I’ve watched 30 - 60 minutes at a time of Nautilus Livestreams (live) where they see nothing but boring sandy seabed, so I totally get their enthusiasm when they find something worthwhile, like this.
Bon Sales imagine if you made a joke that you thought was good (which in my opinion it was pretty good and I think a lot of people would agree with me) and then someone goes up to you and says “NOT FUNNY”
Listen. Y'all have posted some fantastic videos before, but this one just blows me away. This is amazing and incredible. I love love love that we got to see this whale fall, and as always, I love the commentary. I am SO grateful for your team!
Octopi is actually an improper plural. As Latin words sometimes are pluralized with an -i, octopus is actually a Greek word, therefor the plural of octopus, is octopuses. :-)
I was wondering if anyone else noticed that. The coolest thing about this project is the number of female scientists in the front seat. At times all the voices on the stream are female. 30 years ago that would not have happened.
@@danm2084 Historically there haven't been a lot of female scientists, or at least they'd be afraid to be in the lime-light, and would get shamed when they do make the decision to speak up. Ladies like Ada Lovelace and Rosalind Franklin were like this. And they had to work under the preview of men like Babbage and Francis Crick, even though they were doing most ofthe legwork ... DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND WE'LL FINALLY GET CUTE LOLI SUPER SCIENTISTS!!!
Emmanuel Lopez female scientists really don’t need to be held to “loli” standards. Marie Curie certainly wouldn’t care for that, she faced a lot of backlash from the scientific community for being a mature, intelligent woman who didn’t care for fulfilling arbitrary beauty standards for publicity purposes. Her work proved her merit without needing to “attract” people in any other way.
@Isaac Carretero the Osedax rogersi! Roger Waters was the first bassist of Pink Floyd. After a 3ish years, he became the main lyricist & semi forerunner of the band for 15 years. (1965 then 1968-1983) The bone eating worm in question, Osedax rogersi, was discovered & named in 2014 along with 2 others O. crouchi & O. nordenskjoeldi. It looks like the researchers made 2 different artificial whale falls & discovered my 2nd favorite bone eating worm. Someone else commented the name, but it took me a while to find & verify
The amount of worms and octopus here remind me of my snail tank. The detritus worms congregate where the snails eat, like they always do. Are these octopus known for having a symbiotic relationship with the worms or are they just there for the carrion itself?
@MacaroniMailbox that something even the scientists seem unsure of, and one gets the impression they are leaders in the field. Now I'm going to have to do some googling.
@@cameronbrickey & MacaroniMailbox: Marine scientist input: Cephalopods are mainly predators while some also occasionally scavenge. So I assume it would be fair that the relationship between the octopus and the worms is rather a trophic one than symbiontic. There are occurrences of symbiontic relationships between octopus and polychaetes inhabiting their epidermis, but I don't think this is the case here.
The funniest thing on these whale fall's is the fish that have eaten so much they can't swim and are just sitting there digesting like they're on a couch after Sunday Dinner! 😂
That was incredible. I've one question: those worms on the left side of the carcass, were they munching on that fish that seems to be either stuck or resting on them (2:19)?
I love hearing all of the excited voices as apparently not what is seen too often??? ...Love the footage that I would personally never have the opportunity to view....THANK you so much for All of this....WAAY Cool!!!
Amazing! Not sure if anyone has asked already, will those bone-eating worms eventually eat up the entire skeleton? Another question would be what would be left typically after these sea aminals finished eating this poor whale?
With time that skeleton will be eventually completely consumed though I don't know if this "bone worms" are responsible for all of that. The same thing happens on land when a large animal dies. An entirely different cast of opportunistic wildlife descend on rhe animal until it is gone!
@@TheNeonwing Cole Pear. Thanks for the clarification. Watching these Nautilus videos is educational and fun watching the researchers get excited about what they are seeing.
@@lament_rue Bullshit. Hollywood (and the other countries' studios) is full of incredibly talented people that produce an enormous amount of original content. The problem is audiences overwhelmingly go to watch franchise movies, not original ones. 95% of the big hits are franchise movies, so Hollywood obviously feels they're a safer bet and invests in those a lot more. If original movies start making 1.5 bln dollars at the box office, Hollywood would start churning them out weekly. But they don't, so Hollywood doesn't.
Great Stuff!! As a former Biology and Chemistry instructor, I find the Monterey area of the sea Truly Fascinating and when I saw this whale fall and 'the critters' feasting......told my daughter, "Its the circle of Life!" She was kinda surprised about bone-eating worms, saw this info very briefly in SoCal museum open house.
Whomever one of the excited women is, you damn well keep on your path of passion. The world of marine biologists lost one of you recently. My cousin, Adrian Dahood-Fritz. I'm glad to know her soul and spirit survives among those who carry forward work such as this. If there's anything after this, may Adrian and Andrew enjoy and take pride in the work ya'll are doing.
i like how all the scientists were like wow, just sound like bunch stoners just each took a bong hit watching cool nature shows on netflix, and then started saying all that science stuff. so cute! they all sound so hippy. ''dinner is served'' lmao
Way more fascinating than this rare whale fall is the even more unique opportunity to hear this collaborative initial description upon discovery. Scientists in situ
Me: expecting concise and articulate discourse about the current stage of the whale fall The expedition team: excitedly chattering about the amazing event like college kids and making whatever this noise is 0:42
Amazing video. Does anyone know what the technical name for the little green dots in the center of the screen is? Where can I see more footage with these in it?
This is so cool. Wow! I’d never heard of this phenomenon before. You should check it out....and the scientists are so excited and passionate! 😊 What creeps would downvote such a beautiful thing? Jeez.
I’ve watched 30 - 60 minutes at a time of Nautilus Livestreams (live) where they see nothing but boring sandy seabed, so I totally get their enthusiasm when they find something worthwhile, like this.
You mean something worthwhale?
Same! Nothing like this ever happens when Im watching live :D
@@dudeinparadise That joke is over-whale-mingly good.
Where can you watch these?
Alexe • I guess look up “Nautilus Live”. They probably don’t livestream 24/7 so you might not find them live.
never would've expected to hear the phrase "do we have any bone-eating worms" in such a cute voice
Scary idea, something that eats your only remains before they fossilize.
And they are supposed to be scientist
“Awwww.. look at the little bone-eating worms!”
Bone hurting juice
@@bru-uh6868 You think scientists can't have fun and enjoy their work with some excitement?
The audio sounds like a discord chat.
Yea it's like a late night farming group lol.
They're human just like we.
@@Baleur you don't say? i thought they were all ethereal consciouses
Really does haha
Exactly. Time to unsubscribe and block.
Octopus, stumbling across this feast: “Whale, whale, whale, what do we have here?”
Dad joke, but a good one. Not too dry, given the context...
@Brendan Thompson I see what ya did there
LMAOLOLOLOLOL 😂
@@marioe.4400 Nice
Everyone always gets the good puns before me! Lol
so glad they said hello to the octopus that was waving. else, just rude.
plot twist: The octopus was asking them to get off his lawn.
1:49 Little guy said “bye bye”
Whoever said bye to the octopus was so cute
It's more likely like "get the f out of my property, am eating right here" he is treathening the naustilus with his fist.. i mean tentacle..
Nothing you liar
@@joeya.4309 octopus like “🖕 no f u, I’m not cute, I’m fierce”
Bone-eating Snotflower Worm is a fantastic metal band name.
Oceancore.
Hillary Clintons "other" middle name. Has a nice ring to it. Hillary Bone-eating Snotflower Worm Clinton 2020
@@woolysamoan Shhhh
wooly samoan lets not bring politics here please
They look exactly like what they were calling zombie worms in an alligator fall video.
whale: *falls*
octopus: “i t ‘ s f r e e r e a l e s t a t e”
Not funny
Evan 74 likes say otherwise
Evan not nice
@@ryomahoffman6803 why can you explain?
Bon Sales imagine if you made a joke that you thought was good (which in my opinion it was pretty good and I think a lot of people would agree with me) and then someone goes up to you and says “NOT FUNNY”
That little octopus wave is to die for 🐙👋🏼
"Woah, WHALE FALL! Ohh HERE WE GO BABY"
Marine biologists are my new favorite people
Thank you!
You’re a pissa haha
hello there sir
Lol daily dose just swooped in and jacked your content. At least he throws u a thanks !
xD
XD lol
_sees dead whale_
Scientists: UWU what’s dis?
OWO bwone eating worms
StarSilverInfinity “oh Yh this is awesome “ 😂
ûwû do we have any bone eating worms?
More like
*Seas* dead whale uwu
@@amoldybiscuit1368 úwù funny joke ôWô
*Octopus waiving*
"Hey I'm on UA-cam!"
Bone eating worms...now we know why no skeletal remains are are left on the Titanic.
Salt water dissolves bone.
Grow For Less it’s a joke
@@dtroystopper2 it was also due to the worms and the sheer pressure
Yes but think of the lobsters and crabs being set free!
Playing With Fire FREEEDOOOOOOM
Whale Carcass: **Exist**
Researchers: *"Somebody tell Twitter!"*
Scientists reaction are so cute
riiLewd that’s why we go into science studies - because we love finding out cool new stuff!
lol they piss me off, just shut up!!!
@@jordach545 no you
the one talking about worms sounds cute
mritachi15 the one talking about the worms sounded the cutest!
when everyone was saying bye to the octopus :') so pure
Listen. Y'all have posted some fantastic videos before, but this one just blows me away. This is amazing and incredible. I love love love that we got to see this whale fall, and as always, I love the commentary. I am SO grateful for your team!
Ummmm its a dead whale...calm your t1ts weirdy
@@stanlee2200 Hope you have a wonderful day!
@@safaiaryu12 yup
the reactions are sooooo sweet!!! appreciate their wonder and excitement very much
Yeah- it reminds me of how we medical folks react to seeing what others think is disgusting.
Very fascinating. What a time we live in where we get to witness such events from the comfort of home.
The infectious excitement from the scientists was incredible
0:42 "uUAAAAAA"
It’s Toad
Thank you showing us that gem of a squeal😂😂😂😂
Remind me the crow in at the roof of firelink shrine
I can’t stop laughing! What was that? LMAO
I believe that OfflineTV is leaking
Octopi be like: Aliens!
lol, UFO.. what if UFO is just alien observing us? hmmm
More like "Thank you, almighty Cthulhu for your generous gift of whale, we feast in your name!"
Octopi is actually an improper plural. As Latin words sometimes are pluralized with an -i, octopus is actually a Greek word, therefor the plural of octopus, is octopuses. :-)
Lol
@Tony So
Isn't the Grecian plural octopodes?
Incoming "Scientists are cute when they are excited" comments
Honestly, i wont be surprised if that octopus was actually waving, given how clever they are
the girl who mentioned the baleen whale baby has SUCH a cute voice lol
“Aliens observe native inhabitants consuming a mysterious creature from the heavens.”
I’m so used to David Attenborough voice style narrating nature videos that female scientist voices sound so cute (and exciting).
I was wondering if anyone else noticed that. The coolest thing about this project is the number of female scientists in the front seat. At times all the voices on the stream are female. 30 years ago that would not have happened.
Too much info there creeper
@@danm2084 I think you missed the point
@@danm2084 Historically there haven't been a lot of female scientists, or at least they'd be afraid to be in the lime-light, and would get shamed when they do make the decision to speak up. Ladies like Ada Lovelace and Rosalind Franklin were like this. And they had to work under the preview of men like Babbage and Francis Crick, even though they were doing most ofthe legwork
...
DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND WE'LL FINALLY GET CUTE LOLI SUPER SCIENTISTS!!!
Emmanuel Lopez female scientists really don’t need to be held to “loli” standards. Marie Curie certainly wouldn’t care for that, she faced a lot of backlash from the scientific community for being a mature, intelligent woman who didn’t care for fulfilling arbitrary beauty standards for publicity purposes. Her work proved her merit without needing to “attract” people in any other way.
-Hiii octopus
-Bye Byee octopus
💕😂
This is the sound of the collective unconscious if I ever heard it..
This is what "when the chaotic group chat's interests sync up" looks like.
When I first started watch I thought they voiced all of the sharks and octoptus who were excited to be there
We all did the "ooh, whalefall!" At the same time
A pistol shrimp was named for Pink Floyd in 2017: The Pink Floyd pistol shrimp (Synalpheus pinkfloydi).
Do you know which worm they're referring to here named after pink floyd?
@Isaac Carretero the Osedax rogersi! Roger Waters was the first bassist of Pink Floyd. After a 3ish years, he became the main lyricist & semi forerunner of the band for 15 years. (1965 then 1968-1983)
The bone eating worm in question, Osedax rogersi, was discovered & named in 2014 along with 2 others
O. crouchi & O. nordenskjoeldi. It looks like the researchers made 2 different artificial whale falls & discovered my 2nd favorite bone eating worm.
Someone else commented the name, but it took me a while to find & verify
The commentary and excitement that is expressed over a whale fall is pure gold!
The octopuses look at the sub like they're gawking at a UFO.
gaud sent me here and im so glad they did because this is genuinely interesting
I watched this with my mouth open. Fortunately, no one to see me...WOW!
This helps remind me that we live in an incredible time. Thank you.
How can watching a dead whale being eatin remind you that we are living in a good time???
@@TheOne-oo6fq because we can see this amazing event from our homes
i dont remember the last time i got as excited for anything as these researchers did over a whale carcass 😂😂😭😭
The amount of worms and octopus here remind me of my snail tank. The detritus worms congregate where the snails eat, like they always do. Are these octopus known for having a symbiotic relationship with the worms or are they just there for the carrion itself?
Perhaps you could say that the worms benefit from the octopi removing the flesh from the bone?
As far as I know this is the first documented instance of octupi scavenging for food. Short answer: nobody knows.
I don't see any worm...
@MacaroniMailbox that something even the scientists seem unsure of, and one gets the impression they are leaders in the field. Now I'm going to have to do some googling.
@@cameronbrickey & MacaroniMailbox: Marine scientist input: Cephalopods are mainly predators while some also occasionally scavenge. So I assume it would be fair that the relationship between the octopus and the worms is rather a trophic one than symbiontic. There are occurrences of symbiontic relationships between octopus and polychaetes inhabiting their epidermis, but I don't think this is the case here.
The funniest thing on these whale fall's is the fish that have eaten so much they can't swim and are just sitting there digesting like they're on a couch after Sunday Dinner! 😂
That was incredible. I've one question: those worms on the left side of the carcass, were they munching on that fish that seems to be either stuck or resting on them (2:19)?
Yeah I was wondering if that fish had died or something. Maybe it's just resting though?
@@SmolPotatowo I watched this all day, and I think all the fish were healthy. Many had gorged and were just "sitting around" though.
@@daemn42 Ah alrighty, thanks for the info!
@@SmolPotatowo They seem to like it and maybe even get parasites removed by the worms.
just fishes bein fishes..... chillin..... nowhere better to hang.......
Yo those octopuses are so chill like they’re literally just vibin bruh
I love hearing all of the excited voices as apparently not what is seen too often??? ...Love the footage that I would personally never have the opportunity to view....THANK you so much for All of this....WAAY Cool!!!
Amazing! Not sure if anyone has asked already, will those bone-eating worms eventually eat up the entire skeleton? Another question would be what would be left typically after these sea aminals finished eating this poor whale?
With time that skeleton will be eventually completely consumed though I don't know if this "bone worms" are responsible for all of that. The same thing happens on land when a large animal dies. An entirely different cast of opportunistic wildlife descend on rhe animal until it is gone!
@@michaeldeierhoi4096 I guess the Worms eat the Bonemarrow and not the actual Bone itself. That is probably done by Bacteria.
The calcium in the bone will also dissolve long after the meat and marrow is stripped from the whale
@@TheNeonwing Cole Pear. Thanks for the clarification. Watching these Nautilus videos is educational and fun watching the researchers get excited about what they are seeing.
@Ben Yu It's not a poor whale! this is the circle of life, it's beautiful :)
God I hope this inspires some talented horror creator. I have so many ideas from this but not near enough skill
Do not worry about skill, Hollywood has no original ideas. Yours will be a blockbuster movie.
Skill comes with practice. You can do it.
@@lament_rue Bullshit. Hollywood (and the other countries' studios) is full of incredibly talented people that produce an enormous amount of original content. The problem is audiences overwhelmingly go to watch franchise movies, not original ones. 95% of the big hits are franchise movies, so Hollywood obviously feels they're a safer bet and invests in those a lot more. If original movies start making 1.5 bln dollars at the box office, Hollywood would start churning them out weekly. But they don't, so Hollywood doesn't.
Inspires about what? Dead whale?
@@TzvetozarCherkezov Hear, hear
In a natural ecosystem, everything has an agent specifically for biodegrading everything. Wow on those worms that digest the bones 😯
Amazing seeing sea creatures at 10,600 feet and being able to withstand that pressure and depth.
0:58 look at that cute little guy on the bottom right staring up like "what is this insanely bright light"
Great Stuff!! As a former Biology and Chemistry instructor, I find the Monterey area of the sea Truly Fascinating and when I saw this whale fall and 'the critters' feasting......told my daughter, "Its the circle of Life!" She was kinda surprised about bone-eating worms, saw this info very briefly in SoCal museum open house.
I find half buried whale skeletons to be insanely cool because they’re so large. It’s like some mystical beast. I just love the size
Whomever one of the excited women is, you damn well keep on your path of passion. The world of marine biologists lost one of you recently. My cousin, Adrian Dahood-Fritz. I'm glad to know her soul and spirit survives among those who carry forward work such as this. If there's anything after this, may Adrian and Andrew enjoy and take pride in the work ya'll are doing.
Have seen it yesterday live, was glued to the screen ^^
But now i can show it to friends who missed the stream - THANKS!
See, when I read this I saw.
“Whale fall actively devoured scavengers”
*It has begun*
*dead whale*
Scientists: “WOWww”
Same energy as Fluttershy's "Nature is so fascinating..." from the comics
Are those Octopi S-Tier by any chance? #TierZoo
the deep-sea meta is kinda cutthroat but data mining that server is impossible.
Seeing this marine rover just randomly show up at your dinner table must be like the octopus equivalent of a UFO landing
Whale falls are one of my favorite marine environments to watch, I also like the brine pools.
i like how all the scientists were like wow, just sound like bunch stoners just each took a bong hit watching cool nature shows on netflix, and then started saying all that science stuff. so cute! they all sound so hippy. ''dinner is served'' lmao
i came here from link roulette but this is actually really awesome
Way more fascinating than this rare whale fall is the even more unique opportunity to hear this collaborative initial description upon discovery.
Scientists in situ
Am I seeing little sea pigs near the tail, starting at 4:04? At 4:19 you can see one more clearly to the left.
All I see are scattered bones, hungry octopi, and bone eating worms
I do see one at 4:19 actually! :D
One of the coolest videos I have seen on UA-cam. I could watch that for hours
Fantastic footage. Thank you for sharing with the rest of us!
The octopus are just chilling in T pose 😂
1:48 *How cute*
"Wes should get the sexes of them"
Yeah, of course they would...
That octopus legit is waving at the camera.
Gosh I’m studying biology as my major and all I can think of the day I can roam the seas Salt water just runs in my veins
They're taking applicants to study on the Nautilus, go look on their website!
i come back to this video when im sad
1:48 🐙「ばいばーい」
Marine biologists all over a whale fall video like scavengers on a whale fall 🤣
THAT IS ONE OF THE COOLEST THINGS I'VE EVER SEEN
I like to imagine that the voices are coming from the octopus’s
Being able to watch such natural processes at work is flat out amazing!
knowing that the "grass" on the floor is actually a bunch of worms gave me a serious case of the itches.
Why is it called "whale fall" and not "whale sink"? 🤔
Mimi Tea because it also implies the whale “falls”, as in it dies. Whales “sink” in the water naturally all the time when traveling through the ocean.
It refers to Marine Snow, the flakes of organic detritus that rain down on the seabed.
Likely because the fall out of their fluid medium, much like airplanes fall from the sky when they lose lift.
Because it’s a windfall of whale for all them deep sea critters :P
"Where food is so limited I would imagine scavenging is a great strategy, your food doesn't run away!" That was painfully obvious.
The squid are having a feast of the year.
It looks like aliens having their dinner.
Our planet is trully amazing and interesting.
Me: expecting concise and articulate discourse about the current stage of the whale fall
The expedition team: excitedly chattering about the amazing event like college kids and making whatever this noise is 0:42
Feels like I'm listening to a radio show
Feels like watching a movie but with narration is keeping me from looking at the fascination of the deep see.
1:51 what kind of crustacean is that off to the left? Looks like a white spider
Yeti crab
1:48 - Octopus is waving ❤️
Amazing video. Does anyone know what the technical name for the little green dots in the center of the screen is? Where can I see more footage with these in it?
The species you're looking for is Osedax rogersi
The one octopus waving as they go was hilarious
That's news to me octopus eating carrion.
I’m skeptical. Why assume they’re eating the dead stuff when there’s so much live stuff there to eat?
Damn i didnt even think about that but ur rite!
I mean, why shouldn't they? A lot of animals would't walk past a fresh carcass if they are hungry. As they said, they are opportunist.
Its news to everyone. This was a really epic find.
@@TheNeonwing This is a 4-months old carcass.
Learned something again. I didnt know the bottom of the ocean had worms
I never seen octupus's around eating or hanging out where a dead whale is & bones
@@peterandon3052 are you a brony?
@@peterandon3052 oh okay, your profile name on UA-cam sounds you watch the show, it's very good
“Oh look at that!”
**astonished voices** “wOrmS” “WoRmS”
Did anyone come here from Gaud as I did (and you lost of course)
I cheated and looked at the links, but I don't at all consider this a loss...
This is a win dude
yep
watching this while eating like its a mukbang
...as opposed to “passively” devoured?
It's cool to see, but the enthusiasm of the crew is just delightful.
These whale-falls remind me of watering holes in Africa. Entire communities of creatures all coming together in a small area to feed/drink. ❤
I love how that one octopus just waves at them
This is so cool. Wow! I’d never heard of this phenomenon before. You should check it out....and the scientists are so excited and passionate! 😊 What creeps would downvote such a beautiful thing? Jeez.
everyone gangsta till the octopus starts waving
The ends of some ribs and vertebrae looked to have been bitten or gnawed off.
probably from some of the bigger sharks when the whale was still fresh
audio be like youtube tag section
"oh yea wow look zoom amazing ribs worms zoom in wow so many yes ribs carcass baleen woooow yes defintely wow"