Analyzing the 3.3 Kerfuffle - One Page Rules 3.3 Update Analysis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 49

  • @viasolus
    @viasolus 6 місяців тому +8

    A lot of appreciation here.
    Love for OPR and their drive to keep this incredible game balanced. Love for the new wave of content creators like yourself who are passionate enough to provide frank analysis on where that balance needs improvement. And love for a community that cares enough about this game to raise passions when we're discussing numbers values on our tiny painted figurines.
    So long as we all remain respectful and kind, this game will only get better and better.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +1

      I'll say it again and again. I hope my content inspires others to start producing OPR content. I was so happy to hear some people reach out to me to say they are starting UA-cam channels. I'll be spreading the word for their channels once they come online.

  • @TheSpazztech
    @TheSpazztech 6 місяців тому +11

    You are right about the communication, its time to hire some people to do the community interface and social media. These youtube updates tend to wander and there is a lot of time wasted unnecessarily.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +2

      Exactly! Communication may not be his strong suit. Find a good public relations person to handle it. That's what all major companies do.

    • @legatus_newt
      @legatus_newt 6 місяців тому

      How do you suppose they hire community managers. Based on their patreon they barely make enough to pay one person a full time salary.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      @@legatus_newt I understand where you are coming from. But this is what businesses have to do...make tough decisions. Perhaps that means cutting back on ventures that arent as profitable.

    • @legatus_newt
      @legatus_newt 6 місяців тому

      @@NexusWargaming This is not a tough decision to be made it's unrealistic. I very highly doubt you can consider them profitable at all. We don't have insight into their finances but I doubt based on my experience with early stage businesses is that OnePageAnon is unlikely to be paying himself a significant salary compared to how much is spent on contracting the artists and all the expenses involved in running the business. Even if every patreon supporter sticks around got a year at the $10 tier you're taking about less than $200,000 in revenue to run this whole business.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      @@legatus_newt one way OPR can succeed is by embracing help from the community. It’s got to be less about “him” and more about “us”.
      I can understand your perspective, but we all want OPR to succeed. Hopefully this is a learning experience along the way 🙂

  • @davidhalstead402
    @davidhalstead402 6 місяців тому +3

    The new Assault Charge not being mentioned on the page with Charge rules in the rulebook does seem to be a sign it might have been a bit rushed. It does seem like it would benefit best from either being it's own Assault Action which would then allow for it's own page of clarified rules or make it an ability that you add to hybrid units. At the moment it's really hidden away in the rules.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      Exactly! My whole point is: Appreciate the thought, but the "rules" in One Page "Rules" are suffering.

  • @tomasv8732
    @tomasv8732 6 місяців тому +2

    Assault rule solved: allow pistols in melee, was done in 40k what, 20 years ago?

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      I would like them to bring in full use of shooting and melee. If you pay full points for weapons, you should get full use out of them. But that just my opinion

  • @paszergy7784
    @paszergy7784 6 місяців тому

    Hello thanks for the analysis. Assault action seems a great idea but never applied in our last game. We found that, due to half limitation mouvement, this rule is a "payback" action for non killed unit with guns after being charge. The moral rule is great, giving last hope to do something for unit that were hopeless after being decimated. However half movement make it nealy useless. Except again for a last payback shot of the last remaining brother with a missile launcher.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      Thanks for the feedback! I’ll be doing some games soon. Hopefully we get official rules for some of the issues with 3.3

  • @cadiastands8
    @cadiastands8 6 місяців тому +8

    The “complaining” comment could possibly be chalked up to English not being his first language. He may not know how to soften the wording, or even understand the perception his delivery could cause.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +7

      I can definitely understand that, but I would really encourage someone reviewing his script. OPR is getting larger and more people will be on these calls.

    • @DannyEastes
      @DannyEastes 6 місяців тому +9

      I watched the clip and its honestly such a honest and innocent comment. Zero malice. people *were* complaining about alien hives being too powerful, he was right to listen and comment on it. It wasnt inappropriate, it was a genuine communication, and is not this big of a deal.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +2

      I appreciate the feedback! My biggest concern is that for OPR to become a global company, it must act like a global company. I believe these calls will become more popular and the OPR should work on their communication strategy. I really am trying to encourage OPR to fix these issues before they cause further problems.

    • @jcx117
      @jcx117 6 місяців тому +1

      This was my first thought as well. I work for a company with folks from all over the world . Probably half of which English is their second or third language. So, I have had to learn to give folks grace and try to listen to what they are trying to say versus the words they are using.

  • @matthewhorton5860
    @matthewhorton5860 6 місяців тому +1

    Regarding your "Complaints about Alien Hives" comment, the loudest complaints I heard from the community were using your videos as a reference, and honestly using them poorly. I agree though that Assult needed more tweaking to find a better solution.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +1

      Strange, I heard from others about Alien Hives being a problem last year. I had played against some soft lists and didn’t think they were an issue. Once I tested them though, I had to agree with those who were concerned with the army.
      Since then people have reached out to me saying their local games were not fun due to AH players just crushing them.

  • @ironknight132
    @ironknight132 6 місяців тому +3

    We played yesterday and just ignored the changes... will continue too likely. The whole hybrid issue could be solved with a new ability you can just add to pistols, stating that they are also melee weapons. Done.
    Honestly though, I like OPR, but Warsurge and Xenos Rampant are fine games to in the same niche.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +3

      I am open to different solutions. I dont have to answer, but OPR cannot continue to have these sorts of updates. There are new competitors popping up every day!

    • @doctorw0rm
      @doctorw0rm 6 місяців тому

      @@NexusWargaming What competitors did you have in mind? Genuinely interested xD

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +1

      @@doctorw0rm I've been checking out Xenos Rampant for sci-fi and the revamped Warhammer Armies Project for fantasy!

  • @LakeVermilionDreams
    @LakeVermilionDreams 2 місяці тому

    I find it odd you ask about if an opponent removes casualties to bring them out of charge range, then the very next bullet point complain about rules bloat to address corner cases.
    I'm only a Firefight player right now, so I don't know about the full rules. So from that outsider perspective, the statements you made seem contrary to each other.
    Maybe you could clarify for me, let me know if I'm missing something?

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  2 місяці тому +1

      Many of the issues are already addressed with the 3.3.1 changes. I would note that the owner basically agreed with my assessment when he changed it.
      Give the full game a try. Firefight is very different from what I mainly focus on. 🙂

    • @LakeVermilionDreams
      @LakeVermilionDreams 2 місяці тому

      @@NexusWargaming working on it! I've got an army built but I'm waiting on my friends to build theirs!

  • @SetaDragon
    @SetaDragon 6 місяців тому +6

    Don't get me wrong I love opr and I am actively pushing it in my community, but I was concerned in the live stream where he said he was the only one working on rules. With how large the community is growing and the fact he is hiring people there should at least be one other person going over them. Also the fact he does not get a lot of time to play his game is concerning, because he is busy with all the other business stuff.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +6

      Thank youi! That is my exact point. He cannot do everything himself. For OPR to grow to the company we want, he's got to delegate more and focus on his strongsuits.

  • @alekseylibernikel7606
    @alekseylibernikel7606 6 місяців тому

    Undead rule was masive because the moral was brutal. Now moral was nerfed and undead was buffed because of this.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      Thanks! I understand where you are coming from, but do feel this should have been on the call. It's a big change to the game. I do have to disagree that morale was nerfed, but will be play testing to see if that plays out.

  • @MrBanditoRazor
    @MrBanditoRazor 6 місяців тому

    To not complain, I'm going to say what I DO agree with:
    I really wish morale would work like old hammer fantasy.
    If your shaken/routed/morale broken (lol), you roll x dice and have to head directly against the enemy. Then you /must/ spend the next turn recovering.
    If you run off the board, you're wiped.
    Otherwise, stats remain the same.
    Short, simple, and easy..
    Which is why we play it that way. It's OPR, imho -nothing- should ever allow a way for units to just be "removed" without saves.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +3

      Thank you for your thoughts! I hope people understand that I really want the best for OPR. I have been overwhelming positive about what they've done.

  • @dbag16
    @dbag16 2 місяці тому

    I don't want to complain about someone complaining about another person's complaint. But your video has no context nor what he actually said what he was talking about and what people are arguing as the reason he shouldn't be complaining. Why do you think we're all informed from somewhere else? This same thing happened in your video with the fantasy tier list. If you're going to provide news and information for the community of OPR, it might benefit The channel practicing as though you're the only source of information for your fans, even if some of some of them request additional information.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  2 місяці тому

      Thanks for the feedback! I generally take the stance that I will provide my opinions as best I can and assume the viewer will make their own decision.
      That said I do provide context in many of my videos that I’m focusing on the competitive side of the game.
      I also try to get people on with different thoughts and even people who disagree with me.

    • @dbag16
      @dbag16 2 місяці тому

      Sorry for my joking tone, I have really enjoyed the videos and learn from them. I think I am probably not subscribed or lack the resources most viewers might have because I find that certain things aren't announced first and it's more of a meta view like you have been saying. I look forward to seeing you grow as OPR gets more popular! I love it compared to Warhammer and hope more people are introduced to it!​@@NexusWargaming

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  2 місяці тому

      @@dbag16 glad you enjoy them! I just want to do my small part to help OPR grow 🙂

  • @thel1chking
    @thel1chking 6 місяців тому +5

    He needs to - and hopefully will - slow down with these updates. What I hate most is releasing core rules every few months. Absolutely retarded. Also the OpR discord is very cultish - they’re going towards a GW crown where any critique one gives is met with “oh that’s how he made it so whatever “ or “if you don’t like it don’t play or use the rule”. Such children. I’m a Competetive player who plays Raw -
    These changes will not effect me at all but obviously some did not have to transpire. I agree with a lot of what you mentioned but Gaetano needs to relax with these changes because the only thing that’s going for this system are the rules and if he messes them up in the future through bloat and bad writing - people will not stick around for the “lore “ or models.

    • @toastle8005
      @toastle8005 6 місяців тому

      Maybe the models, because their versions of things like Robot Legions and Jackals have a genuinely cool style, but definitely, yeah

    • @ThePolyfamous
      @ThePolyfamous 6 місяців тому +2

      You can tell he is spending too much time tinkering when he talks about potential rules updates. There have been some bad ideas he's put out about the v4 he wants to make next year

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +2

      Couldn't agree more! The rules are what people want. Everyday a new model company pops up. OPR must focus on its strongsuit...the rules!

    • @thel1chking
      @thel1chking 6 місяців тому

      @@NexusWargaming if you guys noticed - now the stupid advertisement pops up whenever I go to my Army Forge. It’s becoming a real company …

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      Lol

  • @alocascio5825
    @alocascio5825 6 місяців тому +1

    Assault rule should go. Just lower the points for the unit. This is the type of stuff that bogged down GW.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому +1

      Thank you! That's how I've felt for a long time. So good to hear others feel the same :)

    • @heathsanders7579
      @heathsanders7579 6 місяців тому +2

      I don’t feel the same at all. I play heavy hybrid armies and opr really makes me not enjoy playing those. You yourself nexus have had to completely we write army books over the “tax” of units having pistols or mixed weapons. So I think while the assault rule isn’t perfect yet it is needed.

    • @NexusWargaming
      @NexusWargaming  6 місяців тому

      @@heathsanders7579 I don't mind the Assault rule's premise, but the current implementation has been problematic. For now, I don't have the solution to the problem other than giving hybrid units a "non-hybrid" version with things like Limited on weapons. I'm open to suggestions!

    • @LakeVermilionDreams
      @LakeVermilionDreams 2 місяці тому

      Lol so how long until OPR bloats so much a new game comes out with all the super simple rules fitting on one page to usurp the bloated king?