It clearly shows that FM has not consulted people on the issue. This is just after thought, when even ruling party people pointed out that this will affect common man.
@@parthibank2736 not everyone. go through some examples. some may even benefit from reduced rate of 12.5% versus earlier 20%. she didn't retract completely, just gave the option for people to choose either old 20% or new 12.5%.
LTCG on equity earning is not acceptable.While purchasing we pay multiple taxes and by the time we book profit after few years you are charged again 12.5%, and what about earnings loosing it's shine over the years because of inflation. Inspite of staunch supporter of B.J.P all my life I hate them for this anti middle class move.😢
in 1998 an army man had a salary of ₹ 5000 , today it is ₹ 50,000. Property prices have grown more. Indexation is Dharm & morally correct way. In all other policies - ii agree with modi ji. Here i strongly disagree but still vote for him. Edit : i commented after watching half the video. Govt has given the option to choose either the old indexation method or the new method. 20-25 year old property owners would benefit from the old method & may be 7-8 year old property owners would benefit from the new one. Modi govt will not betray the common man deliberately.
She is absolutely arrogant.. it’s not because of people - it’s because of real estate companies; if she is hearing people, then income tax & gst on insurance etc should have been revoked; she is just fooling people once again - disgusting
well at least she should consider implementing it from the next FY which would make great sense from accounting point of view. If she reverses it then great. The property owners have got a great deal. Now the law is prospective. Though I understand it will not apply to property bought after July 23. Others get a chance to use both the 2 rates for CG calculation. But no such relief for equity investors. Which is surprising because equity is a risk asset and small investors invest in this class. Hopefully the FM will understand and push the CG tax increase to the next year from April 1,
Don't India have a knowledgable person to make a National budget ? Adhani made an unproffessional budget which needed to prepare many mini budget ! This shows India is 1000 years behind in Science, technology, economics and finance . Shame to Hindustan and BJP ! Jai Hind !
it is available to only those who had property before presentation of budget. No benefits for those who invest or purchase residential Property will continue pay at new proposed rate of 12.5% and NO INDEXATION benefits will be available 😢
Big Charity by Nirmala sitharaman Now for gst relief on Mediclaim and Life insurance she is hiding behind GST council This proves that our FM is incapable of taking independent decisions 😂
I purchased a 30 x 40 feet plot in 1995 for a very low price and sold it on 1st July 24.for very high price. Whether can I go for 12 half percent.Because indexation not benefits me Whether I have option
Which is the correct value of a property 1. Indexed value. Or 2. Guidance value as per state government for registration Capital gains tax has to be paid for which evaluation rate of government Central or State
seems the indexation benefit on LTCG is available only for resident tax payer and HUFs. For NRIs they dont get indexation benefit and have to pay 12.5% on sale price - original purchase price.
Please tell me I purchased site in 1995 for 35000 but sold it on 1.7.24.If I go for 20 percent I get no profit.Can I opt for 12 half percent.I want to know whether I have option
This is definitely not simplication. To collect more tax.. No transparancy/accountability on the amount of tax paid by common people. Disappointing move.
Everybody is screaming and fretting about Indexation benefit....Nobody seems to talk about depreciation of the property on annual basis which gradually erodes the value 0f constructed building over a period of time. ..Let the Super Rich honestly reduce the value of the property through depreciation and then arrive at the indexation benefit.....Well, nobody will Talk about this.....
Raghav Chadda was using bogus valuation to attack the govt. In almost NO market in India, including 3rd and 4th tier cities and towns, has the long term growth rate of property since 2001 been only 6% and is closer to 10% and higher. In these cases, it is almost always beneficial to use the flat 12.5% tax without indexation which benefits shorter term holdings with lower growth rates.
It’s stupid project think this is relaxation. It’s only for old properties. Any property you purchase from now on will not have indexation benefit. So unless your property grows at more than 9% you are actually paying more tax on every new property. As growth rates keep slowing down realty also grows at a lower pace. So you will end up paying not tax than before. This is NIRMA TAX don’t forget
We heard the people, are you heard?? Why middleclass men pay 60% tax, shame to FM, if you want to do good for India, resign your job and save tax payer money . This is tax india,
If you want to buy ₹100 as it's fair price, you earn ₹143 rupees (30% tax deducted you get 100 rs) Then GST on average 18%.. For ₹ 18 GST you spent you have to earn ₹21 after deduction you can spent ₹18. Total ₹164 you have earn for spent ₹100.. What you get from govt minimum basic hospital or educational facilities not provided.. This is tax india
@@eswarroy2103 it didn't start yesterday. We've been paying more since 6 decades. It's coming down gradually and facilities for the money is increasing. The roads, infra, law & order everything needs money. Up to 10 lakhs per person income can escape without paying any direct tax if planned judiciously. Even developed countries take more taxes even though their population density is 1/10 of India and everyone pays. Here 98% effectively don't pay income tax considering 5 L exemption limits. AND tax of 60 on 160 is 35%, not 60. Getvur facts right & learn how things have been historically.
@@Orundaok so since 6 decades, if we have been paying tax like this, what services have we got? Cleaner country? Good road facilities? Good hospital facilities? Atleast basics? No sht! Everything is going into politician’s pockets. Just corruption!
Govt collecting taxes like developed country and provided services like a poooooor country Shame to every tax payer, govt here is collecting taxes and distribute to their friends a1,a2
Shows immaturity of the FM and the Government….
It clearly shows that FM has not consulted people on the issue.
This is just after thought, when even ruling party people pointed out that this will affect common man.
..... and consequently the future votes!😂
@@parthibank2736 what percentage of common man gets affected by ltcg? 😂
Why she retracted?
Middle class is totally affected to sell and buy new properties
@@parthibank2736 not everyone. go through some examples. some may even benefit from reduced rate of 12.5% versus earlier 20%. she didn't retract completely, just gave the option for people to choose either old 20% or new 12.5%.
@@parthibank2736 tax is reduced from 20 to 12.5
One of the Wrost FM in India and she is back door FM she didn't participated in elections
LTCG on equity earning is not acceptable.While purchasing we pay multiple taxes and by the time we book profit after few years you are charged again 12.5%, and what about earnings loosing it's shine over the years because of inflation. Inspite of staunch supporter of B.J.P all my life I hate them for this anti middle class move.😢
in 1998 an army man had a salary of ₹ 5000 , today it is ₹ 50,000.
Property prices have grown more.
Indexation is Dharm & morally correct way.
In all other policies - ii agree with modi ji.
Here i strongly disagree but still vote for him.
Edit : i commented after watching half the video. Govt has given the option to choose either the old indexation method or the new method.
20-25 year old property owners would benefit from the old method & may be 7-8 year old property owners would benefit from the new one.
Modi govt will not betray the common man deliberately.
Please consider to avoid GST on health insurance 🙏🙏🙏
She is absolutely arrogant.. it’s not because of people - it’s because of real estate companies; if she is hearing people, then income tax & gst on insurance etc should have been revoked; she is just fooling people once again - disgusting
True. She doesnt care about people.
She says she wants to simplify tax, and she herself complicates the same! Wah Nirmalaji Wah!
have you ever paid or filed taxes? do u have any idea how it was 10 years back?
@@Orunda what are you trying to tell here?
@@sarcasticmallu_1 that you have no clue or knowledge
@@Orunda boss, as your name means, oru undem ariyaathe chelakkan nikkanda kettalaa..nee maatram alla tax kodth ondaakanath
@@sarcasticmallu_1 Mone, I know about freeloaders like u, chill & eat the free rice.
At the same time, we appreciate if the FM reverse the LTCG increase in shares and Mutual Funds.
well at least she should consider implementing it from the next FY which would make great sense from accounting point of view. If she reverses it then great. The property owners have got a great deal. Now the law is prospective. Though I understand it will not apply to property bought after July 23. Others get a chance to use both the 2 rates for CG calculation. But no such relief for equity investors. Which is surprising because equity is a risk asset and small investors invest in this class. Hopefully the FM will understand and push the CG tax increase to the next year from April 1,
First time I must thank Opposition for helping the common people.
Don't India have a knowledgable person to make a National budget ? Adhani made an unproffessional budget which needed to prepare many mini budget ! This shows India is 1000 years behind in Science, technology, economics and finance . Shame to Hindustan and BJP ! Jai Hind !
Even the government is confused with their policies, how will investors trust them 😢
Pehli baar opposition ne proper tarike se logoan ki problem highlight kee
it is available to only those who had property before presentation of budget. No benefits for those who invest or purchase residential Property will continue pay at new proposed rate of 12.5% and NO INDEXATION benefits will be available 😢
Sadly
It's not sold before 23 July.... It would be purchased before 23 July
Big Charity by Nirmala sitharaman
Now for gst relief on Mediclaim and Life insurance she is hiding behind GST council
This proves that our FM is incapable of taking independent decisions 😂
I purchased a 30 x 40 feet plot in 1995 for a very low price and sold it on 1st July 24.for very high price. Whether can I go for 12 half percent.Because indexation not benefits me Whether I have option
Why LTCG not reduced to 10% on mutual funds?
Tax to infinity 😡
This option available only to individual n HUF only
Should've heard earlier and it's still not properly in favour of people.
Which is the correct value of a property
1. Indexed value. Or
2. Guidance value as per state government for registration
Capital gains tax has to be paid for which evaluation rate of government
Central or
State
what about stcg and ltcg on Stocks?
seems the indexation benefit on LTCG is available only for resident tax payer and HUFs. For NRIs they dont get indexation benefit and have to pay 12.5% on sale price - original purchase price.
Please tell me I purchased site in 1995 for 35000 but sold it on 1.7.24.If I go for 20 percent I get no profit.Can I opt for 12 half percent.I want to know whether I have option
Why rock music for the background 😂
This is definitely not simplication. To collect more tax.. No transparancy/accountability on the amount of tax paid by common people. Disappointing move.
Effect of stronger opposition and strong opposition leader
If i were in her place, i would have taken moral responsibility and quit the position for failing ro serve the public.. being a public servant..
Relaxed. Thank you. Now she will be changing the indexation formula to suit her intentions 😢
What about those who sold during the bracket of time after the budget was announced and before this revision was made??☠️💀😈
first reduce gst looting
Everybody is screaming and fretting about Indexation benefit....Nobody seems to talk about depreciation of the property on annual basis which gradually erodes the value 0f constructed building over a period of time.
..Let the Super Rich honestly reduce the value of the property through depreciation and then arrive at the indexation benefit.....Well, nobody will Talk about this.....
Raghav Chadda was using bogus valuation to attack the govt. In almost NO market in India, including 3rd and 4th tier cities and towns, has the long term growth rate of property since 2001 been only 6% and is closer to 10% and higher. In these cases, it is almost always beneficial to use the flat 12.5% tax without indexation which benefits shorter term holdings with lower growth rates.
Jhandu h kya bhai? Calculation kar ek baar
We want LTCG on stock market to be removed . Like if you agree
Why does she keep tilting her head to the left? (Is the teleprompter tilted?😅)
Loose bearings.
It’s stupid project think this is relaxation. It’s only for old properties. Any property you purchase from now on will not have indexation benefit. So unless your property grows at more than 9% you are actually paying more tax on every new property. As growth rates keep slowing down realty also grows at a lower pace. So you will end up paying not tax than before. This is NIRMA TAX don’t forget
So called finance minister 😂😂
ایسا لگتا ہے الیکشن کمشنر راجہ پاکستان کا سب سے سپریمٹی ہے کوئی بھی عدالت کوئی بھی حکومت اس کے سامنے کچرا ہے
Thankyou Sitaramanji and Modiji.
why thanks? Did they give anything new?
Fool
we should thanks Rahul ji.. not them
Dah! No thanks!
Thank Raghav chaddha instead and chidambaram for keeping LTCG zero on equity for 14 years.
We heard the people, are you heard?? Why middleclass men pay 60% tax, shame to FM, if you want to do good for India, resign your job and save tax payer money .
This is tax india,
which middle class pays 60%? r u nuts?
If you want to buy ₹100 as it's fair price, you earn ₹143 rupees (30% tax deducted you get 100 rs)
Then GST on average 18%..
For ₹ 18 GST you spent you have to earn ₹21 after deduction you can spent ₹18.
Total ₹164 you have earn for spent ₹100..
What you get from govt minimum basic hospital or educational facilities not provided..
This is tax india
@@eswarroy2103 it didn't start yesterday. We've been paying more since 6 decades. It's coming down gradually and facilities for the money is increasing. The roads, infra, law & order everything needs money. Up to 10 lakhs per person income can escape without paying any direct tax if planned judiciously. Even developed countries take more taxes even though their population density is 1/10 of India and everyone pays. Here 98% effectively don't pay income tax considering 5 L exemption limits. AND tax of 60 on 160 is 35%, not 60. Getvur facts right & learn how things have been historically.
@@Orundaok so since 6 decades, if we have been paying tax like this, what services have we got? Cleaner country? Good road facilities? Good hospital facilities? Atleast basics? No sht! Everything is going into politician’s pockets. Just corruption!
Govt collecting taxes like developed country and provided services like a poooooor country
Shame to every tax payer, govt here is collecting taxes and distribute to their friends a1,a2
The worst ever.
More than giving amendments Ragav chadas senseless speech wad aired. Wad it a promo if ragav? Senseless
Most disgusting behaviour.
First Clear The IT Returns Process 🙏Your Doing Too Much Delay
India towards TAX terrorism.😢
Gonzalez Brian Thomas Ronald White Matthew
Hope govt will allow so called middle class to survive
She should have removed indexation benefits with LTCG 7% FOR all kind of properties