Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
How should colleges respond to the pro-Palestine campus protests?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 сер 2024
- Many colleges and universities have called in police to crack down on the pro-Palestine encampments that have popped up on dozens of campuses across the U.S. in recent weeks. But the ACLU of Massachusetts argues that response "escalates tensions" and "creates unacceptable safety risks." The organization's executive director, Carol Rose, joined Saraya Wintersmith to explain, along with Tufts Professor Amahl Bishara, Robert Pape, a University of Chicago political science professor and the director of the Chicago Project on Security and Threats.
0:00 Intro
1:14 ACLU opposes police response
2:21 MIT begins issuing suspensions
3:05 Split in faculty/students amid university handling
5:44 Do protests put student safety at risk?
7:47 Bridging gap between students and admin
8:41 Students risking suspensions and arrests
10:09 Preserving learning environment amid protests
14:22 How to balance safety and free speech?
GBH News is a premier source for in-depth local news and original story telling based in Boston, Massachusetts.
Subscribe to the GBH UA-cam channel: ua-cam.com/users/gbhnews?sub...
Follow GBH News on Instagram: / gbhnews
Like GBH News on Facebook: / gbhnews
Follow GBH News on X: / gbhnews
We can’t do it without you. Support our award-winning community journalism by donating today: bit.ly/SupportGBHNews
Didn’t Brown or some university in Rhode Island agree to divest? It’s both a tragedy and a blessing that we see the flaws of universities and who controls their every move - donors. They are immobile and inept at standing by their own values.
They should lose all funding
No. They agree to discuss. And no, they should not give in.
Any student who prevents another student from attending classes or using services at the campus should be immediately expelled no matter what nonsense they were protesting about
They were camping out NOT blocking entrances you are in the wrong UA-cam section that is NOT what happened in MA. If your classes are NOT outdoors you could enter the building. Again facts are important. And in most cases, it's the university that blocked access.
@waynecmontgomery Yes they were. In some cases actually taking people hostage and not letting them leave
@@reubenhandel210 I will NOT respond to that ignorance. That is the FOX echo chamber.
@waynecmontgomery No. That was what the completely innocent janitors who were held hoatage said.
How should colleges protect the rights of Jewish students to attend ckass and not be impeded, hatassed, intimidated, or threatened by protesters many which are not students?
They trash up everywhere they go.And demand what others have to do .
How should colleges and universities balance free speech and student safety?
Just like they did before all this “woke” bullshit started. You can say whatever you want, if it offends somebody, who cares, get over it and grow up.
Free speech doesn't infringe on safety, period. If a mob presents a threat to other students, it is NOT free speech.
They could try speaking reasonably with students about what they hope to achieve while respecting their rights and not crapping on their public image by just calling the cops on them like an angry elderly neighbor.
What about the rights of student's these protest are not peaceful if they violate the roghts of real students trying to make life better police should have presences there to insure safety
The Saying "Free Speech Ends when others noses begin" ?
Really? Jewish students are discriminated against. THAT violates Federal law.
America desprately needs to remove the big money campaign donations and big money alltogether from government operations. No more money for comgresspeople or potus.
I have listened to this 3 times and all 3 times I got the same thing free speech is constitutionally protected the right to peacefully protest is protected blocking someone's movement are stopping them from using an area is not protected ripping a scarf off someone or a necklace is not protected destroying property is not protected violence of any kind is not protected setting up a tent city is not protected suspending students is lawful arresting them is lawful the rights are not being in French on the students committing unlawful act are being arrested and suspended lawfully so where's the problem it seems quite simple to me if you don't want to be arrested or suspended don't break the law
First word pepper, second word spray. (Third word jail)
In Vietnam we had Americans on the ground we were drafting men this is not the same
I think they buried the lead, I had one of these super left-wing professors once and I had to drop the course because we disagreed so much and I didn't trust her to grade me fairly. I nearly graduated late because of her. So that's a real fear on campus to all the students who just want to get a degree and go out and get a job.
I feel this only applies if they’re blocking public walkways or thoroughfares
Make them pay their own loan.
If your country is bombing the heck out of someone else's country and you sit in the same classroom with them and you d r a p e your country's flag around you then in my opinion you are taking matters into your own hands.
General Population would be good Divest the kids College funds to Israel
An Israeli student going to school in America is not exactly an Israeli soldier in Gaza but they still get off on it.
Carol Rose should worry about all students safety including Jewish and Israeli students.
Dialogue, dialogue, dialogue!
Best thing to do. You are wise.
Those pour College administrators. They're going to have to put down the student loan bag for a little bit and deal with their little problems.😅😂😅😅😅
Divest. They have no business investing in the stock market. That money, student tuition, should be put to good use making higher education far far more affordable rather than gambling and pissing it away on the stock market.
😅😅😅 going to respond to it the same way they respond to that student loan
More pressure needs to be put on the Universities to meet student demands. Our court system in MA should NOT shoulder the financial burden of political speech. The Universities should also have to pay an assessment tax for every arrest to cover court cost. They have brought these students from around the country and world and they now want to dump them into the state's criminal justice system. Universities do NOT pay enough real estate taxes to utilize the police. This is NO different than shipping migrants to MA from Texas or FL.
No. Students should not demand removing investments to critical companies.
@@oceanloverforever8233 It is their tuition dollars. And the Universities could set up private offshore trust companies to hold the investments. They do NOT pay taxes on the investment money anyway.
They should meet some of the demands.
Interesting argument. I agree they should hear and agree to the reasonable and humanitarian demands of the students.
@@waynecmontgomery they don’t like it, they can move on. Universities are also entities in US. They receive money from government of US. If they want to admit people just because they pay money and these people will be voting for interests of other countries … well, universities can move to those countries. Or student can move to other universities. Companies unis are working with are critical to our security
Only have right to peacefully assemble....that hasn't been held for far too long.
Right to protest > Universities bottom line
Right to protest is not > the rights of others to conduct their activities and do so without threat of violence on their being.
@jenalatz3589 I have seen minimal violence. There are frat party fights that are more violent than what is happening at these protests. Police intervention is authoritarian and irresponsible and is why police should have even more scrutiny so we can avoid them being persecuted because of bad actors in their departments. If police abide by the laws themselves, they wouldn't be so distrusted by much of the population.
Dialogue.
by leaving them the hell alone
How? Buy them one way tickets to gaza and leave them there, and then fill that same plane up with smart hard workers from gaza that will actually appreciate and respect the greatest country on earth. We dont need that stupidity here.
Maybe he needs to survey where the “fear of personal safety” is coming from! Maybe the police need to be supervising rather than attacking protesters
Students united ❤ we are the future
Excellent decision
But having Israeli students who are members of IDF “ trained killers who may have killed civilians is unacceptable “ how could they even expect normal interaction ?
Troll
Go unite in Ukraine far away
@@Soma81 I always finish what I started
The only danger to students was created by the authorities. Therefore, we stand with the US CONSTITUTION. First Amendment.
FREE PALESTINE
Free Israel
@@trentonarganbright1871 from the river to the sea
@@ThanhTruong-zw8mf Palestine will NEVER be free
Mission Wonder how many homeless encampments are the police about to read or is it just the Protestant students
Free speech is absolute! Hate speech is not a real thing!
Probably feels real if you are on the receiving end.🥴