No one on SA Voice ‘actually represents’ Indigenous people

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 лис 2024
  • Centre for Independent Studies’ Warren Mundine says no one on the South Australian Voice committee “actually represents” Indigenous people.
    South Australia’s elected Voice to Parliament members have made their inaugural formal presentation to the state parliament.
    It is the first such address ever made before an Australian parliament.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 101

  • @iconsaustraliaproductions4991
    @iconsaustraliaproductions4991 5 годин тому +38

    One thing they forgot, we voted NO...in the real world that's a sackable offence, that's what should happen...

  • @joannemurdock7899
    @joannemurdock7899 5 годин тому +16

    Theses politicians need to play by the rules , the law , and the MAJORITY OF THE PEOPLE OF AUSTRALIA!

  • @joannemurdock7899
    @joannemurdock7899 5 годин тому +17

    Warren Mundine Well said Sir👍

  • @Prognosis__
    @Prognosis__ 6 годин тому +37

    Did not over 60% of voter in SA vote no to the voice which also included many Aboriginal people

  • @kerravon4159
    @kerravon4159 5 годин тому +27

    Didn't everyone say a very, VERY clear NO to this?

    • @rob6543
      @rob6543 4 години тому +7

      We did 🇦🇺

    • @joannemurdock7899
      @joannemurdock7899 3 години тому +3

      Yes but certain Pollies, have their own Agenda 😮 a Big Ego😮get power mad,😮 and think they can do as they please 😮and totally disregard and dont care what the majority of Australians think😮

  • @joycelynbennetts
    @joycelynbennetts 5 годин тому +18

    Love listening to your replies Warren. Thank you.

  • @SOz-uf5yq
    @SOz-uf5yq 5 годин тому +26

    👉 One Nation 👉 One Flag 👉 One Voice 👉👉👉 NO OTHER 👈👈👈 F/STOP.

  • @setildes
    @setildes 5 годин тому +12

    As an SA resident, citizen and voter I am disgusted by our State government who insist on pursuing their personal pet woke projects, whether you are Labor or Liberal surely we must vote fur the politicians who ignore the will of the popular.

  • @tamimrktz6966
    @tamimrktz6966 3 години тому +4

    It's treason.

  • @DominicPelleREAL1
    @DominicPelleREAL1 6 годин тому +33

    The Voice is no substitute for personal responsibility.

    • @Scotty123-o3u
      @Scotty123-o3u 5 годин тому +1

      The Voice: a commitment to justice so small you wouldn’t notice to an indigenous people whose land was stolen, culture trashed, people murdered and survivors marginalised.

    • @Berserker978
      @Berserker978 5 годин тому +10

      ​@@Scotty123-o3u
      Perpetual Victim Language. The Ticket for the Gravy Train.

    • @ArgonYouTube
      @ArgonYouTube 5 годин тому +8

      @@Scotty123-o3u You're going to keep us forever in the past.

    • @Father-Grandfather
      @Father-Grandfather 4 години тому +2

      ​@@Scotty123-o3u👈W⚓

    • @axle.australian.patriot
      @axle.australian.patriot 3 години тому +1

      @@Scotty123-o3u So, what do you want? To be the poor me victim for then next 60'000 years? Move on and joint the rest of team Australia :)

  • @Peter-p5u8t
    @Peter-p5u8t 5 годин тому +7

    The federal government already makes laws for all Australian citizens, and State parliament makes laws for all State citizens. The Treaties are completely unnecessary and a waste of good resources ( and time)🛑

  • @kaosthecosmicreviewer1055
    @kaosthecosmicreviewer1055 5 годин тому +11

    Almost 65% of us here in South Australia said *NO,* but apparently Malinauskas is deaf.

    • @EL-FUKKO
      @EL-FUKKO 3 години тому

      That prick also tried to shitcan the ANZAC Day public holiday

  • @adurasarangheyo9597
    @adurasarangheyo9597 3 години тому +3

    THANKYOU WAZZA.

  • @andi9161
    @andi9161 6 годин тому +29

    native title should be outlawed period

    • @Scotty123-o3u
      @Scotty123-o3u 5 годин тому +3

      European title being outlawed would be fairer.

    • @redtale6527
      @redtale6527 5 годин тому

      @@Scotty123-o3u Great idea. Let's go back to the kurdaitcha man, pointing the bone, divorce by waddy and a third world infant mortality rate.,

    • @bettysteve322716
      @bettysteve322716 5 годин тому +2

      @@Scotty123-o3u why, we are just the second known invaders.

  • @GlennPiggott
    @GlennPiggott 5 годин тому +12

    My direct ancestor was forcebly detained and transported to this land without his consent. Do I have a claim on anyone? Can i sue them? Guess not, wrong skin colour?

  • @chairmandan1794
    @chairmandan1794 6 годин тому +28

    This will come back and bite Malinauskas!!!

    • @RIGHTOCRYPTO
      @RIGHTOCRYPTO 6 годин тому +7

      I like what Malinauskas is doing but I will not be voting for him for this reason. Government should listen to the people.

    • @Prognosis__
      @Prognosis__ 6 годин тому +8

      Typical Labor leader

    • @bettysteve322716
      @bettysteve322716 5 годин тому +2

      @@Prognosis__ you spelled WEF puppet wrong, so sorry.

    • @Prognosis__
      @Prognosis__ 5 годин тому +1

      @ i overuse that phrase 😆

    • @knight2425
      @knight2425 5 годин тому +3

      Second highest spending state government in Australia with a debt that is getting bigger and bigger, he’s bought votes with his spending but tough times are ahead because of him and people are going to hurt, it’s not bad enough that SA has the dearest power in the nation because they have the most stupid renewables!

  • @bettysteve322716
    @bettysteve322716 5 годин тому +4

    UNDRIP, the WEF back door into ruling Astraya.

  • @redtale6527
    @redtale6527 5 годин тому +5

    More additions to the bloated public service.

  • @solar1Aus
    @solar1Aus 5 годин тому +5

    No, it is a non-event, voice, shouldn't be in parliament?..

  • @wombat949
    @wombat949 5 годин тому +6

    I thought we voted NO?

  • @billhesford6098
    @billhesford6098 5 годин тому +6

    The nonsense continues.

  • @wedgism
    @wedgism 4 години тому

    Ty Sir ! Country for all........

  • @troywallace322
    @troywallace322 5 годин тому +1

    The Turks at Gallipoli gave us their version of welcome to country 😢

  • @adurasarangheyo9597
    @adurasarangheyo9597 3 години тому

    IT WAS 62% PERCENT OF US... TIME FOR A RESURGENCE OF CONSERVATIVE VALUES...

  • @rob6543
    @rob6543 4 години тому

    For Christ sake my father and uncles would be turning in their graves they fought for this ,I glad my son has left the armed service

  • @adurasarangheyo9597
    @adurasarangheyo9597 3 години тому

    WHEN IS A WELCOME N-O-T A WELCOME ? when its used in an ATTEMPTED TACIT REMINDER THAT YOU ARE A FOREIGNER IN YOUR OWN COUNTRY.

  • @donaldkaiwi3375
    @donaldkaiwi3375 4 години тому +1

    Micah 2:1-3
    [1]Woe to them that devise iniquity, and work evil upon their beds! when the morning is light, they practise it, because it is in the power of their hand.
    [2]And they covet fields, and take them by violence; and houses, and take them away: so they oppress a man and his house, even a man and his heritage.
    [3]Therefore thus saith the LORD; Behold, against this family do I devise an evil, from which ye shall not remove your necks; neither shall ye go haughtily: for this time is evil.

  • @rob6543
    @rob6543 3 години тому

    I wonder if I’m allowed to have a catholic Christmas in Australia is that alright PM

  • @axle.australian.patriot
    @axle.australian.patriot 3 години тому

    Say no to racial division.

  • @brettralph3403
    @brettralph3403 Годину тому

    NITV, ABC, SBS. 3 National voices!!! But they demand more...and more...and SBS plays no fixed address's "Black boy, the colour of y skin is y pride and joy", as a regular filler!!. very often between shows, wth!!? Obviously never heard of racism or censorship..

  • @isomorph7954
    @isomorph7954 4 години тому

    What is the aboriginal word for usurp?

  • @ConradJupiter77
    @ConradJupiter77 2 години тому

    if it wasn't for the lives of the soldiers sacrificed protecting our lands in WW2 you would be speaking German or Japanese here in Australia and you wouldn't have any rights whatsoever.

  • @matthall5758
    @matthall5758 5 годин тому

    This broadcaster sounds like she got a mouth full when she talks Like big teeth or something. Odd accent. 🇺🇸🇨🇦

    • @JacobElliott-r4n
      @JacobElliott-r4n 5 годин тому

      She talks at you not too you, I can’t even pinpoint where abouts she’s from

    • @Peter-p5u8t
      @Peter-p5u8t 5 годин тому +3

      Dudes, this presenter is from Western Australia and she's a great Aussie 👍💯✅

    • @matthall5758
      @matthall5758 5 годин тому

      @@Peter-p5u8t im not saying shes not a great person she might well be but she talks like shes got a mouth full of dentures.

  • @kd359
    @kd359 3 години тому

    This man is a vile gun for hire. Not an ounce of concern or interest in anyone other than himself and those who pay him. He is not from the state, he is not an elected individual he is nobody.

  • @trickyboy1517
    @trickyboy1517 5 годин тому +1

    It might be a different story if you actually campaigned FOR The Voice, Mundane. The fact that you campaigned against leads me to wonder why should anyone listen to you about First Australian issues?
    ;)

    • @Verrifier-z6z
      @Verrifier-z6z 5 годин тому +2

      The voice is racist. Cope and seethe

    • @Berserker978
      @Berserker978 5 годин тому +2

      Get over it Loser.

    • @underalions2023
      @underalions2023 5 годин тому +3

      You mean aboriginal..

    • @billhesford6098
      @billhesford6098 5 годин тому +7

      Yeah, he was with the majority of Australians.

    • @TrickyBoy1517.
      @TrickyBoy1517. 4 години тому

      This is lame anti-logic even for you, Tricksy ;)

  • @leighmurrell5494
    @leighmurrell5494 4 години тому +1

    Can we please just redact the word "Culture" from the lexicon? It is intentionally over-used and miss-used (just like the term "Ant-Semitism") in order to influence sympathy, funding and power.

  • @Fire.4Effect
    @Fire.4Effect 5 годин тому +1

    Torres Strait Islanders can vote but South Australians can't vote for Parliamentary representation in SA.
    Undemocratic.
    Unconstitutional.
    Un-fucking-believable

  • @jasminewells5134
    @jasminewells5134 5 годин тому

    Stupidity or Corruption? Australia signs ANOTHER bad deal
    ua-cam.com/video/pE5p8BK5HdU/v-deo.html