@thegangatutorial Do you really think patients, especially in government hospital knows English,..and other staffs like nurses,they barely knows to talk English,..and you're going to be pg1 and most of the cases you're going to do alone,..
Nothing to be done.. learn the language that's it.. I am in Assam for last 4-5months I can understand maybe if I stay over a year I will be able to speak a bit.. pg requires local dialect learning.. bit unfortunate but reality
Unfortunately not, state quota for people who did ug from that state is still applicable.. Which fmgs don't hv, they had only domicile based quota applicable in 3-4 states... Which also now is gone.. So it's a loss
I think it is good because now there will be huge positive shift next year bcoz all seats comes under a common pool.... But is there any chance of scrapping service bonds in future ??
@@thegangatutorialHello sir i passed class 12th from cbse in PCM in 2021 and single subject additional biology from NIOS board in 2024 , am i eligible for Neet and Mbbs , will i face problem regarding eligibility, please reply sir
Hello sir i passed class 12th from cbse in PCM in 2021 and single subject additional biology from NIOS board in 2024 , am i eligible for Neet and Mbbs , will i face problem regarding eligibility, please reply sir
Sir please clarify. I’m from West Bengal. There is 50 percent state quota in NEET PG. there are 2 criteria for availing the state quota: 1) being resident of WB 2) studying mbbs in college under WB Health University. So which one will be cancelled? If only criteria 1) is cancelled then students studying in AIIMS and Central universities will get nothing.
@@thegangatutorial Don’t misinterpret supreme court judgement!!! Understand the whole matter in the following points. 1. The State Quota is not equivalent to domicile-based quota. 2. State Quota: It is generally includes students who have completed their MBBS in the respective state. However, some states also include candidates who graduated from other states but are domiciled in the concerned state. 3. Certain states attempted to reserve seats as domiciled quota within the State Quota based on domicile of candidates. 4. The Supreme Court has struck down the domicile-based reservation within the State Quota but has not invalidated the entire State Quota itself.
Actually , caste based quota should be scrapped . As they are already a doctor and they are not longer backward . Need more quality as it is a specialty
@thegangatutorial I'm from Andhra Pradesh and I'm in state obc list but not in all india obc list . So I will be considered as obc in all india counseling???
State counseling will likely still proceed, but with a major change. The state quota seats will no longer be filled based on domicile-based reservations. Instead, the allocation will be based solely on merit, using NEET-PG scores. Each state may conduct counseling, but the pool of candidates eligible for state quota seats will include all NEET-PG qualifiers, not just those from the respective state. This means that while states may still conduct counseling, the seats will be filled purely on merit without considering the candidate’s state of origin. So, while state counseling will not be “canceled,” it will undergo a transformation in terms of eligibility and seat allocation criteria.
@@thegangatutorial North Indian Colleges have high stipend and lesser workload compared to south india. But colleges are less in North india. So if state domicile is nullified then the north indian mid rankers have to settle in states which they are not comfortable of mostly in surgical branches.
@DrAmanKumarRoy every student will have chance to study anywhere for pg course....settle or nit settle ot would be their wish....I think it's good for all
Don’t misinterpret supreme court judgement!!! Understand the whole matter in the following points. 1. The State Quota is not equivalent to domicile-based quota. 2. State Quota: It is generally includes students who have completed their MBBS in the respective state. However, some states also include candidates who graduated from other states but are domiciled in the concerned state. 3. Certain states attempted to reserve seats as domiciled quota within the State Quota based on domicile of candidates. 4. The Supreme Court has struck down the domicile-based reservation within the State Quota but has not invalidated the entire State Quota itself.
Yeah but if the domicile category has been removed , students from all over India can still compete in state counselling of various states so it’s almost like all India counselling but have to apply in individual states , anyway it’s good news for all candidates and it won’t affect service category also bcs according to the court we can compete in state counselling of diff states but we can’t compete in service seats as it is blocked even for domicile ppl ,
@@drbharath8151 yeah sir that’s true but still everyone can compete in that state 50% seats , only thing is we need to apply separately in each state counselling , For example like in my state state qota and domicile qota can compete for state 50% seats Not for other domicile Now other domicile also can compete for that 50% seats
Right for equality hi karna hai toh har reservation hatana chahiye tha na
Usse pehle caste discrimination ghochu
What about illogical, baseless institutional quota??
Like!???
@@AnandMishra-th9ss like management quota
What about language issues with patients,i saw many students now struggling in tamilnadu and kerala without knowing tamil,..and vice versa,..so how
Other staff in hospital can help....or use English...
@thegangatutorial Do you really think patients, especially in government hospital knows English,..and other staffs like nurses,they barely knows to talk English,..and you're going to be pg1 and most of the cases you're going to do alone,..
Nothing to be done.. learn the language that's it.. I am in Assam for last 4-5months I can understand maybe if I stay over a year I will be able to speak a bit.. pg requires local dialect learning.. bit unfortunate but reality
Stipen should be same all over India
Ok Done
@@Medishine01😂
❤❤❤
@@Medishine01😂
Why sc is unnecessaryly involve in state quota kabi NRC kabi demonetisation, foolish government
So finally foreign graduate are in benifit.
Kindly make it clear.
I think so
Unfortunately not, state quota for people who did ug from that state is still applicable.. Which fmgs don't hv, they had only domicile based quota applicable in 3-4 states... Which also now is gone.. So it's a loss
It's a loss
Great sir you are Gem,
This shud be applicable to be UG also. Article 14 is not applicable here??
@@donkey3251 exception for state autonomy
What about cast reservation 🤔🤔
In J&K ,there are RBA &ALC Category which are residence based ?
Are that scrapped in NEETPG
Sir???
@@Tufail123-z1m yes....all quota where domicile is mandatory...now j and k is integral part of india like other states....
Very nice information👍👍
I think it is good because now there will be huge positive shift next year bcoz all seats comes under a common pool....
But is there any chance of scrapping service bonds in future ??
Yes service bond is also harassment for students....may be it diluted gradually
Merit based admission includes Caste based reservation. Wow! Aagey badh raha hai India 😂
But with whose tax money did south Indians created medical colleges here? Did other states contributed towards this? I dont agree with this decision.
Please make a video on pros and cons of this
@@gargithakur8217 ok sure....
@@thegangatutorialHello sir i passed class 12th from cbse in PCM in 2021 and single subject additional biology from NIOS board in 2024 , am i eligible for Neet and Mbbs , will i face problem regarding eligibility, please reply sir
Hello sir i passed class 12th from cbse in PCM in 2021 and single subject additional biology from NIOS board in 2024 , am i eligible for Neet and Mbbs , will i face problem regarding eligibility, please reply sir
No problem
*So stipend will be same all over india* ?
@NishkamKarm07 stipend is decided by state govt or institute itself....it's equal all over India for dnb
Will inservice quotas be used in all india counselling too?
Then why not in neet ug??????!!
PIL file krdo
Paise khilana padega
So INI exams university quota also scrapped????????
@NishkamKarm07 only domicile based...
Institutional quota or minority quota not covered under this judgement
Yes sir I agree with your
Sir please clarify. I’m from West Bengal. There is 50 percent state quota in NEET PG. there are 2 criteria for availing the state quota: 1) being resident of WB 2) studying mbbs in college under WB Health University. So which one will be cancelled? If only criteria 1) is cancelled then students studying in AIIMS and Central universities will get nothing.
@AnuragSamanta one is institutional quota and one is sate quota....State Quota and domicile based institutional quota Scrapped for sure....
@@thegangatutorial
Don’t misinterpret supreme court judgement!!!
Understand the whole matter in the following points.
1. The State Quota is not equivalent to domicile-based quota.
2. State Quota: It is generally includes students who have completed their MBBS in the respective state. However, some states also include candidates who graduated from other states but are domiciled in the concerned state.
3. Certain states attempted to reserve seats as domiciled quota within the State Quota based on domicile of candidates.
4. The Supreme Court has struck down the domicile-based reservation within the State Quota but has not invalidated the entire State Quota itself.
Effect on fmge ? Please explain ?
@mercifulservant172 beneficial.....State Quota also demand graduation from that state in some cases....which fmge could not full fill....
Can anybody explain what has been scrapped
State Quota in neet pg exam scrapped
@thegangatutorial so no state counselling anymore ?
Sir , will the IP quota of AIIMS also scrap off ?
@StethoboyBably may be next number of these Quotas also...but now it's for domicile based only..😃😃
@thegangatutorial Ok sir , Thanks 🙏
Please make a video on pros and cons for in service candidates
If this happens ultimately,there may not be any service quota anymore for which many people from WB is doing Govt job.
In service quota is different thing...
I’m pursuing MBBS from AIIMS Kalyani. WBUHS students will get state quota and AIIMS students will get no state quota?
@AnuragSamanta this will not apply from 2025
No preference to state domicile
@@thegangatutorialthe UG students doing mbbs under state university. Will they get state quota?
Bhai AIIMS m padte ho toh uska internal quota toh tumhe milega ...aur tumhe state quota kui chahiye 😢😢
What about ipu university quota (Delhi)??
Actually , caste based quota should be scrapped . As they are already a doctor and they are not longer backward . Need more quality as it is a specialty
It's not possible in india....
Courts cannot comment on that,. Becoz they know wat will happen next 😂😂😂
Sir bhms main kya hain
Is this appiled to neet mds too?
Yes
Bhot achha decision hai Hounrable supreme court dwara
Sir jo Rajasthan state mein mbc category ko 5% milta thaa ? Vo bhi gyaa ??
@@vyayamvale376 not caste based.....
So sir there will be no state counselling??
Yes...from 2025
@thegangatutorial I'm from Andhra Pradesh and I'm in state obc list but not in all india obc list . So I will be considered as obc in all india counseling???
State counseling will likely still proceed, but with a major change. The state quota seats will no longer be filled based on domicile-based reservations. Instead, the allocation will be based solely on merit, using NEET-PG scores.
Each state may conduct counseling, but the pool of candidates eligible for state quota seats will include all NEET-PG qualifiers, not just those from the respective state. This means that while states may still conduct counseling, the seats will be filled purely on merit without considering the candidate’s state of origin.
So, while state counseling will not be “canceled,” it will undergo a transformation in terms of eligibility and seat allocation criteria.
@@sayedahmedsayeed-1198
In Karnataka For OBC quota
All people from india can compete!?
@@sayedahmedsayeed-1198 u are wrong
In Karnataka We Have Hyderabad Karnataka Quota within State quota
Will that be removed?
Yes...all domicile based quotas...
@thegangatutorial
So no state counselling?!
@Raging-j9j from 2025...
@@thegangatutorial i think you are wrong
No state will accept this
Nowhere supreme court has mentioned
There will be no state counselling
@@thegangatutorial you are wrong sir
Supreme court has not mentioned cancelling of state quota
Stipend will be equal in country
How private college seats wil be filled?
Domicile not required for open state private colleges seats as of now also....
Sir ipu university quota remains or scrapped
Remains...
Is it same as state quota ?
State Quota Scrapped where domicile is need...
Md medicine in rgkar is good??plzz do reply sir
I am mbbs student at rg kar . It is a very good college with very good patient load,only problem you will face is language if you dont know bangla
Those working in state government will they get 10,20,30 percent or not ?
@dushyantyadav2433 they will get it....it's in service quota
@@thegangatutorialthanks a lot for clarification
What about in service quota ??
@@satyawansingh85 next turn may be of it...😄😄
Sir bhms pllz batao
Ye to fmge ke sath atyachar hai....unko reservation khise nhi milta..😢😢
Plz dnt rely on reservations
Round 3 ki joining aage bhad jaye yaar plz god
Join ASAP...or fucus on state R3
Neet ug ki value toh zero ho gyi
No...it has good values
Bhms ke bad md karna hain us me lagu hoga
Ignore bhms....go for paramedical course like nursing, pharmacy etc
@thegangatutorial okk sir bhms private clg se karke govt se md kar sakta hu kya
@VSBiswa yes....
So there will be 100 prcnt AIQ now ???is it?
@@lazymedic5988 yes
@thegangatutorial what about central categories like obc ,st.. are they still valid ...
Yes not caste based reservation @@lazymedic5988
@lazymedic5988 caste based will be present....
What about inservice quotas?
Mtlb in-service quota gya😂
What about in-service quota
It will remain
So is this a good news or bad news for mid rankers???
@@DrAmanKumarRoy it's good for all....
@@naturebliss9997 exactly.
@panveenarayan464 it will provide equal opportunity to all.....
@@thegangatutorial North Indian Colleges have high stipend and lesser workload compared to south india. But colleges are less in North india. So if state domicile is nullified then the north indian mid rankers have to settle in states which they are not comfortable of mostly in surgical branches.
@DrAmanKumarRoy every student will have chance to study anywhere for pg course....settle or nit settle ot would be their wish....I think it's good for all
Sir Dr DNB ki kitne seats hain branch wise
@@drfaujdar953 plz check nbems site...click on accredarion then search....
Very good news
Don’t misinterpret supreme court judgement!!!
Understand the whole matter in the following points.
1. The State Quota is not equivalent to domicile-based quota.
2. State Quota: It is generally includes students who have completed their MBBS in the respective state. However, some states also include candidates who graduated from other states but are domiciled in the concerned state.
3. Certain states attempted to reserve seats as domiciled quota within the State Quota based on domicile of candidates.
4. The Supreme Court has struck down the domicile-based reservation within the State Quota but has not invalidated the entire State Quota itself.
Yeah but if the domicile category has been removed , students from all over India can still compete in state counselling of various states so it’s almost like all India counselling but have to apply in individual states , anyway it’s good news for all candidates and it won’t affect service category also bcs according to the court we can compete in state counselling of diff states but we can’t compete in service seats as it is blocked even for domicile ppl ,
@@trendingtoday7004 but state quota 50 % seats remains unchanged aiq 50 % only
@@drbharath8151 yeah sir that’s true but still everyone can compete in that state 50% seats , only thing is we need to apply separately in each state counselling ,
For example
like in my state state qota and domicile qota can compete for state 50% seats
Not for other domicile
Now other domicile also can compete for that 50% seats
@@drbharath8151students of AIIMS and central universities will be very much affected.they will get nothing reservation anywhere
@@trendingtoday7004 domicile quota students are very less it has negligible impact
Very good news..
Is it for neet mds also??
For all pg medical courses...
@thegangatutorial but technically it's dental courses , so what should I consider? Is it applicable here also?