India - Debate Of Confidence Starts
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
- (27 May 1996) T/I: 10:27:07
The Indian parliament on Monday (27/5) began debating a vote of no-confidence which threatens to bring down the country's first Hindu nationalist government. The debate, in the Indian Lok Sabah (lower house of Parliament) will decide if India's BJP government survives.
SHOWS:
NEW DELHI, INDIA 27/05
Exterior view of Parliament House
Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee arrives
WS interior parliament
Vajpayee SOT (in Hindi)
WS Parliamentarians
Vajpayee SOT (in Hindi)
WS parliament
Former Prime Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao SOT:"What I said was that, from Indira Ghandi's days, there was a clear announcement from the government of India here in this house that the personal law from any section of people can not be changed without consulting them and taking their consent."
Former Commerce Minister Chidambaram outside parliament commenting on Vajpayee's speech to parliament SOT: "The entire speech is laced with anti-Muslim sentiment. Why is he not talking about other things? He is not talking about anything else. Perhaps he is preparing for an election speech?"
2.10
#India #Debate #Vajpayee
Find out more about AP Archive: www.aparchive.c...
Twitter: / ap_archive
Facebook: / aparchives
Instagram: / apnews
You can license this story through AP Archive: www.aparchive.c...
Sri PV Narasimha Rao and Sri Atal Bihari Vaajpayee Two Legendary Prime Ministers India had!
yellayi rajesh right
yellayi rajesh yup
Also please do not forget Sri Lal Bahadur Sastri, Indira Gandhi and Sri Narendra Modi.
@@pshivakumar1 vallu waste pv and vajapayee correct
@@Msh4566 indra Gandhi gurnchi telyadu ankunta... telsthe include chesvaadvi kadu
A strong intelligent pm vs a strong and intelligent opposition leader.
What a time to live😅
That time when leaders had respect for each others whether it was from opposition or government.
Right
Mr. P.V. Narsimharao ....father Economic reforms.
Yes and the most underrated PM of India only coz he was a South Indian !!
Ashok Kulkarni and finally dogs ate him
Ashok Kulkarni Yeah and d credit was given to MMS by some fool buddijeevis
Ashok Kulkarni
Abdul Rahman, He died in the presence of everyone not in Jungle or Desert alone ,and he had peaceful death. its our responsibility to perform his last rights carefully we failed in it.The paap goes to them not him. What if some flood came and taken the body, after you bury them in ground..?
Is he still responsible. Its our duty to ensure he be rested peacefully after his death.
P.V. Narsimha Rao was the best PM the country has witnessed. If he had been given one more chance , our country would have flourished still better. Some times our people do not apply their minds. Very unfortunate
KS chandramouli plz c his funeral videos...he ws eaten by dogs...bloody bastard
KS chandramouli is ki lash kutte kha rahe the
KS chandramouli .
No wonder SoGa and her cronies continue to hate him
That is your thinking . Pv narsimha rso never had guts to challenge gandhi family neither got bharat ratna
Former PM Narsimha Rao will be known as great PM as he un-chained Nehru indira brand of socialism. He invited eminent Economist Dr.ManMohan Singh from world BANK and had appointed him FM of the country.Long live Narsimha Rao,great son of mother India.
जब मुसीबत आती है तो उस समय की सरकार को सही डिसीजन लेने होते हैं और उन्होंने सही डिसीजन लिया मनमोहन सिंह की वजह से
@@raya_ashok manmohan ko lekar kaun aaya tha sarkar mai political decision kiska tha ye bhi mat bhuliye us samay ke majboot vipaksh ne bhi sarkar ka aath diya tha
@@ManishPandey-em9ls मजबूत विपक्ष 🤣😆🤪,,,,,यह वह विपक्ष है जो राजीव गांधी के एटीएम और कंप्यूटर लाने पर देश बंद करने का ऐलान करती है 🤪😆🤣
P. V narashimharao sir and vajpai are great PMs of India ever.....
real indians loves pv narsimha great pm
Sir nijam chepparu
I love Narasimha Rao for growth and for brave and daring Indira Gandhiji and now present pm narendra modiji these are best, Nehru is waste and mahathma Gandhiji, divided india two parts india and pakistan because of Nehru making him as of first prime of india, in my opinion worst pm of india, eating pig and cow
@feli city Super
@little neo
Kid. U need to learn real history lessons.stop reading communist history
@@avinashreddykomatireddy6588 stop reading rss history
Great son of mother India PVNR became PM of the crisis rich nation after tragic assasination of Rajiv Gandhi
in June 1991. Not in majority he was initially hesitant but completed his full 5years term as biggest contributor to nation's economy.
He was so Brilliant and visionary ,that he appointed World bank's Dr.Manmohan Singh as FM of troubled nation.Manmohan in his budget reduced customs duty from peak 275% to only 45pc.
Rate of income tax were brought down to normal 30%from peak 93%.
liberalized and freed the economy from shackles of Nehru indira brand of socialism. Our foreign exchange reserve which was Nil 25years ago is.now USD 400bn. Narshimha Rao will be remembered as great leader after Sardar Patel.
long live Narshimha Rao
long live Manmohan SINGH
Jay hind
Liberalism should have been in place since 1960's itself.
@@reconquistahinduism346 yes post independence for the first decade such laws were good as they helped India be truly atmanirbhar and then to further develop opening the economy would have been very bad sadly waited untill Rajiv Gandhi govt to initiate and pv Narsimha Rao govt to completely perfect the Liberalization
@@adityaswamy9647
Shut up you southie. Brainless pappu Gandhi shit lickers.
The sadistic Gandhi Nehru ideology destroyed India they just appeased jihadi terrorists. China , Korea etc were note ravaged and poor in India in 50's but they improved because they started liberalism in 60's itself. Even the 1991 LPG reforms were useless , self serving , superficially implemented , corrupt in implementation , and so nothing was done. Under Modi , India is the 5th largest economy in just 6 years.
And Atmanirbhar, does NOT mean closed protectionism .It does NOT mean opposing capitalism or free trade. In fact maximum free trade has been done under Modi ji only.
Atmanirbhar means becoming self reliant because nothing can be achieved without it , even globalisation. It is not antagonistic to globalism.
He's architect of modern India
P V Narasimha Rao deserves a Bharat Ratna.He saved India.He is not from the lutyens mafia.he was not even given a decent funeral.Played with his dead body.
Yes
Italy Gandhi insulted PV Narasimha Rao.
I made the like 100 💯
ironically if anyone will give him a bharath ratna it's BJP.
Sonia will pay for her sins for sure
lalbahadur vajpai and pv are greatest prime ministers of india
u r spot on
God given gift of these Pm s
@sabir hussain vo teeno ko bol rha hai actually.Comma lgana bhul gya beech m
Indira Gandhi also
@@kishorkr6415 yes
ఎందరో మహానుభావులు అందరికి వందనములు
Those are the golden days of my childhood. Ambassador cars, Vajpayee Ji and PV Narasimha Rao Ji
Why is Father of indian economic reforms not awarded with coveted bharth ratna...isn't he qualified for that award..what more should he possess...When a cricketer can get a Bharat Ratna(which he played for himself and amassed wealth for himself)..why can't PV Narasimha rao sir?
P.S:i'm not against sachin getting award..but pv sir was even more great than him...he is completely ignored by our generation
I completely agree with your comment.
They will give Bharat Ratna to the entire Gandhi family and even to NTR! This shows how shameless Congress is.
He didn't get because of being a south Indian.
He was the first prime minister out side Nehru dynasty to rule India for full 5 year term.
A lot of people could give you a lot of reasons why a 'Cricketer ' shouldn't be given this award.
But a lot of people would still not support other sports. So let's be another 'lot' of people who don't at all care about 'Bharat Ratna'
ఎందరో మహానుభావులు అందరికీ వందనాలు.
Best PM PV PROUD TELUGU GUY
Most sensitible debates which we guys are missing nowadays, hats off to the best politians till date, PV ji and Atal ji 🙏
Shastri and narasimha Rao were India's best prime ministers.
And both are downgraded by *Khangress* because they want to repeat story of *1947* in *2047* .
This rogue Chidambaram used to speak like this even in those days!"
Haha LOL> I could not stop laughing. He is the biggest asshole in India.
Under his tenure as Finance Minister, India saw some of it's best growth years and even in 1991 as Commerce Minister he had a huge role to play in implementation of the economic reforms. But of course you people wouldn't know about his achievements or give credit where it's due, people like you deserve Ms Sitaraman as our Finance Minister.
Chidambaram is the most dangerous person for nation than an enemy in the border.
@@chandrareddy9861 👍
@@aymanhaque6936, dont you see the scams and corruption of this guy and his son
A real scholar, well mannered, legendary p.m. no one like him. Unforgettable speech by him. really golden days of Indian politics. Long live P.V.Narsimmha Rao Sir. A person deserve to Bharat Ratna award.
We used to have people like Atal ji and PVNR.
Now we have Rahul and Modi 😂😂
yes bro yess
One is stupid (Rahul) and another one is bogus person (Modi) enough of these morons what India need today is we need leader who are CENTRISTs like PVNR and ABV
@@sushmaharsha5445 centrism is even worse atleast with polars like modi and congress lets you know which side is right and wrong since they are so polar opposites
@@sushmaharsha5445 and what exactly did they achieve...at least when you write off some one please give facts
Rahul n Modi both are faaltu
What a Fluent English speaker he was......
Phani Bhushan he was multi lingual learned man sir..
Nagaphanisarma
Mahabhrath
He is a polyglot..he is fluent in as many as close to 10 languages...
Telugu(mother tongue),hindi,urdu,english,marathi,tamil,Gujarati, german,french and some more...Truly india is blessed to have PV sir as our PM during economic crisis...
@@Sandesh-lz2nk let me correct you sandesh he was fluent in 16 languages
The two best PMs of India in a single video
पी वी नरसिंहा राव अमर रहे
The two worst full term PM's apart from modi who started the degradation of a secular republic by injecting religion into politics
Best Prime Minister Of India is Lal Bahadur Sastri and P.V
They are sincere
Vajpayee also
atal ji
नेहरू ने 1950 में ही आईआईटी बना दी थी , 1952 में रोडवेज विभाग , ऐम्स हॉस्पिटल नेशनल इंस्टिट्यूट ऑफ डिजाइनिंग नेशनल इंस्टिट्यूट ऑफ टेक्नोलॉजी , भारत की सुरक्षा के लिए डीआरडीओ , विश्व में तीसरे नंबर की स्पेस एजेंसी इसरो , बाबा जहांगीर रिसर्च सेंटर , कोरोना जैसे वायरस के लिए नेशनल इंस्टिट्यूट ऑफ़ वायरोलॉजी , देश के विकास के लिए भाखड़ा नांगल और हीराकुंड जैसे सैकड़ों बांध , लाखों स्कूल कॉलेज यूनिवर्सिटी हॉस्पिटल
देश का औद्योगिक करण किया ओएनजीसी स्टील अथॉरिटी ऑफ इंडिया जैसे सैकड़ों कंपनियां बनाई
आकाशवाणी केंद्र बनाया
यह सब उस समय किया जब अंग्रेजों ने पूरा लुत्फ सोडके खत्म कर दिया देश को और देश में गिने-चुने डॉक्टर इंजीनियर थे , देश की 90% जनसंख्या अनपढ़ गवार थी और 80% लोगों को दो टाइम खाना नहीं मिलता था
और यह सब उस समय था जब भारत में कार्बन कॉपी की मशीन भी नहीं थी
17 विभाग वाला योजना आयोग बनाया जिससे देश चल रहा है
देश में लाखों समस्या आई थी करोड़ों समस्या थी ,सरदार पटेल देश को भले एक करके गए हो गृहमंत्री के तौर पर परंतु इस देश को 17 सालों तक एक रखना अब उसमें ग्रह युद्ध नहीं होने देना , और देश में विविधता में एकता की नींव रखना , और देश को विकास की ओर अग्रसर करना
यह का महान काम नेहरू और उसके सहयोगियों ने किया था यदि गांडू गोडसे और सावरकर के हाथ में देश होता ,तो आज हम अंग्रेजों के हाथ में ही होते हैं क्योंकि उनको लगता था कि इस देश को केवल अंग्रेजी सही ढंग से चला सकते हैं 😆🤣🤪
Atal ji is best then shashri ji and then narsimha saheb
Years ago, when Parliament bloomed with intellectuals, Who focused on raising the standard of their argument but not their voice.
P.S. I am not talking about the misfit, the culprit of INX Media case
Legendaries PV sir and Atal sir. Present politicians should.learn things from the both.
as a multi language speaking person I like to pvnr and one of PM frm telangana I proud of him
Goutham Kalewar haha even after becoming pm none of your telangana leaders gave their seat for him to contest. It took a rayalseema congress leader to give away his seat from nandyal and ntr didnt even contest against pv just because he wanted a telugu man to be pm of the country. I dont know what u are proud of.
91873delete funniest comment i ever heard! Dumbness profiled, TDP is the only party whos cause for formation was out of cast feeling. Keep barking loosers
but elected as mp from nandyal in ap
@91873delete It is the Jai Andhra Movement because of which PV had to resign as CM of erstwhile AP ? Are you proud of that ?He managed for 5 years at the center and changed the direction of india but could not survive 5 years as CM. And you must know that NTR also contested and won from Nalgonda in 1985.. If the nation needs any AP candidate can also contest from TG constituencies.
Dil wale du
Future: Prime minister Yogi Adityanath slams the opposition over their Anti-hindu sentiments
Good to c a discpilined parliament.... without any jingoism.... !! Both opposition and ruling parties
The school was in full attendence. Then came the spoilsport, read Chidambaram,
🤣
.
😂😂😂😂
Get out of your shitty inferiority complex. You or your progenies in 1000 years can't match the intellect of Chidambaram. Don't blabber shit because it's fashionable for bhakts
2 giants Rao and Vajpayee. Also 2 gems of India!
I witnessed the respect of PVNR clearly by this video by atal ji
Chidambaram was the same before, Anti-Hindu
Samrat Sarkar J in the morningo
He is highly corrupt and he always will be with Sonia as they share same background
chidaraman is useless but no anti hindu .
@@HasanAli-pv4vx listen up his speech ..... every speeches ...he is fucking anti hindu
@@sourabhraghuwanshi6889 no one is anti hindu.... how can an Hindu be anti hindu .....neither anyone is anti muslim....everybody had their point of view ..
India would not be like this fastly growing economy if P V NARASIMHA RAO was not been Prime Minister of India
Hey remember that guy, who was a resident of tihar a little while ago
What a healthy democracy between these two legendary leaders!!!!
Country needs this true leders like pv narsimha rao,AB vajayepi,this difficult dirty political times!!
The current broadcast quality of LS is like as if they're using the 90's cam. And The broadcast quality of LS back then in 90's seems to be using the 70's or the 80's cam. But damn didn't know that there was discipline in the parliament house before I was born, look at the parliament now...
Pv garu. Always respect you sir. Respect from🙏🙏🙏🙏 karimnagar south india. First prime minister gaaru
both are real heros
తెలంగాణా నుండి జాతీయ తకెదిగిన
మహనీయుడు ఆనాడు
పదవుల కోసం ప్రాంతీయతకు దిగజారిన
పుండాకోరులు ఈనాడు
Apatlo Andhra
ఇప్పటివరకు అవిభజిత ఆంధ్రప్రదేశ్ రాష్ట్రం నుండి కేవలం ఒక్కరికే భారత రత్న పురస్కారం లభించింది. అది శ్రీ సర్వేపల్లి రాధాకృష్ణన్ గారికి. పూజ్యూలు శ్రీ మోక్షగుండం విశ్వేశ్వరయ్య గారు మరియు శ్రీ వీ.వీ. గిరి గారు తెలుగు సంతతికి చెందినవారైనప్పటికీ కర్ణాటక మరియు ఓడీషా రాష్ట్రానికి చెందిన వారుగా గుర్తుంపి ఏర్పడింది. ఈ విధంగా చూస్తే ఇప్పటివరకూ మొత్తం 54 మహనీయులను భారత రత్న వరించగా, మన సువిశాలమైన, సకల కళాసుసంపన్నమైన తెలుగు నాటనుండి కేవలం ఒక్కరికే భారత రత్న గౌరవం దక్కడం బాధాకరం. దేశాన్ని తీవ్ర ఆర్ధిక సంక్షోభం నుండి కాపాడడానికి కీలక నిర్ణయాలు తీసుకొని మన దేశ ప్రగతి ని పరుగులు పెట్టించిన మేధావి, బహుభాషా కొవిధులు అయిన మన తెలంగాణ ఠీవి పీవీ గారికి భారత రత్న రావడానికి ప్రభుత్వం, సాంస్కృతికి శాఖ కృషి చేయటమే మనం మన ఈ తెలుగు తేజానికి ఇవ్వగలిగే ఘన నివాళి.
@@AkleshKumar-pg1nz అవును సోదర బాగా చెప్పారు పి.వి నరసింహారావు గారికి ఎన్టీఆర్ గారికి ఇద్దరికీ భారతరత్న రావాలి ఆ ఇద్దరూ మన తెలుగు జాతి ఆణిముత్యాలు భారతరత్నకి అన్ని రకాలుగా అర్హులు
It's our indian Legends, without bloody Congress and chidiya
PVN eleminated Punjab, Kashmir militancy and saved India. Vajpayee approved Nuclear test and Kargil war to make India a real man.
Good to see two legendary leaders. But 1:44 is a cunning 🦊
Never knew congress used religion card against BJP all along.
Same narrative of thief chidu even in those days....
Scared of his intellectual prowess, isn't it cowbelt moron?
@0:53 when Sri Atal ji asks his colleagues to stop thumping ...... Epic and a gentleman move, no one in todays BJP can even be considered a fraction like him even the incumbent
For those Who are saying Economic reforms of 1991 LPG are because of P V Narsimha Rao Then u have misunderstandings Dear.... At That time Dr.Manmohan Singh Was appointed As finance minister ( as he was President for University grand Commission but later Rao Appointed him As finance minister) At that time there was inflation, economic was slowed down & Crude oil (petrol diesel) prices were hiked.... India Requested loan from world bank but due to pressure of USA ,WB denied the loan..so RBI suggested to invest on gold in japan bank and swiss bank...And there comes master mind Dr Manmohan Singh he Planned policy of LPG ( liberalisation privatization globalization) so the foreign company can directly invest in indian industrial sector,Industries were free for trade and pricing..... Rao just supported the Manmohan Singh's decision he said that "Its ur decision,I will not interfere with it ,Whatever you do I support you"....and from that day indian economy took a spike😃....for this U can watch interview of Rao on NDTV
ref :- History of modern India by Bipin Chandra,History of India by- Grover
The way respected vajpayee ji shown respect to respected PV ji is worth watching many times...
At 1:44, my BP just raised and I thought of throwing away my phone and breaking it.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
PV Narasimha Rao English is just too good
And then good for nothing Chidambaram came😃
సార్, గౌ. వాజ్ పాయ్ ,పి.వి. నర్సింహ రావు గారి, మీ లాంటి నిస్వార్థ జీవులు, ప్రైమ్ మినిస్టర్స్ గా ఉండే, భారత పార్లమెంట్ ను మళ్ళీ ఈ మధ్యలో మేము చూడ గలమో లేదో?! అని ఆందోళనలో భారత దేశం ప్రజలు ఉన్నారు కదా?! ప్రజల కోరిక నెరవేరుతుంది అని అంటారా మిత్రులారా?!🙏
मैं मोदी युग में राजनीति की समझ रखने लगा लेकिन मैं देश की इन दो महान विभूतियों का बड़ा सम्मान करता हूँ ये दोनों भारत माँ के 2 रत्न थे..
Atal jee shouting, PV jee's Calm and intelligent reply ( BE like a boss :) ): Chiddu is budhhu then and now
Can't face Chidambaram right? Shit scared of his intellect right?
@@jayeshs7562 his intelligence in corruption & cbi enquiry is good enough to prove himself Non-victim.
Atalji was not shouting. It is the way he talks. Because of hi poetic background, he talks with passion
అప్పట్లో వున్నటువంటి ఆరోగ్యకరమైన వాతావరణం ఇప్పటి రాజకీయ నాయకులలో కూడా కలిగి ఉంటే బాగుంటుంది
What was saying the would be thf Chidambaram ji.???
PV and Atal Ji are real great politicians of last 50 years.
2 legends of Indian politics.....respect...
Great leaders PV narsimharao and Atal Bihari vaajpaaye ❤️
Atal jee mahaan hai they aur rahenge.Jai ho atal jee
Both are legends 🙏💪👍
When parliament actually existed...!!
Vajpayee ji kaheebi ho, saabko 🙏🙏🙏🙏
best pm of india -pv narasimha rao
How ?
P V నర్సింహ రావు గారు తెలంగాణ బిడ్డ కావడం మనకు చాలా గర్వ కారణం....🙏🙏🙏🙏
Yes, Atal was the best
one of the most intelligent pm.And just listen to his voice how humble and polite he is.Unlike our current pm who has no shame.
PVN was a Great Man.........
When PV Narshima roa sir was PM our economic was high
Salute sir
Undoubtedly PV Narasimha Rao is the best prime minister of India.
Saluting the great leaders atal Ji, pv
Lal Bahadur Shastry ji
PV Narasimha Rao ji
Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji
Narendra Modi ji
These people will be forever remembered as the best prime ministers of India.
U fool chitambaram... u can't under Mr.Atal ji... he is way far and only people who are real and not corrupt they can understand. Jai Hind
Indians descandants outside of India largely support BJP..
Once upon a time one respect to another...
The current MPs have a lot to learn from those old LS sessions. When the PM and opposition seniors are talking not even a single MP is cross talking or yelling unlike today's. The entire house is full and quiet as a grave.
GREAT SONS OF INDIA WHO OPENED UP INDIA FOR DEVELOPMENT AND ACHIEVED DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA AS
GREAT PRIME MINISTERS .
I RESPECT AND BOW AT THEIR FEET
AS A MARK OF MY RESPECT TO THE
DEPARTD LATE GREAT LEADERS OF INDIA.
2 gr8 pm's of our country.chiddu is 2nd version of chatur
Some of the decent politicians of INC..Sardar Patel, Lal Bahadur Shastri,PV Narasimha Rao, Pranab Mukherjee
We can't Pay Justice to You-P.V Narsimha Rao -The legendary Prime Minister we had
Wo din bahuth acche the yaar, no hindu muslim. Only thinking about India's development...
Indian role model
देस के साथ धोका किया राव
Sri PV the most Intelligent, Daring & Dashing Prime Minister Who is the ARCHITECT of the INDIAN ECONOMY .
Best of Indian Democracy....
Two great leaders who took Indian politics to a new level. Unfortunately, we have no politician of their stature today.
Left are Chidambrams, Lalus, Mayawatis, Abdullahs, Muftis and....and...??.!!!.
Two legends at the start of the video and then comes Chiddu, the joker
Bharat Mata ke amar saput Atal ji ko shat shat naman. Atal vihari amar rahenge.
Chidambaram saying the samething which he says now .
Anyhow very soon he will land up in Tihar .
Can we see these type of constructive politics again in India. Mostly never India is no more a democratic. I am proud to be an Indian, but feeling sorry to know that democracy is fading now a days....
Came here for PV Narsimha Rao. Saw Chidambaram in end. Happy he is in jail.
golden era of India when culturally conservative and financially liberal approach was prevalent
From Vajpayee and Narasimha Rao to Narendra Modi and Rahul Gandhi. Look how far we've fallen.
Such a dignified speech of Opposition leader and the PM and only issue based.
Two greate leaders from two different parties behave so humbly.
2 Lions PM s.
Many people haven’t understood what P Chitambram said listen 👂 carefully
Pv jj cleared by saying it's media twisted his words that's true. Both are good at their speech. Loved the debate
PV sir held almost all the prominent ministries at the state and central level before he became the prime minister of India. Apart from his intelligence, its his vast experience that helped him to succesfully implement the reforms running a minority govt.
Look at how these gentlemen used to behave.
Look at the parliamentarians now