New First of October Album Is Here! (Tierlist Update 2024)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 19

  • @pinkraven4402
    @pinkraven4402 3 дні тому +2

    Dude what? Infinite Lives was by far my favourite song of this album, it's pure Slowdive hazy shoegaze, beautiful textures and sentiment

    • @idlehi
      @idlehi  3 дні тому

      Im glad you enjoyed it, It’s not bad by any means but it didn’t excite me personally

  • @LovroSabljak
    @LovroSabljak 9 днів тому +6

    Wow you changed lol I just discovered your first foo video now and went to the channel wondering if you made another one for this year, and this was uploaded literally 6 minutes ago :)

    • @idlehi
      @idlehi  9 днів тому +1

      Thanks for watching! Yeah i buzzed my hair last month, growing it back slowly lol

  • @Lucy-jc5wg
    @Lucy-jc5wg 6 днів тому +1

    Apparently cats used to piss monks off a lot by peeing in their manuscripts. The monks left notes in the marginalia indicating how they felt about that. I heard that there were some cats that wouldn’t stop meowing during prayer hours so they were taken to court. I’m not sure who represented them or won the case. They may have meowed in their defense and been executed. Those medieval murderous peeing kittens. I might be making part of this up.

  • @LychkovIA
    @LychkovIA 10 годин тому +1

    Here after watching your previous tierlist video! Love your analysis, and I'm just going to add some of my boring thoughts
    I always liked Ravioli, but I always felt weird about Rob's vocal. But now that you said it out loud, yeeeah, it seems it was autotuned.
    Unpopular opinion here, but I really don't like "First of October" (the song). The lyrics and the melody both seem very corny. I'm not a fan of this "meta" kind of lyrics. When you record an album in a day, and the song lyrics are about how you're recording an album in a day... it makes me cringe a bit, I don't know.
    "Don't Go" - still my huge favourite... Yeah, I love Rob's numbers from the previous album too (not too much into the "country" stuff though), and I have to say I greatly enjoyed "Round 6".
    I never quite connected FoO with Song Generator. I enjoy Song Generator a lot. But it's quite funny that I actually skipped the murderous kittens video! I just wasn't feeling it, so I stopped watching. It wasn't a conscious thing really, but now that you've said it... yeah, I guess it's just because it was something pretending to be funny while not really being funny.
    ........I always wondered why Andrew sounded like... so old on "Pink Fluffy Unicorns"

    • @idlehi
      @idlehi  9 годин тому +1

      Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Now that you mention it I don’t actually know if its Andrew singing on pink fluffy unicorns, maybe he pitch shifted his voice but it could be someone else singing too?

    • @LychkovIA
      @LychkovIA 8 годин тому

      @@idlehi I doubt he'd have another singer uncredited, so my guess is pitch shifting! Sounds cool though, like a 90s whimsical movie narrator (very random comparison)
      One thing I forgot to mention in response to your tier list is that I actually really like "Possible Band Names". IMO usually speaking over music is sorta cheating, but it works in that track. Plus that funny small chord in the end!
      tbh I'm currently sorta obsessed with the FoO project, and I'm in the process of binge-watching the videos, haha

  • @lolotronop
    @lolotronop 8 днів тому +2

    No way! I used to have the same phone! But the player buttons on the side fell off one some point, lol. It was so good

    • @idlehi
      @idlehi  8 днів тому

      MINE FELL OFF TOO I still have my original phone from back in the day but I abused it so hard it barely works now, a few months ago i decided to find and buy one in better condition and try to use it again as my main phone, I surprisingly don't miss my smartphone at all

  • @RobTFilms
    @RobTFilms 2 дні тому +1

    I see what you mean about the humour that just ISN'T FUNNY and I like Rob and Andrew? It's so ODD man!

  • @halfbee7886
    @halfbee7886 6 днів тому

    Andrew did the drumming for Infinite Knives, not Rob.

    • @idlehi
      @idlehi  5 днів тому

      Yeah my bad

  • @micito_lobotomia
    @micito_lobotomia 9 днів тому +2

    The song generator series may be wearing them out on the whole quick songmaking concept, cuz this year really sounds the least inspired one to me. I'm scared it's starting to feel like a chore rather than a fun project to them. I love FOO nonetheless and this year brought some genuine gems, those songs you mentioned do rule indeed.

    • @idlehi
      @idlehi  8 днів тому +2

      I wouldn't go as far as to call it a chore I still got the vibe that they enjoy it a lot from the video, but I do think the song generator takes something away from FOO

    • @micito_lobotomia
      @micito_lobotomia 2 дні тому

      @ nevermind everything i said. Less than a week later and every the single song on this record managed to grow on me. Definitely one of the greats, if not my favorite one so far. lol.

  • @welsmusicofficial
    @welsmusicofficial 9 днів тому +3

    8:27 I want to see you make 10 original songs, in 12h!

    • @idlehi
      @idlehi  8 днів тому +2

      I've tried many times and it's not easy, but their previous albums set the bar very high that's why I complain a bit in the video