Nissan Leaf vs VW e-Golf vs Renault Zoe - what's the best electric car in 2018? | What Car?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 чер 2024
- What's the best electric car you can buy? The new 2018 Nissan Leaf promises plenty, but is it better than the Renault Zoe and Volkswagen e-Golf?
Save on a new Nissan Leaf: www.whatcar.com/nissan/leaf/h...
Save on a new Renault Zoe: www.whatcar.com/renault/zoe/h...
Save on a new Volkswagen e-Golf: www.whatcar.com/volkswagen/go...
New videos are uploaded to What Car? each week. Don't miss a single one. Subscribe now: goo.gl/GlVQ58
Visit our website at www.whatcar.com/
What Car? is the UK's biggest car-buying brand and has been helping Britain's car buyers make purchasing decisions for more than 40 years. Our tests are widely regarded as the most trusted source of new car advice.
This channel brings you trusted reviews on all the new models on the market, all the latest first drives, reader reviews, and great car-buying advice.
All reviews are available in full online at Whatcar.com - the UK's leading car-buying website, offering trusted reviews and data on every new car. The website also offers advice on car leasing, new car deals and new and used cars for sale.
Follow What Car? here:
LIKE What Car? on Facebook: goo.gl/yv5jF8
FOLLOW What Car? on Twitter: goo.gl/SJzmT8
Check out our full video catalog: goo.gl/OIGYuS
#WhatCar #GroupTest #NissanLeaf - Авто та транспорт
My 2016 egolf has been trouble free for 3.5 years. No service needed
Owner of a 2014 leaf all i can say is great car
I could never have imagined that a Golf is the same size as a Golf
Leaf all day long. Had a 30kwh now got the 62kwh +3 zero with all the toys!
The Leaf doesn't have a real world range of less than 100 miles. They've been producing the 30kwh car for 2 years which does over 100 miles.
Also regenerative braking doesn't use the brakes to generate electricity. The electric motor effectively turns into an alternator.
Yet another EV review video by people who don't really understand what they're reviewing and consequently is full of inaccuracies.
Real world range of 90 miles to be precise, we where over generous in our estimation.
They have to make it understandable to people who don't know about regen, so they just call it 'the brakes'
I drove all three and bought the golf. And I never looked back. A friend of mine has a Zoe, also a great car, but for me its the golf.
Type 2 CCS will become the mandatory format that all new charging stations must support soon. I wouldn't be too happy that Nissan are still pushing Chademo when they are the only car using it in Europe. Especially when the Leaf already has a type 2 socket so it wouldn't have killed them to put a couple of DC pins under it and enabled the vehicle to charge from both CCS or Chademo.
The Leaf isn't trying to be a Rolls-Royce.
Best comment for a while.
Rolls-Royce needs to make (some) electric cars.
Leaf is by far and away the most appealing electric car.
Thanks for testing the range of the vehicles. Similar weather locally in winter and this is of great concern.
I will definitely wait for the leaf with the larger 64Kwh battery (with the all important thermal management that is absent on the current model).
because its biggst.. big and heavy is NOT good for EV cars.. so I take the Zoe.. anytime.
You forgot the Leaf has no battery cooling system. Which makes it very slow charging after the second Rapid Charge. That to me is a big negative.
Took delivery of my e-Golf yesterday. Got approximately £13,500 off list price of £35,053 including extras. That's £4,500 from the government, £5,500 VW Diesel scrappage against a car worth about £2.K and a further £3,500 dealer discount. That brings it down to £22,000, a much more attractive price. Range on first trip about 130 miles including about 50 at motorway speeds, but it was a lovely warm day - good for the battery, bad for the air con.
i really like my leaf 62kwh no problem and 2000km + run now
value after 3 years £5500? I bought my battery owned zoe ze40 for 18.900 and the cheapest 3 year old one in the whole UK was 18000. You're using battery leased zoe 22kwh prices to calculate depreciation on the battery owned 41kwh one? ridiculous
Thanks I've just bought a leaf 🍃 today 😊
Regenerative braking does not use the brakes to slow/recharge the battery, my dude
They still call hybrids CVTs... Sometimes there's no hope in this...
Was going to say the same thing:)
for e pedal it does use a blend of both to slow down
John Wu nop...
John is correct. Whilst the e pedal mainly uses the motor to break it does use brakes to bring the car fully to a halt.
The "best" electric car is the one that "best" suits your needs. If you drive hundreds of kilometers/miles per day (some people do) then an EV might not be for you. If however, like most people, you drive 30-50 miles (50-80 kilometers) per day, then you have some practical EV choices. Battery/charging technology is advancing and will catch up with most drivers' needs in the near future. I for one will not miss the stink, noise and heat of ICE propulsion systems (that have remained relatively unchanged for the past 100 years).
Would be interesting to see what the range is for different types of driving
The discount available on a Zoe is much larger than suggested and this needs to be factored in on running costs against an ice car. Also you can buy Zoe or leaf under three years old from £4k to £7k. Now compare runnings costs ! They blow ice cars out of the water. Today's news, petrol going up another 15per litre!
I'm starting my fourth year in a Renault Fluence, limited range yes! But you really can make an EV work for you. Warning once you own one, there is no going back.
So what do you think the third car will be if they do a similar head to head between the Tesla Model X and the Jaguar i-Pace?
Ioniq?
you need an updated version of this when the new zoe comes out and maybe even toss in a model 3...
Model 3 is almost double the price.
I have a 2017 Leaf I bought new for $18,435 after $10K Power company discount &$7,500 fed tax credit. I average 4.2 miles per kWh commuting to work @ 65mph and I pay .06 cents kWh. That's .014 cents a mile. Starbucks just raised a basic coffee to to $2.15 which is what it cost me to drive 150 miles. That is what EV's are all about. My Leaf does everything I require at fraction of the operating cost an ICE car and no consideration of the price of gas. I'm selling my 40 mpg Yaris. 1 gal gas = 33.7 kWh which cost me less then $2, and @ 4.2 miles per kWh I get over 140 MPG equivalent @ $2.00 a gal. Long trip? Rent a car!
Joe Sparks what you say there?
6¢ a kWh? That is dirt cheap, I pay double that and that is slightly below average in the US.
Joe Sparks I just purchased a 2018 Leaf. Had it for a week. Love it already.
Please compare chevy bolt vs kia vs hiyundai vs nissan leaf also ..!
Doug Revolta - what a great name to review electric cars ! 🙂 The e Golf wasn't designed for electric the VW id 3 is now a better bet. But the LEAF is still head and shoulders above the competition.
While the Zoe has this ridiculously old radio and navigation system it can be hacked quite easily to have Android Auto. The new 2018 Zoe has this already activated when bought. These system is far superior to everything that car manufacturers beside Tesla provide.
Here in the US you would have to test the Chevy Bolt with them. But including that and the Ioniq my choice is the Leaf.
Leaf not so good on a proper long journey due to its battery thermal protection, though most people do short journeys regularly.
Ive driven from Edinburgh Scotland to Silverstone Circuit in one and it was fine. Although that was the first Generation.
Blaze 125
The second gen was compared to the Hyundai ioniq on a long trip which has lower range but after three quick charges the leaf was three hours behind. The ioniq can quick charge continuously unlike the leaf which reverts to slow charge on the third stop.
By the time you have a need for a third quick charge, you've covered 720km.
2LegHumanist in hot weather it seems to be worse.
Great name Doug. A petrol/diesel car will be worthless when coming to sell in future. I would go Leaf.
I reckon Ionic would have something to say about that last statement. The best is the Tesla but realistic price for the masses has to Hyundia Ionic.
which one has the most important feather, battery thermal management ??? wake up guys
You should have spoke about battery management
I wonder about E-Golf. You cant order them any more. ZOE LEAF IONIQ would be better.
Which car has the rear independent suspension? I'll take the one that has it! Obviously!
Well since this comparison was made pretty recently were are : Hyundai Kona ? Kia Soul ? Hyundai Ioniq ? BMW - i3 ? Tesla 3 ?
Now its time to compare Leaf with Hyundai Ioniq. My favorite is Hyundai.
Since there's no restriction on price mentioned, Tesla makes the best electric cars currently. With the Model S arguably being the best. (Range, Acceleration, Technology, future potential (software updates))
The Zoe might be the cheapest, however it’s the only one of the three with compulsory battery leasing which in the real world makes it by far the most expensive to run. The Leaf is an absolute bargain for an EV in today’s market.
Jonathan Harrison when buying a zoe you can lease the battery or buy it outright. Also when I ordered my zoe in December i got a £6,500 discount on top of the grant so bringing the price down to £13k which is great for the car
Edward Purkis that’s encouraging Renault have followed Nissan with the purchase option but it’s easy to see why they are being so coy on their website and configurator about that cost of optional battery purchase. Looks like around £7k, bringing a base Zoe to the mid-£20k’s after government incentives. For a sparsely equipped very small car that’s a pretty ridiculous RRP, and although there’s always room to haggle, it’s too a high a point to start negotiations.
I like the Zoe a lot, I also think it’s possibly the best looking small car on the market despite its age, but Renault need to get their act together on pricing, or Nissan will just own the compact EV market.
Jonathan Harrison yes the pricing varies greatly dealer by dealer, they are not supportive of customers, Nissan on the other hand are super helpful and supportive, the base zoe is low 20k which is a lot for the car yes only if it comes down with discounts to 15k ish is it worth it. The leaf is a better car if you can afford it but the zoe is great at the right price.
Edward Purkis you also just get so much more for your money with the Leaf, it’s well equipped even in base spec and is a proper Golf sized 5 seater. It doesn’t have the style of the Zoe but it’s a dramatic improvement over the outgoing model.
I paid less than £18 k for a Zoe with metallic black paintwork and battery purchase. The other cars are better to drive but the range and price of the Zoe were the clincher. Take it easy in the summer and 200 miles is possible.
You forgot to test the Ionic with this lot.
Probably couldn't get one.
Scottish Leaf Owner sold out
How ironic
this. I hope they do an update
HeavyRayne b
You forgot the charging speed at a simple 22KW Loading station - the most Loading stations in Europe . . .
Meanwhile, here in the United States (or at least in the Midwest), it is rare to see a charging station faster than 10kw
The word volt in doug's second name! Coincidence I think not!
Why not use the new more powerfull version of the zoe with 110hp. Why is an ICE car used as benchmark? Why is the ionoq missing? Otherwise quite good review in real circumstances.
Didn't agree about only buying an EV for saving money. They are a lot more than that
That depends entirely on how much driving you do. My Nissan Leaf will completely pay for itself in fuel savings in 7 years.
Yes! I already bought a Leaf!
Is AC heater be come battrey down INEED your advise
"Egolf comes with CCS" as he plugs in a Type 2 cable. Doh!!!
He also said the leaf is the only one with heated seats but then showed the golf interior and you can see the heated seat buttons 😂
But do they have seated heats
You did not test the latest version of the Renault Zoe which is faster
Sorry do not agree with comments on tall people easily fitting in leaf and golf. I cant fit easily or comfortably in either. the best was the Zoe by a country mile waiting to oct 2019 for revised model see if its still as spacious
Good balanced review overall, with a few rough edges. E.g., 7:52 -- no mention of e-Golf's adaptive LED headlights? Apparently they are directional -- and a big convenience and safety plus.
I would go for leaf, if it's interiour wouldn't be like 2006 car. Hope they will fix it
Where’s the ioniq you knobbers
Not just that but also many others full EV models like : Hyundai Kona ? Kia Soul ? Chevy Bolt ? BMW - i3 ? Tesla 3 ?
different standards for range isn't a fair test really is it ?
Good.....
Leaf higher power,range,space and lower cost whereas volkswagen has adjustable steering, are you kidding? To me there is no comparison. Personally own a volkswagen, high price and low quality, cheats. Shame on them.
No mention of the Leaf Quick Charge/overheating battery foibles, nor that it is just a re-bodied first generation car. All have insufficient range for a typical low mileage owner and the depreciation is horrific, again no mention of that. Frankly, although worthy, there’s a long, long way to go before I would even consider any of them.
charging speed, thermal management system, heat pump or resistive heating, you missed all this info
Why to me the new leaf is very similar to the micra?
You've not done a true comparison!!!! You've omitted the Hyundia Ioniq EV, also the Kia Sol (even though it does not look very attractive). Also there is a new testing regime WLTP. Which is a better test of predicted range instead if NEDC. Please amend your review
Shevrolet Bolt is also a good electric car.
niki123489 it is, but it’s not available in the UK, also GM sold the Vauxhall/Opal division to Peugeot group.
The soul is a nice car. It's almost the only suv EV
They tested the most popular
love nissan
What about the Chevy bolt
Like Zoe the most
Zoe is too small.
Can you buy the whole zoe and the battery
Yes
The best sono motors
Have they stopped selling BMW i3 ?
I truly hope so.
Not that I'm aware of... In fact BMW has unleashed a slightly sportier variant, the i3s.
You never mention a cars looks, and most car makers don't seem to give a stuff either. I really love the look of my Zoe, I can't help but look back at it as I walk away and it gives me a lovely warm feeling inside just to see it in a morning. I wouldn't be getting that from either of the others. I was particularly disappointed with the new Leaf. I had discounted the mark 1 for other reasons but it was a good looking car, the new one? Anonymous at best and can't be distinguished from other nissans. The golf? Just boring. I think I must in in the minority for finding this feature as important as any other (judging by some of the dross people buy), but it wouldn't hurt manufacturers to make an effort, would it?
93 miles to 135 mile range is no way near real world range .if i t's not at least 200 mile range I wouldn't spend the money
Intro song?
Not sure why Ioniq was left out here ... it's quite commonly available
Andrej Gobec only in California
fento r what do you mean? It is sold here. I think it went on sale here before the US in fact.
Just to be sure we're all on the same page ... what I meant is, it's quite commonly available in EU. I see them all the time. Not sure about UK, but I'd wager you have them in all the salons as well. Really baffling why it was omitted from the test. If anything it fits the group way more than Zoe ....
Actually, if anything it would kick Leaf's butt, because it has way superior battery management system. So, again ... well researched guys, next time you compare superminis do it without the Golf, eh ...
Ioniq exists in mild hibrid, PHEV and eletric versions. Look it up ...
Dirty Donki there is a full electric version, it's a fair bit more expensive than the hybrid. But the battery is almost 3 times the size.
no mention of nissan leafs rapidgate
What car? Hyundai Ioniq.
So first spot goes to Tesla model3, then ioniq, and 40kw Zoe
And you also forgot the Kia Soul EV.
What about tesla???
3:25 Regen uses the motor not the brakes!!
Ioniq and i3 are missing.
Tune at 0:00 and at 0:08
What about the Tesla Model 3
Hi Gary, Model 3 isn't available in the UK yet, as soon as it is the road test team will be putting it through all our usual testing & new Real Range testing: www.whatcar.com/news/what-car-real-range-which-electric-car-can-go-farthest-in-the-real-world/n18159 😃
@@whatcar I know the Model 3 Isn't available in the UK yet, but your headline doesn't say what's the best car to buy. It says what is the best car
Columns it tabulations and illustrations easy to use and viewings video designed set article ones.
The 2018 and newer versions of the Leaf looks so much BETTER. Previous years the front and rear lights looked ridiculous but I'm biased towards my e-Golf.
Why is Domhnall Gleeson reviewing cars?
Hyundai Ionic is missing , its a shame a great car is not being taken serious
Why does no one ever show a full set of golf clubs in the back with out putting down the back set ????????????????
nice review
Hyundai ionic, Chevrolet Bolt?
What about scratchy dash panels surely this is just as important
Nissan 👍🏻
It's up to the customer what constitutes a deal breaker, and a non telescoping steering wheel is a deal breaker in my book.
Great review, electric cars....the future ?
This doesn't mean older cars with ICEs are banned however.
How can you ban something in the future not knowing what will replace it. Also a small 10kw battery and electic motor/ petrol engine in a ford focus would be an alternative
Yep! ICE is banned from 2040 but that's ridiculous. It will soon be moved to 2030 is my guess and anyway no one will be wanting to buy a fossil fuel car post 2025.
@Chris Hart I have no idea what you are talking about? Battery electric will obviously replace the ICE.
A small battery + ICE is called a hybrid and they are about to go extinct.
EVs are not cars as we traditionally know them. They are tech on wheels and as such will get better and cheaper way faster than most people think.
Pete Coventry new sales of ICE will be banned from 2040, all the cars bought in 2039 can stay and be used. Also after 2040 an ICE car with a very small battery and electric motor (hybrid) will still be available to buy.
@Chris Hart Sorry but you are deluded. We are dealing with information technologies here. The idea that someone would be buying an ICE car in 2039 is just hilarious.
By 2025 EVs will have 300+ miles ranges, amazing performance and will cost less than 20k.
By then the charging infrastructure will be ubiquitous.
Total lifetime running costs of an EV will be a fraction of an ICE car (helped of course by the fact that by 2025 about 30% of the world's energy will come from renewables).
Public opinion is shifting rapidly now. The only ICE cars you will be able to buy in 2039 will be classics and you'll probably need a special licence and have to pay lots of money to drive them.
Regen does not use brakes to regenerate energy. It uses motor to slow car down.
Only Zoe can use 3 phase charging. At home, that is 22kW, which is full charge in 3 hours.
On Leaf and Golf two lower pins are left blank, so they can use only single phase 7kW charge. A shame.
BTW Zoe uses same connector as Tesla for rapid charge, and VW (and other Germans) had to bodge CCS onto type 2 to have rapid charge.
a i-dynamic will never be work £5k after 3 years. Are you using the price of lease battery 22khw models to price a used battery owned 41khw model? makes no sense
I know right - a 3 year old i-Zoe for £5k, now that would be a billy bargain. Unfortunately they STILL seem to be about £6/7k+ but with a battery lease 😖
@@chrisweston9764 ye i can find zoe for 6k or 13k with a battery lease or other without it, but how does that work? how much time you have to pay the battery?
If only they made the Leaf look like the Golf :D
Whats the point its too expensive in my country and the orignal leaf and the 30kwand24kw leaf is becoming kinda affoadable where i live and all the bloody car dealers hate ev's where i live.
7:22 It hast android Auto!
As this point it is Nissan Leaf which is the best but one should really always ask which is best for me instead of going with the heard! I'm still one of those that thinks electric cars will come in masses, but only after maybe 20-30 years from now?
I think the interest and adoption is building increasingly fast now, and mass adoption within 10 years. Just read about the development programmes of most of the manufacturers. Plus the much cheaper fuel and cleaner air a big attraction.
But the batteries are still miles away from beeing fast to charge (how many thousand promises of new battery technologies has there been but none have made it to production?) -> This is what a think will be the dealbreaker and that will take time to solve.
It's not a dealbreaker for many people because you charge the battery overnight, or while you work or shop. Every day I leave my house with a full range. So far have not needed to use a public charger at all. No trips to gas station either.
Jason Baker what about people that don’t have access to charger at home. Condos townhomes apartments. And if you did research the basic charging cord you get with a Tesla doesn’t even charge your battery once the temp drops below 0 degrees
Wrong, the EV's will take over within the next 10 years.
Tesla Model 3 is better than the 3 series, c class and a4.
Good video. Doesn't matter how good/bad the Golf is, as I will never buy any VW product again. I would be too embarrassed to be seen in them, as a bit of an environmentalist.
sane here. disgraceful comany who conned people and damaged air quality
But the new Nissan Leaf is still UGLEEEEEE!
Might not be pretty in looks, but certainly is pretty in driving
So the next model needs to be both, goodlooking and good to drive.
hopefully
The best is Hyundai Kona EV.
all these cars interiors look dated and crap still compared to the BMW i3 lol and that came out in 2014 lol and yep the BMW i3 with range extender beats all these
The chevy bolt is the best. I do 280km at -33c
Charles Cloutier talk to me in 10 years and we will see how much a Chevy costs in repairs. Don’t get me wrong great lease vehicle but purchase fuck noo
leaf = rapidgate
The Leaf's infotainment is horrible. Does no-one else notice the stretched graphics? Did the designers forget that they were designing for a 16:9 screen instead of a 4:3 screen?