Delhi need not be our saviour, we only want a good partnership: Palanivel Thiagarajan
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- We are not expecting Delhi to be our saviour. What we want is fairness, predictability and a good partnership that allows for independent decision-making, said Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Palanivel Thiagarajan, sitting down for a discussion with Montek Singh Ahluwalia, former chairman of the Planning Commission. The session was moderated by Prabhu Chawla, Editorial Director, The New Indian Express at the tenth ThinkEdu Conclave on March 9. #ThinkEdu2022 #TamilNadu #IndianEconomy
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are active on social media! Follow us:
Facebook: / thenewindianxpress
Twitter: / newindianxpress
Stay updated with our Apps:
For Android users: bit.ly/2EdIaWW
iOS users: apple.co/2SrVdHf
For more videos: www.newindianex...
For all the important news: www.newindianex...
We in Tamilnadu are very fortunate to have such a great FM.
PTR is the best. All the indian states should utilize the knowledge of this perfect gentleman.
third rated thug
Like Lehman to close TN
@@sundararaman9940
Who ?
Our man in Delhi ?
@@sundararaman9940 which FM?😂
External affairs of India dr.jaisanker also born to Tamil family ( Delhi)
Excellent Panel....👏👏👏👏👏.....hats off to TN Finance Minister.....
Deliberations of PTR sir is really appreciable and one must take note of his advice on the financial matters.
I liked the tone and style of speaking of Ahluwalia ji..Beautiful presentation. The way he expressed his views on Tamilnadu is really appreciable... Congrats to all..
Brilliant argument by Dr. Thiyagarajan on equilibrium of states in the country.
Tamil nadu is lucky to have such brilliant finance minister to lead the state ahead in all aspects. Congratulations PTR.
great comedy
Unlucky, TN only development in Chennai, other districts are worst than Bihar. Please come and see the infrastructure development project in Coimbatore and other parts after DMK resumed as state government.
@@sureshkumar-cc1jq you go to bihar up and settle there
@@sureshkumar-cc1jq have you been to any other states?? I am from Karnataka apart from Bangalore no other districts are half improved like Bangalore.
Just compare Karnataka districts vs Tamil Nadu. You will know how much Coimbatore Madurai and Vellore have improved.
@@ayapan872 sangi thayoli....
Hats off and my salute to Dr. PTR.
You are truly an inspiring personality Mr. PTR 🖤❤️
God bless PTR sir. Really TN is blessed to have such Finance Minister. Each State should find such persons so that our Country becomes No. 1.
DMR ........|RAV
Ah .. Yes PTR is a gem of Finance Minister well educated who comes from great family, AND most significantly rooted in , imbibed the Social values of Equality to All from birth Education opprtunity to All etc Which are generatrd from magnificent Thamizh Language and Culture viz . Dravidian Philosopy .
The term Dravidian itself was coined in the late 19th Century
by Great Thinkers contemporaneous and precedent to Periyar and friends / similar Social Reformers .
It was ans is to mean , to self define , Non ( Other Than ) and Anti ( Against inimical ) Brahminism This Perriyarism Guided TN and South India sadly, in past 1000 years or so this Adharma has been surreptitiously infiltrated and subsumed by a treacherous Totally ALIEN invasion and take over of
the Aryan Religio Socio Political system of ( shitty ) inequality initiating inequality perpetuating system and " values " ( !)
Oh, you don't like the word Aryan ? fine, say instead , Brahmanical? don't accept that either, say, Sanathana (A) Dharma way of life .
Oh you think this our )
] perspective of you and your ilk , is unfair , untrue and derogatory ... ... fine , continue to believe and spout your truth .
I can Other laugh at your hateful , hate filled, hate spreading, arrogant, abysmally ignorant understanding of RSS tinted reality and consequently your low life mentality .
PLESSE Don' t try to rewrite retell facts of History and in " glorious " ( really inglorious) Hindutva nonsense .
And don't hope to get your cunning aims realised ; bcz present RSS shit Brahminism agenda and implementation , to take modern India to the 16th Century time of then shit holes filled old Bharath Mahaan This will not work for long. .
It is this Sanathana Adharmic influence that is dragging the people and culture of Thamizh Nadu to 7 th / 8 th Century time.
DMK beleivers say there is no god. All gods are fake. Such leaders should be all over the world.
No need to integrate Tamil Nadu it’s best India just allow it to lead. I think it has one of the best model in India.
Whatever the concept to be implemented, it should have practicality. Maran's statement, "there are no backward State, only mismanaged State" is absolutely true. First thing India needs to do is to get rid of corruption and scandals. It may not be achieved overnight but, achievable. This itself would give 50% more growth. PTR is a great GIFT to TN (also to India if he is properly utilized). Best is yet to come!
corruption + dmk. If we burn DMK out corruption will go away from Tamilandu
I want to see this man as India’s FM one day and make some history. Like flipping a page from a book.
@@gallapettisingaram5792 sure. But the government which invites him to be FM of the country should change India into a federation of states first
PTR. Outspoken, intellectual and great visionary person He should be given full frredom in restructuring the economy by our CM. Hope TN will prosper in the years to come. Hats off.
Agree. Definitely he is a pride for TN and envy of many states including the union government.
But really saddened by his omission to refer Shri Kamaraj our then CM who was instrumental 🤔 for the foundation of education in this state which most of us are aware. Today we can proudly announce to the whole nation we are a developed state as far as EDUCATION is concerned 😟
@@lathaantony6913 Kamarajar contribution does not have to be mentioned every time.. it is automatically understood.. TN education = Kamarajar.. that is the equation..
@@vijaykumarkandaswamy1976 No doubt, Kamaraj improved it & dravidan movement maintains it & carries forward.Its a fact.
ha ha ha . Intellectual, my foot. a guy who got education thru caste quota and denied a poor guy his right place inspite of being a minister's son
@@sundararaman9940 You sound like a Brahmin :P
Dr. PTR should definitely take this point from Mr.Aluvalia about "Tamil Nadu's Declining population growth phase". He should also tell people about, how it was purposely done using family planning programs and they purposely increased the population of UP, Bihar, Rajastan, Jharkhand and MP.
are you out of your mind? purposedly increased? Family Planning was in the 70's under Sanjay Gandhi...
Ministers of finance in the Union and other states must use his expertise to grow the economy...
As if she is lacking expertise and knowledge
She does her work without pomp and show and with humility
@@narayananvenkateswaran7663 your reply is the perfect example of your xxxx mentality . Nobody could be knowledgeable unless he is from xxxx . What is the central finance minister's knowledge and experience all of us know. Can you list what and where she has achieved ? The only qualification he has is she was associated with RSS/BJP.. Your XXXX has not has not taken "knowledge " on lease so as others cannot claim . I pity you, still you are in 19 th century mindset, grow, open your eyes .
@@palanisamygopalsamy2020 you are in fool's paradise. You fellows ultimately end up brow beating a particular community directly or indirectly. It affects them the least.But some of you rot with envy and hatred and nothing but those qualities You are nobody to give credentials to our Finance Minister.Sane elements know her worth I am vide open with my eyes But you better get a cure for your jaundiced eyes
You have been hijacked by the DMK leaders... Cool.
@@venkatesh913 yes, hijacked by the knowledge 👏., not by the dung stories...
Excellent interview. Thanks for the transparent discussion about the financial sector.
mass reply in the last Mr.PTR sir
Great discussion by intellects. But none of them clearly explained long term solution for growing wider gap between rich and poor.
Gap will widen till poor the states gets education.
@@princeerskine8978 yes..he explained in that video itself 👍🏽
Current government is pro capitalistic and i think congress too moved from socialist party to capitalistic. We need a strong opposition with socialistic ideology to neutralize it. Maybe
@@princeerskine8978 yes - quality education, education to women / deprived and women empowerment - that is dravidian formula for upbringing of a society
@@princeerskine8978 poorer states will remain poor as there is no political will to educate the masses. If masses are educated then they will THINK before voting. Southern states are better comparatively because of education.
Wonderful insights from Palanivel Thyagarajan.. ❤️
If every state gets a finance minister like ours India will be a super power in economy and administration 😊
watched yet another Dr.PTR interview with full attention and admiration 😊👏👏👏👏🙏
I am a Keralite, but feel proud that Dr. PTR belongs to a sister State.
பழனிவேல் தியாகராஜன் 🔥🔥💯💯👏👏👏
Mr. Finance Minister/sir, . Feel very proud of you as a Tamilan.
Saying Tamils show up in lungis, is like saying these Gujaratis show up with pajama.
Thank you, TamilCM, for appointing such a capable person as Finance Minister. We, the people of the country, appreciate your decision, and we all hope that every state has such capable politicians as our ministers.
Who can guide us in the right direction, strengthening and empowering us in our respective fields.
The introduction itself is Great!
Shri Montek singh, a great economist well known in the economic field and another financial reformer of Tamilnadu state Shri PTR Thiagarajan, both are in a platform gave us a practical knowledge on this crises period to back the economy into the right track. This type of interview of intellectuals at frequent interview is very much necessary in this time of need.
Fantastic Mr. P.T.R. Palanivelrajan Sir
EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT SPEECH SUPER BRO PTR TN FM
PTR 💕awesome!!! Tamilan da ❤️
This is super special discussion on financial management on a kind of large scale and also phenomenal explanation.
Hon TN Finance Minister,your vast experience from Corporate world to Managing state Gov is great.Every gov should think like you.Your facts about women empowerment must be taken seriously.Development of skill is another subject you touched in all your talk,thats great."LEARN A SKILL "is our TAMIL Saying.GREAT SIR..
Who are watching this video for PTR sir??
When a nation is under developed, low GDP, low taxation, low in every development parameter, the first step is to raise wealth. At this stage you have to add fuel to private enterprise, where ever in the country they are, by what ever means. Because there is no better lesson from history that wealth creation is done only in a market based, free capitalism. No politician can generate wealth no matter what percentage of votes he/she got in the last election. But once the economic engine starts rolling, wealth is generated then political direction becomes crucial. How to manage & fine tune the growth. How to channel wealth in to the right priorities. This is a huge, hard but happier national challenge. Unfortunately for India the voters are not informed enough so they threw out the government who planned & executed on the first part, wealth creation, and put in a divisive, narrow minded, regional biased, caste obsessed ideology of BJP in power who are squandering the opportunity of the last 500 years that India had to truly rise and shine as a whole.
The best ever Finance Minister TN Got. Its golden opportunity for the govt to utilise him..instead looking at problem at macro level...looked the issues at micro level which will fix all economic issues slowly @ longterm..if not at shorterm
Grand debate with highly intelligent and most educated intellectuals of our country..
I'm sure Mr PTR is as comfortable in Dhoti as he is in trousers. And he and many before him would excel whatever be the dress. It's their culture and every reason to feel proud.
Covering DMK politics from 1970s yet couldn't distinguish Veshti and Lungi
Which means you know nothing 😂
Start wearing Vesti, you will see the difference.
he is a typical racist northie,look at the condesding manner he says,"dravidian leaders come in lungi and what not and speaking in regional language", he must have thought what this lungi,pungi walas are capable of,typical northie thinking,they think only fair complexioned,suit,boot type s are higher on social ladder when he started covering dmk,now after 40-50 years he would have realised,it is only the grey matter which matters,unfortunately the northern states dont focus on education,personal growth,the politicos,and society filled their mind with,religion,hate,basically narrowmindedness,hopeless
This is North Indian misplaced arrogance
Karunanidhi used to wear lungi in morning
Brilliant analysis. Thank you.
👍👍👍👍👍Excellent interactions
India that is Bharat, was not supposed to be governed as one nation and one economy.
India was supposed to be a federation of states where only defense, communication, currency, foreign affairs would be handled centrally with rest being governed by the states. This is what the cabinet mission plan of 1946 was all about which was accepted by Congress and Muslim League but vehemently opposed by the business houses profiteering under the centralized rule of the British.
Since these business houses were the chief patrons of both Congress and Muslim League, Congress withdrew its consent to this plan.
Withdrawal of Congress from the cabinet mission plan led to the partition and not Hindu Muslim divide that we have been led to believe.
So, India I.e Bharat a federal union of states need to be governed as a union of 30 economies and not one economy.
Well said. 👍
You can better write fiction . Your knowledge about India and its constitution is totally wrong
@@krishnansri7625 India is Greek name of Pakistan.
@@krishnansri7625 Actually no. It sounds like fiction, but it is true. Once Congress withdrew support, Jinnah rushed by offering the rich another deal ie no high taxes and allowing them to hold large landholdings. To top it, he allowed them to own any Hindu property. This made many Muslim businessmen move there and stayed large landlords. Pakistan still has hardly any taxes on fuel and has a lot of large landlords. The lack of land ownership is what makes sure that Pakistan has a lot of slums and farmers who work as tenants.
It is high time that well to do states reduces funding poorer states which has shown no improvements even after 70 years of net transfers, well to do states must not be penalised for performing better, there needs to be lesson taught to the politicians who are responsible for keeping their respective states poor deliberately or otherwise this will only happen when this net transfers stops and they understand the seriousness of the situation
11.00 crystal clear view.
Use like this 11:00
Quality discussion
Great intellectual speech by our finance minister PTR. Kudos to our finance minister. 👏👏💐💐
Very nice and informative discussion.
I request the Chanel bring this into did.
Abdul Matheen
All geniuses who debate from googling current gdp and saying northern states have more tax contributed don't know the ground reality that all coastal stated... industrially developed states contribute more to Indian economy than north Indian states...for the past 30 to 40 yrs that's the truth ...and why still many states not well performing is due to lack of education...more seperation based on caste and religion... and most importantly bad choice of political leaders in this way rich becomes richer ...poor becomes more poor
True..
PTR🔥
Our TN CM is lucky to have PTR like person with him to develop the TN and people.
Great budget Dr. PTR, hats off to you Sir.
Not only CM we people also
TN will be the model state in India.
Am from north...I know both arguments...how tax policy afects south..how freight policy harmed north and favoured south...
But PTR is right about 1 thing....balance is required....Bihar Jharkhand and Bengal need to be developed (like UP recently) ...why GAP is increasing instead of decreasing...
The easiest way to reduce imbalance is to give freebies.
Union.govts responsibility does not end by allocating more funds to under developed states. Those states must be brought under presidents rule. Able administrative officers must be posted there. The utilisation of the alloted money is tobe monitored by the union. Then only those states will be developed.
We have an intelligent and good finance minister Mr.Palanivel Thiagarajan. We will in top 1 state in India soon.
Excellent choice by honorable CM Shri M.K.Stalin
PTR always rocks more of people like him should enter into politics
Listening. Fine. Great
his previous historyin lehman brothers to be probed.
Why? Did you probe the performance of Modi in tea shops he worked?!
India'should come top position for finance.
Well done 👏👏💪💪💪👍👍
why 2 watches in his hand?😂😂
I think that the south especialy tamilnadu ruled entire nation in very good administration ability in future
Rectian rocks 👍🙏
Quota Rectian, by the way. He got thru caste quota. I am from forward caste rectian
PTR PTRajan is an efficient person. But in party hierarchy Stalin's son is projected shamelessly.
Lion 🦁Men PTR great spech for every TMILANDa🌞🌞🌞🌞🌞
It is time for South India to become a separate country. We are tired of financing the north indians.
Not Lungi but Thothi. The Moderator should upgrade his knowledge please
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
The centre wanting to do all things will not help the country like India.
👌👌👌
The present Finance minister should be the pride of tamilnadu and the DMK God bless him
Corruption is the major cause of mismanagement.
Honorable PTR is an extraordinary personality as FM of TN who tor the KD in to pieces
@26:57
PTR should come Indian FM.
North India needs to get out of manuvaathi vedic casteist mind set, start challenging religious blind faiths and start seeing all people as equals. Unless this happens, their development and hence India's will only be a day dream.
Bro read all comments. The all are having a similarity. Ha.. ha.. ha. The Northern States bro's comments are very less. I think they are like debate over Hindustan-Muslim & Ram-Rahim...
Ptr should be cm of Tamil Nadu and dr.jaishanker pm of India 😅
Tamil nadu has always been counter cycle to national trend
tHE OERIOD OF manmohan singhji as fm and pm is the golden period of indiaprosperity> the govt was ably assisted by montek singhiji
Prabhu is not prepared to discuss with person like PTR
After Kamaraj rule.. the most corrupted state is Tamil Nadu in South India. Number one state in India in cash for vote system. The states progress is no way because of the policy or the government it is just hard work of individual progress and the government successfully taking credit for that. Last 4 years the major income for the state X checker is from liquor sales and the defcits managed by state loans. and all everybody will starts Central state blame game...Please tell us the truth sir
Why don't all other state people also work so hard and push TN to bottom 5. The fact is that govt has done something good and people rallied behind and did hardwork. That's why TN is doing good. Get some stomach burn medicine
தமிழ்ல இதுக்கு பேரு 'பொச்செரிச்சல்' ப்ரூவ்!
Not happy with how things are going can be understood, go to BIMARU states then you'll understand what Tamil Nadu has achieved
I can assume that Mr.Mani, when he made the above reply abt Tamilnadu, contributed to the income of TN , albeit in a small way
Ay least some one there to talk from our side this time.
Mr journalist why you said Tamilnadu out of national structure. You should understand if you involve in language or religious politics you will pay a heavy price you should know about it boss.
Every praise of DMK is for MUTHUVEL KARUNANITHI
Lol
We PTR as our CM
தமிழாக்கம்இருந்தால்
மிகநன்றாகஇருக்கும்
How this guy does not know the difference between Dhoti and Lungi? being Journalist he has to learn india first.
Very fluent English there is no Indian slang, easy to understand,can Modi or anyone in his cabinet can talk like this?
His emphasis had always been on socioeconomic development . Unlike some idiots in Delhi
Always PTR is rocking 💥
😀
Sorry Sir , being a journalist you didn't know that it is not Lungi, but Mundu or Dhoti which is white in colour. Lungi is worn inside the house and is coloured or multi coloured.
Veshti
Absolutely correct. North Indians have a tendency, because of their inborn ignorance, to call a mundu a lungi.
Like the way Mr. Motek Singh Ahluwalia, Former Deputy Chairman, Planning Commission express his view on Tamil Nadu and looking forward to learn anything great from any State as a take away for the Center to lead our nation in a better way. His humbleness to put himself whether he had a great job or not in his tenure in Planning Commission is the good indication for good leadership who really wants our nation at priority for its true prosperity. Of course, PTR has a great view on social development. Thanks to the host. Great session!!
Bm7 1
The host seems to know very little about TN.
We Tamilnadu people really thank God for having such an efficient, knowledgeable ,bold , finance minister with clarity in put forth good suggestions to centre in finance issues for state development.
It's funny to see this arrogant man
@@basavarajagoudara7247 which state are you from?
TN,Keralam,Andhra, Telangana, Karnataka combined GSDPs 12% more than than what's equivalent all over the India And still Union set uniform norms for borrowing limit. Clearly South provides a fair share to North and making the south dependable and owing to union is unfair
Can’t argue with that …
So what is the problem. Taking from rich and giving it to poor. Isn't what everyone likes to preach. And your South is run by labourers from UP n Bihar.
@@FromPlanetZX we pay them , not like bonded labour in North
@@FromPlanetZX they are not running the govt. They sell Pani puri and work in construction projects
@@FromPlanetZX One can't only take take and take from the rich to give it to poor just because they are comfortable being poor. The point is to work to improve the lives of poor. Equality should be achieved in the right way to give a permanent solution. Otherwise we would end up hurting one or the other!
Simply great!! Diamond like clarity, highly articulated and rich in content.. salute to PTR and Dr Ahluwalia also. God bless you!!
One nation will not work in Indian subcontinent.. As a new rule, Hindi must be taken out from in Indian constitution, and English is one language should everybody learn as communication language and use their their regional language as local communication. We don't want language chuvanism
The Top Quality of Knoledge possessed by Mr P.T.R. Reflects in the way He Pionts in Cracking the People's Problems.
Its Veshti and not lungi Prabhu chawla covering TN for so long and yet can't distinguish
That's lungi only
The north Indians can't make out the difference between the different South Indian cultures and call all "madrasis". How can you expect them to know the difference between Veshti, Mundu or Lungi.
All the states and the union of India should utilise Mr.PTR's Knowledge
Cholas were the best Indian empire when it comes to Trade and economic policies