I think Membrey brings a different dynamic, age aside it’s just a list spot and gives us some depth, Tomlinson not so keen but again it’s some short term depth
I think Membrey is a perfect fit for us he’s got good hands and he’s probably the 3rd tall banana up forward where at the Saints he was #2. Come on Mate Tomlinson is an upgrade on Frampton.
A real prototype rookie listing is delisted ex Roo and ex Tiger Bigoa Nyoan Could be a new age ruckmen or key defender has big running capacity good frame 6'6 has played defense we can retrain him his physique is the future he is only 23.
Tomlinson will be a good asset at our club. Frampton ruck/defense and Johnson a forward if they can recapture their best form it will be important for the clubs fortunes in 2025.
Ash Johnson is a spud. Doesnt have the work ethic. If we are AGAIN in a tight spot in the ruck I hope they get games into Smits or Steene. Smits is gonna be a player
I think Ash with a big pre season hopefully can recapture some of his 22 and 23 form and live up to his potential. His highlights reel at his best is a reminder of his skillsets as good as anyone in our squad in the air just needs to want to do the work.
@@TAW856Sometimes it is about the right attitude plus right players around you and so far coach Macrae as a young player developer as head coach has his blind spots. He in reality chased Henry out. I think if he would have his time over again with Henry he may have liked what he did well a lot more than the things he didn't do well. JOHNSON has a year to find his best game.
@MattSpencer-g4x . Like all of us McCrae has his likes and dislikes. He disliked Ginnivan and Henry. Both are better off where they are because the coaches like them and have game plans that suit
Cannot wait for season 2025 to start. Think adding Membrey is a good thing takes a ton of pressure off Chekker's. Lets Goooo 👊 🖤 🤍 🖤👊 Also i hope Bob Murphy joins us he has a good footy brain will be a huge addition for us 😉
I’m sorry to see the delistings. But also excited to see the inclusions we have already got and going to get this trade period. Go Pies!
I think Membrey brings a different dynamic, age aside it’s just a list spot and gives us some depth, Tomlinson not so keen but again it’s some short term depth
Tim will add a dynamic to forward line we’ve been waiting for a long time, giving us more weapons for fly to deploy.
I think the concussion was the last straw and a big red flag with Krueger
Bill Frampton and Ash Johnson need to lift their game for Season 2025.
Ben King just had a good year mate, 4th in the Coleman
I think Membrey is a perfect fit for us he’s got good hands and he’s probably the 3rd tall banana up forward where at the Saints he was #2. Come on Mate Tomlinson is an upgrade on Frampton.
I hope you’re right about Tomlinson lol
@@BlacknWhiteUnited I stick by what I said. Frampton let’s his opponents take the front away from him way to easy.
Spewin they let kreugs go he had some real mongrel at the ball
Yeah it’s sad but unfortunately couldn’t stay injury free
A real prototype rookie listing is delisted ex Roo and ex Tiger Bigoa Nyoan
Could be a new age ruckmen or key defender has big running capacity good frame 6'6 has played defense we can retrain him his physique is the future he is only 23.
Johnson is a list clogger. I probably would have kept NK to be honest and I thought he started to show a bit.
Tomlinson will be a good asset at our club. Frampton ruck/defense and Johnson a forward if they can recapture their best form it will be important for the clubs fortunes in 2025.
watch us sign Weideman, because we love a potato
I’m thinking the same thing 🤦🏻♂️
No tackles Frampton, you have got to be kidding. He should have been delisted two years ago.
We don’t win the flag if he gets delisted…
@@BlacknWhiteUnited Haha, nice try, but I am not buying that. Thanks for taking the time to reply, mate. Floreat Pica.
Ash Johnson is a spud. Doesnt have the work ethic. If we are AGAIN in a tight spot in the ruck I hope they get games into Smits or Steene. Smits is gonna be a player
I think Ash with a big pre season hopefully can recapture some of his 22 and 23 form and live up to his potential. His highlights reel at his best is a reminder of his skillsets as good as anyone in our squad in the air just needs to want to do the work.
@MattSpencer-g4x that's the point, IF he wants to do the work. He hasn't shown that for over 12 months now. Time to move on from him
@@TAW856Sometimes it is about the right attitude plus right players around you and so far coach Macrae as a young player developer as head coach has his blind spots. He in reality chased Henry out. I think if he would have his time over again with Henry he may have liked what he did well a lot more than the things he didn't do well. JOHNSON has a year to find his best game.
Johnson is misunderstood and misused. Potential to be very good.
@MattSpencer-g4x . Like all of us McCrae has his likes and dislikes. He disliked Ginnivan and Henry. Both are better off where they are because the coaches like them and have game plans that suit
Cannot wait for season 2025 to start. Think adding Membrey is a good thing takes a ton of pressure off Chekker's. Lets Goooo 👊 🖤 🤍 🖤👊 Also i hope Bob Murphy joins us he has a good footy brain will be a huge addition for us 😉
I’m soewing they announced BM when they did the video was uploading! 🤦🏻♂️ but hopefully it’s a good appointment!