Many people are misunderstanding the title of this talk, and so are thinking: "Misleading title". But why? Just think more carefully about it. He was talking about: - when you're being "taught" in a classroom, - you, as a student, - tend to having a hard time capturing most of the learning material/content that the lecturer is trying to teach you. While on the other hand, if you’re being taught on a more thoughtful and updated, scientifically proven way, along with current technological devices and the power of the Internet and its continuously evolving apps and websites and social-networks, and so on, you would be able to be more effectively memorize what you’ll need to remember and understand about each lesson’s content and reasons of why you need to “know” those lesson in the first place. This is why this talk is being titled: "The more you're taught, the less you know", - simply because you as a student tend to quickly forget what the teacher has "taught" you. So, it is simply outdated to learn the old-fashioned way. Sure the title could have been more informatively titled like: “The more you’re taught the old-fashioned way, the less you’ll remember”.
Such an amazing topic to explore. I love using phones and other technology in my classroom. However, I often tell my students that although they have the entire world at their fingertips... we are now drowning in information. It is important to teach the students how to navigate the system and utilize it properly, especially if we are going to use it as an educational tool.
that's why I only study what matters most to me. as a student I find it that I have to question the way I learn to see if there is a better way because I only get one life and I better not waste it
I dropped out of school because it was boring and they didn't teach or care what I wanted to learn, that's the problem with education. My teaches made me feel like what I thought didn't matter and they never ever asked me what I wanted to learn.
The one thing of value I have taken from this video is; "The perpetually sought after solutions to our problems is the continual posting of videos such as these". There is no solution. We are all human flesh and ultimately fail and die!! The question is?? What's next?
The problem is monetization. Corporations and institutions don't want any part of this way of thinking. Big business and the corporate machine have a stranglehold on politics and law, and it will do everything in it's power to keep it that way. Large entities are run by people who are so far removed from blame by layers of hierarchy that it's nearly impossible to hold them accountable. All life is somewhat selfish, otherwise it wouldn't be successful.
First, circumscribing public transportation as a condition of poverty misunderstands why public transportation is a social benefit. It is a communal equalizer that reduces pollution while serving the immediate environment. Also, if you're going to cite quantities of information possible to access with cell phones and gadgets, then dismissing the very real, cumulative effect of books and formal education upon our culture is counterintuitive. Of course, access to gadgets could very well allow a person to learn Urdu, master finance and open them up to a world of disparate opinions, but what is more likely is that same person will be too distracted to dedicate themselves to another language, forget why anyone else's opinion matters and find comfort in whatever fad tickles their notion of humor at that time. The possibilities may be endless, but the outcomes are quite easily predicted.
+Mitchel Knight I disagree. He sees cell phones as a tool of education, a way to help students learn in a setting more productive than a typical lecture. Who knows what merits or motivation a student has to learn, and to keep themselves from distraction. There is structure to education, no matter what method the teacher may choose to implement it. You seem to be questioning the dedication of the student, not the point the speaker is trying to make.
I'm a student, and even though I agree that modern class room is not the way to go, I dont really think that social network teaching is the solution, but maybe I'm just too conservative, I really don't know.
Zudma Onyx I think I agree with you, and I'm a somewhat liberal person. I feel that in some cases people have bounced back too hard off the 'dusty, old professor' stereotype so are desperately trying things that don't actually work but at least look 'with the times'. Like I can't really imagine applying some of what he said to a subject like chemistry in the same way you could with studying social injustice. I would consider the new tactic of the speaker in this video to be similar to the physics trip my secondary school used to have - we went to Chessington because roller coasters are forces and motion in action. Problem was, it looked like new, innovative education, but was in fact another gimmick and nobody learnt anything. But I also feel the current system is not the way to go.
Im doing a ted-athon (marathon binge watching ted talks ) with breaks of course , i play games pr watche netflix in between . I want to see how many ted talks i can watche in one month , or 6 month . Recently my average had been 3 ted talks per day but i intend to increase the daily amout . Any how i made a playlist on my channel so you can join me and watch them too ( or just half of them if you want skipping a few ). I am having fun watching this video because im learning new things and i hope you are having fun as well
Stop lecturing and let students' learn is essentially the message in this video. Education is not a spectator's sport. Listening to a teacher wax lyrical is BORING. UA-cam can do that so you don't have to. I know, it's a bitter pill to swallow. It is sad to see how some educators are so close minded. Education is supposed to broaden the mind. 🤔 In reality, it has become a big game of trivial pursuit, where all need to do is regurgitate "knowledge" so you can "pass the test" and reach the next level. No learning involved, just a good memory. It's the 21st century. Which century are you teaching your students for?
Got it. School is not for everyone/ some do like to attend/ unschooling or homeschool are other options/ follow your instincts/ etc, etc...👍🍺 I brought up unschooling because that's what brought me to this video
Given that the presenter advocates for less lecturing, it would have been more effective for his speech to be much shorter, so to actively demonstrate his points.
He never even comes close to establishing reasons to believe the idea in the title. Why do these TedX presenters think they need title's that are either hyperbole or outright lies? I am glad I never paid to be educated by this guy.
CALM DOWN .......** This man complained that the lecture is the old style of our ancestors...way of teaching and now ...still doing that way . But LET ME SAY SOMETHING. BECAUSE OF THOSE CRUCIAL FOUNDATIONS .... ....WE CAN BE HERE. THOSE ARE NOT JUST LECTURES AS YOU SAID .......BUT THATS ONE WAY OF THE COMMUNICATION BETWEEN HUMAN AND HUMAN WHICH ARE WARMTH WITH PASSION. BE GRATEFUl. BEFORE THAT , HE SHOULD LEARN THE MANNER OF HOW TO MAKE A SPEECH IN THE PUBLIC.HAVE MANNER . WHEN WEARING FORMAL ......AT LEAST IT CAN SHOW RESPECT TO THE WATCHERS AND LISTENERS,
Now, please, stop screaming. He never insulted the public. He's not trying to undermine the education system. He's a professor himself. He shared points, opinions and studies on why the lecture system is, and was, an inefficient method when it comes to make students learn. You heard him: "In a study of a lecture based course those who tab the course had no significant difference in knowledge than those who never took the course at all, after three years". A student loan of thousands of dollars, and students are basically learning nothing. And, I can tell you, this is not the first study I met with this kind of outcome. I think we can both agree that this is not okay.
I disagree with the statement, "The more you're taught, the less you know" wholeheartedly. It's not how much you know, it's HOW you learned it. Certainly not learning much from this lecture!
Presenter's theme was non sequitur from title. Yeah, that social justice thing has been a little overdone, yeah. So many people have gotten sucked down that rabbit hole. When the eternally offended class can show some self control we can get back to those that have helping those that have less, or nothing. Obama created this class warfare, libs and lefties have to own it. It has been no good but rather unleashed idiocy. Anyway, there is a cost factor with developing and especially delivering new modes of learning. How about people that actually are out there doing their craft / trade become teachers. When you have a class of "professional" teachers they just feed upon their echo chamber and you get the mess education is in, today. Way too many $$ for poor results. Of course there are pockets of excellence, but their is much wasted $$. Oh, that's right, we are a society that kills babies - ones that have emerged from the mother - and chop them to pieces. We have 1/2 society warring for that right - ingnoring reality. Sorry, you lose - and you call it "women's health." Yes, that's our society. The good - all was build-up until 15:55 - the mobile part. Education anywher, anytime. The presenter did have a great perspective of mobile - engage it, somehow - we are not there yet. But, no real world examples. Still none in Q3 2018. Teaching industry should be investigated.
I really feel sorry for you. Sorry that you had to sit in classes that you didn't want to take. You can lead a student to class, but you can't make him thirsty to learn. But, when the combo of a good teacher and a thirsty student come together, magic happens. I'm sorry you missed out on that.
Many people are misunderstanding the title of this talk, and so are thinking: "Misleading title". But why? Just think more carefully about it. He was talking about: - when you're being "taught" in a classroom, - you, as a student, - tend to having a hard time capturing most of the learning material/content that the lecturer is trying to teach you. While on the other hand, if you’re being taught on a more thoughtful and updated, scientifically proven way, along with current technological devices and the power of the Internet and its continuously evolving apps and websites and social-networks, and so on, you would be able to be more effectively memorize what you’ll need to remember and understand about each lesson’s content and reasons of why you need to “know” those lesson in the first place.
This is why this talk is being titled: "The more you're taught, the less you know", - simply because you as a student tend to quickly forget what the teacher has "taught" you. So, it is simply outdated to learn the old-fashioned way. Sure the title could have been more informatively titled like: “The more you’re taught the old-fashioned way, the less you’ll remember”.
George Galamb .. Students will forget what you taught them, but they will never forget how you treated them. A lot of teachers forget this.
So glad to have Dr. Baldridge as a professor. His classes are absolutely wonderful.
Excellent talk Stephen.
We're made to move. To learn on the move. Adapt/evolve/be water.
Added to my everyday listening playlist.
Such an amazing topic to explore. I love using phones and other technology in my classroom.
However, I often tell my students that although they have the entire world at their fingertips... we are now drowning in information. It is important to teach the students how to navigate the system and utilize it properly, especially if we are going to use it as an educational tool.
that's why I only study what matters most to me. as a student I find it that I have to question the way I learn to see if there is a better way because I only get one life and I better not waste it
I dropped out of school because it was boring and they didn't teach or care what I wanted to learn, that's the problem with education.
My teaches made me feel like what I thought didn't matter and they never ever asked me what I wanted to learn.
Great talk, misleading title..
The one thing of value I have taken from this video is; "The perpetually sought after solutions to our problems is the continual posting of videos such as these".
There is no solution. We are all human flesh and ultimately fail and die!! The question is??
What's next?
Wish more people were watching this...
Amazing idea but i don't see any of this stuff actually happening on platforms like instagram!
The problem is monetization. Corporations and institutions don't want any part of this way of thinking. Big business and the corporate machine have a stranglehold on politics and law, and it will do everything in it's power to keep it that way. Large entities are run by people who are so far removed from blame by layers of hierarchy that it's nearly impossible to hold them accountable. All life is somewhat selfish, otherwise it wouldn't be successful.
bro that's my dad. good job dad
Amazing talk and thank you so much!!
First, circumscribing public transportation as a condition of poverty misunderstands why public transportation is a social benefit. It is a communal equalizer that reduces pollution while serving the immediate environment.
Also, if you're going to cite quantities of information possible to access with cell phones and gadgets, then dismissing the very real, cumulative effect of books and formal education upon our culture is counterintuitive. Of course, access to gadgets could very well allow a person to learn Urdu, master finance and open them up to a world of disparate opinions, but what is more likely is that same person will be too distracted to dedicate themselves to another language, forget why anyone else's opinion matters and find comfort in whatever fad tickles their notion of humor at that time. The possibilities may be endless, but the outcomes are quite easily predicted.
+Mitchel Knight I disagree. He sees cell phones as a tool of education, a way to help students learn in a setting more productive than a typical lecture. Who knows what merits or motivation a student has to learn, and to keep themselves from distraction. There is structure to education, no matter what method the teacher may choose to implement it. You seem to be questioning the dedication of the student, not the point the speaker is trying to make.
Thanks
I'm a student, and even though I agree that modern class room is not the way to go, I dont really think that social network teaching is the solution, but maybe I'm just too conservative, I really don't know.
Zudma Onyx I think I agree with you, and I'm a somewhat liberal person. I feel that in some cases people have bounced back too hard off the 'dusty, old professor' stereotype so are desperately trying things that don't actually work but at least look 'with the times'. Like I can't really imagine applying some of what he said to a subject like chemistry in the same way you could with studying social injustice. I would consider the new tactic of the speaker in this video to be similar to the physics trip my secondary school used to have - we went to Chessington because roller coasters are forces and motion in action. Problem was, it looked like new, innovative education, but was in fact another gimmick and nobody learnt anything. But I also feel the current system is not the way to go.
this is so underrated
trying to keep his student awake 1:53
This isn't the worst TED Talk of all time, but it's in the running.
yes! thank you
lectures are teachers talking _at_ students, not _with_ them.
Loved it!!!
Thank you very much great job wonderful teacher شكرا جزيلا لك يا استاذ انت رائع
Im doing a ted-athon (marathon binge watching ted talks ) with breaks of course , i play games pr watche netflix in between . I want to see how many ted talks i can watche in one month , or 6 month . Recently my average had been 3 ted talks per day but i intend to increase the daily amout . Any how i made a playlist on my channel so you can join me and watch them too ( or just half of them if you want skipping a few ). I am having fun watching this video because im learning new things and i hope you are having fun as well
public transportation in Ecuador:
text1: everyone is looking at me.
text2:Wait, they are looking at my phone
-----*no more messages*-----
Hahahaha [as in LOLEST]
Africans using public transport in some of our cities feel you on this one
The more you know, the more you know how little you really know.
So true
Stop lecturing and let students' learn is essentially the message in this video. Education is not a spectator's sport. Listening to a teacher wax lyrical is BORING. UA-cam can do that so you don't have to. I know, it's a bitter pill to swallow. It is sad to see how some educators are so close minded. Education is supposed to broaden the mind. 🤔 In reality, it has become a big game of trivial pursuit, where all need to do is regurgitate "knowledge" so you can "pass the test" and reach the next level. No learning involved, just a good memory. It's the 21st century. Which century are you teaching your students for?
19th century
19th century, just in case someone discovers time travel
watching this to get some inspiration for my ToK essay lmao
I was with him all the way up until he started bashing white males and praising social justice.
+Anthony Voskuhl That and boundaries. Do you really want students to have access to you on facebook?
Anthony Voskuhl how does he bash white males?
Yeah, God forbid we try to understand other people's struggles. Somebody missed the point of the entire talk: education.
Does the talk in anyway related to the title? 🙄
Got it. School is not for everyone/ some do like to attend/ unschooling or homeschool are other options/ follow your instincts/ etc, etc...👍🍺
I brought up unschooling because that's what brought me to this video
💯 Thanks for the mention! 👍
i wish you didnt yell like Anthony Robbins but i agree becoz i already study like this, dynamic and organic ! Cheers.
I think he is right in some points but I find his loud voice disturbing.
Your rose pic is disturbing
Mark Rogers Why? Your picture could be disturbing too. What do you associate with roses???
@@sandracarli1110 dear Sandra,
Your Mom.
Given that the presenter advocates for less lecturing, it would have been more effective for his speech to be much shorter, so to actively demonstrate his points.
He never even comes close to establishing reasons to believe the idea in the title. Why do these TedX presenters think they need title's that are either hyperbole or outright lies? I am glad I never paid to be educated by this guy.
+John Hawkins probably the same psychological reason newspapers/sites and others use catchy titles and why click-bait exists.
🤦♂️
Oh, so that's why we have notebooks, but what's the point we already have our own books...
13:19 "Interesting we just SEEN ..." My God, who is talking about education here?
Shut your face you idiot moron
Awesome boss I watches onl 2 mins
he is shouting because he is not saying anything interesting or insprational
+cat cin Then shouldn't you be shouting too?
+Dork Knight LEMONS!
CALM DOWN .......** This man complained that the lecture is the old style of our ancestors...way of teaching and now ...still doing that way .
But LET ME SAY SOMETHING. BECAUSE OF THOSE CRUCIAL FOUNDATIONS .... ....WE CAN BE HERE.
THOSE ARE NOT JUST LECTURES AS YOU SAID .......BUT THATS ONE WAY OF THE COMMUNICATION BETWEEN HUMAN AND HUMAN WHICH ARE WARMTH WITH PASSION.
BE GRATEFUl.
BEFORE THAT , HE SHOULD LEARN THE MANNER OF HOW TO MAKE A SPEECH IN THE PUBLIC.HAVE MANNER .
WHEN WEARING FORMAL ......AT LEAST IT CAN SHOW RESPECT TO THE WATCHERS AND LISTENERS,
Now, please, stop screaming.
He never insulted the public. He's not trying to undermine the education system. He's a professor himself. He shared points, opinions and studies on why the lecture system is, and was, an inefficient method when it comes to make students learn.
You heard him: "In a study of a lecture based course those who tab the course had no significant difference in knowledge than those who never took the course at all, after three years". A student loan of thousands of dollars, and students are basically learning nothing. And, I can tell you, this is not the first study I met with this kind of outcome. I think we can both agree that this is not okay.
I disagree with the statement, "The more you're taught, the less you know" wholeheartedly. It's not how much you know, it's HOW you learned it. Certainly not learning much from this lecture!
He sounds like Rick Sanchez.
"Interesting we just SEEN ..." My God, who is talking about education here?
😱😱😱
Presenter's theme was non sequitur from title.
Yeah, that social justice thing has been a little overdone, yeah. So many people have gotten sucked down that rabbit hole. When the eternally offended class can show some self control we can get back to those that have helping those that have less, or nothing. Obama created this class warfare, libs and lefties have to own it. It has been no good but rather unleashed idiocy.
Anyway, there is a cost factor with developing and especially delivering new modes of learning.
How about people that actually are out there doing their craft / trade become teachers.
When you have a class of "professional" teachers they just feed upon their echo chamber and you get the mess education is in, today.
Way too many $$ for poor results. Of course there are pockets of excellence, but their is much wasted $$.
Oh, that's right, we are a society that kills babies - ones that have emerged from the mother - and chop them to pieces. We have 1/2 society warring for that right - ingnoring reality.
Sorry, you lose - and you call it "women's health."
Yes, that's our society.
The good - all was build-up until 15:55 - the mobile part. Education anywher, anytime. The presenter did have a great perspective of mobile - engage it, somehow - we are not there yet.
But, no real world examples. Still none in Q3 2018.
Teaching industry should be investigated.
Ummm.....
Your Lecturing right now.....
Alright I won't go to school and maybe join the circus
misleading title...
I really feel sorry for you. Sorry that you had to sit in classes that you didn't want to take. You can lead a student to class, but you can't make him thirsty to learn. But, when the combo of a good teacher and a thirsty student come together, magic happens. I'm sorry you missed out on that.
"i am a white male, the most privileged" okay bbye
Weak.
Your moms weak
Mark Rogers Your grammar'a weak :D
School is (like) a prison
Schools Are Prisons! search post on unschooling!
Worst mentality I've ever got from a TED talk.
Why is the mentality worse?
This is comedy gone bad.
Lost me when he went woke…!
Uni's are over rated. That's all he needed to say. The more he talked the less I cared.
Man... Cool down and learn how to talk as if you're not on speed...
I'll save you some time professor. Social justice is is theft.
Interesting until he talked about social justice bs.