Béla Fleck & Abigail Washburn: Clawhammer vs. Three-Finger Banjo Style | Reverb Interview

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 336

  • @gastonflatulenza1276
    @gastonflatulenza1276 6 років тому +190

    Abigail: Smart, talented, and pretty. She's fluent in Mandarin Chinese. She's never played a bad song or done a show that was not interesting and fascinating (I've seen her live many times). I play banjo and have a degree in classical music, but Bela, when he starts explaining what he does, is like listening to Einstein explain relativity. When Einstein came to America on a ship, a fellow passenger said, "He explained relativity to me every day and I'm convinced that HE understands it." These are two major talents, two national treasures.

    • @evilrainbow
      @evilrainbow 5 років тому +7

      To be fair Bela is just talking about scales and keys while demonstrating multiple bluegrass 3 finger styles, where Abigail is focusing on a single clawhammer style. Abigail states that there are many regional clawhammer styles and she's playing this specific one. It's not really rocket science from Bela, just showcasing a lot of information comparatively.

    • @MrApples6
      @MrApples6 4 роки тому

      Agree. Bela should stick to banjo. If you want to play like a guitar, learn to play guitar. If you want to play a fiddle, learn to play a fiddle. And repeat in reverse. Fine to adapt your instrument to imitate other instruments somewhat, but at a certain point it gets annoying. Respect the technique, but flat picking a banjo to make it sound a guitar emulating a fiddle, nah. That's disturbing. Her banjo is hypnotizing. Very cool.

    • @JosephEchevarria
      @JosephEchevarria 3 роки тому +11

      @@MrApples6 IIf you listen to Victor Wooten talk about how he learned bass, yo discover that emulation is how he ended up playing his instrument like, and yet unlike, people play anything else.
      Crossing the streams doesn't destroy life as we know it (Ghostbusters) and it just might yield some pretty interesting results, and in fact, it does.

    • @blaisemacpherson7637
      @blaisemacpherson7637 3 роки тому

      @@evilrainbow oh I remember reading about her years ago.

  • @danieferreira9094
    @danieferreira9094 Рік тому +17

    2 artists at the top of their craft! What a joy to watch! Thanks for sharing!

  • @Vito_Tuxedo
    @Vito_Tuxedo 6 років тому +130

    Awesome video! Béla (three finger) is the physicist and Abby (clawhammer) is the painter. One is thinking, the other is feeling. Life is incomplete without both. Thanks for posting this!

  • @huttowild
    @huttowild 4 роки тому +41

    Having learned three finger "Scruggs" style, I completely agree with what Bela is saying about clawhammer style. I cannot for the life of me wrap my brain (or my hands) around it. And Steve Martin does both beautifully. I remember being at a concert of his and he walked the audience through the differences and then played a song using both methods... it was incredible. To be a banjo "player" sitting in the audience I was in absolute awe.

    • @RocketTrolley
      @RocketTrolley 3 роки тому +1

      Yeah I've tried emulating Molly's clawhammer on guitar and unless someone sat down and trained with me for a long long time - it's just something I can not wrap my head around. And clawhammer on guitar is way less diverse than banjo - lol. Its like you have to unlearn one to learn the other.

    • @RocketTrolley
      @RocketTrolley 3 роки тому +1

      Kudos on the Steve Martin shout out. He's amazing.

    • @beastinthesky6774
      @beastinthesky6774 2 роки тому +4

      Reminds me of when I first got to New Orleans I was blown away by a particular guitarist who played Hot Jazz, he was in a class of talent of his own, like a present day Django Reinhardt. I play a lot folk/blues fingerpicking stuff (Mississippi John Hurt, Doc Watson, etc) couple months later he stopped and tipped me while I was busking on Royal St, and I was stunned when he told me that he has tried and tried and can't play that style of music to save his life. Yet he can absolutely melt the fretboard playing insanely advanced jazz scales and strumming patterns. It's interesting how different brains work differently.

    • @tvviewer4500
      @tvviewer4500 Рік тому

      Think about why it’s called claw hammer. Imagine you are holding a hammer and your arm is doing the moving - same principle as striking the banjo claw hammer

    • @TakeItEazy77
      @TakeItEazy77 Рік тому +3

      I read this thinking, "oh cool there's a banjo player also named steve martin." Nope, it's actually him 😂

  • @bolguevara
    @bolguevara 6 років тому +602

    sometimes I pickup a frying pan in my kitchen and act like I'm playing the banjo. I can do either clawhammer or three finger style on it.

    • @ThatkidwithCP
      @ThatkidwithCP 6 років тому +3

      lol

    • @jamesha175
      @jamesha175 6 років тому +10

      lol i do the same except with the toaster so mine is the electric air banjo.
      advantage: me

    • @Knight14649
      @Knight14649 6 років тому +4

      That’s pretty funny. 🤣

    • @ronkopald
      @ronkopald 6 років тому

      Haah. Nice.

    • @nemo227
      @nemo227 6 років тому +6

      Octobert, there are many kinds of talent. You could show something new to those people up in the hollers. When I'm in the kitchen I do a duet with the smoke alarm in the adjacent hall. My wife HATES it but I'm the one who does the cooking. BTW, my string bass won't set foot (peg) in the kitchen.

  • @lilhoss1
    @lilhoss1 6 років тому +91

    Abigail's banjo sounds so warm! Very nice!

    • @youaintscarman9957
      @youaintscarman9957 6 років тому +8

      open back, isn't it lovely?

    • @jacktattis143
      @jacktattis143 5 років тому +1

      @@youaintscarman9957 Is open back better than the resonate bANJO?

    • @MattyVicious1
      @MattyVicious1 5 років тому +1

      @@jacktattis143 YESSSS

    • @motomc6962
      @motomc6962 4 роки тому

      Jack Tattis noooo

    • @notjuicedjay
      @notjuicedjay 4 роки тому +4

      Open back will give you that warmer sound so it’s better for claw hammer, a resonate banjo will give you that distinct bluegrass sound you’ll hear from someone like Earl Scruggs

  • @everonlyallforthee
    @everonlyallforthee 6 років тому +24

    I play guitar, but hearing Abigail play here was the first time I've ever loved the tone of a banjo in the same way I respond to guitar tone. She sounds great!

  • @MattH-wg7ou
    @MattH-wg7ou 5 років тому +15

    "There's a different style in every holler" yesmaam there is!
    I love her way of playing!

  • @andrewbeattieRAB
    @andrewbeattieRAB 6 років тому +6

    EXCELLENT VIDEO
    My fraternity brother and roommate for a while played the banjo. He would sometimes bring it out at the end of a party. This was the very early 80s. Instead of thinking it was old-fashioned, everybody loved it! He got me listening to Doc Watson in 1982!! I had never heard of him. By the way, this was at Texas A&M. So, it wasn’t a huge cultural stretch.

  • @neebinmakwah349
    @neebinmakwah349 6 років тому +4

    I could listen to this all day...time for a CD together...just fantastic!

  • @gcbfolk
    @gcbfolk 6 років тому +8

    I love to hear these two play together, the essence of 2 souls meeting in music

  • @Schultzman
    @Schultzman 6 років тому +7

    Awesome! Very different than the Flecktones. Love the mixing of different styles. I hope your playing will keep this style going for many generations.

  • @ketchupman246
    @ketchupman246 6 років тому +75

    This is an amazing introduction to different banjo styles! Good job!

  • @guitarzilla
    @guitarzilla 6 років тому +22

    Great! Always enjoyed the Flecktones at the jazz fests around the country.

  • @marcscordato4385
    @marcscordato4385 6 років тому +25

    Guitar is standardized but banjo is wide open. There are closed backed and open backed banjos, nylon and steel string banjos , tenor, bass, and alto banjos and many alternate tunings . Bela is perhaps the finest living banjo player but Abi is very good and provides a lovely counterpoint to Bela’s virtuosity .

    • @stevelaferney3579
      @stevelaferney3579 5 років тому +6

      Marc Scordato I thought guitar was fairly standardized too til I learned about Harvey Reid and his Liberty Tuning plus partial capos. Wow. A U-turn to different. Keep playing.

  • @stevemary-anne3273
    @stevemary-anne3273 5 років тому

    My brother-in-law and sister-in-law took me to see you two in Green Lake Wisconsin I love the show. It made me want to play my banjo even more. I love how you had your son in the show.

  • @Violetcas97
    @Violetcas97 5 років тому +1

    There is no instrument in this whole wide world that has both enchanted and intimidated me than the banjo, what a magical instrument

  • @thomasjohnson5003
    @thomasjohnson5003 Рік тому +1

    you two are so cool! I'm just getting my first banjo after playing guitars for a couple decades...fascinated by the options...ty for the creativity!

  • @maryfine6489
    @maryfine6489 6 років тому +7

    Have loved Abigail's music, banjo style and voice for a long time. Would love a workshop!!

  • @scottoneil6795
    @scottoneil6795 6 років тому +1

    Fascinating stuff from two of the most talented and kind-spirited people you'd ever hope to meet!

  • @BerlinBo
    @BerlinBo 6 років тому +1

    Thank you explaining some of the mystery of banjo play to those of us who are new to it.

  • @ronkopald
    @ronkopald 6 років тому +4

    You know who else has mastered the second fret clawhammer pull off? BRUCE LANGHORNE.
    He deserves FAR more credit than he gets. But these two are amazing. I've loved Bela my whole life.
    Also, this is an excellent overview of these different banjo styles.
    Edit: Oh and btw, that open scale stuff is called harp tuning by us guitarists, you must know this though.
    This video is excellent. My vocabulary is limited to excellent, but that's what this is!

  • @benparker6825
    @benparker6825 5 років тому +1

    I never tire of watching this video!

  • @nicholaspalacio9672
    @nicholaspalacio9672 5 років тому +3

    This is such a cool video. Never knew the banjo was THAT versatile of an instrument

  • @SimpleSimonUTubeUser
    @SimpleSimonUTubeUser 6 років тому +1

    Wow, they are/sound so good together!

  • @mannyhatz6041
    @mannyhatz6041 6 років тому +1

    Been listening to their albums for a while now... great video explaining their unique styles!

  • @garymichalec9720
    @garymichalec9720 11 місяців тому +1

    Benefits of going down a UA-cam rabbit hole!!! Amazing talent!!

  • @ianflurrance8438
    @ianflurrance8438 6 років тому +17

    Yes! Please do more banjo content!

  • @groovyhippie1165
    @groovyhippie1165 6 років тому +12

    This was great and both sounded amazing together, very cool.

  • @patrickcarroll1754
    @patrickcarroll1754 6 років тому +35

    This man is a legend.

  • @yaquimike
    @yaquimike 4 роки тому +2

    I love this video! It really helped me with some finger picking ideas as well as giving me further look into developing some clawhammer ideas that I apply to cello, mandolin and guitar. Thanks for the great content!

  • @garythebard
    @garythebard 5 років тому

    Phenomenal. Always impressed by Bela Fleck's playing.

  • @drtone
    @drtone 6 років тому +1

    never heard a banjo so warm...Bravo!

  • @rogerbeaird3320
    @rogerbeaird3320 3 роки тому

    Great insights of excitement playing the mandolin for 3 years taking a break to repair new fretts lol I got dad's banjo now I'm excited about tht 😆🤣😂😹 thanks for a good video peeps 😀

  • @doncoe6677
    @doncoe6677 6 років тому +9

    The combination of claw hammer and Scruggs style is beautiful

  • @MrJbaker7
    @MrJbaker7 6 років тому +7

    I love it Bela and Abigail....Wonderful combination...Jack Baker NYC p.s. thanks for explaining "Round Peake" style. Difficult to teach, at least for me....

  • @darrinpennington
    @darrinpennington 6 років тому +1

    Those two style played well together. Really enjoyed the video

  • @stevelaferney3579
    @stevelaferney3579 5 років тому +1

    Oh yeah! Nice! Heard n saw Bela decades ago but how have I missed the Missus play? Wow! TY I grateful.

  • @flamencoprof
    @flamencoprof 5 років тому +1

    Thanks so much. This taught me more about Banjo in 8 mins than I have ever learned in my whole life as a 69yo guitar player. But I am from NZ, so far from where this comes from.

  • @alastair6356
    @alastair6356 27 днів тому

    Beautiful sounding banjo love the moon and stars on the beck.🤩👍

  • @SlimLett2.0
    @SlimLett2.0 2 роки тому

    Love hearing the banjo 🪕 always wanted to learn to play thanks for sharing Gary

  • @ziblot1235
    @ziblot1235 6 років тому +2

    Havent seen Bela in years. He is really amazing.

  • @ejlilley
    @ejlilley 6 років тому +1

    Absolutely wonderful to listen to. Thank you very much!

  • @hawg427
    @hawg427 6 років тому +4

    Great video. I am always amazed at the tones a good banjo player can get out of the inst.

  • @Krabadaque
    @Krabadaque 6 років тому

    Wonderful music! Thanks!

  • @thefool2007
    @thefool2007 3 роки тому +2

    Saw Belah in a few concerts. Honestly, best banjoist in the world and unreal musician.

  • @scroungasworkshop4663
    @scroungasworkshop4663 6 років тому +3

    OMG I have so much to learn! Thanks Stuart 🇦🇺

  • @roscopecotrain9001
    @roscopecotrain9001 3 роки тому

    breathtaking talent, and an excellent explanation of playing styles.

  • @thefool2007
    @thefool2007 3 роки тому

    Awesome video of these gifted players.

  • @walkingbassline
    @walkingbassline 5 років тому

    Awesome demonstration! Answered so many of my banjo questions!

  • @BrandonLewisD
    @BrandonLewisD 3 роки тому

    Such beautiful banjo playing!

  • @fortawesome1974
    @fortawesome1974 4 роки тому

    Clawhammer kicks ass and that's what I'm learning on my new open back Banjo I got for Christmas this year!!

  • @TonyfromBham
    @TonyfromBham 6 років тому +57

    Bela is one the best musicians out there, but Ms. Washburn’s playing absolutely does it for me in ways that no other 5-string banjoist’s playing does.

    • @CorneiliusLibowitz
      @CorneiliusLibowitz 4 роки тому +3

      Then maybe you should check out Rhiannon Giddens.........

    • @TonyfromBham
      @TonyfromBham 4 роки тому +1

      @@CorneiliusLibowitz I’ve listening to her since the very early days of CCd.

    • @sharonwayne1118
      @sharonwayne1118 4 роки тому +1

      @@CorneiliusLibowitz exactly what I was going to say!

  • @abmbarry
    @abmbarry 5 років тому

    ...Brilliant and very captivating! I think I will be pressing "REPLAY" many times . Happy Bears!

  • @derekwalker4622
    @derekwalker4622 9 місяців тому

    I have actually found a fella by the name of Andy Hunt, who has managed to combine 3 finger with clawhammer. This kid is a pretty amazing picker. What cracks me up about him, is he tries to NOT smile when he plays, but you can tell he loves playing banjo. The channel he is on is IHC Banjo. The song he does that shows this skill of combining the playing types is Cripple Creek.

  • @FlatlandMando
    @FlatlandMando 6 років тому +2

    You two together & singularly have some very scary skills. Enjoyed listening...very advanced.

  • @mirakimber6333
    @mirakimber6333 3 роки тому +1

    Abigail talking about old time style 0:55
    Bela talking about 3-finger rolls 3:25
    Playing together and talking about the differences between styles 7:17

  • @GaryBook
    @GaryBook 6 років тому +1

    A Master class, thank you both.

  • @zoomankat
    @zoomankat 6 років тому +5

    Don Mclean plays both Clawhammer and finger styles brilliantly on his wonderful sounding long necked 5 string with diffrent fingerpick combinations .

    • @FIGGY65
      @FIGGY65 3 роки тому

      Yes! And Don McLean is a giant of all music history…try finding some of his impromptu visits at Norman’s Rare Guitar channel. He is fascinating to listen to!

  • @neurofire
    @neurofire 6 років тому +3

    I've loved Bela Fleck since his astonishing Drive album - I wasn't all that much into his Flecktone period - it was a tributary I didn't explore... This clip with Abigail Washburn is (for me anyway) manna. Not only do they acknowledge the heritage of five string greats - but they somehow add to the wealth those players created.

  • @curtheciscokid
    @curtheciscokid 6 років тому +1

    Love you two! But especially Bela, your a legend man.

  • @garysmith9147
    @garysmith9147 6 років тому +1

    A local Lancaster, PA Bluegrass band, 'Dillweed' uses two banjos and an upright bass. The banjo players use the two styles: one plays three-finger and the other Clawhammer. Good stuff and worth understanding the difference.

    • @Mnnvint
      @Mnnvint 6 років тому

      It's a lovely idea to mix the styles, and not so rare either! Glenn Jones does it too in "Across the Tappan Zee", with Laura Baird playing clawhammer.

  • @simplyorange8553
    @simplyorange8553 5 років тому

    Absolutely incredible.

  • @Raptor3400
    @Raptor3400 5 років тому +7

    both are absolute masters of their instrument, but Abagail's style is more hypnotic to me while Bela's seems more precise but bright and lively. Just my opinion.

  • @JLP_710
    @JLP_710 4 місяці тому

    Banjos are so awesome. I heard someone playing three finger on an open back and for whatever reason I like the way it sounds more.

  • @davidcarlson1208
    @davidcarlson1208 5 років тому +1

    Amazing music, and couple!

  • @riviecc
    @riviecc 4 роки тому

    Thanks for the great insight of both styes . Im a guitar player for 40 years . Kind of lazy when it comes to formal techniques . Mostly play blues , rock , pop and country

  • @fast1nakus
    @fast1nakus 6 років тому +25

    7:00 apparently you can do some nice Mideast sound with Banjo

    • @Visengrad
      @Visengrad 4 роки тому +3

      Its because the G notes in the key of A-flat minor makes a Harmonic Minor Scale. That's what gives it that Middle Eastern Sound.

  • @geoffwible2471
    @geoffwible2471 6 років тому +3

    Fantastic stuff right here, these two do it right!

  • @angelbarbosa7835
    @angelbarbosa7835 6 років тому +2

    Banjo and Spanish guitar are the best. Love to hear the Banjo it is awesome.

  • @MattH-wg7ou
    @MattH-wg7ou 5 років тому +10

    Theyre both amazing but something about the way she plays touches my heart. As a Carolina soul especially.

    • @yeezet4592
      @yeezet4592 3 роки тому +2

      Bela has a rally good group banjo sound. 3 finger isn't made for soloing

  • @jtelevenoyd1571
    @jtelevenoyd1571 6 років тому

    Interesting final remark in that video! 3-finger comes naturally to me, but clawhammer kicked my butt so hard I don't even try it now. That said, I can listen to a good clawhammer player all night and enjoy it. It's really nice to hear how the two styles complement each other. Great music!

  • @ayylmao6199
    @ayylmao6199 6 років тому +1

    Probably my favorite couple

  • @robertnewell5057
    @robertnewell5057 6 років тому

    Interesting to hear Bela's comment on different mindsets for thre finger and clawhammer playing. Lynn Morris (Lynn Morris Band) is an award winning clawhammer player and also a great Scruggs Style player, who I had the immense pleasure of being taught by. Now plays mainly guitar in her band, I believe.

  • @DenisCalligraphy
    @DenisCalligraphy 4 роки тому +3

    As a visual artist, I was struck by the simplicity of musical explanations that I understand, but captivated by the stripes on Abigail's dress that illustrate the whole development of complexity: the stripes are modulated by her body and they become increasingly more complex from her neck down her body to her crossed legs, where moiree patterns begin. A purely visual comment! Excuse me. What does a zebra sound like? What key is it tuned to?

  • @jamesyaun
    @jamesyaun 5 років тому +1

    they sound good together. very nice.

  • @GarnettM
    @GarnettM 5 років тому +2

    I agree --I taught myself Clawhammer , But got really liking some Glen Camble tunes that Ashley Cambell And Carl Jackson plays -I totally have to shut off clawhammer to comprehend 3 finger style , Really like the way you play Abigail nice flow , I have big mechanics hands though .

  • @bobsyeruncle4841
    @bobsyeruncle4841 4 роки тому

    astounding incredible and other superlatives both maestros

  • @jonathanvernon7050
    @jonathanvernon7050 4 роки тому

    You guys are amazing

  • @timtravasos2742
    @timtravasos2742 4 роки тому

    Incredible sounds.

  • @tuber2u
    @tuber2u 5 років тому +1

    Fabulous, thank you!!

  • @blueman5924
    @blueman5924 5 років тому

    Pure magic ! This is why I love Bluegrass music

  • @GabrielVelasco
    @GabrielVelasco 5 років тому +1

    Fantastic. Beautiful. Wonderful. Amazing.

  • @suprchickn7745
    @suprchickn7745 4 роки тому +2

    That third scale Béla played near the end sounded like Phrygian or Phrygian Dominant mode. Signals Music Studio has some great theory lessons (guitar-based, however) on UA-cam that explain how theory works in a very musical way. Jake is a brilliant teacher, just look up Modes if you're interested. (Not affiliated, he's just a great teacher)

  • @jasonyoung6420
    @jasonyoung6420 6 років тому +10

    watching this made me realize what I absolutely love about banjo, and it also made me realize why I'll probable never play banjo.

  • @nyartist
    @nyartist 6 років тому +43

    This is great but as a clawhammer player myself I wish there was more to hear from Abigail

    • @pennsyltuckyreb9800
      @pennsyltuckyreb9800 2 роки тому +2

      Old time banjo always gets pushed to the background in "favor" of Scruggs/Bluegrass. It's the atmosphere of modern banjo today, unfortunately. Folk players are "fringe." But that's where the true soul of historical banjo will always be.

  • @Beakphoto
    @Beakphoto 6 років тому +10

    Wow, just... wow!

    • @ronkopald
      @ronkopald 6 років тому +1

      I know, right?

  • @julesotis13
    @julesotis13 5 років тому

    aside from this video being great well done and interesting... i hereby give this youtube posting the award for best most intelligent truly funny comments and in my scrolling i saw nary a rude mean dump one... that also tells us something...well done...varied...heart warming even

  • @Robb0h
    @Robb0h 6 років тому

    Loved this video!

  • @irishfield1
    @irishfield1 6 років тому +1

    Top artists ever Abigail and Bela topssssss

  • @AnnLippert1
    @AnnLippert1 2 роки тому

    GREAT VIDEO!

  • @bluto212
    @bluto212 5 років тому

    terrific video.

  • @tscoffey1
    @tscoffey1 6 років тому

    All joking aside - I got to see Bela perform a year ago with Chick Corea. Really addictive music he was playing. And his bass player was unbelievable!

  • @BenFairbank
    @BenFairbank 6 років тому +3

    Bela is amazing

  • @dannoharlski
    @dannoharlski 5 років тому

    I can almost do that "Round Peak" roll that A.W. demonstrates, but I keep getting a phantom hammer on sounding when I get ready for the pull off on the second fret. Nothing is easy when it comes to the banjo, but man do I love trying to tame that beast!

  • @gospeltruthtv
    @gospeltruthtv 5 років тому

    I love clawhammer & 3 finger played as a duet! I always loved Earl Scruggs & John McEuen playing Soldiers Joy together on the Will The Circle Be Unbroken album. Earl Was Earl & McEuen was playing clawhammer...that was 2 minutes of banjo heaven!

  • @patmcintire1536
    @patmcintire1536 6 років тому +3

    Glad that she mentions Riley Boggus!

  • @TotallyNotLoki
    @TotallyNotLoki Рік тому

    Riley Baugus is a great man. He played at my college recently, and we jammed afterwords. I got to play a fret less banjo he he made, which was neat.

  • @skipgetelman3418
    @skipgetelman3418 4 роки тому

    They are both masters

  • @gregt4202
    @gregt4202 6 років тому

    Great video!