All are deceived to make people sin by Throat off bad people to shed blood Marry many women here in the name of helping them and get many in heaven Go far place to Rotate around black stone Take jaziya from mankind of other race saying third class Finally Make AI to say this is what God says
No, he's not. If you noticed, he didn't actually accept the argument. No matter how many facts have been conveyed, he denied it. He just pretend to be nice but has got insincere intention. For example when he says Jesus has silent approval toward the young marriages, he then associates it with the homos, since Jesus was also silent it means he approved it, he said that because he means to argue with dr, Sabeel's argument knowing that Muslim strongly against LGTB. Wallahua'lam
Why keep entertaining this stoopid question? Does anyone really think that's the thing keeping someone from reverting to Islam? Allah guides whom He wills.
According to Shia sect of Muslims who are followers of Hazrat Ali (r.a), the cousin and son inlaw of prophet do not bleave on virginity and 9 years age of Aish when she got married with the prophet. According to Shia's she was about 21-24 years & divorced before the second marriage with the prophet.
@@jawedakhtar5825 Their are no sects in Islam. A Muslims submits their will to god and follows the teachings of the prophet (SAW). I'm not really concerned about what any other people think regarding any matters pertaining to Islam and Muslims.
Matthew is such a respectful individual and his zeal to learn is admirable. Kudos to your parents, they raised you well. I pray that he embraces Islam. May Allah (SWT) guide him to the truth, Ameen.
*Jesus on When I join man and woman in marriage, it is meant for life...* Message to Prophet John Leary Sunday, October 6, 2024: Jesus said: “My people, I truly have made man and woman just as I have made male and female animals. But I made man and woman in My Image with a soul and body. I have given you free will, but also I have given you My Commandments so you can love Me and your neighbor as yourself. When I join man and woman in marriage, it is meant for life and not to have divorce. What I have joined together should not be separated. You also have been given the opportunity to have children under the bond of marriage, and not with fornication. You are to bring up your children without any abortions which defies My Fifth Commandment of Thou shall not kill. Your families are the core of your society, and you should keep together so the family of a mother and father can help bring up their children. When one parent is missing, this puts an added burden on the children when they are missing a mother or father image to follow. Pray for your couples to get married and stay together.”
Dont think he's that sharp when he brings up the age of A'ishah as if to find fault with Islam when in his Bible there are similar incidents and he didn't research into that.
@@MuhammadAli-hr1bj but illetrate arbi baba never used dialogue and conversation in his dealings with symbol users in workshop. he used terror of 10000 naked sword to capture their temple and destroy creative symbols of God. anyone destroying cultural heritage of the land is good guy or bad guy?
1st time I see a young man that does his research about islam before accusing 1.5 billion brothers and sisters not knowing nothing about them! Plus he’s way too respectful.. may Allah guide him
@@NobodyForsomeone-hp9bv what will they eat ? 😝😝😝..Europeans have stopped Mslm migration and started deportation..your own oil rich Arabs don’t allow y’all to enter their contrys and rest of mslm contrys are too poor to feed such high population 😝😝😝
I'm a Christian. What annoys me about when people ask this about Aisha is the fact that they want to judge and criticism historic events in Islam by todays standards. Things were very different back then. But the hypocritical thing that I've noticed is that the same people tend to be pro zionist. and when you mention Israeli atrocities they want to justify and defend their zionism by making comparisons to historical events that occurred before the Geneva convention. This, to me, is a double standard. They may not have noticed themselves, but j always point it out.
Firstly, you saying you're a Christian does not add anything relevant to the situation, and by what standards are you making this claim? Muhammad was a person of his time, but even if we compare his actions to those of early medieval Christians, they were still wrong. According to ancient Christian standards, it was also wrong. In your Bible, first-century Christian men were not allowed to hold church office if they were in a polygamous relationship. And please, don't bring the Gaza issue into this. Polygyny and polygamy are violations of the institution of marriage as given by God to our father Adam and mother Eve. Do not misrepresent Christianity and confuse your muslim brother and sisters, you will be held accountable for what you say friend.
@@Tomf-tz4pd polygamy are wrong? According to christianity? If that is the case, all the prophets like Solomon, David and Abraham (pbut) has commited sins since they have more than one wife.
@@denoiz 100% Apostle Paul tells us that in the past God winked at our ignorance but now Jesus has come into the world no more excuses. You will also find that King David and King Solomon brought pain, sadness and destruction into their homes and into Israel for their polygamous relationship. God allowed the evil consequences of this relations to play out. We have no problem calling out when the blessed prophets do wrong, only in Islam are prophets infallible.
MashALLAH, I can already see noor in Matthew's face, may Allah guide him to the straigh path ameen, he's very sincere and pure-hearted which ALLAH loves the most
@@Gatteleylife9957thats what Islam is all about asking questions and doing your research and eventually studying the belief/faith unlike Christianity emotion based beliefs and mystery/confusion 😂😂😂😂so sad
Very civilized discussion mashallah ❤. The more I watch you brother Sabeel, the more I get amazed alhamdulillah. I appreciate the patience you have. May Allah reward you in this world and hereafter, ameen !
@@devbakka4073 don’t worry 7 out of 10 converts leave Islam within one yr ,😝😝,24% American and whooping 12 million educated Indian converts have quit Islam according to pew research survey…2.4 million Pakistanis have become atheists according to their columnist Mr Orya Maqbool Jan…5% Saudis are atheists and 19% non religious according to 2012 Gallup survey ..today this percentage will be very high..thanks to MBS 😝😝
@@Hitchens-k9s where you got your study from?? lol come to Pakitan to see..🤣 atheism is dead and so is christainity and judaism...hinduism was dead when islam arrived to India they are so scared that they ban zakir naik🤣by the way why are you happy that people are becoming atheist? I remeber in Pakistan we used used to have 10 people in mosques in prayers now there are more then 50 people in every prayer even in the morning... people now know atheism crap... Godless idiots.. the new generation are way smarter to catch atheism BS they have already cancelled atheism.
@@Hitchens-k9s West society are suffering from pedosphiles, homosexuality, Interests, porn industry,gambling, drugs, alcohol, creating wars and sex out of marriage.. are some of the things that is destroying the west society.. imagine throwing your old parents in an old house while they are sick and dying.. you society is crap and will soon perish because of homosexuality with no new generation to come.
He is ready to accept islm…that’s why he is labelled as intelligent…once he accepts islm he too will start believing in flying donkey, moon splitting,talking ants etc 😂😂😂
@@Hitchens-k9si watch vidio of a man and women with more harsh comment more than you and in the end they end up in tears with regret when the truth hits them..and you know what the 1st indication on the journey they had..they watch all the muslim and islam teaching like you😂😂and comment there..alot of cristian vidio pass in my wall but heyy i never wants to watch or more to comment in the section why..because even if he insult my religion it doesnt bother me,and it waste my time to do it..but youu i can see that something bother your heart thats why you in this comment sections😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉welcome to islam
As an ex Christian myself all one can say is that there is absolutely NO religion or way of life that even comes close to Islam. It’s absolutely perfect.
" It’s absolutely perfect." thats factually and logically not correct. islam allows owning of slaves and 50-60-70 year old perverts can marry a 9-10-11 year old girl.......... so THERE IS ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT in islam............ which makes it LESS THAN PERFECT
@@Just_passing_through23 Same message today about who Christ is as it was when the Holy Spirit descended over the Apostles on Pentecost starting the One Holy Catholic Apostolic Church. You have no idea what you’re talking about, my nonsensical friend.😊
@@georgiacap9294 what are you going on about??? 🤦🏻♂️ The Bible is nothing but filled with mistakes and errors and people manipulating the book??? Who cares what it says about Pentecost when the Bible cannot stand on its own as Christian scholars themselves tell the world that the Bible has been changed and is nothing preserved!!!! Please before you post dribble learn from your own intellectuals what they say about the Bible…
@@rusidahzaidi9703 what date/year was Adam created? How old was Adam when he was created by MAGIC? When did he die ? Any DNA or fossil records or eyewitnesses? 😝😝😝..I bet no mslm will be able to answer these questions
@@silverkhanruykhan6617 it’s as imaginary as your flying donkey,moon splitting,talking ants,124000 so called prphts or you god with 2 right hands ,invisible but male in gender 😝😝😝…or a self proclaimed godman claiming to talk with angel on regular basis but only in solitude and no eyewitnesses 😝😝😝
Uhu The Power of Blood of Christ Blood of Christ Vs Allah's (Eid al adha) Blood of Goat, Bakrid When it comes to mortal sins like murders, adultery, violences, original sin goat's (or animal) blood or Blood of Christ sets humans free ? Bible says "So if the Son sets you free, you will be free INDEED." If Arab / elite wanted to marry many times / women would they not start their own religion or bring out a religious book (called Quran) to suit their needs, appetite ? So allah is not real but man made God for elite's divide and rule policy using man made religion / book mostly copied from the Bible. That's why single book / witness. Bible whereas mainly 7, 5 apostles Saints Peter, Matthew, John, Jude, Paul, and 2 Disciples, Sts Luke and Mark wrote Bible as separate witnesses and through Divine inspiration!
This was so beautiful to watch... He answered and explained so nice. I wish debates could be like this instead of people just arguing and trying to make a person convert by proving them wrong. Make them find out themselves. Show them the beauty of your religion.
Matthew asked for knowledge. He seems sincere. This question always asked by non-Muslim with bad intention, but we never asked them back what was the marriage age of wives of other prophets. Why? Because we respect all the prophets
This christian brother is nice person may Allah guide him. Masha Allah mutmayeen bahtareen jawabat Sabeel shab ne diye... i am truly very impressed by his knowledge very truthfully, and precise answers have been given.
Ayesha was 6/ 7 ye@rs øld when she herself accepted the marriage proposal of prophet Muhammad ﷺ brought by her Father Hazrat Abubakr. But she was already engaged with Zubair Ibn Mut'im. They broke the engagement. Then she actually got married After three years when Prophet Muhammad ﷺ migrated to Madina, then Aisha was 9/10 ye@rs øld. Aisha was mentally capable, physically and biologically mature and martially abled. The jéws and £nemies of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ like Abu jahal, sheebah, Utbah bin Rabeeah, Abu Lahab etc never cr!ticized his marriage. They could cr!ticize his marriage like today's phøbes do, but they knew that Hazrat Aisha was enøugh m@ture. Aisha said that she used to put her head on Prophet Muhammad's shoulders while hugg!ng. She was also in the b@ttlefield where ch!ldren and old ones were not allowed. She was as teacher for women to teach them morals and Islam. She also narrated about 2210 Ahadiths. Even the highly knowledgeable and close companions of Prophet Muhammad acquired knowledge from her. She was always happy with her Marriage. She also said that she used to be@t prophet Muhammad in r@ce. She also led the Army in the B@ttle of Camels. Do you think a k!d can do such things. Wallahi it's the phøbic Heart which doesn't let a person accept the truth unless it opens up and get soften(H@tred-free). May God bless you.
Brother Sabeel explanations are systematic, easy to absorb, based on authentic references, clear and concise. JazakAllaahu khayran, may Allaah preserve and protect him - increase hin in knowledge. 🤲🤲🤲
The ultimate knowledge belongs to THE ALMIGHTY ALLAH (GOD) and no way a believer could protest or decide to go against. May we all be blessed with knowledge, wisdom and understanding.
No need to accuse, but I still don't understand why Muslims kill Muslims, in Syria 500,000 and Yemen and other Muslim countries? Who is a real Muslim and who is not? Christians also fought each other? Without offending anyone, its hard to understand.
If we look at today’s society, we can see how much we suffer from avoiding marriage at a young age. After puberty, there is a natural desire for intimacy, and we can either fulfill it through a halal relationship, like marriage and building a family to please God, or we may get lost in unhealthy relationships. Even worse, we risk becoming addicted to pornography. Even if someone doesn’t marry and manages to avoid sin, they still have to carry the heavy burden of stress from not fulfilling their natural desires, which can harm them in many ways and make them vulnerable in the future. Therefore, I believe we should encourage healthy Islamic marriages as soon as our children reach puberty, and we should be proud of this Sunnah.
Exactly! We are not like western people were we dont care if our daughters/sons go around having zina. What i find paradox is that in the west they are ok with their young childern having intimacy without marriage at 13/14/15 etc but make a big drama when someone at this age wants to marry young, which just doesn't make sense to me🤨
@@mari_000but millions of mslms dream of gettin citizenship in Europe 😂😂😂…and live under western culture…feedin dozens of chldrn in puuur mslm countries is not possible as islm teaches how to re..pro.,duce rapidly but doesn’t teach how to feeed such huge popultn..so mslms run to Christians for fuuuud,and jooobbs for their dozen chldrns😂😂
In a broad sense, I can agree with the sentiment that remaining unmarried, while sexually active, for multiple decades after hitting puberty is not a great strategy. It can be habit forming after awhile, and family formation should start earlier than it typically does in the US. Not as young as 9, though. Obviously. A question worth asking (and not dodging) is, What is the lower end at which meaningful consent can be given to marriage and/or to sexual intercourse? The answer to that cannot be at the earliest possible hint of puberty. That is an open invitation to abuse and exploitation. If you disagree with this for exclusively religious reasons, you should explicitly say so and truly realize that's what you are doing.
@@mmmcounts She wasn't "abused" or whatever nonsense you believe, dude. Even if she was indeed 9 years old, and was evidently mature beyond her years whose father gave his consent, as did she, so? Why don't you make the same, disingenous argument about non believers? Like those in the United States and other parts of the world that married younger girls than 9? Hypocrisy, much? Besides, what do you base "consent" on, dude?
Subhanallah Alhamdulillah I thank Allah for making me a Muslim. Islam is bound to attract the hearts and minds of people of understanding and knowledge
Ayesha was 19 years old when she married, 16 when she got engaged,, ..some one some time in history took 10 years of her age,,,when we stick to historical evidence, we will get to the truth.
No she was 6 when she was engaged and 9 married we know that from the hadith, and we belief it, so don’t try this misinformation. We don’t care what others may think about it because our morals comes from the one true god
MashaAllah! Look at the genuine interest and respect with which this young man is approaching Islam. May God Bless him, Guide him and include him amongst the Righteous. Aameen.
Ayesha r.a was 19 when she married to Prophet muhammad saw becoz Asma, the sister of Aisha r.a was 29...there was a difference of 10 years of age between Aisha and Asma....
@@nathansam9396 I've read it...most of the scholars have reconsidered the fact that somehow the chain of hadith had mentioned only تسعة while the actual تسعة عشر was omitted...it was only becoz that first ASHAR was omitted but we can verify from other "sahi sitta " that it was 19 not 9....to verify only from bukhari is not wise...
I feel that sometimes non-Muslims themselves do not do much research about Prophet Muhammad SAW and Islam, they only take stories from sources that cause hatred towards Islam. For Brother Matthew whom I salute he has done the right way in finding answers about Islam. For me, the questions that always provoke Islam are 1. The age when Aisyah RA got married, 2. The spread of Islam through the point of the sword, 3. Prophet Muhammad SAW had many wives, 4. Muslim women wear headscarves, 5. the assumption that the Quran teaches violence.
@8:30. The fact that these Christians are shocked and surprised to find out that in the Catholic sources Mary pbuh was 12 years old married to a 90 year old Jospeh but they seem to know about the marriage of Aisha (ra) really lets you know the sincerity of these people...
I’ll admit, I was surprised to hear about this tradition… although I am a Protestant, so I haven’t focussed as much of my research on Catholic tradition regarding saints as I have on dogmatic tradition
Actually the age of Joseph is not recorded in the Christian bible. Mary was a young woman and a young woman in Jewish tradition is older than 12 years of age. The exact age is not provided in the bible. Based on Jewish tradition a young woman is over the age of 16. There are no biblical documents or church tradition that states the information you wrote. You got ur information from false gospels ,the protoevangelim of James" to be exact, which was a 2nd century fabricated text,which was not wriiten by the apostle James. The Apostle James died in the 1st century,he never wrote a book under this name. The early church fathers never included this book,and it is refuted as a false gospel. It may be quoted in popular culture,but it was rejected as a book for our cannon or as inspired by the holy spirit. Ur using a fabricated 2nd century text which is not a tradition or accepted by the Christian church and then posting this as facts. Dont spread falsehoods to corrupt minds. When you post claims please be authentic and provide the source document. This is pure intellectual dishonesty here.
@@danthony9306 thank you for this information brother, very enlightening. I knew of the “young woman” tidbit but was not aware of the protoevangelium of James. Love you in Christ 🙏
if all Christians like this man, all the debates and theological exchange of information would be distributed in peace, both Islam and Christian. May Allah guide him into right path.
One undiscussed part is, How big of status Ayesha have in Islam ~ she have strong voice n impact on the ummah, she's not mistreated by Muslim. Muhammad s.a.w also a prophet that are protected from doing any sins and are better n fairest of any human being. Ayesha is wife of Rasullullah not one being mistreated like propaganda suggested
They don't realize that the person Aisha married was the BEST among ANY man ever. Even Aisha and ALL his other wives 100% agreed to this ! Most of them and all the close followers of Muhammad who were very close to Muhammad probably had seen one or 2 miracles performed by Muhammad. Even I too will have NO PROBLEM letting my daughter be married or EVEN WILLINGLY OFFER my daughter to a true prophet of God himself, if I already know that he is indeed 100% a true prophet of God ! What is so weird about that ? Especially if it was already a PERFECT NORM during that time for young girls to get married too the moment they reached puberty ?? Haters will ALWAYS be haters unless God Himself will give them guidance !
@@illzyaz 3 out of 4 caliphs were mur…ddrd…by mslms themselves…it’s a flop concept as not a single Muslim country has implemented caliphate in any of their 57 countries
IMPORTANT FACT : Historically, royal families arranged child marriages to secure alliances, often with no physical contact until both were of age, keeping the promise intact. Share and like to let people know, brothers and sisters!
12 year and 9 year is HUGE difference in a girl's sexual development............. mary was 12 in year -2000, aisha was 9 in year -1500............. by your logic, aisha should be atleast 13....... since 500 years later the norms were going upwards........
@@AsifKhan-hf9zy Mary and Joseph are imaginary unlike 6 yr old bby gurlll.Joseph was not a self proclaimed prpht no was he talking with angels on regular basis,nor he is considered a role model for humanity…😝😝😝…no father is so fuuulish to giv his 6 yr old bby to a 55 year old man who is living on borrowed time as life expectancy was very short 1400 years ago
Masha Allah as usual it so pleasant to watch brother Sabeel. Matthew is such a wonderful and respectful young man it actually made it more enjoyable to watch. May Allah guide him to Islam in sha Allah ameen 🤲
May Matthew be guided upon the right path. And may all our Christian brothers and sisters learn from him to seek knowledge from those to have knowledge, in a humble and respectful way. Really loved this video.
He cant imagine it differently because every time he closes his eyes to imagine, he imagines an American 9,10 year old! Lol and thats a HUGE Problem... Try thinking about it another way like have you lately seen the "Kids" from Palestine when they talk to the the Camera and when asked about things about Life and just pay attention in how Mature their answers are and in comparison to a 25 year old here in the West, those "Kids" sound EXTREMELY MATURE for their age so think about it in the past when many People lived very short Lives because of Many reasons and Wars so you never knew if you were gonna live long enough to make a Family but those young People at that time were hunting, cooking, looking after stock, farming, going to War, just too many reasons to even mention here in tje comment section! They cant fathom that a 10 year old in Ancient times was like an Adult now from Every aspect almost! I remember when I was 10 and in War, I was a Man at 10! I didnt think or play with toys but was truly thinking like an Adult, being around Adults and growing up in a very mature way!!! He needs to get the picture out of his head of a 9 or 10 year old american kid! HUGE DIFFERENCE! Not even a Comparison in Reality!!!
It's also kids 1400+ years ago. We don't know the exact maturity lvl they have. - Didn't Alexander the great conquer most of Europe, middle east, persia n etc under age of 30. People start working only at 23+ nowadays 😅
She's the most influential scholar in Islam, she practically taught all the major early scholars and narrated a huge number of narrations about Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him
@@rimacalid6557 she remained illiterate,motherless widow with no chance of remarriage…her marige was a total flop as she became a widow when she was still a teenager..she served no purpose for Islam as even today 6 billion people don’t believe in Islam and millions are quitting because of this marige
@@rimacalid6557 yea yea she was a professor and taught in Arabian university 😝😝😝…she remained illiterate,motherless ,jobless widow for rest of her life…with no chance of remarriage..what a disaster…she didn’t do anything for islm as there are 72 types of mslms,30 different kkuurrans and 6 billion people refusing to embrace islm
If you believe in your heart that there is only 1 God worthy of worship and that the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is the final and last messenger of God. My brother you are muslim. To make it public just go to the nearest mosque near you and take the Shahadah (announcing that you believe in one God and last Prophet) in public.
I can be your witness. Do you want that ? Super insulters of Islam, their secret weapon against Islam is ONLY with the worst of insult against Muhammad such as calling him a womanizer or child lover. BUT a true Muslim's secret weapon against this is - We really do not have to attack back on their religion ! Our REAL SECRET weapon against them is the COUNTLESS of OUT OF THIS WORLD miracles found in the Quran !!! But unfortunately, not many Muslims will not want to TRULY research about this themselves !
@@deeps3141 to becoming muslim u must admit sincerely with your heart that there is no God but Allah, and prophet Muhammad is a messenger and slave of Allah, if u testify it sincerely, then u became a muslim, but better go to nearest masjid and ask muslim to guide you
I think he’s a trainee missionary. He’s sussing out how to apply his skills in converting Muslims to Christianity, I say this because he is quite knowledgeable in Islam but still very firm in his Christian beliefs. But I hope I’m wrong, inshaAllah
Every country should be blessed by someone like you who can read minds and what's in the hearts so it can protect itself from its enemies. It must feel so good to have such a superpower.🙄🙄
@@eelmohamedand you must be very naive and easily taken advantage of if you think he’s being genuine, remember there is a camera in front of him. ولن ترضى عنك اليهود والنصارى حتى تتبع ملتهم.
@@zawazawa17just like mslms whose only job is to cunvvvrtt ppl once they get citizenship in Europe aftr comin as Ref..lu..gzz to escap pvrty in their mslm contrys😂😂😂
I hope he often comes and asks about Islam even for the purpose you mentioned, until he himself gets carried away and actually gets guidance from his initial purpose😂
@@Hitchens-k9scurrent bjp indian government is biased and influenced by Hindutuva!! Zakir naik is a smart guy , why would he fall into this trap 😂 he is enjoying his life outside india even Interpol has denied indian government’s request for his arrest due to no proof or evidence of crime against dr Zakir naik !!
Good to see a young person come to the mosque and seems genuinely interested in knowing more about Islam. Hope he sees truth in Islam and reverts to Islam.
"a young person come to the mosque and seems genuinely interested in knowing........" ALL THE NEGATIVE THINGS ABOUT ISLAM!.............. did nt ask a single question about salat, fasting, zakat, islam is peace, NOTHING, ZERO..........
that's why he's just like any other Christian who just wants to focus on what they perceive to be the negative things about Islam. He could have asked about anything else and yet zooms straightaway into the age of A'ishah.
19 yrs old. based on history and logic .And If you knew Muhammed personality you would be ashamed of accusing him of that fetish based on one ( 97 yrs old man) once said it and that was all your prove
with all due respect, Aisha WAS NOT 9, but 19-21 when she married. Look at Zakir Naik explanation for that as well (he also give references from credible sources)
It definitely cannot be 20s. As ppl that time died very young as well. Child bearing was important factor and human bodies were better suited the younger they were. Either way do WE need to justify to western cultural norms which they themselves implemented after ww1 due to the need of work force labour? Dont fall to justifying our values to suit western ideologies. Its a slippery slope once you start to accommodate their views.
No, stop trying to appease to the kuffar. She was 6 when she married him and consummated the marriage when she was 9. As an order from Allah, he saw her in a vision 3 times.
She was 9 years old full stop. This was their culture…the girl hits puberty her body is ready for marriage. My grandmother who was born in early 1900s was married off at 12. This was a norm back then. In the culture where I am from (not an Islamic culture but a Hindu culture), as soon as the women gets her period, there is a ceremony. This party symbolises that she is now a women. People in my culture still have puberty parties but the marriage age has gone up. My mum married at 17. Myself married at 25. Times change , customs change etc. it is unfair to look back and say what they did was wrong. The Prophet (saw) sent a 15 year old boy to lead an expedition. How many of us will trust a modern 15 year old boy to do that now? The 15 year old boy now is busy playing Xbox and fighting with his mum lol
@Muslimahintimacy Islam was sent as a universal religion meant for every generation, so your logic of culture fails. If that is the case, then Islam needs UPDATES ??? Do not listen too much to Wahhabi salafis, they ruined Islam and continue to do so
I would like to add to what brother Sabeel said. A’isha was betrothed to Jubayr ibn Mut’im ibn Adi, before Abu Bakr accepted Islam in the first year of the Call (12-13 years before the Hijrah). The marriage was called off. This is uncontested. This shows that the society didn’t see anything wrong with the marriage of Aisha. When Abu Bakr planned to go to Abyssinia during the fifth year of the Call (8-9 years before the Hijrah), Mut’im broke off the engagement because Abu Bakr had accepted Islam. This is uncontested.
More than 1400 years ago was another age. Getting married early was common not only for girls. And they were able to carry out their responsibilities based on the requirement at that time. By the way there were teenagers who were millitary generals in those days and the average life span was very much lower...
"And if you fear that you will not deal justly with the orphan girls, then marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] one or those your right hand possesses. That is more suitable that you may not incline [to injustice]." *This verse permits polygamy with up to four wives but makes justice and fairness among the wives a condition. If a man fears he cannot meet this requirement, the Quran advises him to marry only one. The emphasis on justice indicates that polygamy is not a general recommendation but a conditional allowance.* Another verse, Surah An-Nisa (4:129), highlights the difficulty of being just: *"You will never be able to be equal between wives, even if you should strive [to do so]."* This verse suggests that achieving perfect fairness between multiple wives is very challenging, further reinforcing the idea that marrying only one is often a better choice to avoid injustice. Thus, while the Quran permits polygamy, it encourages caution and fairness, prioritizing justice and the well-being of the family.
I think bro Matthes is a smart man. He's so gentle, open minded, logically and smart. I hope insyaAllah he will back to his fitrah which is as muslim, aameen.
We invite you to Islam brother Matthew. Not everyone who listens and contemplates with their hearts. We see it in you. May God guide you to the peaceful umbrella of Islam.
Some scholars calculate her age based on historical events. Ayesha is said to have been born in the year 613 CE, which was the 4th year after Muhammad's prophethood began. The marriage was consummated in the 2nd year after the Hijra (migration to Medina), which occurred around 622 CE. If she was born in 613 CE, she would be around 16 to 19 years old by the time of consummation in 624 CE .There are discrepancies in Hadith narrations regarding Ayesha's age. Some scholars point out that in another Hadith, Ayesha's older sister, Asma, was 10 years older than her, and Asma is said to have been 27 years old at the time of the Hijra. This could place Ayesha's age closer to 17 or 18 during the consummation of her marriage.
@@Lilly-z1x2m It should make “no sense” that is exactly what he is proving on the podcast! An if it made any sense the livestream are they to make you point. But as you admit none of the individuals goes on the platform makes any sense at all!
@Kirk-d7v you still make no sense. If you have some weird opinion of your own, that's fine, keep it because you are more concerned about your own conclusions than the truth. Everything he said made complete sense, and if u disagree, then to you is your way, and to us is ours Edit: look up Zakir Naik, Yasir Qadhi, Omar Suleiman and Mufti Menk if you are sincere about clearing your doubts, otherwise ✌️
I wish our scholars started with the age of aisha isn’t faith related and doesn’t affect your belief if you don’t believe she was 9 when asked about aisha matter! Bcoz many people confuse aisha age with Islam faith basics
@@seanou2837 not for a 55 year old man to marry 7 yr old bby guurl 😝😝😝…55 yr old men die within few yrs ,they don’t produce an children and no fathr is so fuullish to give his 7 yr old dautr to a 55 year old parvarrt who will die in a couple of yrs and render his dautr a widow for entire life
“I’m not here to debate, I’m here to learn”- this guy is more Muslim than our own Muslims. Debating over deen is not advocated in Islam, Unfortunately, our street dawah preachers should learn from this gentleman. We should never put ourselves in a position to prompt arguments and promote debate, rather we should always maintain an environment for discussion. Thank you, brother Sabeel for always allowing open discussion and conversation and never escalating to arguments like these young, naive, street dawah folks that are unfortunately popular today.
In a narration in Arabic culture womens age used to start after they reach their puberty, so Aisha Radiallahu Anga was 17 when she was engaged and married after a year or two
Salam 3alaikum . The brother have to mention the nowadays there is many young girls and boys have intimate relationship at age of 9 and 10 years old. That why schools are giving them contraceptives. So the western society accepts the term of boyfriend and girlfriend and reject the marriage
This is very common question that non-believers are asking about Mother Ayesha (R.A), who is Ummahatul Momineen ( The Noble Mothers of Muslims Ummah) and we as Muslim should let them know that these wives of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) are the Mothers of The Muslims Ummah. So whenever such a question and interaction comes in, kindly call Her Name as Mother Ayesha(R.A) . JazakAllah Khair!
He seems like a genuine guy. Bless him
I developed a video on this topic with a different approach. Please view it; it could be beneficial. Thanks.
Aameen
All are deceived to make people sin by
Throat off bad people to shed blood
Marry many women here in the name of helping them and get many in heaven
Go far place to Rotate around black stone
Take jaziya from mankind of other race saying third class
Finally Make AI to say this is what God says
No, he's not. If you noticed, he didn't actually accept the argument. No matter how many facts have been conveyed, he denied it. He just pretend to be nice but has got insincere intention. For example when he says Jesus has silent approval toward the young marriages, he then associates it with the homos, since Jesus was also silent it means he approved it, he said that because he means to argue with dr, Sabeel's argument knowing that Muslim strongly against LGTB. Wallahua'lam
Why keep entertaining this stoopid question? Does anyone really think that's the thing keeping someone from reverting to Islam? Allah guides whom He wills.
May Allah guide brother Matthew, he seems like a sincere individual
According to Shia sect of Muslims who are followers of Hazrat Ali (r.a), the cousin and son inlaw of prophet do not bleave on virginity and 9 years age of Aish when she got married with the prophet.
According to Shia's she was about 21-24 years & divorced before the second marriage with the prophet.
@@jawedakhtar5825 Their are no sects in Islam. A Muslims submits their will to god and follows the teachings of the prophet (SAW). I'm not really concerned about what any other people think regarding any matters pertaining to Islam and Muslims.
@@Golden_Scholar then why go criticising other religions who give y’all as..y…lmmm in their sophisticated countries
@@Hitchens-k9s Take your 1st grade level argument and go bother someone else 😂
Amiin 🤲🏽
Matthew is such a respectful individual and his zeal to learn is admirable. Kudos to your parents, they raised you well. I pray that he embraces Islam. May Allah (SWT) guide him to the truth, Ameen.
He really needs to have a discussion on the *God Logic* podcasts live stream!
@@Kirk-d7v.. nah, there is enough garbage on YT I think we'll just stick to helpful true facts
@@jowandean
So I take it *God Logic* podcasts are garbage?
@@Kirk-d7v.. great so you agree
*Jesus on When I join man and woman in marriage, it is meant for life...*
Message to Prophet John Leary
Sunday, October 6, 2024:
Jesus said: “My people, I truly have made man and woman just as I have made male and female animals. But I made man and woman in My Image with a soul and body. I have given you free will, but also I have given you My Commandments so you can love Me and your neighbor as yourself. When I join man and woman in marriage, it is meant for life and not to have divorce. What I have joined together should not be separated. You also have been given the opportunity to have children under the bond of marriage, and not with fornication. You are to bring up your children without any abortions which defies My Fifth Commandment of Thou shall not kill. Your families are the core of your society, and you should keep together so the family of a mother and father can help bring up their children. When one parent is missing, this puts an added burden on the children when they are missing a mother or father image to follow. Pray for your couples to get married and stay together.”
He’s sharp. Knows how to ask his questions without offending. Thank you!
Dont think he's that sharp when he brings up the age of A'ishah as if to find fault with Islam when in his Bible there are similar incidents and he didn't research into that.
@@electricfence3152he wants answers don’t be offended as a muslim i seek the answer as well, by asking bro sabeel can provide further clarity 😉
Yeah otherwise he'll be unalived pretty much 😅
An excellent example of a beautiful conversation on islam. Lots of respect to the young Christian asking pertinent questions with great respect.
@@MuhammadAli-hr1bj but illetrate arbi baba never used dialogue and conversation in his dealings with symbol users in workshop. he used terror of 10000 naked sword to capture their temple and destroy creative symbols of God. anyone destroying cultural heritage of the land is good guy or bad guy?
1st time I see a young man that does his research about islam before accusing 1.5 billion brothers and sisters not knowing nothing about them! Plus he’s way too respectful.. may Allah guide him
islam will reach 2 billion followers at the end of the year
It's 2 billion 1.5 was back in 2011
Aameen
@@NobodyForsomeone-hp9bv what will they eat ? 😝😝😝..Europeans have stopped Mslm migration and started deportation..your own oil rich Arabs don’t allow y’all to enter their contrys and rest of mslm contrys are too poor to feed such high population 😝😝😝
Isn’t that right? Nice to see a prudent people from different cultures. Goodness belongs to the human kind not those who breed satanic in their harts!
I'm a Christian. What annoys me about when people ask this about Aisha is the fact that they want to judge and criticism historic events in Islam by todays standards. Things were very different back then. But the hypocritical thing that I've noticed is that the same people tend to be pro zionist. and when you mention Israeli atrocities they want to justify and defend their zionism by making comparisons to historical events that occurred before the Geneva convention. This, to me, is a double standard. They may not have noticed themselves, but j always point it out.
It's what we called fallacy of presentism. Using today societal norm and applied it to a society that existed more than 1400 years ago.
You got it absolutely correct. The pro zios have this agenda to malign Islam. Divide and rule.
Firstly, you saying you're a Christian does not add anything relevant to the situation, and by what standards are you making this claim? Muhammad was a person of his time, but even if we compare his actions to those of early medieval Christians, they were still wrong. According to ancient Christian standards, it was also wrong. In your Bible, first-century Christian men were not allowed to hold church office if they were in a polygamous relationship. And please, don't bring the Gaza issue into this. Polygyny and polygamy are violations of the institution of marriage as given by God to our father Adam and mother Eve. Do not misrepresent Christianity and confuse your muslim brother and sisters, you will be held accountable for what you say friend.
@@Tomf-tz4pd polygamy are wrong? According to christianity?
If that is the case, all the prophets like Solomon, David and Abraham (pbut) has commited sins since they have more than one wife.
@@denoiz 100% Apostle Paul tells us that in the past God winked at our ignorance but now Jesus has come into the world no more excuses. You will also find that King David and King Solomon brought pain, sadness and destruction into their homes and into Israel for their polygamous relationship. God allowed the evil consequences of this relations to play out. We have no problem calling out when the blessed prophets do wrong, only in Islam are prophets infallible.
What a lovely respectful young man
MashALLAH, I can already see noor in Matthew's face, may Allah guide him to the straigh path ameen, he's very sincere and pure-hearted which ALLAH loves the most
He will be a caller for Islam inshallah. ❤
He is clever. I doubt he will become a muslim, because he asked the important and necessary questions.
@@Gatteleylife9957thats what Islam is all about asking questions and doing your research and eventually studying the belief/faith unlike Christianity emotion based beliefs and mystery/confusion 😂😂😂😂so sad
*God Logic* podcasts says he could be wrong!!
InShaAllah Ameen
@@Gatteleylife9957
What answers didn't you like?
All questions were answered and were totally convincing
Very civilized discussion mashallah ❤. The more I watch you brother Sabeel, the more I get amazed alhamdulillah. I appreciate the patience you have. May Allah reward you in this world and hereafter, ameen !
I've crafted a video on this topic from another perspective. Have a look; you might find it helpful. Thanks.
@@TheologyWithLogic western Christians and atheists are educated ant therefore well behaved,unlike mslms who get triggered at slight provocation 😝😝😝
@@TheologyWithLogic
Is it an adaptation of the *God Logic* podcasts?!
Sabeel needs to take his discussions on a livestream of the * God Logic* podcast .
@@Kirk-d7v No. I haven't even heard of "God Logic podcasts" before. SOrry
Mashallah this sheikh explains things clearly with examples !
To the point
May Allah give this wise man hidayah to revert to Islam.
Allahmah ameen ya rabbi 🤲🏻
@@devbakka4073 don’t worry 7 out of 10 converts leave Islam within one yr ,😝😝,24% American and whooping 12 million educated Indian converts have quit Islam according to pew research survey…2.4 million Pakistanis have become atheists according to their columnist Mr Orya Maqbool Jan…5% Saudis are atheists and 19% non religious according to 2012 Gallup survey ..today this percentage will be very high..thanks to MBS 😝😝
@@Hitchens-k9s where you got your study from?? lol come to Pakitan to see..🤣 atheism is dead and so is christainity and judaism...hinduism was dead when islam arrived to India they are so scared that they ban zakir naik🤣by the way why are you happy that people are becoming atheist?
I remeber in Pakistan we used used to have 10 people in mosques in prayers now there are more then 50 people in every prayer even in the morning... people now know atheism crap... Godless idiots.. the new generation are way smarter to catch atheism BS they have already cancelled atheism.
@@Hitchens-k9s West society are suffering from pedosphiles, homosexuality, Interests, porn industry,gambling, drugs, alcohol, creating wars and sex out of marriage.. are some of the things that is destroying the west society.. imagine throwing your old parents in an old house while they are sick and dying.. you society is crap and will soon perish because of homosexuality with no new generation to come.
@@Hitchens-k9s your fake statistics give you a false sense of security.
Alhamdulillah you speak so calmly....May Allah put his mercy on you
Excellent explanations to Matthew's questions. A very cordial conversation.
This intelligent young man is ready to accept islam and come to the truth inshallah.
He is ready to accept islm…that’s why he is labelled as intelligent…once he accepts islm he too will start believing in flying donkey, moon splitting,talking ants etc 😂😂😂
@@Hitchens-k9sHow about you?
@@realrazi 😝😝😝..I never believed in flying donkey or any self proclaimed prpht…
@@Hitchens-k9si watch vidio of a man and women with more harsh comment more than you and in the end they end up in tears with regret when the truth hits them..and you know what the 1st indication on the journey they had..they watch all the muslim and islam teaching like you😂😂and comment there..alot of cristian vidio pass in my wall but heyy i never wants to watch or more to comment in the section why..because even if he insult my religion it doesnt bother me,and it waste my time to do it..but youu i can see that something bother your heart thats why you in this comment sections😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉welcome to islam
@@Hitchens-k9s but you believed 1+1+1=1 ? 😀
Very respectful conversation and very well explained.
As an ex Christian myself all one can say is that there is absolutely NO religion or way of life that even comes close to Islam. It’s absolutely perfect.
Eastern Orthodoxy. Preserved for 2,000 years.
@@georgiacap9294 no it isn’t 😂 the Bible isn’t even preserved how can the religion be??? That’s totally nonsensical.
" It’s absolutely perfect."
thats factually and logically not correct.
islam allows owning of slaves and 50-60-70 year old perverts can marry a 9-10-11 year old girl..........
so THERE IS ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT in islam............ which makes it LESS THAN PERFECT
@@Just_passing_through23
Same message today about who Christ is as it was when the Holy Spirit descended over the Apostles on Pentecost starting the One Holy Catholic Apostolic Church. You have no idea what you’re talking about, my nonsensical friend.😊
@@georgiacap9294 what are you going on about??? 🤦🏻♂️ The Bible is nothing but filled with mistakes and errors and people manipulating the book??? Who cares what it says about Pentecost when the Bible cannot stand on its own as Christian scholars themselves tell the world that the Bible has been changed and is nothing preserved!!!!
Please before you post dribble learn from your own intellectuals what they say about the Bible…
All questions were beautifully explained by brother Sabeel, Jazaak Allahu khairan.
May Allah swt guide our brother Matthew to accept Islam, Ameen
AaminX3
@@rusidahzaidi9703 what date/year was Adam created? How old was Adam when he was created by MAGIC? When did he die ? Any DNA or fossil records or eyewitnesses? 😝😝😝..I bet no mslm will be able to answer these questions
@@Hitchens-k9swere the biography of jesus given to jesus? Can you answer this beloved sir? 😊❤
@@silverkhanruykhan6617 it’s as imaginary as your flying donkey,moon splitting,talking ants,124000 so called prphts or you god with 2 right hands ,invisible but male in gender 😝😝😝…or a self proclaimed godman claiming to talk with angel on regular basis but only in solitude and no eyewitnesses 😝😝😝
Uhu
The Power of Blood of Christ
Blood of Christ Vs Allah's (Eid al adha) Blood of Goat, Bakrid
When it comes to mortal sins like murders, adultery, violences, original sin goat's (or animal) blood or Blood of Christ sets humans free ? Bible says "So if the Son sets you free, you will be free INDEED."
If Arab / elite wanted to marry many times / women would they not start their own religion or bring out a religious book (called Quran) to suit their needs, appetite ?
So allah is not real but man made God for elite's divide and rule policy using man made religion / book mostly copied from the Bible. That's why single book / witness. Bible whereas mainly 7, 5 apostles Saints Peter, Matthew, John, Jude, Paul, and 2 Disciples, Sts Luke and Mark wrote Bible as separate witnesses and through Divine inspiration!
May Allah guide you Matthew Ameen and may Allah reward our brother for a beautiful islamic lecture Ameen 🤲❤️
Young man was so respectful, you can tell his so genuin.
This young man has a good heart! O Allah, please guide him to your path🤲
This Christian brother is very respectful ❤❤❤❤
This was so beautiful to watch... He answered and explained so nice. I wish debates could be like this instead of people just arguing and trying to make a person convert by proving them wrong. Make them find out themselves. Show them the beauty of your religion.
Matthew asked for knowledge. He seems sincere. This question always asked by non-Muslim with bad intention, but we never asked them back what was the marriage age of wives of other prophets. Why? Because we respect all the prophets
May Allah guide him 🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻 he sound like a good person ❤
What an educational discussion. This educates Muslims in the way to deal with questions: thorough, informed patient answers.
Very Good questions asked by brother Mathew and very Good and comprehensive answers by brother Sabeel 💕
Very calm and respectful conversation. Enjoyable to watch people listening than reacting trying to one-up each other.
dr sabeel is so gentle with his speech, i love listening to his answers
This christian brother is nice person may Allah guide him. Masha Allah mutmayeen bahtareen jawabat Sabeel shab ne diye... i am truly very impressed by his knowledge very truthfully, and precise answers have been given.
JAZAAKALLAHU KHAIRAA brother Sabeel….Cannot think of Answering those tough questions in a better way 🫡🫶🏼👍🏼
Ayesha was 6/ 7 ye@rs øld when she herself accepted the marriage proposal of prophet Muhammad ﷺ brought by her Father Hazrat Abubakr. But she was already engaged with Zubair Ibn Mut'im. They broke the engagement. Then she actually got married After three years when Prophet Muhammad ﷺ migrated to Madina, then Aisha was 9/10 ye@rs øld.
Aisha was mentally capable, physically and biologically mature and martially abled. The jéws and £nemies of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ like Abu jahal, sheebah, Utbah bin Rabeeah, Abu Lahab etc never cr!ticized his marriage. They could cr!ticize his marriage like today's phøbes do, but they knew that Hazrat Aisha was enøugh m@ture.
Aisha said that she used to put her head on Prophet Muhammad's shoulders while hugg!ng. She was also in the b@ttlefield where ch!ldren and old ones were not allowed. She was as teacher for women to teach them morals and Islam. She also narrated about 2210 Ahadiths. Even the highly knowledgeable and close companions of Prophet Muhammad acquired knowledge from her. She was always happy with her Marriage. She also said that she used to be@t prophet Muhammad in r@ce. She also led the Army in the B@ttle of Camels. Do you think a k!d can do such things. Wallahi it's the phøbic Heart which doesn't let a person accept the truth unless it opens up and get soften(H@tred-free). May God bless you.
(let's add our pray with :)
May Allah GUIDE him to become Muslim. InsyaAllah 😊
I have made a video on this topic from a different perspective, please have a look, you might find it useful. Thanks.
@@TheologyWithLogic Where do we find your video? Please.
How do u know he's Christian? Bcuz he's white and he says so? I don't understand the Muslim mindset
@@adams2736 "Theology With Logic", the same name.
What a bright young man. Mashallah tabarakallah. May Allah guide him and his familiy, friends and church, ameen.
Love and respect to this gentleman mathew... very openminded and respecfull
Brother Sabeel explanations are systematic, easy to absorb, based on authentic references, clear and concise.
JazakAllaahu khayran, may Allaah preserve and protect him - increase hin in knowledge. 🤲🤲🤲
@@zamaniahmad3920
Read Sahih Bukhari.. Not nonsense from him.
This was actually very interesting and helpful to understand these topics ❤
The ultimate knowledge belongs to THE ALMIGHTY ALLAH (GOD) and no way a believer could protest or decide to go against.
May we all be blessed with knowledge, wisdom and understanding.
Allahamdullilah I am a muslim ❤️, Allah Bless you brother, you are enlightening people
No need to accuse, but I still don't understand why Muslims kill Muslims, in Syria 500,000 and Yemen and other Muslim countries? Who is a real Muslim and who is not? Christians also fought each other? Without offending anyone, its hard to understand.
MashAllah, Matthew is a great guy...May Allah open his heart towards islam Ameen
thanks both of you guys are amazing an example of good people that respect each other
Genuine non Muslim putting effort to learn! Well done, Matthew, I pray Allah almighty guide me and you to the right path.
This was one of the best explanations I’ve heard on the Aisha age issue. I’m saving this to my favorites. Tysm
Very eloquent answer and great interviewing. جزاك الله خيرًا
Alhamdulillah.. wish all of us God creations get to listen to this very insightful, respectful session.
This subject has being on my mind a lot the ladt few days.. and its being answered... brilliantly..
If we look at today’s society, we can see how much we suffer from avoiding marriage at a young age. After puberty, there is a natural desire for intimacy, and we can either fulfill it through a halal relationship, like marriage and building a family to please God, or we may get lost in unhealthy relationships. Even worse, we risk becoming addicted to pornography. Even if someone doesn’t marry and manages to avoid sin, they still have to carry the heavy burden of stress from not fulfilling their natural desires, which can harm them in many ways and make them vulnerable in the future. Therefore, I believe we should encourage healthy Islamic marriages as soon as our children reach puberty, and we should be proud of this Sunnah.
Beautifully said. Mashallah
Exactly! We are not like western people were we dont care if our daughters/sons go around having zina. What i find paradox is that in the west they are ok with their young childern having intimacy without marriage at 13/14/15 etc but make a big drama when someone at this age wants to marry young, which just doesn't make sense to me🤨
@@mari_000but millions of mslms dream of gettin citizenship in Europe 😂😂😂…and live under western culture…feedin dozens of chldrn in puuur mslm countries is not possible as islm teaches how to re..pro.,duce rapidly but doesn’t teach how to feeed such huge popultn..so mslms run to Christians for fuuuud,and jooobbs for their dozen chldrns😂😂
In a broad sense, I can agree with the sentiment that remaining unmarried, while sexually active, for multiple decades after hitting puberty is not a great strategy. It can be habit forming after awhile, and family formation should start earlier than it typically does in the US.
Not as young as 9, though. Obviously. A question worth asking (and not dodging) is, What is the lower end at which meaningful consent can be given to marriage and/or to sexual intercourse? The answer to that cannot be at the earliest possible hint of puberty. That is an open invitation to abuse and exploitation. If you disagree with this for exclusively religious reasons, you should explicitly say so and truly realize that's what you are doing.
@@mmmcounts She wasn't "abused" or whatever nonsense you believe, dude. Even if she was indeed 9 years old, and was evidently mature beyond her years whose father gave his consent, as did she, so? Why don't you make the same, disingenous argument about non believers? Like those in the United States and other parts of the world that married younger girls than 9? Hypocrisy, much? Besides, what do you base "consent" on, dude?
What a beautiful video this was alhamdulillah for Islam
The brother is well prepared, may Allah reward him. And may Allah guide Mathew.
Subhanallah Alhamdulillah I thank Allah for making me a Muslim. Islam is bound to attract the hearts and minds of people of understanding and knowledge
😂😂😂😂
@sfuller5612 Alhamdulillah
Very well explained. It was nuanced and clear.
Ayesha was 19 years old when she married, 16 when she got engaged,, ..some one some time in history took 10 years of her age,,,when we stick to historical evidence, we will get to the truth.
But Christians forgot Maria married Joseph when Maria was 12 years old and Joseph was in his 90s. And at that time Jesus was born😂😂😂
No she was 6 when she was engaged and 9 married we know that from the hadith, and we belief it, so don’t try this misinformation. We don’t care what others may think about it because our morals comes from the one true god
She was 9 years old, not 19! Where did you get this information?
She was 19 or 20. Read into this yourselves instead of lazy requests for evidence.
Alhumdulillah. This was explained so well. Even I learn so much from this.
MashaAllah! Look at the genuine interest and respect with which this young man is approaching Islam. May God Bless him, Guide him and include him amongst the Righteous. Aameen.
Another and discussed matter is that, our beloved prophet (sm) never married a single women without Allah SWT 's permission.
May Allah give guidance to Mathew to true path , Ameen ❤
Ayesha r.a was 19 when she married to Prophet muhammad saw becoz Asma, the sister of Aisha r.a was 29...there was a difference of 10 years of age between Aisha and Asma....
Read Sahih Bukhari which clearly says Aisha was six and playing with dolls
Read Sahih Bukhari.. Not rubbish
@@nathansam9396 I've read it...most of the scholars have reconsidered the fact that somehow the chain of hadith had mentioned only تسعة while the actual تسعة عشر was omitted...it was only becoz that first ASHAR was omitted but we can verify from other "sahi sitta " that it was 19 not 9....to verify only from bukhari is not wise...
@@hawaalaina
Bukhari is not wise?
Sahih means AUTHENTIC.
Who are you to say it is not?
@@hawaalaina
Breastfeeding adults were in the quran as per these hadiths...
Still think islam is good?
this answered most of my long-time questions. wonderful, thank you..
I feel that sometimes non-Muslims themselves do not do much research about Prophet Muhammad SAW and Islam, they only take stories from sources that cause hatred towards Islam. For Brother Matthew whom I salute he has done the right way in finding answers about Islam. For me, the questions that always provoke Islam are 1. The age when Aisyah RA got married, 2. The spread of Islam through the point of the sword, 3. Prophet Muhammad SAW had many wives, 4. Muslim women wear headscarves, 5. the assumption that the Quran teaches violence.
I heartly appreciate brother Mathew for his maturity and being civilised through the whole discussion
May Allah grant him the best reward!!!!
What a great listener
@8:30. The fact that these Christians are shocked and surprised to find out that in the Catholic sources Mary pbuh was 12 years old married to a 90 year old Jospeh but they seem to know about the marriage of Aisha (ra) really lets you know the sincerity of these people...
I’ll admit, I was surprised to hear about this tradition… although I am a Protestant, so I haven’t focussed as much of my research on Catholic tradition regarding saints as I have on dogmatic tradition
@@user-en1xu7bj1r which claims are you referring to? :)
And that Issac married Rebecca when she was 3 years old when he was 40.
Actually the age of Joseph is not recorded in the Christian bible. Mary was a young woman and a young woman in Jewish tradition is older than 12 years of age. The exact age is not provided in the bible. Based on Jewish tradition a young woman is over the age of 16.
There are no biblical documents or church tradition that states the information you wrote. You got ur information from false gospels ,the protoevangelim of James" to be exact, which was a 2nd century fabricated text,which was not wriiten by the apostle James. The Apostle James died in the 1st century,he never wrote a book under this name. The early church fathers never included this book,and it is refuted as a false gospel. It may be quoted in popular culture,but it was rejected as a book for our cannon or as inspired by the holy spirit.
Ur using a fabricated 2nd century text which is not a tradition or accepted by the Christian church and then posting this as facts. Dont spread falsehoods to corrupt minds. When you post claims please be authentic and provide the source document. This is pure intellectual dishonesty here.
@@danthony9306 thank you for this information brother, very enlightening. I knew of the “young woman” tidbit but was not aware of the protoevangelium of James. Love you in Christ 🙏
if all Christians like this man, all the debates and theological exchange of information would be distributed in peace, both Islam and Christian. May Allah guide him into right path.
May Allah guide this brother to the true and one religion "Islam". His heart seeks truth and also has respect for other religions.
One undiscussed part is, How big of status Ayesha have in Islam ~ she have strong voice n impact on the ummah, she's not mistreated by Muslim. Muhammad s.a.w also a prophet that are protected from doing any sins and are better n fairest of any human being. Ayesha is wife of Rasullullah not one being mistreated like propaganda suggested
They don't realize that the person Aisha married was the BEST among ANY man ever.
Even Aisha and ALL his other wives 100% agreed to this !
Most of them and all the close followers of Muhammad who were very close to Muhammad probably had seen one or 2 miracles performed by Muhammad.
Even I too will have NO PROBLEM letting my daughter be married or EVEN WILLINGLY OFFER my daughter to a true prophet of God himself, if I already know that he is indeed 100% a true prophet of God !
What is so weird about that ? Especially if it was already a PERFECT NORM during that time for young girls to get married too the moment they reached puberty ?? Haters will ALWAYS be haters unless God Himself will give them guidance !
Yes and her father Abu Bakr is our 1st khalifah.
Dr Ahmed raised all of those points. Try to watch it again and you'll see.
@@illzyaz 3 out of 4 caliphs were mur…ddrd…by mslms themselves…it’s a flop concept as not a single Muslim country has implemented caliphate in any of their 57 countries
She rose up against the 4th Khalifa R.A. in the battle of Jamal...what a great feminist, the daughter of a great politician, must say!
IMPORTANT FACT : Historically, royal families arranged child marriages to secure alliances, often with no physical contact until both were of age, keeping the promise intact. Share and like to let people know, brothers and sisters!
8:00 Mary was 12 and Joseph was 86 when they got married... The norm. Of today is not the norm of back then
12 year and 9 year is HUGE difference in a girl's sexual development.............
mary was 12 in year -2000, aisha was 9 in year -1500............. by your logic, aisha should be atleast 13.......
since 500 years later the norms were going upwards........
The Virgin Mary was a virgin before and after giving birth to Jesus. She remained a perpetual virgin. Do not compare her to any other woman.
@@AsifKhan-hf9zy Mary and Joseph are imaginary unlike 6 yr old bby gurlll.Joseph was not a self proclaimed prpht no was he talking with angels on regular basis,nor he is considered a role model for humanity…😝😝😝…no father is so fuuulish to giv his 6 yr old bby to a 55 year old man who is living on borrowed time as life expectancy was very short 1400 years ago
Masha Allah as usual it so pleasant to watch brother Sabeel. Matthew is such a wonderful and respectful young man it actually made it more enjoyable to watch. May Allah guide him to Islam in sha Allah ameen 🤲
May Matthew be guided upon the right path. And may all our Christian brothers and sisters learn from him to seek knowledge from those to have knowledge, in a humble and respectful way. Really loved this video.
He cant imagine it differently because every time he closes his eyes to imagine, he imagines an American 9,10 year old! Lol and thats a HUGE Problem... Try thinking about it another way like have you lately seen the "Kids" from Palestine when they talk to the the Camera and when asked about things about Life and just pay attention in how Mature their answers are and in comparison to a 25 year old here in the West, those "Kids" sound EXTREMELY MATURE for their age so think about it in the past when many People lived very short Lives because of Many reasons and Wars so you never knew if you were gonna live long enough to make a Family but those young People at that time were hunting, cooking, looking after stock, farming, going to War, just too many reasons to even mention here in tje comment section! They cant fathom that a 10 year old in Ancient times was like an Adult now from Every aspect almost! I remember when I was 10 and in War, I was a Man at 10! I didnt think or play with toys but was truly thinking like an Adult, being around Adults and growing up in a very mature way!!! He needs to get the picture out of his head of a 9 or 10 year old american kid! HUGE DIFFERENCE! Not even a Comparison in Reality!!!
Exactly 💯
It's also kids 1400+ years ago. We don't know the exact maturity lvl they have.
- Didn't Alexander the great conquer most of Europe, middle east, persia n etc under age of 30. People start working only at 23+ nowadays 😅
@@gjulia312
In the BIBLE too it clearly states that Prophet Soloman married 700 Women !!
Does that mean Prophet Soloman was a WOMANIZER !
@@gjulia312 Alexander didn’t claim to be a prpht,nor did he live long,nor did he mari bby guuurls,now was a role model for humanity 😝😝😝
@@MeemHaMeemDhal--khaYaRaWawNun Solomon is as imaginary as your god with 2 right hands or 124000 so called prphts 😝😝😝
Muslims elevate Ayesha (may Allaah be pleased with her) as "our mother" - Mother of Believers.
She's the most influential scholar in Islam, she practically taught all the major early scholars and narrated a huge number of narrations about Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him
@@rimacalid6557 she remained illiterate,motherless widow with no chance of remarriage…her marige was a total flop as she became a widow when she was still a teenager..she served no purpose for Islam as even today 6 billion people don’t believe in Islam and millions are quitting because of this marige
No we didn't elevate her rather God himself called Wife's of prophet as Mothers of believers.
@@rimacalid6557 yea yea she was a professor and taught in Arabian university 😝😝😝…she remained illiterate,motherless ,jobless widow for rest of her life…with no chance of remarriage..what a disaster…she didn’t do anything for islm as there are 72 types of mslms,30 different kkuurrans and 6 billion people refusing to embrace islm
@@rimacalid6557 and still 6 billion people don’t believe in islm and millions of mslms are quitting islm😝😝😝
I want to convert to Islam today .. pls can u explain how ??
If you believe in your heart that there is only 1 God worthy of worship and that the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is the final and last messenger of God. My brother you are muslim. To make it public just go to the nearest mosque near you and take the Shahadah (announcing that you believe in one God and last Prophet) in public.
Go to your nearest masjid and speak with them.
I can be your witness. Do you want that ?
Super insulters of Islam, their secret weapon against Islam is ONLY with the worst of insult against Muhammad such as calling him a womanizer or child lover.
BUT a true Muslim's secret weapon against this is - We really do not have to attack back on their religion !
Our REAL SECRET weapon against them is the COUNTLESS of OUT OF THIS WORLD miracles found in the Quran !!!
But unfortunately, not many Muslims will not want to TRULY research about this themselves !
@@street_smartss137 so it means I have to accept Muhammad as my prophet to become a Muslim ??
@@deeps3141 to becoming muslim u must admit sincerely with your heart that there is no God but Allah, and prophet Muhammad is a messenger and slave of Allah, if u testify it sincerely, then u became a muslim, but better go to nearest masjid and ask muslim to guide you
May Allah bestow upon this young man taufiq and hidayah…Amin
Beautifully explained. ❤
I think he’s a trainee missionary. He’s sussing out how to apply his skills in converting Muslims to Christianity, I say this because he is quite knowledgeable in Islam but still very firm in his Christian beliefs. But I hope I’m wrong, inshaAllah
Every country should be blessed by someone like you who can read minds and what's in the hearts so it can protect itself from its enemies. It must feel so good to have such a superpower.🙄🙄
@@eelmohamedand you must be very naive and easily taken advantage of if you think he’s being genuine, remember there is a camera in front of him. ولن ترضى عنك اليهود والنصارى حتى تتبع ملتهم.
@@zawazawa17just like mslms whose only job is to cunvvvrtt ppl once they get citizenship in Europe aftr comin as Ref..lu..gzz to escap pvrty in their mslm contrys😂😂😂
Dont worry, they plan but Allah is the best of planners.
I hope he often comes and asks about Islam even for the purpose you mentioned, until he himself gets carried away and actually gets guidance from his initial purpose😂
India has this teacher but most of them are still blind 💔 may Allah guide them 🇸🇴❤🇮🇳
just ignorant, even after our Creator send one of the best sheikh like Zakir naik, most of them still denying the truth
India has not yet seen the *God Logic* podcasts debates?
@@treebusettt and many contrys have banned his channels..also allla couldn’t save him that’s why he is running away from Indian govt 😝😝😝
@@Hitchens-k9scurrent bjp indian government is biased and influenced by Hindutuva!! Zakir naik is a smart guy , why would he fall into this trap 😂 he is enjoying his life outside india even Interpol has denied indian government’s request for his arrest due to no proof or evidence of crime against dr Zakir naik !!
@@turbocharge2512 😝😝😝…he is definitely enjoying in pak and Pakistanis too are learning truth about islm….😝😝..
Good to see a young person come to the mosque and seems genuinely interested in knowing more about Islam. Hope he sees truth in Islam and reverts to Islam.
Jesus is THE Truth
"a young person come to the mosque and seems genuinely interested in knowing........" ALL THE NEGATIVE THINGS ABOUT ISLAM!.............. did nt ask a single question about salat, fasting, zakat, islam is peace, NOTHING, ZERO..........
that's why he's just like any other Christian who just wants to focus on what they perceive to be the negative things about Islam. He could have asked about anything else and yet zooms straightaway into the age of A'ishah.
@@electricfence3152 because the-taking of 6 year old Aisha by a 54 year old prophet , bothers every honorable man and woman .
19 yrs old. based on history and logic .And If you knew Muhammed personality you would be ashamed of accusing him of that fetish based on one ( 97 yrs old man) once said it and that was all your prove
InsaAllah this boy will embrace Islam soon❤❤
Matthew & Mr. Sabeel shares the same positive vibes. Bless for both
The status of Aisha was not "Single" rather it was "Engaged".
U can break an engagement by giving back the ring.
@@manmin517 you can break any things when you are conned by conmen 😝😝😝
with all due respect, Aisha WAS NOT 9, but 19-21 when she married. Look at Zakir Naik explanation for that as well (he also give references from credible sources)
It definitely cannot be 20s. As ppl that time died very young as well. Child bearing was important factor and human bodies were better suited the younger they were. Either way do WE need to justify to western cultural norms which they themselves implemented after ww1 due to the need of work force labour? Dont fall to justifying our values to suit western ideologies. Its a slippery slope once you start to accommodate their views.
No, stop trying to appease to the kuffar. She was 6 when she married him and consummated the marriage when she was 9. As an order from Allah, he saw her in a vision 3 times.
@@zawazawa17 where's the source sahih Bukhari fails with historical figures?😂😂😂😂😂
She was 9 years old full stop. This was their culture…the girl hits puberty her body is ready for marriage.
My grandmother who was born in early 1900s was married off at 12. This was a norm back then. In the culture where I am from (not an Islamic culture but a Hindu culture), as soon as the women gets her period, there is a ceremony. This party symbolises that she is now a women.
People in my culture still have puberty parties but the marriage age has gone up. My mum married at 17. Myself married at 25.
Times change , customs change etc. it is unfair to look back and say what they did was wrong.
The Prophet (saw) sent a 15 year old boy to lead an expedition. How many of us will trust a modern 15 year old boy to do that now? The 15 year old boy now is busy playing Xbox and fighting with his mum lol
@Muslimahintimacy Islam was sent as a universal religion meant for every generation, so your logic of culture fails. If that is the case, then Islam needs UPDATES ??? Do not listen too much to Wahhabi salafis, they ruined Islam and continue to do so
Brother Sabeel is a Great example for mankind Alhamdulilah ☝🏽🇵🇸 from Bradford west Yorkshire England 😊
may allah reward you brother and may allah make us all steadfast and firm in our belief on allah almighty for ever
I like the respectful man
May Allah SWT guide him ❤
I would like to add to what brother Sabeel said.
A’isha was betrothed to Jubayr ibn Mut’im ibn Adi, before Abu Bakr accepted Islam in the first year of the Call (12-13 years before the Hijrah). The marriage was called off. This is uncontested.
This shows that the society didn’t see anything wrong with the marriage of Aisha.
When Abu Bakr planned to go to Abyssinia during the fifth year of the Call (8-9 years before the Hijrah), Mut’im broke off the engagement because Abu Bakr had accepted Islam. This is uncontested.
More than 1400 years ago was another age. Getting married early was common not only for girls. And they were able to carry out their responsibilities based on the requirement at that time. By the way there were teenagers who were millitary generals in those days and the average life span was very much lower...
@@anuarismail8070 so a grown man around 53 married a child of age 9. Sickening
@@dushyantchaudhry4654 hindu marries cows and trees...Look at your own standard before judging something 🤦♂️
@@shinoiki3443 yes ofcourse., both sickening right? A grown man marrying a 9 year old and a man marrying a cow. Do you agree?
yes ofcourse., both sickening right? A grown man marrying a 9 year old and a man marrying a cow. Do you agree?
@@shinoiki3443 both disgusting right? a grown man marrying a 9 year old and a grown man marrying a cow. do you agree?
"And if you fear that you will not deal justly with the orphan girls, then marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] one or those your right hand possesses. That is more suitable that you may not incline [to injustice]."
*This verse permits polygamy with up to four wives but makes justice and fairness among the wives a condition. If a man fears he cannot meet this requirement, the Quran advises him to marry only one. The emphasis on justice indicates that polygamy is not a general recommendation but a conditional allowance.*
Another verse, Surah An-Nisa (4:129), highlights the difficulty of being just:
*"You will never be able to be equal between wives, even if you should strive [to do so]."*
This verse suggests that achieving perfect fairness between multiple wives is very challenging, further reinforcing the idea that marrying only one is often a better choice to avoid injustice. Thus, while the Quran permits polygamy, it encourages caution and fairness, prioritizing justice and the well-being of the family.
I think bro Matthes is a smart man. He's so gentle, open minded, logically and smart. I hope insyaAllah he will back to his fitrah which is as muslim, aameen.
This is the correct and just way to seek more understanding. Kudos to both. Alhamdulillah.
We invite you to Islam brother Matthew. Not everyone who listens and contemplates with their hearts. We see it in you. May God guide you to the peaceful umbrella of Islam.
ASSALAMOU ALEYKOUM
Asalaamu alaykum
Subtitle mode no active
Some scholars calculate her age based on historical events. Ayesha is said to have been born in the year 613 CE, which was the 4th year after Muhammad's prophethood began. The marriage was consummated in the 2nd year after the Hijra (migration to Medina), which occurred around 622 CE. If she was born in 613 CE, she would be around 16 to 19 years old by the time of consummation in 624 CE .There are discrepancies in Hadith narrations regarding Ayesha's age. Some scholars point out that in another Hadith, Ayesha's older sister, Asma, was 10 years older than her, and Asma is said to have been 27 years old at the time of the Hijra. This could place Ayesha's age closer to 17 or 18 during the consummation of her marriage.
Thank you for tje info ❤
This was very informative!
Br. Sabeel beautifully explained it. May Allah further bless him.
How can he be blessed when Br Sabeel is avoiding the livestream on the *God Logic* podcasts??
@@Kirk-d7v ? You make no sense
@@Lilly-z1x2m
It should make “no sense” that is exactly what he is proving on the podcast!
An if it made any sense the livestream are they to make you point.
But as you admit none of the individuals goes on the platform makes any sense at all!
@Kirk-d7v you still make no sense. If you have some weird opinion of your own, that's fine, keep it because you are more concerned about your own conclusions than the truth. Everything he said made complete sense, and if u disagree, then to you is your way, and to us is ours
Edit: look up Zakir Naik, Yasir Qadhi, Omar Suleiman and Mufti Menk if you are sincere about clearing your doubts, otherwise ✌️
@@Lilly-z1x2m
Unfortunately all the “Scholars”‘you mentioned above are reluctant to debate in the *God Logic* podcasts so that should say it all.
I wish our scholars started with the age of aisha isn’t faith related and doesn’t affect your belief if you don’t believe she was 9 when asked about aisha matter! Bcoz many people confuse aisha age with Islam faith basics
What Was The Age Of Consent In Europe/America In 1900/1800/1700 Century.
Case Closed
Delaware 1900, age if consent was 7.
@@seanou2837 not for a 55 year old man to marry 7 yr old bby guurl 😝😝😝…55 yr old men die within few yrs ,they don’t produce an children and no fathr is so fuullish to give his 7 yr old dautr to a 55 year old parvarrt who will die in a couple of yrs and render his dautr a widow for entire life
“I’m not here to debate, I’m here to learn”- this guy is more Muslim than our own Muslims. Debating over deen is not advocated in Islam, Unfortunately, our street dawah preachers should learn from this gentleman. We should never put ourselves in a position to prompt arguments and promote debate, rather we should always maintain an environment for discussion. Thank you, brother Sabeel for always allowing open discussion and conversation and never escalating to arguments like these young, naive, street dawah folks that are unfortunately popular today.
In a narration in Arabic culture womens age used to start after they reach their puberty, so Aisha Radiallahu Anga was 17 when she was engaged and married after a year or two
Salam 3alaikum . The brother have to mention the nowadays there is many young girls and boys have intimate relationship at age of 9 and 10 years old. That why schools are giving them contraceptives. So the western society accepts the term of boyfriend and girlfriend and reject the marriage
This is very common question that non-believers are asking about Mother Ayesha (R.A), who is Ummahatul Momineen ( The Noble Mothers of Muslims Ummah) and we as Muslim should let them know that these wives of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) are the Mothers of The Muslims Ummah. So whenever such a question and interaction comes in, kindly call Her Name as Mother Ayesha(R.A) . JazakAllah Khair!