F&O Taxation Rumors | 30% TDS applicable? | Budget 2024

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 чер 2024
  • This Video is only for educational purpose and Speaker is not liable for any wrong trade taken by viewer. Trading is Very Risky Business and it should only be done with proper Knowledge.
    As 89% of traders loose money as per SEBI Data, I have limited the users from joining my telegram channel any further. A person should 1st learn and then think about trading. So, if someone wants to join my channel, remember I dont have any Holy Grail and I also make losses while trading, I share my experience in my channel. 1st Learn from my free videos on How to Trade Playlist and Option Trading tips playlist and then take Technical Analysis course in my Cosmofeed page and then join the telegram channel for live comments. Comments provided during live market are general expectations with respect to market and no trading advise is provided on our channel.
    app.cosmofeed.com/vig/62e655d...
    In case of any issue related to joining mail at support@cosmofeed.com
    Our Videos on How to Trade: • How to Trade
    Free Candlestick basics in Hindi, Use code AFF100
    bit.ly/3lT7PYm
    Free Technical Analysis Indicators Basics bit.ly/3EO8iU7
    #StockMarkets
    #Nifty
    #BankNifty
    #MondayMarketPrediction
    #StockMarkets
    #Sensex
    #ShareMarketNews
    #Nifty50
    How to earn money
    How to earn money online
    nifty analysis for 24 June Monday
    bank nifty analysis for 24 June Monday
    nifty analysis for 24 June Monday
    bank nifty analysis for 24 June Monday
    bank nifty expiry 24 June Monday
    nifty expiry on 24 June Monday
    bank nifty expiry 27 June Thursday
    NIFTY EXPIRY ON 27 June Thursday
    Nifty outlook for next week
    Bank Nifty outlook for next week
    Nifty outlook for Monday
    Bank Nifty outlook for Monday
    Nifty outlook for tomorrow
    Nifty Forecast
    nifty
    Nifty Nifty
    nifty share price
    bank nifty
    bank nifty share price
    nifty today
    nifty tomorrow
    nifty analysis
    banknifty analysis
    nifty prediction for tomorrow
    nifty analysis for tomorrow
    best trading stock for tomorrow
    nifty target for tomorrow
    nifty prediction
    nifty and bank nifty analysis
    nifty and bank nifty trading levels
    best stocks for intraday trading
    Nifty prediction for today
    Bank Nifty prediction for today
    Bank nifty tomorrow prediction
    nifty tomorrow prediction
    Nifty Bank nifty tomorrow
    Bank Nifty Expiry Prediction
    Nifty Expiry Prediction
    banknifty option for tomorrow
    banknifty intraday trading strategy
    banknifty future strategy
    bank nifty tomorrow prediction
    tomorrow nifty prediction
    tomorrow market prediction
    nifty tomorrow
    nifty trading strategy
    nifty tomorrow prediction
    bank nifty options for tomorrow
    nifty bank nifty tomorrow
    nifty tomorrow
    nifty analysis
    banknifty analysis
    nifty prediction for tomorrow
    nifty analysis for tomorrow
    nifty target for tomorrow
    nifty prediction
    nifty and bank nifty analysis
    nifty and bank nifty trading levels
    best stocks for intraday trading
    Stock Market tomorrow
    Stock Market tomorrow predictions
    share market news today
    share market tomorrow
    Monday market prediction
    24 June bank nifty
    24 June market
    24 June market analysis
    24 June nifty
    monday market prediction
    bank nifty monday prediction
    bank nifty on monday
    bank nifty prediction for monday
    bank nifty tomorrow prediction
    banknifty 24 June
    banknifty options for tomorrow
    market prediction for monday
    market prediction for tomorrow
    monday banknifty prediction
    monday market analysis
    monday market strategy
    monday nifty prediction
    monday nifty target
    monday prediction for stock market
    monday share market prediction
    monday stock market prediction
    monday trading strategy
    next week share market prediction
    nifty 24 June Monday
    nifty 24 June 2024
    nifty 24 June prediction
    nifty analysis
    nifty analysis for next week
    nifty bank nifty tomorrow
    nifty monday
    nifty monday prediction
    nifty next week
    nifty next week prediction
    nifty on monday
    nifty prediction
    nifty prediction for monday
    nifty prediction for next week
    nifty prediction for tomorrow
    nifty today analysis
    nifty tomorrow
    share market monday prediction
    share market on monday
    tomorrow market prediction

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2 тис.

  • @sagarmore1895
    @sagarmore1895 13 днів тому +899

    Agar BJP ne F&O par tax badhaya to NO VOTE FOR BJP

    • @vishalkumarsolanki8055
      @vishalkumarsolanki8055 13 днів тому +30

      Vote tum do na do bhai lekin ab BJP nhi jane wali

    • @AkshayBohra-nn4fj
      @AkshayBohra-nn4fj 13 днів тому +49

      Aur do b. J. P ko vote.. . Is govt ko bs only paisa chahie. Khi se v aaye bs

    • @sagarmore1895
      @sagarmore1895 13 днів тому +48

      @@vishalkumarsolanki8055 bhai hamare yaha abhi vidhansabha election baki hai........dikha denge hum bhi

    • @manas19781
      @manas19781 13 днів тому +18

      @@vishalkumarsolanki8055 satta aise hi jaati hai ek time congress bhi same hi sochti thi

    • @thedoctrader
      @thedoctrader 13 днів тому +33

      Tax ka baar, Agli baar BJP ka haar

  • @afawegzcasdge1270
    @afawegzcasdge1270 12 днів тому +230

    Not making up to a million before retirement is unfulfilled retirement.!! I’m 54 and my wife 50 we are both retired with over $7 million in net worth and no debts. Currently living smart and frugal with our money. No longer putting blames on FED for our misfortunes. Saving and investing lifestyle in the stock and forex market made it possible for us this early, even till now we earn weekly.

    • @afawegzcasdge1270
      @afawegzcasdge1270 11 днів тому +2

      trading should on every wise individuals bucket list. You will be ecstatic of the decision you made today.

    • @OlgaBrynda
      @OlgaBrynda 11 днів тому +1

      so perfect

    • @OlgaBrynda
      @OlgaBrynda 11 днів тому +1

      I got my first house the year I started investing and today networth is over £732k

    • @Cheryl_J_Hughes
      @Cheryl_J_Hughes 11 днів тому +3

      I’m a young mom, I’m really glad to hear your story it inspires me. can you share how you earn weekly.

    • @afawegzcasdge1270
      @afawegzcasdge1270 11 днів тому +2

      Credits to Dylan Kyle Zachary, He saw me through the process.

  • @amitgahlawat6002
    @amitgahlawat6002 12 днів тому +34

    If opposition oppose it ...
    90% traders vote for INDIA alliance
    I'm one of them.

    • @uniqueman-pb5ox
      @uniqueman-pb5ox День тому

      Kya 30% tax Dene ke baad income tax alag se Dena padega kya

  • @lalitkumar9667
    @lalitkumar9667 13 днів тому +16

    Agar f&o par 30 % tax lga ,toh ye samajh ke chlo ki kafi log berojgaar ho jayenge,jaise brokers,and their employee ,CA ,consultants ,and many more like this, yaha desh mein berojgari ke liye government kuch bhi nahi kar Rahi,balki aise raste dhoondh Rahi hai jisse public berojgar ho gaye.

  • @DilipAghav
    @DilipAghav 13 днів тому +307

    I am a profitable FnO trader. I oppose the taxation on FnO income. Govt should close casinos, paan, bidi , cigarate shops also as they are also dangerous to common man. Crap logic given by Govt on FnO taxation.

    • @learndesignwithdev
      @learndesignwithdev 13 днів тому +11

      What Illogical statement. 🤦‍♂️
      Tax on Tobacco products is the biggest earner for the government. 🤣
      Many politicians whether BJP or NCP are Tobacco barons.

    • @munirathnam96
      @munirathnam96 13 днів тому +1

      Lets hold a dharna in front of North block before they implement these stupid taxes

    • @OakSantosh
      @OakSantosh 13 днів тому

      Election is the biggest gamble 😂. Only 1% people winning. In trading at least 11% are winning. Trading is 11times better than election. CAN WE BAN ELECTION?

    • @basantkumarprajapati9794
      @basantkumarprajapati9794 13 днів тому +1

      My gyan Ye govt chal hi gutka bidi sigrate daru ta tax se hai to ye esa kabhi bhi nahi kar sakte hai
      I I'm from cg 2019 me new Stat govt aaya usne bola thha ki ham sare daru bhatti band Kar denge lekin jab corona aaya to unko pata chala ki daru se govt ko kitna profit hota hai isliye jab 2023 me election hua to wo bole ham daru ko band nahi kara sakte hai
      Jaise railway start se hi electrik engin ka infrastructure develop karne laga thha uska fayde ab hua ki sare train electricity se chala raha hai jabki ev bike eV car kyo susseful nahi ho raha hai kyo ki sara infrastructure desel petrol bike kar ke liye develop hai to turant eV har jagah nahi aayega esi tarah daru likker biseness band nahi hoga

    • @ArmyLoverIndia007
      @ArmyLoverIndia007 13 днів тому +1

      Great bhai

  • @krishna07204
    @krishna07204 13 днів тому +114

    sir let's make a community and file a case in supreme court against this rule..

    • @ajaygope3327
      @ajaygope3327 13 днів тому +5

      Great bro 👏

    • @scalpertradingbull
      @scalpertradingbull 13 днів тому +7

      I agree

    • @Vishal77885
      @Vishal77885 13 днів тому +10

      Mai 4 year me ab profit me aaya hu or ab ye🤬😭😭😭❤😡😡😡😡😡😡
      Mere paas ab suicide krne ke alawa kuchh nhi bacha
      Mene govt job chhoda hai iske liye

    • @sumanmodak8410
      @sumanmodak8410 13 днів тому +1

      I agree

    • @enayatshk
      @enayatshk 13 днів тому +2

      Yeah i agree

  • @TheFlyingLots
    @TheFlyingLots 13 днів тому +71

    Aisa Thumbnail डालने में Jiggra लगता है ❤❤💪💪

  • @suwarnadeshmukh9224
    @suwarnadeshmukh9224 12 днів тому +10

    Trading is not a gambling. It requires discipline, knowledge and patience. Its all about managing risk.

    • @onlytolearn
      @onlytolearn 8 днів тому

      that's absolutely misleading. Trading (anything under 1 day timeframe) is 99% Gambling 1% Risk Management. That's why even proper risk management can't guarantee you profits everyday (and overall profitability), in fact with full knowledge discipline and patience you may lose huge chunks of money just because the market doesn't move as per logic based on previous data. Anybody claiming anything else is either ignorant or a fraud. If luck favours you, you can even close your eyes and take a hugely profitable trade 😂

  • @hbknowledgeinhindi8152
    @hbknowledgeinhindi8152 13 днів тому +188

    CA community aage aa kar aandolan karo ham aapke sath ha✌️✌️✌️✌️

    • @learndesignwithdev
      @learndesignwithdev 13 днів тому +8

      CAs are busy counting money thanks to many laws on taxation.
      They'll never protest in the streets. 🤣

    • @jayendrapatil8087
      @jayendrapatil8087 13 днів тому +1

      NOT ONLY CAs Not a single common man in this profession will protest against this

    • @MrH15
      @MrH15 13 днів тому +2

      Brother I also

    • @MrH15
      @MrH15 13 днів тому +2

      Brother I also

    • @nagrarecords5414
      @nagrarecords5414 13 днів тому +1

      I will protest

  • @virendarji6135
    @virendarji6135 13 днів тому +76

    1 week trading strike karni chahiye. no trade no share buy sell nothing for 1 week. 5+ cr people karenge to farak padega. second time jyada tax ka nahi sochegi.

    • @sciencelover3465
      @sciencelover3465 13 днів тому +2

      bro this time..woh exactly yehi chahte hai, ke tum exerpeienced traders market chod do. tabhi to tax badha rahe hain, bycott to woh karwa hi lenge cost bhada ke..unko koi farak na padna, Fii already 5 saal optons mein ulimited money choos chuke hain. har business ka season hota hai, usko over run karke koi fayda nahi. 5 month bhi chod doge to bhi farak nahi padega. They have already booked profits at all time high..SIP, mein retailer already sab kharid chuka hai. Ab chod do...unko kya.. they want it.

    • @sciencelover3465
      @sciencelover3465 13 днів тому +8

      traders union ban na chahiye sabse pehle

    • @ArmyLoverIndia007
      @ArmyLoverIndia007 13 днів тому +2

      Ye baat practical nahi hai
      Kafi mehnat karni hiti hai
      Sare youtuber stock wale mil kar hi ise excute kar sakte Hain

    • @sagarsinghpanwar689
      @sagarsinghpanwar689 13 днів тому +4

      Sell all your shares and cashout kr lena chahiye sabhi paisa taki sare share dhadam se gir jaye, fir bana lene do 5 Trillion economy...

    • @ArmyLoverIndia007
      @ArmyLoverIndia007 13 днів тому +3

      अंधभक्त आपके पीछे पड़ जायेंगे
      इस मैसेज के बाद @virendar

  • @durga677
    @durga677 13 днів тому +5

    4 sall se loose karne ke bad, Health and wealth karab karne ke bad..
    Day and night mahanath karke, abi options sikh ne ke baad..liquidity katham karna..
    Yeh abtak ka, Duniya ka Sabse bada trap hey

  • @sagarupadhayay679
    @sagarupadhayay679 13 днів тому +4

    Manish bhai aap hi bilkul Perfect Knowledge provide karate ho , Alag hi Dikhta he Koi Padha Likha insaan Baat karrha he
    Or Satik knowledge 🎉❤

  • @nilahanwar1456
    @nilahanwar1456 13 днів тому +143

    Many youths who are in stock market because of massive unemployment what does the Govt expect for us. To sell pakoras and panipuri.

    • @learndesignwithdev
      @learndesignwithdev 13 днів тому +7

      You can earn more by selling pakoras and panipuri than stocks. 10 day profit and then stop loss hunting next day in stock market. 😂

    • @SYTRADING
      @SYTRADING 13 днів тому +7

      ​@@learndesignwithdev then you didn't learned enough

    • @learndesignwithdev
      @learndesignwithdev 13 днів тому +2

      @@SYTRADING Nahi bhai. F&O big money ka khel hai. Retailers sirf cash stock buy par focus kare like Warren Buffet.

    • @SYTRADING
      @SYTRADING 13 днів тому +1

      @@learndesignwithdev without two people markets can't run...if there is a buye rhe needs a seller..and vice versa so it's markets it's not big player or small player thing

    • @learndesignwithdev
      @learndesignwithdev 13 днів тому

      @@SYTRADING Well, F&O is only an instrument to hedge share price on daily basis. But people especially retailers have made it a game thanks to mobile app. If you study data, retail can make money in stocks than Options

  • @umeshchaudhari5797
    @umeshchaudhari5797 13 днів тому +76

    यह तो ऐसे हुआ की स्कूल में बच्चों को पढ़ाई नहीं आती तो स्कूल फीस बढ़ावा दो
    वह खुद ही स्कूल छोड़ देगा....

  • @gauravsikri828
    @gauravsikri828 13 днів тому +2

    You are absolutely Right...and your each and every word related to a general category thats is good... But wahi aapki baat... Samajhne wale samjhenge or jo nahi samjhte unka kya hi karein..unko kya hi bolun..

  • @amitgahlawat6002
    @amitgahlawat6002 12 днів тому +2

    12lakh people appear for UPSC exams and vaccancy are 820 to 1000. What is success rate in other exams.
    How many students spends their parents income in lakhs per year on coaching & fooding

  • @Jaihind23575
    @Jaihind23575 13 днів тому +34

    Retailers ka loss नही होगा, क्योंकि वो Trade ही नही करेगा 😂😂🎉🎉

    • @user-zh1pm1zm2x
      @user-zh1pm1zm2x 12 днів тому

      शेयर में ट्रेड करो कौन कह रहा है जुवा आप्शन और फ्यूचर खेलो

    • @nikhilghoshNG7
      @nikhilghoshNG7 10 днів тому

      ​@@user-zh1pm1zm2x are lund jitna kwaab pura krna h na utna paisa ni hota normal retailer paas..... leverage na ke barabar h atleast 50-60 lakh minimum chahiye for starting decent investing

  • @amaterasu0409
    @amaterasu0409 13 днів тому +25

    Agar 400 paar aaya hota toh loss par capital loss tax laga dete

  • @MelissaHobbs-qm8wi
    @MelissaHobbs-qm8wi 13 днів тому +4

    Purchasing a stock may seem straightforward, but selecting the correct stock without a proven strategy can be exceedingly challenging. I've been working on expanding my $210K portfolio for a while, and my primary obstacle is the lack of clear entry and exit strategies. Any advice on this matter would be greatly appreciated.

    • @BrianAlbert-hh3pi
      @BrianAlbert-hh3pi 13 днів тому +3

      The strategies are quite rigorous for the regular-Joe. As a matter of fact, they are mostly successfully carried out by pros who have a great deal of skill and knowledge to pull such trades off.

    • @OliverLiam-px3vx
      @OliverLiam-px3vx 13 днів тому +2

      Even with the right strategies and appropriate assets, investment returns can differ among investors. Recognizing the vital role of experience in investment success is crucial. Personally, I understood this significance and sought guidance from Desiree Ruth Hoffman, significantly growing my account to nearly a million. Strategically withdrawing profits just before the market correction, I'm now seizing buying opportunities once again.

    • @WhitneyRoss-dj4rf
      @WhitneyRoss-dj4rf 13 днів тому +2

      That's incredible! How can I connect with the person who helps you with investments, if you don't mind sharing? I could use some guidance at the moment.

    • @OliverLiam-px3vx
      @OliverLiam-px3vx 13 днів тому +2

      @@WhitneyRoss-dj4rf Desiree Ruth Hoffman is the licensed advisor I use. Just research the name. You’ll find necessary details to work with her correspondence to set up an appointment.

    • @WhitneyRoss-dj4rf
      @WhitneyRoss-dj4rf 13 днів тому +1

      @@OliverLiam-px3vx Thank you for this pointer. It was easy to find your advisor; she seems very proficient and flexible. I booked a call session with her.

  • @vedbratikundu2255
    @vedbratikundu2255 12 днів тому +1

    There are vry few wise people in the market like u who raise their voice for retail trader in the right way. Hatsoff sirji. Take care 😊

  • @ROSSVELT1996
    @ROSSVELT1996 13 днів тому +52

    मेने भी बहुत सारे ट्रेडर्स से बात की तो फिर पता चला की ये ३०% टैक्स की अफवा इकोनॉमिक टाइम्स के एक पत्रकार ने फैलाई थी। तो सभी ट्रेडर्स relax रहो ऐसा कुछ नहीं होने वाला बाकी जो १००० करोड़ से ट्रेडिंग करने वाले अलगो ट्रेडर हे उनपर सरकार एक्स्ट्रा tax लगाने के बारे में सोच रही है।

    • @Rik23358
      @Rik23358 13 днів тому +6

      सर जी जैसे लोगो को वीडियो बनाने का बहाना चाहिए पैसे जो कमाना है एंटी बीजेपी एजेंडा चलाना है फेक न्यूज फैलाना है

    • @sandipkhairnar4710
      @sandipkhairnar4710 13 днів тому +3

      Yes right and tax increase is only in STT on turnover which is 0.05% as of now. If STT increase is 30% in coming budget then it will be 0.065% on turnover. Also it is only for HFT-high frequency trader whose daily turnover or sell value is above 1000 crore in f and o trading 😊😊

    • @anonymouswizard9396
      @anonymouswizard9396 13 днів тому +1

      Yeh chij bhi galat hai

    • @healthproblems858
      @healthproblems858 13 днів тому

      यही मैं सोच रहा है अभी तक अंधभक्त आया नही ,,,,आ गया अंधभक्त,,,अगर टैक्स लगा 30% जो यह बाकचोदी कर रहा है यहां सोच कमेंट में तेरी ??????????कर दूंगा,,,अंधभक्त😮😮😮

    • @radheshyampatel2447
      @radheshyampatel2447 13 днів тому +1

      मैने भी ऐसा ही कुछ सुना है।

  • @raviprakashsingh2115
    @raviprakashsingh2115 13 днів тому +15

    Some persons use fno for hedging purpose only and by default incur losses in fno. This 89% figure include this group of investors also.

  • @voiceagainstinjustice9015
    @voiceagainstinjustice9015 13 днів тому +1

    sir ye equity pr bhi lagega kya??

  • @Manojsingh00099
    @Manojsingh00099 13 днів тому +2

    Bahut acchha vishleshan ❤

  • @trade.for.future
    @trade.for.future 13 днів тому +63

    Gujraat me Mai 4 saal raha hai...gujraat ke har kone kone me sarab milta hai 4× rate pe...

    • @irfanrangrez6947
      @irfanrangrez6947 13 днів тому +3

      Chalti huyi road pr line lgi rhti h sarab k liye koi bolne wala nhi

    • @learndesignwithdev
      @learndesignwithdev 13 днів тому

      Liquor ban is helpful for lowest people in pyramids, like daily wage earners.
      Rich people can always buy their poison. 🤷‍♂️

    • @sjdmyworld2406
      @sjdmyworld2406 13 днів тому

      Sahi bat he I m from Gujarat 😢

  • @patelpiyush5427
    @patelpiyush5427 13 днів тому +29

    Thumbnail badiya hai guru 😂😂

  • @VASOYAMANOJ
    @VASOYAMANOJ 13 днів тому +24

    निकम्मे सरकार खुद तो नौकरी देने लायक नहीं ऊपर से जो लोग घर बैठकर कमा रहें है उसके ऊपर भी बरस गए। मतलब सिर्फ अडानी और अंबानी कमाएगा बाकी सब उसके नीचे काम करेगा और निकम्मे सरकार लोगों के tax के पैसों से ऐश करेगा.
    High level true...

  • @Suvendu6666
    @Suvendu6666 13 днів тому

    Avi kya Cash segment pe trade badega?

  • @manjunathah5857
    @manjunathah5857 13 днів тому +14

    All these are just speculations, do get the market down. They will not do any changes in FNO segment, but they might think about algos, one more best idea is to educate and make it mandatory certification for FNO segment will be an awesome idea

  • @skm841
    @skm841 13 днів тому +49

    Government or jyada kamana chahti hai fno se esi liye tax badhana chahti hai.. kisi ko rokne ka to bahana hai.

    • @dr.taruntyagi4472
      @dr.taruntyagi4472 13 днів тому

      Hum already lose m hai but yeh profit m hai tho tax inko dana hai fat gayi hai inki 😂😂😂

    • @dailyfunnymemes6939
      @dailyfunnymemes6939 13 днів тому +1

      Jo profit me h wo already 30% slab me h.. unko ghanta farak nahi padta Jo already 30% de rahe h

  • @mohideenmb
    @mohideenmb 13 днів тому +1

    Kya baat hai sir, perfect naration. I appreciate you for this detail information.

  • @rZERO_game
    @rZERO_game 13 днів тому +26

    big fish ko rokna hi solution hay, manipulate rokna bhi jaruri hay.

    • @sayaktarafder77
      @sayaktarafder77 13 днів тому +2

      That doesn't mean govt go on and levy 30% tax + tds. Kisi bhi financial market mein more or less manipulation hota, we have to accept that. Regulations are welcome, but unnecessary taxes are a big no...

  • @Bankniftyscalper.30
    @Bankniftyscalper.30 13 днів тому +38

    अगर सरकार का कहना है अब शेयर मार्केट का F nd O जुआ है , तो investment जुआ नि है क्यु वो share market से अलग है क्या और हम सब Traders जुआ खेल रहे हैं., तो जुए को बंद करना चाइये.... हमारे जुए से कमाए गए पैसे से हिस्सा क्यु मांग रहीं हैं.... मतलब ये तो फिर रिश्वत और हफ्ता और घूसखोरी हुई..... 😂😜🙏

    • @rajeshshetty3342
      @rajeshshetty3342 13 днів тому +1

      Abhi mera isht ko gali dene ka mann kar raha

    • @Bankniftyscalper.30
      @Bankniftyscalper.30 13 днів тому

      @@rajeshshetty3342 किसको ??

    • @Jeetshorts036
      @Jeetshorts036 13 днів тому

      Kuchh bhi shikh ne mai 4-6 year lagte hai pesa bhi jata hai jo naye hai ab kitna gusa àaarha hai

    • @Vishal77885
      @Vishal77885 13 днів тому

      Mai 4 year me ab profit me aaya hu or ab ye🤬😭😭😭❤😡😡😡😡😡😡
      Mere paas ab suicide krne ke alawa kuchh nhi bacha
      Mene govt job chhoda hai iske liye

    • @Bankniftyscalper.30
      @Bankniftyscalper.30 13 днів тому

      @@Jeetshorts036 मेरा मानना है ये सरकार apporunity देती नि है और जो है उसे भी छीन लेती है 😡

  • @baponpal9375
    @baponpal9375 13 днів тому +1

    Thank you sir ji ajtakka sabse beriya videos laga mujhe

  • @rahulpanchavate1295
    @rahulpanchavate1295 12 днів тому +1

    Sir, I am neutral on politics 😊. But you guided me on What not to do , profitable 🎉 thanks for being a Watchtower in the dark ocean.

  • @tradingnifty50
    @tradingnifty50 13 днів тому +24

    Gambling needs no skill set. You just need money & luck in your favour.
    F&O needs lots of skill. You can't make them equal. Where was this consern about retailers (losing money), when monthly options were converted to weekly & creating everyday expiries...?

    • @abrahamgideon
      @abrahamgideon 13 днів тому

      Why create daily expiry and reduce lot size - big traders and institutions don't have the need for smaller lot size. If the government does tax F&O at 30% they are admitting that they are so bad at regulating the market that at this.point so much manipulation is happening that the market has become gambling.

  • @meethunghosh1892
    @meethunghosh1892 13 днів тому +14

    *stock trading done on intraday basis is also a speculative income...so WHY 30% TDS on only FnO...30% tax lena hai toh Financial Year end hone ke baad lo*

    • @bhat080380
      @bhat080380 13 днів тому

      Income Tax financial end pe hi liya jata...TDS bi karenge to 1-2% hi katega

    • @seeker008
      @seeker008 13 днів тому +1

      Tu de Bhai 30% hamare liye kyu bol raha hai

  • @Dinumarwadi.
    @Dinumarwadi. 13 днів тому

    Very good analysis of new rules. Really eye opening video. Every trader, nps holder, mutual fund holder, investor should watch

  • @kamil6224
    @kamil6224 13 днів тому

    Thank you ,your information is very helpful,you are great 👍

  • @DevChoudhary-tk8no
    @DevChoudhary-tk8no 13 днів тому +16

    Apko follow kiye sirf 20 days hue h but apne muje bjp ke against kr diya..bcz ap right ho sir ❤️❤️

  • @mukeshtanna4373
    @mukeshtanna4373 13 днів тому +17

    Yahi video chahia thasir aap se .. q ki trading community ko dar lag raha he ab , news sunke

    • @Vishal77885
      @Vishal77885 13 днів тому

      😢😢shi kha protest kro sab milke😡😡😡

  • @mukeshsonar6450
    @mukeshsonar6450 13 днів тому +1

    Dhanyawad sir ❤❤❤🎉🎉

  • @user-nh4xq8in7p
    @user-nh4xq8in7p 12 днів тому

    Sir aaj maza aa gaya vedio sunkar, kya bindas bol rahe ho country ke andar ki reality ke baare mei ❤

  • @ani2guha
    @ani2guha 13 днів тому +7

    I used to trade in currency. It was good for option sellers. In last few due to illiquidity, my account went to huge losses. In equity fno, I earn 2-4 rupees monthly, government will ruin that also. What is sebi doing except for sucking blood of gullible investors? They and exchanges are sitting on huge corpus of ipf and isf, they should educate, kya aur bole?

  • @samiraj1832
    @samiraj1832 13 днів тому +6

    If every trader take a pledge to not trade for one month.. we can teach lesson tk government...this message can be circulated through UA-cam and telegram groups if every trader is determined to teach the lesson

  • @siddharthbhatnagar2075
    @siddharthbhatnagar2075 12 днів тому

    Very informative video, and what a way to explain and giving honest opinion, need such kind of efforts. Thankyou sir keep everyone educated like this ❤

  • @jkukukumar886
    @jkukukumar886 13 днів тому +1

    Agar f&o trading ko business ki tarah samjha ja Raha hai to kya is per loan mil sakta hai aur iska insurance ho sakta hai?

  • @ashuexcel
    @ashuexcel 13 днів тому +12

    3 sàl lag gaye confidence aur protiable bane me..kafi paisa lose kia is sab me..aur 30% tax ke bad quit karna hoga

    • @sciencelover3465
      @sciencelover3465 13 днів тому +3

      game ko samjhe ab? bachpan mein cricket mein jab batting aati thi, to bat wala bacha, bhag jata tha, bat leke, bolke ki mumy bula rahi hai. game kahtam, kya samjhe ; )

    • @utkalsahusahu837
      @utkalsahusahu837 13 днів тому

      Nehi Bhai 30% loss karne pe milega g.t dega😢😢

    • @Vishal77885
      @Vishal77885 13 днів тому +1

      Mai 4 year me ab profit me aaya hu or ab ye🤬😭😭😭❤😡😡😡😡😡😡
      Mere paas ab suicide krne ke alawa kuchh nhi bacha
      Mene govt job chhoda hai iske liye

  • @balkrishnatalele3408
    @balkrishnatalele3408 13 днів тому +7

    18:16 main crux of video

  • @helpthepoorandorphanpeople7092
    @helpthepoorandorphanpeople7092 13 днів тому

    Sir TDS application daily income sai deduction possible ni lagta hai market says TDS application. Taxation may be possible ho skta hai

  • @akkikumar5309
    @akkikumar5309 10 днів тому

    people should share this video bahut achi baat kahi hai inhone.
    disclaimer: i am first time visitor on this channel. although subscribed and liked today.

  • @arunhblsunrise2009
    @arunhblsunrise2009 13 днів тому +3

    Really excellent valuable perfect explanation sir ji 👍

  • @nehajadhav7263
    @nehajadhav7263 13 днів тому +3

    इतना सारा न्यूज आप कहा से पडते है बहुत अच्छे अच्छे बताते है आप रोज बहुत हेल्प होता है समझने में

  • @ShivaKumar-cp7th
    @ShivaKumar-cp7th 13 днів тому

    Amazing video and awesome analysis Manish ji, thank you for educating us

  • @Mahi9tube
    @Mahi9tube 12 днів тому

    People are also speculating on this matter but your view is really appreciable. There should be a PIL in SC regarding Change in nature of business and there should be creation of a platform where all traders can come say in one voice against government inefficiency.

  • @manas19781
    @manas19781 13 днів тому +4

    Market will make LC on budget day if any such changes to FNO gets implemented in reality , hope better sense will prevail in the govt.

  • @AkashGupta-nm6bt
    @AkashGupta-nm6bt 13 днів тому +11

    Kudos to you bhaiya for raising the voice and explaining with numbers. Totally agree with you they don’t want people to earn , gadha majdori karna hoga.

  • @homelogica977
    @homelogica977 12 днів тому

    Correction rest of 89% people who are losing will also pay the brokage and some transaction fee.. they are only not liable to pay tax as they havent made any money.. so 11% he baki logo ka ghar chala rahey hai ki 89% log chala rahey hai ye discussion ka visay hai..

  • @hirenchonani4717
    @hirenchonani4717 13 днів тому +10

    Muje to lag raha hai ye sari rumors hai
    Government mai is me loss hai ye aisa nahi karegi

  • @callhereallrjcomedypranks1754
    @callhereallrjcomedypranks1754 13 днів тому +7

    Thumbnail 😂😂😂
    100 crores like❤

  • @RajeshMosalenaghbhushanrao
    @RajeshMosalenaghbhushanrao 13 днів тому

    Very informative video Sir, I acknowledge the grief people feel when market income is treated as speculative.

  • @krishnas3008
    @krishnas3008 13 днів тому

    Sir bilkul sahi bol rahe ho.sarkar ko lottery aur skill mai fark nahi dikhtasarkar se sawal ye hai-
    1-kya lottry kharidte time kisi skill ki jarurat hoti hai?
    2-kya lottry mai hue nuksan ki bharpai apne lottry skill se kar pana possible hai?
    3-kya lottry ke liye course hota hai ya books padhni padti hai?
    Lekin agar f&O mai kar sakte hai....ha agar aam aadmi ki life par koi negative asar agar iski vajha se aa raha ho to govt ko precautionary measures lene chahiye varna kyublogo ko barbad karne mai lage hai ye log.

  • @chahatchaudhari1432
    @chahatchaudhari1432 13 днів тому +9

    100% agree, Gujarat me kahi bhi sharab mil jata hai, desi bhi English bhi, I know because I am from Gujarat

  • @orhankaris
    @orhankaris 13 днів тому +7

    .Not making up to a million before retirement is unfulfilled retirement.!! I’m 54 and my wife 50 we are both retired with over $7 million in net worth and no debts. Currently living smart and frugal with our money. No longer putting blames on FED for our misfortunes. Saving and investing lifestyle in the stock and forex market made it possible for us this early, even till now we earn weekly.

    • @orhankaris
      @orhankaris 12 днів тому

      trading Investment should on every wise individuals bucket list. You will be ecstatic of the decision you made today.

    • @Enidmcgarvey2232
      @Enidmcgarvey2232 12 днів тому +2

      so perfect

    • @Enidmcgarvey2232
      @Enidmcgarvey2232 12 днів тому +1

      I got my first house the year I started investing and today networth is over £732k

    • @landernaallman1264
      @landernaallman1264 12 днів тому

      I’m a young mom, I’m really glad to hear your story it inspires me. can you share how you earn weekly.

    • @orhankaris
      @orhankaris 12 днів тому

      Credits to Dylan Kyle Zachary, He saw me through the process.

  • @pranavdhole9773
    @pranavdhole9773 9 днів тому

    Thank you sir ji, very informative and knowledgeable video

  • @raisingcaterpillars1581
    @raisingcaterpillars1581 13 днів тому

    Sir apne account main liquid cash kitna rakhna chahiye maximum. Mere pas 7 lakh hai liquid. PLs suggest

  • @JOLLY1007
    @JOLLY1007 13 днів тому

    Sir, After Long time Core Issues discussed & made a easy way to understand regarding for the same.

  • @yashsemwal693
    @yashsemwal693 13 днів тому +5

    Real teacher and real analysis ❤ true person with crystal clear heart ❤️ love you sir ji❤

  • @yashkumar1527
    @yashkumar1527 13 днів тому +10

    Hello sir, mera beta jo ki abhi 20 years old hai pichhale 3 saal se index option mi trading kar raha hai. Mera full support bete ko hai. Mai bhi thora sikh raha hu.Abhi hum baap bete ek saath baithkar strategy base trading kar rahe hai aur profitable ho rahe hai. Hum dono aapko 3 saal se follow kar rahe hai.thank u sirjee.

    • @LearningMarketsWithManish
      @LearningMarketsWithManish  13 днів тому +3

      Thanks :) Keep it up

    • @adityasingh-dl4dn
      @adityasingh-dl4dn 13 днів тому +2

      This is what CA Manish Bhaiya has earned transforming generations with his honest & impartial views and knowledge Proud member/viewer of learning markets with Manish Family❤❤❤

    • @pradeepsharma8048
      @pradeepsharma8048 13 днів тому +3

      UNCLE JEE .. ABBB 40% TAX BHARO .. BAHOOT KAMA LIYA BAAP BETE NAE

    • @yashkumar1527
      @yashkumar1527 13 днів тому

      🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @lavkarlife6964
      @lavkarlife6964 13 днів тому

      Fno tough hai upar se manipulation😢😢loss

  • @abhijitdas6084
    @abhijitdas6084 12 днів тому

    I can feel it when you were emotional at @18:20 . Thank you dada for all the information and guidance you provide us daily. সুস্থ থাকুন, ভালো থাকুন 🙂

  • @legendfaker5410
    @legendfaker5410 12 днів тому +1

    Manish sir jesa log bahat harsh reality batate hai...koi bhakt or chatukar jesa nahi hai isliye to log inko bahat respect dete hai...

  • @sjdmyworld2406
    @sjdmyworld2406 13 днів тому +17

    Sir 3 se 4 year lag gay mujhe trading sikhne me
    Or ye training mene kisi class se nahi balke khud prectical or loss kr k sikha hu
    Or ab ese rule ayge k 30% tax dena hoga
    Sahi mayno me ab mere carear start hone wala he or ye sab sunna par Raha he😢😢😢
    Sale pagal ho gay he ye log
    Jo ese ese rule la rahe he
    Khud ki tijori to noto se bhari he,
    Ham jese logo ko chen se jine nahi dege😡

  • @divikkhurana3308
    @divikkhurana3308 13 днів тому +13

    Main Pyaaz Bhi Khata Hu
    Main Trade Bhi Karta Hu 🤡

    • @chrisvarghese7199
      @chrisvarghese7199 13 днів тому +1

      Bas ek hi tammana hai, ye dialogue nirmala tai ke samne bolna hai😂

  • @Humanity47026
    @Humanity47026 13 днів тому +1

    जब देश का लोग अनपढ़ और गरीब रहेगा तभी तो ये राजनेता राज करेंगे और आम आदमी को Corporate का गुलाम बनाना चाहते है

  • @ashishkunwar5803
    @ashishkunwar5803 13 днів тому +3

    Thumbnail:- ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @krushnatangade7497
    @krushnatangade7497 13 днів тому +10

    The Man The Myth The Legend ✔️

  • @debrajchaudhuri9941
    @debrajchaudhuri9941 13 днів тому

    Very relevant and informative video. Manish ji your points are bang on and I appreciate the courage you have to voice out such difficult issues in the interest of all traders in the community. Really appreciate the effort 👍

  • @stockmarketsoldiers1266
    @stockmarketsoldiers1266 12 днів тому

    Two times watching after clear your information
    Thanks for sharing valuable information ❤

  • @sksanu766
    @sksanu766 13 днів тому +78

    Or do bjp vot 😂😂😂

    • @Rangi764
      @Rangi764 13 днів тому +2

      Promise Bhai agli janam me be vote nayi daltha huu bjp ko

    • @vipassanameditation3419
      @vipassanameditation3419 13 днів тому

      ​@@Rangi764ye Janam mai kya karoge

    • @AnuragSingh-br7yj
      @AnuragSingh-br7yj 13 днів тому +2

      Bhai koi bhi government aaye it doesn’t matter ……congress put more taxes to fuel their populist policies

    • @Random-nd7gv
      @Random-nd7gv 13 днів тому

      Bs iss janam me hi dalenge vote

    • @shubhamchaturvedi495
      @shubhamchaturvedi495 13 днів тому

      ​@@Random-nd7gvab vote nhi juta milega inko😂

  • @guptajimemewaale9890
    @guptajimemewaale9890 13 днів тому +5

    Jbtk budget me clear nahi hota hai krta rahunga agr clear hoga to chhod dunga options

  • @dattanimekar5
    @dattanimekar5 13 днів тому

    नमस्ते मनीषजी... 🙏🙏

  • @Humanity47026
    @Humanity47026 13 днів тому +2

    Agar 90% Retailers Loss mein hai to unke liye Education open karna chahiye tha ki Aisa bakwas aur ghaplebaaz taxation lagana chahiye tha

  • @dipukhandelwal9688
    @dipukhandelwal9688 13 днів тому +6

    50lac Me 5lac hi kama rhe h baki 45lac to loss hi kr rhe h😮😮

    • @sagarmore1895
      @sagarmore1895 13 днів тому +2

      ha to loss kyu kar rahe hai....unke pass skill nhi hai isiliye na.........unko kya hath me paisa dena chahiye

    • @Deepak_Arya
      @Deepak_Arya 13 днів тому +1

      Jodna ghatana to seekh le phle....50 lakh me se 5 lakh gye to kitne bache....loss krne wale bi aapke hi bhai h.....

  • @V12320
    @V12320 13 днів тому

    For the first time i came across your channel.
    Subscribed !!!
    The pain is real when someone make more than 2cr and 40% of it goes into government pocket as DIRECT tax. Now with remaining 60% you try to fight inflation and make some money then ready to pay these stupid no brainer charges and taxes which eatup another 35-40% of income.

  • @sumitanne7818
    @sumitanne7818 12 днів тому +1

    What about tax for FIIs FPIs DIIs???? Will they too get taxed?

  • @mritunjaisingh6510
    @mritunjaisingh6510 12 днів тому

    Thankyou for explaining things manish ji

  • @Vishal77885
    @Vishal77885 13 днів тому +2

    Mai 4 year me ab profit me aaya hu or ab ye🤬😭😭😭❤😡😡😡😡😡😡
    Mere paas ab suicide krne ke alawa kuchh nhi bacha
    Mene govt job chhoda hai iske liye

  • @anilkumargiri397
    @anilkumargiri397 13 днів тому

    Great message sir .... I am fully agree with your each words... Mann ki baat bol diye

  • @santoshjaiswal50
    @santoshjaiswal50 13 днів тому +1

    Bahut hi sahi batiye h apne

  • @manikchatterjee
    @manikchatterjee 12 днів тому

    Ek Trader banne ke liye bohut mehanat lagta hai, bohut time lagta hai, aur hum ishhey business mante hai naki jua / gambling ....... CFA Course bhi phir hata dena chahiye...../market ki finance ke upar all learning, courses hata dena chahiye ..... agar yeh jua hai toh...!
    ( TDS 30% agar hua toh mkt par no liquidity)
    Phir hum bhi trading bandh kar denge .....
    Nice sir ❤

  • @satyambanerjee4758
    @satyambanerjee4758 13 днів тому

    Aj tak ka sabse bst video bolunga on market as I am profitable for lst 3 yrs approx but I don't get the respect as I have left my job of engineering post... Thanks sir!!! I have been motivated so much

  • @shamraomali3337
    @shamraomali3337 13 днів тому

    interim budget 2024 apply for current financial year or not?

  • @prashantgaikwad5764
    @prashantgaikwad5764 12 днів тому

    Bahut achi information sir thank you.

  • @saritarawat3333
    @saritarawat3333 12 днів тому

    Ye baat sahi kahi aapne ki therotically aur practically me fark hai.।

  • @kailashvir3947
    @kailashvir3947 11 днів тому

    Sir, option are purchased to protect our equity shares.

  • @santhaganeshiyerganeshiyer1536
    @santhaganeshiyerganeshiyer1536 13 днів тому

    Very informative video sir.. thanks 🙏

  • @malangwithhimalayan
    @malangwithhimalayan 13 днів тому

    Bestest explaination bhai saab❤❤❤

  • @rajeshjuyal3917
    @rajeshjuyal3917 13 днів тому

    Very well explained, thank yu ou

  • @TanwarKal3
    @TanwarKal3 12 днів тому +1

    I do equity swing trading (3-4 shares max) , last year my return was 110% . these 3 month of this financial year , has been terrible still i was able to make 7-8% of my capital . Now they are targeting stcg and ltcg , now my income has increased now this is pissing me off , i take so much risk what i'm getting in return ?, i am a bjp supporter , but seriously if this way they will increase tax and do this nonsense of gambling income , i and my family will never vote for them because i know options are even more risky . i am learning from you still will enter this space after 4-5 year with enough experience

  • @vijay_prhr
    @vijay_prhr 13 днів тому

    Thanks for excelent knowledge ........ :)