Curator Q&A #5: Tank Shells | The Tank Museum

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 373

  • @Gravlar
    @Gravlar 4 роки тому +319

    Bloody hell, made my heart skip a beat when you started talking about David Fletcher there with “unfortunately”

    • @jlvfr
      @jlvfr 4 роки тому +16

      Right? Bad way to start!

    • @sshep86
      @sshep86 4 роки тому +37

      Now, unfortunately...
      Me: Noooooooooooooooo... Oh, he's got bad Internet. Phew.

    • @zizkazenit7885
      @zizkazenit7885 4 роки тому +1

      I KNOW

  • @MPPelli
    @MPPelli 4 роки тому +154

    Curator at Home, Director at Home, this is almost a daily thing. And all interesting and fun. You really spoil us!

    • @markfryer9880
      @markfryer9880 4 роки тому +1

      I am having trouble keeping up as I still have to go to work. Maintaining a large school never stops, especially in Autumn Downunder, damn leaves doing their best to clog up gutters and drains.

  • @obsydium
    @obsydium 4 роки тому +194

    As unpleasant as those tales may be, it is imperative that we are all told such things. Only through knowing the horrors of war will we do our best to avoid it. Thank you.

    • @aidan11162
      @aidan11162 4 роки тому +5

      Obsydium both on point and missing it. Knowing on an intellectual level and knowing at the physical and emotional level by living it are two entirely different things

    • @robnichols9331
      @robnichols9331 4 роки тому +4

      Absolutely and wholeheartedly agree. Superbly handled here in the video too.

    • @piotrwadoowski1280
      @piotrwadoowski1280 4 роки тому +6

      Well said. I think that this topic as unpleasant as it is, it's more important then "fun" stuff with tanks.

    • @jancz357
      @jancz357 4 роки тому +5

      let politicans pay with their own money for wars and suddenly you'll have world peace, war is expensive, and is never payed by those who start it

    • @25xxfrostxx
      @25xxfrostxx 4 роки тому +2

      Agreed. If the reality is horrific, the knowledge of it has to be as well or people start to lose the gravity of it.

  • @matthayward7889
    @matthayward7889 4 роки тому +294

    “David fletcher is staying somewhere there’s not any internet”: he’s holding out in the museums Mk VIII.

    • @pdehun6234
      @pdehun6234 4 роки тому +35

      Or in the TOG 2, he can even make a dance party in it :O

    • @Boric78
      @Boric78 4 роки тому +22

      @@pdehun6234 You just know he has his own one, out the back. I would imagine furnished like a Hobbits hole with a fine selction of cakes and real ale.

    • @neilwilson5785
      @neilwilson5785 4 роки тому +10

      I don't know. I bet WiFi reception is just as good in there now as it was in 1918. Should be fine.

  • @AndrewJonWright
    @AndrewJonWright 4 роки тому +72

    Lest we forget - war isn't about games, but death and destruction. Thanks, David, for reminding us all.

  • @rainerfantasie9573
    @rainerfantasie9573 4 роки тому +21

    The curator of one of the most important and influencial tank museums in the world sitting in front of his compost heap explaining the jacket hanging over his chair.
    There's upsides to this virus situation.

  • @1337flite
    @1337flite 4 роки тому +55

    David I'm so glad you told the stories about the casulaties. I"m sure its unpleasant for you in many ways, but it is necesary and too many people do disassociate the horrible sites, smells and experiences from the games, the displays etc.

  • @detlevschmalzbauer2346
    @detlevschmalzbauer2346 4 роки тому +17

    “It is only those who have neither fired a shot nor heard the shrieks and groans of the wounded who cry aloud for blood, more vengeance, more desolation. War is hell.” William Tecumseh Sherman

  • @hermanlindqvist7238
    @hermanlindqvist7238 4 роки тому +39

    David here I was thinking, what if the COVID-19 lock down didn't come along? You would have never told us the story about Ron? With all this great detail... what a miss. Think how long these videos can be seen in future, how many great details are mentioned in each talk that you might not even realize are of great value to others looking back. Dave you must keep this going. Thank you very much!

    • @ginvr
      @ginvr 4 роки тому

      Indeed, as awful as these times are the tank museum have produced some real gems

  • @CommissionerSleer
    @CommissionerSleer 4 роки тому +29

    11:40 for David's dog :)
    A welcome cameo appearance to soften a very morbid subject.

  • @LurchLures
    @LurchLures 2 роки тому

    So quintessential British. A guy in a sunny garden. Blackbirds singing and some great commentary about a favourite subject. Perfect.

  • @jamesharbourt4787
    @jamesharbourt4787 4 роки тому +6

    For the record as an American the first time I went to the Museum I cried like full tears which the thought “these were there they saw soo much” it was truly beautiful

  • @cobra5087
    @cobra5087 4 роки тому +3

    Yes! David thank you for the hand rubbing and the clap! Love from Canada! We’ve had to postpone the effort to adopt David Fletcher as my grandfather! We had maybe one vote for! Things made in Canada last for ever.

  • @forresta65
    @forresta65 4 роки тому +3

    Thanks for doing these. Should be a regular go.

  • @jbuckley2546
    @jbuckley2546 4 роки тому +10

    It couldn't get any more British. Decided to shoot the vid with a compost heap as backdrop. Love you to bits.

  • @JamLeGull
    @JamLeGull 4 роки тому +20

    Thanks for the story about the casualties. It’s important we know this stuff.

  • @domhardiman6437
    @domhardiman6437 4 роки тому +69

    The mustache is well gentlemen. All is right in the world.

    • @james.black981
      @james.black981 4 роки тому +3

      Kim Jung Un hasn't been seen in public, neither has David Fletcher. Coincidence?...

  • @MacChew008
    @MacChew008 4 роки тому +7

    Thank you for remembering those that made the ultimate sacrifice. It is comforting, that even in the midst of War, Chivalry and Honour is upheld. Stay Safe Sir.

  • @keeperofthecheese
    @keeperofthecheese 4 роки тому +3

    These little explanations are excellent. Thanks very much for going out and doing them. I only wish you had a good cup of tea to enjoy as you do them!

  • @mymomsaysimcool9650
    @mymomsaysimcool9650 4 роки тому +13

    I was a US 3rd Armored medic in Desert Storm. The smell from Highway of Death has remained with me to this day. I can not associate the smell of diesel without the smell of .... well, you know.

    • @FieldMarshalFry
      @FieldMarshalFry 4 роки тому +1

      the Highway of Death was a damn war crime....

  • @Daemascus
    @Daemascus 4 роки тому +192

    *Sees him heft a 17 pounder shell one handed* What. Oh it's an inflatable.

    • @JamLeGull
      @JamLeGull 4 роки тому +47

      Nah, Willey is just that much of a man

    • @le_floofy_sniper_ducko
      @le_floofy_sniper_ducko 4 роки тому +2

      @@JamLeGull or is he a Manly Man

    • @sootyj1
      @sootyj1 4 роки тому +1

      His names pronounced David yes I will

    • @rogerbradbury9713
      @rogerbradbury9713 4 роки тому +18

      A tank shell that blows up? I didn't expect that! 😉

    • @russeldavis1787
      @russeldavis1787 4 роки тому +19

      Some say, he can load a 17lber one handed, others that he can kick start Tiger tanks , and leap over M60's with a mighty bound. We just know him as : "The Curator"

  • @burningSHADOW42
    @burningSHADOW42 4 роки тому +4

    Thank you for talking about the dark sides of military technology and history. It's important keep it in mind.
    The sort of motto of the Heeresgeschichtliches Museum in Vienna is fitting here: Wars belong in the museum.

  • @jjc5475
    @jjc5475 4 роки тому +17

    i think it's pretty dope that a museum has such a active social media presence with actual good content! i wish the local museums near me in the Netherlands had this too...
    one of your tanks is lend to one near me i think? (national military museum soesterberg) wish i could go see it...

  • @markedwards158
    @markedwards158 4 роки тому +2

    Great to see Finn. Sorry David what were you saying ? Great episode once again and so glad to hear David Fletcher is doing well. Please keep up the good work until I can get back down there once again.

  • @jammer3618
    @jammer3618 4 роки тому +1

    Well done sir. Well done. As a vietnam era vet it disgusts me when people forget the human cost of these battles.

  • @axestal1
    @axestal1 4 роки тому +9

    If I remember correctly, it was interview of Red Army veteran, he was mechanic in a tank battalion. He said that some times knockout tanks came for repair with dead crewmembers inside the vehicle, so it was their duty to get them out and bury.

    • @Wien1938
      @Wien1938 4 роки тому +1

      German and British tankers talked about using a shovel to scrape out the remains of burnt tank crewmen.

  • @Masada1911
    @Masada1911 4 роки тому +13

    Are you being cheeky with that thumbnail or is it just me? Really glad to hear Fletcher is well! You are quite right to state the truth about these matters, its not a game after all.

  • @Ben-uw8wx
    @Ben-uw8wx 4 роки тому +50

    I didn't even notice that was an inflatable until you said.

  • @stevewareing8525
    @stevewareing8525 4 роки тому +1

    Thank-you for another superbly informative video David. Nice to know that David Fletcher is keeping well as I hope all the staff at the museum are. Finn the dog is a total star with his super canine sense of when to enter camera shot! Your piece about Ron Huggins (Hope the spelling is correct) really touched me. Profound words from a man with a first hand experience of such terrible events carries so much impact. I hope his wish that if Civilians could share those experiences that War would become less likely will one day come true. A pipe dream I know as mankind seems hell bent on self destruction regardless of the cost but the example set by such museums as yours provide an insight not just into the technological advances made through war but that technology can be developed to eliminate the excuse for going to war in the first place. 👌👍

  • @jeffreyplum5259
    @jeffreyplum5259 4 роки тому +1

    The gentlemen of the Tank Museum do great work. You are doing very well without your central collection at hand. And extra thanks for reporting on Mr David Fletcher's condition. I recall he had some health issues some time ago. I regret I may not be addressing him with his full honours. This just a quick note, without proper research. I hope by next year the usual evens may return. I am in America, so your UA-cam videos are my chance to see them. God bless you all.
    BTW If Mr Fletcher is the Museum's Mustache, Mr Wiley must be its Beard. And a regal Beard it is, Yes Sir..

  • @1971stretch
    @1971stretch 4 роки тому +1

    Another great film. Good to have Finn formally introduced as well! 🐶

  • @nightjarflying
    @nightjarflying 4 роки тому +22

    John Kipling [died 27th September 1915] was the only son of Rudyard Kipling - he died at the Battle of Loos which grieved his father terribly, he never got over it. John didn't need to go to war because his eyesight was so poor he was rejected, but Rudyard used his influence to get him an army commission. After WWI Rudyard got involved with the Imperial War Graves Commission - probably as a result of his son's death - perhaps some guilt it is claimed. I speculate that this was also part of the reason Kipling wanted the tools of WWI [the tanks etc.] preserved for later generations.

    • @alecblunden8615
      @alecblunden8615 4 роки тому +2

      Kipling also penned the inscription for unidentified soldiers - "Known unto God".

    • @Simon-jj2pu
      @Simon-jj2pu 3 роки тому

      Check out the play and film My Boy Jack about John (Jack) and Rudyard, heartbreaking

  • @thetourettesgamer8851
    @thetourettesgamer8851 4 роки тому +1

    It amazed me how long the museum has been about for! My grandad can remember going when he left the 1st royal dragoons in 1959!

  • @Tesshier
    @Tesshier 4 роки тому +8

    Thanks for looking a bit at the grimmer side as well. One may admire these machines/equipment but not necessarily idolize or romanticize them.

  • @EdwinK-13
    @EdwinK-13 3 роки тому

    Thank you for what you do. Thank you for saying what need to be said.

  • @chrisjordan4210
    @chrisjordan4210 4 роки тому +3

    As a child, it was always a treat to visit the tank museum en-route to the west country for holidays. You could climb all over them in those days, everything was painted in three colours of gloss paint, dark green, grey or pale yellow depending on which nation they came from and irrespective of the original camo scheme - always remember sweet wrappers stuffed in the vision ports on the tiger's cupola!
    Some of the WW1 vehicles were outside rusting away, almost unbelievable now.
    Now I live in the west country and every trip back to Sussex entails a visit to the museum - not sure my wife is always overjoyed though.

  • @fletcherhaley6015
    @fletcherhaley6015 4 роки тому +1

    Such an amazing video to watch and very well put! This reminds me why I cant wait for our restoration of our DDay sherman Holy Roller next spring!!

  • @apex107lrp
    @apex107lrp 4 роки тому

    Mr. Willey, there is no possible way you could go "overboard" when reminding us all of the purpose of these magnificent machines, and the consequences of their use. Not yet inside a tank, I've been very fortunate to have taken a short ride in a B-17 Flying Fortress. What the young warriors, land or air, had to contend with is inconceivable to me. Carry on the great work.

  • @keithorbell8946
    @keithorbell8946 4 роки тому +4

    Thank you for reminding us of the ultimate result of war. As you say, the films and games are great, but in the real thing people die, and they die in horrible ways. To me that’s what the phrase “Lest we forget” means.

  • @gunner678
    @gunner678 4 роки тому

    I have to say, Iove the clap. Good video. I went to the aftermath of a Challenger one system error in the Balkans in the 90s. A crewman was badly injured whilst cleaning above the breach, when the system reset and went back to battery. It was a horrible sight. I am glad to say, unbelievably I discovered some time later that the chap had recovered, amazing. As a veteran myself, I agree, everyone should just once see the result of war first hand and particularly smell it!

  • @chrisgibson5267
    @chrisgibson5267 4 роки тому +6

    No problem. We completely understand that the Internet connection on The Ramtops can be problematic the closer you get to The Hub. 'Tis common knowledge round these parts.

    • @matthayward7889
      @matthayward7889 4 роки тому +2

      Chris Gibson the clacks are quite reliable these days, I hear

    • @Spookieham
      @Spookieham 4 роки тому

      Kudos for the TP reference

  • @claytonmundy1269
    @claytonmundy1269 4 роки тому +2

    I just want to say hey from the USA. I want to see the tank Museum some day and listen to David F or David Wille and give me a tour keep up the good videos at home I enjoy watching u speak David and to learning things that I didn't know☠💀

  • @pmwalt22
    @pmwalt22 4 роки тому +1

    I really enjoy, and look forward to, these chats that you offer. They're both informative and entertaining. Keep up the great work, it's greatly appreciated.

  • @todd3205
    @todd3205 4 роки тому

    i worked with a fine gentleman for decades who manned to Browning .50 on an M-32 Tank Retriever in the Battle of the Bulge. The results that the presenter talks about were a big part of Uncle Bruce's job. Peace be with them, for theirs was the stuff of nightmares.

  • @dasebeard5730
    @dasebeard5730 4 роки тому

    Please don't apologise about talking about the darker aspects of this. It's such an important part of the museum. I was really fortunate to visit last year and speak to people in your education team about how they approach these subjects with children as part of some research I'm doing. I have to say the Tank Museum team are one of the best I've seen with regards to presenting all the gritty nuances of these difficult subjects head on, and in a sensitive manner.

  • @Trojan0304
    @Trojan0304 4 роки тому

    On my bucket list to visit Tank Museum. Lock down in California

  • @smoothfox007
    @smoothfox007 4 роки тому +1

    Fantastic, informative, interesting and touching as always. Thank you, for all you are doing during these challenging times.

  • @mikebalis9963
    @mikebalis9963 2 роки тому

    Superb job during a very difficult time.

  • @terifarley4770
    @terifarley4770 4 роки тому

    God Bless David Fletcher stay safe

  • @mikethemoomin8604
    @mikethemoomin8604 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you for keeping it real. We should never allow politicians to manipulate us into wars again.

  • @Tinblitz
    @Tinblitz 4 роки тому +2

    There was a man who used to live in my street who once talked to me about his experiences being part of a Sherman crew in Normandy after D-day. He specifically told me about being told by his officer to climb into destroyed tanks with a hacksaw, as the burned bodies inside were in too much of a state to remove from the tank in one piece. I think he said his memoirs were somewhere in the Tank Museum archives, but this was about 8 years ago now, and I fear he's passed away.

  • @TheMunt2000
    @TheMunt2000 4 роки тому +2

    A perfect capture of a collective knowledge

  • @Eiensakura
    @Eiensakura 4 роки тому +46

    Finn is adorable.

    • @teme82
      @teme82 4 роки тому +2

      I wonder where he got his name ....

    • @Splodge542
      @Splodge542 4 роки тому +1

      I had a border collie named Finn. He was named after a former beagle. It's hard to let go of pets. You just have to keep naming new ones after the ones you've lost.

    • @chaz8758
      @chaz8758 4 роки тому +2

      @@teme82 David does explain in an earlier chat, Finns full name and where from

  • @stevebettany8778
    @stevebettany8778 4 роки тому +2

    Thank you for your continued and excellent efforts as Benny Hill said “learning learning all the time”.

  • @munichbier1167
    @munichbier1167 3 роки тому

    What a perfect half hour. Thank you

  • @Pearmain2009
    @Pearmain2009 4 роки тому

    Yet another great chat and some interesting little known facts. These are great. My interest in tanks came from my first visit as a boy to the museum, and it continues now as a man in his fifties and these chats are every bit as interesting if not more so than the usual ones. Keep safe all of you and thanks for the work you are doing.

  • @1mrunforgetable
    @1mrunforgetable 4 роки тому

    Crazy idea...someone drive out to fletchers home plop a cammera on his lawn and see if you can catch him in the wild so to speak..then pick up the cammera after.....i do have a new respect for curators though thank you for all your hard work and for sharing all this awesome history.

  • @andynixon2820
    @andynixon2820 4 роки тому

    I had a great uncle who worked as a tank repair crew out in North Africa. He said when they came in they'd often have to hose out blood and small body parts before repair and returning to service. Grim but the reality of war .

  • @HerrZenki
    @HerrZenki 4 роки тому +17

    I have a sudden urge to buy that 17 pdr inflatable.

  • @Spookieham
    @Spookieham 4 роки тому

    Really enjoying these videos. It shows that content is absolute king not flashy presentation. Best of all the moustache is alive and well!

  • @Blastmaster1972
    @Blastmaster1972 4 роки тому

    Good to hear from Mr. Fletcher! Glad he's OK.

  • @TheMrZ100
    @TheMrZ100 4 роки тому

    I stopped paying attention for a moment as Finn came on screen and instead my mind switched to dogdogdog. He is a very nice addition along with the birds makes this a very relaxing video to listen and watch.

  • @whirving
    @whirving 4 роки тому +14

    In Alaska: FURIOUSLY GOOGLING "Canadian Army Mackinaw Coat".

  • @damo7667
    @damo7667 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for doing such a great job ! really enjoying these videos. Keep up the good work!

  • @enormhi
    @enormhi 4 роки тому

    Thanks for continuing to do these videos even from home!

  • @ryanmatrix11
    @ryanmatrix11 4 роки тому

    Im from Michigan and love your guys videos saved up for awhile to afford a plane ticket to get over there to see your museam and the virus shut me down lol so since i cant support you directly i ordered a few scale models to do while im on lockdown thank you for the videos great operation!!

  • @stevetaylor5933
    @stevetaylor5933 4 роки тому

    As always, thank you for your time and knowledge

  • @AndreiMartovski
    @AndreiMartovski 4 роки тому +1

    We;re glad to know that David and all the tank museum personnel are okay! Also, another question - why did nations decide on from drive sprockets or back drive sprockets?

  • @intertr0ns
    @intertr0ns 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you for another great Q&A Curator. It's often the little stories & personal tales that are most interesting!
    Could you please share a few of the more unique examples of how the Tank Museum acquired some of the tanks in its collection?

  • @davidslarks6508
    @davidslarks6508 4 роки тому

    Fascinating David. I have ordered Dad (Ernest) a 17 pounder shell. He used to load these in the Sherman Firefly. I also enjoyed your Jerry Can chat

  • @paulcarr2632
    @paulcarr2632 4 роки тому

    David I really have enjoyed your at home chats. I could see that when you spoke about the question of real people being in war it was difficult for you, but unfortunately that's the reason these fascinating machines exist. Also I'm loving my tiger 131 mug that arrived 2 days ago. Keep up the good work, and when we can get out a bit more the first thing I'll do is travel from Dublin to visit the museum.

  • @ssnviper
    @ssnviper 4 роки тому

    The first time I visited the Tank Museum was in September 1974 when I was a Junior Leader RAC - spent my pass out term in 1976 in the what was known as the ‘ Spider Huts’ now somewhere under the Museum’s extended footprint🙂 It was definitely rows of ‘rows’ of stuff then!

  • @davepearce6359
    @davepearce6359 4 роки тому +1

    Excellent film once again. Thank you. 😊👍🏻

  • @t0mred
    @t0mred 4 роки тому

    Loving these chat episodes and the history of the museum. Just bought a tank model from the shop. Many thanks!

  • @RandysFiftySevenChevy
    @RandysFiftySevenChevy 4 роки тому

    So David did you ever touch on how you ended up at the Museum?
    What's your interest in tanks ? Did you serve in a tank unit?
    I feel like I'm having a set down with you in your proper English garden. All that's missing is the spot of tea. Thank you for having me and my mission in life is to visit the Museum one day soon..
    -Randy from California

  • @idanceforpennies281
    @idanceforpennies281 4 роки тому

    I saw a video from Bovington where Armoured Officers were being trained in assessing the key features, strengths and weaknesses of different tanks. Very interesting.

  • @Lord.Kiltridge
    @Lord.Kiltridge 4 роки тому +1

    It is my understanding that the bore evacuator is charged with 'fresh' air from in front of the round, that the 'rear' holes usually have valves that allow gasses in and not out, and that the system works best with semi automatic and fully automatic breeches which automatically open as the gasses are at their maximum forward momentum.

  • @loupiscanis9449
    @loupiscanis9449 4 роки тому

    Thank you , Mr Willey

  • @JohnRodriguesPhotographer
    @JohnRodriguesPhotographer 4 роки тому

    People need to know the real physical cost of war. It isn't a game. The mental and emotional scars are invisible. They are there none the less. Always keep that in mind when dealing with combat veterans.

  • @GAR85120514
    @GAR85120514 4 роки тому

    Thanks for keeping these videos coming. Much appreciated

  • @alexwenzel6932
    @alexwenzel6932 4 роки тому +2

    Love all your videos and what you do for the tanking community. Can you do an updated Panther chat when we all get back to normal. The Panther has become one of my favorite ww2 tasks and would love to know more from your all point of view on this machine. Thank you Cheers!

  • @Fjoliver
    @Fjoliver 4 роки тому +4

    great vid as always

  • @Spookieham
    @Spookieham 4 роки тому

    From what I recall reading, the Germans and British in North Africa often communicated in the clear over radio giving names of captured soldiers to each other. There were allegedly occasions in the deep desert where both sides passed right next to each other rather than fight it out and die in a pointless little battle with no hope of medical care or rescue.

  • @mongolike513
    @mongolike513 4 роки тому +1

    There are many photos of bodies being removed from armoured vehicles burnt, broken and blown. You are correct in identifying the disconnect between the tank aficionados and the reality of reality of torn, shredded results when a crew gets plastered. Which begs the question of what were the tank crews looking out for? Apart from concentrating on their individual tasks what were the general threats beyond the vehicle that the crew were ordered to keep an eye out for? How were units of tanks covering themselves? I ask this because so much of the reminisces of tankers in ww2active operations basically seem to accept hits as just bad luck that was unavoidable, the enemy not noticed almost like no one was really keeping a look out, just hoping that someone else would be hit by the rpg or 88 or whatever. Those kids, Russian and American, British and commonwealth took terrible punishment from very efficient German anti tank artillery with materiel which never got in front of the curve of the armour, Armourment and maybe tactics which their opponents possessed. It was like sending these children into a big pool and 80% knew they couldn’t swim and their ‘leaders’ also knew this. Bloody hell, that is bravery being expected to get within 500m of the enemy with any hope of knocking him out when he can kill you at 1200m. It was also murder. So in the interest of reality maybe we should get to see what the engineering companies saw when they had to clean up and hose out battle damaged tanks and armoured vehicles. Won’t be pretty but we should stop pretending that there were no downsides. Respect and best wishes and thank you for all the work you chaps do.

  • @rvail136
    @rvail136 4 роки тому

    I love the coat. I've been looking for one for nigh on 20 years!

  • @josephravu5039
    @josephravu5039 4 роки тому

    "waffling on" the man says. These new videos are brilliant.

  • @buckshot6481
    @buckshot6481 4 роки тому +1

    Don't ever forget the reality of what those awesome vehicles were there for. My Uncle George McAdams was there.

  • @peckelhaze6934
    @peckelhaze6934 4 роки тому

    Very interesting. Made a purchase of an 88mm shell and two books.

  • @richardklug822
    @richardklug822 4 роки тому

    Your comments about extraction of casualties from armored warfare echoed the words of Randall Jarrell's poem "Death of the Ball Turret Gunner":
    "I awoke to black flak and the nightmare fighters. When I died they washed me out of the turret with a hose."
    Chilling thoughts. RIP to all that perished.

  • @carlkinsey8736
    @carlkinsey8736 4 роки тому

    Your videos are brill, many thanks

  • @Delta2414
    @Delta2414 4 роки тому +48

    I didn't even know that the Germans and the British had such an arrangement. Interesting.

    • @DannySB991
      @DannySB991 4 роки тому +3

      Quite the stark difference from war today isn't it?

    • @Cloudman572
      @Cloudman572 4 роки тому +17

      In most case (non SS etc) the soldier on both sides are just ordinary blokes trying to get on with life. I have read reliable accounts of American civil war look out posts that were used by one side in the day and the other side at night for days and they always ensured the fire was fuelled up for the other side before leaving because you get back what you give.

    • @andreww2098
      @andreww2098 4 роки тому +7

      they had Gentlemans agreements, such as stopping for afternoon tea and swapping/ransoming prisoners, read Pegasus Bridge by Stephen Ambrose, the first chapter mentions this!

    • @samuelvimes5770
      @samuelvimes5770 4 роки тому +17

      "War: a massacre of people who don't know each other for the profit of people who know each other but don't massacre each other" Paul Valery

    • @Tinderchaff
      @Tinderchaff 4 роки тому +7

      If you follow this link here www.forces-war-records.co.uk/blog/2018/05/11/75th-anniversary-victory-of-the-allies-in-the-north-african-campaign-as-the-afrika-korps-and-italian-troops-surrender and scroll to the bottom you'll see a German POW lighting a cigarette of a wounded British soldier. The photo, for me, gives an insight into the people who fought in North Africa and how they behaved once the fighting was over.

  • @onetrueevan6992
    @onetrueevan6992 4 роки тому

    Excellent video. I firmly believe that we, as fans of military history and military equipment, should always keep the horrors of war in mind.
    This is what David does here.
    Also as a Greek, I am curious to know what is written inside that Greek helmet.
    I don't think David mentioned it in this video. In another one maybe?

  • @stephen9869
    @stephen9869 4 роки тому +5

    26:49 made me laugh. I have had a really bad day, so thank you Sir.

  • @bfmcarparts
    @bfmcarparts 4 роки тому

    Hello David, and Finn!
    I'm glad to stop by and I've enjoyed your chat.
    At first I thought "So that's what tank curators keep in the garden shed to control the gophers!"- Not.
    Your story about Ron's experience with tank crew mortality reminds me again of my Grandfather, the WW1 big gun man. He became a Norfolk constable, and during WW2 he would get up have a crumpet and a cuppa and tell his wife he was going "for a walk".
    His "walk" was to go to his patrol section of the Wash, passing through the barb wire and look for the airmen that washed ashore over the night.
    What an awful way to start your day.
    ps- Does Finn supply the canine landmines?

  • @mikemcginley6309
    @mikemcginley6309 4 роки тому

    Its well to remember that tanks are made to smash things and hurt people. But they are interesting and a lot of fun. If you were never a tanker you'll never know what you missed.

  • @ddraig1957
    @ddraig1957 4 роки тому

    By Tank into Normandy by Stuart Hills,describes how his tank unit's padre recovered and buried bodies from knocked out tanks. Death Traps by Belton Cooper,a maintenance officer in the US Third Armoured Division ,is a gripping account of tanks in action but also of the often difficult and unpleasant task of recovering and repairing tanks after battle.
    On a lighter note,nice to see Finn again.

  • @shoppy00
    @shoppy00 4 роки тому +4

    "The cries of men trapped inside theyr burning tanks will forever haunt the minds of those who heard them" - heard it on the Discovery Channel some 20 years ago on a WWII documentary(must have been edited out)...

  • @cdmoraleda
    @cdmoraleda 4 роки тому

    Thanks a lot for these videos

  • @stephenvince9994
    @stephenvince9994 4 роки тому

    Excellent clip David, you have a great screen presence, Im sure you could talk for hours and it would still be interesting. I first had a look around the Tank Museum in about 1962 / 63 when My family (I was about 7 or 8) was shown round by my uncle who was a very senior rank in the Army. It was great as I could have a close look at the exhibits as it was after hours in the museum! Interesting to hear the comments on the injured / dead of tank crews. Ive had the job of putting deceased in body bags, some of whom died by burning and it is a task which is very difficult to clear from your mind. Perhaps we never do. I had another Uncle who was a tank commander during the war, who had lost two fingers of his right hand (not the important ones-he could still invite you to leave!) - - I remember his story was his tank had been hit (normandy I think) and his hand had got involved in the still racing engine of the tank somehow and the fingers had been removed. I remember him relating that he was in a ditch some fifty yards away before he noticed! Keep well David, and many thanks for these clips, great to listen to whilst marooned in our houses!

  • @esnipe2
    @esnipe2 4 роки тому

    Loving the content you guys keep putting out