It’s definitely Carter. He was holding the sticks correctly, had good posture, was focused, and showed strategy. Although Luke seemed to play well it wasn’t strategized and messy.
As a drummer, My vote is Carter. He has the right grip on the sticks. It's where your thumb is grabbing facing the ceiling and the index finger is wrapped around the drumstick.
Carter was the only one who was holding his sticks correctly, and he seemed more calm Edit: hey guys! It’s a year later and I just realized this blew up! Thanks for the likes ❤️
@@imdoloo2065 I don't think you were listening to the song it started because he had a foot drum and he started with that I don't really know what it's called but I will call it a foot drum
Carter bc he was holding the sticks right, had good posture, looked not afraid of drums, had a beat, stayed focus, had tempo, and he was the only one trying not to do it right. I’m also a percussionist btw 2 years now🎉❤❤
Neither to be Carter or Luke, but i would say in my opinion that i have my high expectations that Carter is 100% more of a drummer with his confidence, best rhythm, and very knowledgeable talent.
Im not a good drummer, but im pretty sure its Carter. He has a sense of rhythm in there and by how he plays, he has a lot of knowledge on how to play drums-
Carter is holding his sticks correctly and has good posture, he also seems very focused on what he's doing. If Carter isn't the drummer, my life is a lie.
Carter is the older bro who is also the drummer and teaching Luke how to drum which is why he's good too but they were both like "hey guys wanna do this video?" Nailed it
Carter I know it’s Carter for sure for sure. He also look like he knew what he was doing and he started off good he was very focused and he didn’t laugh at the end. He was very very very focused so it’s CART ER for sure for sure.
Carter is doing it right. As I guitarist and drummer i can confirm he’s holding the sticks right and has a really good Rhythm Edit: thanks for the likes this is the most I’ve had
I used to be a drummer, took a long term break and it seems to be turning permanent, but anyway your correct Carter is the only one holding them correctly
@@nickjessen4247 they have to be in a way lose in your hand, and the all have a different way of holding it. it is like holding a gun and aiming straight verses just holding a gun. if they both fire it is the one who is aiming who will mostly win.
Definitely Carter due to him adding in multiple set pieces of the drum together, bouncy leg to keep the tempo, how calm he was, how he didn't just focus on one or two parts of the set, hand placement and movement Is great with the sticks. though holy all of you have great potential!
As a musician, it sounded to me like carter is the drummer because of the consistent tempo whereas I felt that luke sped up the beat & tempo a bit during his bit
Carter, he has an actual rhythm and tempo he also held the sticks right
@@ThankUnexx They were NOT holding them the same lmfao
@@ThankUnexxTHEY WERE NOT
He also has the screech of a pterodactyl :)
@@ThankUnexx they werent tho
I don't mean this mean but he looks like the type of guy to be good at drums
It’s definitely Carter. He was holding the sticks correctly, had good posture, was focused, and showed strategy. Although Luke seemed to play well it wasn’t strategized and messy.
Plus the percussion ego when playing
How was he the only one holding it right they all held it the same expected for the girl
I played drums for a year and I agree
yes
Same😀
Carters scream at the end is something I’d 100% do as well
Agreed 👍 👍 👍
ethan played some sick polyrhythym phrases he clearly is the drummer
It’s Carter
@@stitch-brickshere's the joke:
Here's you:
@@theroundtable6371 damn
he's not
@@cheesemate2it's a joke
The drummer is Carter because he used proper form and tempo, but I’m guessing that Luke is a percussionist because of his skills. ❤
Luke used proper form as well that’s how I would play a fill
Final boy
Nah it’s carter because he was wearing an sjc shitt
Lol at my school you have to learn all percussion if you want to learn drums
@@purpledarkness84that isn’t proper form
Luke: shows off
Carter: hold my drink
Guys thank you so much for 82 likes, i would never think that i would get this many likes
@@PTsoukalas_Music lmao now you have 585 likes
Yea
Lol
@@Sky-ok2zl now 744
It’s so incredible that Virginia was able to teach Carter how to play like that
"Virgin-ia" 💀
@@ayhandogan4414vigina💀
Damn Carter! Would love to see that rhythm going on! It hits! 🔥
carter’s the only who looks like he isn’t afraid of the drums lol.
Man Ethan went all in tho
Luke didn't seen scared lol
True
Virginia didn’t look scared at all so idk
No it’s Virginia
As a drummer, My vote is Carter. He has the right grip on the sticks. It's where your thumb is grabbing facing the ceiling and the index finger is wrapped around the drumstick.
Or maybe because he's significantly more skilled...
I was thinking that too
Nah it’s obviously Virginia
If he is significantly more skilled he would most likely be the drummer
I agree with you because I made it obvious
Everytime i see Carter playing something on his own, i could sear he was about to go into the nastiest metal breakdown ever
FRR
My god they got to
Ethan obviously, he mastered the art of polyrhythms
LMAO
F
blud
Nah its carter
@@kikzguanzon5885 The joke flew over your head.
Carter was the only one who was holding his sticks correctly, and he seemed more calm
Edit: hey guys! It’s a year later and I just realized this blew up! Thanks for the likes ❤️
Carter
Yeah
Yeah
Carter
He had no beat or tune at all
Carter, you could also tell by how he was looking and his confidence, while the other ones looked like they never saw a drum in there life.
Carter
Agree
Carter
True
I agreee
I literally just vibing with Cartel's drumming by simply add metal to it (Growling)
CARTEL
CARTEL
Cartel 💀💀
Cartel is crazy 💀
Ethan, he truly mastered the art of syncopation.
Carter actually had a flow going and his posture was good. He also paid attention to where he was going to strategize his play
Carter
@@Onward_and_upward ??
Carter seemed like he had a lot of practice and he was very fluent with it
@@chip3206 y-es
Yessssss
At first I thought it was Luke but then Carter came into the frame and shut shit down.
Lol
Same
Yep
Carter’s a badass.
Carter scream:AHHHhHh!!!!!
As a drummer myself I’d say it’s carter, he looks so into it and had his posture right and was holding the drum sticks right
But it Already started when Carter played
@@imdoloo2065 I don't think you were listening to the song it started because he had a foot drum and he started with that I don't really know what it's called but I will call it a foot drum
I cant even drum but good for you 👏😫
SHEEEEESH HELLO FELLOW DRUM MAIN
Brothers Carter sounded like an actual band well the others just sounded like random parts
Carter, he’s the only one who didn’t laugh at the end
*Blueberry*
@@luvxoxundertalehazbinhotel1835 strawberry
@@madelynnandrea3530 apple
@@itzzravenn4522 *carrot*
@@1MMXRT4L_EY3S Tomate
Carter bc he was holding the sticks right, had good posture, looked not afraid of drums, had a beat, stayed focus, had tempo, and he was the only one trying not to do it right. I’m also a percussionist btw 2 years now🎉❤❤
carter’s soul fr js left his body in that scream💀
Virginia looks at ease more than the first two boys, but Carter seemed as if it came natural and sounded much better.
The girl legit tapped it three times
@@kylebutler6564 lol true
@@mainalex839 hes just simping
@@GreenToast01 bruh
Carter sounded like a rabbit at the end-
Neither to be Carter or Luke, but i would say in my opinion that i have my high expectations that Carter is 100% more of a drummer with his confidence, best rhythm, and very knowledgeable talent.
Plus the sjc shirt
Same
Its carter
@Ryleigh's world i said was "Neither to be Carter or Luke"
Carter because Luke isn't even using the pedals
Drums are so much easier than guitar oml
No, Carter, at the end that scream called me off guard😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Luke and Carter, both were the most consistent, and Carter absolutely wrecked all of them.
True
Yeah idk who it is now
Its Luke
@@x3tr3yo37 no it's Carter
Both of them were good but I think its Carter
I’m a percussionist, and seeing the way Carter plays, it is definitely him.
Yea
No no no I'm sure it's the first one. His experimentation with rhythm is immaculate.
I dant tell lmao
Same. I think the weird scream verifies it
No shit sherlock
Ethan was so funny and Luke that I laughed so hard .
i thought it was luke but then when carter came on i was like ‘ummmm… never mind!’
Same
Same
Ur not the only one
Same
As soon as he did the stick flip you can just tell
Im not a good drummer, but im pretty sure its Carter. He has a sense of rhythm in there and by how he plays, he has a lot of knowledge on how to play drums-
Same. His scream at the end tho 🤣! That got me off guard lmao
I think it's Caryer as well, although Virginia has potential, if only hers was a bit longer
And he has the party legs
Carter
I also think it’s Carter!
The last one was really good and it's him
God damnnn!
Carter be goin crazyyy 🔥
Carter, he seemed pretty confident like he knew what he was actually doing.
I know
Luke sounded like he was going into a song but carter looked like he knew the drums a bit better
Luke looked like he was looking for approval. That’s what made me pick Carter
Fax
Agreed
Luke was just straight up bad at drumming. Didn’t know what was going on, was just trying to be loud, and the beat sounded trash,
@@joe-broadway-cintron8186 oh ya
Carter came out with the metalcore special in that double bass nah it’s him
Carter, for sure. He can hold tempo and also that scream the the end was BEAUTIFUL!!
i mean carter is the obvious choice, but luke seems to know what he’s doing
I agree
Agreed
Agreed
luke is just doing a drum roll and adding in random notes
Luke just did a single roll with random notes
Luke and Carter, however I think carter has more technique
I know for a FACT that is was Carter. And not because of his mad skills…. But because of the screach
Carter. He's also wearing an SJC shirt sooo😂
Carter is holding his sticks correctly and has good posture, he also seems very focused on what he's doing. If Carter isn't the drummer, my life is a lie.
I guessed it was carter from the start he just had the drummer look
@@gv90072_ yeah the hat glasses grey shirt his hair style that's drummer style 100%
same
Yep
There is no right way to hold drum sticks
I wanted to say Luke, but it’s definitely Carter. He’s super chill and focused at the same time and even gave a good tune.
Agreed
Same
I was going to say the same thing
Your 2 days to short
same tho
Carter is a Realtalk nice Drummer, welcome to Club
carter with that fuckinf beat dude made my brain melt
whoever looks the most relaxed playing drums is always the drummer
He was playing an aggressive type of beat and he looked chill, definitely him
You got a point there
Except when watching Meg white
Definitely carter. As a drummer the beats and stick movements were accurate
Ethan definelty had em vibes 🥁
Ethan slays though fr 😂
Carter, everytime people were laughing at the others, it made it obvious that Carter was the drummer.
Ya
Carter, as a fellow percussionist, the scream is on point. 👌🏻
Same here
Amen
Ah fr
Yessir
Ethan tho😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
She's cute. You guys are cool. It's reassuring to see millenial kids rock out and have fun away from the new normal.
Carter, i also scream after every mess up I make. We are similar.
When I mess up a fill or something I always yell out aaahhh and keep going
Literally same here to😂
Do you agree that sloths are the best animals? I do
i’m no expert but i’m gonna go with Carter it just seems so natural the way he played
Yep
Carter
Carter
Bro really said 🦅
At first, I was like, it’s clearly Luke, Then I heard Carter and was like, YEAH IT’S DEFINITELY CARTER🤣🔥🔥🔥
Carter is the older bro who is also the drummer and teaching Luke how to drum which is why he's good too but they were both like "hey guys wanna do this video?"
Nailed it
Luke was just playing random sounds
Carter because he’s literally wearing an SJC shirt, and he’s the most comfortable
Carter
He's also taping his foot to 4/4 to keep the beat and he holds the drum sticks correctly unlike the other people.
What are you talking about it’s obviously Virginia
Luke's cymbal choke fooled me
But Carter's double kicks distinguished him
If they have a baseball cap on backwards, theyre a drummer.
That little screach at the end 😂
“Oh it’s obviously lu-“
+sees carter”
Thought the same
Same 😆
Luke just played a ton of the same note
So funny
Same💀
I played drums throughout high school, it's Carter he's doing everything correctly and he knows what he's doing.
I agree
Ethan: had a massive headach Luke: had a seisure
Carter I know it’s Carter for sure for sure. He also look like he knew what he was doing and he started off good he was very focused and he didn’t laugh at the end. He was very very very focused so it’s CART ER for sure for sure.
Carter because his posture is more nearly what a professional drummer would do and he looks like he has experience
Copy
hello
Im pritty sure its luke bc of how holds the sticks in the beggining
Carter
Carter
As a drummer myself I would say Carter since he seemed most comfortable and had the correct grip and all that stuff 👌
Ethan’s Midtown High shirt caught me off guard
Obviously Carter he is SOOOO GOOOOOD
Carter actually knows how to hold the drum sticks and he looks more focused then the other people
True
When the drummer looks like that youre about to die in that pit
100/100 Carter has the rhythm
Luke in the first shot: 🥢
At first i was "it must be luke", then carter started playing
Me too
Luke was good, but is form wasn't very good lol
Same
This is so true
Yep
Carter with the double kick!
The little scream at the end 🤣🤣
Gotta be Carter, manz is a professional on straight faced drumming and screaming *"AH-"*
Same
Carter
Mhm gotta be him
y e s
Carter is doing it right. As I guitarist and drummer i can confirm he’s holding the sticks right and has a really good Rhythm
Edit: thanks for the likes this is the most I’ve had
I’m not a drummer but my dad is and he’s trying to teach me and I think it’s him to
They all hold them the same
I used to be a drummer, took a long term break and it seems to be turning permanent, but anyway your correct Carter is the only one holding them correctly
agreed
@@nickjessen4247 they have to be in a way lose in your hand, and the all have a different way of holding it. it is like holding a gun and aiming straight verses just holding a gun. if they both fire it is the one who is aiming who will mostly win.
Luke was so tense like all new drummers, but carter was was only showing 3% of his true power (it’s carter)
What Ethan played at the beginning sounded a lot like kill the director by the wombats lmao
Carter has the feel of the drums and knows where he is going next
Really?!?!?!?? Naawwwwwwwww
Same
@@lilchungo lol
I liked at 999 and I made it 1k
I feel powerful
I’m feeling luke, but Carter definitely knows his way around nf
Stole the word out of my mouth
@@vistertheone5002 same
Yeah Carter :)
Same
Man looks like he sits down alot
Definetly Carter.
carter's last scream was personal
Carter is literally using TWO BASS PEDALS!
lol who call is a bass pedal😂
you say that like its crazy or unusual
Carter seems like the type of person who bring up death metal in every conversation
this comment has 101 likes
102
105
111
147
Carter, he’s the actual rhythm temple person ever
Double bass goes hard Carter
Everyone talking about Carter being the drummer
Me : The way Crater screamed in the end Michael Jackson is alive
HeE hEe
Ptffffff 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 hahahahaha 🤣🤣🤣😎
Exactly I’m dying
@@thefloorhatesme6918 go to the ER please
@@simianto9957 BAHA
Definitely Carter due to him adding in multiple set pieces of the drum together, bouncy leg to keep the tempo, how calm he was, how he didn't just focus on one or two parts of the set, hand placement and movement Is great with the sticks. though holy all of you have great potential!
Yes
Agreed
True
Yes it is carter
It’s probably from using the kick drum and maybe the hi hat
It’s definitely Carter but Luke fooled me for a sec there
Carter did the stick flip, that's how you know
Carter and his scream is absolutely FLAWLESS
@@stringy_sum so?? I cant say it?😑
Carter
Carter sounded like an eagle lol
Yesssssirrrrrrrr
ikr
Carter held his sticks right and kept rythm going. Definitely him.
It's the camera man.
As a bass player, Carter has the best timing and rhythm 🥁 🎵
Luke's def the drummer, as much as Carter seems more experienced, did you hear his beautiful singing voice at the end?😂
Luke
Carter really should be on America’s got Talent with that voice ✨
As a musician, it sounded to me like carter is the drummer because of the consistent tempo whereas I felt that luke sped up the beat & tempo a bit during his bit
Luke did not say anything i think you meant Carter
No