Reflecting on Pakistan's Regime Change and Military Involvement | Moeed Pirzada
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 чер 2024
- Reflecting on Pakistan's Regime Change and Military Involvement
I regret deeply that officers of the Pakistan Army and Intelligence, despite their extensive training at the National Defense Ministry and the Staff College, couldn't understand what General Bajwa was doing. Dr. Shahbaz Gill, in his UA-cam vlog, highlighted how Moeed Pirzada had been analyzing for over a year that Khan's government was subjected to a regime change operation orchestrated by General Bajwa in collaboration with Sharif and Zardari.
Pirzada openly discussed his realization starting from March 3, 2022, noting how various missions and the past months' events indicated efforts to change Pakistan's government. Despite high-quality access within Pakistan and international missions, his warnings went largely unheeded.
He expressed frustration that even those in Pakistan's establishment and intelligence agencies, despite their capabilities, couldn't grasp the implications of General Bajwa's actions. Pirzada believes that General Bajwa's compromise with international forces, including India, was aimed at shifting Pakistan's domestic politics.
Despite trying to convey his message through his blog, many people did not understand the full extent of the regime change operation until late 2023. The crackdown on political workers, media regulation, and the international community's muted response to human rights violations highlighted the deeper strategic dynamics at play.
Pirzada laments that even today, only a small minority comprehends the full scope of the political changes in Pakistan, driven by South Asian dynamics and external strategic paradigms. He acknowledges his failure to reach a broader audience and emphasizes the importance of understanding international relations and strategic balance to fully grasp these complex issues.
جزاك الله.ملک کی اکثریت جھلأپرمشتمل ھے،جنہیں روٹی کےچکرمیں شاطر اور چالاک ہینڈلرزنےپھنسارکھاھے۔لاچاروبےبس عوام سمجھ ھی نہیں پاتےکہ انکےساتھ ھوکیارہاھے😢
So sad that people like you are living in abroad due to our corrupt Mafia led by Military. One day Insha Allah you’ll be among us. Keep it up with your good work.
ھر کام میں اللّٰہ پاک کی مصلحت ھوتی ھے اگر یہ سب کچھ نہیں ھوتا تو پچھتر سال کا گند کیسے سامنے آتا
ڈاکٹر صاحب
آپ کے وی لاگ کا addict ہوگیا ہوں
جماعت اسلامی کا کل وقتی کارکن ہوں ہر وقت کسی نہ کسی مصروفیت میں رہتا ہوں ابھی بھی چرم قربانی کی مہم کے لئے پلاننگ کر رہا ہوں لیکن جیسے ہی نوٹیفیکیشن آتا ہے سب چھوڑ کر پہلے سنتا ہوں
میں ایک بار پھر درخواست کرونگا کہ آپ اپنے وی لاگ میں کچھ وقت غزہ فلسطین کی موجودہ صورتحال سے آگاہ کیا کریں تاکہ ان مظلوموں کی کچھ داد رسی ہوسکے امید ہے غور فرمائیں گے جزاک اللہ مشیر السلام
میں نے بھی ساری عمر جھک ماری ہے جماعت میں، اب 70 سال کے قریب ہو، امیر بننے سے پہلے جماعت کا لیڈر کھل کے بولتا ہے اسٹیبلشمینٹ کے خلاف، امیر بنتے ہے، منصورہ میں پرانے فوج کے پٹھو اسکو اسٹیبلشمینٹ کے خلاف لاءین نہیں لینے دیتے، منور حسن صاحب مرحوم نے جب کہا، کہ ایک جہاد فی سبیل اللہ کے مجاہد کا مرتبہ تنخواہ لے کر لڑنے والے سے بلند ہے، سبکو آگ لگی، حالانکہ بات درست تھی، مگر جماعت کے باہر اور اندر سے پریشر بڑا اور اگلے امیر کے الیکشن میں منور صاحب کو ان فوج کے پٹھوءوں نے ہروادیا، حافظ نعیم تو بڑے سخت ناقد تھے فوج کے سیاسی کردار کے، انہوں نے اپنی صوباءی اسمبلی کی سیٹ بھی واپس کی ، کہ یہاں پی ٹی اءی جیتی ہے اور ہر حلقے میں جماعت کے ہارے ہوءے اُمیدواروں نے اپنے فارم 45 پیش کءے، لیکن ابھی اسلام آباد کی تین سیٹوں کا کیس آخری مراحل میں تھا تو پی ٹی اءی، مصطفی نواز اور ٹی ایل پی نے اپنے فارم 45 دکھاءے، جب جماعت والے امیدوار سے کہا، آپ بھی دکھاءو تو اسنے کہا، یہ پی ٹی اءی اور حکومت کا معاملہ ہے ، ہمارا کیا تعلق، اسی طرح جب پی ٹی اءی سمیت ساری پارثیاں منصورہ اءین تو حافظ نعیم نے بڑی اچھی تقریر کی اور تعاون پر آمادگی ظاہر کی اور کہا ، ہم مجلس عاملہ کے اجلاس میں فیصلہ کریں گے، اجلاس ہوا، وہاں وہی پرانے پٹھو بیٹھے ہیں ، فیصلہ حکومت کے خلاف احتجاج کے خلاف ہوا، یہ ہے جماعت کی متضاد پالیسیاں، پھر کہتے ہیں ، ہمیں ووٹ نہیں ملتے، نہیں ملیں گے، صرف کھالیں ملیں گی
Best analysis by moeed peerzada we proud of you
عید مبارک معید پیرزادہ صاحب ❤
Excellent Analysis DR MOEED PIRZADA Sahab
Sach Bolna JAHAD hae ,keep it up thank you,Dr Moeed
Allah bless and protect you brother Moeed Perzada Allah bless and protect PM imran Khan Allah bless Pakistan 🇵🇰 love from Canada 🇨🇦
A very happy, safe, secure and joyful Eid Ul Adha to you and your family members all around the world.
خواہش کےبندےاونچی جگہ بیٹھےہیں اورذہنی غلام ملازم مانندسگان ہرحکم بجالاتےہیں!
Well done moeed
پاکستانی میڈیا بک چکا ہے شکریہ کہ آپ کی وجہ سے معلومات مل رہی ہیں ۔🫡
With all due respect… you never failed to explain this fact.. I think this fact was well understood when Imran khan himself said it out loud that gen. Bajwa took orders from America.. this is the whole concept of Cypher.. no one could avoid this!! Only if these generals/establishment/DGs could agree on one point with each other … only way to keep Pakistan strong is unity!! Imran khan was only used as a tool!!
The point that I strongly agree with you on is why did they not understand that outside forces want to disunite us? This was a such an evident fact!! I Guess their egos are more important.
Eid Mubarak Sir G ❤❤❤❤❤
Only love Imran Khan 💯❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Very intriguing point raised by Dr Moeed. Does the silence of Univ graduates not reflect inadequacy of training, Or critical silence of the premier learning seat, Or is this a fixed match ?
Always love listening you
A honest person you are
Allah Allah 🤲
Part-2: by now the Chinese have realized that Pakistan's cold shouldered attitude to China will continue for some time to come. Therefore, Chinese have made alternative routes via Wakhan Belt to reach Chabahar in Iran. They have so far done substantial work on highways or at least they have crossed Wakhan Belt and very actively working in Afghanistan to reach their destination pending Cpec atleast for the time being. Very sad situation for Pakistan and this depicts the short-sightedness of 12-grade passed military elite.....of there is a conflict of interest of this elite. 😢 i do not know whether you like it or not but Haider Mehdi sahib had explained and elaborated on oath and in quite detail that Bajwa and few top generals, of course, including the current chief, had sold Pakistan to USA and we all know the US desire to ultimatly surrender our nuclear and strategic assets. And in this context, i have listened and read the book ' No Exist from Pakistan'. We have have seen how the US has been buying, pliticians, military and civil administration, student leaders and media persons and channels in Pakistan eversince Pakistan came in to being.😢😢
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Eid ul Azha Mubarak! I have been listening to you since you were in Pakistan. Strategic affairs has been my favourite subject, albeit, i did my masters in commerce & economics. Yes, i have been analysing the regime change in the broader context of south asian regional politics esp. quard policy of USA 2019 encircling the China or you can quite specifically say containment of China. We understand all these policy paradox of USA. But my question is will this policy of 2019 continue even if Trump comes back to presidency. There are two dimensions: one is the China contaiment policy which will be continued one way or the other but will the new administration of USA continue the "muted policy" towards Pakistan because if there is a shift in US policy towards Pakistan, there is going to be a shift in policy of Choudhry Nizamdin towards domestic policy especially against IK and PTI.
Long live Mr . Ik
السلام وعلیکم
I have not heard more powerful and potent fact defining although I don't read international affairs but I always say it is not these rotten souls who can do this it is Israel US UAE ,India and many more
Dr.Sahab everybody understood whats happening however intelligent they were. our ruling class personal interests always fulfilled by West so its Bajwa or anybody else it supposed to happens this way, this is a 70 years system that is challenged now.
Thx for a short video
Good clip, you have started this new you tube thing
Nhi sir ap fail nhi howe. Imran khan or us ki team he nalique ( boZdari) team thi. Jo waqat py faslay nhi krty waqat un KO ronta howa nakil jata hai. Aik dam teek horah hai khan ky sath............
Was the top military brass with Bajwa on what he was doing on behest of foreign powers?
Why Bajwa could not secure more extension if he was the broker of all this? Does that mean the new military establishment put in place got aligned to Bajwa's surrender?
Agli mazboot hokumat ate hi foj ke muamilat ko apne control men len. Foj ka ya security idaron ka koi bi officer kisi bhi foreign tour par na jaaye aur na hi kisi foreign diplomat se mele, agar chupke se milay to courtmartial kia jaye. Aur bhi senkron precautions lene honge (see Erdogan). ....
They were / are part of it
Mera khayyal hai isi v log ki wajh se aap aaj off air ho boss😢
Wisdom does not come with degrees.
Discipline.and people of average world vision.please don't expect them to behave like scholars.
AA dear sir I m not at all supporter of PDM but kiya ye reality ni k imran khan any ajandy ki takmeel mein totally failed ho giya tha ? Plz reply must. Different parties k electables or specially establishment k he logun sy kesy change laai ja sakti the ?
The simple answer is khan is Pola
Mooed sahib , fouji itnae parrhae likhae nahi kae wo app ki baat samajh sektae.
ڈاکٹر صاحب ۔ مختصرآ بات کرتا ہوں کہ جنرل باجوہ اکیلا ہرگز نہیں تھا MI کے ذمہ داران بھی اس خباثت میں شامل تھے ۔ اس حمام میں سبھی ننگے ہیں ۔ ایسا حمام جس میں کوئی ventilation نہیں ۔ اب تو تعفن اٹھنا شروع ہوگیا ہے ۔ اللہ پاکستان اور پاکستانی عوام پر رحم فرمادے
Kal se koi v log nhi aaya kya baat hai???
وہ اس لئے نہ سمجھ سکے کیونکہ جو کر رہے تھے وہ بھی اسی طرح کے کورسز پڑھ چکے تھے۔ لہذا ملازم ملازم ہی کی طرح کام کرے گا۔
You should have known when 70 million $ were sent to Pakistan a few days before the overthrow. This money was used as bribe for MNAs.
These people are degree holders but not educated.
Dr.Sshab ! I want to give you my opinion about your narrative that if Imran would be in power now, he wouldn't be able to do anything for the Ghazah people.I would like to tell you, what Shabbar Zaidi , an auditor, Charted accountant and former FBR chairman for few months ( during Imran government).He is a chartered accountant, but he is not just a Chartered account like Ishaq Dar, he is an intellectual, a learned man, who claims that I have craze to read books and study Qura'n daily.He almost speaks on every topic.In a recent podcast with two hosts, he revealed something.He said, when in cabinet meeting with Imran, I said, abolish FBR and make a new institution, next day, his friend Ali Zaidi, also a minister for shipping in same cabinet, called Shabbar to inform him," You have gone".Second on 16th August 2021, a day after, Taliban regained total control of Afghanistan, Imran gave interview to a foreign journalist and said joyfully," Afghans have broken the shackles". After few days, Shabbar received phone calls from his overseas/ US friends,"Imran has gone". After this he said," World is changing, on 1947, Pakistan was created over the name of Allah, except few years,is contineously in trouble,on 1948, another country, Israel was created on the bases of religion, performed well, got support from all over the world, but Israel is also in trouble.Ghazah was an already decided incident and it was also in plan that at that time, Imran will be out of power.So what Imran could,he would make alliance with Turkey , Iran, Malaysia, some Arab countries, who have leftist governments, like Aljazair, Islamist Tunisia and few other like Kuwait ,to force pro Isreal devils like MBZ and MBS to atleast stop oil supply to Israel.Aljazair and some Arab countries moved a resolution in Arab League Foreign Ministers conference, but Saudi Arab and UAE didn't let it passed.Side by Side OIC Foreign Ministers meeting was also being held and there also the two devils Saudi Arab and UAE dominated and a weak resolution was passed.Imran has the guts to convince the people to accept his point of view.That's why he was removed.Now dot connecting, which I am trying to learn from you, Khwaja Asif said on media, in May, 2019, Bajwa told us that we are not happy with Imran, so first we will give you Punjab government then in Centre, but Corona pendemic broke out world wide and they sit silent to expect failure of Imran in dealing with Corona, but by the help of Allah he successfully manage it.Then they again started the game at the end of 2021, when Khan have said ,for Afghan," They have broken the schakles".It proved, last straw on the back of camel and things moved fast and resulted the regime change on 09 April 2022.
Can you explain explicitly what you mean when you tie IK’s removal to India and China’s future roles in that part of the world? What was IK going to do which was not acceptable to western powers and so he had to be removed? What was IK being asked that he was not ready to do? Why did Bajwa agreed with western powers and helped in IK removal? You have to be more explicit in your analysis.
انتہائی ذلت اور رسوائی کی بات ہے کہ ہماری فوج امریکی اور اسرائیلی ایجنڈے کے تحت کام کر رہی ہے
ایک نام آپ skip کر گئے وہ ہے انڈیا ۔ بدقسمتی سے ہمارے تمام جنرلز انڈیا سے بھی ھدایات لیتے ہیں
You were also used in your those times by them.
They are very cunning.
Bajwa hamri party ka bap tha
Sir, you are still far from , international conflicts have been influenced for personal financial and power gains ,one out of which has been achieved. درہم و دینار کا بندہ بھی کیا بندہ ہے
Respected, All of you So called intellectual/ Philosopher/ Well informed people, none of you knew anything. Kind all of accept your shortcomings. Everything. Kindly don't blame anyone Except yourself. Please study Philosophy/ History before doing any job in life. All of u are simply Bubble.
so khud keon nhi sumhaj saky k 76 year se kiA ho tha hy jb tak leffa molta rha ap bh chup rhy such rhy 😎😍😎😎
Mr. Pirzada, while you are very knowledgeable, you underestimate the extent of the corrupt culture in Pakistan. Your assumption that military officers could not grasp the current situation is incorrect. They are fully aware, but many are deeply corrupt and unwilling to lose the privileges and wealth they have accumulated through corruption. These theories only work when people are sincere and loyal to their countries. Do you truly believe these theories would be effective with corrupt leaders in power, such as Bajwa, Asim, Nawaz, and Zardari?
اپ نے عمران خان کو بتایا تھا کہ باجوا کو ھٹاو ورانہ وہ اپکو ھٹانے والا ھے ۔اس وقت اپ اسٹیبلشمنٹ کی زبان بول رھے تھے ۔۔۔بزدار غلط چوائس نہی تھا کیونکہ وہ عمران خان کے کنٹرول میں تھا اور اسٹیبلشمنٹ اسکو استعمال نہی کرسکتاتھا اس لیے کی ھواہ کو کھڑا کیا جسکو اپ نے نظر انداز کیاگیا