He wrote the perfect song, and then gave the lead vocal to his brother Carl, because he knew he could sing it better than him. What a brother. That's love.
Brian is the best. I had the pleasure of knowing him personally and to this day I love and respect him. I have known him since I was 14 years old and I am now 75 years old. That’s the love and respect I have for him. God bless you Brian always. ❤
I wish i could thank Brian Wilson in person for everything he did for me and for us. No autograph, no discussions about anything, just shaking his hand and say «thank you» for making my life more beautiful and loving.
@@gregoryk.tanaka4285😮 That is an amazing story! I love him. He inspired me in middle school when I was a "nerd" who played French horn. This is the best sing ever. I would love to meet him. I pray for his health and well being. What a beautiful man ❤
Listening to music in the 60's I took songs like this for granted. Now at 74 and looking back I see that people like Brian Wilson were musical geniuses. Thank you Brian Wilson and all artists for the fantastic music.
Man! Hearing him do this in digital stereo with earphones on almost made me have a breakdown. So grateful to GOD that Brian Wilson recovered and got good enough to recreate his timeless love song.
I learned the French Horn in middleschool. Everyone was kind of unimpressed with it until the day I played the opening of this song, this perfect, beautiful song. I got a standing O from my class! This is my #1 favorite song, ever! Brian Wilson is genious. Thanks man
@gustavoheberle6265 Thank you! I still listen to this song all the time. It moves me like no other can. It kind of makes me cry because of Brian being in a sad way since his wife passed away. I love the brilliance of this exceptional man ❤
I attended a Brian Wilson concert about 12 years ago and following the concert he sold items like cd’s and hats. I bought a blue baseball cap that he signed. It is one of my most cherished possessions-and after he signed it, I told him thank you for helping to define my teenage years. Superb memory for me!
Seriously, he's almost 80 (6/20/22). I was moved this time as much as when I heard this song 50 years ago. He still sounds smooth and it's one of the great songs of the last 60 years. I can't believe a man of his age can still sing like that. Beautiful.
I can't believe I think this is better than the original. It's so subtly different, but every bit as perfect as the original. Pretty sure this violates some mathematical law.
So true. Sometimes we forget: It's Brian Wilson, by God, He makes his own rules. It's incredible he's still with us, Because God is a jealous God and sure seems that that level of talent is fleeting.
He sings as well as Carl in this version. I was quite surprised. And is everybody knows this is one of the most brilliant songs ever written. God bless you Brian.
Brian spends part of his year here in Hawaii. Rides the city bus like the rest of us locals to go shopping, etc. Glad to see this genius of music hasn't lost the common touch. No limousine. Nobody really recognize him only some of the bus drivers maybe chat with Brian.
Paul, too? I read an interview where George Harrison said that - or that it was his favorite melody - ( I may be mistaken - he may have said that about 'Don't worry baby').... I'm surprised Macca didn't choose a Buddy Holly tune. I think we've been spoon-fed this beatle lore stuff by the Fabs themselves, because having lore adds to credibility and superstar status. ever heard the one where Paul said that Yesterday came to him all at once in a dream presented by his mom - it just fell out on him? - and that he had to ask and search all over to be sure it wasn't already someone's song? Well I saw Paul on TV with John saying it came in drips and drabs and was originally called scrambled eggs..."but wait" you may be thinking - "that was the abbey road medley, right?" (...well that's what you said about that a few years later, Paul)...." yeah it was all this mish mosh of disconnected melodies and words and it became 'I read the news today oh boy...woke up, fell out of bed...found my way upstairs and had a smoke' ...etc..." So it seems the laugh is probably on us - they were just having us on - their songs, hairstyles, look and public personae weren't the only things that were cleverly crafted... THAT is , perhaps, the Beatles' real genius; the greatest marketing machine known to man. there are those who say others penned their songs for them. I say, 'probably' - they weren't just a band but something like a government secret weapon - and organiztion... a mind and social control operation. I say 'maybe- could be'
It means nothing to him but everything to me that my wife bought meetvand greet 50th Anniversary Pet Sounds tickets and I got to shake the hand of that genius. Music with which to be brought to tears....in the best way possible
He is incredible. His music is incredible. His story is incredible. Brian you are an amazing beautiful person, not to mention my favorite singer. Thank you for the music you've made that is still being played and loved by so many. God bless you
John Lennon called Brian the American musical genius. Brian called Lennon the British musical genius. They became great friends Imagine hanging out with both of them. Mjh. 7178
What this shows is the sheer quality of Brian Wilson's writing. Its timeless and in the right hands is as good as ever (if not better). An extraordinary man .
Grew up in the 50s and early 60s lived down the street from the Wilsons on Felton Avenue in Hawthorne Calif occasionally they would play at our High School dances in the early 60s. We all would wear Pendletons because of them
Somehow, the fact that Brian's aged into his 70s and him singing this really HITS you. I mean, more than the original. It's like it's more effective when someone still remembers and performs his own creations. It's such a remarkable thing to see.
I’m privileged to have hearing to hear these heavenly voices, and watched The Beach Boys most of my life, I’m a few years younger than Brain, I graduated HS in 1963,
Anybody else got wet eyes? What I wouldn't give to turn back the hands of time to see all my heroes young and thriving again. It is not idol worship, it is a love for how good Brian Wilson and the others were.
Welcome back Brian! This is absolutely fabulous and easily the best version you've done in 40 years. The old Brian Wilson is back. For me this is easily one of the best songs ever written. Thanks, Keith
Not "underrated" in any way, shape or form. Known as one of the top 2 pop songwriters and composers of the 20th century and by half of those, as #1 and is celebrated as a genius across the world. He's the least "underrated" songwriter on planet Earth. lol
I grew up with the Beach Boys. Have been backstage in a concert in Chicago and have seen them many many times. Absolutely love their music and this is one of my favorite songs from them. I tear up each time I hear it it's so beautiful. Thank you Brian and Tony Asher for writing this song
Brian, the eternal Beach Boy! Brian, you have sung me to sleep, for 5 decades. Well, you and your brothers. I miss Carl Dean, and Dennis Carl, everyday of my life. Just glad you are still around, along with Alan and Matt. The TRUE Beach Boys! steve
Not "underrated" in any way, shape or form. Known as one of the top 2 pop songwriters of the 20th century and by half of those, as #1 and is celebrated as a genius across the world. He's the least "underrated" songwriter on planet Earth. lol
@@redadamearth agree. Most likely wrong use of word. I agree. My point to make was that he was so good it was never enough to me but yes he was very highly regarded. Grew up with their music. Appreciate your viewpoint.
Just total perfection from the genius Brian Wilson still sounds the same his voice is so pure it gives me goosebumps - the most perfect song ever from the most perfect voice bless you Brian Wilson ❤❤
I was 18 years in 1966 and it was then a great song. Now 50 years later it is even more beautiful than in 1966. The beauty, depth and simplicity is really amazing. A masterpiece! Like Keats once said: " A thing of beauty is a joy for ever."
He is inspirational through the good time as well as the bad time. I am grateful for his humility and humbleness.. I do pray that his closest friends will take care of Brian Wilson so that he can live to his 90's and just maybe to his 100's. Bran Wilson can see his melodies and lyrics in his head before writing them and then executing them. Great artists are very unique. Carl and Dennis Wilson have passed away. Brain Wilson's songs yield hopes & dreams for a better tomorrow.
God Only Knows, The Warmth Of The Sun, In My Room and Surfer Girl..awesome Beachboys ballads..great to finally see Brian sing this song, and the complete song..brother Carl sang it origianlly, both are fabulous..thanks for this great post
Thank you Brian. You gave so much to the world through the music you made. I hope the world and your fans showed you a fraction of the love you gave us back to you sir. Words arent enough.
I about 15 feet away from Carl when he sang this a month or so before his passing. HE NAILED IT!!! The band was in awe, and did the "Im not worthy bow". Carl didn't see the band...but he saw me and leaned down to say thank you.
Let's not forget that Carl did the original album version. He also did lead vocal live for this. Both versions are BB masterpieces. Brian would write these knowing what would be their best sound. Been listening for 50 years. Just gets better.
+David Goldblatt Brian had a real talent for writing songs to fit the different BB voices. Heroes & Villains and Help Me Rhonda for Al was spot on. Can you imagine if Mike did it! Brian knew how to write for Carl and the rest of them. He is so amazingly talented. Love his music.
God only knows what we would be without Brian Wilson
👏👏👏👏👏👏
He is referring to the Devil that God is the only one that knows.
He wrote the perfect song, and then gave the lead vocal to his brother Carl, because he knew he could sing it better than him. What a brother. That's love.
I could not agree more! Well said, my friend. Thank you.
Carl did sing it beautifully too. It had to be him.
True. It did have to be Carl. Carl singing this song is a true inflection point of the 1960s.
So many background sounds that just jell
This is better then Carl
Brian is the best. I had the pleasure of knowing him personally and to this day I love and respect him. I have known him since I was 14 years old and I am now 75 years old. That’s the love and respect I have for him. God bless you Brian always. ❤
The man is a musical genius. Their music will live forever.
You know that you have found gold if you can make Paul McCartney jealous !
Me, too!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
The love I have for Brian Wilson is unmatched! The man is a genuis and has gone through so much! Thank you Bri for your amazing music! ❤
I wish i could thank Brian Wilson in person for everything he did for me and for us. No autograph, no discussions about anything, just shaking his hand and say «thank you» for making my life more beautiful and loving.
Well said, bluedove!
I totally agree with you..the beach boys music is amazing..love it all...❤❤
Wouldn't it be nice? You have so succinctly stated what most of America thinks about this genius and the rest of the Beach Boys.
@@gregoryk.tanaka4285😮 That is an amazing story! I love him. He inspired me in middle school when I was a "nerd" who played French horn. This is the best sing ever. I would love to meet him. I pray for his health and well being. What a beautiful man ❤
He got America through the Vietnam War, High School, College, and CHILDBIRTH.
I can just see Carl up in heaven and smiling down at his brother Brian
I totally agree..I wish Carl and Dennis were still here..missed alot..❤
Every voice in this harmony is just perfect.
That's auto tune lol
@@speedspeed121I like the autotune. It's very 80s electronic sounding.
That is a matter of taste. However, when someone says their singing is great, they should be made aware that autotune is being used. @@pascalg16
The song, IMO, is the greatest song ever written, but the voice God gave Brian was so pure and unique to the universe. God Bless Brian Wilson!!!
There's infinite better songs than this song, lol
@@gregjameson2141 great! Please name some. I'd like to hear them.
God only knows where Brian’s voice comes from ❤
Listening to music in the 60's I took songs like this for granted. Now at 74 and looking back I see that people like Brian Wilson were musical geniuses. Thank you Brian Wilson and all artists for the fantastic music.
There was a lot of music I took for granted in the 60s and 70s, but I have to say, this one has been one of my favorites for 57 (!) years. 🙂
@@MelissaThompson432The same here. Lot's of songs and bands I wish I'd absorbed more but thankfully this one hit home with me.
Today's music is musack. As Dylan said, "Your mind wants to be it's music but your heart knows it's not."
This song is heartbreakingly beautiful. A real tearjerker but in a good way.
Agreed ! And Im 63 … 😊
I could be having the best time of my life and 40 seconds into this song my eyes well up with tears. Man what a perfect song.
Sure is one of the very best . No one will ever take his place .
Perfection personified! What a lovable/talented man/musician-great cover guys here as well!😎💕🤗🎶✍️
I had the same response. Tears immediately
I agree, I cry every time I hear it. It's a perfect gift we get to unwrap and love over and over.
Ditto! A masterpiece.
Man! Hearing him do this in digital stereo with earphones on almost made me have a breakdown. So grateful to GOD that Brian Wilson recovered and got good enough to recreate his timeless love song.
Beautiful, no matter who sings it (Brian or Carl), the lyrics are killer .
I learned the French Horn in middleschool. Everyone was kind of unimpressed with it until the day I played the opening of this song, this perfect, beautiful song. I got a standing O from my class! This is my #1 favorite song, ever! Brian Wilson is genious. Thanks man
👏👏👏👏cool !!!
@gustavoheberle6265 Thank you! I still listen to this song all the time. It moves me like no other can. It kind of makes me cry because of Brian being in a sad way since his wife passed away. I love the brilliance of this exceptional man ❤
I love your beauty Brian. You are a genius, but a kind and gentle loving person. Grateful you found love again with Melinda and got your life back.
Condolences to Brian for losing his wife. RIP
I attended a Brian Wilson concert about 12 years ago and following the concert he sold items like cd’s and hats. I bought a blue baseball cap that he signed. It is one of my most cherished possessions-and after he signed it, I told him thank you for helping to define my teenage years. Superb memory for me!
Espectacular, saludos desde Argentina!!!
This song is simply perfect. Brian Wilson is a musical genius.
Perfection from a genius
totally agree!
Fabulous production too. Great vocals. Love it !
Agreed. Masterpiece...
Paul McCartney says he wishes he wrote it because to him it was perfect. One genius to another.
Seriously, he's almost 80 (6/20/22). I was moved this time as much as when I heard this song 50 years ago. He still sounds smooth and it's one of the great songs of the last 60 years. I can't believe a man of his age can still sing like that. Beautiful.
I didn’t think anyone could touch Carl’s version but Brian did it without breaking a sweat. What a talent.
I can't believe I think this is better than the original. It's so subtly different, but every bit as perfect as the original.
Pretty sure this violates some mathematical law.
Originally....way back when...Brian sang lead on it. Don't know the particulars, but they went with Carl...I loved both.
There is an old version of Brian singing this as well.
So true. Sometimes we forget: It's Brian Wilson, by God, He makes his own rules. It's incredible he's still with us, Because God is a jealous God and sure seems that that level of talent is fleeting.
He sings as well as Carl in this version. I was quite surprised. And is everybody knows this is one of the most brilliant songs ever written. God bless you Brian.
My God both Carl and Brian had voices of angels
Brian still has a great voice he just doesn't utilise it much for some reason
Yes, God certainly gave Brian Wilson this song . . . a tribute to all the committed, faithful marriages!
This people, is what a musical genius for 50+ years will give you
Brian spends part of his year here in Hawaii. Rides the city bus like the rest of us locals to go shopping, etc. Glad to see this genius of music hasn't lost the common touch. No limousine. Nobody really recognize him only some of the bus drivers maybe chat with Brian.
If i saw him i would just say hello and carry on walking. Famous people should be treated the same way as non famous people.
It is cool that he makes no fuss on the bus.
Leaves you shaking your head, don't it? Man. We were SO lucky to be born at this time.
Makes me take a deep and slow breath of appreciation to understand the best song ever written
He still sounds great.
Beautiful. Seeing the empty chairs around Brian at the end made me choke up, he is the last Beach Boy alive.
Mike love and al jarride are alive
@@graysonpitman8959 Al *_Jardine_* , but yes.
David Marks is also still living
Mike Love… Al Jardine and Bruce Johnson are all alive …Carl and Dennis are the only two original each Boys that have passed away.
Brian Wilson is a musical genius. Nothing else to say. Thank you Brian.
Brian's singing voice puts tears in my eyes.
Yea, but Carl really nailed it.
He sure did.
This of the definition of “timeless”. God bless you Brian.
Played this over and over in the summer of 1967 before marrying my long time girl in the October. Still happily together in 2023, Thank's boy's.
One of the very best in the business .
A beautiful song. My favorite from The Beach Boys. Brian wrote a perfect song and let Carl sign it❤
Paul McCartney said this is his favorite song ever. Enough said
Paul, too? I read an interview where George Harrison said that - or that it was his favorite melody - ( I may be mistaken - he may have said that about 'Don't worry baby').... I'm surprised Macca didn't choose a Buddy Holly tune. I think we've been spoon-fed this beatle lore stuff by the Fabs themselves, because having lore adds to credibility and superstar status. ever heard the one where Paul said that Yesterday came to him all at once in a dream presented by his mom - it just fell out on him? - and that he had to ask and search all over to be sure it wasn't already someone's song? Well I saw Paul on TV with John saying it came in drips and drabs and was originally called scrambled eggs..."but wait" you may be thinking - "that was the abbey road medley, right?" (...well that's what you said about that a few years later, Paul)...." yeah it was all this mish mosh of disconnected melodies and words and it became 'I read the news today oh boy...woke up, fell out of bed...found my way upstairs and had a smoke' ...etc..." So it seems the laugh is probably on us - they were just having us on - their songs, hairstyles, look and public personae weren't the only things that were cleverly crafted... THAT is , perhaps, the Beatles' real genius; the greatest marketing machine known to man. there are those who say others penned their songs for them. I say, 'probably' - they weren't just a band but something like a government secret weapon - and organiztion... a mind and social control operation. I say 'maybe- could be'
It's Sheer Perfection in Musical Form
Actually he must have said that it's the best love song ever. I'm not sure but this is what I remember
He said it was his favourite BBs song.
No! He said that is the Beach Boys favorite music!
It means nothing to him but everything to me that my wife bought meetvand greet 50th Anniversary Pet Sounds tickets and I got to shake the hand of that genius. Music with which to be brought to tears....in the best way possible
What would we be without this classic. Thank you, Brian Wilson.
He is incredible. His music is incredible. His story is incredible. Brian you are an amazing beautiful person, not to mention my favorite singer. Thank you for the music you've made that is still being played and loved by so many. God bless you
Perfectly said. 🙂
John Lennon called Brian the American musical genius. Brian called Lennon the British musical genius. They became great friends
Imagine hanging out with both of them. Mjh. 7178
Brian is a beautiful man, singing a beautiful song. Simply wonderful. God loves you Brian.
What this shows is the sheer quality of Brian Wilson's writing. Its timeless and in the right hands is as good as ever (if not better). An extraordinary man .
One of the most beautiful songs ever written and performed. A true musical genius.
One of the greatest songs ever written. Outstanding production as well
Every time I hear Brian or the Beach Boys sing, I immediately smile. I grew up on these songs and it always reminds me of good times.
Grew up in the 50s and early 60s lived down the street from the Wilsons on Felton Avenue in Hawthorne Calif occasionally they would play at our High School dances in the early 60s. We all would wear Pendletons because of them
My favourite song ever
Somehow, the fact that Brian's aged into his 70s and him singing this really HITS you. I mean, more than the original. It's like it's more effective when someone still remembers and performs his own creations. It's such a remarkable thing to see.
Masterpiece, hits all the emotions
I'm not religious,but the the brothers Wilson had a gift in their voices.
I am religious and I agree, brother!
I’m privileged to have hearing to hear these heavenly voices, and watched The Beach Boys most of my life, I’m a few years younger than Brain, I graduated HS in 1963,
An amazing human being. I only wish he could realize how much he is truly loved by so many.
Masterpiece. The chord changes, harmonies and the way the lyrics sit perfectly within it all. Be grateful you have experienced this blessing.
An absolute musical genius. 🎶 God Only Knows and In My Room bring tears to my eyes.
Brian Wilson - one of the best songwriter and musicians in the world
The ultimate and universal song of all time
Thank you Brian🙏🏻✨This song was our Mother/Son song to dance to at my precious boy’s wedding last October - the words say it all ❤️
Anybody else got wet eyes? What I wouldn't give to turn back the hands of time to see all my heroes young and thriving again. It is not idol worship, it is a love for how good Brian Wilson and the others were.
in my opinion, this is one of the best - if not the best - songs...ever! Thank you so much Brian!
This is right up there with the greatest classics. Cole Porter, Hoagy Carmichael, Claude Debussy.
One of the greatest songwriters!
WHAT A GIFT TO MUSIC THIS MAN HAS BEEN. MY GOODNESS.
This is literally the greatest song ever written. I like the piano alone version he does as well, no sound effects just the power of the chords
one of the best vocals Brian ever recorded
Some people should live forever!
What a classic. I’m 26 and love Brian.
It's good to hear him sing his own song for once
Brian originally did the lead vocal on a demo of God Only Knows but gave instead let Carl do it since he thought he could do it better.
he sang the first version.
ua-cam.com/video/nL_zKqEK-j8/v-deo.html
@@jaggass and Carl was better
Still great
All are good in their own ways
Welcome back Brian! This is absolutely fabulous and easily the best version you've done in 40 years. The old Brian Wilson is back. For me this is easily one of the best songs ever written. Thanks, Keith
Brian's. Wonderful. Voice. N. Soul...put. Forth!!!
And. His. Faithful. Disciple
Brothers. To. Make. The
Magic. Of. Beach. Boys
Euphoric. Sounds. Come. Alive!!!!
Love. This. Brian's. Masterpiece... Till
My. Last. Breath and
I.ll.. Take. It. With. Me!!!
Hallelujah... Brian..!!!
Honestly, the most underrated composer of all time
underrated ? what are you talking about ? He's mega-celebrated by one and all.
Not "underrated" in any way, shape or form. Known as one of the top 2 pop songwriters and composers of the 20th century and by half of those, as #1 and is celebrated as a genius across the world. He's the least "underrated" songwriter on planet Earth. lol
🥺😢😭 one of the most beautiful songs ever written , thanks Brian for you magic
This is one of the most amazing songs ever made. Everything on that song is right.
I grew up with the Beach Boys. Have been backstage in a concert in Chicago and have seen them many many times. Absolutely love their music and this is one of my favorite songs from them. I tear up each time I hear it it's so beautiful. Thank you Brian and Tony Asher for writing this song
Brian Wilson is a legend!
Truly a gift from God. Brian just might be the finest musician of the past hundred yearsr
Brian, the eternal Beach Boy! Brian, you
have sung me to sleep, for 5 decades.
Well, you and your brothers. I miss Carl
Dean, and Dennis Carl, everyday of my
life. Just glad you are still around, along
with Alan and Matt. The TRUE Beach Boys!
steve
God bless you and give you strength and peace, Brian! SO many people love you!
A most underrated musical genius. So talented. Love their music.
Not "underrated" in any way, shape or form. Known as one of the top 2 pop songwriters of the 20th century and by half of those, as #1 and is celebrated as a genius across the world. He's the least "underrated" songwriter on planet Earth. lol
@@redadamearth agree. Most likely wrong use of word. I agree. My point to make was that he was so good it was never enough to me but yes he was very highly regarded. Grew up with their music. Appreciate your viewpoint.
Just total perfection from the genius Brian Wilson still sounds the same his voice is so pure it gives me goosebumps - the most perfect song ever from the most perfect voice bless you Brian Wilson ❤❤
A Real Masterpiece !
The Song of the Century !
Love, love, love that song always will
Cheers Brian.
A perfect song from the soul of a genius, a poet. How lucky we are to have Brian Wilson in our midst.
Chef-d'œuvre !❤
This is a Song for 100 Years ! Genius.....Paul said....LOVE
masterpiece ... masterpiece ... masterpiece😘
Saw Love & Mercy last night...brilliant film...Cried my eyes out x
That's a pretty honest film. Loved it. Glad he is happy now!
I just bought the DVD last week...Great movie!
God only knows what we would do without you, Brian.
This song just hits your heart. Luv u Brian Wilson for giving it to us.
I love the Beach Boys - grew up with them. My favorite is Brian Wilson.
So beautiful and a heart felt masterpiece by the genius of harmony.
My husband was such a huge fan. And I listen to brian Wilson songs daily to remind me of my husband. My husband sang the last song all the time.
I was 18 years in 1966 and it was then a great song. Now 50 years later it is even more beautiful than in 1966. The beauty, depth and simplicity is really amazing. A masterpiece!
Like Keats once said: " A thing of beauty is a joy for ever."
its the best song ever most songwriters agree one of them being paul mccartney.
I was born 3 years after this song was released and now at 51 I am in awe at how Beautiful this is. It is timeless.
A sound for all times and ages.
He is inspirational through the good time as well as the bad time. I am grateful for his humility and humbleness.. I do pray that his closest friends will take care of Brian Wilson so that he can live to his 90's and just maybe to his 100's. Bran Wilson can see his melodies and lyrics in his head before writing them and then executing them. Great artists are very unique. Carl and Dennis Wilson have passed away. Brain Wilson's songs yield hopes & dreams for a better tomorrow.
seriously I'm a 30 year old guy who heard this song today and it made me cry my eyes out ..
I believe it.
We are crying for a long, long time. We still are.
yeah
Me too, and I'm 52
Like... for the first time?!?
God Only Knows, The Warmth Of The Sun, In My Room and Surfer Girl..awesome Beachboys ballads..great to finally see Brian sing this song, and the complete song..brother Carl sang it origianlly, both are fabulous..thanks for this great post
Not many better songs than this one. Not human if you've never shed a tear to it.
@Brian Wilson I'd love a chat Brian, but I fear you're in Ghana trying to get my credit info.
@Brian Wilson I'd love a chat Brian, but I fear you're in Ghana trying to get my credit info.
@Brian Wilson I'd love a chat Brian, but I fear you're in Ghana trying to get my credit info.
Thank you Brian. You gave so much to the world through the music you made. I hope the world and your fans showed you a fraction of the love you gave us back to you sir. Words arent enough.
I about 15 feet away from Carl when he sang this a month or so before his passing. HE NAILED IT!!! The band was in awe, and did the "Im not worthy bow". Carl didn't see the band...but he saw me and leaned down to say thank you.
Brian Wilson and this song has to be up there with the top songs ever recorded, thank you Brian......
Let's not forget that Carl did the original album version. He also did lead vocal live for this. Both versions are BB masterpieces. Brian would write these knowing what would be their best sound. Been listening for 50 years. Just gets better.
+David Goldblatt Brian had a real talent for writing songs to fit the different BB voices. Heroes & Villains and Help Me Rhonda for Al was spot on. Can you imagine if Mike did it! Brian knew how to write for Carl and the rest of them. He is so amazingly talented. Love his music.