Manyi calls SCA ruling on Zuma’s medical parole absurd
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2024
- The Jacob Zuma Foundation spokesperson Mzanele Manyi says the Supreme Court of Appeal ruling that former president Jacob Zuma's release on medical parole was unlawful is absurd.
Tune into Newzroom Afrika DSTV channel 405 for more.
courts are used to fight political battles
True Nzama. It's so clear and the victims are black people.
@@Fezile580 These black judges are painted?
"who's law is it anyway" - Lindiwe Sisulu
Ramaphosa and his brown envelope Judiciary have been given instructions by their handlers to deal with Zuma by all means necessary
Very true, the gods of this world, the gods of South Africa, they themselves will face a day of judgement by a true judge our God.
Prove brother?
Manyi is very educated.its refreshing to see such brains in this country.very rare quality
Well educated?, while being very vague and not giving proper facts, just a story that he believes is happening, not talking at all about the medical Parole which is the main reason he's going back to jail😂😂😂he talks about detail of the court decision but doesn't focus on the main fact, he brings up the legislation but that legislation doesn't stand if his medical Parole is unlawful, he can't even distribute the medical Parole unlawfulness just gives a story😂😂😂well educated hey, all these state capture dogs
You are a joke, clearly he is more educated than you. That's why you feel like he is more educated, you are easily excitable by his soup of words and ranting. Udom sani
Whoever files appeal must foot the bill personally.
The department of correctional services has appealed😳😳😳
I used to have a God like respect for Appeals and Constitutional court judges. But the incarceration of Jacob Zuma without a trial made me realise there's nothing special about them. They are just individuals like you and me, but with robes and opinions backed by state power. I mean Zuma has already served his 15 months in prison, but they want to add more months to his already served sentence. After sending Zuma to prison again although he has completed his 15 months under correctional services, do they expect him to apply for parole again? The judgement does not make sense, it breaches so many laws of natural justice but our legal scholars will ignore the mess just because they hate everything about Jacob Zuma.
Since when do you need to go to trial for a direct contravention of a court order and stupid with half a brain knows this
He was in jail for like 2 months then left cause he was under medical Parole which was fake, he's barely served time, also you need to see zuma has no respect for the courts, this all began when he refused to listen to the courts, so stop twisting yourselves into pretzels, he didn't serve, it was a holiday he was on, not in prison where he should be
@@rastaweed1268 Familiarise yourself with Section 12 of the South African Constitution before commenting nonsense: Freedom and security of the person
12. (1) Everyone has the right to freedom and security of the person, which includes the
right-
(b) not to be detained without trial;
@@thokohildamthombeni8544 familiarize yourself with the criminal procedure act and the merit of the case whereby there was a direct contravention of a court order which clearly means there cannot be a trial because the contravention of the order is sufficient enough to prove a case of disregard for the law of the country. So don't run to the constitution. The constitutional law governing the fairness is enshrined in the fact that the court order was contravened so the fairness of the constitution was adhered to.
Sometimes u need to learn that bantu education doenst qualify you to run your mouth
@@rastaweed1268 well said brother plus he disrespected the highest court in the land 😢
These courts are a big political joke, how do you allow a president (politician) to ignore Judicial Services Commission (experts and society) recommendations on who to appoint as a judge and allow a parole board to have super powers when we don't even see what their process as the public? Talk about beneficial double standards.
Manyi talking nonsense as usual.
Don't expose yourself, how bankrupt you are
Jimmy comes to Jozi. Another 5 years of Ramaphosa loading.....
Jimmy Manyi is talking politricing. He's talking correctional and punishment. For Waluzs he promotes punishment but for his prisoner Zuma he is singing correctional rhetoric. Jimmy wants us to treat Zuma and Waluzs differently yet they are both recognized equally before Constitutional laws.
Kingdoms do rise and fall. This is the wind of change never ever think you will be in control for iternity Mr J Z, as polotician you shoud have know that better.
We are never guilty
That is how we were brought up. Never admit to your guilt, always live in denial and enjoy anarchy
Inmate my butt he lived in a R245 million rand Mansion and partied like a rock star .....
I don't no why is news africa giving this man a platform to speak on legal matters. He has no qualifications speak about law. He is misleading the public with his comments. Manyi always portray Zuma as the victim of conspiracy. Zuma took an oath then walk out of commission of State capture commission. Zuma thinks he above law. He must face the music and go back prison and serve his 2 months.
This decision is draconian. It smells of intentions 😌. This case cannot go back to the Constitutional Court, that is the Apex Court, hence this matter was "deliberately" lodged in the CC, when there are lower Courts. Nxamalala was in actual fact denied his Constitutional Rights by doing so.
Denied by who?
@@luthandonomzaza1607 Did he go on trial? That's the starting point...
testify or go back to jail🤗
too late... straight to jail
Jimmy sing for your supper. blah blah blah. you sooo clever not.
😂😂😂😂
You talk about janus wals, for not showing remorse but get parole. Now did zuma say sorry for f..... Up this country, and get medical parole for not even be sick. Wtf
People who are not legally trained want to debate LAW while politicizing it.
Legality doesn't mean just
This is not a court room. It is social media where everyone can say whatever they want about anything. If you only want to hear from legally trained people, then go the the courtroom, law symposium, or have lunch or dinner with lawyers and judges.
No mistakes were made only corrupt decisions.
Yet he managed a trip to the casino
This man is talking about a subject that he knows nothing.He is not a legal er
Zuma did not refuse to testify before the commission but before Zondo as he want him to recuse himself because of the relationship which Zondo denied but later admitted during interview and said he knew him for more than 20 years
President Zuma should run to the Concourt, albeit its bias against him to raise the defence of atrefois convict(he served his parole), and therefore shouldn't suffer jeopardy.
Well said Manyi, I wish the Judges are listening. They are merely wasting their time on Zuma. If correctional officials erred what does that has to do with Zuma? Again Zuma has complied with the rules and regulations as set up by parole board or parole regulations
Zuma has himself to blame, acted like he was sick but suddenly could dance with his people and went to court to prosecute those telling the truth then said he is fit to serve high positions in the ANC, hey put more focus on his medical Parole and we found it was unlawful, ubaba needs to go to jail
This guy has a passion for lying.
If the court decision is absurd why are you not appealing the judgement? This judgement favours Zuma
JZ did his time that's is it the haters of Zuma can talk ,aluta kontinua bomzansi.away captured courts
Does Manyi have any legal qualifications?
Does the answer to ur question diminish his opinion and understanding thereof?
Zuma should have acted like an unwell paroly, but he was showing off his hipster dancing move straight from his hips....stay in Nkandla with the wives. Enjoy retirement in peace.
Hai Jimmy boy, do u still own that media house from the guptas
Focus on the ball.
@@hallaback2010 yes his head is very distracting like a big ball
Joo manyi leshilo le
@@rastaweed1268 👍🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Rasta you high
I'm fed up by SCA and Constitutional Courts
Why because they are upholding the law. Zuma should not be treated special. We all equal before law.
@@angelodoubel9653 principles of Roman Dutch law and common law are applied unfairly against some people
@@Fezile580 please tell why did Zuma walked out of the State capture commission after taking an oath?
Really pls pls stop with this apartheid in everything which dont go your way ,get it in your head the law is for everyone
This law ...is Roman Dutch Law.....?
You need to have millions of Rands to access justice in this country...it is not for everyone.....
I was almost 100% expecting this ruling! There is no way to rich a different ruling! It was clearly UNLAWFUL! The parole was obtained from an UNLAWFUL decision and intentional, not a mistake! On top of that, they came all publically saying ZUMA completely his jail term!
stupid judges, failing to interpret such simple law
Are you saying Jacob Zuma unlawfully and intentionally gave himself a medical parole? And hence deserve to be punished by increased time in his sentencing? Are you aware that Jacob Zuma did not even initiate the application for his medical parole? It was done by his state doctors because they were concerned about his medical condition.
@@thokohildamthombeni8544 It was an orchestrated process between everybody, from Zuma to Frazer, so please as much wrong with him as with me. He owes us roughly 45 days. Nothing wrong with SCA judgement and Correctional service going get hiding in ConCourt as well. Manyi just like Mpofu. Only people in this country who knows the law.
@@mauritzvandenheever2780Do you have evidence that Zuma and his 'deceitful' doctors were part of the orchestration? Or are you just speculating? Obviously, the judges also believe your theory of orchestration, they have thrown the rules of evidence in the dustbin just because they are biased against Zuma. The judiciary is losing credibility amongst the masses. It is only the elites like you who still strongly believe in this compromised judiciary. The day we have a revolution, the judiciary will be the first to be lynched.
Even your English demonstrates that you may not understand things deeper.we use reach not rich
Wierd that the man is bemoaning Zumas PAROLE not being recognized but Hanis wife is screaming that it shouldnt exist...I mean they are both murderers only Zuma s victim wasnt as well known as Hani
so you will never fix your sound???????
Please Manyi, in this country we've got President after the President has vacated office he or becomes Former president therefore Former President Zuma is our Former president he is no longer President but he is enjoying the benefits as registered Former president please, we've got students in this country that needs clear diminution of events please man, don't confuse this country about repeating our Former president as President. We've got one President please manyi. Or shut up
Talking rubbish as usual
zuma must go and do his TIME! Manyi talks a lot but zuma is CRIMINAL !
Unbelievable how many on this thread are dumb enough to buy the jailed without trial story. And why does Manyi think he knows the law better than the SCA. Zuma committed a crime. He chose not to appear at his trial. He escaped prison on medical parole when he was not sick but calling favours off his old friend Arthur Fraser. He lived 13 months in his palace on medical parole most South Africans couldn't even dream of, even visiting a casino. And now the courts have said the commissioner could even take that as time served, butt is not up to the court to decide. The purpose of justice is twofold. Punishment for the purpose of deterrent, and rehabilitation. Zuma has not been punished. He's lived a life of luxury most SAns couldn't imagine. This is not Cyril. Not a bought judiciary. This is justice.
When and where was Jacob Zuma's trial held?.
i went. to. jail. for stealing the pack. of ox tail. in the supermarket they. moer me. like. hell. and i. was a servant of master so called. Nongoloza if he goes to the toilet. i. must wipe him after the job. well done but none said i must get parole