I love the jabs at Germans about history. It has to be like an inside joke, but it's funny how he just rags on them for not understanding history or being so exacting as to miss the tree for the forest.
I'm using this as part of a curriculum for my local yDSA chapter's polied program. In fact, your recordings feature heavily in it. As always your recordings are top notch; incredibly clear and very well read, with great commentary in between.
He wrote it when he was 25 yo. His motive: full reclaim of the human essence, scientifically. This planet will not be able to avoid premature destruction by ignoring Marx work. For me he is the greatest human being that ever lived! Thank you S4A!!!!!!!
Thanks for this. You did an excellent job and you are blessed with a good voice for audio recording. Looking forward to reading more Marx with my ears on your channel.
Imo this, Utopian/Scientific, 18th Brumaire, and Value, Price, and Profit are the cliff notes of communism until the era of the second international's split
I like the characterization of production relations under existing economic system as “inorganic”! A real classic by Marx and Engles. Great job putting out Audio versions of all these excellent works.
9:03 First premises of materialist method 19:43 The essence of the materialist conception of history, social being and social consciousness 24:57 History: fondamental conditions 34:59 Private property and communism 48:30 Summary of the materialist conception of history 51:12 1:02:25 Preconditions of the real liberation of men 1:10:03 Ruling class and ruling ideas 1:49:32 (Capitalism and the State)
"On the other hand, man's consciousness of the necessity of associating with the individuals around him is the beginning of the consciousness that he is living in society at all."
Thanks for the encouragement. I've only put up this chapter so far because it's the only one on the basic ML syllabus, the others are pretty long, and I have so much other material I want to cover, but I'll keep it in mind if there's an opening.
It’s cool when you can see where people developed their ideas from. I think it’s clear that Lenin’s State and Revolution is very influenced by this work.
~~just testing if formatting works on youtube here for engagement~~ it turns out it does not, thanks for the audiobooks by the way keep up the good work
The last third or so of this chapter is particularly good. It's a shame Lenin didn't have access to this text, at least not in full as it wasn't published until 1932. Some say if he had, his conception of ideology would have been different. That's all mainly in Chapter 4, though. Thanks for the audio book. One more note: I've noticed the translation that is in the Marx-Engels Collected Works (which you can get on libgen) is easier to read at least for me compared with that of the Marxists Internet Archive. Take care.
@@KingOfShenanigan “Whereas for Marx the idea of a ‘proletarian ideology’ is totally foreign,” as Larrain writes, “for the new generation of Marxists,” beginning especially with Lenin, “each class produces its own ideology, or at least an ideology that serves its interests can be ascribed to it.”3 In Lenin’s hands, “a move from ideology to class ‘ideologies’ is firmly established which loses the originally negative sense of the concept.”4 In this positive, neutral version, ideology merely becomes the thought that serves a particular class. Ideology is not a pejorative itself, only “bourgeois ideology,” which is false because it is bourgeois, not because it is ideology. Here, Marx’s problem of ideology in general becomes that of the false ideology of one class at odds with the true ideology of another. While Lenin adapted ideology to the relativity of the class struggle, claiming each side of the conflict has its own, he and the Marxist intellectuals who followed him rid Marx’s concept of its specific meaning: “Detached from its critical connotation, ideology loses what for Marx was its essential feature and becomes a concept which covers the whole range of social and political thought, whatever its origin, function or validity. Thus the value which the concept had in Marx's work as a tool of analysis and critique has almost disappeared.”5 As Larrain observes, a crucial factor in the evolution of a positive, neutral concept of ideology “is the fact that the first two generations of Marxist thinkers after Marx's death did not have access to The German Ideology.”6 Unpublished until 1932, only after theorists such as Lenin, Lukacs, and Gramsci shaped discussion of the concept, The German Ideology is the text that most clearly demonstrates Marx and Engels’s critical, negative treatment. For them, ideology is not the subjectivity of a particular class, but the objective result of a “limited material mode of activity” that produces both contradictory social relations and the distorted consciousness of those relations.7 "The Lost Meaning of Ideology" Benedict Cryptofash (Substack) What would have actually turned out differently? Perhaps not much considering the conditions of Russia in the early 20th century and the fact it 'needed to' go through a bourgeois revolution.
@@malayali-appreciator-69"For them, ideology is not the subjectivity of a particular class, but the objective result of a "limited material mode of activity" that produces both contradictory social relations and the distorted consciousness of those relations." What is the limitation on one's material mode of activity? Could it be, class? Really I'm not sure what this is supposed to mean.
Its called "Anti Dühring, Ludwig Feuerbach und der Ausgang der klassisch deutschen Philosophie." Its the Diploma Work to privy councilor E. Dühring. The criticism to Hegel neologic was some different from the set by L. Feuerbach "Entwürfe zu einer neuen Philosophie" ...They Marx/Engels published the Diploma, where they present is E. Dühring for conclusion. See the point, there are three ideom German philosophers, near the other that times, and Marx/Engels found a way of logical critic to that social class of constition heriditary. Often its important to see a Timeline of more important persons +- 100 years.
I finally finished this book and while I feel like I understand the general picture I would like to either read some support article/ summary, or watch a video explanation. Does anyone have any recommendations?
thank y'all for the content it helps someone with adhd do other things will listening to stay stimulated! Please do Micheal Parenti if y'all ever get the chance!
Section A: 01:58
Section B: 44:34
Section C: 1:21:08
Section D: 1:54:57
Thank you
i love the beginning of section a so far and how it just dunks on the young hegelians and idealism
Wait til you hear the Critique of the Gotha Program!
Marx and Lenin have mad dunks
I love the jabs at Germans about history. It has to be like an inside joke, but it's funny how he just rags on them for not understanding history or being so exacting as to miss the tree for the forest.
I'm using this as part of a curriculum for my local yDSA chapter's polied program. In fact, your recordings feature heavily in it. As always your recordings are top notch; incredibly clear and very well read, with great commentary in between.
Thanks, glad they're useful!
He wrote it when he was 25 yo. His motive: full reclaim of the human essence, scientifically. This planet will not be able to avoid premature destruction by ignoring Marx work. For me he is the greatest human being that
ever lived!
Thank you S4A!!!!!!!
27 years old*
I use these recordings whilst reading the books themselves. Thanks for these, they really help!
i admit, i replayed this a few times as i was really struggling to absorb this work. thanks for the upload!
Thanks for this. You did an excellent job and you are blessed with a good voice for audio recording. Looking forward to reading more Marx with my ears on your channel.
Thanks for making these. Much better to listen to this than commercial musical pollution.
Imo this, Utopian/Scientific, 18th Brumaire, and Value, Price, and Profit are the cliff notes of communism until the era of the second international's split
I wish there was still a functioning international! #Revolution2030
I like the characterization of production relations under existing economic system as “inorganic”! A real classic by Marx and Engles. Great job putting out Audio versions of all these excellent works.
This was a tough one, ngl. Can't thank enough for the hard work that goes into these audiobooks.
Thank you so much for providing this audiobook!
You're welcome!
Nice diction. Thank you, comrade. Most audiobooks of Marx are boring as shit. But you kept me interested.
9:03 First premises of materialist method
19:43 The essence of the materialist conception of history, social being and social consciousness
24:57 History: fondamental conditions
34:59 Private property and communism
48:30 Summary of the materialist conception of history
51:12
1:02:25 Preconditions of the real liberation of men
1:10:03 Ruling class and ruling ideas
1:49:32 (Capitalism and the State)
I just found your channel through a moot of mine on twitter, can't wait to get into your videos!
Thank you so many - trying to find out about all this - perfect way for me through audio 👍
Glad it was helpful, and I'll be uploading the rest of the playlist as time allows.
Thank you for the time and effort put into reading this
Thanks!
Another great historical piece. Thank you again and again, S4A.
You're doing good work, I hope you keep it up. Your podcast(?) on Vaush was the first thing I saw and was very good, looking forward to more :3
Thanks.
So much good stuff in here. It gives such a good insight into Marx's historical materialist outlook so well!
I've gotten quite a bit from your audiobooks. Thank you for your hard work.
The self indulgence of stirner is just so funny
That's egoism for you
@@SocialismForAll clown behavior for real
You have such a soothing voice. Thank you for this
Thanks for your comment!
1:58 starts
Lenin was a gamer
"On the other hand, man's consciousness of the necessity of associating with the
individuals around him is the beginning of the consciousness that he is living in society at all."
He stated in an last ZK conferences with Trotzki and Stalin to national documents -4true.
What his fav game? Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker, Bioshock, Persona 5 or Assassin’s Creed Syndicate in which he appears as a historical figure?
Great that you’ve done this. I’ve got confused by this before so an explanation helps.
Such a good text! Thanks for producing this ❤
Thanks for the content.
Please do more chapters!
Thanks for the encouragement. I've only put up this chapter so far because it's the only one on the basic ML syllabus, the others are pretty long, and I have so much other material I want to cover, but I'll keep it in mind if there's an opening.
Thanks just in time for my Political Theory paper!
Thanks for reading all these books!
Love the work
Thanks for everything you're doing!
Thanks SO much for this
🔥 #Revolution2030 🔥
Thank you!
30:33 lol
😳
Thanks. Is there an audio only version to save on bandwidth?
Not currently, maybe if I get a website some day.
If you get a chance, Soundcloud is free :)
@@alexjgrant Honestly managing the things I manage right now is barely worth the effort.
for the algorithm (it's what marx would've wanted)
#Revolution2030
@@SocialismForAll facts
Karl spent some breaks in Eastbourne. UK. He rented a flat above which is now Edinburgh Woolen Mill.
Thank you
Based and redpilled
We put the "red" back in "redpilled."
Thanks for the 📚
"Since we are dealing with the Germans, who are devoid of premises" 😭
Uhhhjkjhgjjhjjj I keysmash for socialism!!
Marx really was a scientist, i'm now convinced of this
Thank you for doing this!
Boop boop ba doop, boosting da comrade
Comment for the algorithm
It’s cool when you can see where people developed their ideas from. I think it’s clear that Lenin’s State and Revolution is very influenced by this work.
lenin wouldn't have had access to this work. it was published in the 30s
Very heavy lifting. I read some Feuerbach. I obviously didn't understand what he was saying. Going back sometime soon.
Great audio!
comment for algorithm, thankyou for the book comrade
~~just testing if formatting works on youtube here for engagement~~ it turns out it does not, thanks for the audiobooks by the way keep up the good work
Random letters : solidarity forever
comments are good for the youtube algorithm
For the algorithm and for the people! ☭
36:14
the *real* german ideology
Thank you!
Here's a comment for the algorithm gods
Thank you!
The last third or so of this chapter is particularly good. It's a shame Lenin didn't have access to this text, at least not in full as it wasn't published until 1932. Some say if he had, his conception of ideology would have been different. That's all mainly in Chapter 4, though. Thanks for the audio book.
One more note: I've noticed the translation that is in the Marx-Engels Collected Works (which you can get on libgen) is easier to read at least for me compared with that of the Marxists Internet Archive. Take care.
What do you mean? What would have been different? Who is "some"?
@@KingOfShenanigan “Whereas for Marx the idea of a ‘proletarian ideology’ is totally foreign,” as Larrain writes, “for the new generation of Marxists,” beginning especially with Lenin, “each class produces its own ideology, or at least an ideology that serves its interests can be ascribed to it.”3 In Lenin’s hands, “a move from ideology to class ‘ideologies’ is firmly established which loses the originally negative sense of the concept.”4 In this positive, neutral version, ideology merely becomes the thought that serves a particular class. Ideology is not a pejorative itself, only “bourgeois ideology,” which is false because it is bourgeois, not because it is ideology.
Here, Marx’s problem of ideology in general becomes that of the false ideology of one class at odds with the true ideology of another. While Lenin adapted ideology to the relativity of the class struggle, claiming each side of the conflict has its own, he and the Marxist intellectuals who followed him rid Marx’s concept of its specific meaning: “Detached from its critical connotation, ideology loses what for Marx was its essential feature and becomes a concept which covers the whole range of social and political thought, whatever its origin, function or validity. Thus the value which the concept had in Marx's work as a tool of analysis and critique has almost disappeared.”5
As Larrain observes, a crucial factor in the evolution of a positive, neutral concept of ideology “is the fact that the first two generations of Marxist thinkers after Marx's death did not have access to The German Ideology.”6 Unpublished until 1932, only after theorists such as Lenin, Lukacs, and Gramsci shaped discussion of the concept, The German Ideology is the text that most clearly demonstrates Marx and Engels’s critical, negative treatment. For them, ideology is not the subjectivity of a particular class, but the objective result of a “limited material mode of activity” that produces both contradictory social relations and the distorted consciousness of those relations.7
"The Lost Meaning of Ideology" Benedict Cryptofash (Substack)
What would have actually turned out differently? Perhaps not much considering the conditions of Russia in the early 20th century and the fact it 'needed to' go through a bourgeois revolution.
@@malayali-appreciator-69"For them, ideology is not the subjectivity of a particular class, but the objective result of a "limited material mode of activity" that produces both contradictory social relations and the distorted consciousness of those relations."
What is the limitation on one's material mode of activity? Could it be, class?
Really I'm not sure what this is supposed to mean.
Great work, keep going.
Thanks
I fuck with this
Random letters! Thanks for the read comrade.
great channel
Thanks
Finish the rest!!!
is this both volumes? Just gathering an audiobook study guide, and your audiobooks have been very helpful :)
No, it's actually only one chapter, but that's what's on the MAI syllabus.
@@SocialismForAll Oh alright, I might just watch your playlists then. Thanks.
Alhamdulillah for this video
random letters. Great vid man
Thanks A LOT 🙏
Chapter 1 is written by friedrich engels
Feeding the glorious algorithm overlords
Comment for the algorithm
#Revolution2030
Thanks for this
That was heavy.
"Weight has nothing to do with it!" #Revolution2030
Its called "Anti Dühring, Ludwig Feuerbach und der Ausgang der klassisch deutschen Philosophie." Its the Diploma Work to privy councilor E. Dühring. The criticism to Hegel neologic was some different from the set by L. Feuerbach "Entwürfe zu einer neuen Philosophie" ...They Marx/Engels published the Diploma, where they present is E. Dühring for conclusion.
See the point, there are three ideom German philosophers, near the other that times, and Marx/Engels found a way of logical critic to that social class of constition heriditary.
Often its important to see a Timeline of more important persons +- 100 years.
workers rise up!
I finally finished this book and while I feel like I understand the general picture I would like to either read some support article/ summary, or watch a video explanation. Does anyone have any recommendations?
Yes, Engels' Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy should do: ua-cam.com/video/wQdXGJ2sCO0/v-deo.html
thanks comrade
Thanks!
Very nice.
Thanks
Thanks
make a list wit
Time and the theme he is reading (like other UA-camrs)
So if we want to go back to a specific topic we don't lose time. Dankeee
Go for it.
Epic ‼️
Good work!
Great
Keep up the great work
Proletariat of the world unite✊
Comradery form Chennai, India ✊
Random letters pog
thank youuuuu
You're welcome! More uploads coming every week or every other week! #Revolution2030
great content
Marx woulda been a vamp 🧛🏽
Power
Commenting for algorithm
❤
thank y'all for the content it helps someone with adhd do other things will listening to stay stimulated! Please do Micheal Parenti if y'all ever get the chance!
Thanks, and we do have Blackshirts and Reds up currently
1:54:57 - section d