The clean Katana channel is modelled on a JC 120. The crunch channel is modelled on a Bassman. Turn the gain down on the crunch, and the volume right up, and you get those classic Fender cleans. Hope this helps.
Yeh, I like my cables to be colourful, it's quite handy to have a sort of colour coding if you run an effects loop. I've bought great quality green/blue/red/yellow/purple guitar cables online at Visiosound. They're their own brand of cables and they're a great price. They are well worth checking out. 👍
@@JammyGit I use little colored tie wraps just at the plugs at both ends, so that's the only thing you can see what's what. On a dark stage I find it better and ecstatically more pleasing to have black cables lying around. You just have to cable route them a bit so you won't trip over them.
Pete is magnificently talented. And I am ever surprised at Bea's skill. He's a metalhead that can throw down jazz, blues, rock, and folk with anyone. Such enjoyable videos. It's just a shame London is so far away. Andertons would be have all my business.
Sto Osam I’ll bet these froods know where their towels are. That hoopy Ford Prefect claims to be from Guildford, but it turns out that he is from a small planet somewhere in the vicinity of Betelgeuse.
well, both have transistor poweramps, though. So, basically the "power control" is just a second master volume, really, since modern poweramp transistors should never actually reach the point of being pushed into clipping and therefore have a strictly linear response on the master volume. It basically is just a labeling thing for guitarists who have grown accustomed to those powersoaks on valve amps, where they actually do something, tonewise. (On another note: the amount of volume that pushes the speaker might very well influence the tone, though. Very lightweight neodym magnet speakers probably will sound way better than heavyweight oldschool celestions, and on very low volumes both might sound worse than an Impuls Response Plugin). In other words: just use the master volume with any transistor poweramp, really. You can even take one of those hybrid mini heads (valve in preamp / transistor in poweramp) and just run them out of the sent of the fx loop and into a IR plugin. Its no witchcraft, really.
You dont need a power control on a solid state amp. The sound does not change when using the master volume, like it does on valve amps. I find it weird that they even put that power control on the katana, since it seriously is nothing but useless.
Finally someone takes the clean tone of an amp to the test. Thanks. You two should record an album together. Great playing. Goes to shoe you. Doesn’t matter the guitar or amp. Real playing is what counts.
I'm willing to bet that 0.5w setting sells more Katanas than all the other features combined. If Fender was trying to steal some thunder from Boss with this amp, i think they may have barked up the wrong tree by chasing the consumer who gigs with a modelling amp. If youre gigging a modeling amp, odds are youre practicing with the same amp. I cant really work out who the Fender is for. Great playing and banter as usual from Bea & DP. Cheers guys!
Except that Fender's modelling amps are not the Champion series but the Mustang GTs, which if I'm not mistaken are more expensive than comparable Boss Katana amps. The Champions are less versatile, with about a dozen set amp voicings and a small selection of onboard effects.
Except the fender gt's are absolute garbage. I bought the low wattage gt first, hopping on the fender amp bandwagon, and returned it within a week. Amp models were shite. Everything sounded Hi-Fi and like it was in a cardboard box. Let alone the android app was buggy as crap, not anywhere near public release ready. Returned it within a week and got the katana 50, and a great pair of studio headphones for the same money. Best decision ever. I cant sing the praises of the Katana more. And this was before the market was flooded with Katana reviews.
John Borchardt The new firmware of the Mustang GT is supposed to offer massive improvements - but I am with you, I would also opt for the Katana, given the overall package.
Katana is still King to people who Live in an apartment Have small children Married to someone who hasnt suffered hearing loss. Has a neighbor Has a roommate Is not Chappers Wants to own 1 amplifier affordably. Fender is the new King of...everyone else?
As always, a solid video from these gents! Quick FYI To those saying the Katana loses in the clean department, the use of the power amp stage (always max it out on the Katana) and sneaky amps as opposed to the stock will easily get it to the level of the Fender cleans in this video. I say this not as a Katana owner (although I am) but as a studio owner/engineer who has a Rivera era Fender Twin II, one of the rarest Twins ever made. When using the Katana as noted above you would be surprised how close it can get! Regardless of what one prefers, it's great that the consumer has so many choices these days. Thanks lads for this video!
You guys give the best and most comprehensive demos of products. I really appreciate it. Hopefully you prevent a lot of buyer's remorse from showing the actual capabilities of products.
Damn it, i own a Katana 50 - with the Katana you have to use the model you like most and then adjust the gain! For crunch: I use brown sound with low gain, then add the in-built tube overdrive pedal for hi-gain
You know that new fender reminds me of the one I had ( They look verrrrry similar ). It was a FM65R. It was a solid state old school tweaker. Very similar to the idea here but from early 2000s. They discontinued it fairly early on. I cranked it for 10 years before I blew it up at practice one day! Now I`ve got myself an AC30c2 which has some upgraded components. Love you guys!!! Great coverage, great content! Cheers!!
I wasn't too surprised. With the work Fender have put in to the Tonemaster amps and the new range of pedals, they definitely have a team their that knows solid state tone.
I bought the Fender on the basis of this review. I play blues, mostly clean through a Fender Vibrolux, sometimes with some mild crunch. I've been thinking about the Katana for a small practice amp for some time but I don't need the heap of effects. I'm glad I didn't make up my mind sooner :)
If you like playing blues than there is small tubes amp by Fender, I forgot the nama I think it was Blues Junior. It was considered to be the best for blues. See Rhett Shull review.
I'm 5 years late to this party, but wow- what a fantastic video. This is exactly the kind of video I've been looking for: a genuine, unbiased comparison of these two amps with a spontaneous back-and-forth and immediate reactions and thoughts; I love it.
Hey i have both katanas and will love to see a speaker swap video with some popular speaker models, maybe some neodymium and alnico magnets as well, thanks and keep doing such a great work!!!.
I love the genuine surprise you both had for how well the Fender performed. That, more than anything, sold me on the product. Also, kudo's for using affordable guitars!! TY TY TY!! Oh, and Pete, eat a banana or two. They help alot for cramping muscles!
You two are, definitely, my two favorite musicians from andertons. Would love to see more of you together. Possible drums and guitar with Pete's backing tracks playing underneath? Different electric kits, amps, and guitars. Maybe Pete on bass and Bea on Guitar? Food for thought. Great stuff, per usual.
Great video!! Love that classic vibe strat! Would love to see a video with this fender amp And for you guys trying to sound like famous guitarists without using a pedal challenge! 👍🏼
I just bought the Katana 100W and love the way it handles high end pedals like my strymon Tineline in the effects loop and overdrives in the front end especially on the clean setting. But damn that fender sounds amazing!
Nice video guys and i loved the way you differentiate between both the amps and even i loved the tone of Fender it has the punch that's required for the gig.
The first video I have seen from you guys and all I can say is that you f*c*ing rock. I laughed so many times and you actually listen to the sound with your ears, not the tabloids and your eyes. How refreshing!
Got mine today and it nails the Fender clean tone 100%. Has that hard but warm attack on the treble and a deep but not flubby bass. You can play it as quietly as you like as it's solid state so no need for a voltage drop switch. The effects are really good and the only time you get the fizz (that all other solid state and modeling amps have) is on the Brit setting + distortion and high gain. Every other voice is fantastic. It's also dead simple to use, no menus or tiny LCD displays or apps. Just a few choices on the front panel knobs. I love it. As I said before, I usually play clean/crunch on a fender 68 Vibrolux and don't need 100+ effects. I honestly don't think anyone else does either. This amp is a perfect quiet practice substitute. Just an update for fairness. I was muting all the strings and testing the slapback on the reverb and noticed that the reverb continues on forever as a sort of background rumble until you play another note. This is not an issue as it doesn't happen when playing normally. I searched around and only found two other posts that mention this, but not many people own the amp yet and I suppose not many of them would necessarily post. I'd be interested to see if Anderton's can replicate this
Oh, you guys are in for it now! Yes, love the idea for the comments and questions videos. I love the show. My favorite youtube thing for guitar addicts of all stripes. Can you do more weird and bizarre pedals at your convenience? Perhaps a Lovetone Flange With no Name? The Metasonix TX-2 Butt Probe? The Frostwave FUNKADUCK? Just any kind of rare and exotic gear really. Thanks for all the excellent work! Rock on dudes.
I have a Boss Katana 50wt and love it. But after this vid I will look into the Fender amp. I loved the clean tones. I may even dual them up for fun. Use the fender for clean and katana for gain. At the price point, well worth the experiment.
To my ears the Fender wins on all tones. Not sure why all the surprise the Champion XD was killer. Thumbs up for these two guitars, finally something people might use. Lastly, this demo was a lot of fun, you guys are great together.
@@MrBossei They're full tube, but they've got some modelling that happens in the voicing stage before it hits the pre-amp tubes, and of course it has digital effects. To some people that means it must not sound good.
@@MrBossei & @James Close The Super Champ XD and X2 aren't "real" full tube amps, they are hybrids. The 12ax7 in them isn't for the preamp, it's the phase inverter for the power section. They are full tube power section, with a transistor w/ digital effects preamp. Remember there's no tubes in the preamp, the only full tube super champ on the market, is the original one from the 80s
This confirms my in-store impressions: when the Boss sounds awesome, it sounds "no more questions, I'll buy one" awesome. It isn't as sweet overall (or as easy to use) as the Fender GT series, but when it clicks, you don't want to change a thing.
Compared the Champion 40 this weekend with the katana 50, and I understand all the love for the Katana, it is a very good sounding and versatile amp (Boss digital effects are perfect) However one aspect can’t beat the Fender and that’s definitely its crystal clean sound! Still need to test how different the sound of the Champion 50 XL is.
This is an interesting demo, and the playing by both men is great. Regarding the one with a "fuller" sound and more punch, I suggest a couple of things to make the comparison more valid: Adjust the volume controls so both amps are the very close to the same loudness, and try to adjust the tone controls to see if they can make the Katana match the tone of the Fender. Then, A-B both amps using the same guitar and player playing the same stuff. Thanks.
4 роки тому
WEll... Now that's not what the Boss & Fender people want- A real comparison? Come on.... we all know that would too helpful. They need us to buy BOTH-Either right away or over time....
Fender is a big company. They're not going to let the Katana go unanswered. I kind of like the fact that they dropped this amp with no fanfare, and are just letting people make up their own minds about it. That shows a lot of confidence. Sounds like it's well earned in this case. Full disclosure, I do own a Katana 100, and think it's quite a cool device.
@Everything Not at all. They are massive and forward thinking. But the other big amp brands aren't going to just quit. Good to see Fender making it a fight.
@@Fektthis That will be an element I'm sure. If you blow the bugle big but the product is not well recieved, it just shouts 'we totally got this wrong and completely misjudged the market'. I believe that Fender are re-trying with an upgraded GT but I think that the damage is done for that amp.
Leave it to a guy whose *second language* is English to use the proper past tense of "sneak." Thank you, Danish Pete. You give me hope for the english language.
Well, am I wrong if I say that "sneaked" and "snuck" are both OK depending on how you treat the word (regular or irregular)? Just being curious newbie to English grammar :)
That first jam has so much 'feel', I keep 'rewinding' the video to watch it over and over again. I wanted to find out about the amps. but I haven't even watched the rest of the video yet.
I so appreciate your guys playing. And the fact that you play clean when you say you are clean. When the Chappers and the Captain do a video, even their clean is distorted.. I don't think they know what a clean sound is. They blow you ears off with in your face distortion. That might be their "style". But when you are reviewing gear, you need to also do what others would possibly do. And not everyone is a in your face distortion nuts. Thanks so much. Love your playing. Both of you are amazing players.
Would pay good money for the Fender with some of the Boss pedal stuff integrated. IMO shortcomings of the Katana speaker are very clearly illustrated here. But it’s impossible to ignore the overall value it represents especially at this end of the market. The Fender is a great, cheap amp. The Katana is a viable cheap complete signal path
Came into this video with my mind already made up on the katana. Left the video wanting the fender. HOWEVER, as a katana owner myself, I'd like to make 2 suggestions. 1. Try this comparison with a used katana. The stock speakers break in wonderfully, all the harshness and pokiness of mine is gone after a few months of heavy use. 2. Keep the master pinned to it's max setting and use the channel volume and gain knobs to control the volume instead. You'd be surprised how much of a difference in tone it makes. All that being said though, as a comparison between the two brand new amps being used as any amp typically would, I greatly preferred the sound of the fender and if it came down to it, I'd buy that one over the katana.
As someone who owns a Katana and has used an original Champion, (which this looks like a rebrand of) the Champion really loses out in a gain setting. The lack of a mid control really neuters it imo. Any sort of high gain gets muddy pretty quick. Takes pedals well, though. Edit: it seems they HAVE actually changed the gain section. My point on the muddiness still stands though.
I can definitely hear the harshness of a new speaker in that Kat.. I own a Kat too, and use the Per Channel EQ in a very meaningful way for almost all my channels.. I wonder what kind of tweaking you can do with the fender??
@@gavinw8835 "The lack of a mid control really neuters it imo" A James tone stack lacks a mid control and it's basically objectively superior to the Fender/Marshall 3-band tone stacks used in most amps. The James allows for a mid boost. Typical 3-band tone stacks do not.
at 2:48 the most impressive thing i noticed (apart from all the great playing ) was the percussive syncopation playing for a brief time by Rabea ..really cool playing ...my guess is he can hold a beat on a drum kit ....cos that was nice .
I'd have to say Fender for cleans and the Katana for higher gains stuff. Playing high gain metal stuff you NEED to have a low, high, _and mid_ controls! Plus the versatility of all those Boss effects is super nice to have with the Katanas. Not to mention all the customization when you plug it into a PC! Also, you can get a 12" speaker with the 50watt Katana, whereas with the Fender you don't get a 12" below the 100watt version.
@@niclastname Again, you are wrong. You don't need a mid knob. In fact, a bass-treble only circuit such as James allows for MORE mid control than the usual FMV tone stack. With the FMV (which is in traditional Fenders and Marshalls etc) you basically have a choice of scooped or more scooped. "Flat" (ish) eq is achieved only with mids at 10 and both bass and treble at 0. With James (or something similar) you can actually create a mid boost. If you want a mid boost with your usual, say, JCM800, you'll need an EQ pedal.
I don't get the whole idea of running the EQ at 12 o'clock and saying it sounds really bright. That's what the EQ is there for. Tweak it. Most people would want to hear what it's capable of, not what it sounds like if you don't use the EQ. Normally love your vids guys. Still liked this one. Just my 2c. Rock on!
Yes, but you didn't really get into what the EQ (or the amp voicing on the Fender) could really do. Not complaining, just asking for a followup video, I think...
@@andertons Yep. Start to finish. I know at one point you were tweaking it a bit but still saying the Katana sounded bright, then just changing to the other amp without resolving the issue. Look, as I said, I still like the vid. I agree the Fender sounded better. The Katana 50 has always lacked bottom end as you showed when you brought the Katana 100 in.
The idea is to show more or less what the amp's innate voice is, then demonstrate how that voice can be changed. Consider how many different amp manufacturers have established signature tonalities, then consider how effective (more precisely, ineffective) tone knobs are with regard to bridging those gaps.
Without a doubt the main difference is with the speaker. I have worked at Celestion in the past and different speakers in the same cab make almost as much difference as the amp driving it. Great to see a budget amp with a more up market speaker in it and the guys in Ipswich, and China, do great job of building those drivers.
I own both, if you prefer clean Fender is better, Katana better w gain. That being said, both great amps and neither is bad in an area where you should take it back. If you like the tinker, Katana is where it's at. I prefer Fender cleans and I'm more of a plug n play type, so I use the Fender. Just too lazy to sell the Kantana, but it's a good amp I wish I used more. Hope you're enjoying it.
8:30 Not just boss effects... has lots of other stuff too (big muff, proco rat, all sorts of stuff) The fender sounds pretty good, but I love my Katana... :) 15:00 Not really a surprise that the Fender clean sound is better (that is what Fender is known for). That being said, I don't play a whole lot of clean stuff... :)
Yeah, and that's why everyone who doesn't play clean should probably get the katana. Definitely more bang for the buck...BUT I got the Fender because Katana can't touch the Fender clean and that's what I personally like. No wrong answer here.
You guys should start your own UA-cam channel with just you playing... no talking... just playing, for hours and hours... great stuff
I agree with the no talking.
heyy ola
I personally like Bea and Pete talking 🤓
Great, more people telling them what to do.
The Jams of Anderton's TV
Just grabbed my guitar and jammed along with that intro there the 3 of us had a great time.....we should do this again some time
Chris Neary hahahah
Lol great
You are so right. We three are the best of buds.
I think I will join the band..
lol
+1 for using fairly priced and good guitars :-)
Chappers and the Captain would have used a PRS Custom 24 and a Fender Custom shop Strat.
Guitar choice doesnt affect the amp comparison
@@metalpuppet5798 It kinda does though.. Most folks that buy one of these amps would not be playing a '59 strat.. ;)
@@metalpuppet5798 - In my limited experience, some amps are forgiving of mediocre to junk pickups and some are not. I agree with the OP.
The Quantum pickups in the low/mid Ibz are win
The clean Katana channel is modelled on a JC 120. The crunch channel is modelled on a Bassman. Turn the gain down on the crunch, and the volume right up, and you get those classic Fender cleans. Hope this helps.
Yea sure 😂😅
Thank You
That’s how I run the Katana to get cleans. Gain all the way down and volume all the way up. You get that nice Hendrix “clean crunch.”
30% booster on green works nicely with these settings too...
Isn't it great that nobody has toxic opinions on here? ;)
I really like the white cables. You can see what you are plugged into. Sometimes it is hard to see. This makes it easy. Thanks!
Based on that idea they should each have their own color, like light blue and orange, or green and yellow
@@fritsvanzanten3573 Good point.. Perhaps Anderton's is listening???
Yeh, I like my cables to be colourful, it's quite handy to have a sort of colour coding if you run an effects loop. I've bought great quality green/blue/red/yellow/purple guitar cables online at Visiosound. They're their own brand of cables and they're a great price. They are well worth checking out. 👍
@@JammyGit
I use little colored tie wraps just at the plugs at both ends, so that's the only thing you can see what's what. On a dark stage I find it better and ecstatically more pleasing to have black cables lying around. You just have to cable route them a bit so you won't trip over them.
Ernie ball cables FTW
Pete is magnificently talented. And I am ever surprised at Bea's skill. He's a metalhead that can throw down jazz, blues, rock, and folk with anyone. Such enjoyable videos. It's just a shame London is so far away. Andertons would be have all my business.
Trevor Reniger which part is magnificently brilliant playing in this video?
Plus he’s a great drummer! And just seems like an overall good dude
They aren’t based in London. I travelled pretty far to visit Andertons recently. Great store, worth a litre trip.
Guildford ... about 35 minutes out of London Waterloo station
Sto Osam I’ll bet these froods know where their towels are. That hoopy Ford Prefect claims to be from Guildford, but it turns out that he is from a small planet somewhere in the vicinity of Betelgeuse.
Power control on the Katana is a superb feature in my opinion - as someone who pretty much only plays at home.
well, both have transistor poweramps, though. So, basically the "power control" is just a second master volume, really, since modern poweramp transistors should never actually reach the point of being pushed into clipping and therefore have a strictly linear response on the master volume. It basically is just a labeling thing for guitarists who have grown accustomed to those powersoaks on valve amps, where they actually do something, tonewise. (On another note: the amount of volume that pushes the speaker might very well influence the tone, though. Very lightweight neodym magnet speakers probably will sound way better than heavyweight oldschool celestions, and on very low volumes both might sound worse than an Impuls Response Plugin).
In other words: just use the master volume with any transistor poweramp, really. You can even take one of those hybrid mini heads (valve in preamp / transistor in poweramp) and just run them out of the sent of the fx loop and into a IR plugin. Its no witchcraft, really.
Totally agree, I found that function KEY when I need to play in my bedroom at low volume. Unfortunately I live in a flat, so I need to be very quiet!
That's the whole reason I'm buying the amp in a few months, that and the versatility of tones you can get though the thing.
0.5 mode is great.
You dont need a power control on a solid state amp. The sound does not change when using the master volume, like it does on valve amps. I find it weird that they even put that power control on the katana, since it seriously is nothing but useless.
Rabea and Pete! A great start to the week!
The amp shootout is nice. But I'm here for Pete and Rabea!
Agreed, they are awesome.
Rabea + Pete = instant click :D
Parcevaux Florent same here lol
I'm glad Chappers didn't do this review. It's nice to hear an amp without a wall of gain.
Exactly
J Bolo. Chapters is not as good as he used to be. He doesn't play much anymore between business and family, apparently.
Agree 100 %!!!
I think they understand their capabilities, i love pete and rabea but it must be sad for chappers to read all these comparison comments
and 12 fret bend, same licks, boring shred
Finally someone takes the clean tone of an amp to the test. Thanks. You two should record an album together. Great playing. Goes to shoe you. Doesn’t matter the guitar or amp. Real playing is what counts.
I'm willing to bet that 0.5w setting sells more Katanas than all the other features combined. If Fender was trying to steal some thunder from Boss with this amp, i think they may have barked up the wrong tree by chasing the consumer who gigs with a modelling amp. If youre gigging a modeling amp, odds are youre practicing with the same amp. I cant really work out who the Fender is for.
Great playing and banter as usual from Bea & DP. Cheers guys!
Except that Fender's modelling amps are not the Champion series but the Mustang GTs, which if I'm not mistaken are more expensive than comparable Boss Katana amps. The Champions are less versatile, with about a dozen set amp voicings and a small selection of onboard effects.
I actually even gig with the 0.5W setting on :D
Except the fender gt's are absolute garbage. I bought the low wattage gt first, hopping on the fender amp bandwagon, and returned it within a week. Amp models were shite. Everything sounded Hi-Fi and like it was in a cardboard box. Let alone the android app was buggy as crap, not anywhere near public release ready. Returned it within a week and got the katana 50, and a great pair of studio headphones for the same money. Best decision ever. I cant sing the praises of the Katana more. And this was before the market was flooded with Katana reviews.
John Borchardt The new firmware of the Mustang GT is supposed to offer massive improvements - but I am with you, I would also opt for the Katana, given the overall package.
Katana is still King to people who
Live in an apartment
Have small children
Married to someone who hasnt suffered hearing loss.
Has a neighbor
Has a roommate
Is not Chappers
Wants to own 1 amplifier affordably.
Fender is the new King of...everyone else?
As always, a solid video from these gents! Quick FYI To those saying the Katana loses in the clean department, the use of the power amp stage (always max it out on the Katana) and sneaky amps as opposed to the stock will easily get it to the level of the Fender cleans in this video. I say this not as a Katana owner (although I am) but as a studio owner/engineer who has a Rivera era Fender Twin II, one of the rarest Twins ever made. When using the Katana as noted above you would be surprised how close it can get! Regardless of what one prefers, it's great that the consumer has so many choices these days. Thanks lads for this video!
Awesome playing! Keep continue to rock the world!
Ty for the honesty.
It was audible on this end. Night and day actually.
Good job.
You guys give the best and most comprehensive demos of products. I really appreciate it. Hopefully you prevent a lot of buyer's remorse from showing the actual capabilities of products.
I laughed way too hard with them plugin and unplugging cables around 16:58. The editing is always great in these videos!
anything with gain = katana is better
clean shimmery stuff= fender
Not the most shocking result is it?
@@SixString_J5 didnt say it was shocking did I?
@@skippityblippity8656 No you didn't. The sarcasm was not aimed at you. I even 'liked' your comment. Cheers!
@@SixString_J5 well if thats the case im sorry for my overreaction
have a good one
Well, it does surprise me when I see civilised conversations in a UA-cam comment section haha
Dude I'm addicted to this channel's vids. Keep em coming !
Best yet . Nice playing makes all the difference. You showed the capacity of a little gem in a spontaneous setting . Perfect . Thanks 🙏
That double bend at 2:42 had me laughing right along with Pete. TASTY.
Damn it, i own a Katana 50 - with the Katana you have to use the model you like most and then adjust the gain! For crunch: I use brown sound with low gain, then add the in-built tube overdrive pedal for hi-gain
I'm just enjoying how this two guys play! Man, that clean jam sounded really sweet!!
Very tasty playing! Great to see/hear Rabea contain himself and not shred. Pete is great as always.
for me, Fender win on clean channel, but Katana win on versatility.
well written comment!
Agreed!
Yeah, I think this sums it up well.
You want nice interesting cleans on the Katana, use the acoustic voicing on your electric guitar. You're welcome!
Setuja borr
Wow. That intro jam had an ATOMIC ASSLOAD of groove!!!
You know that new fender reminds me of the one I had ( They look verrrrry similar ). It was a FM65R. It was a solid state old school tweaker. Very similar to the idea here but from early 2000s. They discontinued it fairly early on. I cranked it for 10 years before I blew it up at practice one day! Now I`ve got myself an AC30c2 which has some upgraded components. Love you guys!!! Great coverage, great content! Cheers!!
I come back to listen to that intro groove periodically. It’s so funky I can smell it over the internet!
That was a really nice review.
Two different colored cables and maybe a few text labels for the amp being played would be helpful.
I wasn't too surprised. With the work Fender have put in to the Tonemaster amps and the new range of pedals, they definitely have a team their that knows solid state tone.
This is one of the best reviews you guys have put up for a while!! Many thanks and great playing :) :)
Probably the best guitar intro I’ve seen on this channel!
Amp, guitar, and a lead for around 400? Sounds like Merry Christmas ...
I bought the Fender on the basis of this review. I play blues, mostly clean through a Fender Vibrolux, sometimes with some mild crunch. I've been thinking about the Katana for a small practice amp for some time but I don't need the heap of effects. I'm glad I didn't make up my mind sooner :)
I have the Katana too, but got the Fender for the same reason. Just kept both...I prefer the Fender. :)
If you like playing blues than there is small tubes amp by Fender, I forgot the nama I think it was Blues Junior. It was considered to be the best for blues.
See Rhett Shull review.
I agree with last post. You guys have a killer groove and real guitar tone. Love the classic vibe strat.
I'm 5 years late to this party, but wow- what a fantastic video. This is exactly the kind of video I've been looking for: a genuine, unbiased comparison of these two amps with a spontaneous back-and-forth and immediate reactions and thoughts; I love it.
Hey i have both katanas and will love to see a speaker swap video with some popular speaker models, maybe some neodymium and alnico magnets as well, thanks and keep doing such a great work!!!.
I love the genuine surprise you both had for how well the Fender performed. That, more than anything, sold me on the product. Also, kudo's for using affordable guitars!! TY TY TY!!
Oh, and Pete, eat a banana or two. They help alot for cramping muscles!
You two are, definitely, my two favorite musicians from andertons. Would love to see more of you together. Possible drums and guitar with Pete's backing tracks playing underneath? Different electric kits, amps, and guitars. Maybe Pete on bass and Bea on Guitar? Food for thought. Great stuff, per usual.
Great video!! Love that classic vibe strat! Would love to see a video with this fender amp And for you guys trying to sound like famous guitarists without using a pedal challenge! 👍🏼
That's a whole lot of talent in one room.
I just bought the Katana 100W and love the way it handles high end pedals like my strymon Tineline in the effects loop and overdrives in the front end especially on the clean setting. But damn that fender sounds amazing!
Nice video guys and i loved the way you differentiate between both the amps and even i loved the tone of Fender it has the punch that's required for the gig.
absolutely phenomenal playing, and very entertaining personalities!
Lovely jam performed by lovely people
There's got to be an A/B switch laying around somewhere!
The first video I have seen from you guys and all I can say is that you f*c*ing rock. I laughed so many times and you actually listen to the sound with your ears, not the tabloids and your eyes. How refreshing!
Lots of love for that intro jam!! And the one finger solo by Pete :))))
Unbelievable how good these two are!
You mean the amps or Pete and Bea?
@@ChrisBlackTV yes.
Got mine today and it nails the Fender clean tone 100%. Has that hard but warm attack on the treble and a deep but not flubby bass. You can play it as quietly as you like as it's solid state so no need for a voltage drop switch. The effects are really good and the only time you get the fizz (that all other solid state and modeling amps have) is on the Brit setting + distortion and high gain. Every other voice is fantastic. It's also dead simple to use, no menus or tiny LCD displays or apps. Just a few choices on the front panel knobs. I love it. As I said before, I usually play clean/crunch on a fender 68 Vibrolux and don't need 100+ effects. I honestly don't think anyone else does either. This amp is a perfect quiet practice substitute.
Just an update for fairness. I was muting all the strings and testing the slapback on the reverb and noticed that the reverb continues on forever as a sort of background rumble until you play another note. This is not an issue as it doesn't happen when playing normally. I searched around and only found two other posts that mention this, but not many people own the amp yet and I suppose not many of them would necessarily post. I'd be interested to see if Anderton's can replicate this
You guys are not allowed to be this good. It hurts our egos. Thanks for the great, informative video!
Oh, you guys are in for it now! Yes, love the idea for the comments and questions videos. I love the show. My favorite youtube thing for guitar addicts of all stripes. Can you do more weird and bizarre pedals at your convenience? Perhaps a Lovetone Flange With no Name? The Metasonix TX-2 Butt Probe? The Frostwave FUNKADUCK? Just any kind of rare and exotic gear really. Thanks for all the excellent work! Rock on dudes.
I have a Boss Katana 50wt and love it. But after this vid I will look into the Fender amp. I loved the clean tones. I may even dual them up for fun. Use the fender for clean and katana for gain. At the price point, well worth the experiment.
The Fender is awesome, gorgeous sound.
two years later and I can still listen to Pete and Rabea jam all day
Best way to start my morning is the first 4 minutes of this review!!!!! Great sounds gents!
To my ears the Fender wins on all tones. Not sure why all the surprise the Champion XD was killer. Thumbs up for these two guitars, finally something people might use. Lastly, this demo was a lot of fun, you guys are great together.
Champ XD was a tube (or a hybrid, depending on who you talk to) though.
@@ryanteacher8134 Fender Super Champ XD/X2 was/is tube-amps. Fender Champions are transistor-amps.
@@MrBossei They're full tube, but they've got some modelling that happens in the voicing stage before it hits the pre-amp tubes, and of course it has digital effects. To some people that means it must not sound good.
@@jamesclose2792 Yep. And they sound really good. Especially on the clean channel which is pure Fender-tone.
@@MrBossei & @James Close
The Super Champ XD and X2 aren't "real" full tube amps, they are hybrids. The 12ax7 in them isn't for the preamp, it's the phase inverter for the power section. They are full tube power section, with a transistor w/ digital effects preamp.
Remember there's no tubes in the preamp, the only full tube super champ on the market, is the original one from the 80s
This confirms my in-store impressions: when the Boss sounds awesome, it sounds "no more questions, I'll buy one" awesome. It isn't as sweet overall (or as easy to use) as the Fender GT series, but when it clicks, you don't want to change a thing.
Woohoo! Fantastic jam! One of you 2's absolute best. And that's sayin' sumpin'!
Thank you for the clean channel demo using more than jangly open G-C-D chords!!! keep it coming
Man, the two of you shuold just do like a two-hour jam session and just call it an album! I'd buy it! And study it thoroughly... ❤️
Compared the Champion 40 this weekend with the katana 50, and I understand all the love for the Katana, it is a very good sounding and versatile amp (Boss digital effects are perfect) However one aspect can’t beat the Fender and that’s definitely its crystal clean sound! Still need to test how different the sound of the Champion 50 XL is.
The intro to this video was so good! Love this vid
Great review, regardless of the products! Excellent job!
This is an interesting demo, and the playing by both men is great. Regarding the one with a "fuller" sound and more punch, I suggest a couple of things to make the comparison more valid: Adjust the volume controls so both amps are the very close to the same loudness, and try to adjust the tone controls to see if they can make the Katana match the tone of the Fender. Then, A-B both amps using the same guitar and player playing the same stuff. Thanks.
WEll... Now that's not what the Boss & Fender people want- A real comparison? Come on.... we all know that would too helpful.
They need us to buy BOTH-Either right away or over time....
I think the Fender crunch/distortion tones were very much lacking.
I always come back to this video for the playing at the beginning!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
My favourite players on the channel, great playing and a good demo of very reasonably priced combinations
Just bought the Boss Katana 50 and it’s killer for the money! Don’t say the Fender is better!! 🙈🙈🙈 Still think the Boss is ridiculous 🔥🔥🎸😍
The Boss is a nice amp for the money and pack full of 100 Boss effects
radialdrift 58
I prefer the Boss Katana. The Fender sounds... sort of muddy to my ears through my speakers.
@@patrickmaszun8906 I think that's more the Ibanez's fault than the Fender's.
But the Katana is still better.
I just got the Fender, but I mainly play clean. If I was into distorted tones I’d go for the katana.
You could make a delicious sandwich with that jam
davidf2281 PB(Pete and Bea) and Jam!
D Peters I like it! PBJ...
2:44 that john mayer "i Guess i just feel like" bend💗
Like your guitar choices! I like that you don't pick the expensive stuff all the time. Very thoughtful
Fender is a big company. They're not going to let the Katana go unanswered. I kind of like the fact that they dropped this amp with no fanfare, and are just letting people make up their own minds about it. That shows a lot of confidence. Sounds like it's well earned in this case. Full disclosure, I do own a Katana 100, and think it's quite a cool device.
If you dial your Katana tones using the computer, that puny Fender doesn't stand a chance.
@Everything Not at all. They are massive and forward thinking. But the other big amp brands aren't going to just quit. Good to see Fender making it a fight.
i'm under the impression the lack of fanfare is more a reaction to the blowback from their last foray into this market with the garbage GTs.
Katana 100 is the one. I almost wish I got the 2x12 though
@@Fektthis That will be an element I'm sure. If you blow the bugle big but the product is not well recieved, it just shouts 'we totally got this wrong and completely misjudged the market'. I believe that Fender are re-trying with an upgraded GT but I think that the damage is done for that amp.
Greatest intro so far Andertons!!
4:35 killed me, perfect edit. Insane intro jam too, super clean
I'm gonna get both and run a stereo rig.
In my office. 😭
Leave it to a guy whose *second language* is English to use the proper past tense of "sneak." Thank you, Danish Pete. You give me hope for the english language.
@@davman115 And this is why you never ever pull someone up on their grammar / spelling online!
I thought Danish Pete was just a nickname. His English is impeccable. Even now I know i can't really tell it isn't his first language
Well, am I wrong if I say that "sneaked" and "snuck" are both OK depending on how you treat the word (regular or irregular)? Just being curious newbie to English grammar :)
@@MrKultivar depending were you are
Another great video from my favorite music store in Great Britain!
glad to see you guys using what people can afford when doing demos
"Got my first real six string, played it til my pinky locked"
Till your fingers bled
Someone didn't watch until the end of the video.
I hope we're thinking of the same pinky...
I would love to see a comparison of a Blackstar ID core 40 and say the Boss Katana 50. Which do you think is the better amp?
You intros always top notch👌🤩
That first jam has so much 'feel', I keep 'rewinding' the video to watch it over and over again. I wanted to find out about the amps. but I haven't even watched the rest of the video yet.
I so appreciate your guys playing. And the fact that you play clean when you say you are clean. When the Chappers and the Captain do a video, even their clean is distorted.. I don't think they know what a clean sound is. They blow you ears off with in your face distortion. That might be their "style". But when you are reviewing gear, you need to also do what others would possibly do. And not everyone is a in your face distortion nuts. Thanks so much. Love your playing. Both of you are amazing players.
Would pay good money for the Fender with some of the Boss pedal stuff integrated. IMO shortcomings of the Katana speaker are very clearly illustrated here. But it’s impossible to ignore the overall value it represents especially at this end of the market. The Fender is a great, cheap amp. The Katana is a viable cheap complete signal path
Gotta say like many here, listening to you guys jamming is just too good. I could do that for hours.
I love pete's playing at the start, can see a song out of these two song.
Came into this video with my mind already made up on the katana. Left the video wanting the fender. HOWEVER, as a katana owner myself, I'd like to make 2 suggestions.
1. Try this comparison with a used katana. The stock speakers break in wonderfully, all the harshness and pokiness of mine is gone after a few months of heavy use.
2. Keep the master pinned to it's max setting and use the channel volume and gain knobs to control the volume instead. You'd be surprised how much of a difference in tone it makes.
All that being said though, as a comparison between the two brand new amps being used as any amp typically would, I greatly preferred the sound of the fender and if it came down to it, I'd buy that one over the katana.
As someone who owns a Katana and has used an original Champion, (which this looks like a rebrand of) the Champion really loses out in a gain setting. The lack of a mid control really neuters it imo. Any sort of high gain gets muddy pretty quick. Takes pedals well, though.
Edit: it seems they HAVE actually changed the gain section. My point on the muddiness still stands though.
I can definitely hear the harshness of a new speaker in that Kat.. I own a Kat too, and use the Per Channel EQ in a very meaningful way for almost all my channels.. I wonder what kind of tweaking you can do with the fender??
I have a feeling they're using the floor model katana which probably is already broken in. They said they just took the fender out of the box, though.
.@@ArthurStephenHicks Given the physics of speakers the Fender will sound even better when it's been broken in
@@gavinw8835 "The lack of a mid control really neuters it imo"
A James tone stack lacks a mid control and it's basically objectively superior to the Fender/Marshall 3-band tone stacks used in most amps. The James allows for a mid boost. Typical 3-band tone stacks do not.
That double bend thing that Bea does at 2:43 though 👌🏻❤️
Beena yes mate
Beena trucksy vibes
two fantastic machines! thanks for the demonstrativo!!
at 2:48 the most impressive thing i noticed (apart from all the great playing ) was the percussive syncopation playing for a brief time by Rabea ..really cool playing ...my guess is he can hold a beat on a drum kit ....cos that was nice .
I'd have to say Fender for cleans and the Katana for higher gains stuff. Playing high gain metal stuff you NEED to have a low, high, _and mid_ controls!
Plus the versatility of all those Boss effects is super nice to have with the Katanas. Not to mention all the customization when you plug it into a PC!
Also, you can get a 12" speaker with the 50watt Katana, whereas with the Fender you don't get a 12" below the 100watt version.
"Playing high gain metal stuff you NEED to have a low, high, and mid controls!"
Nope, you actually really don't.
@@isodoubIet Well yeah you don't NEED it. I just meant if you want it to sound good. Especially in a mix.
@@niclastname Again, you are wrong. You don't need a mid knob. In fact, a bass-treble only circuit such as James allows for MORE mid control than the usual FMV tone stack.
With the FMV (which is in traditional Fenders and Marshalls etc) you basically have a choice of scooped or more scooped. "Flat" (ish) eq is achieved only with mids at 10 and both bass and treble at 0. With James (or something similar) you can actually create a mid boost. If you want a mid boost with your usual, say, JCM800, you'll need an EQ pedal.
I don't get the whole idea of running the EQ at 12 o'clock and saying it sounds really bright. That's what the EQ is there for. Tweak it. Most people would want to hear what it's capable of, not what it sounds like if you don't use the EQ. Normally love your vids guys. Still liked this one. Just my 2c. Rock on!
Did you watch the full video?
Yes, but you didn't really get into what the EQ (or the amp voicing on the Fender) could really do. Not complaining, just asking for a followup video, I think...
@@andertons Yep. Start to finish. I know at one point you were tweaking it a bit but still saying the Katana sounded bright, then just changing to the other amp without resolving the issue. Look, as I said, I still like the vid. I agree the Fender sounded better. The Katana 50 has always lacked bottom end as you showed when you brought the Katana 100 in.
The idea is to show more or less what the amp's innate voice is, then demonstrate how that voice can be changed. Consider how many different amp manufacturers have established signature tonalities, then consider how effective (more precisely, ineffective) tone knobs are with regard to bridging those gaps.
My two favourite andertons!lovely playing lads
Without a doubt the main difference is with the speaker. I have worked at Celestion in the past and different speakers in the same cab make almost as much difference as the amp driving it. Great to see a budget amp with a more up market speaker in it and the guys in Ipswich, and China, do great job of building those drivers.
Best pre show jam ever!
I bought a Katana 50 about two weeks ago and I love it
But now I'm wondering if it was the right decision... it probably was because of the tone studio and versatility.
Tbh the 100w kat would have been the right decision.
Both the 50 and 100 are good.
Tone studio gives you way more options. So many pedals and sounds, deeper EQ and noise gate.
Kat50 is good if you want portability. It weighs nothing. I'd go the Artist over the 100.
I own both, if you prefer clean Fender is better, Katana better w gain. That being said, both great amps and neither is bad in an area where you should take it back. If you like the tinker, Katana is where it's at. I prefer Fender cleans and I'm more of a plug n play type, so I use the Fender. Just too lazy to sell the Kantana, but it's a good amp I wish I used more. Hope you're enjoying it.
I love this video and just ordered both of these amps If I could play like these guys I would be set!
Now this is an excellent review. You got everything correct! Good job Bea and The Danish Viking!
8:30 Not just boss effects... has lots of other stuff too (big muff, proco rat, all sorts of stuff) The fender sounds pretty good, but I love my Katana... :)
15:00 Not really a surprise that the Fender clean sound is better (that is what Fender is known for). That being said, I don't play a whole lot of clean stuff... :)
Yeah, and that's why everyone who doesn't play clean should probably get the katana. Definitely more bang for the buck...BUT I got the Fender because Katana can't touch the Fender clean and that's what I personally like. No wrong answer here.