Ford F150 3.73 vs 3.31 Gears (5L Coyote V8) | Which Tows Better??
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 чер 2024
- I review the 2024 Ford f150 with the 5L coyote V8 engine and compare 3.73 gears to the standard 3.31 gears when it comes to towing performance. I compare fuel economy (MPG), acceleration, power, and how these trucks pull through the Appalachian mountains. How much better is the 5L coyote with the higher 3.73 gear set - we find out.
What I Use:
Engine Oil - amzn.to/4aEbtNE
Engine Oil Filter - amzn.to/3J1nDUM
Engine Air Filter - amzn.to/3JMmMVV
Cabin Air Filter - amzn.to/3JMZAHh
Gear Oil - amzn.to/3PoIcxa
Penetrating fluid - amzn.to/3EOclkx
Rust protection - amzn.to/3Zo0Rh6
Towing Gear:
10 ton Pintle hitch (2.5" receiver) - amzn.to/3r7Axvm
7 Ton Adjustable hitch (2" receiver) - amzn.to/46i2iAf
Adjustable Pintle hitch mount (2.5" receiver) - amzn.to/3RqHGS3
15 Ton Pintle hitch - amzn.to/45SaCqv
10,000lbs Tie Down Straps - amzn.to/3ZBnxeh
My Camera Gear:
Go Pro Hero 10 - amzn.to/3ObZdJJ
Go Pro Hero 8 - amzn.to/36grzkM
Go Pro Accessories - amzn.to/3JLhlXo
Sony A6400 - amzn.to/3vkqzob
Today we are doing something I've wanted to do for a while and that is compare different gear sets in a truck. on paper a higher gear set like the 3.73's in this ford F150 with the 5L coyote v8 should perform better then the standard 3.31 gears.
the reason is because 3.73 give the driveline a mechanical advantage for putting down more torque to the wheels then 3.31. this in tern gives the truck better acceleration and better towing performance when under load.
the downside of higher gearing is that the engine will have to rotate faster to maintain the same speed. this in turn can result in poor fuel economy. throughout out comparison today we go over fuel economy and we do see that indeed the higher 3.73 gears drink more fuel when towing on my towing loupe.
gearing is pretty simple but sometimes I find the number can be hard to grasp. at the end of the day if you want to tow more weight and have an easier towing experience putting in a higher gear like 3.73 gears will give your truck a mechanical advantage and will performance better.
00:00 - Intro
02:03 - Off-The-Line Acceleration Test
03:10 - Highway Acceleration Test
04:16 - 3.73 vs 3.31 Gears Explained
07:20 - First Impressions
09:05 - Fuel Economy
09:23 - Pulling Hills
13:41 - Conclusion - Авто та транспорт
Higher gear is 3.31. Lower is 3.73. Some people have no clue.
A 4 cycle engine fires each cylinder every 2 rotations of the engine.
Divide the cylinders by 2 and we come up with 4 power strokes per rotation with that engine.
4 times 3.31, and the 3.31 gets 13.24 "power impulses" for each tire rotation.
The 3.73 gets 14.92 impulses, or 1.68 more impulses per tire rotation.
More energy is given per rotation, but it adds up fast when you rotate the tire 7 or 8 hundred times per mile driven.
I like the breakdown! makes sense.
Your math is great, but doesn't take into account the transmission. Your numbers only apply in typical high gear, 1:1.
4 stroke.
All engines have 1 complete cycle.
You have a transmission too. And one with 10 speeds at that. Your math was probably more important when trucks had 4 speed transmissions and torque well under 400 ft-lbs
The higher the number, the "lower" the gearing. 3:73 is a "lower" gear ratio than 3.31.
If you hadn't said it, I and probably many others, would have.
Maybe folks who pretend to teach via video should actually learn first, then teach. It might also be good to have someone proofread or proofwatch their stuff. It would save a lot of the ol' egg-on-face syndrome.
@@hotflashfoto - I actually typed a lot more than that. Then I proof read it and decided to just keep it simple. I do that a lot sometimes. It's a good way to blow off steam without making a arse of myself in the process. ;-)
As a rancher, it always surprises me that the vast majority of truck owners know absolutely nothing about gearing. Anytime I ask someone what type of gearing they have, they usually say they don’t know. Even people towing camper trailers don’t know. When someone says that their truck is really bad it towing, and they say Fords suck at towing, Chevys suck, or Rams suck, it’s because it probably sucks because they are clueless about the gearing in their truck, and they’re probably towing illegally.
Most people today are just plain ignorant or speaking out of their ass.
You are right and I would guess about half of the trucks out there on the road towing anything are over payload. They will look at the tow capacity of the truck and assume they are okay. They often won’t look at pin weight or payload.
You are correct. As a teenager I learned a lot about engines and the importance of the rear end gear ratios. Added that I worked around truck drivers, I learned even more.
you can put it more simple : vast majority of people are ignorant, or dumb, or both.
that’s pretty harsh. Some people are just more in tuned or intuitive about the mechanics of trucks. I’m still learning and I’m in my 60’s, with the newer trucks and their technology.
So what this video actually proves is that gearing *almost* doesn't matter. The slower 3.73 gear DOES help in first gear. The total gear ratio for the 3.31 gears is 15.56:1 compared to 17.53:1 with the 3.73. so the 3.73s will help you get a heavier load moving. But from there you have to account for both the transmission and rear end gear. And since the transmission has multiple ratios, at certain speeds, the 3.31s actually have an advantage over the 3.73s. Your tow test demonstrated this perfectly, despite your attempts to bury the evidence. The 3.73 truck *feels* more powerful because you are comparing gear for gear. Of course it has more torque in 5th gear than the 3.31 in 5th. But at the speed you were driving, the 3.31s pulled in 5th gear for a total of 5.03:1 torque multiplication, compared to the 3.73 gears at 4.77:1. This is why the 3.31 truck did not have to downshift. It had more torque available to it because it was running in 5th gear. If the test speed were increased slightly or decreased slightly, such that the 3.31 truck were to shift to 6th, or the 3.73 truck could have remained in 5th, then the test would have shown different results. The point being that the truck will try to make the ratio it needs via the transmission, regardless of what gear is in the rear end. The only time the rear end gear truly matters is in 1st gear when getting the load moving, and 10th gear when trying to minimize rpm on the highway.
Regarding the 3.73 truck kicking down to 4th rather than 5th-- this is a cruise control logic issue. The pcm wants to keep the truck in the fastest gear it can maintain speed in, so it resists downshifting until a certain speed below the set point is reached. Seems to he 5 kmh below set point. Once that threshold is reached, the truck is downshifting with intentions of returning to the set speed, not maintaining. So it downshifts twice for extra torque to bring the truck back up to speed. If it downshifted sooner it could do a better job of maintaining speed in 5th rather than a double kickdown, but it would require a narrower bandwidth on the set speed
This comment needs a pin
Thank you for a great video Alex, always enjoy your true to life information. I am a retired Ford senior master technician in Texas and I really like how you explain truck differences. I currently drive a 2023 F150 5.0 Tremor, a 2023 Whipple charged F150 5.0 Platinum and a 2024 base Raptor pickup. I love your content and just wanted to give you a shout out of recognition to your content. My father in law drives an 06 Power Wagon (and I am his mechanic) so I am quite versed in Ford, Chevy and Dodge trucks. I am glad that you see some benefits that Ford trucks offer, but also respect that you own the Power Wagon. Please keep up the great content! Thank you for your hard work that you obviously put into your videos.
I tow a 5000lb TT 24 foot, 2014 F150 5.0 3.55 i tow about 8000km a year and get around 12 mpg cnd. I try to drive around 63mph in 4th or 5th gear. Tows like a dream
I also shift it manually when towing as I like to control it when in rolling hills.
The 63 mph is a sweet spot for many tow vehicles. All of my tow vehicles (2 Tahoes, a 1500 Silverado, and a 2500HD Silverado) have had that sweet spot that produces the best mpg.
Dude those comparisons are very interesting and informative. Great job 👏
Great video! I’ve been waiting on an explanation like this.
This was a very informative video! Thanks for all that you do.
Thank you sir!
Great comparison video.
I used a 2021 F150 pick up 5 litre with 3.73 gears. Towed a 6x12 double axel trailer. Maybe 5000 lbs plus 500 lbs in the truck bed. Drove this 1400 miles at 65mph and got near 15 mpg.
I'm betting your trailer frontal area is a lot smaller.
This is the kind of comparison that needs to be done! Thank you for a great video!
Thank you sir.
I paid chunk to regear my 2014 f150 3.31 to 4.10's. Wasn't cheap (4x4) but man when I was towing, it was worth it. Everyone said "just tune it" but let me tell you, my tuned 3.31 still couldn't compete with my 4.10's even when stock. Truck just feels like it's working so much less. Granted mine is a 6spd transmission, so the improvement for mine is greater than the improvement on a modern 10spd.
331 would've towed like an absolute dog, I've wondered about even going 3.73 with my 14 5L as i have 355 but it likely wouldn't be noticeable enough to warrant the change. I tow often but also do alot of highway. Feel like 3.55 is the good middle of the road gear, yours probably pulls like a train especially since these are rev happy engines
Hi Alex.
Excellent results numbers in each segment (V6 Biturbo and V8 normally aspirated). That coyote is great for occasional work and recreational trips and with the V8 coyote it is the best! There is no doubt that the coyote became the most efficient! Although my reasoning will always be: large loads and/or towing long distances and with a daily routine; then the best choice will be a diesel. THANK YOU very much for your EXCELLENT COMPARISON AND YOUR COMMENTS!
You are the best Alex, a HUG and BLESSINGS x ALWAYS! 🙏
Big HUG from CDMX; México! 😮
Kinda seemed like there was a mixed bag in terms of impressions on the 3.73s here. Mentioning more shifting, less fuel economy. I have no doubt the 3.73s feel more peppy but the 3.31s seemed to do very well at the speeds you were traveling at, and perhaps they were more advantageous at some of those particular speeds versus the 3.73s. Having the 10-speed really means you can have your cake and eat it too (if it's reliable).
Thank you sir Alex for this incredible film 👏
That's a great test of an F150 with gas. Let me offer a Diesel towing example. I have the standard 2023 6.7 diesel. Gears are 3.31. I tow at 65-70 MPH with my 6,000 lb trailer and get about 15.5 MPG up and down hills. On the flat, it gets about 20 MPG
I just drove it across Oregon and down to Yuba City, Ca. I kept it about 75 and occasionally 80. I got 21.3 MPG on a little over 1,200 miles. The trip down I actually got 22.3 MPG. The hills going back to Portland were quite a bit steeper. the Diesel engine produces fairly flat torque between 1500 and 3000 RPM and it doesn't hit 1500 RPM in 10th gear until I hit 70 MPH.
It's great to see how these trucks perform in the extremes.
Excellent videos man. Any chance you’ll do some tests on the F150 Raptor?
Excellent comparison, i tow with 3.73s in my OBS Chevy and I think the key to towing with them and still get decent fuel economy is to just go a little slower on the highway. Towing our travel trailer and stay between 55&60 mph and I average between 10.5&12 depending on the conditions. I only have three speeds though since I don't tow in overdrive lol.
Alex, another great test video. The mpg's do hurt, but that's the price with towing a trailer. I wonder how the F250 7.3 would compare, times and mpgs? Have a great week.
I'm a happy 3.73 gear owner. I'm glad to see the comparison
It's not a make or break but certainly makes the towing experience easier on the truck.
Better than the Eco on fuel, worse than the 3.31. That all makes sense. I have seen some frustrating shift logic when towing with the 3.73. I have locked out gears 8-10 while towing in some steep, and/or rolling hills. Still was able to get 9-12 mpg towing a 22 foot Airstream at up to 75 mph in those hills. It might rev higher, but it isn't an unpleasant sound track. 😊
You should lock out gears 8-10 when towing anyway.My MaxTow 3.5 when in tow haul mode does not shift past 8
@@jasonbrushett2005 I think 8th gear is one to one in the transmission too.
@@LandParkColby 7th gear is one to one
75 is to fast. What is your hurry?
65 should be the max when towing
If I were towing all the time...like 85% or more or some odd situation where I needed that off-the-line grunt to move something like a loaded farm wagon or whatever, then 3.73's. But with the 10 speed transmission and all those close ratios, it seems the 3.31's would be a more logical choice for overall performance and economy. The 3.31's got the job done just fine with the added benefit of better fuel economy both towing and I'm sure empty driving. The 10 speed transmission is definitely a rear gear equalizer when driving down the road. Almost like having a splitter in a big truck.
Exactly my thoughts…
Agreed, I think the difference is pretty minor with 10 speed transmissions. When we used to have 3 or 4 speeds it would make a lot more difference. Aside from getting the load moving it's not that big of a difference. People get way too worked up about what the best gearing is.
That’s why GM offers only 1 diff ratio, even in the big diesels
I drive a F150 FX4, 5.0 engine, 373 gears, 10 speed trans, I pull trailer with 4wheelers in the ozark mountains. It also has Nitto's Recons 11:00 X 34's. This truck is perfect in the mountains or my drive to work. (lot of power).
@@sledforpeace No, GM does that because they’re lazy and ran by liberals.
Seems to me that the takeaway is that many-speed transmissions eliminate the need for shorter final drive ratios.
The difference is only in the first gear and 10th gear.
No you still need the lower (numerically higher) gear ratio to pull loads.
@darryladams519 Did you watch the video? Yea, the shorter ratio pulled harder from a stop, but neither struggled much. Once moving there wasn't much difference at all.
You are correct. Unless you’re always in 1st gear or reverse there is no need for the super low rear end gearing.
I'm going to re-gear my rear-end from 4.11 to 1.89. But I'm gonna put a 65 spd transmission in .
“If I liked the video “!! Of course
Great job man
Awesome comparison, I'd love to see this same video with the gm 3.0L Diesel
Those suckers are hard to get! but would love to see this with the 3L Duramax
4.56's did wonders for my old 4.6 2v truck, with regards to towing.
Man what are your rpms on the highway?
@@ramsesgonzalez5193 I had 33's on that truck, but about 2k at 60
can you do a fuel mileage test with 3.73 vs 3.31 also?
I know e85 isnt available everywhere but that is a major reason I bought the 5.0. It gains big time without a tune running e85 and it will tow my 7k enclosed around 2600 rpm. If all you ever plan to run is 87, obviously the 3.5 will be stronger but just throwing e85 in the tank closes that gap big time, granted mpg tanks but e85 is also 20-25% cheaper than 87 so it works out.
Now you need to order a custom flex fuel tune for both trucks from reputable 5L F150 tuners like All Motor Research Labs, or an OZ tune, and put E85 (or 91/93 if you must use pump gas) in the tank, and really experience how potent these 18+ 5L/10R80 trucks can be with just a basic tune. You'd be surprised at how well these trucks respond to good gas, and a tune. Factory tuning is ultra conservative, and withholds a ton of timing from the engine to let it live happy on 87 octane with a 12:1 CR. Also the tuning on the transmission is much improved with these tuners.
I assume this is e85 ethanol and not e85r ethanol? What sort of mileage decrease would you expect running e85?
@@ryananderson6321 just E85 you buy at the pump. At the pump they claim it has an octane rating of 105, but that its actual content can be anywhere from E70-E85. Still a much higher octane than premium octane pump gas, and the beauty of flex fuel is it will self adjust to match whatever you're running in the tank. Some tuners want to give you 4-5 different tunes for this fuel of that fuel. The heck with that. Mustang with 5L, or F150 with EB are nit factory flex fuel, but the gas cap on the F150 5L is yellow indicating that it is factory flex fuel. Use it and let it self adjust to whatever fuel mixture is in your tank and whatever situation you're in. All this, "I got a 87 tune, and a 91 tune, and a 93 tune, and a tow tune, and blah, blah, blah. Piss on that, leave that to them Egobewst's. (I own a 17 3.5L/10R80 501A truck as well) That why I push AMRL and OZ so much. Their tunes embrace the factory flex fuel setup, and use it, where most every other tuner want to give you tunes for any given octane of situation, but what if you get some crappy gas, or what if your mixture of filling up a previous tank of 87 with E85 only yields 97 octane instead of 105? IDK why Lund, or PBD, or other big 5L tuners don't adopt flex fuel when tuning the F150. It doesn't compromise overall power/performance like adaptive tunes for EB do.
Its MPG's are pretty piss poor on E85. Think GEN2 Lightning, or GEN Tundra 5.7L type MPG's. Still that's expected. It takes more E85 to = X energy than it does gasoline. I've seen where some people with 21+ trucks that use cylinder deactivation can cruise around between 16-17 MPG. In my 18 I get in a 13 MPG range. Still worth it for the power, as it's over $1.00 less a gallon than premium, so in the long run it kind of equals out, and I personally am not going to run around on 87 octane with a 12:1 CR regardless of what the OEM claims.
Here's a bone stock 4x4/crewcab with an OZ tune.
ua-cam.com/video/1XrsIZd4IjE/v-deo.htmlsi=4F7DuMsYVuAMmteb
Here's a 2WD/crewcab, with a ported Boss 302 manifold, a ram air intake, LT's, and deleted cats, running an AMRL tune and E85 in the tank.
ua-cam.com/video/Vv_OGA7oKF8/v-deo.htmlsi=_vDykPe1K3x7m-v0
If I knew I would tow with a 5L, I'd order the 3.9-ish or 4.11 axle. The latter WILL reduce the MPG, BUT gain you about 4000 Lbs of "towing capacity" by Ford's website. "If you ain't got HP, you better have gears." The late Mr. Springer, a 50 year GAS 115-165 HP semi driver who taught me to drive a Triplex transmission.
My 2020 F150 has 3.55 gears. I have the best of both worlds.
You also have the worst of both worlds lol
Mine has 3.55 as well, wish I had 3.73 because sometimes I tow at the edge of 1/2 ton sanity.
Great video! The other towing factor not discussed, is downhill. I have a '16 Ram 1500 with 3.92 ratio. My wife used to have a '14 Ram 1500 with 3.21 ratio. Speed control going downhill was way better with my trucks 3.92 ratio.
One day, she went and traded in her truck for a brand new Ram 2500 6.7L Cummins with the 3.42 ratio, just to get the VGT turbo exhaust brake. Of course that Cummins gets awesome fuel economy using Hot Shot Secret EDT and that tall ratio gearing. But since the 6.7L has excess torque. The two missing gears of the six speed vs eight speed and the tall ratio are not a problem.
I wish my 21 Tundra had a 10 speed auto!!
I’d be grateful these engines don’t spin bearings!!
I've been towing Rv's for 40+ years. Old school no replacement for displacement was whisked away for me when I got my 2015 F150 with a 3.5L ECO with a 3.31. This was the Heavy Tow option pkg. I towed a 7200# travel trailer. Tows it like a dream up and down the hills & mtns here in the Pacific NW. I also had a 2020 F150 with the V-8 & 3.73rear. I actually preferred the ECO for towing. The twin turbos make torque! Now have a F350 with 3.73 rear & 7.3L Godzilla & 8400# trailer. About the same tow with more stability. MPG's on all 3 are very, very close to the same at 10.3 mpg +/- 0.1 mpg. I've never gone below 7 mpg's & that was with a good sized head wind. Not sure how you got 5-6 mpg's? Totally agree the higher numbered rear will move a load better though. Its all about getting it started and keeping in the TQ range.
TURBOS KILL ENGINES....GOOD LUCK
@@billw8476 Do you own one that gave you a problem?? I sold mine 3 years ago with no issues and the new owner to this day has had no issues. I was hesitant at first due to the small cu.in. size but a friend with one several years old and over 100k miles hauling a track hoe had nothing but praise. I'd buy another one in heartbeat. Lots of "war stories" but actual problems are no different than any other engine. Turbos have been used for many years in many engines. Honda, Toyota & Ram have gone to them as well.
Good video. While not directly relevant, I'm surprised you didnt give a courtesy-mention that the 3.31 gears are a 8.8" differential while the 3.73 come with a 9.75" diff.
Great video! I have the 6.7 ho power stroke and broke my brain going between the 3:31 and 3:55. I got the 3:31 and the thing is a rocket. I wonder how they'd do with the tq from the diesel.
3.55 is a happy median
yes or 3.45
3.73 is the best all around for 6 speed, 8/10 speed a 3.55.
That's what I have on my '18 5L and the 3.55 is nice for road trips and but it's a little bit sluggish when towing a big box trailer. The transmission temp is always pinned in the middle and my MPG is usually around 12 when going 70mph
Yeah I have the 3.55 gears ⚙️ in my 2021ram1500 classic great for towing my boat 😊
@@TomStarcevich-fb3qo same 2013 4x4 short bed ram tow a 6000lb airstream
Did you test downhill engine braking performance between the two? I have a 2018 Silverado 5.3 6 speed with the heavy tow package and 3.73 gears and the engine braking is nowhere near as good as my dad's 2015 Sierra with 5.3 and 3.43 gears.
Would be interesting to see a similar comparison with the 7.3 gasser and 4.30s vs 3.73 or even 3.55s
My 7.3 with 4.30 gears pulls harder than my dad’s 7.3 with 3.55 gears, but the 3.55 isn’t available any longer. It’s only 3.73 and 4.30. But the 4.30 gears are jumpy in traffic til I put it in eco mode. My dad gets 1mpg better, which is significant. Our trucks have 48 gallon tanks so he can go about 42 miles further on each tank before the “low fuel” light kicks on.
@@cliffordmontana4562 I have the 4.30 with the diesel and don't find it bad in traffic. The biggest issue is that you are in 10th by 45 mph.
@@rich7447 Maybe it’s programmed different with the gas engine, or maybe the little bit of turbo lag the 6.7 has makes it feel less jumpy. I don’t know. And yes, my gas truck is in 10th gear at 45 mph as well. If I’m driving on roads under 50mph I lock out 10th gear and cruise in 9th.
@@cliffordmontana4562 It definitely could be related to the difference in power delivery. The rev range for the powerband is a lot different with the 7.3 vs the 6.7. You are almost past my redline at idle. LOL.
The truck also doesn't give me full power in the first two or three gears (traction control).
Good video. Didn’t catch the weight you were towing or the tow rating of each truck.
I have an f-150 with 3.73 gears. I wouldn't want it any other way. I don't tow all the time but when I do tow the gear really helps.
love your vids.. you struggled on this one to prove a point that was working against you lol, old school drivers knows lower gearing, or a higher gear ratio so I don't het slammed is better for towing heavy loads, if you had a manual trans and not relied on computers to determine what the truck does people would understand better
I ordered a '24 STX 5.0 supercab with the max tow pkg (3.73) as I'm hoping to pull a 26-ft Grand Design toy hauler (Momentum 21G) that's about 9K lbs when loaded with a Can-Am 3-wheeler.
Gearing doesnt matter as much as it used to. With the amount of gears these new transmissions have (10 in this case) the truck has many gears to choose from while towing. Back in the day when trucks had a 4 or 5 speed transmissions, you’d want to choose your rear end gearing to optimize torque at the speed you want to tow at.
So in this case you actually are better off with the 3.31 for towing that weight at that speed. The 3.73 couldn’t maintain speed in 6th so it had to downshift. The 3.31 maintained speed without downshifting because it was putting the necessary torque to the wheels.
Seems like the 10-speed auto mitigates much the need for a 3.73, at least after you get out of first from a standstill?
It does performance wise, but the 3.73 upgrades to a 9.75” rear axle which handles more weight than the 8.8” with the 3.31.
Big heavy tires like lower gearing.
Good video Alex.....you just proved that regardless of rear axle ratio,the 3.5 Ecoboost is better than both of those 5.0's when it comes to towing performance😊.Maybe try a 3:55 axle next time.
I don’t think anyone has ever disputed that! The disputes always center around long term durability.
He would have to get a 2020 or older to test a 5.0L with 3.55s.
Will factory wheel size make a mpg difference? My 2024 5.0L with 3.73 has 20” factory wheels.
Total tire diameter impacts gearing. Bigger diameter tires are like taller gears. Wheel diameter won't change gearing if tire diameter is the same. Heavier wheels and tires affect unsprung weight. Harder to go, stop, or turn.
2022 RCSB 5.0 4x4. 4.10 @ torsen front 4.09 @ clutch posi rear. 22x9 Ford aluminum wheels 46psi 285/55/22 GO15 Yokohama tires. Basically 3.73 effective gear ratio. Truck rips avg 19+ 60-65 @ 17+ @ 70-80mph. Have towed 6,900lbs of steel in my dump trailer (3,300lbs) for a total of 16,860lbs @ avg 60mph with no problems. Have a ladder rack @ aluminum tool box in bed. New F150 is under rated in what it is capable of doing with the right gears ,wheels and tires. Stock not so much.....
Even comparing different years with the same axle ratios but more gears in the transmission can make a huge difference. A five speed vs. an eight speed, you will definitely notice a differenc.
On the Transcontinental Railroad the steeps grades are in the Appalachians, and the steepest Interstate grade is in the Appalachias.
Great video though Ive never heard anyone say High gearing for a higher numerical gear set and visversa.
I have been playing with HP tuners, tuning, and towing with the 10 speed. There are some odd combos of weight and gear ratio with the 10 speed. If your speed and load are just right, you get the double downahift problem as noted on the 3.73 in this video. Thia is a transmission tuning problem and does hurt fuel mileage. The lower gear (3.73) in this case, should have less "space" between gears and be able to find the perfect RPM for every load, but the double downshift issue seems to negate the advantage. If one would manual shift, in this situation, the 3.73 gear truck would probably never drop in to 4th gear to run this loop. But thats just a work around for poor calibrating on Fords part. Its interesting because fuel mileage is gained when it hangs onto 6th gear "too long" but the downside is that when it finally has to shift, it misses 5th gear all together and hits 5000 rpm in 4th. A shift back to 5th when speed drops to 105 kph instead of hanging on to 102 and then going to 4th is the right adjustment for this combo.
even tho i hardley ever use my truck s a truck...when i order it i always go for the lowest(higher number) gear i can..so 4.10 or 3.92 or whatever. Because when i spend 75-90k on a truck today i want it to have the most truck capability. And one thing i hate is putting the cruise on....and getting to a hill and having the tranny downshift..i want it to just smoothly cruise
You should have to pass certain tests to qualify for towing or even qualify to use a truck to be honest. People just load up their truck and/or trailer and hit the road. Now they’re an expert truck driver.
In reality, most people don’t know anything about gearing, weight limits, payload capacity etc.
Before engines had the torque and horsepower of today’s trucks gear ratios were the only means of ensuring a decent ability to tow with relative ease. My last two pickups I ordered with 3:73 axel gears because I lived in a mountainous region and towed a lot. If I were to buy a new pickup I would consider a gear ratio that delivers a wee bit better fuel economy, not something so tall.
The 3.31 paired with the 3.5 is pretty solid. The 5.0 does best with the 3.73
I have the 3.55 paired with the 3.5. I had the 3.31 with my last 3.5 Night and day difference. I will never get the 3.31s again
Agreed the 3.73 seem to make the 5L feel the best to drive
3.5 with 3.73
@@TheGettyAdventures CORRECT!
With a 10 speed and all the ratios it has, final drive gearing means much less than it ever has. Back when we only had 4 gears it made a much bigger difference. If you want the best towing option you probably need to look at the 3.5 EB.
I tow a 30 foot camper with my 2014 F-150 5.0with 3.55 gears and it gets roughly 32L/100km and tows it fine in my opinion. Ive never felt under powered. Maybe my "old" truck is better then these "new" ones 😂. 3.55 seems to be a great all around gear ratio in my opinion
I have same truck 5000lb 24 foot TT doing 62mph I get around 12mpg wind is the biggest factor
I hope you get to do a highway fuel economy test without the trailer. I’m curious how much of a hit the 3.73 will take on the freeway at 70+ miles per hour compared to the 3.31….if there is even a significant hit at all.
I certainly do sir! and its a mind bender to say the least!
@@TheGettyAdventures awesome! Can’t wait to see the results. Love your channel!!
I towed with a 3.5L Tacoma and got 9 mpg over 180 miles.
I have a 2021 5.0L with 1:00 1:00 3.31 gear ratio and plan to tow 5klb travel trailer. What is the cost to change over to 3.73 and who do you go to for that? Ford dealership? Is that even an option. Tx
My 2011 Ram 4x4 with 5.7 hemi. It has 3:92 gears and has always towed anything i hook it to effortless.
The "higher" numbers (3.73) is a LOWER gear ratio over a lower number 3.31. Said differently, a 3.31 is a higher gear ratio over a 3.73.
I have 3.73 gears in my 2.7 and it does surprisingly well towing
Gearing was a bigger issue back in the day of 3 and four speed transmissions. With todays 8-10 speeds. To can go to a higher gear like the 3.31 gear. The extra drop in gears (going from 6 to 4) is due more to the program if in the computer. If you had a transmission that was only 1/1 or a direct drive you might need 450 hp to get up the hill. The truck doesn’t produce that. So it splits the gears and compounds the house and torque. The computer lets the rpm drop to conserve fuel then drops two gears to make sure it’s at peak hp. Companies are all about mpg now adays. The lower gear will always be better for towing loads but mpg seems to be what companies are going for the most.
I average 9.2 towing 9200lbs with my 5.4l expedition, 18 while not towing. Yes, i k ow I'm towing a ton over what its rated for. No, it doesnt cause me any ill issues. 3.55 gearing.
It's not quite that simple.
In the bad old days most everyone had 3 or 4 widely spaced gears in the trans and you were in high gear on the highway except on very steep grades. With only a few transmission ratios and a 1:1 top gear, the axle ratio meant far more. The difference between 4.10 and 3.54 gears (15.8%) was substantial in a Dodge with a 150-ish hp 318 and 727. The difference between 3.73 and 3.31 is only 12.7% and the 10-speed can run one gear lower to (over)compensate. With 400 hp from a direct injected 5.0 and 10 forward gears it's a whole new era and axle ratio doesn't mean nearly as much as it once did.
By chance do these trucks have advanced trailer options where the weight of the trailer is programmed into the truck? Maybe the trailer value was different between them so it dropped 2 gears thinking the trailer was heavier? Or something like that.
Could be worse though, I had a diesel zgMC Terrain and in order to downshift it from 6th to fifth I had to pull the switch for manual on the dashboard and at 65 MPH it dropped to 4th and like 3000 RPM! Just screaming that poor little thing. Thankfully I was then able to click it in 5th. I learned to put it in manual limited shift and just click the top gear allowed to 6th so it would drive normal then bump it to 5th before I got to the hill. Worked like a charm.
Did the trucks have similar tires?
As a basic rule always order a truck with the lowest gear set and biggest engine available if you want to use it for truck stuff.
3.31 is a diesel truck gear set and even to high for diesel s with twice the torque of a little gaser
Modern semi trucks use 2.15 - 2.64 as standard rear ratios , no loss in pulling power at all. Gear reduction is handled in the transmissions
Wrong.
Exact same truck just different years right?
Remember when back in the 60s n 70s, it was common to potion muscle cars with 3.73, 4.10, 4.30, 3.31 gearing. Now the best one ive seen in modern muscle cars is 3.09. Higher gearing is now for towing
I towed a 14 foot enclosed aluminum trailer with my 2012 ford f150 with 5.0l 6 speed tranny and 3.55 gears from Minnesota to Wyoming and back and average 7 mpg for the trip. Average speed was about 70mph the whole trip on the interstate. Trailer was loaded with 2 atvs and some camping/hunting gear
Something must be wrong lol.
My 2014 has 35 inch tires, 3:55s and with a 16 foot enclosed, and about 7000lbs total it gets 11mpg doing 70mph
Yeah what he is saying is not even feasible. You will be lucky to see 7mpg on an unloaded truck. My ram 1500 ecodiesel could get 8mpg with nothing but me and was tuned/deleted and doing less than 120 km/h.
Funny, this is done in Amerika with metric measurements.
I like you calling the flatlands mountains.
You make great videos, sir, and I watch many of them, and maybe this was corrected elsewhere in the video or comments....
However, higher gearing is NOT the bigger number, like 3.73.
3.73 is the 'lower' gearing, even if it has a larger number.
Keep on Truckin.
-
Edit...
The bigger number, 3.73:1 in this case, does give a mechanical advantage as you say, as gearing multiplies torque. However, the higher number is a 'lower gearing', not a higher.
re-geared my 2014 f350 from 3.73 to 4.56's.. in the Pacific Northwest it makes a huge difference when you go from sea level to 3k or 5k in only a few miles. Truck pulls the hills so much easier, that being said, it is not a highspeed long distance truck, unless your towing the whole time.
What engine?
@@johnhahn8464 6.2 gas
@@tarster what's you mpgs now?
@@johnhahn8464best I ever got stock 14.9, regularly got 13 - 13.5, now I get solid 10, maybe 11 at best.
the older one that can run on E85 should test that see how much better it can tow on E85
It all depends upon what speed youre wanting to tow at...and where your drivetrain makes its power 😊
Transmission and tire size also play a huge roll in gearing, or the perception of it. A truck with 33” tires, 4.10 gears and a 4 speed won’t tow as well as the same truck with a 3.73 gear ratio, and the same truck with a 10 speed and a 3.42 will even tow better, if you drop a gear or two in the 10 speed with a 3.42 it will be at about the same RPM as the truck with the 4.10 at the same speed, but it will have a lower first gear and closer gear splits so it won’t feel like it’s working as hard.
You keep recommending the 3.73 but the only point it was any better was off the line. The 10spd is really a bit of an outlier when it comes to traditional thoughts on gearing because the transmission itself has so much more mechanical advantage that vesicles have traditionally had. And sub 6mpg is appalling. My old 15 truck with the 6spd managed 9.5 pulling just shy of 11,000 lbs over a roughly 500 mile loop. That truck also has a mustang manifold that likes rpm, 3.31s and a taller tire than factory. I’d take it over that 3.73 truck any day of the week
It has nothing to do with pulling power and everything to do with weight handling. The 3.73 upgrades the rear axle to a heavier duty 9.75” rear axle. The 3.31 comes with the standard 8.8” rear axles. The 9.75” holds 1000 more lbs of direct weight on it than the 8.8”. That’s why he keeps recommending the 3.73. Why do you think the max tow package for the 5.0 automatically includes the 3.73?
The only thing more heavy duty about the 9.75 is the center chunk. They both have 3.25 axle tubes but the S8.8 gets thicker walled tubes
@@tylerphelps4868 well there’s actually 2 different variants. There’s a standard 9.75” and a 9.75HD
The 3.73 had to downshift because the total mechanical advantage wasn't enough to satisfy engine load based on the calibration. Total mechanical advantage (4.75) = transmission ratio (1.275(6th) ) X differential ratio (3.73). The 3.31's were at 5.03 = 3.31*1.520. The chosen vehicle speed adds to this all.
I have the 3.55 rear end in my 2013 F-150. I pull a 6k Black Series HQ15. 3.55 is a good gear ratio for fuel economy and the 5.0 Coyote power makes up for this gear ratio.
Can someone explain why I can’t ad the tow/haul package to the 2024 f150 5.0 3.73. It’s saying I need to ad the 3.5L instead
With a modern 10 speed transmission, my choice would be the taller gearing (3.31) all day, shifting isn’t a bad thing, that’s why the tranny has 10 gears. The better fuel economy towing and empty is worth it. If the trailer is much over 8000 lbs, I’d rather be towing with a 3/4 ton anyway.
Did you not watch the video?
Yes I did.
@@ambassadorofconciliation 5.0s suck down low. 3.31s are for empty daily drivers, not tow rigs. Nobody that tows often would willingly give up the mechanical advantage and an easier life for the engine and trans for .8 mpg.
✌️ Honestly, if I was towing anything of consequence OFTEN, I probably would not buy a 5.0 half ton with either 3:31 or 3:73.
Bro the critical part of all this is that the transmission has 10 gears. The 3.73 vs 3.31 is going to make very little difference from like 3rd to 8th gear maybe even 1 more on each side. The 3.73 has the biggest effect on the extremes of the tranny gearing. So you are gonna take off right from a stop faster, and your top gear will hang around a little higher rpm than the 3.31. But there are 8 other gears for the transmission to adjust from in between. For a ten speed I’d just choose the middle gear set 3.55 and let the transmission figure it out unless you tow really heavy. One thing the 3.73 does do though is take a little bit of mechanical stress away from the transmission by letting it spin a little faster for the same speed output. A 3.73 would be a little more practical in a truck with less transmission gearing. Like my 2011 f150 with the 6 speed. Otherwise like a said, the biggest notice will be in 1st and 10th on the new truck.
Torque is mechanical advantage which reduces effort to move a weight. The bicycle could better explain the relationship of drive gear at the axle and the transmission looking at the bicycle having only one gear at the back wheel. Deciding which size of gear which is better depends on value engine effort vs distance desired (think as how many pedal strokes on a bicycle going up a hill).
Which ratio is better for road trips without a trailer?
Depend what you consider better? The 3.31 will show better mpgs but the 3.73 will be quicker(faster)
Judging from the downshifts on the hills, it almost sounds like the truck with the 3.73 gears is missing some hp/torque somewhere.
Maybe should do an empty 0-100 run to show how much quicker the truck gets up to speed…and highway RPM
I think that would be cool but I do an empty fuel economy comparison between the two also!
Do a premium vs regular gas’s test on the ecoboost
That would be interesting. on paper it should help but my guess would be in the real world you won't see much difference. BUT I could be wrong lol
lot of new gm trucks/ suburban -Tahoe , toyota tundra sequoia have 3.21 or 3.23
Dude, you need to understand gear ratios before talking about them. A 3.73 is a lower gear ratio than a 3.31. Numerically it's a higher number but in gear ratio speak it is lower.
Took the words right out of my mouth. When I started watching I was like wait a minute. LOL
I was thinking that too, but I think he meant numerically. Was just awkward though.😮
He is a big diesel mechanic, he probably knows just didn’t word it well.
He knows what he's talking about. His terminology may be a little off. It's a good thing all the internet experts are here to save the day.
He explained it properly. The higher the number, the more the drive shaft turns for every wheel revolution therefore a higher gear ratio.
My only question and or thought is 2024 is a gen 4 5.0 the 2023 is the 3(.5) gen motor, I wonder if that could also change the outcome?
Whats different between the 23 and 24? I thought they were the same gen?
@@johnhahn8464 I think there is a change in oil pump and a few other things can’t find the difference right now
With the ten speed transmission it probably makes less of a difference than back when there were only three and four speed autos.
My 2010 Tundra 5.7L had a 4.30 gear ratio and was a gas killer with 6mpg towing a 6500lbs boat. 2018 Ram 2500 Cummins pulls the same boat at 13mpg. Easy decision for me.
I find it wild toyota went with such intense gearing. but the high gear ratio probably helps put less stress on the engine and trans with that mechanical advantage. BUT fuel economy as you pointed out takes a large hit lol
@@TheGettyAdventures : I always thought Toyota was going for the higher tow rating and 0-60 times. They figured lower fuel economy would be an acceptable price to pay. It was a great truck and my Ram 2500 will never ride as smooth as the Tundra with the independent front suspension.
lol my f350 6.2 gasser gets 10mpg with 10,000 tt.
My diesel ram work truck gets 10.2 with just a little service body on it. Way under 10,000lbs
Note: If you put bigger tires on your rig you are defeating any advantage of lower gearing.
The answer is obvious. Of course it will tow better. It will accelerate better when not towing also. The trade off is slightly worse fuel economy when taking long highway trips as you will be running a higher rpm. Always buy the higher gear ratio! It will put you in the engines powerband faster. It really depends on matching the rpm that the gears give you to the engines sweet spot.