Heeramandi Series Review By Baradwaj Rangan | Manisha Koirala | Aditi Rao Hydari | Sonakshi Sinha

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 кві 2024
  • #heeramandi #manishakoirala #sonakshisinha #aditiraohydari
    Heeramandi Series Review By Baradwaj Rangan | Manisha Koirala | Aditi Rao Hydari | Sonakshi Sinha
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    GT Holidays - South India's No.1 Travel Brand.
    For vacation enquiries call +91 9940882200
    Website : www.gtholidays.in
    GUVI:
    bit.ly/49wRFes
    GUVI is an HCL Group Company based in IIT Madras Research Park Chennai, India. GUVI offers free and paid learning courses on various IT and tech domains in Indian vernacular languages such as Tamil, Telugu, Hindi, Kannada, Bengali, and English.
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    In Association with Divo :
    Website - web.divo.in/
    Instagram - / divomovies
    Facebook - / divomovies
    Twitter - / divomovies
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 113

  • @zanseb574
    @zanseb574 Місяць тому +96

    Sharmin was really unbearable to watch. No variety of expressions and a monotone dialogue delivery.

    • @amodhsaxena6103
      @amodhsaxena6103 Місяць тому +2

      Nepo kid, she is related to Bhansali

    • @sabrinakhan8217
      @sabrinakhan8217 Місяць тому +1

      Bhansali is confusing Lahore with Hyderabad, Ouadh or Lucknow. Lahore has always been a Punjabi city. You guys are totally ignorant about Pakistani regions, its race, culture, languages, geography and ethnic make up. Please stick to subjects that pertain to India. Pakistani regions were part of British created India for less than 100 years, in its over 5000 years of history. Bharat is a lie concocted by Vivkenanda, Gwaliar, Arya Smaj, RSS etc schools of thought , in late 1800's. Under which all regions under British rule were hallucinated as one ancient Bharat that never existed. lol. No European, Russian, isreali, Japanese scholar, historian has ever verified the existent of Bharat. The term India was creation of Europeans for South Asian regions just like they created the word AFrica.
      It seems like Sanjay ne apni budsurraat neice ko promote kerne ke liya Netflix ko loot liya hai.

    • @amodhsaxena6103
      @amodhsaxena6103 Місяць тому +1

      @@sabrinakhan8217 ‘Pakistani culture’? Are you delusional? You can’t have it both ways. If you say India as a concept is concocted, then how do u say Pakistan isn’t? Come on, at-least be consistent with your logic. And what do u mean ‘you guys’? Bhansali koi representative nahi hai ek pure culture ka. Many of us are at least interested in learning about other people.

    • @mahnoorqureshi3281
      @mahnoorqureshi3281 25 днів тому

      @@sabrinakhan8217Very Apt! Spot on! 👏👏👏

  • @Besties591
    @Besties591 Місяць тому +23

    The way Manisha koirala performed Mallikajaan gave it an unimaginable flare.. especially because of the shock and surprising factor of not seeing her in such a role as well as offscreen demeanor a complete contrast to the portrayal of Mallikajaan! It was fabulous

    • @neov100
      @neov100 13 днів тому

      💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

  • @harshithchintu
    @harshithchintu Місяць тому +41

    Baddy is like 'The Harsha Bhogle' of cinema. The way he breaks it down🤌🏽
    I look forward to your reviews more than the actual film itself!

    • @vishalramesh6939
      @vishalramesh6939 Місяць тому +3

      Sorry but Bhogle has lost his spine, not through any fault of his own, its just India

  • @nipunpurohit6029
    @nipunpurohit6029 Місяць тому +14

    Sonakshi Sinha was great, but her character was not written that well with unconvincingly sudden changes of heart. Sharmin Segal had one bland expression throughout.

    • @vkvarman2422
      @vkvarman2422 Місяць тому

      You dont have much experience with women i take it

  • @m.pd4619
    @m.pd4619 26 днів тому +3

    Excellent narration. I felt like I re-watched the whole series. Keep going BR.

  • @bilal_ahmed1011
    @bilal_ahmed1011 Місяць тому +12

    I think Bhansali should become an painter rather than a story teller. His love for opulence, grandeur, beauty and aesthetics consumes the story. The series bleeds with beauty but never comes even close to plucking your heart's strings like a Devdas or Begum Jaan does.

  • @ojaswijoshi4337
    @ojaswijoshi4337 Місяць тому +21

    So good! Love the entire series. Everyone in the cast did a great job, but Sonakshi and Manisha truly stole the show with her captivating performance. The songs were enchanting, the costumes were exquisite, and the cinematography was breathtaking. Congratulations to Sanjay Leela Bhansali and the entire team for crafting such a mesmerizing cinematic experience.

  • @vatsaldesai3131
    @vatsaldesai3131 Місяць тому +5

    Thank you for wonderful Review... Just completed 1st Episode... Can't wait to watch them all ... ❤

  • @aishuin2002
    @aishuin2002 Місяць тому +11

    Absolutely brilliant.. Manisha has nailed her role 👌

  • @shrutiaryal5223
    @shrutiaryal5223 Місяць тому +17

    Are you crazzy? Sonakshi was terrific. No comparison with Sharmin who was poorest cast. Unanimously she was bland and bad actor!

  • @joeldubba
    @joeldubba 28 днів тому +1

    Excellent review! Thank you Baddy sir!

  • @englishvinglishh5601
    @englishvinglishh5601 Місяць тому +7

    Boring series I didn't expect this magicless screenplay from Bansali. Few starting & last episodes are okay. Rest just boring conversations.emotions not captured ..the main love story completely failed no felling.. the music is not at all good which trademark of Bansali. the visuals are very impressive but how long we can watch it.

  • @hianjana
    @hianjana Місяць тому +7

    Manisha was on fire! Absolutely loved her! 🤩🤩🤩 Loved Sonakshi too! Every scene where Mallikajaan and Fareedan was 🔥🔥🔥 Bibbojaan (Aditi) was also interesting to watch. The outfits and palace like setting was very beautiful but I wondered if courtesans could really afford this much. Overall, it was a treat to watch (except for those scenes featuring Alamzeb!!!).

  • @Pushpanflow
    @Pushpanflow Місяць тому +1

    Onother outstanding reiew by a Master of his craft. Thanks so much MR Baradwaj. Hope to meet you Sir, when in Chennai in August.

  • @myspace04
    @myspace04 Місяць тому +1

    Really appreciate you providing your thoughts in one sentence on the video thumbnail. I have been waiting for something like this from you sir, so that I can decide whether to watch a film or not, without watching the full review and getting spoilers. Will watch the review after I watch the movie.

  • @krishniarumugam
    @krishniarumugam Місяць тому

    I think it also highlights the cusp of old vs new..changes in the guard whether politically or socially and how "values" have to be adapted.

  • @Arya-cs7kj
    @Arya-cs7kj Місяць тому +56

    This is cheating. Where's the interview with SLB? 😭😭

    • @adityamohan1773
      @adityamohan1773 Місяць тому +8

      It hasn't even been 2 hrs since the movie was reviewed. He'll call him for lights camera analysis maybe

    • @kuumarrdbhattarrai7772
      @kuumarrdbhattarrai7772 Місяць тому

      alongside Manisha Koirala would be a feast ,Baddie

  • @gtramt2960
    @gtramt2960 Місяць тому +5

    I loved the series. Manisha and Sonakshi were top notch. What dialogues…

  • @HAssifi
    @HAssifi Місяць тому +4

    This is my feedback, sorry it’s a long one. Usually with series you get invested in the characters and the story line keeps you on the edge of your seat but not in this case. Lot’s of hard work and it beautifully made but it doesn’t hold your interest for too long. It should have been made as a 2 hour movie. Music is fine, I have all the songs but none of them stands out. ⭐️⭐️⭐️

  • @dhaneshmenon2915
    @dhaneshmenon2915 22 дні тому

    Must watch for it's stunning visuals, music & performances👌

  • @abinayaarunakumar137
    @abinayaarunakumar137 Місяць тому +4

    I never knew Manisha and sonakshi would act like devil ..!

  • @femiqueen5855
    @femiqueen5855 Місяць тому +13

    Manisha is absolutely brilliant

  • @vineeshp6
    @vineeshp6 Місяць тому +27

    11 minutes video.
    Code accepted ❤

  • @AshwiB21
    @AshwiB21 29 днів тому

    hey hey hey. what does fareedhan's hindi quote means? english pls!

  • @ashrafffazal5638
    @ashrafffazal5638 Місяць тому +1

    Agree with most of this review, except I thought the Sonakshi was really bloody good. Her expressions were on point and she really brought it home for me. Also Sharmin was good imho, she is a new actor and has limited experience, but I liked her in the movie. Farida Jalal was so delightful. Bhansali is really the man though, he really has an amazing vision and there is something to find in every scene, treasures that you really have to watch properly to watch.

  • @diana9856
    @diana9856 Місяць тому

    I love your reviews thank you :)

  • @prabhathalovesmovies
    @prabhathalovesmovies Місяць тому +2

    Cannot wait to see the web series

  • @kanakchiru9090
    @kanakchiru9090 12 днів тому

    Superb analysis !

  • @amodhsaxena6103
    @amodhsaxena6103 Місяць тому +24

    Baddy, even the trailer indicated that the show will have horrible acting, and over the top treatment, how can you defend this non sense? Even the streaming space seems to be cannibalised by these overrated theatrical directors like Shetty and Bhansali. This should stop. They will pollute this space also.

    • @Hrith_
      @Hrith_ Місяць тому +3

      Bro, the ott platform wants the crap shit . Many directors around india are rejected the reason being not popular actor , not over the top film ,they just want safe generic shit . When netflix launched new shows of trailers for the year, it was only bollywood and 1 telugu show, which is copied. They are racist to some regions as well.

    • @SuyashFayn
      @SuyashFayn Місяць тому +4

      Over the top performance doesn't mean it's a bad performance.

    • @girijaphatak9022
      @girijaphatak9022 Місяць тому

      Ya i didn't like the series too

    • @amodhsaxena6103
      @amodhsaxena6103 Місяць тому

      @@SuyashFayn this one is bad though.

  • @aasthagupta1661
    @aasthagupta1661 Місяць тому +1

    Love the review 😊

  • @storywala88
    @storywala88 Місяць тому

    Well put. Sounds intriguing.

  • @kaarthikarul
    @kaarthikarul 8 днів тому

    i loved it till the 6th episodes. I felt the freedom fighting narrative could be avoided and it could have focused more on Fareedan's backstory.
    I usually watch in the original language but due to too much Urdu I switched to Tamil and the dubbing is ammmazing. Rohini for Manisha and Deepa Venkat for Sonakshi simply made it worth watching 🔥
    Even the dialogues are so good esp the shayaris are written with rhyming words in the dubbing as well.
    Sharmin is a major drawback for me. Also I felt SLB could have cast Rekha in a role or at least made the actresses playing courtesans watch Rekha's Umrao Jaan to learn those bewitching looks and attitude and also to dance with such grace and elegance ❤

  • @prabhathalovesmovies
    @prabhathalovesmovies Місяць тому +2

    Absolutely loved the web series particularly the integration of the freedom movement and Tawaifs. The Azadi song raises such goosebumps unlike Deepika's Jauhar sequence in Padmavat that was more of a fashion parade. Both Manisha Koirala and Sonakshi Sinha were too good

  • @ankitgokani
    @ankitgokani Місяць тому +1

    Beautifully captured

  • @rajarshisyam5093
    @rajarshisyam5093 Місяць тому

    you could not see the fire in Sonakshi? I felt she shined in every frame. Shamim was a stone faced wooden log though.

  • @swatkat6286
    @swatkat6286 Місяць тому +6

    Boring series! It was all over the place.. I'm not sure how much longer you did want get to an extent of being in the good books of these film makers from the way you reviewed animal. Please unfollow him folks!

  • @VamsiGatamaneni
    @VamsiGatamaneni Місяць тому +3

    Sharmin could have been replaced by Ananya or even Jahnvi for that matter, she just had a stone face throughout the show

    • @madhukarg8052
      @madhukarg8052 Місяць тому +1

      just watch Tried and Refused Productions review of Heeramandi and you will definitely have a kick 😂

    • @Besties591
      @Besties591 Місяць тому +1

      Haha jahnvi ananya and Sharmin .. nepo kids are ingrained in us now that we can’t think beyond them

    • @PerzinDaruwala
      @PerzinDaruwala Місяць тому +1

      I think Tripti Dimri could have been good Alamzeb

  • @seemamshetty
    @seemamshetty Місяць тому +1

    Sorry , it was hard to get past the first episode , manisha acted well .

  • @YaathumOoreGo
    @YaathumOoreGo 29 днів тому +1

    Finally BR also took money for review? Seems like Netflix paid him huge

  • @saravananbojarajan6424
    @saravananbojarajan6424 Місяць тому +6

    Hold on Rangan - isn't it a series ?you watched all episodes with in a day? that's a lot of screen time in a day.

    • @noneofyourbiznizz
      @noneofyourbiznizz Місяць тому +2

      All critics and joufnalists got to see it 2days beforr

  • @vanderer_prashant
    @vanderer_prashant Місяць тому

    baradwaj, is it good or not?

  • @nooralimran4643
    @nooralimran4643 Місяць тому +1

    So basically, there are elements that can be celebrated but not the whole thing as a whole. This Urdu, poetry, grace, glitter, glamor and "Muslimexotification" is old and cliche. Wish there was a more compelling story, screenplay and something different. Not every Bhansali movie has to be a Ghazal

  • @ayushranjan4881
    @ayushranjan4881 Місяць тому

    Sir u were absolutely right Sonakshi and Sharmin this is what happens when nepotism and mediocrity thrives 👀💀

  • @neelamsrjn
    @neelamsrjn 28 днів тому

    Please don’t put sonakshi and sharmin in the same sentence 😮… sharmin was unbearable….Sonakshi was really good

  • @prabhathalovesmovies
    @prabhathalovesmovies Місяць тому +1

    Very happy for SLB

  • @bobo-cm7zq
    @bobo-cm7zq Місяць тому

    The hype he gives for sonakshi s entry is way too much.

  • @user-xu3wl3hn7b
    @user-xu3wl3hn7b Місяць тому +3

    Wtf man it's terrible series i couldn't pass the terrible pronunciation and accents of urdu in Lahore that's the heart of Panjab

  • @satishtorgal7050
    @satishtorgal7050 Місяць тому +13

    Bansali's this is 3rd or 4th movie on prostitutes.

    • @MrinmayChakravarty-jf4nr
      @MrinmayChakravarty-jf4nr Місяць тому

      😂

    • @eileenguy9478
      @eileenguy9478 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@MrinmayChakravarty-jf4nr what's so funny?

    • @ankitm7030
      @ankitm7030 Місяць тому

      Because her own mother was stage singer...

    • @Saialluri7854
      @Saialluri7854 Місяць тому

      Yeah. Super tired of this.

    • @PhoneTest-vf3gv
      @PhoneTest-vf3gv Місяць тому

      Devdas, Saawariya, Gangubai and Heeramandi. SLB is obsessed with sex workers, courtesans. I wonder why

  • @rameshgopal3394
    @rameshgopal3394 Місяць тому

    Terrible writing and story , torturous show... The change into patriotic mode in the finale episode was totally off tone.... There is absolutely nothing in the show , hated every character and nothing to connect with them... Will come back to this review after a few days again , maybe I can like something

  • @debowmick
    @debowmick Місяць тому +5

    he is a sold out now 😢

  • @pallavi31dec
    @pallavi31dec Місяць тому

    i thought sonakshi was good, sharmin was given screen time cuz #nepobaby

  • @dontknowwhatsgngon2704
    @dontknowwhatsgngon2704 Місяць тому

    i dont agree w the flowery review - Other than photography and production value, it was a did - The girl who played alam was unbearable - Minsha, Sonakshi and aadithi were wasted -

  • @Gurglingbrook
    @Gurglingbrook Місяць тому +1

    You gave away way too much with no warning

  • @unpackedwonders
    @unpackedwonders 15 днів тому

    Alamzeb has no expressions at all.. The only drawback is her in this series

  • @nandanheble7941
    @nandanheble7941 Місяць тому +2

    Not interested in this

  • @1234CDAB
    @1234CDAB Місяць тому

    Sharmin was absolutely pathetic. Unbearable, stood out like a sore thumb

  • @mayak2676
    @mayak2676 Місяць тому +4

    Opulent but quite boring....very poor writing

  • @kuumarrdbhattarrai7772
    @kuumarrdbhattarrai7772 Місяць тому

    ❤❤❤

  • @tashmivyas
    @tashmivyas 29 днів тому

    It was a very bad series, with so much of pakeezah, Meena Kumari overdose/plagiarism. It has become too much of bhansali just copy pasting things from MKs movies, the opulence is absolutely out of place, the characters and their arc were not well thought out, had abrupt twists and change of hearts. Manisha did well, but was again forced to modulate her voice in Rekha's pitch, Sharmin was absolutely hopeless.
    You hv lost all credibility with your review of animal and now with this. If a series is bad call is so, stop buttering people.

  • @shadabahmed579
    @shadabahmed579 Місяць тому

    sabzimaandi

  • @user-xu3wl3hn7b
    @user-xu3wl3hn7b Місяць тому +7

    you didnt have to be this intellectually dishonest

  • @user-xu3wl3hn7b
    @user-xu3wl3hn7b Місяць тому +2

    It's a terrible tv series, probably the worst indian i have ever watched

  • @bharatchaudhary8996
    @bharatchaudhary8996 Місяць тому

    Takla ye Hindi me hai hindi me review kar

  • @m.pd4619
    @m.pd4619 26 днів тому

    Excellent narration. I felt like I re-watched the whole series. Keep going BR.