Appreciate the kind words! Yes, had to have both the OG Gestalt and the 1.22 remake on here, because sometimes they improved it and sometimes there's just no improving it
refreshing to see a unique list with not just the same few (although amazing) tracks taking the top spots. I wish this also contained NieR Reincarnation OST, some of the tracks from it are replicant/automata level of quality despite it being a mobile game.
In a series with music this good, 18 is a very honorable spot! I love Weight of the World. But I think many of the area and battle themes in these games are even more transcendent
End of the Unknown just missed the cut at number 36 on the combined list for me! It’s number 20 on my Automata list. I always rank more songs than I end up including in the videos
Ah makes sense I personally would have it in top 10 just because of the fight in automata and one of the Alliance Raid bosses in FFXIV and it really standing out from the other songs.
Doesn't matter in the grand scale of things but number 35 is (Cold Rain) version, (Spring Rain) is my favourite and is always overlooked because it plays on a DLC fight only, to my knowledge.
Have you considered making an entry for the NieR Reincarnation game in your ranking ? Also, if you're wondering, yes this game is important as it is both the NieR series' conclusion and an answer to all of the questions and incomprehensions we could have from these games. edit : i see that you already answered that question, so i'm satisfied ahah (thanks for that ranking by the way)
@@26.nguyenhuuminhtuan74 Touhou 7 soundtrack, Touhou 8, Touhou 10.5,Touhou 11, Touhou 14.5, Touhou 15, Touhou 15.5, Touhou 17, Touhou 17.5, dolls in pseudo paradise album (the best ones, imo) my favorite touhou stage theme: SA last remote My favorite touhou boss theme: LoLK clownpiece theme
@@26.nguyenhuuminhtuan74 "you may know dream" by sound holic is a good song with a great music video. For channels check out FELT, Akatsuki records, shibuyan records, swing holic, IOSYS, anything reddevils500a reuploads, shinra bansho.
Oh boy, easy top 5 nier ost as last, rank 35... Also snow in summer v1.22 at bottom 28? That song is beyond haunting & beautiful... No... No! What is thiss? Okay top 10 time. Gods bound by rules.. good, good. Wretched automatons, easy god tier. At 8? Hmmm.... What could be better? Ooh wretched weaponry 7. Thats nier automata theme song, the eternal, never ending conflict that leaves everyone heartbroken. Okay, you might have solid opinions after all... Maybe I'll give another try and look at 35-10...
I know they’re related but this is just a Nier series list! I’m sure I will rank the Drakengard series eventually and then fuse them into another video!
@@calebgames6159 Oh, kinda feel bad rn. My comment was kinda ironic - we all know how "Special" DOD ost is, and its impossible to compare it to moder nier series music :)
A lot of these just depend on whether you favor emotional pieces or active battle pieces more. Kaine Salvation at no. 11 on possibly the greatest series of music ever is still very high praise from me! You’re probably right that Voice of No Return should be on here somewhere. I don’t think it was in the ost list I was listening to. Will have to consider!
@@mojahead Square did strike my original top 1,000 VGM video a couple years ago for having Nier and Final Fantasy in it. I’m a little surprised this one has lasted this long with this many views. However, apparently they won’t strike videos that include gameplay, so if and when I get struck again, I will try to get gameplay footage and reupload
To be honest you could have put this ranking in any order and I would have agreed with you. This composer is amazing
Indeed, it's one of the greatest set of soundtracks ever conceived
Vague hope at 35 killed it from the start ngl
Yeah I don't try to rank based on effectiveness for the video, but that was a strong way to kick it off!
Shadow Lord is my no.1 personally, God bless though 😊
Fair enough! It goes hard!
@@calebgames6159🔥
Gotta appreciate adding the classic gestalt here👌 great playlist i happily have it on during the night knowing such greatness was created👌
Appreciate the kind words! Yes, had to have both the OG Gestalt and the 1.22 remake on here, because sometimes they improved it and sometimes there's just no improving it
refreshing to see a unique list with not just the same few (although amazing) tracks taking the top spots. I wish this also contained NieR Reincarnation OST, some of the tracks from it are replicant/automata level of quality despite it being a mobile game.
I will eventually rank Reincarnation and then mix it into a new Nier series list
Ur wild for putting weight of the world at 18
In a series with music this good, 18 is a very honorable spot! I love Weight of the World. But I think many of the area and battle themes in these games are even more transcendent
Lovely playlist... Thank you very much :)
Thanks for listening!
Very nice, think you just have one missing track which is "End of the Unknown".
End of the Unknown just missed the cut at number 36 on the combined list for me! It’s number 20 on my Automata list.
I always rank more songs than I end up including in the videos
Ah makes sense I personally would have it in top 10 just because of the fight in automata and one of the Alliance Raid bosses in FFXIV and it really standing out from the other songs.
Im also guessing u don't include like collab ost thats cannon to Nier like FFXIV which has one song changed "Weight of the World (Prelude Version)"?
I would include cases like that in the game where song plays, so if I rank FFXIV it might appear there
10# plays at the end of the 2nd NieR raid in FF14, which is quite fitting considering the title and all that ^^
Interesting!
I think what we're forgetting here in the comments is that all these songs are absolutely amazing regardless of their ranking
I encourage and respect the disagreement!
Doesn't matter in the grand scale of things but number 35 is (Cold Rain) version, (Spring Rain) is my favourite and is always overlooked because it plays on a DLC fight only, to my knowledge.
I did listen to both! I like cold Rain just a little more
i very agree with you , but where is the EMIL DESPAIR ( エミール/絶望) THE Nier Automata True Final Boss Fight ending Y
song of the ancients hollow dreams is my #1, no diff
I love every Song of the Ancients iteration, but that's definitely not my favorite one! Different tastes
Have you considered making an entry for the NieR Reincarnation game in your ranking ? Also, if you're wondering, yes this game is important as it is both the NieR series' conclusion and an answer to all of the questions and incomprehensions we could have from these games.
edit : i see that you already answered that question, so i'm satisfied ahah (thanks for that ranking by the way)
Are you talking about Reincarnation?
@@calebgames6159 yes !
@@calebgames6159 i just saw i typed replicant instead, my bad
Nob is 1 of a kind
One day I will listen to these soundtracks after i have finished listening to Touhou music
can I get some good soundtracks from touhou?
@@26.nguyenhuuminhtuan74
Touhou 7 soundtrack, Touhou 8, Touhou 10.5,Touhou 11, Touhou 14.5, Touhou 15, Touhou 15.5, Touhou 17, Touhou 17.5, dolls in pseudo paradise album
(the best ones, imo)
my favorite touhou stage theme: SA last remote
My favorite touhou boss theme: LoLK clownpiece theme
I need to give Touhou a try!
@@26.nguyenhuuminhtuan74 "you may know dream" by sound holic is a good song with a great music video. For channels check out FELT, Akatsuki records, shibuyan records, swing holic, IOSYS, anything reddevils500a reuploads, shinra bansho.
missing emil karma/despair otherwise excellent list 👍
Fixed it😉
ua-cam.com/video/CIK3Vf-Q0fU/v-deo.html&ab_channel=Mojahead
Literally every song is number one
fr
I find it weird that Birth of a wish is in here, but not the variants.
I just like it better without them! The variants are neat for the game but just for listening I prefer the default
Missing 'Memories of Dust". 😢
Not my favorite sadly
when the 35th place would be one of the best songs in any other game
I know right
Oh boy, easy top 5 nier ost as last, rank 35... Also snow in summer v1.22 at bottom 28? That song is beyond haunting & beautiful... No... No! What is thiss?
Okay top 10 time. Gods bound by rules.. good, good. Wretched automatons, easy god tier. At 8? Hmmm.... What could be better?
Ooh wretched weaponry 7. Thats nier automata theme song, the eternal, never ending conflict that leaves everyone heartbroken. Okay, you might have solid opinions after all... Maybe I'll give another try and look at 35-10...
Haha I love to see the opinion evolve as you go through it
Im disappointed that no Drakengard 1 music is included in the list
I know they’re related but this is just a Nier series list! I’m sure I will rank the Drakengard series eventually and then fuse them into another video!
@@calebgames6159 Oh, kinda feel bad rn. My comment was kinda ironic - we all know how "Special" DOD ost is, and its impossible to compare it to moder nier series music :)
Although im hyped for Drakengard ost ranking - Don't forget about Drakengard mobile ost ;p
wretched weaponry is best
No nier reincarnation? Sad
One day!
俺のベストはパスカルなんだが...
Now go listen to Drakengard 3's soundtrack, and NieR Reincarnation's soundtrack.
One day!
no shot kaine salvation not top 10 and voice of no return not even on here laughing at you
A lot of these just depend on whether you favor emotional pieces or active battle pieces more. Kaine Salvation at no. 11 on possibly the greatest series of music ever is still very high praise from me!
You’re probably right that Voice of No Return should be on here somewhere. I don’t think it was in the ost list I was listening to. Will have to consider!
How do you avoid a ban from Square Enix?
My top has been deleted several times already🥲🥲
@@mojahead Square did strike my original top 1,000 VGM video a couple years ago for having Nier and Final Fantasy in it. I’m a little surprised this one has lasted this long with this many views.
However, apparently they won’t strike videos that include gameplay, so if and when I get struck again, I will try to get gameplay footage and reupload
@@calebgames6159 Thanks for the life hack with gameplay. Will use it in the future
isnt 1:49:43 popola? btw devola better
Nope, it's the Remake version of Devola!
@@calebgames6159 damn k my bad, still first is better. i listen to it all the time. cant get tired of it