Secret Life: Episode 1 - KEEP A SECRET!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 48 тис.

  • @quill9918
    @quill9918 Рік тому +12953

    grian: i need people to not laugh at my jokes
    grian: goes directly to the man who laughs at any awkward situation

    • @Walkdplankfrank
      @Walkdplankfrank Рік тому +299

      Task Suggestions:
      1. Summon the Warden / and bring to surface
      2. Only speak after someone else speaks. --- only speak after other people
      3. Give everyone a bed, then be the one who never sleeps. + tell everyone your mining etc...
      4. Subtle voice changer. ---- You don't want other half lifers noticing your voice is off.
      @KaiWat

    • @blackcube6722
      @blackcube6722 Рік тому +28

      @@Walkdplankfrankreminds me of another smp

    • @IceyFG
      @IceyFG Рік тому

      kinda reminds me of friend or foe@@blackcube6722

    • @fizzplease6742
      @fizzplease6742 Рік тому +64

      Suggestion: call everybody by the first letter of their name for 10 minutes (must seek out people to talk to)

    • @brittanyhock5758
      @brittanyhock5758 Рік тому +11

      task idea get grain,rendog,pearl,solidartiy, maritn to said bigb my prince

  • @Toaster157
    @Toaster157 Рік тому +3125

    the fact that mubo laughs at all the puns and makes the task harder accidentally is proof of friendship

    • @kdt_yt4386
      @kdt_yt4386 Рік тому +92

      And then you realize that mumbos task was to make puns

    • @Toaster157
      @Toaster157 Рік тому +25

      @@kdt_yt4386 ye but I mean like, 25:20 for example

    • @ChinghangHui-us7vz
      @ChinghangHui-us7vz 10 місяців тому +8

      Ahh yes my favourite creater mubo

    • @aulus9
      @aulus9 9 місяців тому +5

      who's this mubo character?

    • @spookskeley
      @spookskeley 7 місяців тому +4

      mubo :)

  • @samwright6853
    @samwright6853 Рік тому +576

    Etho completely missing the jokes because he was too busy trying to convince grian to put a bed down so he could steal it and grian being so happy that etho didn't laugh that he hardly questioned the need for him to put down a bed is peak comedy

    • @Vallyntinx
      @Vallyntinx Рік тому +12

      Been waiting. LOVE IT!!

  • @TomNixon-fk8tn
    @TomNixon-fk8tn Рік тому +2551

    Scar: "OH MUMBO IM GUNNA HUG YO- oh, I just failed my task.".
    Grian: "*Dying with laughter*"

    • @Zack_Zander
      @Zack_Zander 11 місяців тому +92

      I was already lightheaded from all the puns. Scar suddenly saying that took me out.

    • @Lillymood123
      @Lillymood123 7 місяців тому +13

      I laughed so much😊

  • @ThiVasss
    @ThiVasss Рік тому +6703

    Unlike the previous series, this one actually rewards watching each and every individuals POV. If two people were together, that was essentially the same thing, but now each perspective is unique due to the nature of the secret task. GENIUS.

    • @EpicRandomness555
      @EpicRandomness555 Рік тому +119

      Good thing I watch Mumbo and Grian

    • @PeamThePanda
      @PeamThePanda Рік тому +215

      Exactly. This is so galaxy-brain, and I love everything about it.

    • @tumblingartist
      @tumblingartist Рік тому +52

      IKR!! It adds an extra level of intrigue!! :D

    • @gamerarmy936
      @gamerarmy936 Рік тому +8

      ​@@PeamThePandabut you didn't have to cut me out

    • @HASNAINSHAH-my9ks
      @HASNAINSHAH-my9ks Рік тому +4

      This Is so true

  • @determineddaaf3
    @determineddaaf3 Рік тому +594

    I love how Grian and Mumbo had similarly themed tasks, but it turns out in a way so that Mumbo practically makes Grian's task impossible and Grian makes Mumbo's task blatantly easy.

  • @_Dalee_
    @_Dalee_ Рік тому +3157

    *Task idea:*
    Give someone a raw salmon without them noticing, and then later, ask them if they have a spare raw salmon for you.

    • @Dusti_buns
      @Dusti_buns Рік тому +52

      This is amazing

    • @githyanki1899
      @githyanki1899 Рік тому +18

      *Task Idea* Give Someone A Carrot Sandwich

    • @abdelrahman_osama
      @abdelrahman_osama Рік тому +25

      Make 3 people /gift you a heart

    • @Aschilon
      @Aschilon Рік тому +2

      Unless it's Cleo, then it should be to tame a cat with a cooked salmon.

    • @JunKKraft
      @JunKKraft Рік тому +2

      Suggestion: Convince someone to kill another hermit

  • @Charlotte-vl9bs
    @Charlotte-vl9bs Рік тому +660

    If you see Grian and Mumbo together you know it’s gonna be a good episode

  • @fairyfriend5367
    @fairyfriend5367 Рік тому +1449

    Task idea: To not enter anyone's base via front door.

  • @hotnopgames
    @hotnopgames Рік тому +19522

    Its funny how Mumbo and grian had almost opposites of each others tasks

  • @Daios7234
    @Daios7234 Рік тому +8019

    Task idea: Convince another player to change their skin

    • @sc0rch3d
      @sc0rch3d Рік тому +288

      One step further! Convince a person to act as your twin (change skin) for 5 minutes!

    • @Xandog
      @Xandog Рік тому +156

      another step further, convince ETHO

    • @thenopequeen
      @thenopequeen Рік тому +112

      That's easy mode. Scar is always looking for an excuse to get out the Scitties

    • @tofusem
      @tofusem Рік тому +20

      this is definitely a possible hard task if given a bit more oomph

    • @themaydayman
      @themaydayman Рік тому +7

      @@tofusem twins would definently be hard, maybe though get two others

  • @Bear-tp9zc
    @Bear-tp9zc Рік тому +2944

    I SWEAR GRIAN AND MUMBO NO MATTER WHAT SERIES THEY ARE IN TOGETHER THEY ALWAYS JUST RANDOMLY HAVE A INSIDE JOKE OR BONDING TIME ITS SO FUNNY

    • @ghostietoastie_
      @ghostietoastie_ Рік тому +23

      YES it's the best!!

    • @Petunia_Kit
      @Petunia_Kit Рік тому +17

      It’s my favorite part of these series haha

    • @SillyCrilly
      @SillyCrilly Рік тому +55

      I remember in Hermitcraft season 7, when they both had little hobbit hole, and they had a secret tunnel to visit each other.

    • @o1iviaxx
      @o1iviaxx Рік тому +6

      IKK ITS SO FUNNY LMAO

    • @wildsumo9755
      @wildsumo9755 Рік тому +6

      Seson 2 last life
      'Well that's because I have been hiding my diamonds hear"

  • @thiefyee3686
    @thiefyee3686 Рік тому +2728

    One task should definitely be get another player to sing a song with you. That would be hilarious

    • @Zlovk6310
      @Zlovk6310 Рік тому +24

      you are my

    • @Moonbeam169
      @Moonbeam169 Рік тому +5

      Yes!!

    • @Dragon_Fire_2468
      @Dragon_Fire_2468 Рік тому +21

      Bdubs and Impulse Mario song?

    • @dbseamz
      @dbseamz Рік тому +33

      Since Lizzie and Scott are both on this server that could lead to a "Deal with Destiny" callback. And I'm all for that!

    • @AbbyGilbert-f6h
      @AbbyGilbert-f6h Рік тому +4

      That’s what I was about to comment lol

  • @camdinjewell7470
    @camdinjewell7470 Рік тому +317

    Task Idea: Get someone to believe you have a pet mob that is invisible/unrendered for them.

  • @sepiasmith5065
    @sepiasmith5065 Рік тому +295

    I'm glad someone acknowledged the non-stacking items haha the other perspectives I've watched, no one said anything and i was like?????
    also "Mumbo cliffhanger" genuinely got me laughing out loud
    yet another Life Series with Grian screaming "STOP" because he's laughing too hard. very good
    Mumbo is the worst person to be around for this task HAHA he'll laugh to any randomt thing. it's lovely

  • @pumkinhead2079
    @pumkinhead2079 Рік тому +3119

    Task Idea: Fully convince someone their mic is off when it's not

  • @circusmeat
    @circusmeat Рік тому +9302

    Task idea:
    Convince someone that you have exposed your task by accident, have them escort you to the button only to see you click the success button

    • @bignono2439
      @bignono2439 Рік тому +281

      This is realy creative! I like it a lot

    • @runic_raptor
      @runic_raptor Рік тому +78

      I love that one

    • @hybridsel6
      @hybridsel6 Рік тому +143

      thats amazing, we need to see this one, thats an easy like from me, i want to see grian convince like a whole group of people he failed it and bring them to the keeper for this

    • @maximushank1115
      @maximushank1115 Рік тому +13

      That is an amazing idea

    • @ItsNeito
      @ItsNeito Рік тому +10

      I love this one

  • @WalletWorrier
    @WalletWorrier Рік тому +12935

    Suggestion: trick someone into thinking they overheard you describing your secret. Only counts if they attempt to take you to the buttons.

    • @merilynnshark6144
      @merilynnshark6144 Рік тому +1001

      This is SO GOOD! Them taking you to the button to get you to hit the fail button and then you just casually strolling up to the success button would be hilarious xD

    • @StormStabs
      @StormStabs Рік тому +192

      Suggestion: Convince someone to give you they’re sword.

    • @animal_peg1620
      @animal_peg1620 Рік тому +20

      Yes

    • @JunKKraft
      @JunKKraft Рік тому +72

      Task suggestion: Form two separate alliances

    • @RedNeck_Zeus
      @RedNeck_Zeus Рік тому +5

      I literally had the same idea.

  • @wendigosstudio8586
    @wendigosstudio8586 Рік тому +279

    Task Idea: make a joke that Grian and Mumbo wont laugh at

    • @monicasegovia6176
      @monicasegovia6176 Рік тому +26

      That's a hard task if it's both of them that can't laugh

  • @sleepy_riley
    @sleepy_riley Рік тому +231

    Task Suggestion:
    Convince another player that your task has an exception that allows you to tell them what it is. Make them do a silly made-up task with you.

  • @shinyfirefly5034
    @shinyfirefly5034 Рік тому +188

    It was absolutely priceless when Scar was saying he could hear nerds and then quietly in the distance you just hear Etho say, "Are you callin' me a nerd?!"
    Something about the volume drop-off over distance just makes that kind of thing 10x funnier to me.

  • @Randomname-f1q
    @Randomname-f1q Рік тому +387

    Suggestions:
    - Re-name another person's pet and get them to call their own pet by the name you gave it.
    - Announce five very unimportant things in the style of a news reporter trying to show off something small as a big deal.
    - Cause someone else to get three in-game advancements.
    - Convince someone to take on a harder difficulty secret.
    - Re-explain exactly the same thing as what someone says using simpler words three times.
    - Pretend to accidentally reveal your secret and have at least five people walk with you to the button.
    - Invent a word in front of a group of two or more people without anyone questioning it.

    • @AngieTheCatGD
      @AngieTheCatGD Рік тому +33

      Second last one would be funny, I can imagine people's reactions to pressing complete instead of fail
      Last one reminds me of the Dare Stick, when grian came up with the word 'chobblesome'

    • @DriestApollo
      @DriestApollo Рік тому +10

      ​@@AngieTheCatGDliterally was gonna say that exact thing!

    • @MadDJSimmons
      @MadDJSimmons Рік тому +5

      Steal an enchant table from 3 players

    • @Verdantixx
      @Verdantixx Рік тому +7

      c o b b l e s o m e

    • @lukehuber1268
      @lukehuber1268 Рік тому +4

      I like how creative some of these are!

  • @loreleiloriestone9179
    @loreleiloriestone9179 8 місяців тому +66

    Still can't get over Grian's panic over Mumbo's "drowning in puns" bit. That, "STOP!" was so genuine!

  • @Ph4ntomHourGlass
    @Ph4ntomHourGlass Рік тому +321

    The irony that both Mumbo and Grian get joke related secrets and confuse each other in the first ten minutes of the session...

  • @chrysanthemum13
    @chrysanthemum13 Рік тому +2730

    Some task ideas:
    - Say somebody's name in every sentence you say for at least 5 minutes
    - Convince Scar to buy a useless item from you
    - Throw an egg at 3 different people and blame the man in the chicken costume
    - Build a base under somebody's base without them noticing for the rest of the episode
    - Don't jump for at least 30 minutes
    - Discreetly compliment Timmy five times
    - 'Accidentally' burn somebody's house down
    - Cheer for somebody three times without anybody else joining in

    • @kitotek
      @kitotek Рік тому +112

      I like the don't jump idea, maybe 15 minutes for an easy task and 30 for hard

    • @dacosmoshark7281
      @dacosmoshark7281 Рік тому +48

      Another task idea (this may be kind of risky): Steal/take a camel and use it to travel for 10 minutes.

    • @ariesoginaro1062
      @ariesoginaro1062 Рік тому +27

      The ship burns it all burns

    • @dabadllama
      @dabadllama Рік тому +6

      These are good ones.

    • @JoshPabustan
      @JoshPabustan Рік тому +38

      i feel like the "don't jump" one isn't really an "interaction" like what grian said.

  • @Andy-fr4yf
    @Andy-fr4yf Рік тому +1318

    I think we have proven Grian and Mumbo truely share a braincell

    • @Tugg_on_a_segway101
      @Tugg_on_a_segway101 Рік тому

      they both have 1 braincell (combined)

    • @lsmgamer
      @lsmgamer Рік тому +17

      True I can't stop laughing

    • @SomaShiori
      @SomaShiori Рік тому +15

      As soon as I saw this I had to double check that Mumbo was gonna be in then I was like "yup Grain + Mumbo I'm committed now lol" they are hilarious together

    • @joshlongbottom2213
      @joshlongbottom2213 10 місяців тому +7

      Scar technically shares the same brain cell. He just never gets it from the other two

    • @rottenpawz_official
      @rottenpawz_official 7 місяців тому +1

      And a soul! Mumbo still has Grian's waffle :)

  • @LoneWolf-we9gk
    @LoneWolf-we9gk 10 місяців тому +581

    as somebody who is hard of hearing... i LOVE these subtitles-
    not ONLY do they exist in the first place, but everytime someone speaks, their name pops up-
    AND IT'S COLOUR CODED- i didn't even know you could do that! each person has their own colour and that makes things so much more easy to understand!
    previously i watched scott's one and i struggled to understand a LOT of what was going on because i couldn't hear or figure out what people were saying 😭
    same with lizzie's which i watched before scott and grian
    i love subtiltes, and i have to say, these are some of my favourite subtitles ever ♥

    • @rottenpawz_official
      @rottenpawz_official 7 місяців тому +18

      Same here, love these subtitles!

    • @ThatOneGuy-hq5cj
      @ThatOneGuy-hq5cj 7 місяців тому +29

      :0 I didn't know they were an option!! Usually subtitles aren't available, aside from the auto-generated ones, which are usually questionable. Love it when they add subtitles :]]]] /lh /gen

    • @L-ghtlessSky
      @L-ghtlessSky 6 місяців тому +13

      people think i only watch grian because he’s popular and the admin
      i watch grian because of THIS

    • @RoseBerryYeeps
      @RoseBerryYeeps 5 місяців тому +7

      yoo I didn’t even notice Subtitles were available! That’s sick!!!

    • @monke7919
      @monke7919 4 місяці тому +8

      And they're called "English-grian" in the subtitles menu

  • @xoangelesxo
    @xoangelesxo Рік тому +405

    Task idea: start a rumor. Two players must repeat that rumor to you without prompting.

  • @mataric1157
    @mataric1157 Рік тому +808

    Task idea:
    Convince 3 people to 'help' you build a monument or communal building, then never place or destroy a single block yourself.
    Task idea:
    Create a treasure trail/hunt with signs and the like that lead in a circle. Convince a player that there is treasure at the end and have them spend (3) minutes going in a loop.

    • @MMAX-zb6bp
      @MMAX-zb6bp Рік тому +15

      First one is genius

    • @loganhall6660
      @loganhall6660 Рік тому +8

      I think these would definitely constitute as the hard tasks.

    • @cosmojack9859
      @cosmojack9859 Рік тому +2

      Yep, 1st one is fantastic

    • @zombotanycmc
      @zombotanycmc Рік тому

      First one is hilarious

    • @JelliiGemii
      @JelliiGemii Рік тому +4

      spoiler
      Someone did that already and lizzie/LDshadowLady followed it-

  • @thomasdevlin5825
    @thomasdevlin5825 Рік тому +103

    I love how Grian solidified puns as a bit with Mumbo so they both started laughing every time they made a pun, then half the server started following them around making it almost impossible to slip in a bad joke without someone laughing

  • @AhlyThamonwan
    @AhlyThamonwan Місяць тому +11

    2:29 Skizz “Hey Buddy! 😁” is so CUTE 😭😭

  • @TextualDeviant
    @TextualDeviant Рік тому +755

    Task Idea:
    Place a button mid-conversation, and get at least five people to press it.
    Alternatively, place a button mid-conversation, and you only succeed the task if it HASN'T been pressed.

    • @RdubPlays
      @RdubPlays Рік тому +61

      If you are in a conversation with Grian, the second task is actually impossible.

    • @sue9647
      @sue9647 Рік тому +7

      Lol don't do it near grian. Lol

    • @waffler-yz3gw
      @waffler-yz3gw Рік тому +6

      the second one could be one of the hard tasks, since the first one is a lot easier

    • @little.chillax
      @little.chillax Рік тому +6

      Lol, imagine if there's bonus points if Grian doesn't press the button

  • @nikwalker8932
    @nikwalker8932 Рік тому +207

    Task Suggestions:
    - Receive a flower from 3 different players
    - Get someone to perform a water bucket save from a precarious height
    - Observe a player succeed their task without them knowing you are there

    • @NaterGamer101
      @NaterGamer101 Рік тому +5

      Tell tango that decked out is amazing with out him saying thanks

    • @charlotte_piglover
      @charlotte_piglover Рік тому +4

      Task ideas:
      - slightly change parts of your skin throughout the session without people noticing

    • @Rustleaf
      @Rustleaf Рік тому +1

      @charlotte_piglover
      Great idea!!!

    • @citra1885
      @citra1885 Рік тому

      I see what you did on that last suggestion:)

  • @littlecryptids
    @littlecryptids Рік тому +346

    mumbo and grian giggling hysterically at each others bad jokes is everything i needed

    • @thefriendlywaffle
      @thefriendlywaffle Рік тому +2

      task idea: talk to someone about waffles for 2 minutes

  • @gotchufam2964
    @gotchufam2964 Рік тому +91

    37:14 “No, No, Thank you Etho. Thank you”

  • @crystalize_l1362
    @crystalize_l1362 Рік тому +211

    Suggestion for hard tasks: Convince 3 people to believe a ridiculously WRONG trivia about any member on this server without getting caught by the member. The trivias told must be different for the 3 people.

    • @JolydieFer
      @JolydieFer Рік тому +1

      Do you fail if the person who's meant to believe finds out it's false or if the person it's about finds out?
      Or both?

    • @crystalize_l1362
      @crystalize_l1362 Рік тому

      @@JolydieFer I think it depends on how difficult they'd like the task to be. If it's me I'd say as long as the person you tricked expressed that they actually think it's true at one point, and the person it's about doesn't find out by the end of the session- then it's a win, even if the person you tricked came to realize it wasn't true after the conversation

  • @eggyolk6735
    @eggyolk6735 Рік тому +137

    There needs to be a task that is just "Laugh at someone's joke for 1 minute straight", I love that some tasks collide with each other

  • @SweetGachaVideos
    @SweetGachaVideos Рік тому +329

    A task idea I had: stay close enough to hear another player for a full minute without them realizing you’re there.

    • @krishh794
      @krishh794 Рік тому +20

      Increase the time to something like 3-4 minutes just to make sure they don't complete it in the first attempt, making it much more hilarious for both the one with the task and the one being eavesdropped

    • @benepastayolo4049
      @benepastayolo4049 Рік тому

      that's so funny, I approved

    • @ddb4
      @ddb4 Рік тому +1

      thats what skiz had tho

    • @SweetGachaVideos
      @SweetGachaVideos Рік тому +5

      @@ddb4 but like not knowing they’re there at all. Like sneaking and being hidden

    • @FireBat31
      @FireBat31 Рік тому +1

      But they can’t be muted

  • @savd1y665
    @savd1y665 10 місяців тому +33

    i love that mumbo laughed at every joke grian made, so sweet

  • @jasonthedumb9438
    @jasonthedumb9438 Рік тому +211

    We've reached the point where Grian meeting Mumbo can be a great cliffhanger.

  • @elleauden805
    @elleauden805 Рік тому +720

    It's probably already been suggested but: Everybody gets the SAME task. Imagine the Chaos. Imagine the drama.

    • @HatsumeMiku745
      @HatsumeMiku745 Рік тому +8

      I’d love that

    • @scrapbotcommander
      @scrapbotcommander Рік тому +58

      Imagine if the task they all got was "Find out what someone else's task is" 🤣

    • @ICUPcomedygold
      @ICUPcomedygold Рік тому +4

      Everyone would find out pretty quickly tbh, then the novelty is lost

    • @NotHUSTLE
      @NotHUSTLE Рік тому +5

      Hard task: ask someone to play tag; they have to say yes and you have to outrun them for at least 5 min

  • @darksplash873
    @darksplash873 Рік тому +230

    Honestly this concept is genius cause you really wanna watch another person's POV, even if it's just to know what task they have. Suddenly you're watching everything with a whole new context, from a not only different player's perspective but just a new perspective on the situation!

    • @diamondoof767
      @diamondoof767 Рік тому

      ok.

    • @carimeslockdownedtree2654
      @carimeslockdownedtree2654 Рік тому +1

      Yes! This is the only season where, from the get-go, I'm considering watching every single pov. I'm still trying it out, will pace myself for a few days rather than my bad habit of binging everything I can at once, but _man_ am I so excited for this. This is the fifth pov I've watched so far. 12 more to go!

    • @rayotex8881
      @rayotex8881 Рік тому

      ​@@ChrisPezetkeep dreaming

    • @Hoi_Kirb
      @Hoi_Kirb Рік тому

      That's such a good comment @darksplash873 ! Like... i think this is the most ingenious season of 3rd Life

  • @lancemcpherson2526
    @lancemcpherson2526 Рік тому +18

    Grian, I've watched Hermitcraft for years. I believe since season 2. I love the Hermits and everything they're done; but, by God, you've brought a such a vitality to the Minecraft world. Whether by script or improvisation, I truly appreciate and have been uplifted by your endeavors across all the different series.

  • @PartyStarlow
    @PartyStarlow Рік тому +7653

    That Secret Keeper is giving off Watcher energy

    • @BigSisMaddie5591
      @BigSisMaddie5591 Рік тому +435

      I saw it too. I’m currently watch the EVO smp series

    • @jordanenby9734
      @jordanenby9734 Рік тому +125

      Right?!

    • @scaracak3s
      @scaracak3s Рік тому +106

      i know right⁉️😭

    • @QueenCami_123
      @QueenCami_123 Рік тому +578

      It also quite literally has the watcher symbol on its face made out of cobblestone

    • @scaracak3s
      @scaracak3s Рік тому +84

      @@QueenCami_123yeah it dose!

  • @Burgerhero
    @Burgerhero Рік тому +344

    Hard task: Build a dispenser with a button prominently displayed somewhere, bring Grian to it, and try to keep him from pressing the button.

  • @tyleremery7088
    @tyleremery7088 Рік тому +233

    I love how Grian's bad joke immediately turned into a STRING ( _throws string_ ) of genuinely good jokes.

    • @fluffypeguin09
      @fluffypeguin09 Рік тому +9

      I appreciate what you did there

    • @Shift2101
      @Shift2101 Рік тому +6

      I don’t get it. Would *throws wood block* you mind explaining it?

    • @ZAPChuck18
      @ZAPChuck18 Рік тому +2

      @@Shift2101w lol

    • @BooTheEater
      @BooTheEater 10 місяців тому +1

      Come on guys, the joke has been *throws a bucket of milk* milked to death now
      You could *throws down a berry* bury it 6 feet under

    • @xtremesubber9136
      @xtremesubber9136 9 місяців тому +2

      He really has an EYE (throws spider eye) for these sort of puns

  • @Scothulu
    @Scothulu Рік тому +102

    Task Idea - Gaslight 3 other players to the point of audible confusion

    • @ahmed4363
      @ahmed4363 2 місяці тому +3

      BigB's secret task

  • @danielfleming5585
    @danielfleming5585 Рік тому +106

    Hard Task Idea: Convince another player that you have the same task that they did.
    It would be fun because you would have to figure out what their task was and then pretend to be doing the same thing around them for long enough that they ask you if you have the same task they did. It'll also be challenging because they'll know you're lying if you just told them your task was theirs because that would cause you to fail so you really have to act like it's your task and make them come up with the idea that it's what you have. Also, you would be in a rush to do it because you couldn't start till someone finishes their task.

  • @nonival1189
    @nonival1189 Рік тому +335

    Task ideas:
    - Ride in a boat with another player and get them to call you captain
    - Start a secret club. It needs to have at least three other members, a secret greeting, and a secret clubhouse by the end of the session.
    - Have a romantic sunset picnic with another player

    • @Yolanda4
      @Yolanda4 Рік тому +4

      To add to the club idea, they could make it themed, like a swifties club, or even make it specifically a cult 😂

    • @baguettewoman1413
      @baguettewoman1413 Рік тому +3

      I like these!

    • @kalkkunapaisti6664
      @kalkkunapaisti6664 Рік тому +3

      i WILL BE remembering you three years later about this. Yeah slide 4 right here

    • @DragonTheOneDZA
      @DragonTheOneDZA Рік тому

      Mumbo would definitely have a romantic sunset with a goat
      Not THE goat A goat

    • @kalkkunapaisti6664
      @kalkkunapaisti6664 Рік тому

      @@Yolanda4 swiftie? Yeah slide 5

  • @michaelpeebs
    @michaelpeebs Рік тому +110

    The fact you started the puns off, and that was Mumbo's task was incredible. Had to come see your pov to work out what your task was.
    Brilliant. Gonna be an epic series

  • @sourbanna
    @sourbanna Рік тому +67

    I just got into Grians channel fairly recently so when I was watching Secret like and Hermitcraft I always wondered why these two seemed to gravitate towards each other, but after I found out how close they where it all made sense and it just makes me smile

  • @CryingARiver
    @CryingARiver Рік тому +507

    I think a funny task would be getting someone else to express concern over your safety at least once. It would mean you’d have to do risky things and risk damage in order to complete your task

  • @KimberlyBright-h7r
    @KimberlyBright-h7r Рік тому +236

    Task idea:
    Convince someone that an item in their inventory is actually your item and get them to give it to you. This item cannot actually be yours or have ever been yours.

  • @WidgetDaWah
    @WidgetDaWah Рік тому +319

    Suggestions:
    Do not touch water for the entire session
    Sell three things to three different people
    Scare three people enough to elicit an audible response
    Get somebody to tell you their secret and fail their challenge

    • @witherwarrior1148
      @witherwarrior1148 Рік тому +9

      Id change it to only scare one person, maybe 2. And getting someone to tell their secret should definitely be a hard task if its added

    • @Cheeserio
      @Cheeserio Рік тому +2

      I also have some too
      You have to build your first base out of your least favorite block and live in it for the entire session
      You can’t eat any meat or animal product entire session
      You can only use one tool for the entire session your choice
      You can only use and mine, one type of wood for the entire session
      You can’t move a single block her item in your inventory for 10 minutes straight.
      You can’t touch any grass for 10 minutes
      In my final one, you can’t make a single pun and if you see someone making one or hear someone making one scream and run away like a crazy person for the entire session.
      Sorry, my brain to full of things
      You have to have a birthday party and get at least five other people with you.
      Change your skin slightly and try to hide it so nobody else notices for the entire session .
      Make a zoo with at least three animals
      Build a statue of anything as long as it looks cool
      You can only talk to three people on the server anyone else tries to talk to you you cannot respond at all.

    • @aperson9532
      @aperson9532 Рік тому +2

      i think the dont touch water cant rlly be done bc it has to be finished at the end of the lesson for hearts

    • @wrentheelf2656
      @wrentheelf2656 Рік тому +2

      I just know the sell things task is directed at Scar lmao

    • @thedyingmeme6
      @thedyingmeme6 Рік тому

      "Scare three people enough to get an audible reaction."
      Prox Chat go brrr

  • @Indigo_Ivy
    @Indigo_Ivy Рік тому +32

    suggestion- obtain an item from each person. whether they give it to you, you ‘borrow it’ etc

  • @basilarium
    @basilarium Рік тому +229

    Suggestion: in front of other players, pretend you're talking to another player of your choice that isn't there (perhaps act like they're responding, the other players are just too far away to hear). the task is completed once someone else also tries to talk to the player you're pretending is there.

    • @wasntwas
      @wasntwas Рік тому +31

      I love how so many of these tasks are just gaslighting people into thinking theyre crazy.

    • @JT_Joyval
      @JT_Joyval Рік тому +1

      This one is super good!!!

  • @Narzissist
    @Narzissist Рік тому +9592

    Suggestion: Team up with at least 3 different people and then sneak away secretly when you‘re accepted.

    • @humanbloger5533
      @humanbloger5533 Рік тому +685

      Something similar:
      Make 3 people follow you somewhere then disappear before arriving

    • @LillyRose.creates
      @LillyRose.creates Рік тому +47

      Key word: secret-Ly :D

    • @CreeperENDERMAN0
      @CreeperENDERMAN0 Рік тому +12

      Yes

    • @James-6407
      @James-6407 Рік тому +54

      Come up with a nickname for a player and get 3 other people to use that nickname
      (I wrote this before seeing scars second task)

    • @Maglev178
      @Maglev178 Рік тому +54

      Convince someone to fully eat a cake you made

  • @erikabeca852
    @erikabeca852 Рік тому +780

    Grian and Mumbo will always and forever be my favorite duo. Whenever I watch them I suddenly realise I have the biggest smile or even tears in my eyes from the silly jokes and the chemistry they have.

    • @Charlotte-vl9bs
      @Charlotte-vl9bs 9 місяців тому +5

      YES I feel the same, that was probably why I loved last life so much

    • @nightmarexgaming120
      @nightmarexgaming120 7 місяців тому

      Reminded me of LeBron James meat riding memes

  • @N0NON0NON0
    @N0NON0NON0 Рік тому +134

    Task idea: give 5 people your garbage without them noticing

  • @AlphaJPM
    @AlphaJPM Рік тому +5244

    Suggestion: Call 5 redstone components (dust, torch, repeater, ect) by their incorrect names infront of a Redstone expert on the server without them correcting you

  • @nonyaproductions2050
    @nonyaproductions2050 Рік тому +189

    Idea: while you are around other people, you are only allowed to speak when spoken too for at least 30 minutes. (If you are alone, you are free to speak to your audience but once someone is in range, you can only speak when they speak to you first.)

  • @miozusuki4436
    @miozusuki4436 Рік тому +486

    Suggestion: protect scar for 30 mins of the session, make sure he doesn't take damage, if he does the timer restart

    • @icesharkk6399
      @icesharkk6399 Рік тому

      -.-

    • @RukaTea
      @RukaTea Рік тому +7

      Pretty sure mumbo got this task! Great suggestion !!

    • @LunealSky
      @LunealSky Рік тому +17

      ​@RukaTea Actually, Mumbo's task was make sure Scar doesn't take more than 3 hearts of damage for the entire session

    • @RukaTea
      @RukaTea Рік тому

      @@LunealSky they probably adjusted it- but yeah it was smth like this lol

  • @kyceessadki2501
    @kyceessadki2501 Рік тому +19

    task: don''t sprint for a whole video
    if you don't think it's social, picture this, it's night, everyone is trying to avoid mobs, yet you are just walking, everyone has to wait for you if they want to go somewhere, and it adds extra challenge to the fact you can't regen without finishing the challenge

  • @forgerogue
    @forgerogue Рік тому +278

    Suggestion: You're not allowed to say a certain word or phrase that the task chooses but somehow get a hermit or two to use that exact word.

  • @personpacman7439
    @personpacman7439 Рік тому +227

    Task Suggestions:
    1) Scare three people so that they audibly scream
    2) Follow someone around and annoy them to the point that they Hit you, Ask you to leave, or try to escape from you
    3) Hold an active conversation with one or multiple people for 5 minutes while saying less than 100 words total

    • @WoodlandDrake
      @WoodlandDrake Рік тому +6

      I was going to say like 1, but "Scare someone using a mob sound you made with your mouth", so no soundboard creepers.

    • @eggz7189
      @eggz7189 Рік тому

      Those are some good ones

  • @entomolodee
    @entomolodee Рік тому +260

    Task: switch all the doors in two people's bases to another wood type

    • @cooperhawk6716
      @cooperhawk6716 Рік тому +25

      You also have to make them believe it's always been this way

  • @vince_gl
    @vince_gl Рік тому +28

    The puns are bringing back flash backs of the aha jokes-

  • @enchantednetheritehoe
    @enchantednetheritehoe Рік тому +141

    Grian and Mumbo cracking jokes and them laughing histerically, some things never change man

  • @djwillcaine
    @djwillcaine Рік тому +172

    Task idea: Get at least 3 players to accuse you of acting suspiciously

  • @ChuM00n_
    @ChuM00n_ Рік тому +103

    It's the fact Grian, Mumbo and Scar cannot take each other seriously and are flopping around and laughing, revealing secrets and horrible puns😂

  • @efml
    @efml Рік тому +27

    grian and mumbo's tasks work together so well

  • @mr.toaster2762
    @mr.toaster2762 Рік тому +247

    Hard Task: Bring up 3 references from previous seasons of the Life Series without getting called out for it.

  • @PlatypusPersonnel-uy3of
    @PlatypusPersonnel-uy3of Рік тому +178

    Secret task: get at least 3 people to guess what task you have, by acting Suspiciously each time. I think this would cause some hilarious interactions

  • @myloalt1163
    @myloalt1163 Рік тому +166

    Task idea: Make a trade with a player, but then later on in the session, re-trade those same items back.

    • @lasersound4842
      @lasersound4842 Рік тому +8

      Even better, do the classic villager scam of stealing something from someone and selling it back to them!

  • @borger2768
    @borger2768 Рік тому +17

    Task Ideas:
    1. Convince other players to give or trade unique items with you 5 times
    2. Have 4 different players ride in a boat with you
    3. Use the wrong tool to mine a block without someone around you noticing 5 times (EX: mining wood with a pickaxe)
    Hard Task Ideas:
    1.Secretly give another player 5 unique items without them noticing
    2. Borrow 3 different tools from others and give them back (or a tool of the same kind) enchanted without them noticing
    3. Lead another person for 5 minutes without a destination without them leaving

  • @kiston8630
    @kiston8630 Рік тому +89

    Suggestions:
    - Interrupt someone in every sentence they say for 20 minutes or 40 sentences.
    - Convince 3 people that you leaked your secret, eg. get caught talking to yourself.
    - Clearly tunnel to someone's base and pretend like it was accidental.

  • @psychoneticcc
    @psychoneticcc Рік тому +130

    Seeing big B gaslight Grian and drive him into insanity and paranoia may be THE funniest thing I’ve seen in the life series 😭

  • @cozytong
    @cozytong Рік тому +720

    Hard task: Make someone fully believe you have the same task as them

  • @TheAdvertisement
    @TheAdvertisement 6 місяців тому +4

    0:16 Something perfect about Gem being the one on red and attacking.
    4:30 I love how Grian's task is to make bad jokes and not get laughs, he takes it to MUMBO of all people, makes a dumb but decent pun, and ends up in an item pun off with Mumbo
    6:11 You could say he... left them in solidarity. :)
    10:45 THE TRAGEDY
    29:42 Lmfao Grian chose to live

  • @frostymikeb3322
    @frostymikeb3322 Рік тому +265

    A great task would be to protect Scar and prevent him from losing a single heart for 30 minutes without getting called out for it.

    • @striderfairchild8647
      @striderfairchild8647 Рік тому +17

      They'd have to add that to the Hard mode 💀

    • @IsabellaNelson586
      @IsabellaNelson586 Рік тому +1

      New difficulty unlocked: impossible difficulty

    • @madselyn3637
      @madselyn3637 Рік тому

      You mean Grian in double life?

    • @lillafinan
      @lillafinan Рік тому

      The first part isn't even possible unless you literally trap him in an obsidian cage without a pickaxe, and he'd probably still find a way to lose hearts

  • @deetles
    @deetles Рік тому +1194

    Task idea: bring the whole server to spawn just to tell ask them why they are there

    • @wingdingsgaster5835
      @wingdingsgaster5835 Рік тому +40

      Y e s

    • @colin_the_protogen
      @colin_the_protogen Рік тому +42

      ​@@wingdingsgaster5835 Your comment translates to forks, for some reason

    • @Mask-Shop
      @Mask-Shop Рік тому

      ​@@wingdingsgaster5835forks

    • @laurabid
      @laurabid Рік тому +21

      other task idea: use the wrong tools for everything for 45 mins without anyone noticing

    • @lilangels2980
      @lilangels2980 Рік тому +1

      Definitely

  • @evavlgs
    @evavlgs Рік тому +101

    suggestions;
    1. whenever referring to someone’s name, you have to call them ‘[name] dear’
    2. give everyone on the server an apple
    3. give at least four members a a raw salmon
    4. stay with Smallishbeans for 10-doesn’t have to be consecutive-minutes

  • @connorchurchman7558
    @connorchurchman7558 5 місяців тому +3

    I love how hard Grians theoretically easy task became immediately so hard just because Mumbo found the puns so unironically hilarious that Grian couldn’t slip any in without it getting a laugh 💀

  • @haze8588
    @haze8588 Рік тому +151

    Task Idea: Change all of the doors on someone's base, and convince them that they've always been that way.

    • @TheCell-vx3pk
      @TheCell-vx3pk Рік тому +8

      Maybe better even: Turn the doors around, so that they are closed in the open state. That way a pressure plate would always open them when they get off it.

    • @RandomThing-j7u
      @RandomThing-j7u Рік тому +1

      I feel like Pearl would be good at that.

  • @TylerRamsier-ei3ef
    @TylerRamsier-ei3ef Рік тому +2317

    Maybe one hard secret could be “fill someone’s inventory with gray glass panes and have them not notice for 1 minute”

    • @toastge
      @toastge Рік тому +81

      that's impossible they wouldn't be going afk in planned sessions

    • @SergioEduP
      @SergioEduP Рік тому +165

      @@toastge you would have to name all panes different things so they don't stack, so maybe throwing 1 at a time while the other player is distracted doing something, like crafting or mining, could work, but it would definitely be a hard task

    • @redity4836
      @redity4836 Рік тому +30

      if there’s more than one open slot in their inventory, the panes would need to stack to 64 so other slots could be filled, which would make it obvious. the person would need an inventory with only one open slot, which could be really hard to find/get w/ how secretive the game is.

    • @DLBookTheGamer
      @DLBookTheGamer Рік тому +20

      That's not a task, that's just cruelty

    • @ZephyrysBaum
      @ZephyrysBaum Рік тому +48

      @@redity4836 RENAME THE PANES!

  • @haandotexe
    @haandotexe Рік тому +145

    Hard Task: move someone's base 1 block in any direction without them catching you in the act.

    • @jimbocraggins
      @jimbocraggins Рік тому +4

      smart saying it now cuz it will be impossible later on

  • @AB-solutely813
    @AB-solutely813 Рік тому +9

    5:17 You COALd have made some more puns with that there ore, but I could SWORD of see why you didn’t, dying of laughter and all that. Not even halfway through, it’s already so good

  • @HaralHeisto
    @HaralHeisto Рік тому +92

    Hard task suggestion : Start a rumour amongst the lifers until someone you haven't told spreads it back to you

  • @axolotl102
    @axolotl102 Рік тому +219

    Task idea: change the language of the game to one of the easter egg languages(ex: Prirate speak or LOLCAT) for at least thirty minutes while with another player and refer to the items with their new names

    • @AsheHides
      @AsheHides Рік тому +7

      Ok this would be amazing to see

    • @planetfall5056
      @planetfall5056 Рік тому +10

      Maybe you also have to get one or two players to also refer to an item by it's joke name. I guess that'd be the hardmode version

  • @Notharah
    @Notharah Рік тому +336

    For a later session: Get at least 4 other people with you in boats, and subtly mention "whatever floats your boat" during the stay.

  • @Astro_cam1
    @Astro_cam1 9 місяців тому +10

    2:29 *Distant* "Hey Buddy! :D"
    5:56
    Solidarity: *No context* "I just walked into you two doing puns at eachother." WHY IS THAT SO FUNNY

  • @HiveMasterMind
    @HiveMasterMind Рік тому +135

    Hard Task: Get somebody to follow you from one border wall to the opposite wall without them guessing that this is your task.

  • @legolegolas3859
    @legolegolas3859 Рік тому +134

    Task idea: while talking to a player, build a replica of an oak tree without them questioning you

  • @TheJam1414
    @TheJam1414 Рік тому +147

    Task idea: Convince another player that it's your birthday, and have them sing Happy Birthday to you.

  • @syrup8055
    @syrup8055 2 місяці тому +2

    Grian and Mumbo throwing puns at each other is hilarous! I love the dynamic

  • @metalfanfromhell
    @metalfanfromhell Рік тому +225

    Secret task: Get a named item into 1-3 people's inventory, without them noticing.

    • @Newo48
      @Newo48 Рік тому +2

      thats super easy lol

  • @zacharypeloquin1586
    @zacharypeloquin1586 Рік тому +225

    I think we can all agree that Mumbo and Grian laughing uncontrollably about bad puns is the most wholesome thing ever!😂😂😂

    • @daveetter4573
      @daveetter4573 Рік тому +3

      And it counted as getting a laugh or thirty 😂

  • @jdawggy8761
    @jdawggy8761 Рік тому +167

    The Mumbo scar and grian shenanigans will never get old

  • @chandnityagi9156
    @chandnityagi9156 7 місяців тому +7

    00:09 lmao the fact that gem was used to show red is CRAZY because near the end she literally has a murder cult.

  • @Florjb0rjTheFloorboard
    @Florjb0rjTheFloorboard Рік тому +3602

    Hard task: keep Jimmy alive for a whole session

    • @CorwinSixbey
      @CorwinSixbey Рік тому +146

      Maybe keep jimmy from taking an amount of damage?

    • @Florjb0rjTheFloorboard
      @Florjb0rjTheFloorboard Рік тому

      @@CorwinSixbey that's a good one too

    • @NovaTheAngel
      @NovaTheAngel Рік тому +139

      Wouldn't it be harder to keep Scar alive one whole session? Or did you already think of that and deemed it impossible?
      I'd go with Scar but I would understand if people would consider it impossible. 🤣

    • @ifthenelse2469
      @ifthenelse2469 Рік тому +25

      Woahhhh, a little too hard I think

    • @randomwolf1374
      @randomwolf1374 Рік тому

      @@CorwinSixbeymaybe like a certain amount of damage?