NEW 2021 -MARTIN OR COLLINGS SHOOTOUT -GUITAR REVIEW

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 177

  • @jmihendrix4
    @jmihendrix4 Рік тому +18

    The Collings sound bright, punchy, and crispy. Maybe it will age with time. But the Martin sounds like aged fine wine with the dark, broken in, deep tone

  • @soliddrake11
    @soliddrake11 2 роки тому +20

    They both sound phenomenal. It’s hard to dispute Collings being the more clear/loud and beautiful sounding guitar. I think the Martin is just so ingrained in my head as what an acoustic is supposed to sound like. Which is why I have a Martin.

  • @andrzey8903
    @andrzey8903 3 роки тому +33

    Beautiful guitars, but the Collings... It sounds so heavenly

  • @cs3634
    @cs3634 3 роки тому +21

    i own both. Collings OM42 and a Martin OM custom shop. They are both amazing. I play the Collings way more often. For me, I like the Martin for cowboy chord country stuff and rhythm. The Collings excels at fingerstyle, lead, recording, and soloist work. I really love both.

  • @tfdharley1360
    @tfdharley1360 2 роки тому +3

    They both have their place. The Martin in the back blending away, the Collings up front voicing away.

  • @oliver7763
    @oliver7763 3 роки тому +26

    I was about to buy a Collins before deciding on martin hd28e. Perhaps I'm just accustomed to that martin sound but the Collins sounds much brighter (brasher) whereas the martin sounds more mellow/balanced(mature). Fingerstyle on a martin is heavenly. It's hard to put down my martin sometimes...

    • @postiticeland8783
      @postiticeland8783 Рік тому

      But did he use the same type of strings? Because if not it´s hard to say that "Collings is brighter" might just be the strings

    • @G_Demolished
      @G_Demolished Рік тому

      I agree. I always hear the Collings as though someone tried to build a Martin in the Taylor factory. 🤷‍♂️

    • @CharlesChou
      @CharlesChou Рік тому

      i have since moved on and settled on an OM28e. The HD28 was just too boomy and sides a bit too deep for me although the lows and mids were so beautiful and resonant. @@G_Demolished The OM28e is my forever guitar, rip...

  • @anonymohipp9097
    @anonymohipp9097 3 роки тому +7

    Both sounded great. I preferred the Martin. Thank you for doing such a great video!

  • @robotusa88
    @robotusa88 3 роки тому +6

    Both great in their own right. It would be interesting to hear them from the other side of the room. I bet the Collings sounds better in ten years.

  • @user-ev2qo1hj1g
    @user-ev2qo1hj1g Рік тому +1

    I have had both and now have a Martin HD35. I think the Collings to my ear have always sounded more sterile without the warm vintage overtones like the Martin. I have 2 Collings electrics. An I30LC and and I35LC and they are killer.

  • @drbo42
    @drbo42 3 роки тому +7

    Pretty sure I followed the channel close to a decade ago. Jarvis does not age.

  • @gabeah
    @gabeah 3 роки тому +10

    It’s amazing how much clearer and more open the Collings sounds. Seems to have more volume as well. It makes the Martin sound like it’s being played inside a metal bin.

  • @ronniemason9291
    @ronniemason9291 3 роки тому +5

    Difficult to put that Martin in second place. So I can't I tried but can't do it.
    Collings has some amazing instruments though.

  • @blonchie4724
    @blonchie4724 3 роки тому +4

    Always Martin🙏 I Keep trying and buying other brands, but I end up selling them because I only play my Martin custom

    • @TheGuitarSpaSingapore
      @TheGuitarSpaSingapore  3 роки тому +1

      Buy what you will play the most that’s what I would suggest and what you like

  • @migalito1955
    @migalito1955 2 роки тому +5

    You can really hear the impact of the Rosewood sides and back on the Martin. It punches out the bass. In the end they are both superbly crafted instruments and pieces of art, but I swing towards Martin & Co.

  • @brycekoslan7791
    @brycekoslan7791 9 місяців тому +2

    I have both in dreadnought models and to me. As for the video, to me, the Collings just has much better note separation and volume. I've always thought Collings is a "take no prisoners" guitar and they will be heard. Collings are loud and cut through in a bluegrass jam. The Martin has the more traditional tone (especially for bluegrass) and it has the edge if you want a warmer dryer tone and extra ++ bass. Both are great guitars. But if I had to choose, I'd go with the ........... no ................. maybe ............. OK, the Collings. BTW, I enjoyed your playing.

  • @vanessacai
    @vanessacai 3 роки тому +4

    Love these two brands very much ! But still prefer Martin sound more deeper . Between Martin 0-28vs and Collings 02h, I prefer Collings !

  • @tanukibrahma
    @tanukibrahma 3 місяці тому

    They sound equally good to me for strumming, but I’d choose the Collings for fingerpicking for the slightly better clarity, which is what I did when I was comparing Martins with Collings’ (I didn’t have an OM42 available to demo). Back in 2018 when I was comparing Collings OM2Hs with Martin OM28s, the Collings had more sparkle in the overtones. And of course, these guitars mellow with age.

  • @salciaburri5133
    @salciaburri5133 Рік тому +1

    I prefer Martin, but they both sound great. The Martin has a warmer sound to me . The Collings is brighter a you stated in the beginning.

  • @scouser2230
    @scouser2230 5 місяців тому +1

    I enjoyed the brighter tone of the Collins. I have played Matins all of my life and have never has the pleasure of playing a Collins.

    • @pcar928fan
      @pcar928fan 4 місяці тому

      Go find a Collings and play it! Or, on second thought, DON’T…unless you are planning to buy and have the $$$$$!!! I met Bill at the race track and then toured his first big factory (I think it was the one just before they moved to the one they are in now) and I had NO PLANS to buy a guitar…. LOL! Rolled out with a SWEET sounding OM1! Then I toured the factory they are in now and bought an SJ! LOL!

  • @simon-oy6um
    @simon-oy6um 29 днів тому +1

    You can make a load of guitars out of the same batch of wood and they will always have the slightest differences . And of course it depends how you play it too 😊😊😊😊

  • @BobK5
    @BobK5 10 місяців тому

    I thought I’d vote for the Martin as my ears have become sensitive to trebly tones but the Collings is so much clearer that I’d have to go with it. The Martin might benefit from having the same bridge pins as the Collings, Ebony, or FWI or bone might sparkle it up a bit to go with its looks.

  • @vyvynylification
    @vyvynylification 3 місяці тому

    I played an OM-28 Modern Deluxe which was the most impressive OM I heard so far. It's never thinny, it's so dynamic and it can get SO loud I couldn't believe it. The 2 downsides to it for me were the weird neck and that sometimes the bass overpowered the melody strings. Now, I never played a collings, but I do have a Boucher SG-51 sitting behind me and though it's not as loud it's definitly more balanced with a richer tone and a more expressive guitar. Both would serve different purposes in my arsenal but the martin would take the backseat due to the neck alone.

  • @riffmagos
    @riffmagos 3 роки тому +1

    Wow. Great to see you still doing your thing.

  • @blessedwithchallenges9917
    @blessedwithchallenges9917 2 роки тому +1

    The second example was so much richer on the Martin...surprisingly so.

  • @scouser2230
    @scouser2230 2 роки тому +2

    I own two Martins but I have to say I prefer the clarity of the Colins.

  • @Apollos-아볼로
    @Apollos-아볼로 3 роки тому +1

    Great sounds and Beautiful play!

  • @victorwee3319
    @victorwee3319 7 місяців тому +2

    It you want to impress your peer, then go for the brand Martin.
    But if you just want to enjoy playing your lovely song, then go for the Collings!

  • @Captain_Nightspore
    @Captain_Nightspore 2 роки тому

    Nice comparison and playing! Thanks!

  • @nledelnr
    @nledelnr 2 роки тому +1

    A beautiful soul making beautiful music on two incredible guitars. Your talent is under rated. I think you should do brief covers of classic songs on the guitars they were recorded on and then played on a guitar that you think is equally special for that tune.

    • @TheGuitarSpaSingapore
      @TheGuitarSpaSingapore  2 роки тому

      I’m just love doing reviews and not covers but thanks for your suggestions

  • @fixairplane3624
    @fixairplane3624 Рік тому +1

    I’m bluegrass so Martin all day for me, but props to Collings sound. Just too tingy & sustained for Bluegrass

  • @jaytouvelle2359
    @jaytouvelle2359 3 роки тому +4

    Many more people own Martin's and they are bias to their own guitar. They are both great but look at the tops you know the Collings is not even close to being broken in yet while the Marin has aged. Collings are built better and has the best finish in the business. They also sound great but you can buy a nice used truck for the price of one.

  • @theID2
    @theID2 12 днів тому +1

    i'll take the collings ... some like the softer bassier sound of a martin but to me the word is 'muddy'.

  • @secho2395
    @secho2395 2 роки тому

    For this video, Colling is the winner, very clear and sweet like heaven. But question is I also have a Martin OM42 myself and the one in ur video should have been brighter based on what I hear from mine. Could it be the strings?

  • @swillis3987
    @swillis3987 2 роки тому +2

    Great review Jarvis! Love your playing and reviews. How often does one get to compare such high end guitars? Either one is a keeper? However in this case I give a slight edge to the Collings simply because the intonation on the more modern Collings seems more precise. However if given a choice short of the ultra expensive dream guitars I would prefer a master grade torrified Boucher triple 0 or OM. I think they make a better Martin for less money?

  • @chrisgarver7904
    @chrisgarver7904 10 місяців тому

    better clarity with the Collings. Martin definitely has more lows, but can sound muddy at times.

  • @jocika022
    @jocika022 2 роки тому

    Collings in any case (beside of tone) ... if you need neck reset its much easier. Bolt-on neck will take you 45 minutes to do perfect neck reset . Luthier will ask you 100 bucks and for Martin (if you are lucky) 1,000 and huge risk that something goes wrong.

  • @BaktaBak3
    @BaktaBak3 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks to the owners of these guitars for having Jarvis review them for us. :-) I'd like to own both ! !

  • @bartofilms
    @bartofilms 10 місяців тому

    Excellent Comparison! May I ask what are the songs and are the guitars in Standard or D Modal tuning? They both sound perfect (but different…) to my ear. I’d be unable to choose one and would love to own both of them! The Martin sounds a bit more ‘True’, ‘Serious’ or ‘Professional’, like James Taylor to my ear, while Collings sounds ‘Brighter’ and more emotionally positive, ‘Happy’, or modern. Cheers from 9 January on ‘24.

  • @ScottCommon632
    @ScottCommon632 Рік тому

    Martin all day.... warm adn love the separate distinct note feel. Collins all the strings blend together too quickly, compactly. Perhaps depends on your goal : band backup, solo, singer songwriter, etc.

  • @vincizara
    @vincizara 2 роки тому +1

    I like the Martin especially if you are a soloist acoustic player you need more Bass woody sound I’m hearing that on martin

  • @sasquatchlife8836
    @sasquatchlife8836 3 роки тому +2

    Collings sounds better in this comparison to me. I love Martins, but Collings for me on this one. nice playing

  • @bluesysamurainao4557
    @bluesysamurainao4557 2 роки тому

    Attraxtive chords and play. I am satified with OM28 but in this case Collings might be easier to play in my style.

  • @cmoreno12345
    @cmoreno12345 2 роки тому

    It’s as if the Martin was using cedar. Seems to be warmer but lower top end. Could be strings or too age difference. Not sure what would make such a big difference in tone in this case.

  • @pcar928fan
    @pcar928fan 4 місяці тому

    Give me the Collings and not just because I knew Bill either!! I usually like a more mid heavy guitar but the Martin seems to be missing some high end.

  • @raquelghibellov.1484
    @raquelghibellov.1484 3 роки тому +4

    ooh I'm early, those guitars sounds awesome!

  • @12166971
    @12166971 2 роки тому +1

    Both guitars are great! Martin for me. Thanks

  • @billurban9973
    @billurban9973 2 роки тому +1

    love your chord progressions

  • @neophytosdm
    @neophytosdm 2 роки тому

    I'd prefer it to see the models on the title to know if I'm interested to watch the review. Cheers

  • @arthurl2045
    @arthurl2045 3 роки тому +6

    Seems like the Martin sound is deeper and more reflective. The Collings is brighter and projects more, especially on trebles and mid. They both sound great. I have a Martin but wouldn't mind a Collings, or both if I could afford that. For songwriting, I would use the Martin for more reflective songs, and the Collings for brighter songs. Same with performing.

  • @jimmycollette9209
    @jimmycollette9209 3 місяці тому

    This is unfair. How can you compare these two perfect guitars? There are so many good guitar builders in the market today. A very good comparison. A man would be fortunate enough to own either. Just beautiful.

  • @MsDenver2
    @MsDenver2 3 роки тому +1

    Although a lot of people say collings is better I prefer the Martin after listening to you play , the collings to me sounds harsher whereas the Martin seems more gentle with feeling , more natural;. So definitely the Martin for me.

    • @TheGuitarSpaSingapore
      @TheGuitarSpaSingapore  3 роки тому +2

      Collings have that clarity on the highs the trebles and the bass are more contained - martin have that bold Rich bassy tone and the trebles are more matured or played in

    • @potterwalker4823
      @potterwalker4823 Рік тому +1

      well said.all the treble wears a crowd out as well. kind of gimicky and no justification for the price. Martin all the way.

  • @hongphuco6780
    @hongphuco6780 3 роки тому +1

    That Collings is so damn impressive. Can I ask which one is cheaper Martin or Collings?

  • @scottpalance
    @scottpalance Рік тому +1

    Odd gear comment here. They both sound different. They both sound absolutely amazing. I'm about to jump on the Collings. I'm just getting into capos (I know. I held off for no good reason) and I don't recognize the model but I like the lack of protruding grips. Any ideas on the model? Totally appreciated

    • @BobK5
      @BobK5 10 місяців тому +1

      It looks like a G9 capo 😎

    • @scottpalance
      @scottpalance 10 місяців тому

      @@BobK5 thanks so much

  • @cbayardelle
    @cbayardelle 10 місяців тому

    The Collins has the Taylor mid & treble sound, the Martin is more balanced, I’m 73, Alvarez yairy from the 70’s rules.

  • @daveross8879
    @daveross8879 2 роки тому +2

    Collings are on another level to Martin, if thats even possible. But hats off to Martin, they invented the steel string guitar, and the body shape the Collings is emulating and without them Collings would not exist

  • @martinrosschou
    @martinrosschou 2 роки тому

    Collins very bright, which I like (bright); but once the capo came on, Martin just sounded sooo good.
    Collins sounded good to, very clear, very bright, but the Martin just did something, for me..

  • @greeremalachi926
    @greeremalachi926 2 роки тому

    I bought a new Martin for a few thousand dollars couple of years ago. The tortoise binding fell off. Martin did a shabby repair. Purchase the Collings, otherwise, good luck.

  • @riceflatpicking4954
    @riceflatpicking4954 2 роки тому

    Theyre both amazing and different.

  • @adamstewart247
    @adamstewart247 2 роки тому +1

    Collings out "Martin-ing" the Martin

  • @carpathus
    @carpathus 3 роки тому +5

    Collings for me.

  • @douglasfan2
    @douglasfan2 3 роки тому

    I prefer Collings, a bit more balanced tone for both strumming and fingering.

  • @localguy8
    @localguy8 3 роки тому +3

    I like the Martin sound better this time 👍🏻🎸☮️

  • @jasonbussellsmusic8828
    @jasonbussellsmusic8828 2 роки тому

    Is the age of the guitars similar? The Collings sounds more mature and opened up.

  • @nogoogleplus
    @nogoogleplus Рік тому +1

    Honestly the both sound killer, just depends on your taste

  • @alanroberts7678
    @alanroberts7678 2 роки тому

    I don’t know the Collings but it sounds great. Al

  • @mailvilla
    @mailvilla 2 роки тому

    06/24/2022: What is the difference in the quality and tone between the Guild D-150ce Guitar Westerly Collection Acoustic-Electric Guitar, and the same guitar made in China?

  • @clementnade972
    @clementnade972 2 роки тому

    I can't help but notice that the strings on Martin sounds a little muffled. Maybe it's because it's harder to play?

  • @BaktaBak3
    @BaktaBak3 3 роки тому +1

    Both very nice ! Thanks Jarvis . :-)

  • @AvatarKnownAsNathanielPeters
    @AvatarKnownAsNathanielPeters 5 місяців тому

    As a Nazarene growing up I’ll always love Martins.

  • @fahadhashmi2889
    @fahadhashmi2889 2 роки тому

    I think the action on martin was a bit low.. I could hear the 6th string buzz a little

  • @nicetalkintoya
    @nicetalkintoya 2 роки тому

    reading a lot of comments favoring the collings but I don't hear it. martin sounds noticeably better to me.

  • @kenanbarends5543
    @kenanbarends5543 3 роки тому

    Can you do a review on the Larrivee D40R Legacy?

  • @potterwalker4823
    @potterwalker4823 Рік тому

    as a confirmed drummer/treble freak i definitely go w Martin.Collings is a one trick pony (relying on treble)to me and in no way is able to justify the price considering they are copies of Martins.greed plays in to that one. I have played every acoustic guitar around and it’s just whatever one likes in the moment whether on stage etc.The Martin is the more versatile and mature of the two.🎼

  • @dylanthomas7443
    @dylanthomas7443 3 роки тому +1

    The Martin was - for want of a better word perhaps - subdued I think. The Collins was a much better sound.

  • @Tech12301
    @Tech12301 3 роки тому +3

    The Collings sounds similar to a Taylor but not as much high end sparkle the trebles. I prefer the Collings. But then again Jarvis you can make almost any guitar sound good.

    • @christianvidigalmiranda4229
      @christianvidigalmiranda4229 3 роки тому

      I agree and that's why I prefer Martin.

    • @theocorfiatis8456
      @theocorfiatis8456 2 роки тому

      I have to disagree here..... I own two Martins, and tried out a few Collings and compared them with the Martins and a few different Taylors. Collings sound nothing like Taylors, as well as sounding nothing like Martins. Taylors I find are easier to play than Martins and so are Collings guitars which are very well set up from the factory. The Taylors are generally quieter and have a more twangy, less low mid heavy sound than most Martins and less bass. The Collings is somewhere between Taylors and Martins, but different. Collings have an extremely well balanced sounds across all the strings, amazingly so!, and guitars I use for fingerpicking are easier to play when they have a very balanced sound. The Collings have a lovely resonant and clear sound when fingerpicked, without the accentuated highs of the Taylors. I love my Martins for flat picking or strumming, you can't beat that power of that more bass heavy sound for strumming. But for fingerpicking the Collings beats the Martins for clarity and beats the Taylors for balance. One Collings I played had an Engleman spruce top which gave it noticeably more richness in the mids than a Sitka spruce top, so it was great for both strumming and fingerpicking. I'm happy to sell both my Martins and get that Engleman spruce Collings if I can find one still (and selling both Martins would just manage to pay for a Collings). As for Taylors, they are beautiful guitars which record very well, but I've never been blown away by their sound, not to say that some of the high end Taylors don't sound amazing, but still I'm more impressed by the Collings. That's my personal preference.

  • @simon-oy6um
    @simon-oy6um 29 днів тому +1

    You never play your strings like square ,makes it twacky so you twist your pick 25 degrees so it plays the string rather than hearing the pick 😊😊😊

  • @DB-rr1eo
    @DB-rr1eo 8 місяців тому

    The collings is clear the Martin has the Martin rumble.

  • @j.l.l.
    @j.l.l. Місяць тому +1

    Martin!

  • @Tigrebleau1
    @Tigrebleau1 7 місяців тому

    The Martin just sounds more "alive" than the Collins. But both are wonderful, in their own way.

  • @ronniemason9291
    @ronniemason9291 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you sir!

  • @jamesparr6840
    @jamesparr6840 2 роки тому +1

    The Collings sounds better to my ears..

  • @lanes58
    @lanes58 10 місяців тому

    I’m a Martin guy, but that Collings really jumped out at me.

  • @fourocker
    @fourocker Рік тому +1

    Mass produced Martin or hand crafted Collings 🤔 hard choice.....not 😅

  • @nickfletcher4132
    @nickfletcher4132 Рік тому

    For me the Martin still best all round guitar in the world.

  • @thecatladytm7172
    @thecatladytm7172 Рік тому

    I think Collings won out for me, but with what you played here, I think the mic was already kinda biased towards the bass on the mix. It felt like you had to fight to get the treble to be heard over the bass on the Martin, and the strings jangled or buzzed more because of it. The Collings required no such effort, and the eq and woods (rosewood is biased for bass and treble, scooped mid) balanced out the bass nicely. Idk, just what my rando ears heard ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

  • @rtmca1
    @rtmca1 10 місяців тому

    COLLINGS IS pronounced as it is spelled. Sound out the ending G. I live a few miles from the Collings shop and know some of the luthiers. It is Collings with a G. They hate it when it is pronounced “Collins”.

  • @Elaleyelunivese
    @Elaleyelunivese Рік тому

    Martin of course.

  • @bigal25938
    @bigal25938 Рік тому

    Martin kills it.

  • @ng3845
    @ng3845 3 роки тому +1

    Martin has thicker tone with more bass
    Isn't ?

  • @brettbhowell
    @brettbhowell 2 роки тому +2

    I can’t believe how much better the Collings sounds than the Martin. Both are incredible but one is exceptionally incredible

  • @pericliskipreos2165
    @pericliskipreos2165 3 роки тому

    I have both of them. I could say that are different guitars. Martin is more "clear", but Collings is more "strong" in their sound. So,i think it's difficult to choose one of the other. I feel lucky that i could have both of them!! Excellent video. Thanks a lot.

  • @leesanders1619
    @leesanders1619 Рік тому

    Collings. Hands down.

  • @SHINEIKYU
    @SHINEIKYU 3 роки тому

    Please compare yamaha ls36

  • @sergeykichuk2586
    @sergeykichuk2586 11 місяців тому

    By your smile I see you like more Martin 😉

    • @TheGuitarSpaSingapore
      @TheGuitarSpaSingapore  11 місяців тому

      yes i do

    • @RtaniDean
      @RtaniDean 5 місяців тому

      Yep. You could tell he autonomously was smiling from the core of being with the Martin. Hey hey, all about the instrument you resonate with. Both beautiful guitars. I’d say the more mature percentage of guitarists might go for the Martin. Be happy you have an instrument to play. In closing, my preference is to drum on. 😎🎵

  • @lilycat1694
    @lilycat1694 Рік тому

    Collings good but Martin sounds better to my ears.

  • @jurgenmaes7690
    @jurgenmaes7690 3 роки тому +1

    7000 € für eine Gitarre? 😂 Mein Auto hat 450€ gekostet ☝
    Wer den Martin Sound liebt, kauft eine Martin. Oder für viel weniger Geld eine Blueridge. Ich bin zur Zeit begeistert von Recording King Dirty 30' all solid. Nice special sound 🤗

  • @davidstoeckl6439
    @davidstoeckl6439 Рік тому

    Martin, totally

  • @johnmyers8415
    @johnmyers8415 2 роки тому

    both

  • @EdwinGuzmanRD
    @EdwinGuzmanRD 15 днів тому +1

    Collins’s sounds much better compared to the Martin. Different worlds

  • @ZRJZZZZZ
    @ZRJZZZZZ 4 місяці тому

    Collings guitars are superior to Martins in every way. Collings perfected Martin’s designs, and make the instruments one at a time. I would estimate that Martin’s weekly output is Collings annual output.