Experts slugfest mailbag: More 'Wicked' acting nominations, Sebastian Stan controversy

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 50

  • @mattyrse
    @mattyrse 15 годин тому +9

    "Maybe i should put her back in" after hearing the Q&A Meryl did for Selena is the most Chris thing ever.

    • @chrisjrosen
      @chrisjrosen 13 годин тому +4

      I have somehow resisted the urge to do this so far.

  • @JoshFriedman786
    @JoshFriedman786 9 годин тому +3

    The emailer Ash is off his nut. I don't see any world where A Complete Unknown gets shut out. Not only because Bob Dylan is someone who the Academy has given an Oscar to but also it's the only major biopic in the awards race this year.

  • @myytchanneldinakoha8498
    @myytchanneldinakoha8498 10 годин тому +4

    Campaigning for Seb Stan for that fifth slot!

  • @kristinab3838
    @kristinab3838 12 годин тому +3

    Funny enough, A24 put out their own Actors on Actors with Stan and Colman Domingo about a month ago. And they did talk about him acting as Trump among other things.

  • @mr29
    @mr29 16 годин тому +3

    Eisenberg absolutely deserves a Best Actor Oscar nomination for A Real Pain.

    • @JoshFriedman786
      @JoshFriedman786 7 годин тому

      @@mr29 Oh, he'll definitely get in. He's gonna win the Golden Globe for Best Actor in a comedy and once he gets in at SAG he'll be nominated because it's Searchlight Pictures campaigning.

  • @myytchanneldinakoha8498
    @myytchanneldinakoha8498 8 годин тому +1

    Agree with that BBC critic. The animal talking subplot was not engaging and felt like a different movie. John Campea said he didn’t care for that part. And yeah, the wheelchair sister was expendable in this part 1.

  • @SleepFan771
    @SleepFan771 10 годин тому +1

    Them both picking Adam Brody easily over Adrien Brody is crazy to me.
    Adrien Brody killed it in The Thin Red Line, Summer of Sam, The Pianist, The Village, King Kong, The Darjeeling Limited, Fantastic Mr. Fox, The Grand Budapest Hotel, The French Dispatch, See How They Run, & Asteroid City. I'm sure The Brutalist is amazing too.

    • @chrisjrosen
      @chrisjrosen 9 годин тому +4

      Obviously, and I'll speak for myself here, I think Adrien Brody is a better actor and a real great. But Adam Brody played Seth Cohen, and he is a lifetime pass. But having spoken to both for interviews, I think I'd give the edge to Adrien. Idk! It's tough.

    • @myytchanneldinakoha8498
      @myytchanneldinakoha8498 8 годин тому

      ‘Easily’? Didn’t you hear Chris ref Sophie’s Choice?

    • @SleepFan771
      @SleepFan771 7 годин тому

      @@chrisjrosen Sure thing Chris. Love hearing the talks between you and Joyce.

  • @memorieswithouthomes1438
    @memorieswithouthomes1438 11 годин тому +1

    On Twitter, I quoted a post of the Sebastian Stan interview with the names of several publicists. I think people deserve to know the names of the people who control what they get to see from these performers.

  • @SoulKnightKing
    @SoulKnightKing 13 годин тому +1

    People have to remember, Kidman has never won a SAG. Actors love her and this is the perfect time to award her SAG. Shes respected by BAFTA, she can easily win. Also If Kidman and Brody were smart they woukd do the press tour together and set themselves like a package deal and if they both win itll be a callback to both winning in 2003

  • @haroldandmod
    @haroldandmod 13 годин тому +1

    As another attendant of the Savannah film festival, I actually overheard a lot of people being into The Substance, including industry people

  • @mudstyle5288
    @mudstyle5288 17 годин тому +5

    Gladiator 2 - Sharknado

    • @ktom5262
      @ktom5262 16 годин тому +4

      Sharknado is better. At least it doesn't pretend it's serious cinema.

  • @SnowyTaco
    @SnowyTaco 5 годин тому

    I just love these. Thank you!

  • @JoshFriedman786
    @JoshFriedman786 12 годин тому +1

    Shame on other actors for not wanting to talk with Sebastian Stan on Actors on Actors just because the film is about Trump. It's about the performance not the politics. 👎

  • @timgriffin3368
    @timgriffin3368 4 години тому

    Honestly, I feel the same, not the same.
    A Real Pain is The Holdovers this year.
    Get it?

  • @ktom5262
    @ktom5262 15 годин тому +2

    I don't understand why they like Gladiator II, it's very disappointing. The script is idiotic and simplistic, seems written for an undemanding and unsophisticated audience. Maybe Ridley and the screenwriter Scarpa think so lowly of viewers' intelligence that they think the ridiculous stuff like - for example - a citizen reading a newspaper in a café in Rome circa 200 AD, is acceptable. The movie doesn't even look great, it looks like a film made for TV.

  • @timgriffin3368
    @timgriffin3368 14 годин тому +1

    I would love a fight to tie finish with Ariana and Zoe duking it out with someone unexpected (Michael Clayton days) squeaking through at the Oscar's.
    Danielle? Isabella?
    That would be 😁

  • @KaiOpaka
    @KaiOpaka 15 годин тому +1

    Adam Brody. Best Gilmore Girls boyfriend and better human being. Keep your hands off any actress on stage when you come up to accept an award, Adrien Brody (and don't work with a guy with multiple rape allegations, not just the one people know about). Halle Berry confirmed later she was not happy about it. So if a guy slaps someone, they get banned from the Oscars, and if someone forcibly kisses an actress, they just get laughs and cheers? She couldn't slap him for it or act upset on stage because she would have gotten roudly criticized.

  • @aaronvillagomez3548
    @aaronvillagomez3548 9 годин тому

    i’ve had harris dickinson and Nicole Kidman in since August

  • @friendlypup5650
    @friendlypup5650 Годину тому

    Am I the only person who liked the Emilia Perez doctor song?

  • @taterbug1234
    @taterbug1234 15 годин тому +2

    I finally saw Wicked. Ariana is amazing, but I’m curious why Cynthia isn’t more in the conversation. It was her numbers that touched me more. Defying Gravity was astonishing to me. I cried… like ugly cried. I know she’s moving up, but she should be a lock, in my opinion.

    • @mr29
      @mr29 15 годин тому +2

      Her category is just sooo competitive - legitimately there are 12 candidates for only 5 slots. I still think she'll get in though.

    • @suesommerton
      @suesommerton 15 годин тому +1

      good God, it is a kidds movie.

    • @taterbug1234
      @taterbug1234 14 годин тому

      @@mr29 yeah, that would be the reason she doesn't get in, but her work just spoke to me. If not this year, hopefully next year.😃

    • @taterbug1234
      @taterbug1234 14 годин тому

      @@suesommerton really, have you seen it? It's all about the subtext. With the toxic political and social challenges we are facing, you should understand why this IP is so relevant. If you don't ... I can't help ya.

  • @oldschoolabrahamhicks2742
    @oldschoolabrahamhicks2742 18 годин тому +2

    YAY

  • @LeeBeeDeeTree51
    @LeeBeeDeeTree51 11 годин тому

    On the one hand, you say it's silly for people to be afraid to discuss a movie because it is about a controversial figure like Donald Trump because it is after all, JUST a movie, yet your platform elevates the importance of movies as an art form.

  • @Cafe-yz4fm
    @Cafe-yz4fm 15 годин тому +3

    Wicked is a baby movie, yes it is a baby movie. it doesn't matter how much it makes it will get 6 nominations at best. Win for best costume and productions design. Please talk about the serious contenders.

  • @janekent190
    @janekent190 15 годин тому +7

    Goldderby and UA-cam are infested by Grande and Gomez stans and just because we love The Substance and Demi and we are being vocal about it, are we bots now?? Come on Chris. You don't have a single episode without mentioning The Substance ( negatively) so I am here to hear what you say.

    • @chrisjrosen
      @chrisjrosen 13 годин тому +3

      We literally talked about how we don't hate this movie, and I actually like it -- I gave it 3.5/5 on Letterboxd and have it in my top 25 of the year, and I'd much prefer it to Nickel Boys, A Room Next Door, The Outrun, and a host of other "beloved" movies. I also don't think it's the best movie, and I question it's viability as a real Oscars contender -- though I think it may get in for three or four nominations. I'm sorry you think this is talking negatively about it.

    • @myytchanneldinakoha8498
      @myytchanneldinakoha8498 8 годин тому +1

      Bot.

  • @backto-il9ne
    @backto-il9ne 16 годин тому +3

    Forcing actors to talk about a polarizing toxic figure like Trump is actually gross. This is no laughing matter. A celebrity engaging with Trump in any form is a magnate for toxic culture wars. Actors have the right not to want to deal with that in such a sensitive polarizing moment.

    • @nicholasmorre7371
      @nicholasmorre7371 13 годин тому

      no one is forcing anyone to do anything. and actors talk about Trump all the time. i just saw a clip today of Josh Brolin talking about Trump. i'm sure plenty would be happy to do it, it's just neurotic reps gatekeeping like Chris and Joyce said.

    • @backto-il9ne
      @backto-il9ne 12 годин тому

      @@nicholasmorre7371 Um, these guys are laughing about leaking the names of actors who refused to talk about Trump. How is that not coercion ??? Also, Brolin can talk about Trump unscatched because he is a white male with a traditional sensibility that is not offensive to Trump's base. Many actors do not have that privilege. Trump's goons like Elon Musk have already used their platforms like X to demonize actors who are willing to engage with Trump in a balanced and objective manner. Imagine the hate and toxicity actors will get if they dared to talk about Trump in a fair and honest manner. Not everyone wants to deal with that kind of vitriol and hate right now and they should not be accused by these critics who "not caring about the art" and "being fake" simply because they want to protect their piece of mind. What a self-rightenous and nasty thing to say.

    • @LeeBeeDeeTree51
      @LeeBeeDeeTree51 11 годин тому

      I agree that in this day and age of endless culture wars, one way you can guarantee that someone will come after you is to discuss Donald Trump either positively or negatively. Some folks may truly not want the drama.

  • @robertsaner8766
    @robertsaner8766 18 годин тому +5

    bruh the wicked heads are drinking the kool-aid. Like its going to do well as the specific niche of the lighter toned middle-brow blockbuster hadn't been filled. This type of film does not, on nomination morning, have a high likelihood of overperforming.

    • @robertsaner8766
      @robertsaner8766 18 годин тому +3

      it will likely miss director, screenplay, cinematography with a chance of missing makeup and vfx

    • @ktom5262
      @ktom5262 16 годин тому

      Hmm, I'm not sure. If it reaches a billion dollars at the box office it may defeat The Brutalist, Anora and Dune 2 at the Oscars.

    • @KaiOpaka
      @KaiOpaka 16 годин тому

      Keep anti-dicting. Only helps predictors who know what's going on.
      PS, it's not kool-aid. It's Wicked hater tears. They alternate between green and pink because the Wicked marketing team is just that good.

    • @robertsaner8766
      @robertsaner8766 16 годин тому +1

      @ktom5262 plenty of movies have made a billion at the box office before got nominated for BP and then didn't win - avatar 2, black panther, top gun maverick, barbie, joker, etc.

    • @nafischowdhury7375
      @nafischowdhury7375 16 годин тому +2

      @@ktom5262 barbie literally grossed 1.5 billion dollars and it won only one oscar and that was also in a below the line category.