On one hand you say Manmohan Singh was acting as per the dictats of the family. Then again every body admits his policies turned around India in very difficult times and had both welfare measures and economic progress including all economic pundits and journalists. Most corruption charges could not be proved even after more than 10 yeras of opposition. So what is wrong in giving some credit to the Congress. president.
What policies...he oversaw the biggest decade of corruption in independent India. Bombs were going off left right and centre. Pakistan was hitting us both from across the border and from within through its Jihadi proxies. That Italian bar maid did nothing but run the country into the ground. India grew despite the policy paralysis.
There are still so many bakhts of the corrupt family to which "the transfer of power" was given by the British Raj, even if a foreign lady of dubious connections who insulted Narasimha Rao-ji even after his death. Yes, it was PVN Rao that did the liberalization and NOT Moun Singh or Sonia or Rahul.
He was forced to make those changes as the congress' daddy the USSR collapsed and India became bankrupt. India and China were at the same level in 1991 but see what has china become.
This man is responsible for humiliation of Dr. Singh, having him here now is a wrong on many levels. He enabled the BJP to make that insult of a movie about Dr. Singh. Disgraceful, in my opinion.
yes, The 2G spectrum case was a major political scandal in India that involved the allocation of licenses for 2G spectrum, a type of mobile phone radio frequency. The case was investigated by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and resulted in the acquittal of all accused in 2017 by CBI court
Sorry, Dr Singh was chosen to be there - to guide us through the unchartered territory of a liberalised market-driven free economy. Please don't forget he was an economist, an academician and a fine bureaucrat before he accidentally became a politician.
MMS was also responsible for the high inflation in late 70s. He had a long history of being socialist with high taxation that ruined our economy. The only reason we opened up was because IMF arm twisted us. We had to do it because we had no more than 2 weeks of forex reserves to buy oil. As simple as that. While we all respect him, lets not give extra credit for the opening of economy - we did it because we had to.
@@Dogmatix-24that road map would've been thrown into dustbin had there been no PV Narasimha Rao. The only credit he deserves is for Bharath - US civil nuclear deal where he stood up like a rock against all odds.
@@spectrum_X If Dr Singh's roadmap were to be thrown into the dustbin would that have been his fault or shortcoming? Maybe his roadmap was good enough for Mr Narasimha Rao to back. Maybe Mr Narasimha Rao was smart enough to recognise a good man who understood economics though not politics. We can forever dwell on ifs and buts of history but what eventually matters is he delivered us from the throes of economic disaster. If I am not mistaken Dr Singh was the PM when we had the highest economic growth without imposing popcorn tax, demonetisation, Rs 15,000 crore haircut, Rs 100+/litre of petrol, without devaluing rupee to record low. At least have the heart to give the man some credit though he never thumped a 56-inch chest.
Well, history may or may not have been better. But if you go through history and try to learn from that, india would have become a miserable country. Look, Biden was a silent guy. What happened to America. Gorbachev was a less aggressive guy, which happened to the USSR. EVERY TIME a leader is less aggressive and silent it is always the country THAT HAS ALWAYS GONE DOWN THE DRAIN.
Munnabhai PhD & MONTY AHLUWALIA WERE DIRECTED BY WB to implement its policy to infuse oxygen to ailing Indian economy. Moorakh Ratan RajivPappu openly called him JOKER, Moorakh Vibhushan Rah Ul Pappu tore Munnabhai PhD 's policy documents when he was PM, As PM,Munnabhai couldn't take seat before Bxxxh Sonia Pappu was beseated & Munnabhai PhD failed to act appropriately to counter Pakistani terrorist attack on Mumbai. Still non actors are making him bigger than life character. Sad.
Congress O thought Indira was a gungi Gudia and they can rule using her family. Hoeever she turned to be tiger and destroyrd them. Soniaji took MMS to shine on his limelight but turned out MMS lost all shine and faded the congress irreparably
@@deepakhiremath6171 Yes, Doing a better job, criticizing country criminals and sharing 25k tax yearly(old tax regime) for freebees reservation. Why asshole Gandhi does not remove the caste system? add reservation so caste remains forever. Who creates license raj? Congress. Due to US pressure open the market and then take credit for saving the economy !! from whom? Congress.
Now a days many people know about each and everyone in politics and their doings but can't open the facts in lieu of political threats for their normal lives but The Time Will Never Excuse the Culprits who ever may be
He did defame him. He brought the truth out in the open which was already an open secret. However, it was unethical to have done so when he didn't have the permission of Manmohan Singh.
A parents mistake that costed all the efforts of a maverick person, including the future and today we are on a condolence prayer. Today with their death, only Hnble Mr PC is the last hope in classic leadership lineup. History is full of lessons. RIP
MMS was a good man and an economist. But as economists go, from theory he supported free trade. He failed to understand the importance of manufacturing, science, technology.... he is responsible that he failed to protect and promote Indian manufacturing. MFG as a % of Indian GDP, did not increase. Indian MFG as a % of world's MFG, remains below 2%, despite 10 years of MMS or Modi. Only by creating jobs in industry or MFG, can we lift our people out of poverty. Deng Xiaoping realised it, our leaders do not. Trade and Manufacturing are taxed the same, while the later can create many many more jobs.
MMS should have left after first term as PM. It is always better to go out on a high. Walk away into the sun while you are on top. The lows that came in the second term really hit him and his reputation hard.
DR MMS WAS a great scholar! BEING SACHIN TENDULKAR IS GREAT FOR COUNTRY & CRICKET!! But that didn’t solve Indian cricket woes!! One needed pragmatic people like Saurav Ganguly, MS Dhoni TO TAKE INDIAN cricket to great heights!! Like wise TODAY YOU NEED A leader with a strong pulse of the indian civilization TO solve India’s problems today & in future!! These guys only go by western brainwashing.. and apply western philosophy on a civilization that has stood the test of time.. 5 year old kid teaching 5000 years old Professor!!
Manmohansingh ki aadat ma DMK rjd gandhi khandhan aur bhi neta le go na desh ko luta hai or tha yah barkha usi samay ministry or portfolio dilwana ki dallali bhi karti thi manmohan singh imandaarr tha magar dekhta rehata tha
On one hand you say Manmohan Singh was acting as per the dictats of the family. Then again every body admits his policies turned around India in very difficult times and had both welfare measures and economic progress including all economic pundits and journalists. Most corruption charges could not be proved even after more than 10 yeras of opposition. So what is wrong in giving some credit to the Congress. president.
Narasimha Rao didnt listen to Sonia that is a fact. Hence she gave him cold shoulder. Only bcoz of Narasimha Rao did liberalization happen.
What policies...he oversaw the biggest decade of corruption in independent India. Bombs were going off left right and centre. Pakistan was hitting us both from across the border and from within through its Jihadi proxies. That Italian bar maid did nothing but run the country into the ground. India grew despite the policy paralysis.
There are still so many bakhts of the corrupt family to which "the transfer of power" was given by the British Raj, even if a foreign lady of dubious connections who insulted Narasimha Rao-ji even after his death. Yes, it was PVN Rao that did the liberalization and NOT Moun Singh or Sonia or Rahul.
He was forced to make those changes as the congress' daddy the USSR collapsed and India became bankrupt. India and China were at the same level in 1991 but see what has china become.
This man is responsible for humiliation of Dr. Singh, having him here now is a wrong on many levels. He enabled the BJP to make that insult of a movie about Dr. Singh.
Disgraceful, in my opinion.
Thank you Sanjay for sticking to facts.
Dr Manmohan Singh was a great man.
A great man, a great patriot, a great economist ...yes without any iota of doubt. But a great prime minister ... NO.
Mr Baru and Mr Vinod Rai...what they served to Nation , shud be discussed once...
yes, The 2G spectrum case was a major political scandal in India that involved the allocation of licenses for 2G spectrum, a type of mobile phone radio frequency. The case was investigated by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and resulted in the acquittal of all accused in 2017 by CBI court
Why are you calling this fraud man?
India was forced to open up its economy from the licence Raj and Singh happened to be there when it happened ! Same with Russia and china !
Sorry, Dr Singh was chosen to be there - to guide us through the unchartered territory of a liberalised market-driven free economy. Please don't forget he was an economist, an academician and a fine bureaucrat before he accidentally became a politician.
MMS was also responsible for the high inflation in late 70s. He had a long history of being socialist with high taxation that ruined our economy. The only reason we opened up was because IMF arm twisted us. We had to do it because we had no more than 2 weeks of forex reserves to buy oil. As simple as that. While we all respect him, lets not give extra credit for the opening of economy - we did it because we had to.
That's how exactly it is 🙏
Are we forgetting the fact that Dr Singh laid out the liberalisation road map and guided the policies? Or, do we give credit to IMF for that as well?
@@renukaraj5113 exactly !!!
@@Dogmatix-24that road map would've been thrown into dustbin had there been no PV Narasimha Rao. The only credit he deserves is for Bharath - US civil nuclear deal where he stood up like a rock against all odds.
@@spectrum_X If Dr Singh's roadmap were to be thrown into the dustbin would that have been his fault or shortcoming? Maybe his roadmap was good enough for Mr Narasimha Rao to back. Maybe Mr Narasimha Rao was smart enough to recognise a good man who understood economics though not politics. We can forever dwell on ifs and buts of history but what eventually matters is he delivered us from the throes of economic disaster. If I am not mistaken Dr Singh was the PM when we had the highest economic growth without imposing popcorn tax, demonetisation, Rs 15,000 crore haircut, Rs 100+/litre of petrol, without devaluing rupee to record low. At least have the heart to give the man some credit though he never thumped a 56-inch chest.
Is he the only expert to speak on Dr. Singh, or is it because he is controversial and that is why he is always called to give his opinion on Dr Singh
Well, history may or may not have been better. But if you go through history and try to learn from that, india would have become a miserable country. Look, Biden was a silent guy. What happened to America. Gorbachev was a less aggressive guy, which happened to the USSR. EVERY TIME a leader is less aggressive and silent it is always the country THAT HAS ALWAYS GONE DOWN THE DRAIN.
He is culprit
Munnabhai PhD & MONTY AHLUWALIA WERE DIRECTED BY WB to implement its policy to infuse oxygen to ailing Indian economy.
Moorakh Ratan RajivPappu openly called him JOKER,
Moorakh Vibhushan Rah Ul Pappu tore Munnabhai PhD 's policy documents when he was PM,
As PM,Munnabhai couldn't take seat before Bxxxh Sonia Pappu was beseated &
Munnabhai PhD failed to act appropriately to counter Pakistani terrorist attack on Mumbai.
Still non actors are making him bigger than life character.
Sad.
Congress O thought Indira was a gungi Gudia and they can rule using her family. Hoeever she turned to be tiger and destroyrd them. Soniaji took MMS to shine on his limelight but turned out MMS lost all shine and faded the congress irreparably
congress: license Raj to open the market. We save India from ourselves. Pls, thank us. plz. We are not clowns. 😂😂😂😂
So you going around all UA-cam videos spouting this crap? Don't have anything better to do?
@@deepakhiremath6171 Yes, Doing a better job, criticizing country criminals and sharing 25k tax yearly(old tax regime) for freebees reservation. Why asshole Gandhi does not remove the caste system? add reservation so caste remains forever. Who creates license raj? Congress. Due to US pressure open the market and then take credit for saving the economy !! from whom? Congress.
Baru is an oppertunist & confused in his thinking. He to sell his book has adopted to falsehood. Baru also talks a lot of lies.
Now a days many people know about each and everyone in politics and their doings but can't open the facts in lieu of political threats for their normal lives but The Time Will Never Excuse the Culprits who ever may be
They joke about the sinister ways in which the nation was looted- you know what was done; we know what was done
Wish he had become a real PM like PVR
Sorry !!! PM is PM. Lok Sabha or Nominated.
He was the one who defamed sms. History and God will not be kind to him.
He did defame him. He brought the truth out in the open which was already an open secret. However, it was unethical to have done so when he didn't have the permission of Manmohan Singh.
@adityabhatt6746 Truth is a double edged sword. We are petty humans and truth will come out one day and we will be judged by our deeds.
A parents mistake that costed all the efforts of a maverick person, including the future and today we are on a condolence prayer. Today with their death, only Hnble Mr PC is the last hope in classic leadership lineup. History is full of lessons. RIP
Baru betrayed MMS..
How? Because he wrote about those years after he left the job?
Sanjaya Baru has made very important point. Things would have been definitely different, had Dr Manmohan preferred Lok Sabha in 2009 elections.
MMS was a good man and an economist. But as economists go, from theory he supported free trade. He failed to understand the importance of manufacturing, science, technology.... he is responsible that he failed to protect and promote Indian manufacturing. MFG as a % of Indian GDP, did not increase. Indian MFG as a % of world's MFG, remains below 2%, despite 10 years of MMS or Modi. Only by creating jobs in industry or MFG, can we lift our people out of poverty. Deng Xiaoping realised it, our leaders do not. Trade and Manufacturing are taxed the same, while the later can create many many more jobs.
History will not kinder to Sanjay Baru. You haven’t left no stone to tarnish Mr Singh image.
😮no comment😮😮😮😮
MMS should have left after first term as PM. It is always better to go out on a high. Walk away into the sun while you are on top. The lows that came in the second term really hit him and his reputation hard.
DR MMS WAS a great scholar! BEING SACHIN TENDULKAR IS GREAT FOR COUNTRY & CRICKET!! But that didn’t solve
Indian cricket woes!! One needed pragmatic people like Saurav Ganguly, MS Dhoni TO TAKE INDIAN cricket to great heights!! Like wise TODAY YOU NEED A leader with a strong pulse of the indian civilization TO solve India’s problems today & in future!!
These guys only go by western brainwashing.. and apply western philosophy on a civilization that has stood the test of time..
5 year old kid teaching 5000 years old Professor!!
Rip Dr Manmohan Singh 🙏
The last gentleman in Indian politics.
And that is all he was.
@@Dogmatix-24 he was like ostrich hiding his head,when upa allies were looting India.
Country is not dependent on one individual. It will move on
No one depended on him, he was guided and supported by the late PV, so he was successful
😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮 2:40
India witnessed galloping inflation in his time.
MMS and Sail Singh were accidental PM and President of India and both lowered the dignity of their position by acting like slaves of Gandhi family
Jail singh
Weakest PM of India
History would have been different had Nehru not being the prime minister,
Manmohansingh ki aadat ma DMK rjd gandhi khandhan aur bhi neta le go na desh ko luta hai or tha yah barkha usi samay ministry or portfolio dilwana ki dallali bhi karti thi manmohan singh imandaarr tha magar dekhta rehata tha
Yes if he would have been alive, India would have been officially named ....istan....