Came here from Jungkook’s live on 18th December 2024. Thank you Jungkook for singing this song so beautifully and introducing ARMY to this amazing song. Thank you Park Hyo Shin for this masterpiece. Love from an ARMY 💜
@catherinewanjiru427 JK & Jimin sing it a lot. It's one of their favorites. They really love ballads. When Army asked them what songs they like to sing at karaoke, JK said, "It's a ballad for us." They usually shut the place down & go after hours so they can sing to their hearts' content. Wait staff gets a free concert.
I am also Army💜, I came here also after Jungkook's live. I needed to know the words to this beautiful song. I cried when JK sang it, but didn't know why? Now I know why, thank you for sharing this song JK. Thank you for making a beautiful song Mr. Park Hyo Shin🥰❤💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Oh wow. Now that I read it in English my heart broke even more. You can love someone so much that it so hard to get them out of your memory. 😢. This song is so beautiful and so soulful. ❤❤❤❤
این ترانه خیلی به قلبم فشار میاره😢 به یاد اولین عشقم که به هم نرسیدیم❤ چرا اشک از چشمانم سرازیر میشه هر موقع این آهنگ خداحافظی رو میشنوم؟؟؟؟؟؟؟ چون هنوز عشق اول را فراموش نکردم😔😢
This song to me represents myself letting go of an impossible love I have, no matter how hard decisions are, always take the best realistic choice. Don’t fight for the impossible.
Does this have to do with loosing his friend Park Yong Ha about 10 yrs ago. Meaning he is now going to go on with his life and have closer finally and only think of the the good memories? I would really like to have your interpretation. I just found him and his friend about a month ago and cannot get over hthe spectacular talent of his and his friend was also very talented. My heart breaks for both of them. May God Bless him and keep him safe. Regards from the USA.💖💖💖💖💖
This is the saddest song I’ve heard but it’s beautiful sung in another language COs you can tell and feel pain. I love this song since I watched I can see your voice?. Beautiful
멀어져 가는 오후를 바라보다 스쳐 지나가 버린 그때 생각이나 기억 모퉁이에 적혀 있던 네가 지금 여기에 있다 이젠 멈춰버린 화면 속에서 내게 여름처럼 웃고 있는 너 어쩌면 이번이 마지막 Goodbye 오래 머물러 주어서 고마워 이 말이 뭐라고 그렇게 어려웠을까 이제 Goodbye 우린 다른 꿈을 찾고 있던 거야 아주 어린 날 놀던 숨바꼭질처럼 해가 저물도록 혼자 남은 내가 지금 여기에 있다 이미 멈춰버린 화면 속에서 내게 여름처럼 웃고 있는 너 어쩌면 이번이 마지막 Goodbye 오래 머물러 주어서 고마워 이 말이 뭐라고 이렇게 힘들었을까 손에 꼭 쥐었던 너와의 Goodbye 끝내 참지 못한 눈물이 나 어쩌면 오늘이 마지막 Goodbye 함께 했던 모든 날이 좋았어 이 말이 뭐라고 그렇게 어려웠을까 이제 Goodbye Goodbye
Fyi this song is made up of 50ish ensembles arranged by JJI (he's also on piano) so it is definitely not some cheap set up. m2.melon.com/album/detail.htm?albumId=10281385
![[MV] Park Hyo Shin(박효신) _ Goodbye(굿바이)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Xp8Ep1W-azw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MV] Park Hyo Shin(박효신) _ Goodbye(굿바이)](/img/tr.png)
Came here from Jungkook’s live on 18th December 2024. Thank you Jungkook for singing this song so beautifully and introducing ARMY to this amazing song. Thank you Park Hyo Shin for this masterpiece. Love from an ARMY 💜
Why does it feel like a break-up song. I'm sad😢😢😢
@ it is indeed a breakup song.
Same here
@catherinewanjiru427 JK & Jimin sing it a lot. It's one of their favorites. They really love ballads. When Army asked them what songs they like to sing at karaoke, JK said, "It's a ballad for us." They usually shut the place down & go after hours so they can sing to their hearts' content. Wait staff gets a free concert.
@ that’s so sweet to know. Could you tell me when did JK say that “it’s a ballad for us”? I would like to watch that interview 🥺💜
I just discovered this young man browsing through UA-cam. Oh my God what a beautiful, beautiful voice. I’m in love with him now.
I am also Army💜, I came here also after Jungkook's live. I needed to know the words to this beautiful song. I cried when JK sang it, but didn't know why? Now I know why, thank you for sharing this song JK. Thank you for making a beautiful song Mr. Park Hyo Shin🥰❤💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Oh wow. Now that I read it in English my heart broke even more.
You can love someone so much that it so hard to get them out of your memory. 😢. This song is so beautiful and so soulful. ❤❤❤❤
I can’t stop listening to this song. It’s absolutely amazing. I just love is voice. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I came here after JUNGKOOK weverse live. And omg this song is so beautiful and made me cry 💔
Que divino!!! Emocionada com essa voz que musica linda!
너무 좋으시다 정국이 덕에 좋은 곡 하나 더 알게 됐네요
스트레스받을때 대장님 노래들으면
힐링이되서 너무좋네요.박효신대장님.새해복많이받으시고 좋은노래작품으로 팬옆에 와줬으면 해요
되서 ㄴㄴ 돼서 ㅇㅇ
진짜...첫소절부터 이미 내 고막은 박수침
에바
@@exit8489 이윽고 같은 느낌
진짜 감성...목소리....빠져든다...
여름처럼 웃고있는 너..라는 문장..너무좋으네요
این ترانه خیلی به قلبم فشار میاره😢 به یاد اولین عشقم که به هم نرسیدیم❤ چرا اشک از چشمانم سرازیر میشه هر موقع این آهنگ خداحافظی رو میشنوم؟؟؟؟؟؟؟ چون هنوز عشق اول را فراموش نکردم😔😢
저녁이라는 말을 오후가 멀어져 간다고 표현하다니 너무 이쁘다 이별을 이렇게 예쁘게 표현하다니 :)
박효"신"
이름만으로도 한편의 드라마고 예술이며 인생이다
울게만드소서, 영원히 함께해주소서
오 거룩하도다 박효 '신'
역시 박효신의 노래에는 모든가사가 감명적이다...
2년뒤 이댓글은 베댓이 됩니다..
1년뒤 이댓글은 배댓이 됩니다
ㅇㄷ
좋은 말이지만 국어공부좀 더 하셨으면 좋겠다..
@@qqqqqqqq-r4o ㅎㄷㄷ
One of the most beautiful singers! So talented. Such emotion.
Тази песен докосва сърцето, а изпълнението и е фантастично! Затваряш очи и попадаш в рая.
박효신의 목소리를 들을 수 있는 청각이 있음에 감사하고,
노래의 가사를 번역 과정 없이 들을 수 있는 한국인임에 두 번 감사하다.
no joke i listened to this song for a month straight when it just came out last year , and i still do , i memorized all the lyrics
I love how he sings about life and the emotions he puts in , we all can identify us with his songs somehow.
언제나 옳다~
노래가 엄청 좋은 노래인 건 알고있었지만 , 풍류대장에서 이아진 님이 부른 것 보고나서
여운이 너무 남아 , 다시왔는데 너무 슬프네요ㅠ 좋다 진심
진심슬픈노래 맞네요 ㅠ ㅠ
@@건방진라이언 맞아요ㅠㅠ 거의 들을때마다 눈물나네요ㅜ
이노래는 감상하기엔 완벽하지만
부르기엔 너무 힘들다
박효신 사랑해요!!!!!!!♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
첫소절 가사가 왜이리 뭉클하지
"멀어져 가는 오후를 바라보다
스쳐 지나가버린 그때 생각이나"
I absolutely adore, love and cherish this amazing beautiful ballad!!!!!❤❤❤
Thank You. Now I understand ❤️. Love this song. Park hyo shin👑
참 좋다 가사도 이쁘다
모든 사람들이 인정하는 가수의 경지를 뛰어넘은 예술가 박효신
Thank you so much for the English translation!
이 노래 우리집 강아지가 무지개다리로 떠났을 때 정말 많이 들었던 노래인데 오랜만에 들으니까 그때가 생각난다 널 잃고 사무치게 힘들던 그 가을
I had no regret clicking on this while cruising through paul kim’s covers .. Park Hyo Shin is crazy gooooooddddd.. and this song... omg.. the feels 😍
효신최고
This song to me represents myself letting go of an impossible love I have, no matter how hard decisions are, always take the best realistic choice. Don’t fight for the impossible.
We are stupid so fight for the impossible especially for love😂😂
@@user-cs8ny7wo3x ur cringe
잊지 못할 첫사랑의 기억
Thank you so much for the translations, it's very beautiful.
After reading the lyrics i can say that i knew in my heart this song was special, so emotional and beautiful.
Does this have to do with loosing his friend Park Yong Ha about 10 yrs ago. Meaning he is now going to go on with his life and have closer finally and only think of the the good memories? I would really like to have your interpretation. I just found him and his friend about a month ago and cannot get over hthe spectacular talent of his and his friend was also very talented. My heart breaks for both of them. May God Bless him and keep him safe. Regards from the USA.💖💖💖💖💖
가사가 미침
가사도 가수도 노래도 완벽... 너무 신기하다.
finally I can understand all the lyrics that he try to convey it 😌❤️
감사해요❤❤ 정말 이노래를 많은 분들이 들으셨으면 좋겠네요
Que voz maravilhosa!
와웅 가사도 좋고 노래 너무 좋은거 아닙니까!
So many people like this song now it's crazy!🌸🌸🥺
왜영어로쓰셈?
This is the saddest song I’ve heard but it’s beautiful sung in another language COs you can tell and feel pain. I love this song since I watched I can see your voice?. Beautiful
Love this song Your voice is outstanding and Your expression You feel the song the words the tears Thank You Park Hyo Shin
2022년7월인데 유튜브 알고리즘... 고맙다... 또 박효신 노래 계속듣게 해줘서...
박효신 사랑해ㅠㅠ❤️
박효신 선생님은 미첬어요
아 몰라 그냥 미첬어요
대단해요
오늘 눈물 흘립니다
감사합니다
대단해요
감동입니다
감사합니다
im almost crying to hear this song . . . its hurts 😭😭😭😭
Beautiful song with Amazing singer. ♡
Finally.. I understand the song and it made me love it more.. 😘😘❤️👍
Thank you x
너무 좋다..
멀어져 가는 오후를 바라보다
스쳐 지나가 버린 그때 생각이나
기억 모퉁이에 적혀 있던 네가
지금 여기에 있다
이젠 멈춰버린 화면 속에서
내게 여름처럼 웃고 있는 너
어쩌면 이번이 마지막 Goodbye
오래 머물러 주어서 고마워
이 말이 뭐라고 그렇게 어려웠을까
이제 Goodbye
우린 다른 꿈을 찾고 있던 거야
아주 어린 날 놀던 숨바꼭질처럼
해가 저물도록 혼자 남은 내가
지금 여기에 있다
이미 멈춰버린 화면 속에서
내게 여름처럼 웃고 있는 너
어쩌면 이번이 마지막 Goodbye
오래 머물러 주어서 고마워
이 말이 뭐라고 이렇게 힘들었을까
손에 꼭 쥐었던 너와의 Goodbye
끝내 참지 못한 눈물이 나
어쩌면 오늘이 마지막 Goodbye
함께 했던 모든 날이 좋았어
이 말이 뭐라고 그렇게 어려웠을까
이제 Goodbye
Goodbye
박효신. 나얼의 노래는 성스럽다.
박효신의늪에빠지게된입덕곡
미정미박포에버
항상 마음의 위로가 필요할 때 듣는 노래
감사합니다 대장님❤
나무 올림.
i cried in my first listen... i cried harder while reading the lyrics...
He has so many songs like this! lmk if you wanna know more.
@@suavesweett thanks! but I've already listened to all his songs 🥰 so many good songs!
@@leyn4822 Once you hear one you cant stop!
@@suavesweett so true! i love Goodbye so much i have to listen to his whole discography.
@@leyn4822 For me I love "Memories resemble love" sm
👍👍👏👏 무슨 말이 필요한가요...
Lyrics soo sad yet BEAUTIFUL, meaningful voice expressing perfectly each other soo well I can listen forever this song from PHS 💗🦚💗🤟🌟🌟🌟🌟🔥
How did Park Hyo Shin take my entire soul for 4:28 than bring back to life at the same time singing to me goodbye. I can’t even....wow
추억속에 빠져든다 13년째 팬인데 13년째 귀가 호강중 물론 앞으로도 ~ 🙂
당신의 노래는 슬프고 미워할 수 없습니다
고맙습니다
Thank you so much!
키야 이래야 가수지
❤Never disappoints. Love to listen 🎶 🎶
박 효 신 💖
미친 첫소절에 기절했다가 금방 깼네ㅜㅜ
멜로디도 멜로디지만 가사가 너무 좋다...
노래 참 좋다
보이스 쥑이네♡
2:43
마음이 내는 소리.
I fell asleep last night listening to his song one hour play. 😘😘
Maravilhoso... linda música amoooo!!
대장님사랑해요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ❤️❤️❤️❤️
좋은노래 감사합니다 박효신 정재일 형님
❤linda linda esta música
이분이 어떻게 40살이지ㅋㅋㅋㅋ진짜 골때리네
진짜 신이군요
음색이 두꺼웠을때도 매력적이였는데 지금은 초월되셨음
? ㄹㅇ? 30대 초중반인 줄
We are all present because jk and Jimi sings and harmonized in the shower,just imagine them singing like they did in "are you sure''
Beautiful...❤️ I like the MV better. ⭐️
Love you always PHS ❤
I'm so glad I stumbled onto this
I came here from Hyungwon V Live.
What a beautiful song.
He has a fantastic voice and he deserves much better backing music. This especially was clearly made on a synthesizer, and not a real piano.
Fyi this song is made up of 50ish ensembles arranged by JJI (he's also on piano) so it is definitely not some cheap set up. m2.melon.com/album/detail.htm?albumId=10281385
love
Thank you for posting this, translations etc. He is so good......outstanding. A celectial song 🙏💖🙏
Park hyo shin ❤️
i come here after i see park hyung shik cover in hes instagram . 💖
대장님을 국보로 지정해주세요 ㅜㅜㅜ 진짜 목소리 미쳤어 ㅜㅜ
겨울이면 찾아와요
Gracias ^^
Feels like if i were to drive off a cliff and this would be the last song i would play on the way. And theres peace and a tranquility to it
가수가 발성 바꾸는거 진짜 힘들다고 하던데..
파도같은 현악기들 소리가 너무 감미로운 노래
훌륭한
잘듣고
갑니다
사랑하는 사람을 잃거나 이별한 사람들을 위로할수 있는 곡입니다.