Iran-Israel conflict: When
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- As Iran-Israel conflict deepens & other Muslim nations stay out, abridged Episode on when #NationalInterest argued on how nationalism trumps Pan-Islamism. Watch the National Interest column, first published in November 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Two things to remember -
1. Existence of Pan-Islamism
2. Existence of Shia-Sunni division.
3. Nationalism can't be fully ruled out but it can't be that significant.
No Muslim Countries What Iran to Have the N Weapon 😮
You forget that the US with a quarter of the world economy and defense spending more than the next 10 biggest economies combined of 660 billion dollars, backs israel. The expendable income of an average American that can be taxed and directed towards warfare is huge. The middle-eastern economies rely hugely on american imports to make significant profits on their oil exports. Many like Qatar even host american bases.
More than 800 billion dollars
Usa is Present in Every Coner of the World
Azerbaijan a friend of Pakistan and Turkey openly supports Israel.
where edorgan hate isreal
so ? what it does 😆😆
U interchanged Turkey & Azerbaijan here.
Its Azerbaijan which supports Israel, coz Israel is the biggest arms supplier of Azerbaijan
@@ulala9729Turkey is a member of NATO..
It does not support Openly
Sunni versus Shias. Please study the difference
The problem is this community cannot live in peace. Whether in minority or majority.
IF MUSLIMS ARE LOYAL TO UMMAH WILL THEY LOYAL TO INDIA ??
should a hindu abroad be loyal to india?
@@MrHumanforlifeone living in india should be though.
@@MrHumanforlifeSo u mean Indian Muslims came from Arabia?? Ur Halala logic is perplexing.
@@MrHumanforlife Rishi sunak ne bola main india se loyal hu kya ????,😭 asie hain uske pm bana diya ...? Hinduon mein likha rashtra dhrama sarve prathme means nation is before all dharamas .....isiliye kamla ki banaya warna kabhi koi kuffr country momin ko nhi banati ja kar dekh le bete
History says Muslims r NOT LOYAL to India. Those LOYAL to India want India for themselves and aim for Gazwa-e-Hind, with all Hindus gone. So both ways whether loyal or not, Hindus r not welcome. With just 25% population in United British India they created Pakistan and took such large amount of our land while 80% of them didn’t even go to Pakistan instead stayed back with an even bigger agenda.
The history is repeating I believe, this is the Khilafat movement 2.0 going on today. We have Jinnah 2.0 in the opposition aiming to divide India on every possible line and a Nehru 2.0 running the country with aim of SABKA SATH SABKA VIKAS.
Hindus should learn to be united in India first.
😅 Never Will They 😅
@@billubadshah897Not possible; Pappu won’t allow it ;
Excellent analysis. As a Muslim, how can we blame others when we are our own worst enemy.
Islam has a 'rich' history of internal struggle and violence right after the death of Mohammad. It continues
The first 3 minutes (one-third) of this episode sounded like an attempt by Mr. Gupta to provoke the muslims into planning protests and taking actions against Israel by citing how powerful the muslims are (as if they need any provocation). Not once did he realize that India is home to some of the largest population of muslims in the world and this provocation may very well lead to repercussions in not-so-good a manner. But, what to say...Gupta ji ka mann jo nahi manta.
At 4:00 he says " thier country, that is India"...Not your country Gupta ji? Not your country?
4:30 UMMAH LOYALITY AND FANTASY
Ayatollahs better learn to sleep with one eye open!!!
Even both eyes open , no escape
Shekhar is inciting muslms ...he started speaking like a moulvi 😂😂
Shekher is criticising Muslim Ummah because he is a Hindu and a loyal friend of Jews..
whats national about this topic?
Dera Chief Ram Rahim Singh Gets Parole Ahead Of Haryana Elections 😂
Why do not u go to court and stay
@@maniaphobia4719
Our ruling party works hard to protect rapists 😂
Thats why India never deserves any seat in the big leagues still a third world corrupt country so sad😢
@@maniaphobia4719
Some political parties are seen always interested in protecting rapist 😂
Any views on Lalloo sand his medical bail?
Hundred years back labenon was Christian country, see what a mess after getting islamised... Mr. Gupta ji it was the same in India, and now you see what is happening in those area... Islaam.
India won't become a Muslim majority country.
That's impossible
Great Analysis and lots of authentic information. Sometimes I wonder what contribution these 200 crore Muslims offered to modern civilization???
Next Republic Day celebration in India ( 26th Jan 2025 ) , I wish , Chief Guest has to be Geert Wilders from Netherlands ; He will give a special address and then a free press meet with Q & A
Shekhar The Journalist ❌
Shekhar The Moulvi ✅
Kamred shekh gupta
Excellent explanation
In Today Materialistic World Self Interest of Oneself or Country is Above All
If only Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela’s methods were followed ❤
Muslims when it comes to free Palestine 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
When it comes to free Kashmir 🤫🤫🙊🤐
This shows that they are loyal to their religion and not india
Sanskaris always insecure
@@odhdhd1543
Leftover Pakistani muslim in india spotted 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
They have show their loyalty to their religion throughout their history. In common knowledge it was Khilafat movement and today’s time it’s Hamas movement.
I ran to Israel for the peace.
US backed israel expert to bombard the civilian not on ground..
You are always against Muslims....Hindus also consider themselves as Sanatani, but are they all one....they have differences . Nepal a hindu state does not accept india as a nation...
Excellent👍
U got the wrong meaning of umma. Umma includes jews, Christian’s & Muslims since all of them are Abrahamic son.
Moulavi Gupta is trying to provoke ummah😂
Some correction to analysis Shekhar
Power>money>religion>nationalism for them. They become cannibalistic against own only after they have wiped out others from their place. Until then they have religioj first. So examples you quoted arrive only after they have 90% plus majority in that country. Until then they are unified for themselves. And yes power and money above that but never nationalism if that country is outside that desert. Example look how Indian diaspora of them has opinions on Iran and Palestinians and how they may go against India to support them
Shekhar ji kaun sa maal fuka Hain aaj
I know couple of hight educated working muslims, who have boycotted the jews based products.
And u talking about Muslim division it's a myth sirji
Only thing that's persistent is they can match might of isarel otherwise they would eaten up isarel in half an hr
chat gpt prepared this script... very much unlikely of Shekhar Gupta... too much mechanical
Utter nonsense, inciting a rabid group. What is needed is not standing up to Israel, but standing for peace and calling off terrorism as a means to browbeat others. Israel is acting brazenly for the same reason that they are a tiny part of the world and can be overwhelmed as was happening earlier. We need a more sensible and responsible analysis and not something that would inflame people who are already misguided.
What sense is there in your comment?? The current crisis was triggered by Hamas October 7 attacks. Israel is absolutely right in defending itself against its enemies who love, cherish and glorify violence.
Almost all your points can be countered easily. Absolutely baseless and poorly researched video with a selective bias. In fact in Islam, it is clearly mentioned to love your own nation.
Stupid analysis, This is not Jews vs Muslims. If it was like that there would have been different results.
This is very much a religious war. The world has gone through the charter of hamas and Hizbullah. Nobody can fool the world....
Result depends upon the least on the unskilled number of population having least education with least scientific temper with respect to the rest of the world. War isn't fought today by horses and swords anymore.
It is a Jew versus Islam fight.
@@holywarrior5719 its about islam vs others
If it was Islam vs Jews or others. Pakistan, Turkey, Malaysia, KSA and 54 other countries would have jumped in.
But it is not. It is Zionists vs Native Palestinians.
If you live long enough to see Islam vs Others you will witness the bloodshed everywhere even in your Town. So be careful what you wish for 😉
If Israel and Iran go to war, will this affect Indian investments like Chabahar Port and NSTC corridor?
Both these investments r delusional at best. They r meant to keep Iran engaged with India and not fall into Chinese hands completely. On ground and in reality it doesn’t mean much. India just doesn’t want Chabahar to fall into Chinese hands.
Our tax money wasted on Islamists!
@@pmt7483 They are not delusional !
They provide market access to Central Asia, Russia and Europe, for our exports. And also to get alternative route for Russian oil. Right now, trade with Russia, moves around China, via Southeast Asia, which can become a bottleneck.
What’s there in central Asian countries? Africa is the future growth story..
@@rajx7120Pipe Dream Untill Regime Change in Iran 😅
Peaceful community 😅
Israeli economy has left the server.
Don't worry about their economy, worry about Iran.
first here
Second here
This is not the correct way
Jus coz islamic nations aren't united against Israel doesn't mean there is no concept of Ummah...there are many reasons behind major gulf nations not uniting against Israel...that doesn't prove the dogmatic n archaic thought process of Ummah doesn't exist in Muslims...ask any random Muslim in India he/she will say faith above nation😮
Absolutely right Indian Muslims support Palestine and hate Israel even they know our country wants Two State Solution,So that we donnot loose Israel friendship.
Islam believes in one world,one religion,one law..
@@sameermir4037 i piss on chuslam
In theory, not in practice
@@sameermir4037 never, there is not consensus among muslims .... shia , Sunni, ahammadiya etc.
Will you agree with RSS one India ? Don't try to act smart. Islam does not accept diversity , they want to impose their 7th century thought process on everyone and take the civilization back to stone age
jai Israel 🇮🇱 jai Israel 🇮🇱 jai Israel 🇮🇱 jai Israel 🇮🇱
jai Israel 🇮🇱 jai Israel 🇮🇱 jai Israel 🇮🇱 jai Israel 🇮🇱