We hate India,, back off india Please try to understand 🙏 Y India is showing wrong power India is big land of country , then also India want Nepali land.. why??? How much u want .. come and eat our body We want Nepali land Sikkim, Darjeeling Uttarakhand, Law of karma is there Pakistan & China is doing good with good..
Being a Nepali, I can tell that this is best and accurate analysis made by any Indian towards the current conflict.. Hope both sides of the government should table talk and solve this problem as soon as possible..
@@RahulSingh-zv6qd what if I tell you, your government is under US influence? burned, isn't it? same thing happens when you blame us without any proof.
@@nischalkoirala994 We give jobs to Nepalese people in our government jobs. America has nothing to do with this border. But China is playing diplomacy in it.
@@nischalkoirala994 we brought S400.from russia instead of the CAATSA act under the threat of sanctiones ..... your government cannot even give a single anti china statement in the favour of nepal...so next time vote carefully
Bro it all started cuz of that communist party in Nepal which is going to be nothing but a puppet of CPC.. WE love our Nepali brothers and sisters.. Love and respect from India.
Dear nepali brothers we love you a lot . Don't spread hate against us . China is doing shit diplomacy through nepali communist party . They intentionally spread hate against us . Be awake
krishna rawat hope hum naftat ko ni apnayenge mere kafi workers nepal se h ,mene hamesa iske baare mei unse pucha toh unhone pahle mana kar diya but bht time baad ek ne mujko btaya aur 1806 se pahle ka map dikaya mene jab unko sach bataya toh unhone bataya aajkal nepal mei maowadi yahi sab kar rahe h taki india ke kilaf hate message fele aur ye ab government tak aa gaye h
Indian bros dont involve china in everything ..becoz indian govt had occupied our land ...and claiming its as it own..so it us natural thar we fought back..for our land..hope..indian govt return what is ours..then this prblm will be solved..
K ko ni yesta misleading garne video xa na kehi study gareko xa k ko yesta lai ramro vaneko ni? Dr re k bhutri dr k science ma nadiko muhan kun ho bhanera prasta bhanxa Jun lamo Ra paniko Matra dherai vako nadi Jun sthan bata aauxa tyo muhan ho Tara yo haram dr le tributaries lai muhan bhaneko ma Pani sahi thapne ani Nepal le haryo re British le jityo re Jun British le Pani aafno history ma bhaneko xaina ki Nepal le hareko bhanera ani yo sale ko ho Nepal le harera treaty garyo bhanne yesto video lai dislike nagarera murkha Nepali haru.
@@shailendraadhikari5085 even in INDIA there are many problems bcoz of illegal- immigrants from BANGLADESH & PAKISTAN and that's why we need NRC here. During AAKHAND BHARAT era, things were different but w.r.t. time, things got mixed & messed up and have changed a lot. As we are not living in 6th - 7th Century now. It's high time 4 both the govt. 2 take a tough call and sort it out the differences via Public Domain 4 both the Nation. Otherwise Anjaam bahut bura hoga aage jaakar, dono mulko ke liye. Peace out🙏🙏🙏
I'm from Uttrakhand India and I have many Nepali friends they are kind, open minded, friendly. So I am learning Nepali language and my friends are helping in that. It's very simple and easy for me because some of the words are similar to my mother tongue garwali language. Lots of love for Nepali language and culture from Uttrakhand💓
We proud of our Gurkha Regiment. Nepalese are our brothers, this dispute will solve one day. Mujhe lagta h koi bhi nirnay baithkar soch samajh kar lena chahiye, sath hi Nepal ka point bhi valid H, wahi India ka bhi, Sara jhagda confusion ka h, kisi ka bhi yaha intention dusre ki sovereignty ko hurt karne ka nahi h.
@@hemangshrivastava9561 But ek baat or manni padegi, Nepal me koi media nahi h, lik china, Jo Government ka stance dikhaye, logo ki baat kare, Media ka hona bhi jaruri h.
@@sparrowvlogs7998 kuchh bhi bakwas mat karo, yadi India ke ho, jo jiska h wo h. Or pakistani ho to apne kaam se kaam rakho, hame tum logo ki tarah kisi jameen par jabardasti apna adhikar nahi chahiye.
Thank you sir for such a wonderful video. My respect towards Nepal has strengthened more. I am from India particularly from Motihari (Bihar) and I love Nepal and Nepali people. And I respect the sovereignty of Nepal and India. This matter has to be solved in diplomatic manner immediately and stop politicising it. It is simply worsening our relationship.
भारत और नेपाल एक बहुत ही सुलझे हुए व समझदार मित्र है। साथ ही एक ही संस्कृति से है, इसलिए एक परिवार तुल्य है। हम यह मामला भी जल्द ही बातचीत के माध्यम से सुलझा लेगे। नेपाली भाईयों आप हिमालय पर जरूर ध्यान दीजिये, चीन उसको हड़पना चाहता है। 🙏 🇮🇳 Loves 🇳🇵 and 🇳🇵 loves 🇮🇳. जय हिंद जय भारत 🇮🇳
Yes Bro But Modi Policy Towards Seems Like Now Towards Pakistan , According To India Pakistan Is Dusman Desh But Modi Shows Nepal Also Indian Dusman Desh Infact Modi Made Nepal Too Be Angry With India And Now Made Totally Against It......Now We Nepalese Hate These Hitler Facist Modi And BJP ... Ultimately India Loose Nepal..
if you know the history of your country, it had an area of just 2,500 square kilometres which your king decided to enlarge it by invading neighbouring countries... And you're claiming kalapani area just because of treaty signed between Britishers and your king... Do you know what it means? Also the reference of Kalapani is in mythology of ancient India but you have reference of it only during British raj.
@@susandmelli9273 plz go and research first..who asked king Mahendra bir bikram shah for those land during Indo china war...We gave you those land and India captured it..And what indian army is doing over there ..they just recently killed one Nepali when He was trying to cross the river.
Me too..i am kumaoni (east uttrakhand) Nepal is not that bad, but at present i can say cities like delhi, bombay, banglore r ours.. That feeling of OURS is something different.. it's shows what an democratic country provides us
Im a nepali and hindu also though i respect all religion. India and nepal are very similar in many things. And biggest hindu countries also. Why india cant play a role like a friend or brother. Nepal is a small and less powerful countty. Why india is spreading hinduism in western country and playing as a villain in its neighbour hindu country. I love india and indian people. Lets stay as a good friend and neighbour. Lets spread love . Lets follow krishna and buddhas ways
India has always respected other countries and supported them in times of need. But nepali under communist control are opportunistic as they have china card to play. Why don't you respect indian map
@@biswajeetdas11 India has been of help true but that doesn't mean it gets to bully people, you're doing the same thing that China is doing now. We never really liked the CCP, how they suppress human rights and all, but lately actions of BJP is closely resembling the CCP. China's not backing Nepal up, it's just a small country trying to stand up to it's bully neighbors. Both of them
Lol. India is spreading Hinduism in West?? R u nuts. U think Art of Living,Sadhguru and others r spreading Hinduism 😂. It's spiritualism bro,yoga and all. We r not Christian Missionaries. Hinduism is not just a religion but a way of living, it's a conjunction of many beliefs. And we r playing villain in neighbouring cntry lyk seriously u think that. Wth we care abt ur territory,we r 7th largest cntry bro we don't need to capture lands. And for Indians,we always want to hv the best of relationship with all countries irrespective of religion. Let them be Arabs or Africa etc.we always revere all nations. So there is no role of b Hinduism in improving relation. Ind-Nep hv long been gud frnds in terms of military exchanges, education,movies, culture etc. And culture is not solely dependant on religion ofc religion has it's impact but not totally. We always want gud relationship with all neighbouring countries be it Pak China Ban, but we won't ever relent when it comes to protect our sovereignty. We will always vouch for our land. Jai Hind
आपने सत्य, तथ्य और समझदारी की वात कही । आप एक सच्चा और इमान्दार इनसानहो । ए भिडियो हर नेपाली और भारतियको देखना चाहीए और सच्चाको समझकर नेपाल भारतका सिमा विवादको सुल्झाना चाहीए । अभी हम दोनो देश वसियोमे तनावहै अव दो देशोके सरकार आमने सामने बैठकर सिमा विवादको मैत्री पूर्ण वार्ता और समझदारीसे सुल्झाना चाहीए । सत्य मेव जयते
Nepal and India are blood bonded! We both are one! from Lord Gautam buddha to Hinduism we are equal! Governments can grow mutinous but as a citizen of our respected countries it's our duty aswell to keep them in check!
But now they are thinking Indian as their enemy...I can see many comments on Facebook and UA-cam..They abuse Indians...They are think Pakistan as their friends and India as their Enemy
@@genichiroashina1 I know, but most of the account as genuine Nepali account....I was shocked that the Country which happened to be Hindu Country hates India and love Islamic states and i was shocked more when i see the accounts were real...They say they don't care about Hindu...
Firstly we Nepalese genuinely have no problem or hatred for india citizens.. the problem is only with indian modi government to be very specific which is fair enough for blockade and dominance over small country where there is roti beti sambandh.. Secondly I have seen many comment in social media where indian citizens are saying we take islamic country like Pakistan as our genuine friend which is so incorrect.. neither we have open border like with india nor we have any access to their culture or traditions.. Thirdly most of the indian citizens thinks that we stay in China's lap or some other shit.. but the fact is modi government created gap between our good relation with blockade, political interference, interference while drafting constitution, border capture and so on.. china just fill that gap as we all know that china is pure business man.. Lastly indian people will say that the blockade is not done by indian government.. to them please check video on UA-cam where opposition party of india themselves spoke against this blockade.. I m sorry i forgot name of that politician but you will find them.. See we don't want this hatred.. we just want peace.. so responsible citizens instead of spreading hatred should give pressure to your government to solve this problem for ever.. To conclude this, just want to say modi government failed to meet expectations of indian citizen.. economic recession seen on india.. to fight with this government took loan from reserve bank of India and to collect more money from public they raised fine.. at one point fine on vehicle was so high that it was higher that price of vehicle.. Hatred for india government reached at a peak and to divert mind of citizens they raised article 370 and Kashmir issue.. government knows its very easy to play with indian sentiment.. they have always played pakistan Pakistan to make fool out of Indian citizen.. After Kashmir issue modi government raise border issue just to distract indian citizen.. if not why they have to inaugurate roads at this point where entire world is fighting against corona.. I found hatred in indian citizens for us and one of the biggest reason is they are not provided with proper facts by government and godi media.. I know many people won't take my above points.. but its fine.. dont need to buy my points.. just read it once and done..
Nepal and India bhaiyo ki tarah hai....kabhi kabhi nauk jhok hoti ki Iska matlab he nhi ki rishta kamjoor hai....hum milkar kar jald hi iss vivad ko suljha lenge...... Sabko apni matrabhoomi se pyaar hota hai aur yeh baat humse acha Kaun samjhta hai.... Sir ka bahut bahut dhanyawad.
I fell in love with HISTORY because of lectures of #MAHIPAL SIR.....[ never thought that this subject would be so interesting and now rarely missed even a single video uploaded by him...] Thank you a lot sir....
And i fall in love with history when i was in 6th class bcoz of my teacher...he was a legend ,it was like we were watching a movie ,he never use book also didn't allow us to carry book...salute to u sir wherever u r
Nepalese was never a friend of indian people. They were friend of Britishers. They helped Britishers even in 1857. They helped Chinese in 1962. Now they are still helping the Chinese
Huge respect to Dr. Mahipal Singh Rathore from Nepal🇳🇵。one thing very clear is that we never demand something more nor we want to lose our an inch of land. We raise our voice so that Our brave soldiers’s prestige remains same like before. #bravegorkhas 🔪
Bhai ham bhutan jise chote desh or sacche friend ke lia jb chinese se unki zamin bachane ke lia doklam me lad sakte hai to ksi ki zamin kyu lege bhai or ye jo nepal bhai india khilaf bina kuch jaane bijhe zaher ugal rhe hai na ye zaher ek din inhe hu kha jye ga
suraj singh try to understand politics. In the present context, India is alone in South Asia. India wants to be the power house of Aisa like Japan, China and want to the member of Security council but with the same attitude of domination, intimidation. It is next to impossible. In fact India is being alone. Look at Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Nepal. India loses them already.
Venoth Kumaar that’s non of our business. If you want fight, go and fight. But one I want to mention. If you start fight with China, Pakistan would be the one who win.
Indian government ko nepal government ke sath beth kar is problem ko hamesha ke liye khatam kar dena chahiye, dono ki dosti aur border par shanti bani rahe. Jai Hind
🇳🇵🚩🇮🇳🇳🇵🚩🇮🇳 Total number of forces in Nepal is 2 lakhs (1lakh army +35000 APF +65000 NEPAL POLICE). In Nepal army 95% are khas pahari. 🇳🇵🚩🇳🇵🚩🇳🇵. Be positive
1. यदि आर्यों ने भारत पर आक्रमण किया और संस्कृत आर्यों की भाषा थी, तो यूरोप में संस्कृत का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं है? 2. अगर आर्य हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों के लेखक थे और उन्होंने इसका अनुसरण किया, तो इसका मतलब है कि वे हिंदू थे। फिर यूरोप में हिंदू धर्म का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं मिला? 3. अगर आर्यों को घोड़ों और रथों के लिए जाना जाता है, तो घोड़े और रथ 1500BC के बाद भारत में आने चाहिए थे लेकिन महाभारत के युद्ध (हड़प्पा सभ्यता के लगभग समकालीन) में घोड़ों और रथों का प्रयोग हुआ था और पूरे भारत से राजाओं ने भाग लिया था. इसका मतलब है कि पुरे भारत के राजाओं पास घोड़े और रथ थे। यह कैसे संभव हो सकता है? 4.हड़प्पा सभ्यता और आर्यों के बीच में क्या हुआ? हड़प्पावासी ही उत्तर भारत की और पुरे भारत में फैले. हाल ही में जीन एनालिसिस भी हुआ है. लगभग पुरे के लोग जो भारतीय सभ्यता के है, उनके जीन हरप्पा और राखीगढ़ी से मिलता है. 5. अगर आर्यों ने भारतीय लोगों को दक्षिण की ओर जाने के लिए मजबूर किया। फिर प्राचीन काल से ही दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय एक-दूसरे को दुश्मन क्यों नहीं मानते थे? 6.यदि आर्य विदेशी थे तो सभी भारतीय एक ही धर्म और धार्मिक अनुष्ठानों का पालन क्यों करते थे? हिंदू धर्म और हिंदू देवताओं के अलावा कोई और धर्म और देवता जरुर होने चाहिए थे। 7. आर्य 1500 में आये तो भारत के बारे में इतना कैसे लिख दिए? 8. भारतीयों के बहुत कम जीन(Gene ) ही यूरोपियों के समान क्यों हैं? और हड़प्पा सभ्यता के जीन(gene) दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय दोनों के साथ अधिक से अधिक क्यों मेल खाते हैं? आज के दिनों में कई लोग दूसरे देशों के लोगों के साथ शादी करते हैं, यह उस समय भी संभव हो सकता था और इस वजह से, भारतीयों के कुछ प्रतिशत जीन यूरोपीय लोगों के साथ मेल खाते होंगे, इस पर विचार क्यों नहीं हुआ? 9. क्यों अंग्रेजों के AIT से पहले भारतीयों को आर्यों के आक्रमण या पलायन के बारे में कुछ नहीं पता था? क्यों सभी भारतीय सोचते थे कि वे सभी भारत के मूल निवासी हैं? 10. क्या यह "फूट डालो और राज करो" की नीति के तहत नहीं था? क्या हम भारतीय अब तक मूर्ख नहीं बन रहे हैं? क्या भारत की कई मूल जनजातियाँ जैसे द्रविड़ और मुंडा आदि नहीं हैं? 11. वेद कहता है "आर्य" का अर्थ है महान व्यक्ति, क्या यह गलत है?
Dear Sir, The content which you accumulate and the way you present and speak is beyond any appreciation. So i love listening to your videos even when i am not a upsc aspirant. Truly inspiring. Thank you.
You are awesome. I am from Nepal. I have seen several journalists of India talking without research. Thank you so much for being neutral. You have researched well and giving a true massage to Indian friends. Our claim is simple, Kalapani, and Lipulek are disputed regions. None of Nepal and India can construct a road in such disputed area. Once again thank you sir.
Hello everyone... Please donot spread hate/ blame game...India and Nepal both are close allies and now a days so many forigen powers, NGOs and media houses are trying to cause a drift between us...stay hopeful we can solve our conflicts by talks Thanks for positivity
1. यदि आर्यों ने भारत पर आक्रमण किया और संस्कृत आर्यों की भाषा थी, तो यूरोप में संस्कृत का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं है? 2. अगर आर्य हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों के लेखक थे और उन्होंने इसका अनुसरण किया, तो इसका मतलब है कि वे हिंदू थे। फिर यूरोप में हिंदू धर्म का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं मिला? 3. अगर आर्यों को घोड़ों और रथों के लिए जाना जाता है, तो घोड़े और रथ 1500BC के बाद भारत में आने चाहिए थे लेकिन महाभारत के युद्ध (हड़प्पा सभ्यता के लगभग समकालीन) में घोड़ों और रथों का प्रयोग हुआ था और पूरे भारत से राजाओं ने भाग लिया था. इसका मतलब है कि पुरे भारत के राजाओं पास घोड़े और रथ थे। यह कैसे संभव हो सकता है? 4.हड़प्पा सभ्यता और आर्यों के बीच में क्या हुआ? हड़प्पावासी ही उत्तर भारत की और पुरे भारत में फैले. हाल ही में जीन एनालिसिस भी हुआ है. लगभग पुरे के लोग जो भारतीय सभ्यता के है, उनके जीन हरप्पा और राखीगढ़ी से मिलता है. 5. अगर आर्यों ने भारतीय लोगों को दक्षिण की ओर जाने के लिए मजबूर किया। फिर प्राचीन काल से ही दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय एक-दूसरे को दुश्मन क्यों नहीं मानते थे? 6.यदि आर्य विदेशी थे तो सभी भारतीय एक ही धर्म और धार्मिक अनुष्ठानों का पालन क्यों करते थे? हिंदू धर्म और हिंदू देवताओं के अलावा कोई और धर्म और देवता जरुर होने चाहिए थे। 7. आर्य 1500 में आये तो भारत के बारे में इतना कैसे लिख दिए? 8. भारतीयों के बहुत कम जीन(Gene ) ही यूरोपियों के समान क्यों हैं? और हड़प्पा सभ्यता के जीन(gene) दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय दोनों के साथ अधिक से अधिक क्यों मेल खाते हैं? आज के दिनों में कई लोग दूसरे देशों के लोगों के साथ शादी करते हैं, यह उस समय भी संभव हो सकता था और इस वजह से, भारतीयों के कुछ प्रतिशत जीन यूरोपीय लोगों के साथ मेल खाते होंगे, इस पर विचार क्यों नहीं हुआ? 9. क्यों अंग्रेजों के AIT से पहले भारतीयों को आर्यों के आक्रमण या पलायन के बारे में कुछ नहीं पता था? क्यों सभी भारतीय सोचते थे कि वे सभी भारत के मूल निवासी हैं? 10. क्या यह "फूट डालो और राज करो" की नीति के तहत नहीं था? क्या हम भारतीय अब तक मूर्ख नहीं बन रहे हैं? क्या भारत की कई मूल जनजातियाँ जैसे द्रविड़ और मुंडा आदि नहीं हैं? 11. वेद कहता है "आर्य" का अर्थ है महान व्यक्ति, क्या यह गलत है?
@@priyank3530 it also demolishes Aaryan Invasion/migrations theory. May be we Indian were the first to rule over the most part of the world. Before British there was no any theories like Aryan/Invasion migrations theory. It was only under divide and rule policy. You can also watch the video about it on Study IQ.
Angreji nahi chhodte toh alag alag bhasha wale log apas me baat kaise karte.. Angreji aaj bhi jivit hai kyunki ye upyogi sabit hui hai, alag alag kshetra ke logo ko apas me communicate kar pane me.
Angrej nhi aate bhai to mujhe bta india kabhi ek desh ban pata ?? Kya rajputana jo khud alag alag rajao m banta hua tha .. vo ek ho pata ?? Jo hona tha vo ho chuka .. Hmne struggle kiya independence mili .. Hmne ek naya united bharat bnaya .. Hm vishv ki 3rf or 4th biggest army h , hm nuclear power h , hm economic power h .. Hmari problems hme hi solve krni h bhai .. Hr bar past ko blame nhi kar sakte .. Past m jo hua vo q hua usse sikh lekar aage badhna h
Thank you Dr Rathore for giving detail and correct information about Anglo - Nepal war. However a small mistake has been made about General Amar Singh Thapa, he didn't get martyrdom rather he died of natural cause. Thank you.
In and around Muslim and British era India was in many kingdoms it used to be not the case in early periods of Mourya and Ashoka empires and all Nepal was part of Great Mouryan empire, proof of that is Ashoka Pillars in Present day Nepal in Rummindei and Nigliva. Hopefully once again these parts will be united forever and make a strong Hindu state.
In those day (and it still is today), it was totally legitimate for any country to gain territories by military conquest or by other means (such as marriage, inheritance and exchange of territories). A majority of the countries in the world were made this way. The territories that Nepal lost to East India Company in the 1814-16 Anglo-Nepal War did not belong to Nepal in the first place. They were conquered by Nepal from their local rulers only a few decades earlier. They belonged to us for a short time through conquest and then the British took them from us through conquest. Perfectly legitimate. So whether the Treaty of Sugauli is still intact or has been dismantled is of no consequence. India has no obligation to return the territories. Those (of my compatriots) who are demanding India to return it to us are either ignorant or do not want to accept the facts. If they want the territories back, then have to conquer them from India. It’s as simple as that. It’s not my fight and I won’t be a party to it.
Nepal compromised some areas in the south, west and the east( Dehradun, Darjeeling, Sikkim etc) and India made some compromises and it was all decided in the trearty of Sugauli. You are funny, sir. If the only treaty demarcating the borders is not factual enough then you are the ignorant one. It wasn't as if the document was signed in the stone age. According to your logic, India did not belong to India because it was conquered by the Britishers. The land belonged to Nepal and it is in the written documents and pacts that it still is. India was not a single state either, it has been unified in a long stretch of time. It is equivalent to saying India won't respect Pakistan's boundary because it had the influence of East India Company during the separation. India had rulers which were not Indians and they decided to sign an agreement and you coming out and claiming that the historical facts are not facts enough is plain stupidity. The fact that you are not ready to respect the treaties of the past says a lot about your character as well.
@@educationforyou1248 India Nepal se bhi jyada bada border dispute tha Bangladesh ke sath India ka lekin wo slove hogaya toh ye bhi solve ho jayega, ye toh bohot choti si chiz hai iske liye saalo tak baat karne ki koi jarurat nahi hai ye problem shayad 2,3 baar ma hi slove ho jayega
This is by far the respectful and neutral analysis. Prashant Sir also explains things very good but he favors little more to India. Prashant sir being indian, may be he does that but Rathore sir was spot on. Adding a bit, India claims the Kali Temple being the origin of Kali river which was built way way after the sugauli treaty. The acutal point of origin is the place called Limpiyadhura. Nepal has record of Census being conducted and land tax being collected. We know India is doing this because India sees lipulekh pass as way of transportation and kalapani as strategically important. We have all the evidences but India is there by force which is not a good sign to be friendly. India is loosing its neighbors. Nepal, bangladesh, sri lanka, maldives. No need to mention Pakistan, India sees pak as enemy which is not our concern. India must change its geo political policies. We Nepalese can control such strategically important places. So india must return our part of land without placing its ego on the way.
Your Nepal is running according to Chinese govt. Why you guys don't say something about sagarmatha (Mt. Everest). Some days back China claimed whole chomulungma . Nepal govt didn't say anything. All know China in playing a very cheap political game in Asia. China threatening south east Asian countries as well. You can see the recent news. China always trying to weaken other countries. Pls don't listen to China be a friendly nation as before.
nagaraj GB there was not any country called india in ancient time bro ... British east india company (british ) brought this in 18th century ... ancient time there was bharat barsa (mahabharat ) but this was not one a country there was so many nations from south bharat to northa bharat and they use to fight with each other amd some kingdoms like mauray , ghuta had ruled almost all lands of bharat barsh but whole bharat barsh was never a one country /nation , it was british was who united bharat by invading nations of bharat barsh , nepal was one of many .... india should treat us nice india is already a huge nations now why india has to take nepal small lands when nepal is already very small country ... we both are hindu country we should be good friend .
@@MrHuofeng well he was unhappy due to that treaty but he also had a lot of enemies in darbar because he was almost king of western Nepal. There were numerous conspiracies towards him some even called him british secret agent. All this made him sad and he left army and went to Himalayas where he died
unification was under process but still had to lose those parts in the hands of firangee and went under colonization...After the end of colonial era, they were neither returned to Nepal nor was freed. india, formed by Britshers kept occupying and perhaps people from there, too already accepted their new identity of being occupied by india... this is the truth
@@bimaladevi327 indeed but sikhs betrayed us (gorkhas) in the end, they joined britished raj instead of helping gorkhas because they were afraid of aggressive gorkha expansion. so we (gorkhas) the only hindu empire in bharatvarsha had to surrender to british. its a humiliating defeat for us.
The 8th point of India -Nepal Peace and friendship treaty signed in 1950 says " ALL THE PAST TREATIES SIGNED BETWEEN NEPAL AND EAST INDIA COMPANY BECOMES INVALID FROM NOW-ONWARD"....Doesn't that means india has to return the lands taken by british back to nepal after british left?? because treaty was signed between nepal and british (royal family). At present however ;given the strategic location of lipulekh ,india will unlikely give up that point easily. So it would be better if goverment talks out in more peaceful way and find a solution asap before intolerance starts to grow between peoples of two brotherly-nations !!!
It can also mean that India can backdate it's empire to a time when Nepal did not exist(it did not) and make it a part of india ? It is invalid bothways not just one way. We are friendly nations and should work together peacefully to resolve the issue.
I am from uttarakhand it was a part of gorkha rajvansh. Hamre vaha iss gorkha haar ko bakayada celebrate kiya jata hea. Aur haa hum nepali nahi hea. Kullu aur sikkim mea bhi regional tauhaar manaya jata hea. Jaha tak muhe pata hea. Aur kai log gorkha sasan ko bilkul pasand nahi karte the kyuki vaha pe gorkha raja ne Kumon aur garwaal se ladkiyo ko leke prostitute ki tarah bhi use karte the. To isiliye yea area vapas bhi nahi huva aur haa aaj bhi chidane ke liye tyuhaar mante hea. To sirf tumhare manne se kuch nahi hota.
I was reading history. The rule of Nepalis over Uttarakhand was very brutal and oppressive. Plus Wikipedia pe tho clearly explain kia hai pura scene.... Please check that out....
Hello Mahipal sir Namaste! I am from Nepal and I am your great fan. I watch all your study IQ videos and I have subscribed your channel because it’s very informative. By seeing this video I would like to thank you for how you interpreted the issues in a real sense. I believe this you have done with your deep research. You are speaking the truth with 100% purity in this matter. Some Indian channels like Republic of Arnab Goswami( most indisciplined & controversial Indian reporter) must learn from an intelligent and disciplined Indian person like you sir. Thank you for telling the truth to the world. But Arnab Goswami is just spreading rumours regarding Nepal India border issues and exaggerating the matter at its height which breaks the relationship bond that has existed between Nepal & India for many years.
i m from nepal and i seriously respect how u explained without annoying anyone nor indian or nepalese,but your media such as ABP whose words were so bitter,that media is such a shame to indian medias,we have a good friendship from years,and it seems these medias want to wage wars with their word rumors etc...hope this will be stopped and our relations will be as same as before one again
Few media in India or in Nepal always point fingers at each other govt. Fact is India and Nepal kingdom has a long and strong bond from thousands of years. Everyone knows China & pakistan are trying very hard to break this strong cultural bond. We educated people should never comment on few selected media or people from India or Nepal. Best is to ignore them because that is the source of conflict.
Thanks bro for saying facts ,Sikkim was independent at once ,annexed by Nepal for 40 years ,again got independence . Nepalese says that Sikkim as their part but it's not .
Sir letme clear the fact , i 've had visited the western part of Nepal 4 or 5 years ago. Yes you are right there are many small streams and ultimately they'll mix and we call it Mahakali river . However, there's a river whose water volume is extremely high compared to others and it originates form Limpuadhura. I think this is the main Mahakali river since it's origin is large. (As per definition of River,) . hey there is also a river near kalapani, artificially its path is deviated and its small ,indian army called it Mahakali , i dont know why they called it. To find the fact , you have to visit that place and find which is the main mahakali river ( we don't call Mahakali to many others small rivers there). Otherwise , you're sitting in the room 9000 miles away , googleling it, printing that googled data , viewing others interview, m sure you'll never find the actual fact. You must visit the area. Thats the only way to find truth.
@@RTL_Coder4u madam . Malai lagxa aba tya sam jana teti sajilo xaina . Sathi vai sag jaam herau nata vane jasto thau vayena hola tyo aile . Maile suneko jo pai tei Nepali haru lae tyo bibad area ma jana dinna re .
Lots of kumaon area are still in nepal...the sudur paschim praant of Nepal is kumaoni and dotiyali dominated.....anyways who care what nepal have or india have... we have to focus on what we have now and make that region develop....
@SUMIT CHETTRI what are you talking about. Kumau gadwal are and western Nepal are khash people who came from khibarpass when alexgender the grate was expanding his empire. The different between Aryan and Khas people are like Chandra gupt mourya vs alexgender the great. Aryan people have more like dark brown features where as khash are more like white.
Nepal government knew that there was a road being built by India. When BRO started working on that road, they should have raised concerns at that time. Also BRO did not built the road, they just developed the road which was previously present there. Why Nepal government did not object back then, if they thought that was Nepal's territory. India spent a huge amount of money on developing that road for pilgrims.
U are again wrong. The first thing is that, India should concern why India built infrastructure in Nepal Territory. If built, Then India do encroachment of Nepal land. U have no any right to do so!!
Yaar mujhe lag rha hai ye nepal ki govt bik gyi hai China ki govt ko...bs or koi baat nhi hai...Nepali Kal bhi humare Bhai the age bhi rhege...Nepal ke sath hum humesha hai
@@tridentmusic4833 @@@@ bhai Saab Aap galat hain. Sayed Aapko pata nahi hain. Yeh jo road banaye hain aaplog ne woh Indian PM Narendra Narendra Modi aur chinese PM Li Keqiang ni 2015 mein jake AGREEMENT signed kiya tha Economic Corridor k liye!! Truth jano, bhai. Khali media sun k bakchodi mat karo. Yeh Indo sino AGREEMENT hain. Toh Nepali kaise bik sakte hai bhai. Sachhai na tumhari media tumhe batati hain na hi tumhari govmnt. Dushre ka jamin kabja karo!! Aur swor bhi machaow. Shame!! Shame!!
Yeh sabhi Indian bhaion ko nahi pata hain. Yeh jo road banaye hain woh Indo- china Economic Corridor k hissa hain jo Indian PM Narendra Modi and Chinese PM Li Keqiang sign kiya tha 2015. Jakey PM Modi ko puxa bhai log phir AAP. Fuckat bakchodi mat karo woh 3rd class Indian media waali.
The border which India claim is just a small stream of river. And the border that Nepal claim is huge and original Kali river consisting maximum volumes of water originates from himalayas of Limpiyadhura. According to the universal law of river, limpiyadhura is the original Kali river's origin. Before indo-sino war in 1962, Indian army forcefully come to kalapani and made base camp for the defence against China. Nepal Government also allows this, in agreement with Indian government, for the defence until the war ends. But after the war ends, kalapani seems to be the perfect location for army base camp and business purposes, Indian army do not want to leave that place and claims kalapani as their land. India, now being large and strong, always try to show the wrong power and dominates the smaller countries.
True.No wonder why India doens't have good relationship with her neighbouring countries..there are plenty of such news .. india has always been the one that encroaches the border.
Nepal is not innocent either.they supress Religion in nepal.Majority of Nepali men women children are Hindu religion but nepal remove Hindu country title and add communist. and when Bharat was fighting Mleccha(muslim&christian country ivasion armies)Nepal attack Bhartiya and capture lands. first it should be calculated how much Bhartiya land nepal has captured.and all of it should be returned.
@@जितेन्द्रगुप्ता-छ4न First We all Nepali people do not want to have social discrimination in terms of any aspects. Either we are hindu or Muslims or Buddhist, we are all equal. And we want our identity to be as Nepali. I am also belong to Hindu religion but I have great love and respect towards other religions too. Secondly, we do not attack any bhartia people and capture other land.
Few hours before I was watching 6month old kalapani issue ...and in the mean time i get chance to watch this Sugauli treaty relevance to this topic.. Good analysis detailed in a simple way..
This was great knowledge who did know the history of Nepal. I request you to talk about the map that was printed and is still present in London, US and other coutries. Please talk about the map that was created till India was independent. That will be a great proof to stop all these India Nepal hatred situation. Also talk why india posted army in kala pani area.
@@Professor314-21 kisi k marne na marne se defend kr lega ye logic clear kroge agr Amar Singh thapa na bhi Marta ya mar jata to usse aj ki ya uss time ki boundary pr ky effect pdta
@@Professor314-21 Bhai dekh jitna Maine pdha h or jitna Wikipedia ya authentic jitna h usme to yhi likh h ki wo war me ghayal ho kr mare yank ki Killed in Action to mujhe khi se baate glt Ni lgi or agr wo marte ya na marte fr bhi treaty pr koi effect pdta Ni to defend ki baat na kro may be ap logo ki trf koi Kahani ho ki wo war me ni mare but teacher h wo or teacher ussi pr baat krega Jo exam me sahi Mana jyega so student prospect se dekho or search kro tmhe bhi killed in action hi milega or defend jaisi baat na kro kuki aj subh hi Nepal ne kha h ki unhe koi dikkt ni h ISS road se so clear your self
i think you are the first indian becoz no body want to talk about this topic specially indians. thanks for this video and the truth. i respect you and i will. god bless you.
Really good and helpful information i really appreciate for all of your's hard work I would really love to see English version of these videos some time people who don't understand Hindi want to understand these information as well but they can't
यह विडियाे सुगाैली सन्धि के उपर अपनी तरह का पहला है i think so| thanks sir for this truth. love from nepal. भारतीय सरकार जिसकाे महाकाली नदी का origin बाेल रही है वह दरअसल एक छाेटी सी मन्दिर बना दिया अाैर नाम काली मन्दिर दे दिया गया । उसीके बगल मे एक छाेटी सी कुन्ड है जहाँ से बहुत थाेडी पानी बह रहा है । अाेैर ईश तरह षड्यन्त्र करके कालापानी नाम देदिया। जबकि महाकाली का origin लिम्पियाधुरा है जहाँ है विशालकाय महाकाली नदी बहती है। इसका origin खुदका बनाया हुअा कुन्ड नही बल्कि हिमालय है।
@@msahai7017 hypocrisy is coming from Nepal ..they hv nothing to say to there Chinese brothers who hv been regularly encroaching their land,interfering in their politics, trapping them in huge debt.. India has been providing Nepalis govt jobs dude since years,India has always stood by Nepal and this is what they are giving. And even you don't know what's right and what's wrong so I also cannot comment on that
@@msahai7017 or agar kalapani India n Nepal Ko de bhi diya to they will invite Chinese Soldiers over there and that wd be problematic for us..Nepal cannot be trusted now
In 1805, war faught between Maharaja Sansar chand katoch (10000army) of kangra and gurkhas(40000 army) under amar singh thapa....two wars happened in which katoch army won first war and lost 2nd...then Katoch king left to Kangra fort.....gurkha army tried to capture kangra fort for 3 years but failed.....then in 1809 Maharaja Ranjit singh himself came with army and defeated gurkhas.....
@@LONEWOLF-ss5dy clear cut defeat.....amar singh thapa with 40000 soldiers and the armies of chamba kehlur and sirmour princely states were defeated by combine sikh and katoch army in 1809 and were pushed back beyond satluj river...
First time I watch video info about nepal and its past history in good research and 99% truth by Indian youtuber . All peoples who are in India and don't know about nepal and not research and follow media influences they should watch this video.
I'm from kumaun and kalapani and lipulekh is ours. Half of our kumaun is already in Nepal, we can't loose any more territory. Nepalese need to know that they are not going to get any Greater Nepal. They should stop claiming territories based on old kingdoms.
Can you give a piece of land to your neighbour. What if your neighbour claimed your land as his land. What the hell is wrong with you. Jitna tum Indian ko kashmir pyara hai kalapani is much more important to nepalies. U better don't dare to comment that its your land. Just go back. Dotnt dare to clame that's your land. If so it wil be risky for nlindian government.
@HIMANSHU SINGH himachal sikim darjeling is our. That's our great nepal. If u speak like this.. All those land were owned by British not India. So India keep quite and watch. U don't have any right to interfair here. Fuck Indian politicians 😒. I hate modi. And kapalbastu was our Is our and will be our. Get that.
DR mahipal singh rathore you intentionally forget to mention that 1950 treaty between india and nepal, 1950 treaty article 8 clearly mention that the sugauli treaty is now cancelled and india must return all the lands to nepal including sikkim and all the hill stations you mentioned above and all the land of terai to nepal.
Sahi h sabko india chahiye.. pakistan ko, china ko, Bangladesh ko, Nepal ko.. to hum kya karenge bhajan?? Aur ye sahi h phle khud kisi aur ki zameen pe kabza karo fir agar usko wapas pana h to treaty karo aur jab mann kare to treaty cancel karke kabze ke zameen wapas mangne lago... Q itna lalach h sabko raho shanti se aur rhne do..
If the 1950 treaty makes past treaties invalid and by that logic you ask parts of India, India can backdate it's empire when Nepal did not exist(it did not) and ask it to become a part of India. What say?
@@bipulsapkota6715 brother mujhe lgta h ki aapko history achhe se padhne ki jarurat hai.. humne kabhi kisi ko lans steal Ni ki... Ki hoti to aaj humari hoti.. plz don't spread hatred.. one day or the other u must realise that what India actually is???
@@vikashpal4875 मैं ने किसी Country को search कर रहा थाyou tube पे तब प्रशांत sir का वीडियो देखा Country of world series ka video तभी से फैन होगया Study iq का मैं नेपाली हू bro
@@Sanatani_pankaj1 Nepali people should understand that anyone who attacks nepal equals attacking india. So we are not their enemies. Otherwise china had already annexed nepal into tibbet
Fair and truth lecture sir....love from Nepal we want our land as per sugauli treaty. And talking about origin of kali river check out political map released by india in 2017,check out the map released in 2007 showing river system in uttarakhand cleary mentioned kali river emerges from limpiyadhura.
@@amitpadal6089 we want the govt. To settle the issue but you people are abusing our whole nation... want everything without even debating or talking...
The government of Nepal has decided today to publish revised map of Nepal including the whole region of Kalapani. The first step of taking back our land.
Attention here.. Read whole plz This treaty is also called as treaty of sangauli. -this treaty signed between gurkha genral Amar singh thapa and the brithish Major David ochhterloney . Year 2 dec 2015 Under this treaty Gurkhas were allowed to return along with there private property to Nepal and keaving the hilly territory from river kali to satluj under the sovereignty of brithishes. After, This treaty is ratified, And this treaty is signed between EICompany represented Leutanant col Parish BRADSHAW and guru gajraj mishra from side of nepal king. Date- 4 march 1816 Again, sanguali treaty was superseded in dec 1923 by treaty of perpetual peace and friend ship. Later, A seperate treaty was signed with India in 1950 which resorted fresh relation between the two independent countries. Histroy /Reason for war - gurkahs invaede hilly region oh uk and hP. Gurkha forces barbarberic in natur they looted and killed people of kangra and its impact was that all pople of kangra migrated to plains. Raja Sansar chand kept himself inside kangra fort for 3 year 1806 to 1809 (after losing in Battle Mahal moria 1806.).becoz its is sorounded by gurlahs for 3 yr. When himachal ,kangara king Sanasar chand asked help from maharaj Ranjit sing( treaty of jawalamukhi date 1809 after a month negotiation ) , so maharaja ranjit defeated Amar singh thap and pushed the gurkhas to other side of satluj river. Son now gurkhas start controling today shimal area solan nalagarh etc. And the exploitd every hill riyasat . - on humanitarian ground - atrocities of gurkahs was absolute barbaric - so hill riyast asking help form Britisher. -trade dispute happn in imporrant pass which leato to tibet(tibet because was source for musk and Borox) btwn Brithisher and Amar singh thapa. -and ,Amar singh thapa gurkha general, claming 6 villages on yhe bases of the fact that these 6 village were part of sirmaur riyasat. Ans all the local chief of shimala hill riyast states the British to take action. After this treaty, -bithis recruited and grokha regiment est at sabathu , hiamchal. Royal gurkha england -nepal lost the right to deploy any American and EU employee in its service. -1/3rd of Neplases territory lost to brither that the king of nepal won in last 25 year. Eg sikkim, kuaman gharwal. -but traih region was restored to Nepalin 1860. Becoz nepal help brithisher to supress 1857 revolt. And last brithis granted SANANDS( conditional independency) to hilly area inky upper satluj area today shimla sirmaour solan,( not kangars mandi) but later chamaba also got sanand.
Some older people in uttrakhand Garwhal also tell us about their atrocities in our Garwhali people ...we called their reign Gurkhani ....They attacked Garwhal in 1791 but got defeated but again in 1803 when garwhal was facing a destruction from earthquake , they attacked and conquered whole region ....
2 Dec 2015? And Amar singh never signed any treaty. Gurkhas built multiple temples in Kumaon and Garhwal region including gangotri. Amar singh thapa banned rent free grant of land to brahamin. Therefore they made fake stories around him.
@@parthsachdeva7280 and no need to be glad or proud of your sikh Heritage they constantly raided dehradun and took whatever they found. It was gorkhas who made them go back to there kingdom and dehradun was free of their reign for 12 years. The fact all our kingdom has dark side too which we are often not taught
@@axel3895 read book mian singh govedhan blokhra government approved. . No need to be sentimental.. And emotional Agar exam de rhe ho toh.. Fact pakdo.. Local logo ki kha niyha ne.. HPAS exam ka most imp topic hai yeah topic mains mai.
Sir ne kya kaha shayad aapne theek se suna Ni.. british chupchaap Bengal se dekh rhi thi ki nepal kaise expand kar rha h war karke... Treaty me wohi land wapas British ne le li so ideally wo land to India ko hi belong karta h na..
Hume kisi ka land aur property Ni chahiye bas jo humari h wohi bani rhe bht hai... Na hi humne attack karke kisi ki property pe kabza kiya h .. so plz don't complicate this issue... Hum indian Nepalese ke liye itna kuch karte but still hostility milti h.. dekh lenge china aapko kitna apna manta hai???
Nepal is a part of India history because our hindu Kosala kingdom extended across both banks of the Sarayu (modern Ghaghara) River and north into what is now Nepal. According to the Hindu epic the Ramayana, Kosala was ruled by kings descended from the Sun; one of these kings was Rama, whose capital was Ayodhya (Oudh), near modern Faizabad... Kingdom of Kosala was an ancient Indian kingdom, corresponding roughly in area with the region of Awadh in present-day Uttar Pradesh.
If u think like that then there is no country in this world! But since country exists! Our Country Nepal is unified by King Prithvi Narayan Shah! just like Gandhi unified independent! Your country and my country exists after unification! Just dont make assumption and support your country only! It will make more enemies! You are making patroism on ur country making enemies! Its better to have mutual understand and negotiation and support what is right! Hope u understand! Respect for both countries!
Thats the point bro! Youre going back to history, we are going back to history! If we keep on going back on time then no country exists! You are judging from one specific time and I am judging on one specific time!
India is soo big country. Why india need nepal's land. If india has necessary then india should lease this area from Nepal. This situation is win win for both counties.
N u both depend on Indian assistantance!!! From trade to military trainings... Agri products to services... So dnt b foolish n have open mind to analyse the situation.
These are invaded lands. Gurkhas were ruthless, cruel and merciless towards the inhabitants of these places. Not to forget, the EIC already took these territories back 200 years ago.
You can say that when British left India they gave back all land that belong India to Indians but forgot to give the land that belong to Nepal to Nepalese and Indians are enjoying others property as that of there own and also disputing...
Nepali rule only 20 years over garhwal and kumao aur vo unki ho gyi esa kya janmo janmantar se unka nhi tha uk and hp jaise unhone kabja kiya vaise british ne kabja kiya
@Gaurav Bisht So Kumaon and gadhwal should be separate country from india according to you. You know india is like collection of countries.... Today you lost your culture and became hindi speaking like plain people.....And you are speaking as if people drop from sky to your place? Where did kumauni gadhwali came ?????
20 year kabje me lene se koi state kisi ka nahi ho jata ?? Agar India apne greater india ka land claim karega to kya hoga ?? Wese bhi wo area ek raja ke kabje me tha not of Nepal govt .
We all Indians🇮🇳(mainly Sanatani🚩) love Nepal🇳🇵 and Nepali peoples ❤️ but hate nepal communist party govt. 😖 Because the Nepal government is a puppet of the Chinese government.
Bhai tum godi midia ki baat sunoge to pkisthan ko bhi nepal kaa bhaai batayega china se jayada bharat se ache riste hai nepal ke bharat ho yaa china dono hamaare padosi desh hai or padosi se riste achee hone chahiye
Kalapani area officially falls in pithoragarh district of kumaon uttrakhand india as per treaty of sugauli,but even if it falls in darchula district of western nepal as claimed by nepal then also this darchula district along with baitadi and doti district was historically part of kumaon kingdom that snatched away from kumaon in sugauli treaty
Download our app - play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.studyiq.android
We hate India,, back off india
Please try to understand 🙏
Y India is showing wrong power
India is big land of country , then also India want Nepali land.. why???
How much u want .. come and eat our body
We want Nepali land Sikkim, Darjeeling Uttarakhand,
Law of karma is there Pakistan & China is doing good with good..
Plese make a video about kerala covid19 model
We Nepalese people support India stand on lipulek but few khas pahari aren't. Don't worry be happy 🇳🇵🚩🇳🇵🚩🇳🇵
Gi tag wala video banaye sir
Sir one request..
Plzz make a detailed video on What FM Sitaraman announced yesterday. Plzzz
Being a Nepali, I can tell that this is best and accurate analysis made by any Indian towards the current conflict..
Hope both sides of the government should table talk and solve this problem as soon as possible..
Your government is under the influence of China.
@@RahulSingh-zv6qd what if I tell you, your government is under US influence? burned, isn't it? same thing happens when you blame us without any proof.
@@nischalkoirala994 We give jobs to Nepalese people in our government jobs. America has nothing to do with this border. But China is playing diplomacy in it.
@@nischalkoirala994 we brought S400.from russia instead of the CAATSA act under the threat of sanctiones ..... your government cannot even give a single anti china statement in the favour of nepal...so next time vote carefully
@@RahulSingh-zv6qd tum map jari karo toh haq, hum vi waise hi karein toh what the fuck? aisa kon karta hai bhai..
Best and neutral analysis. Huge respect to you Rathore Sir from 🇳🇵
Bro it all started cuz of that communist party in Nepal which is going to be nothing but a puppet of CPC..
WE love our Nepali brothers and sisters..
Love and respect from India.
Dear nepali brothers we love you a lot . Don't spread hate against us . China is doing shit diplomacy through nepali communist party . They intentionally spread hate against us . Be awake
krishna rawat hope hum naftat ko ni apnayenge mere kafi workers nepal se h ,mene hamesa iske baare mei unse pucha toh unhone pahle mana kar diya but bht time baad ek ne mujko btaya aur 1806 se pahle ka map dikaya mene jab unko sach bataya toh unhone bataya aajkal nepal mei maowadi yahi sab kar rahe h taki india ke kilaf hate message fele aur ye ab government tak aa gaye h
Indian bros dont involve china in everything ..becoz indian govt had occupied our land ...and claiming its as it own..so it us natural thar we fought back..for our land..hope..indian govt return what is ours..then this prblm will be solved..
Divide and rule policy are now used by China between two Hindu majority countries...
Maan gaye sir without bias video bana dali.. 👏 👏 👏
Respect.! 🙏
Love from Nepal 🇳🇵 👍❤️
Bro it is civil service preparation channel not dump channel who is spreading hate between two we know what is truth
We brother but some countries doesn't want
K ko ni yesta misleading garne video xa na kehi study gareko xa k ko yesta lai ramro vaneko ni? Dr re k bhutri dr k science ma nadiko muhan kun ho bhanera prasta bhanxa Jun lamo Ra paniko Matra dherai vako nadi Jun sthan bata aauxa tyo muhan ho Tara yo haram dr le tributaries lai muhan bhaneko ma Pani sahi thapne ani Nepal le haryo re British le jityo re Jun British le Pani aafno history ma bhaneko xaina ki Nepal le hareko bhanera ani yo sale ko ho Nepal le harera treaty garyo bhanne yesto video lai dislike nagarera murkha Nepali haru.
100% true... U r rely true man. I m frm Nepal n i hv watched ur max lecture n i rely lov dat. Thnx fr ur honesty. 🇳🇵🇳🇵
@rrpatil2006 we hv already lost. Our hard tym we didn't get any good governance who hv loved our nation n wrk fr our country.
@rrpatil2006 🤞🤞👍👍
@@thearvindsingh2615 yah u can say dat... At somehow!!
@@thearvindsingh2615 dnt wry we wnt let dat happen....
@@shailendraadhikari5085 even in INDIA there are many problems bcoz of illegal- immigrants from BANGLADESH & PAKISTAN and that's why we need NRC here. During AAKHAND BHARAT era, things were different but w.r.t. time, things got mixed & messed up and have changed a lot. As we are not living in 6th - 7th Century now. It's high time 4 both the govt. 2 take a tough call and sort it out the differences via Public Domain 4 both the Nation.
Otherwise Anjaam bahut bura hoga aage jaakar, dono mulko ke liye.
Peace out🙏🙏🙏
Wake up with study iq sleep with study iq..🔥🍫🙏
Bahut achha
I also sister.i can't sleep without this lecture.
Ya true.. Same mera bhi h..
Ha same here
All day long..
I'm from Uttrakhand India and I have many Nepali friends they are kind, open minded, friendly. So I am learning Nepali language and my friends are helping in that. It's very simple and easy for me because some of the words are similar to my mother tongue garwali language. Lots of love for Nepali language and culture from Uttrakhand💓
Love from Nepal 🇳🇵
Too.
@@bottle676 lol katti nam change gareko hola😂
@@bottle676 jaile vettinxa yo
@@neutralboi1984 yo pani😂
We proud of our Gurkha Regiment. Nepalese are our brothers, this dispute will solve one day. Mujhe lagta h koi bhi nirnay baithkar soch samajh kar lena chahiye, sath hi Nepal ka point bhi valid H, wahi India ka bhi, Sara jhagda confusion ka h, kisi ka bhi yaha intention dusre ki sovereignty ko hurt karne ka nahi h.
Nepal ko bharat se dur karne me indian midia ka bada haath hai
@@sudipkarki3946 Ha ho sakta h, Media ko sudharna Chahiye.
@@hemangshrivastava9561 But ek baat or manni padegi, Nepal me koi media nahi h, lik china, Jo Government ka stance dikhaye, logo ki baat kare, Media ka hona bhi jaruri h.
Pura nepal india ka hain..
@@sparrowvlogs7998 kuchh bhi bakwas mat karo, yadi India ke ho, jo jiska h wo h. Or pakistani ho to apne kaam se kaam rakho, hame tum logo ki tarah kisi jameen par jabardasti apna adhikar nahi chahiye.
This one is totally favour with both countries. Respect sir! Love frm Nepal 🌷
Thank you sir for such a wonderful video. My respect towards Nepal has strengthened more. I am from India particularly from Motihari (Bihar) and I love Nepal and Nepali people. And I respect the sovereignty of Nepal and India. This matter has to be solved in diplomatic manner immediately and stop politicising it. It is simply worsening our relationship.
भारत और नेपाल एक बहुत ही सुलझे हुए व समझदार मित्र है। साथ ही एक ही संस्कृति से है, इसलिए एक परिवार तुल्य है। हम यह मामला भी जल्द ही बातचीत के माध्यम से सुलझा लेगे।
नेपाली भाईयों आप हिमालय पर जरूर ध्यान दीजिये, चीन उसको हड़पना चाहता है। 🙏
🇮🇳 Loves 🇳🇵 and 🇳🇵 loves 🇮🇳.
जय हिंद जय भारत 🇮🇳
Yes Bro But Modi Policy Towards Seems Like Now Towards Pakistan , According To India Pakistan Is Dusman Desh But Modi Shows Nepal Also Indian Dusman Desh Infact Modi Made Nepal Too Be Angry With India And Now Made Totally Against It......Now We Nepalese Hate These Hitler Facist Modi And BJP ... Ultimately India Loose Nepal..
@@DeepSu1235541 shut your mouth do not interfere in our area
Do research !! We have Himalayan civilization and culture !! it's different from India !!
@@shovadahal3961 ha Aur uttrakhand aur himachal to southindia me ate hai na
@Shubham ChauhanUK n far west Nepal much similar in terms of dialect, culture, custom.
A person who is looking for peace is obviously in turmoil
Bhai kiya tu rojina comment liktha hai mai pehele comment mai kuch gk dhontha tha ab uske saath tere comment bhi search kartha hoom
@@veerswami7175 😂😂😂
@@veerswami7175 aree bhai 😂
sourabh Baghel
Not necessarily bro, there many person who are really not interested in any controversies
When you have to speak about the west border...you just skipped.... research again bro ...its fake!
This is way to brief after learning the history, great, love from Nepal 🇳🇵
if you know the history of your country, it had an area of just 2,500 square kilometres which your king decided to enlarge it by invading neighbouring countries... And you're claiming kalapani area just because of treaty signed between Britishers and your king... Do you know what it means? Also the reference of Kalapani is in mythology of ancient India but you have reference of it only during British raj.
Help me
@@susandmelli9273 plz go and research first..who asked king Mahendra bir bikram shah for those land during Indo china war...We gave you those land and India captured it..And what indian army is doing over there ..they just recently killed one Nepali when He was trying to cross the river.
@@educationforyou1248 please go and research how Nepal formed in first place
@@susandmelli9273 plz go and research and read sugauli treaty and Treaty of 1950.
Thank god due to this treaty i am in india from mithila area bihar.
Me tooo bro
Me too..i am kumaoni (east uttrakhand)
Nepal is not that bad, but at present i can say cities like delhi, bombay, banglore r ours..
That feeling of OURS is something different.. it's shows what an democratic country provides us
But still very undeveloped
But we are lucky to be Nepali
bro what will u say if some one told who are u and what is your history dont be pussy let that brave gorkhali blood burn.jay greater nepal
Im a nepali and hindu also though i respect all religion. India and nepal are very similar in many things. And biggest hindu countries also. Why india cant play a role like a friend or brother. Nepal is a small and less powerful countty. Why india is spreading hinduism in western country and playing as a villain in its neighbour hindu country. I love india and indian people. Lets stay as a good friend and neighbour. Lets spread love . Lets follow krishna and buddhas ways
Bro love from Kolkata
India has always respected other countries and supported them in times of need. But nepali under communist control are opportunistic as they have china card to play. Why don't you respect indian map
@@biswajeetdas11 I dont want to argue on yt. Just study the history as a neutral person
@@biswajeetdas11 India has been of help true but that doesn't mean it gets to bully people, you're doing the same thing that China is doing now. We never really liked the CCP, how they suppress human rights and all, but lately actions of BJP is closely resembling the CCP. China's not backing Nepal up, it's just a small country trying to stand up to it's bully neighbors. Both of them
Lol. India is spreading Hinduism in West?? R u nuts. U think Art of Living,Sadhguru and others r spreading Hinduism 😂. It's spiritualism bro,yoga and all. We r not Christian Missionaries. Hinduism is not just a religion but a way of living, it's a conjunction of many beliefs. And we r playing villain in neighbouring cntry lyk seriously u think that. Wth we care abt ur territory,we r 7th largest cntry bro we don't need to capture lands. And for Indians,we always want to hv the best of relationship with all countries irrespective of religion. Let them be Arabs or Africa etc.we always revere all nations. So there is no role of b Hinduism in improving relation. Ind-Nep hv long been gud frnds in terms of military exchanges, education,movies, culture etc. And culture is not solely dependant on religion ofc religion has it's impact but not totally. We always want gud relationship with all neighbouring countries be it Pak China Ban, but we won't ever relent when it comes to protect our sovereignty. We will always vouch for our land. Jai Hind
आपने सत्य, तथ्य और समझदारी
की वात कही ।
आप एक सच्चा और इमान्दार इनसानहो ।
ए भिडियो हर नेपाली और भारतियको
देखना चाहीए और सच्चाको समझकर
नेपाल भारतका सिमा विवादको सुल्झाना
चाहीए ।
अभी हम दोनो देश वसियोमे तनावहै
अव दो देशोके सरकार आमने सामने
बैठकर सिमा विवादको मैत्री पूर्ण वार्ता
और समझदारीसे सुल्झाना चाहीए ।
सत्य मेव जयते
2 minutes of silence for those who dislike this awesome lecture driven by our sir.
Yeah, what they saw any disliking thing in this awesome lecture by our sir
Bhakts don't like fact hence they dislike truth and love comforting lies
Nepal and India are blood bonded! We both are one! from Lord Gautam buddha to Hinduism we are equal! Governments can grow mutinous but as a citizen of our respected countries it's our duty aswell to keep them in check!
But now they are thinking Indian as their enemy...I can see many comments on Facebook and UA-cam..They abuse Indians...They are think Pakistan as their friends and India as their Enemy
@@Abhianand420 oh na that can be easily done by ISPR its there daily job to spread venom on social media and they are doing it quite well!
@@genichiroashina1 I know, but most of the account as genuine Nepali account....I was shocked that the Country which happened to be Hindu Country hates India and love Islamic states and i was shocked more when i see the accounts were real...They say they don't care about Hindu...
@@Abhianand420 they are gone
Firstly we Nepalese genuinely have no problem or hatred for india citizens.. the problem is only with indian modi government to be very specific which is fair enough for blockade and dominance over small country where there is roti beti sambandh..
Secondly I have seen many comment in social media where indian citizens are saying we take islamic country like Pakistan as our genuine friend which is so incorrect.. neither we have open border like with india nor we have any access to their culture or traditions..
Thirdly most of the indian citizens thinks that we stay in China's lap or some other shit.. but the fact is modi government created gap between our good relation with blockade, political interference, interference while drafting constitution, border capture and so on.. china just fill that gap as we all know that china is pure business man..
Lastly indian people will say that the blockade is not done by indian government.. to them please check video on UA-cam where opposition party of india themselves spoke against this blockade.. I m sorry i forgot name of that politician but you will find them..
See we don't want this hatred.. we just want peace.. so responsible citizens instead of spreading hatred should give pressure to your government to solve this problem for ever..
To conclude this, just want to say modi government failed to meet expectations of indian citizen.. economic recession seen on india.. to fight with this government took loan from reserve bank of India and to collect more money from public they raised fine.. at one point fine on vehicle was so high that it was higher that price of vehicle..
Hatred for india government reached at a peak and to divert mind of citizens they raised article 370 and Kashmir issue.. government knows its very easy to play with indian sentiment.. they have always played pakistan Pakistan to make fool out of Indian citizen..
After Kashmir issue modi government raise border issue just to distract indian citizen.. if not why they have to inaugurate roads at this point where entire world is fighting against corona..
I found hatred in indian citizens for us and one of the biggest reason is they are not provided with proper facts by government and godi media..
I know many people won't take my above points.. but its fine.. dont need to buy my points.. just read it once and done..
Nepal and India bhaiyo ki tarah hai....kabhi kabhi nauk jhok hoti ki Iska matlab he nhi ki rishta kamjoor hai....hum milkar kar jald hi iss vivad ko suljha lenge...... Sabko apni matrabhoomi se pyaar hota hai aur yeh baat humse acha Kaun samjhta hai....
Sir ka bahut bahut dhanyawad.
I fell in love with HISTORY because of lectures of #MAHIPAL SIR.....[ never thought that this subject would be so interesting and now rarely missed even a single video uploaded by him...]
Thank you a lot sir....
Same 2 u
And i fall in love with history when i was in 6th class bcoz of my teacher...he was a legend ,it was like we were watching a movie ,he never use book also didn't allow us to carry book...salute to u sir wherever u r
Hi
@@rutik9322 kitna bela hai re tu utube ko v dating site bna rha h...
@@Gamingwithshubham284 sorry bhai 😅
Indian and Nepali bhai bhai
हमे इन छोटी छोटी बातों से अपने रिस्ते खराब नही करनी चाहिए
Then give our land back to us
We will be bhai bhai after that
NEPAL abhi CHINA ke god me baitha hai, samay utar dega.
@@rajangurung4021 le lo
You guys are saying bhai bhai but silently occupying Nepali land.
Shitman.
What kind of brotherhood is this !?!
Nepalese was never a friend of indian people. They were friend of Britishers. They helped Britishers even in 1857. They helped Chinese in 1962. Now they are still helping the Chinese
This is called neighbour n true friend!!!!with so polite,,he shows d prove,,,,luv u from Nepal.......
This lecture was very helpful to understand the dispute of this region from a neutral point of view.
Huge respect to Dr. Mahipal Singh Rathore from Nepal🇳🇵。one thing very clear is that we never demand something more nor we want to lose our an inch of land. We raise our voice so that Our brave soldiers’s prestige remains same like before. #bravegorkhas 🔪
parth sachdeva thanks you brother.
Bhai ham bhutan jise chote desh or sacche friend ke lia jb chinese se unki zamin bachane ke lia doklam me lad sakte hai to ksi ki zamin kyu lege bhai or ye jo nepal bhai india khilaf bina kuch jaane bijhe zaher ugal rhe hai na ye zaher ek din inhe hu kha jye ga
suraj singh try to understand politics. In the present context, India is alone in South Asia. India wants to be the power house of Aisa like Japan, China and want to the member of Security council but with the same attitude of domination, intimidation. It is next to impossible. In fact India is being alone. Look at Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Nepal. India loses them already.
Venoth Kumaar that’s non of our business. If you want fight, go and fight. But one I want to mention. If you start fight with China, Pakistan would be the one who win.
Venoth Kumaar does it make any difference? Then I ask does India have attitude problem DNA or over smart DNA ?
Love u Nepal from All Indian citizen ❤️❤️❤️
The essence of History can be felt in the lectures by Mahipal Sir.
11 minutes and information of one important treaty in History recieved.
YES SIR...!!!! I M FROM SUGAULI.❤️
Bhai Mai bhi bettiah se hu..
Indian government ko nepal government ke sath beth kar is problem ko hamesha ke liye khatam kar dena chahiye, dono ki dosti aur border par shanti bani rahe. Jai Hind
🇳🇵🚩🇮🇳🇳🇵🚩🇮🇳 Total number of forces in Nepal is 2 lakhs (1lakh army +35000 APF +65000 NEPAL POLICE). In Nepal army 95% are khas pahari. 🇳🇵🚩🇳🇵🚩🇳🇵. Be positive
Khas is bhramin and chhetri people but trend have been changed
Now it's more like gurung and chhetri
1. यदि आर्यों ने भारत पर आक्रमण किया और संस्कृत आर्यों की भाषा थी, तो यूरोप में संस्कृत का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं है?
2. अगर आर्य हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों के लेखक थे और उन्होंने इसका अनुसरण किया, तो इसका मतलब है कि वे हिंदू थे। फिर यूरोप में हिंदू धर्म का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं मिला?
3. अगर आर्यों को घोड़ों और रथों के लिए जाना जाता है, तो घोड़े और रथ 1500BC के बाद भारत में आने चाहिए थे लेकिन महाभारत के युद्ध (हड़प्पा सभ्यता के लगभग समकालीन) में घोड़ों और रथों का प्रयोग हुआ था और पूरे भारत से राजाओं ने भाग लिया था. इसका मतलब है कि पुरे भारत के राजाओं पास घोड़े और रथ थे। यह कैसे संभव हो सकता है?
4.हड़प्पा सभ्यता और आर्यों के बीच में क्या हुआ? हड़प्पावासी ही उत्तर भारत की और पुरे भारत में फैले. हाल ही में जीन एनालिसिस भी हुआ है. लगभग पुरे के लोग जो भारतीय सभ्यता के है, उनके जीन हरप्पा और राखीगढ़ी से मिलता है.
5. अगर आर्यों ने भारतीय लोगों को दक्षिण की ओर जाने के लिए मजबूर किया। फिर प्राचीन काल से ही दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय एक-दूसरे को दुश्मन क्यों नहीं मानते थे?
6.यदि आर्य विदेशी थे तो सभी भारतीय एक ही धर्म और धार्मिक अनुष्ठानों का पालन क्यों करते थे? हिंदू धर्म और हिंदू देवताओं के अलावा कोई और धर्म और देवता जरुर होने चाहिए थे।
7. आर्य 1500 में आये तो भारत के बारे में इतना कैसे लिख दिए?
8. भारतीयों के बहुत कम जीन(Gene ) ही यूरोपियों के समान क्यों हैं? और हड़प्पा सभ्यता के जीन(gene) दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय दोनों के साथ अधिक से अधिक क्यों मेल खाते हैं? आज के दिनों में कई लोग दूसरे देशों के लोगों के साथ शादी करते हैं, यह उस समय भी संभव हो सकता था और इस वजह से, भारतीयों के कुछ प्रतिशत जीन यूरोपीय लोगों के साथ मेल खाते होंगे, इस पर विचार क्यों नहीं हुआ?
9. क्यों अंग्रेजों के AIT से पहले भारतीयों को आर्यों के आक्रमण या पलायन के बारे में कुछ नहीं पता था? क्यों सभी भारतीय सोचते थे कि वे सभी भारत के मूल निवासी हैं?
10. क्या यह "फूट डालो और राज करो" की नीति के तहत नहीं था? क्या हम भारतीय अब तक मूर्ख नहीं बन रहे हैं? क्या भारत की कई मूल जनजातियाँ जैसे द्रविड़ और मुंडा आदि नहीं हैं?
11. वेद कहता है "आर्य" का अर्थ है महान व्यक्ति, क्या यह गलत है?
M kumaun se hu
🚩🚩🚩
Nepal se hmare bhut purane rishte h
K ho yr jatiyeta feri
Its a pride of Nepal, this can be solved with good intentions. The origin of the Mahakali river is Limpiadhura.
I'm from Kumaun region of Uttarakhand and lipulekh pass and Kalapani is ours. We won't let even an inch of our land to be grabbed by Nepal.
Dhoti peoples
Dear Sir,
The content which you accumulate and the way you present and speak is beyond any appreciation. So i love listening to your videos even when i am not a upsc aspirant. Truly inspiring. Thank you.
👍
Exactly same here
.. But triah region was restored to nepal in 1860 by brithisher becoz they helped them to supress the 1857 revolt.
पुर्बमा टिस्टा पुगेथेउ पश्चिम् किल्ला कागडा कुन शक्ति को समुह मा कहिले हामी झुकेथेउ
Ghanta
chal do plate momo laga
@@harismanral2458 chal ek plate panipuri laga
@@harismanral2458 teri momo khane ki waikat nahi hai vhai chal road meh panipuri chatpat cholevhatore laga ...
@@harismanral2458 ghar pe kawaad padaa hai, kab lene aaoge...
You are awesome. I am from Nepal. I have seen several journalists of India talking without research. Thank you so much for being neutral. You have researched well and giving a true massage to Indian friends.
Our claim is simple, Kalapani, and Lipulek are disputed regions. None of Nepal and India can construct a road in such disputed area.
Once again thank you sir.
Very well Explained , Hope everyone is clear about the right things. Thanks Study IQ Education for this video.
Hello everyone...
Please donot spread hate/ blame game...India and Nepal both are close allies and now a days so many forigen powers, NGOs and media houses are trying to cause a drift between us...stay hopeful we can solve our conflicts by talks
Thanks for positivity
1. यदि आर्यों ने भारत पर आक्रमण किया और संस्कृत आर्यों की भाषा थी, तो यूरोप में संस्कृत का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं है?
2. अगर आर्य हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों के लेखक थे और उन्होंने इसका अनुसरण किया, तो इसका मतलब है कि वे हिंदू थे। फिर यूरोप में हिंदू धर्म का कोई प्रमाण क्यों नहीं मिला?
3. अगर आर्यों को घोड़ों और रथों के लिए जाना जाता है, तो घोड़े और रथ 1500BC के बाद भारत में आने चाहिए थे लेकिन महाभारत के युद्ध (हड़प्पा सभ्यता के लगभग समकालीन) में घोड़ों और रथों का प्रयोग हुआ था और पूरे भारत से राजाओं ने भाग लिया था. इसका मतलब है कि पुरे भारत के राजाओं पास घोड़े और रथ थे। यह कैसे संभव हो सकता है?
4.हड़प्पा सभ्यता और आर्यों के बीच में क्या हुआ? हड़प्पावासी ही उत्तर भारत की और पुरे भारत में फैले. हाल ही में जीन एनालिसिस भी हुआ है. लगभग पुरे के लोग जो भारतीय सभ्यता के है, उनके जीन हरप्पा और राखीगढ़ी से मिलता है.
5. अगर आर्यों ने भारतीय लोगों को दक्षिण की ओर जाने के लिए मजबूर किया। फिर प्राचीन काल से ही दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय एक-दूसरे को दुश्मन क्यों नहीं मानते थे?
6.यदि आर्य विदेशी थे तो सभी भारतीय एक ही धर्म और धार्मिक अनुष्ठानों का पालन क्यों करते थे? हिंदू धर्म और हिंदू देवताओं के अलावा कोई और धर्म और देवता जरुर होने चाहिए थे।
7. आर्य 1500 में आये तो भारत के बारे में इतना कैसे लिख दिए?
8. भारतीयों के बहुत कम जीन(Gene ) ही यूरोपियों के समान क्यों हैं? और हड़प्पा सभ्यता के जीन(gene) दक्षिणी और उत्तरी भारतीय दोनों के साथ अधिक से अधिक क्यों मेल खाते हैं? आज के दिनों में कई लोग दूसरे देशों के लोगों के साथ शादी करते हैं, यह उस समय भी संभव हो सकता था और इस वजह से, भारतीयों के कुछ प्रतिशत जीन यूरोपीय लोगों के साथ मेल खाते होंगे, इस पर विचार क्यों नहीं हुआ?
9. क्यों अंग्रेजों के AIT से पहले भारतीयों को आर्यों के आक्रमण या पलायन के बारे में कुछ नहीं पता था? क्यों सभी भारतीय सोचते थे कि वे सभी भारत के मूल निवासी हैं?
10. क्या यह "फूट डालो और राज करो" की नीति के तहत नहीं था? क्या हम भारतीय अब तक मूर्ख नहीं बन रहे हैं? क्या भारत की कई मूल जनजातियाँ जैसे द्रविड़ और मुंडा आदि नहीं हैं?
11. वेद कहता है "आर्य" का अर्थ है महान व्यक्ति, क्या यह गलत है?
@@theprincechandrayan ua-cam.com/video/_X6dRsAZUXM/v-deo.html
@@priyank3530 some scholars also discovered about Indian rulera that ruled on turkey, Iran and Iraq.
Countries do not have friends and enemy.
They have just political interests.
@@priyank3530 it also demolishes Aaryan Invasion/migrations theory.
May be we Indian were the first to rule over the most part of the world.
Before British there was no any theories like Aryan/Invasion migrations theory.
It was only under divide and rule policy.
You can also watch the video about it on Study IQ.
I watch it everyday having lunch in office and Sir gives best deep analysis of such sensitive issues without being partial
Angrez chle gye , lekin angrezi aur problems dono chhod gye
Angreji nahi chhodte toh alag alag bhasha wale log apas me baat kaise karte..
Angreji aaj bhi jivit hai kyunki ye upyogi sabit hui hai, alag alag kshetra ke logo ko apas me communicate kar pane me.
Angrej nhi aate bhai to mujhe bta india kabhi ek desh ban pata ?? Kya rajputana jo khud alag alag rajao m banta hua tha .. vo ek ho pata ??
Jo hona tha vo ho chuka ..
Hmne struggle kiya independence mili ..
Hmne ek naya united bharat bnaya ..
Hm vishv ki 3rf or 4th biggest army h , hm nuclear power h , hm economic power h ..
Hmari problems hme hi solve krni h bhai ..
Hr bar past ko blame nhi kar sakte ..
Past m jo hua vo q hua usse sikh lekar aage badhna h
Kbhi ashok aur maurya empire , yaa gupta empire yaa maratha empire suna h ??
@@amitsingh-sl2zg हाँ । भूरे अँगरेज उसे थामे रक्खा । अब मैकालेको भगाओ । नेपालका हक उसे दे दो ।।
@@नामसंगीति already given.
Thank you Dr Rathore for giving detail and correct information about Anglo - Nepal war. However a small mistake has been made about General Amar Singh Thapa, he didn't get martyrdom rather he died of natural cause. Thank you.
Huge Respect from Nepal for a fair analysis
In and around Muslim and British era India was in many kingdoms it used to be not the case in early periods of Mourya and Ashoka empires and all Nepal was part of Great Mouryan empire, proof of that is Ashoka Pillars in Present day Nepal in Rummindei and Nigliva. Hopefully once again these parts will be united forever and make a strong Hindu state.
In those day (and it still is today), it was totally legitimate for any country to gain territories by military conquest or by other means (such as marriage, inheritance and exchange of territories). A majority of the countries in the world were made this way.
The territories that Nepal lost to East India Company in the 1814-16 Anglo-Nepal War did not belong to Nepal in the first place. They were conquered by Nepal from their local rulers only a few decades earlier. They belonged to us for a short time through conquest and then the British took them from us through conquest. Perfectly legitimate.
So whether the Treaty of Sugauli is still intact or has been dismantled is of no consequence. India has no obligation to return the territories. Those (of my compatriots) who are demanding India to return it to us are either ignorant or do not want to accept the facts. If they want the territories back, then have to conquer them from India. It’s as simple as that. It’s not my fight and I won’t be a party to it.
Nepal compromised some areas in the south, west and the east( Dehradun, Darjeeling, Sikkim etc) and India made some compromises and it was all decided in the trearty of Sugauli.
You are funny, sir. If the only treaty demarcating the borders is not factual enough then you are the ignorant one. It wasn't as if the document was signed in the stone age. According to your logic, India did not belong to India because it was conquered by the Britishers.
The land belonged to Nepal and it is in the written documents and pacts that it still is. India was not a single state either, it has been unified in a long stretch of time. It is equivalent to saying India won't respect Pakistan's boundary because it had the influence of East India Company during the separation. India had rulers which were not Indians and they decided to sign an agreement and you coming out and claiming that the historical facts are not facts enough is plain stupidity.
The fact that you are not ready to respect the treaties of the past says a lot about your character as well.
Best Educational UA-cam channel 🥰🥰🥰
Very clear and neutral analysis by Dr Mahipal!
Love from Nepal 🙏👏❤
What should be the best solution on this situation? Your openion most awaited! ❤
Aab toh Nepal aur Bharat ke dono Government ek sath baith ke baat karna chahiye yehi ek solution hai
@@utsabsingharay4654 Nepal tried many times to talk with India but as usual Modhi denied to have conversation on this topic???
@@educationforyou1248 India Nepal se bhi jyada bada border dispute tha Bangladesh ke sath India ka lekin wo slove hogaya toh ye bhi solve ho jayega, ye toh bohot choti si chiz hai iske liye saalo tak baat karne ki koi jarurat nahi hai ye problem shayad 2,3 baar ma hi slove ho jayega
This is by far the respectful and neutral analysis. Prashant Sir also explains things very good but he favors little more to India. Prashant sir being indian, may be he does that but Rathore sir was spot on. Adding a bit, India claims the Kali Temple being the origin of Kali river which was built way way after the sugauli treaty. The acutal point of origin is the place called Limpiyadhura. Nepal has record of Census being conducted and land tax being collected. We know India is doing this because India sees lipulekh pass as way of transportation and kalapani as strategically important. We have all the evidences but India is there by force which is not a good sign to be friendly. India is loosing its neighbors. Nepal, bangladesh, sri lanka, maldives. No need to mention Pakistan, India sees pak as enemy which is not our concern. India must change its geo political policies. We Nepalese can control such strategically important places. So india must return our part of land without placing its ego on the way.
Your Nepal is running according to Chinese govt. Why you guys don't say something about sagarmatha (Mt. Everest). Some days back China claimed whole chomulungma . Nepal govt didn't say anything. All know China in playing a very cheap political game in Asia. China threatening south east Asian countries as well. You can see the recent news. China always trying to weaken other countries. Pls don't listen to China be a friendly nation as before.
Perfectly explained!! I belong to Uttrakhand Pithoragarh am currently living in Lucknow.
Nepal is part of India in the ancient times
nagaraj GB there was not any country called india in ancient time bro ... British east india company (british ) brought this in 18th century ... ancient time there was bharat barsa (mahabharat ) but this was not one a country there was so many nations from south bharat to northa bharat and they use to fight with each other amd some kingdoms like mauray , ghuta had ruled almost all lands of bharat barsh but whole bharat barsh was never a one country /nation , it was british was who united bharat by invading nations of bharat barsh , nepal was one of many .... india should treat us nice india is already a huge nations now why india has to take nepal small lands when nepal is already very small country ... we both are hindu country we should be good friend .
Amar Shing Thapa comitted suicide as he couldn't accept that sugauli treaty which shed parts of motherland to the expansionist Angrej...
Nah he has different story
@@axel3895what story, share it...may be i will know new things abt him
@@MrHuofeng well he was unhappy due to that treaty but he also had a lot of enemies in darbar because he was almost king of western Nepal. There were numerous conspiracies towards him some even called him british secret agent. All this made him sad and he left army and went to Himalayas where he died
You do realise that those regions were conquered through war just less than 50 years before that. How can you claim conquered land as mother land?
unification was under process but still had to lose those parts in the hands of firangee and went under colonization...After the end of colonial era, they were neither returned to Nepal nor was freed. india, formed by Britshers kept occupying and perhaps people from there, too already accepted their new identity of being occupied by india...
this is the truth
Please provide this study to your media and leaders . This is correct one
Maharaja Ranjeet singh(sikh empire) aslo help to encounter the Gorkha's.form expanding there empire .
Hmm or Kashmir Aaj India ka hota... Ranjit singh ji soft hearted the. Unhone Kashmir ko release kar Diya. Jiske baad me Kya haal hue sab Jante hai..
@@harendersinghbisht9757 right
Kashmir Dogra chutiyon ko bech diya
If Gorkhas Sikhs and Rajputs were United British would never ruled Us
@@bimaladevi327 indeed but sikhs betrayed us (gorkhas) in the end, they joined britished raj instead of helping gorkhas because they were afraid of aggressive gorkha expansion. so we (gorkhas) the only hindu empire in bharatvarsha had to surrender to british. its a humiliating defeat for us.
The 8th point of India -Nepal Peace and friendship treaty signed in 1950 says " ALL THE PAST TREATIES SIGNED BETWEEN NEPAL AND EAST INDIA COMPANY BECOMES INVALID FROM NOW-ONWARD"....Doesn't that means india has to return the lands taken by british back to nepal after british left?? because treaty was signed between nepal and british (royal family).
At present however ;given the strategic location of lipulekh ,india will unlikely give up that point easily. So it would be better if goverment talks out in more peaceful way and find a solution asap before intolerance starts to grow between peoples of two brotherly-nations !!!
It can also mean that India can backdate it's empire to a time when Nepal did not exist(it did not) and make it a part of india ? It is invalid bothways not just one way. We are friendly nations and should work together peacefully to resolve the issue.
Though EIC no longer existed in India that's why the treaty got renamed by keeping the terms same. Book ka cover change kiya syllabus vahi tha
I am from uttarakhand it was a part of gorkha rajvansh. Hamre vaha iss gorkha haar ko bakayada celebrate kiya jata hea. Aur haa hum nepali nahi hea. Kullu aur sikkim mea bhi regional tauhaar manaya jata hea. Jaha tak muhe pata hea. Aur kai log gorkha sasan ko bilkul pasand nahi karte the kyuki vaha pe gorkha raja ne Kumon aur garwaal se ladkiyo ko leke prostitute ki tarah bhi use karte the. To isiliye yea area vapas bhi nahi huva aur haa aaj bhi chidane ke liye tyuhaar mante hea. To sirf tumhare manne se kuch nahi hota.
I was reading history. The rule of Nepalis over Uttarakhand was very brutal and oppressive. Plus Wikipedia pe tho clearly explain kia hai pura scene.... Please check that out....
@@rajnikanthnosurname539 do you even know how international law works according to you Mongolia can claim whole Asia.
Hello Mahipal sir Namaste! I am from Nepal and I am your great fan. I watch all your study IQ videos and I have subscribed your channel because it’s very informative. By seeing this video I would like to thank you for how you interpreted the issues in a real sense. I believe this you have done with your deep research. You are speaking the truth with 100% purity in this matter. Some Indian channels like Republic of Arnab Goswami( most indisciplined & controversial Indian reporter) must learn from an intelligent and disciplined Indian person like you sir. Thank you for telling the truth to the world. But Arnab Goswami is just spreading rumours regarding Nepal India border issues and exaggerating the matter at its height which breaks the relationship bond that has existed between Nepal & India for many years.
i m from nepal and i seriously respect how u explained without annoying anyone nor indian or nepalese,but your media such as ABP whose words were so bitter,that media is such a shame to indian medias,we have a good friendship from years,and it seems these medias want to wage wars with their word rumors etc...hope this will be stopped and our relations will be as same as before one again
Few media in India or in Nepal always point fingers at each other govt. Fact is India and Nepal kingdom has a long and strong bond from thousands of years. Everyone knows China & pakistan are trying very hard to break this strong cultural bond. We educated people should never comment on few selected media or people from India or Nepal. Best is to ignore them because that is the source of conflict.
Thanks bro for saying facts ,Sikkim was independent at once ,annexed by Nepal for 40 years ,again got independence . Nepalese says that Sikkim as their part but it's not .
Dhoti ko xora
THANKS SIR
For the video
From NEPAL
Sir letme clear the fact , i 've had visited the western part of Nepal 4 or 5 years ago. Yes you are right there are many small streams and ultimately they'll mix and we call it Mahakali river . However, there's a river whose water volume is extremely high compared to others and it originates form Limpuadhura. I think this is the main Mahakali river since it's origin is large. (As per definition of River,) . hey there is also a river near kalapani, artificially its path is deviated and its small ,indian army called it Mahakali , i dont know why they called it.
To find the fact , you have to visit that place and find which is the main mahakali river ( we don't call Mahakali to many others small rivers there). Otherwise , you're sitting in the room 9000 miles away , googleling it, printing that googled data , viewing others interview, m sure you'll never find the actual fact. You must visit the area. Thats the only way to find truth.
You are right. Thank you.
Ab gai ra dekhna parla....
right, i support NEPAL. india should go back before its too late.
@@RTL_Coder4u madam . Malai lagxa aba tya sam jana teti sajilo xaina . Sathi vai sag jaam herau nata vane jasto thau vayena hola tyo aile . Maile suneko jo pai tei Nepali haru lae tyo bibad area ma jana dinna re .
ua-cam.com/video/mVu_3X_J2C8/v-deo.html
Must watch greater nepal
Lots of kumaon area are still in nepal...the sudur paschim praant of Nepal is kumaoni and dotiyali dominated.....anyways who care what nepal have or india have... we have to focus on what we have now and make that region develop....
Devloent k naam par tum culture khatam karo bas....
ham karlenge bikas bas hame dedo
चुप माधरच... द
Lots of butthurt nepali here.... I can made offensive comments but i won't...
@SUMIT CHETTRI what are you talking about. Kumau gadwal are and western Nepal are khash people who came from khibarpass when alexgender the grate was expanding his empire. The different between Aryan and Khas people are like Chandra gupt mourya vs alexgender the great. Aryan people have more like dark brown features where as khash are more like white.
Nice lecture sir..lots of love from UTTRAKHAND..😏😍
Nepal government knew that there was a road being built by India. When BRO started working on that road, they should have raised concerns at that time. Also BRO did not built the road, they just developed the road which was previously present there. Why Nepal government did not object back then, if they thought that was Nepal's territory. India spent a huge amount of money on developing that road for pilgrims.
Nepal has regularly been offering for bilateral talks in this matter. India always denied for some reasons..!!
U are again wrong.
The first thing is that, India should concern why India built infrastructure in Nepal Territory.
If built, Then India do encroachment of Nepal land.
U have no any right to do so!!
Yaar mujhe lag rha hai ye nepal ki govt bik gyi hai China ki govt ko...bs or koi baat nhi hai...Nepali Kal bhi humare Bhai the age bhi rhege...Nepal ke sath hum humesha hai
@@tridentmusic4833 @@@@ bhai Saab Aap galat hain. Sayed Aapko pata nahi hain.
Yeh jo road banaye hain aaplog ne woh
Indian PM Narendra Narendra Modi aur chinese PM Li Keqiang ni 2015 mein jake AGREEMENT signed kiya tha Economic Corridor k liye!!
Truth jano, bhai. Khali media sun k bakchodi mat karo.
Yeh Indo sino AGREEMENT hain.
Toh Nepali kaise bik sakte hai bhai.
Sachhai na tumhari media tumhe batati hain na hi tumhari govmnt.
Dushre ka jamin kabja karo!!
Aur swor bhi machaow.
Shame!! Shame!!
Yeh sabhi Indian bhaion ko nahi pata hain.
Yeh jo road banaye hain woh Indo- china Economic Corridor k hissa hain jo Indian PM Narendra Modi and Chinese PM Li Keqiang sign kiya tha 2015.
Jakey PM Modi ko puxa bhai log phir AAP.
Fuckat bakchodi mat karo woh 3rd class Indian media waali.
Now there's no doubt that THE BRAVE GURKHAS are from Nepal! Thank you so much sir!
@Rajendra But the main origin was from the GORKHA district of Nepal
Ghurkha are not only from Nepal,
@Rajendra no any govt decreased the numbers of Gorkhali , those eastern indians are just using the tag
@Rajendra Its due to lack of knowledge
@Rajendra That's why Singapore and british armed forces recruit gorkhas from Nepal , the genuine ones
100 % right talk , some people doing thumb down but history is never dies
The border which India claim is just a small stream of river. And the border that Nepal claim is huge and original Kali river consisting maximum volumes of water originates from himalayas of Limpiyadhura. According to the universal law of river, limpiyadhura is the original Kali river's origin.
Before indo-sino war in 1962, Indian army forcefully come to kalapani and made base camp for the defence against China. Nepal Government also allows this, in agreement with Indian government, for the defence until the war ends. But after the war ends, kalapani seems to be the perfect location for army base camp and business purposes, Indian army do not want to leave that place and claims kalapani as their land.
India, now being large and strong, always try to show the wrong power and dominates the smaller countries.
that is true bro!
एव्हरेस्ट बचालो ......नहीतो इन्कम भी चला जायेगा...
True.No wonder why India doens't have good relationship with her neighbouring countries..there are plenty of such news .. india has always been the one that encroaches the border.
Nepal is not innocent either.they supress Religion in nepal.Majority of Nepali men women children are Hindu religion but nepal remove Hindu country title and add communist.
and when Bharat was fighting Mleccha(muslim&christian country ivasion armies)Nepal attack Bhartiya and capture lands.
first it should be calculated how much Bhartiya land nepal has captured.and all of it should be returned.
@@जितेन्द्रगुप्ता-छ4न First We all Nepali people do not want to have social discrimination in terms of any aspects. Either we are hindu or Muslims or Buddhist, we are all equal. And we want our identity to be as Nepali. I am also belong to Hindu religion but I have great love and respect towards other religions too.
Secondly, we do not attack any bhartia people and capture other land.
Few hours before I was watching 6month old kalapani issue ...and in the mean time i get chance to watch this Sugauli treaty relevance to this topic.. Good analysis detailed in a simple way..
respect sir from nepal 🇳🇵
This was great knowledge who did know the history of Nepal. I request you to talk about the map that was printed and is still present in London, US and other coutries. Please talk about the map that was created till India was independent. That will be a great proof to stop all these India Nepal hatred situation. Also talk why india posted army in kala pani area.
Sir Amar singh thapa didn't die in This war. He was sad with this treaty and left army
He is focused in saving india rather telling truth..
He occasionally misinform because of the bias.
@@Professor314-21 kisi k marne na marne se defend kr lega ye logic clear kroge agr Amar Singh thapa na bhi Marta ya mar jata to usse aj ki ya uss time ki boundary pr ky effect pdta
He is making videos with out proper information and knowledges
@@Professor314-21 Bhai dekh jitna Maine pdha h or jitna Wikipedia ya authentic jitna h usme to yhi likh h ki wo war me ghayal ho kr mare yank ki Killed in Action to mujhe khi se baate glt Ni lgi or agr wo marte ya na marte fr bhi treaty pr koi effect pdta Ni to defend ki baat na kro may be ap logo ki trf koi Kahani ho ki wo war me ni mare but teacher h wo or teacher ussi pr baat krega Jo exam me sahi Mana jyega so student prospect se dekho or search kro tmhe bhi killed in action hi milega or defend jaisi baat na kro kuki aj subh hi Nepal ne kha h ki unhe koi dikkt ni h ISS road se so clear your self
i think you are the first indian becoz no body want to talk about this topic specially indians. thanks for this video and the truth. i respect you and i will. god bless you.
Really good and helpful information i really appreciate for all of your's hard work
I would really love to see English version of these videos some time people who don't understand Hindi want to understand these information as well but they can't
यह विडियाे सुगाैली सन्धि के उपर अपनी तरह का पहला है i think so| thanks sir for this truth. love from nepal.
भारतीय सरकार जिसकाे महाकाली नदी का origin बाेल रही है वह दरअसल एक छाेटी सी मन्दिर बना दिया अाैर नाम काली मन्दिर दे दिया गया । उसीके बगल मे एक छाेटी सी कुन्ड है जहाँ से बहुत थाेडी पानी बह रहा है । अाेैर ईश तरह षड्यन्त्र करके कालापानी नाम देदिया।
जबकि महाकाली का origin लिम्पियाधुरा है जहाँ है विशालकाय महाकाली नदी बहती है। इसका origin खुदका बनाया हुअा कुन्ड नही बल्कि हिमालय है।
The lallantop pr jao 2/3 din purana hai detail me milega
India ke khilaf chinese nafrat thoos lia hai nepal ke logo ne apne dimak me ab ye itni aasani se nhi nikle ga
@@msahai7017 hypocrisy is coming from Nepal ..they hv nothing to say to there Chinese brothers who hv been regularly encroaching their land,interfering in their politics, trapping them in huge debt..
India has been providing Nepalis govt jobs dude since years,India has always stood by Nepal and this is what they are giving.
And even you don't know what's right and what's wrong so I also cannot comment on that
@@msahai7017 or agar kalapani India n Nepal Ko de bhi diya to they will invite Chinese Soldiers over there and that wd be problematic for us..Nepal cannot be trusted now
abhi china ne mt. everest ko apni territory claim kar diya uss par toh yeh nepali kuch nahi boley aur yanha aakar gyan jhad rahey hain bc
only one indian youtube channel i found who give true information about nepal - india.
In 1805, war faught between Maharaja Sansar chand katoch (10000army) of kangra and gurkhas(40000 army) under amar singh thapa....two wars happened in which katoch army won first war and lost 2nd...then Katoch king left to Kangra fort.....gurkha army tried to capture kangra fort for 3 years but failed.....then in 1809 Maharaja Ranjit singh himself came with army and defeated gurkhas.....
are you comedy me ?? 😀😀
Gorkha have 40000 army ??
@@karanvirkatoch4573 no , there are 4000 army ( 1200 female , 300 child )
Not defeated but just stopped.
@@LONEWOLF-ss5dy clear cut defeat.....amar singh thapa with 40000 soldiers and the armies of chamba kehlur and sirmour princely states were defeated by combine sikh and katoch army in 1809 and were pushed back beyond satluj river...
@@karanvirkatoch4573 give me proof.
40000?😞😂
सिमा मे तार लगाना चाहिए । हाम बहुत परेशान है : काठमाडौ से एक युवा
pahle ye decide hona chahiye ki Bharat ka kitna land nepali logon ne kabzaya tha,wo chahe kitne saal pahle hi kyun na kabzaya ho.
@@जितेन्द्रगुप्ता-छ4न then the need would be to talk dinosaur..😂
Don't take it personal brother i also love my motherland I N
@@RviJay047 no 15th century onwards maybe.
First time I watch video info about nepal and its past history in good research and 99% truth by Indian youtuber . All peoples who are in India and don't know about nepal and not research and follow media influences they should watch this video.
The origin of the Mahakali river is Limpiadhura.
All the indian are understanding but why modi didn't understanding.
We support modi ji that land belongs to us and you will never get it
I'm from kumaun and kalapani and lipulekh is ours. Half of our kumaun is already in Nepal, we can't loose any more territory. Nepalese need to know that they are not going to get any Greater Nepal. They should stop claiming territories based on old kingdoms.
Can you give a piece of land to your neighbour. What if your neighbour claimed your land as his land. What the hell is wrong with you. Jitna tum Indian ko kashmir pyara hai kalapani is much more important to nepalies. U better don't dare to comment that its your land. Just go back. Dotnt dare to clame that's your land. If so it wil be risky for nlindian government.
@HIMANSHU SINGH himachal sikim darjeling is our. That's our great nepal. If u speak like this.. All those land were owned by British not India. So India keep quite and watch. U don't have any right to interfair here. Fuck Indian politicians 😒. I hate modi. And kapalbastu was our Is our and will be our. Get that.
So good to see the British not able to conquer Nepal..
british and nepal same thing for Bhartiya. nepal king millitary and british millitary were both killing Bhartiya in 1857.
DR mahipal singh rathore you intentionally forget to mention that 1950 treaty between india and nepal, 1950 treaty article 8 clearly mention that the sugauli treaty is now cancelled and india must return all the lands to nepal including sikkim and all the hill stations you mentioned above and all the land of terai to nepal.
what india , nepaal.we are one.Whole india is for nepaal and whole nepal is for india
Sahi h sabko india chahiye.. pakistan ko, china ko, Bangladesh ko, Nepal ko.. to hum kya karenge bhajan??
Aur ye sahi h phle khud kisi aur ki zameen pe kabza karo fir agar usko wapas pana h to treaty karo aur jab mann kare to treaty cancel karke kabze ke zameen wapas mangne lago...
Q itna lalach h sabko raho shanti se aur rhne do..
If the 1950 treaty makes past treaties invalid and by that logic you ask parts of India, India can backdate it's empire when Nepal did not exist(it did not) and ask it to become a part of India. What say?
@@vandanaverma4474 India ke tarakki dekh ke sabko lalach ho rahi hai. Udhar katora khan, north pe she jin pink- aur abhi nepal vi samil hua hai.
@@bipulsapkota6715 brother mujhe lgta h ki aapko history achhe se padhne ki jarurat hai.. humne kabhi kisi ko lans steal Ni ki... Ki hoti to aaj humari hoti.. plz don't spread hatred.. one day or the other u must realise that what India actually is???
Thank you gaurav sir for clarity
अब इंडियन लोग समझ गये होंगे कि महाकाली नदी पूर्व का जमीन नेपाल का है
गाली नहीं करेंगे नेपाल को
pankaj treaty ke anusaar Kali Nadi ke idhar Ka hissa India Ka hai
Tu apne aap ko indian nhi maanta to yaha kya kar rha he jo indian givt job ke studies ke liye he.
@@vikashpal4875 मैं ने किसी Country को search कर रहा थाyou tube पे तब प्रशांत sir का वीडियो देखा Country of world series ka video तभी से फैन होगया
Study iq का
मैं नेपाली हू bro
@@Sanatani_pankaj1 चुप कर नेपाली हम भारत वालों का दीमाग घुम गया ना तो ऐक दीन में पुरा नेपाल भारत का ऐक राज्य बन जाएगा
@@Sanatani_pankaj1 Nepali people should understand that anyone who attacks nepal equals attacking india. So we are not their enemies. Otherwise china had already annexed nepal into tibbet
Dr. Mahipal Singh Rathore is the best. Your history lectures are amazing sir! Respect from Nepal.
Fair and truth lecture sir....love from Nepal we want our land as per sugauli treaty. And talking about origin of kali river check out political map released by india in 2017,check out the map released in 2007 showing river system in uttarakhand cleary mentioned kali river emerges from limpiyadhura.
@karina patel who and where we claimed your land...
@@amitpadal6089 kalapani...it's currently under our administration...
@@amitpadal6089 we want the govt. To settle the issue but you people are abusing our whole nation... want everything without even debating or talking...
@@sandeeppathak5932 that's what we want to talk with India...kalapani is ours..according to sugauly treaty if it is yours why would we claim it
@karina patel there was no treaty on 1857,please name the treaty and on whuch point kalapani is mentioned .
The government of Nepal has decided today to publish revised map of Nepal including the whole region of Kalapani. The first step of taking back our land.
thanks sir...regular viewer from Nepal
Sir 1950 friendship treaty ko ve explain ke geye
Sup Gorkhali
He did in previous videos
I do not found
@@Vyom108 sir what is the title of 1950 friendship treaty
india ne 1950 Ke treaty me sugauli treaty dismiss kiya tha
yeh vi batawo
Plz sir explain about 1950 s treaty bet nep and indis..
Attention here.. Read whole plz
This treaty is also called as treaty of sangauli.
-this treaty signed between gurkha genral Amar singh thapa and the brithish Major David ochhterloney . Year 2 dec 2015
Under this treaty Gurkhas were allowed to return along with there private property to Nepal and keaving the hilly territory from river kali to satluj under the sovereignty of brithishes.
After,
This treaty is ratified,
And this treaty is signed between EICompany represented Leutanant col Parish BRADSHAW and guru gajraj mishra from side of nepal king.
Date- 4 march 1816
Again, sanguali treaty was superseded in dec 1923 by treaty of perpetual peace and friend ship.
Later, A seperate treaty was signed with India in 1950 which resorted fresh relation between the two independent countries.
Histroy /Reason for war - gurkahs invaede hilly region oh uk and hP.
Gurkha forces barbarberic in natur they looted and killed people of kangra and its impact was that all pople of kangra migrated to plains.
Raja Sansar chand kept himself inside kangra fort for 3 year 1806 to 1809 (after losing in Battle Mahal moria 1806.).becoz its is sorounded by gurlahs for 3 yr.
When himachal ,kangara king Sanasar chand asked help from maharaj Ranjit sing( treaty of jawalamukhi date 1809 after a month negotiation ) , so maharaja ranjit defeated Amar singh thap and pushed the gurkhas to other side of satluj river.
Son now gurkhas start controling today shimal area solan nalagarh etc. And the exploitd every hill riyasat .
- on humanitarian ground - atrocities of gurkahs was absolute barbaric
- so hill riyast asking help form Britisher.
-trade dispute happn in imporrant pass which leato to tibet(tibet because was source for musk and Borox) btwn Brithisher and Amar singh thapa.
-and ,Amar singh thapa gurkha general, claming 6 villages on yhe bases of the fact that these 6 village were part of sirmaur riyasat.
Ans all the local chief of shimala hill riyast states the British to take action.
After this treaty,
-bithis recruited and grokha regiment est at sabathu , hiamchal.
Royal gurkha england
-nepal lost the right to deploy any American and EU employee in its service.
-1/3rd of Neplases territory lost to brither that the king of nepal won in last 25 year. Eg sikkim, kuaman gharwal.
-but traih region was restored to Nepalin 1860.
Becoz nepal help brithisher to supress 1857 revolt.
And last brithis granted SANANDS( conditional independency) to hilly area inky upper satluj area today shimla sirmaour solan,( not kangars mandi) but later chamaba also got sanand.
Some older people in uttrakhand Garwhal also tell us about their atrocities in our Garwhali people ...we called their reign Gurkhani ....They attacked Garwhal in 1791 but got defeated but again in 1803 when garwhal was facing a destruction from earthquake , they attacked and conquered whole region ....
2 Dec 2015?
And Amar singh never signed any treaty. Gurkhas built multiple temples in Kumaon and Garhwal region including gangotri. Amar singh thapa banned rent free grant of land to brahamin. Therefore they made fake stories around him.
@@parthsachdeva7280 yeah and the same garwali king made whole sikh army cannon fodder for there own agenda in front of Britishers
@@parthsachdeva7280 and no need to be glad or proud of your sikh Heritage they constantly raided dehradun and took whatever they found. It was gorkhas who made them go back to there kingdom and dehradun was free of their reign for 12 years. The fact all our kingdom has dark side too which we are often not taught
@@axel3895 read book mian singh govedhan blokhra government approved. .
No need to be sentimental.. And emotional
Agar exam de rhe ho toh.. Fact pakdo.. Local logo ki kha niyha ne..
HPAS exam ka most imp topic hai yeah topic mains mai.
I salute mr rathore sir
From Nepal
plz respect our sovereignty
This matter should be solved in UN or ICJ so both the countries can accept it.
Waah re aaj k chacha Nehru😂
We need all of our land back it is between British and Nepal there is nothing to do with India.. Indian government using our land as colony....
Sir ne kya kaha shayad aapne theek se suna Ni.. british chupchaap Bengal se dekh rhi thi ki nepal kaise expand kar rha h war karke... Treaty me wohi land wapas British ne le li so ideally wo land to India ko hi belong karta h na..
Hume kisi ka land aur property Ni chahiye bas jo humari h wohi bani rhe bht hai... Na hi humne attack karke kisi ki property pe kabza kiya h .. so plz don't complicate this issue... Hum indian Nepalese ke liye itna kuch karte but still hostility milti h.. dekh lenge china aapko kitna apna manta hai???
@Rajendra if we clam we have all the document to get back our land and we will clam soon....
@@vandanaverma4474 India block the boarder at the time when 8.0 earthquake hit Nepal and we didn't forgot that...
@@vandanaverma4474 we have all the document to clam our land back in international court and we are on process...
Thanks Sir for this true analysis. 1857 me Gorakha role bhi tha ,aaj pata chala.
Nepal is a part of India history
because our hindu Kosala kingdom extended across both banks of the Sarayu (modern Ghaghara) River and north into what is now Nepal. According to the Hindu epic the Ramayana, Kosala was ruled by kings descended from the Sun; one of these kings was Rama, whose capital was Ayodhya (Oudh), near modern Faizabad...
Kingdom of Kosala was an ancient Indian kingdom, corresponding roughly in area with the region of Awadh in present-day Uttar Pradesh.
If u think like that then there is no country in this world! But since country exists! Our Country Nepal is unified by King Prithvi Narayan Shah! just like Gandhi unified independent! Your country and my country exists after unification!
Just dont make assumption and support your country only!
It will make more enemies!
You are making patroism on ur country making enemies!
Its better to have mutual understand and negotiation and support what is right! Hope u understand! Respect for both countries!
@@blackknight5769 if Nepal can go back to 1800 of history
Why don't we.
We have our own Hinduism history
We can also claim righteously what is ours...
Thats the point bro! Youre going back to history, we are going back to history! If we keep on going back on time then no country exists!
You are judging from one specific time and I am judging on one specific time!
Ok which history did u read....can u suggest me that history book.
@@vickysunar6416 Are u telling me!
India is soo big country. Why india need nepal's land. If india has necessary then india should lease this area from Nepal. This situation is win win for both counties.
Because indian goverment is selfish.it is imperlistic.
you place is a shithole anyway :D
N u both depend on Indian assistantance!!! From trade to military trainings... Agri products to services...
So dnt b foolish n have open mind to analyse the situation.
@@rashmikapatel7606 in the world there is no any country independent, all are interdependent.
@@rashmikapatel7606 are you want one more country like Islamic Pakistan. or familyhood country like Nepal. Its your chooice
I have many gorkha friends , they are really kind hearted and brave..
Himachal aur Uttarakhand ke log Nepali nahi bolte toh Uttarakhand aur Himachal वैसे bhi Nepal ke Under mei nahi rehte
Is logic se sirf western nepal me orginally nepali bolte hai to?
😂
Nepal is diversed country 🇳🇵❤
The Sugauli Treaty should be repealed. Nepal is the land up to Tista and Kangra
These are invaded lands. Gurkhas were ruthless, cruel and merciless towards the inhabitants of these places. Not to forget, the EIC already took these territories back 200 years ago.
Glad to say that. I am from Sugauli ✌️
You can say that when British left India they gave back all land that belong India to Indians but forgot to give the land that belong to Nepal to Nepalese and Indians are enjoying others property as that of there own and also disputing...
Nepali rule only 20 years over garhwal and kumao aur vo unki ho gyi esa kya janmo janmantar se unka nhi tha uk and hp jaise unhone kabja kiya vaise british ne kabja kiya
@Gaurav Bisht So Kumaon and gadhwal should be separate country from india according to you. You know india is like collection of countries.... Today you lost your culture and became hindi speaking like plain people.....And you are speaking as if people drop from sky to your place? Where did kumauni gadhwali came ?????
20 year kabje me lene se koi state kisi ka nahi ho jata ?? Agar India apne greater india ka land claim karega to kya hoga ?? Wese bhi wo area ek raja ke kabje me tha not of Nepal govt .
@@ashishchhetri5714 those places choose to stay with India its that simple . They could join nepal if they wanted to
@@anksssssssss Greater India kabhi tha hi nahi ...if hai toh dekhao picture
We all Indians🇮🇳(mainly Sanatani🚩) love Nepal🇳🇵 and Nepali peoples ❤️ but hate nepal communist party govt. 😖 Because the Nepal government is a puppet of the Chinese government.
Rahul kaushik we hate Indian government
We love Indians too but hate Indian government
We hate Indian government
@@Somu..9905 tu bhi Kar hamko v ghanta farak Nahi padega
Bhai tum godi midia ki baat sunoge to pkisthan ko bhi nepal kaa bhaai batayega china se jayada bharat se ache riste hai nepal ke bharat ho yaa china dono hamaare padosi desh hai or padosi se riste achee hone chahiye
Nice knowledge and collection.thanks sir.
Kalapani area officially falls in pithoragarh district of kumaon uttrakhand india as per treaty of sugauli,but even if it falls in darchula district of western nepal as claimed by nepal then also this darchula district along with baitadi and doti district was historically part of kumaon kingdom that snatched away from kumaon in sugauli treaty
I am from Sagauli {east champaran, bihar}
best ever explanation on this subject😍😍