אתאיסט מראיין את הרב טוביה סינגר בראיון ללא הנחות -Rabbi Tovia Singer
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 чер 2024
- 00:00 02:37 מה גרם לך להיות רב?
02:37 05:45 מה הופך אדם ליהודי?
05:45 07:30 ומה עם גרים? האם הם נחשבים יהודים?
07:30 10:41 למה חוקי התורה לא נאכפים? האם אתאיסט יכול להיות יהודי?
10:41 14:16 מה ההבדל בין הזרמים ביהדות?
14:16 17:47 מה דעת הרב על גידול פרה אדומה?
17:47 19:27 האם בניית בית המקדש השלישי שווה את המאמץ?
19:27 25:25 עבדות ביהדות
25:25 27:27 מה הפסוק האהוב עליך?
27:27 30:15 מה עמדת היהדות לגבי השטן?
30:15 34:04 מה הרב אומר על ספר איוב?
34:04 35:24 סיכום
Help us combat aggressive Jewish evangelism in Israel: outreachjudaism.org/partners/
Let’s Get Biblical Study Guide (Volume 1 & 2) outreachjudaism.org/shop/lets...
outreachjudaism.org/
www.videvo.net
/ @rak_emet הרשמו לערוץ חדש נגד המיסיון
Music: www.purple-planet.com
www.toviasinger.tv/
#toviasinger #Judaism #Christianity #Messiah
I visited the Land of Israel once and I had the overwhelming feeling that I had come home when the plane landed. When the day arrived that I had to return to the States I felt so sad. So far I don’t think I am Jewish but I have a longing to return. I was a Christian but thanks to Rabbi Singer I am now a Noah-Hyde and I am so home sick for the homeland of our Hashem. My prayer is that people will read the Hebrew Tanakh in context and compare it with the Christian Bible.
I have experienced the same thing, israel are my roots 🇮🇱💯
Baruch HaShem! ✡️❤️
Observant Noahides may live in Israel.
I have the same longing and I am Jewish. I think that it has nothing to do with who you were born, it has to do with a spiritual longing. Don’t forget that the Tanach never mentions ‘Jews’ they mention the. Nation of Israel which is open to all the righteous people, according to a Kabbalah expert in Israel.
@@tippytalk The true identity of a person is Jew or Gentile.
Toda Raba Rav Singer for guiding me out of christianity into noahidism and now to Orthodox Judaism as a Korean-Canadian convert, ger tzedeck, hoping to join Schara Tzedeck Congregation in Vancouver, BC, Canada, when HaShem allows, and eventually to make aliyah and live in Yerushalayim as Eliyahu HaNavi and Moshiach ben David are revealed, the Third Temple built, eternal Shabbat Isaiah 2:4 fulfilled. When I realized I was a Jew, I started to give donations to Rav Singer and help Israeli charities. If King David was PM of Israel now, and was battling out Psalm 83, Ezekiel 38-39, Zechariah 12/14, simultaneously, I would give everything I could to support the brave warriors of Israel, the IDF.
Thank you for your support!
🎉 Congratulations on your journey and path! 👣🎆
I could listen to the Rabbi forever.
This is completely off topic, and I apologize for the long comment. I used to be a Methodist Christian. I have not fully went to Judaism. When I found out my daughter had disabilities I lost my faith in God, and I was studying to become a Pastor. I challenge God daily and tried to become an Atheist. Jesus I could disapprove. Hashem i couldn’t. As I was going through my UA-cam channels of religious fanatics I came across your page in the hopes of destroying your ideology but yet as I listen to you, I felt influenced by God to listen to you. I continued to listen to your messages for years this comment will go unnoticed but if by any chance u see it, I want to say Thank You and Praise Hashem for leading me to you and reawakening my Spiritual Enlightenment. Thank you Rabbi Singer for doing Hashems work and bringing me back to Enlightenment.
You are loved
@@ToviaSinger1 Thank you Rabbi, I'm still working in my conversion to Judaism. Thank you for awaking my Enlightenment in my darkest times. Thank you 😊 Have a Blessed Day.
@@user-no7qh8lf4m Gentiles have no obligation to convert to Judaism.
@@ToviaSinger1 hi Rabbi
Would you agree that our souls are thousands of years old or even older? God knew us before we were born so is it possible that we were with God but after being born into a body we do not remember were we came from?
@@ToviaSinger1hi Rabbi. Looking at how big the universe is I came to the conclusion that I cannot phantom how big God is as my brain capacity cannot compute it. Is it normal to pray and to just stop and realise that God is so big that it is better to keep quite before Him. I know God said to be still and know that I Am God but is this normal to just keep quite before God as I am sure He knows me and my thoughts better than what I know myself?
I love this guy! I'm glad you got to talk with him Rabbi.
Thank you Rabbi, you are so patient.
Incredibly patient!💙
I'm a Noahide thanks to your truthful teachings! You have changed my life! Thank you rabbi tovia singer for being the light in the dark for the lost!🤍
Baruch HaShem! ✡️❤️
Welcome home!
Shalom from Rapid City South Dakota. Thank you rabbi
Hello rabbi tovia I am an Indian hindu and I support you love you from India
Thank you, Rabbi Singer! Love your kindness and humility 🤍
Greetings from the United States.
Blessings from Australia 🇦🇺 ❤❤❤
Thanks! Rabbi. Baruch Ha Shem❤️🕎✡️🇮🇱🇺🇸USA
Thank you!
My great grandfather is a Jew from Spain he was forced to convert to Catholics and change his family name but later as we discovered it we are now practicing Judaism and follow the mitzvot here in the Philippines.Toda raba Rabbi for the enlightenment.
The true identity of a child as a Jew or a Gentile by birth is matrilineal; it follows the identity of the mother who conceived the embryo and carried it through pregnancy until the child's birth.
Very enjoyable watch. You’re consistent in your teachings and you’re poised. The interviewer asked really enjoyable questions and it was very engaging. I am very pleased you’ve shared which tribe you’re from. Reading a bit about the prophet Elijah being a descendant of Aaron really took my breath away. You provide excellent fruits and you are guiding many people back to G-d’s word. Thank you again as always Rabbi Tovia. Im not Jewish and not sure what it’ll take to become a Noahide but none of that matters to me as long as I feel joy when hearing G-d’s word. You always make it so simple to understand. You’re blessed with the gift. Many blessings to you and your family and loved ones! You’re in my prayers.
You become a Noahide when you have a Gentile mother.
Thank you rabbi
Shalom from California
A ton of good info!
Recommended by Rudy. Thank you.
Baruch HaShem Rabbi, thank you for reminding us of our place within the covenant.
I have never heard an Atheist be so quiet in an interview before. Very polite.
That probably has a lot to do with *who* the atheist is talking to and *how* they are acting. How someone treats you has a lot to do with how you're treating them. If Tovia isn't going out of his way to *solicit* negative attention, he's not so likely to get it.
@@somexp12 This is correct. However I have seen very calm non-inflammatory religious people get over talked by interviewing atheists. Hence my surprise at the cordiality displayed by this interviewer.
@@Oneamongthelegion I don't have any context for these other cases, but (in addition to things varying by personality) there are more ways than one for religious people to be inflammatory, and not every way may be immediately apparent to everyone. For example, some reasonably decent religious people have a tendency to, more or less, "butt-in" whilst an atheist is dealing with the problematic ones. Also, some religious people have a way of saying the most insulting things about nonbelievers but with the most angelic of countenance.
And then there's also just differences in personality.
@@Oneamongthelegion I wonder if the interview you have in mind is the interview done by that MythVision guy (Derek Lampert)? Since this is Tovia Singer's channel, I imagine that could be what you're thinking of. If so, I'm about 99% sure that's personality. Lampert is a former heroin addict. Having met several, they're often lovely, but can be talkative and impulsive in a way that'd be rude to some people. But that would be a temperament thing more than anything to do with religious belief or lack thereof. He would've still been that way back when he was an Evangelical.
@@somexp12 I didn't have any specific examples in mind.
Greetings from Indonesia.
שלום וברכה מצפת
Great interview! Well done. Thank you Rabbi.
This perky atheist just rubs me the wrong way (*seems he isn't really truly listening!) and it is so so admirable how Rabbi Singer shows such a gentle touch with his great patience💙
מרתק מאוד ותמיד מוסיף לידע שלי!
Excellent presentation! Baruch HaShem
Well articulated!! Great interview
A very good interview. 🙂
This Video answers so many entry Level questions and puts away with so many misconceptions. The reason the people hate on the bible is because of the false way Christian translations have obscured the Language
That and they dont want to have to listen to the laws
@@heythereall Gentiles have the 7 Noahide laws only.
It’s not just 7 Laws!
there’s a lot of subsections to these 7
I have enormous respect for the rabbi and his wealth of knowledge. I would not argue the custom of being a refuge in a Jewish family and being considered part of them.
What I see is that in leviticus, the Jews were given instructions as to whom you could enslave. It was the heathens that surrounded them. They were given instructions as how to treat them, how much to punish them and they could be passed down to their sons.
Maybe what the rabbi was talking about was for the jews. But the heathen slaves none of this kind treatment.
Wow wow wow wow
It's ironic. christians lie by saying that the eyes of Jews are scaled . However as soon Jews see whatever reality check needed and seen then the irony will be even more. Calling idolatry (jesus) the opposite of having eye scales is ironic. There is sure so much more to see.
Blessed be The God of Jewish Faith Hashem ✡️.
iTS NOT YOUR RELIGION i LOVE its the people and their suffering that drew me to you.Knowing who you are.and what your people have been through to survive.undeserved hatred.
💥🧡
❤
One world of no religion and one love under God IMAGINE
21:00
I very much respect Rabbi Tovia and his videos. In this case, his interpretation of the Hebrew word AR(U)R being same or similar to A(U)R (light) is interesting.
As he pointed out correctly, the Hebrew word for curse is KLL not ARR. But still, the term ARR is definitely negative. Meaning negative light. We see this word used multiple times in the Torah in conjunction to negative themes.
The passage indeed tells us that Ham "revealed his father's intimate parts", and then told his brothers.
Generally, the bible uses clean language to describe intimate relationships. As seen clearly in similar passages in the Torah of the same context.
So this passage is purposely ambiguous.
The following passage relates that Noah awoke and saw what his youngest son had done to him. Which implies that something was physically done to him.
The Talmud brings two traditions, one , that Hams sin against his father Noah, was that he castrated him (to prevent further reproduction). The other, that he sodomised him.
Another tradition indicates that it was Hams youngest son Canaan who actually did the bad deed, interpreting "his youngest son" as referring to Hams youngest son (at the behest of Ham).
The main theme here is exploiting the vulnerability of the father (who has saved them from the flood) , as a means to dominate and reverse the natural course of authority.
To Paul Sandberg. You said "no one has to keep the Law any more." That doesn't explain why in Acts 15 the Jewish-Christians were debating whether the Gentiles had to keep the Torah (including circumcision). This means those who were Jewish continued to do so (in the year 50 CE). Also, Acts 21:24 has James saying to Paul, "You yourself live in observance of the Law, but as for the Gentiles who have believed...." No indication that Jewish believers stopped observing the Torah.
Gentiles have to keep the 7 Noahide laws.
🙏🏽💙🌹🕎
How come you look better as you get older!!?
Gravitas, maybe.
Hay Burt, your a great actor I though you were brilliant in "The Train"
Most prisoners stuck in some kind prison or cage .... smoke.... probably until less stuck
"Moslems happen to have a high regard for the Jewish faith" -- Tovia
Yes, that is true for the vast majority of Moslems. ✡️❤️
@@sitresjolie2343 Quran, Chapter 9 Verse 30:
"The Jews say, "Ezra is the son of Allah "; and the Christians say, "The Messiah is the son of Allah." That is their statement from their mouths; they imitate the saying of those who disbelieved [before them]. May Allah destroy them; how are they deluded?"
It’s true, considering that the Jews continue preaching absolute oneness of the G-d of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob something Christians failed to do over 2000 years.
Rav Singer did a video on Surah 9 v30 watch it he explains it in detail. In short summary, it refers to a small sect of heretical Jews who lived during the time of prophet Muhammad. This verse doesn’t apply to the Jews living today.
He interviewed me also. Is it ok to upload?
I've not known of any Muslims that have had a "high regard" for Jews. Is this mainly in Indonesia?
Probably because you never met one
@@abc_6 I know Rabbi Singer is in Israel and there are Muslims that live there, but I’d say the truth is most Muslims have high disdain for Jews, to put it mildly.
ממש מעניין מה שאמרת על חם והצורך בכיבוד משפחה. מי אומר את זה?
22:20 is this referring to עבד כנעני? That is חייב במצוות כאשה and not in the גדר of קידושין?
32:15 if the שטן is the general evil inclination of each specific יצר הרע is the a general מלאך for each specific יצר טוב ? Rabbi singer ?
Ironically, Satan doesn't have free will of his own, bec he is an angel. Angels are compelled to do exactly what Gd wants
Hello Rabbi 👍 Great teacher, Question if the scripture stated God or the Gods gave Mankind dominion over the Earth told them what to do ,said everything was Good 👍Seems to me God and the Patheon was satisfied.😁 Where did this other junk come from and why is it put in the Bible 🤔, I don't believe , I know God didn't inspire that it was full of Chaos , our problem is we believe in too Many different Gods but KNOW nothing about the Spirit of Creation.😏😏, But there is hope The Spirit of Truth is still waiting to Enlighten us.😲👌
I love watching the Rabbi's videos, as I was brought up in the Christian tradtion and have gradually come to the insight that Christianity corrupts the Jewish Scriptures. His presentation of those is quite interesting. However; I have also come to the insight that the Jewish Scriptures are not what they are purported to be. An archaeological view on the Jewish Scriptures, as presented by prof Israel Finkelstein, brought me to the insight that the Jewish Scriptures are not divinely inspired, but more of a product of political ideology and religious spin. I love the Jews as a nation however. Their cultural history is also part of my own. I just do not take myths like the creation narrative, the deluge and the exodus literally. If I had been a Jew, I would be proud to be one, but I would certainly be a secular Jew.
I'm so blessed to have found his channel and know HaShem has guided me to his light! Because I was so confused by Christianity and lost now my eyes and heart are open and are being filled with truth I found myself because of his teachings He's so amazing! 🥹
Just obey the seven Noahide laws. ✡️❤️
I hope you realize there are many Jews who don't hold to the creation, Noach, etc in a literal sense. Some don't believe Moshe wrote Torah but rather 4 different Jewish sects did over 100s of years. This train of thought is well known in Reform Judaism for example.
@@shawnwatson1419
Yes, I do know the various theories.
I don’t give a flying flip what Reform Jews think or do. I love them and support them as much as I can in what mitzvahs they do keep. ✡️❤️
@@sitresjolie2343 That comment was for Fanusvdm btw. Not for you. Personally I follow Orthodox teachings as a Ben Noach.
Rabbi, How come we don't have fur?
The real problem is that "eved" does not mean slave; it's a very poor translation.
How would you translate the word, Greg? What are your credentials in Hebrew scholarship? ✡️❤️
If we're Jewish because of the mother how do we Trace David's bloodline?
Kvod haRav: As Jacob came to Egypt with 70 souls. Only 2 females were among them. Adding the 2 sons of Josef, that Jacob adopted in Egypt, all the jewish spouses are not mentioned, although they are essential for jewish descendency and for „kadesh li kol peter rechem“. How is that matrinlinear DNA-gap to fill ?
The Jewish people did not exist before Sinai.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Your comment is thoroughly wrong. Pharao forced the jewish people into slavery and kept them for 210 Years until the Exodus.
@@bell1095 At Mount Sinai, the approximately 3 million assembled Israelites entered into a Divine Covenant with God and became the Jewish people, and they received the Torah Law from God through Moses. From that point on, anyone born to a Jewish mother is a Jew, and is obligated in the Jewish commandments of the Torah. Likewise anyone born to a Gentile mother is a Gentile (one of the Children of Noah), and is obligated in the Noahide commandments of the Torah.
I beg to differ on that statement regarding tobacco. They don't give a darn bout us it's all bout money. But i get the actual message lol
Better lies than half-truths! The second is more dangerous!
The karaites go by father. Are they wtong?
Yes. ✡️❤️
The true identity of a child as a Jew or a Gentile by birth is matrilineal; it follows the identity of the mother who conceived the embryo and carried it through pregnancy until the child's birth.
Yup they're wrong✅
@@bigtomboye Logically, why are they wrong? Why is the father's lineage not equal to the mother's in this respect?
@@jazzsnare Jewishness comes via Mother 👩 and Tribe is determined by Father 👨
Rabbi singer if a convert/ גר צדק has a child with a born Jewish woman does the child not have a tribe / שבט? I'm only asking from a body perspective I'm not asking from the soul that each tribe has different soul attributes/ שורש הנשמה?
The membership of a born-Jewish person in one of the Twelve Tribes of Israel is patrilineal, based on the tribe of the born-Jewish father.
In the end of chapter 47 in Ezekiel the prophet writes that the converts will inherit the land with the Jews - among the tribe they have dwelled with. So, basically you get adopted into a tribe. Even though born into people have a tribe identity, they don’t live in tribes at this time. Born and converts are all Israel and that’s what matters at this time. Everything will be restored when Moshiach comes.
@@DavidMoshe77 a גר if he brings ביכורים he is מביא ואינו קורא because he didn't receive the land ?
@@DavidMoshe77 I don't know if a convert also is not obligated in blessings after meals for the same reason like women
@@ytsi7505 all converts are obligated to do everything a born Jew is to do and bound by the Mitzvot. They are to be treated as a born Jew and shouldn’t be asked if they are a convert. But everyone knows because you are named (chosen Hebrew name) with Avraham v'Sarah. But, yes all converts live and practice as born Jews.
Because the Old Testament always, always says son of the father’s name only and never mentions the mother’s name I thought you are Jewish through your father, and not your mother. Doesn’t the special gene that all Jews are suppose to have come from the father only???
The true identity of a child as a Jew or a Gentile by birth is matrilineal; it follows the identity of the mother who conceived the embryo and carried it through pregnancy until the child's birth.
I think you're great Rabbi but I was a believer in god but no more , I don't know how people can think god is good. I don't think killing poor animals is good infact it is horrible!
Animals are not created in the image of God.
Well, relative to the fashion industry alone, Gd has asked for very very very few animal sacrifices over the centuries and millennia. And, animals are not on our level, Gd made us in G-d's image, not them
For all the understandable questions about G-d's goodness, this one is almost unusual in that so few animals were even sacrificed -- mostly people comment on mu4der and war and disease and child starvation etc
@@bigtomboye
Wow! So few! How many if so few?
@@williamthrasher7961 who cares ❤ 😴 🥱
The mineral world created to feed the vegetal world, which feeds the animal world which feeds man.
If you don't like to eat animal meat, it is okay. Others do.
I personally turned away from vegetarian lifestyle because i am too anemic and became ill.
We each do what is best for our health.
When Biden yimach shemo heard Israel captured the Philadelphia route he said that the IDF better not invade Scranton 😂😂😂
We Believers in Allah [ The One True God ] must Unite Against the Evil Of Athiesm. Its Unnatural and Most Evil Desease of Humanity And Misguidance From the Devil.
Jew , Christian and Muslims we Must Unite Against Athiesm. And Save people from Hellfire.
So if your mother was not Jewish, you and your progeny would still be descendants of Aaron and of the tribe of Levi, but you would not be Jewish?
NOTHING CORPOREAL has anything to do with the SOUL OF ISRAEL, which is not a physical entity but the SOUL BEING FORMED WITHIN THE ENTITY: Israel started FROM THE NATIONS, and always comes out of the nations, even the nation of Judea: The physical is the animate part, the ESAU (Hairy) part of Jacob (smooth) the SOUL who must RISE ABOVE THIS ANIMATE NATURE:
I can’t listen or watch an atheist for more than a couple minutes without getting annoyed. The smug tone and the mocking condescending laughter is intolerable
This is great news about yourself! Consider yourself lucky to be able to acknowledge that you have just entered the neurological understanding of neurochemical modulators that allows the insensitive structure of decision making at any given time. All that is required now is to control these chemicals by practicing neuro-hacking and bio-hacking. Nootropic supplements and foods alone with exposure to natural conditioning of your body.
@@yvonnegordon1952
What do you meaning to say? Choosing the good in truth? One unity of existence?
@@williamthrasher7961 at the core of existence is the SINGULARITY (da'at) and I experienced this UNITY and from that time forward (since 1992) I know God is ONE and is represented by the LETTER SHIN (a threefold flame coming from a SINGLE POINT): The single point is HASHEM, the three fold flame is the expression of himself into his creation: Without the experience of Hashem I think it is impossible to know the UNITY of God: This is why Abraham's religions see three gods no matter how much each one thinks it is only their God that is real:
...I was taken-aback by Rabbi Singer's contention (5:03--5.26) '...one of the very important things about Judaism is that we DON'T change; we're unchanging...so the idea that Judaism evolves or we change the rules at some point, that's completely antithetical to the Jewish faith...we, we just don't change...we don't alter..."
For you to contend that Judaism of The First Temple was In NO WAY DIFFERENT from the "Tent Tabernacle Judiasm" practiced by the newly liberated Post-Exodus
Hebrews, provokes EPIC Eye-Rolls...
For you to assert that the Judaism of the 'Second Temple' was Identical to it's preceding "Post-First-Temple" practices, deserves muffled Laughter...
And for you to Insist that "...changing the rules [of Judaism] is Antithetical to the Jewish Faith." Flies in the Face of 'Trends in Faith'. How can you insist that Judaism in present-day US of A has 'rarely-- If EVER' been embroiled in' the kinds of internal Disputes which have caused Christianity to schism into Multiple Denominations & Sects ?, The range of beliefs & practices betrays Willful Ignorre-ance that Judaism has NOT been 'granted immunity' from Unreconciled Disagreements which have led to the formations of multiple factions -- little different from Every OTHER Faith dedicated to "Invisible Sky Daddies".
In addition to 'Ethno-Geographic' dustinctions (Ashkenazi, Sephardic, Mizrahi[ic?], etc. Jewish-ness comes in a number of 'Degrees' ("Streams): Reform, Conservative, Orthodox (and ULTRA-Orthodox) and Reconstructionist in the U.S. -- members of each likely to hold to distinguishably Different "Traditions"...with the %age shares of the current population rising & falling with the passage of time, and the Evolution of Social Movements.
Tovia says he can trace his lineage back but the Bible says the children of Isreal can’t trace theirs because the forgot who they are
Sorry not the descendants of Aaron, and DNA evidence is there
That is speaking about the House of Israel, the Northern Kingdom, who were ALL taken into captivity to Assyria. The House of Judah, the Southern Kingdom, were taken into captivity 137 years later, to Babylon. They never lost their identity. This is written in the Tanakh.
@@chanitalevitz4945 look up the kohan gene and see where it mostly found
@@beefynachos6574
Obey the Noahide laws and be kind to Jewish people. I did look up Kohan gene and found zero surprises. ✡️❤️
People who are cohanim(priests) have the tradition in their family.
thank you rabbi
I always like your videos your wisdom is amazing when i was a kid my Father forbid me to talk he saw me like a work horse a servant
I ask him why you forbid me to talk
He told me to protect you from your tongeu your tongeu is your first ennemy when you dont talk you look like wise but when you talk you expose yourself to be an idiot
My son my sweet litle donkey dont think i hate you
Dont say what you know
Learn to know what you say and the qonsqeunses of your words
And when i see you talk i inmediatly think what my father teach me when i was a kid 😂
your only enemy is your own self, your vessel of vanity that is the EXILE of Adam and this exile continues in the Jew who has not yet been JOINED (YICHUD) to HASHEM: If a Jew is joined to Hashem he can HEAR HASHEM TODAY and the MESSIAH is revealed within his HEART:
My Family are Bedouines From Oman and without family a man became a nobody everything i do must not harm My tribes interest
My Father Iwn Rams Camels Horses Goats Turkey and istudy in Netherland Agriculturale Science and i devloped the lands of My father in the west when you became 20 years you wil be independent
But by Bedouines my Father own me all the days of his life iam his Servant so he is like Our King
Europeans wil tell me you must rise up against your father😂
We belief realy if you love your parents Lord wil bless you but if you did not your future wil be gone