and chaeyoung high 7
Mina, tzuyu, dahyun and jeongyeon mid 7
Yes.
If Momo can develop her groove to what level she will reach ؟
@@Zineb-q3pTier 4
@@Minty_Sana thanks you
Jihyo is low5 afaik
I was sad about ur ranking until Momo was first
Finally
ive❤