I’m so glad that our honest Jewish people like Amy Goodman raising their voice against genocide innocent civilians in Gaza . Thanks as none Palestinian Muslim wishing you all the happiness God bless you.
Years ago I read an article in the NYT Sunday magazine that was outlining some of the atrocities perpetuated by Israel against the Palestinians, but I remember the author of the piece saying that there are millions of Israelis who were in favor of a two state solution, but it was the Zionists in both Israel and the US who were against that solution. The ADL and other Zionists groups in the US have managed to control the narrative in the US, but I think that is coming to an end as they can't control social media...the youth will be their downfall.
I think there are more honest Jewish people it’s just that they are buying what our gov is saying, it’s hard to make people think otherwise if they are told they are at danger. Specially Hamas attack set them off. They are being told pro Palestine protest means death to all Jews and Israel. Honestly just like some Jews that want to wipe out all Palestinians I don’t doubt there are some Palestinians that believe the same but that’s not majority. And what majority pro Palestine is asking for is just the right to self govern without interference and give back the occupied land that was taken over in the last 75 years. The west literally thinks anything in Arabic means they want to blow them up 🤦🏻♂️.
@@kevinbeaumont8750 ohh really , then will u replace Hamas in fighting to get back the Palestinians land??? I'm sure u can't do it , then it's better for u to keep ur mouth shut .!
I hope the citizens of the USA are ready to say goodbye to our way of life. The participation in the Israeli genocide of Gaza is changing everything. The US will never recover from this in the eyes of the world.
Sadly the US has never recovered, in the eyes of the world, the moral ground lost with the post 9/11 invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan, and the torture in Guantanamo. What is happening now with Israel/ Gaza feels like just more of the same mistaken thinking on the part of the US.
We gave up on the US when they marched into Iraq and killed our families and humiliated our people. This is how we Iraqis felt when the world watched in silence. It’s happening again. People in the west should be worried about the fact that their “democracy” never actually reflects its people. It’s a dictatorship in disguise
Especially with our history! What's going to change? These Europeans are standing with the Palestinian's oppressors because they have been doing the same. NOW the world is watching and seeing how that colonial mindset is destroying our everyday lives. 75 years!!! The West hypocrisy has no shame!
There was once a time when no one was allowed to criticize Israel or dare say the word Zionist with out looking like a racist or conspiracist! Now the world is awake and can speak the truth! God always opens hearts and exposes the lies!
It's better to see it wider as nationalism because it puts the way that the Israel government operates in recent political situation all around the world - more and more governments deny responsibility and blame (fe immigrants), lack of worker law and rights, walls on borders, economical depravity, high cost of living, etc and of course status quo about corporations, capitalism and planet destruction Maybe it should be discussed, rationalized and act against.
I’m a time traveler I saw a young man that god chosen one he comes to earth wins the war gives Justine to Palestine but after that there will be jews man with one aye he will give to this earth a hell lots of people follow him thinking he is a god until Jesus come down Jesus not god by the way
If hamas stops then so will Israel. Stop hamas and save lives. Problem is that hamas kills their own people. Not just with IEDs but also they buy weapons off the street that are Israel made and use them on their own people. Clever. Didn't Stalin use the same tactics?
My deepest condolences to the people of Israel and Palestine! I know that ordinary people never want war, it’s the politicians and their evil political games!
"ordinary people never want War" Not True.The Extreme right does.Just look at those in the US Who want a civil war if Trump is held accountable for his crimes. Some of these politicians even win Reelections ."Normal people" voted for them
@irenenabizadeh6802: It's not a war, it's a genocide. The Israelis voted their politicians into power. There are plenty of 'ordinary people' among them and in the Diaspora who want even more barbarism in the form of a ground offensive.
@AlexisWenberg you keep repeating genocide and collective punishment like a mantra. It is not Israel's fault Hamas does this. Hamas can simply stop doing it. Israel is running a military operation against Hamas and is not actively targetting civilian population. You throw around this "genocide" accusation why exactly?
"Defend themselves” has become an ambiguous way of saying kill civilians. I hear this point so often and I can’t believe how many people use it as justification for anything.
3:46 this woman is awesome and shows what true Jewish honestly is about. Honest Jews believe no one in humanity should have to be subjected to genocide.
@@belthool4934they are living under a complex system of apartheid and occupation. I wouldn't call that 'living' when it's next to an army that thinks people like me are inferior and wants to steal my land.
UN Security Council Resolution No. 242, the Palestinian Arabs were unable to exercise their right to create their own state, which became a victim of Jewish extremism and the Arab defending their rights for the land. Any occupied, country has a right to defend itself using all possible ways .Stop blaming people of Palestine, stop intervention, stop the genocide, ceasefire NOW!
The UN can come up with resolutions against Israel until the cows come home, because sadly the US will do what it has always done with each and every such previous resolutions. The US will simply veto the resolution, and in the garbage it will go.
Only people with hearts 💕 know the real genocide happening in Palestine 🇵🇸 Israel and its allies will have to face these war crimes they should not be allowed to get away with this.
Note the popularity of Hamas terrorists with democrat BLM representatives. Now consider the other main contingent of Hamas Boosters: foreigners, who, for reasons I can't understand, are in my country. In the past few weeks, Muslims and Arabs have poured into the streets in nearly every U.S. city to celebrate the slaughter of Israelis, while wearing scarves, keffiyehs and other clown outfits and waving the flags of Palestine, Egypt, Algeria, Iraq, Lebanon, Morocco, Yemen, Turkey, Afghanistan, India, Pakistan, Nigeria, and on and on. It's so obvious that these people don't belong here that the immediate reaction of a number of politicians was to demand that their visas be revoked. Question: Why are we importing millions of people from lesser cultures who will inevitably despise and resent the West for its very success? This isn't the old They hate us for our freedoms! Rather, it is simply an acknowledgment of the fact that the most common and destructive human emotion is jealousy. People will brag about being gluttons, prideful, greedy, angry, lustful and lazy. The only venal sin no one will cop to is envy. That's how insidious it is. Consider the "open letter" from 33 Harvard student groups blaming Israelis for their own slaughter. In addition to about a dozen Muslim and Arab groups, the letter was signed by clubs for immigrants from various locales notable for their high levels of corruption and leprosy. Freshly installed and deeply unimpressive democrat Harvard president Claudine Gay (daughter of Haitian immigrants) issued a kumbaya statement in response to the bloodthirsty student letter, expressing sadness about both the 1,500 slaughtered Israelis AND "the war in Israel and Gaza now underway." At this, billionaire donors to the university finally began to notice the insanity they've been funding. A couple of Israeli billionaires, Idan and Batia Ofer, quit Harvard's Kennedy School of Government board in protest. Another Jewish billionaire, Bill Ackman, demanded the names of the students behind the letter. Gentile -- and Republican! -- Ken Griffin (cumulative gifts to Harvard: more than $500 million) also raised a ruckus. The same thing happened at other institutions of higher learning. The gleeful cheering for the mass murder of Israelis is only the latest expression of hate by inferior cultures toward the superior culture of the West -- of which the donors are a shining example. And how did democrat Gay become the president of Harvard in the first place? Obviously, it was a rigorous competition -- just as it was for democrat Kamala Harris, Supreme Court Justice democrat Ketanji Brown Jackson and democrat Sen. Laphonza Butler. Gay's "historic" appointment gave Harvard its first black democrat president! (Who could've seen that coming?) The shocked Harvard alums might not even be admitted today, with their cisgender white privilege. The college's admissions office describes its job as "antiracism work." But when the exact same people who hate our country turned out to hate Israel, too, our clueless elites were gobsmacked. Gee, where'd that come from? We thought you liked us. Of course barbarians hate Israel! Surrounded by enemies, Jews transformed an unforgiving desert into a first-rate civilization. Did anyone imagine the Holocaust would temper the bitter jealousy? That's like heterosexual white coeds claiming to be "binary" to earn woke street cred. You're still pretty, and they still hate you. The conflict is far larger than a few hundred disaffected immigrants, "colonized" and "indigenous" people cheering mass murder by invading paragliders!X!X! This is an endemic problem. Israel can't do much about the neighborhood, but why on Earth is the U.S. importing preposterous foreigners from third-rate cultures? The failure of their ancestors to create anything worthwhile, certainly compared to the stupendous accomplishments of the West, is too glaringly obvious. Inviting millions upon millions of them here, to gawk at our magnificent civilization, is a guarantee of perpetual strife and resentment. Instead of trampling on the free speech rights of people who hate the West, how about avoiding the problem altogether by leaving them where they are? They'll like it! Vastly fewer "white supremacists" to oppress them. They can hate us all they want. Just do it from their own countries.
A military operation into a terrorist territory is not a genocide. Islamic culture is the only one that actively fosters militants. I am sorry for them but not doing anything is worse.
The whole world has been brainwashed.....where the aggressor is believed to be victim. This is how satan operates. Judith likely isnt and doesnt represent Jewish people. Shes a woke lefty
The head of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, speaking at a lecture at the Hudson Institute, said that Hamas and Russia are similar to each other. Vladimir Putin wants to wipe Ukraine off the face of the earth. Hamas, which is backed by Iran, wants to wipe Israel off the map. Russia and Hamas are similar to each other. As President [Vladimir] Zelensky said, “the essence is the same.” According to von der Leyen, Russia and Hamas deliberately target civilians, including children, to kill and take hostage. “This is a barbaric way of fighting,” the head of the European Commission emphasized. “And if this infection is not stopped, it could potentially spread from Europe through the Middle East and into the Indo-Pacific region.” "We are all targets of the Palestinian Hamas militants and must not fall into the trap of allowing them to achieve their goal of creating a divide between Arab countries, Israel and the West and sparking a war of civilizations," Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said at a peace summit on Saturday. Middle East in Cairo.
🕊🤝🕊Thank you professor Butler for speaking up. What’s happening is beyond comprehension we all have a duty to stop this ethnic cleansing of Palestinians 🕊 🕊I hope more influential Jewish speak up & express their outrage so that we put the pressure on all leaders to standup against the Genocide of Palestinians🕊⚖️🕊🕊
@@johnsmith7140 Yes, that is one of the goals. But if you dictate the terms like a bully, they may end up dying. If you are a bully, you don't belong on any peace table.
We are calling to stop bombarding innocent people… and we already can loose job education and so on… when call for peace was called terrorism???? This days only…
The "TRUTH" is that 1,400 innocent civilians were murdered on 07OCT23 .....something Butler has chosen to completely ignore. Why is it that EVERYONE who has ANY kind of argument against the current Israeli military action of bombing Gaza ....completely ignores the fact that the Palestinians (under the guise of "Hamas"), pushed over 3,000 buttons on 07OCT23, bombing Israel, attacked a music festival on foot and killed hundreds of innocent patrons, attacked on foot Israelis settlements killing more hundreds of innocent civilians in a manner that is in fact called ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS .....such as DECAPITATING BABIES. There are many more examples of ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS ....but the point has been made. Rather than just reading words, THINK ABOUT DECAPITATING BABIES. THINK ABOUT IT!!!! WHY ARE THESE PEOPLE ARGUING THAT ISRAEL SHOULD STOP THE RETALIATORY RESPONSE ???? This is called RETALIATION ....which Israel has every right to RETALIATE .....WITHOUT QUESTION. Are these people thinking that Israel should have done NOTHING but just sit at home and watch TV? Israel, within the first week instructed ALL Palestinians to vacate Gaza, very clearly warning that they were going to level Gaza. Plenty of notice .....yet most stayed. Now this video brings in an "expert" with all sorts of "qualifications" and "titles" ......as if this is going to make any difference to the 1,400 Israelis that were murdered by PALESTINIANS on 07OCT23. "Scholar" JUDITH BUTLER makes statements as if she is the authority and correct in anything and everything that comes out of her mouth .....when in fact she is NOT correct. What she says is nothing more than her OPINION ......allegedly supported by all her jargon of reasoning. At the 2:20 area, she uses the term "genocide" and brings in the U.S. A very weak and aloof statement. Also at 4:50 the reference to the bombardment of civilians and "hospitals" .....which it has been made public that these Palestinian terrorists, who have even admitted publicly, have set up their headquarters UNDER these hospitals for the purpose hiding behind these "not-to-be-touched" areas ......like the COWARDS THEY ARE .....yet BUTLER mentions NOTHING about ALL THESE RELATED FACTS AND REALITIES. BUTLER is about a USELESS in pretty well EVERYTHING she says by completely ignoring what these PALESTINIANS HAVE INITIATED AS OF 07OCT23, AND CONTINUE TO DO TO THIS VERY DAY. The hundreds of Israeli hostages taken and still held ....not mentioned at all. SERIOUSLY??? From the 5:45 mark, Butler goes into nothing by rhetorical drivel ....lots of words .....saying absolutely NOTHING. This is about "religious beliefs" .....commonly known as the "ROOT OF ALL EVIL" ....which is exactly what is happening right now ......and BUTLER completely ignores this fact ....along with many other facts. People/civilians try to get out of Gaza are being kept in Gaza by border guards. WHY???? What's this about "genocide"? Israel is NOT attacking West Bank .....so where does the word "genocide" fit in with Butler's gum-flapping??? ISRAEL HAS NO CHOICE BUT TO GO INTO GAZA AND ERADICATE EVERY ONE OF THESE PALESTINIAN TERRORISTS ......EVERY ONE. I also have to add, Butler starts talking about the 75 year-old conflict that has never ended, supporting the Palestinians as a "society", etc., etc., .....and once again, COMPLETELY IGNORES the fact the fact that the Palestinians have been in conflict/WAR with ALL NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES through the last century. As this war, started by Palestinians continues, Netanyahu is garnering more and more support from the global community. It is only Palestinians who are now understanding that they are NOT going to get away with their actions. .
STOP LYING ABOUT THE ISRAEL WAR!!! YOU KEEP SAYING THEY WERE ATTACKED ON 10 7!!! NOOOO THAT IS WHEN THEY ATTACK BEGAN!!! ISRAEL HAS HAD 7400 ROCKETS FIRED AT THEM SINCE OCT 7!!! YOU NAZIS LYING TO THE WORLD TO SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS. WHILE TERRORISTS DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY OF ISRAEL! LIKE ISRAEL IS SUPPOSED TO JUST SIT THERE AND HAVE ROCKETS AND MISSILES SHOT AT THEM WHILE THEY SIT BACK DO NOTHING!! EGYPT SHOULD HAVE ALLOWED EVACUATION AND ANY PEOPLE WHO REFUSE TO EVACUATE SO THEY CAN GET HAMAS ARE SHIELDING HAMAS! ONLY THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT! PALESTINIANS SHIELDING HAMAS ARE TERRORISTS HOW DARE THEY DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY BY ISRAEL AND DEMAND HAMAS BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO SHOOT ROCKETS AT ISRAEL AND HOW DARE YOU NOT TELL THE WORLD HOW MANY ROCKETS ARE FIRED INTO ISRAEL..YOUR HAMAS SUPPORTERS WITH YOUR DECEPTION BY OMISSIONS!7400 ROCKETS IF HIT THEIR TARGETS WOULD HAVE KILLED OVER MILLION PEOPLE!! YOU DONT MENTION THAT BECAUSE YOU SUPPORT HAMAS!
Why is it that EVERYONE who has ANY kind of argument against the current Israeli military action of bombing Gaza ....completely ignores the fact that the Palestinians (under the guise of "Hamas"), pushed over 3,000 buttons on 07OCT23, bombing Israel, attacked a music festival on foot and killed hundreds of innocent patrons, attacked on foot Israelis settlements killing more hundreds of innocent civilians in a manner that is in fact called ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS .....such as DECAPITATING BABIES. There are many more examples of ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS ....but the point has been made. Rather than just reading words, THINK ABOUT DECAPITATING BABIES. THINK ABOUT IT!!!! WHY ARE THESE PEOPLE ARGUING THAT ISRAEL SHOULD STOP THE RETALIATORY RESPONSE ???? This is called RETALIATION ....which Israel has every right to RETALIATE .....WITHOUT QUESTION. Are these people thinking that Israel should have done NOTHING but just sit at home and watch TV? Israel, within the first week instructed ALL Palestinians to vacate Gaza, very clearly warning that they were going to level Gaza. Plenty of notice .....yet most stayed. Now this video brings in an "expert" with all sorts of "qualifications" and "titles" ......as if this is going to make any difference to the 1,400 Israelis that were murdered by PALESTINIANS on 07OCT23. "Scholar" JUDITH BUTLER makes statements as if she is the authority and correct in anything and everything that comes out of her mouth .....when in fact she is NOT correct. What she says is nothing more than her OPINION ......allegedly supported by all her jargon of reasoning. At the 2:20 area, she uses the term "genocide" and brings in the U.S. A very weak and aloof statement. Also at 4:50 the reference to the bombardment of civilians and "hospitals" .....which it has been made public that these Palestinian terrorists, who have even admitted publicly, have set up their headquarters UNDER these hospitals for the purpose hiding behind these "not-to-be-touched" areas ......like the COWARDS THEY ARE .....yet BUTLER mentions NOTHING about ALL THESE RELATED FACTS AND REALITIES. BUTLER is about a USELESS in pretty well EVERYTHING she says by completely ignoring what these PALESTINIANS HAVE INITIATED AS OF 07OCT23, AND CONTINUE TO DO TO THIS VERY DAY. The hundreds of Israeli hostages taken and still held ....not mentioned at all. SERIOUSLY??? From the 5:45 mark, Butler goes into nothing by rhetorical drivel ....lots of words .....saying absolutely NOTHING. This is about "religious beliefs" .....commonly known as the "ROOT OF ALL EVIL" ....which is exactly what is happening right now ......and BUTLER completely ignores this fact ....along with many other facts. People/civilians try to get out of Gaza are being kept in Gaza by border guards. WHY???? What's this about "genocide"? Israel is NOT attacking West Bank .....so where does the word "genocide" fit in with Butler's gum-flapping??? ISRAEL HAS NO CHOICE BUT TO GO INTO GAZA AND ERADICATE EVERY ONE OF THESE PALESTINIAN TERRORISTS ......EVERY ONE. I also have to add, Butler starts talking about the 75 year-old conflict that has never ended, supporting the Palestinians as a "society", etc., etc., .....and once again, COMPLETELY IGNORES the fact the fact that the Palestinians have been in conflict/WAR with ALL NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES through the last century. As this war, started by Palestinians continues, Netanyahu is garnering more and more support from the global community. It is only Palestinians who are now understanding that they are NOT going to get away with their actions. .
It is not complex nor can it be reduced to "basic empathy". There is simmering anti-antesemitism that has been brought to a boil by many interested, hate-filled parties.
Why don't the Egyptians open the border? Answer, becuase they don't care, and they don't dare. The Egyptian foreign minister stated last week that if westerners were so concerned about human rights, they should take in the Gazan people themselves. Chrarming. At least Egypt has a reason for being cautious, given what happened in Jordan when the country tried to do the same ( (Palestinians swiftly murdered Jordanians and tried to overthrow the King). Hamas are even worse in blatantly using their pupulace as pawns and human shields. Talking about human rights while being naive about who we are dealing with helps no-one.
If she is questioning WHY the American Government is involved with Genicidal acts, I can turn in a laundry list going back in modern terms over 80 years..
Strong, honest with moral and ethics woman for saying the true about the war crimes committed by Israel. She is a jews and said this a genocide and countries who provides intellectual, war material or financial support are complicit of the genocide.
Western moral ethics is an obstacle when you fight terror organizations. Genocide doesn't come along with the growing Palestinian population. Stop being Naive!
There are many Jewish people around the world who are calling the bombardment of Gaza genocide. What really impresses me about this interview is that Judith made it clear that everything Israel was already doing, prior to the attack by Hamas, was also genocide.
Imagine me immigrating to ANY predominantly Muslim country and telling them how to run their political ideology, asking you to pay for my education and to support my crazy ideas from the west??. Moreover, me then protesting about not getting my way and creating a civil disobedience in the process? What do you think would happen to me? Honest question?
So if she defines Hamas as a resistance movement, then she would need to define the Haganah, the Irgun and the Stern Gang as resistance movements for their role in fighting the British. Right? What's good for the goose is good for the gander.
Untruthful doing will not create peace. I salute Professor Butler. God bless the whole world. Prayers for those injured and unjustified innocent people. Thanks for sharing this video.
There is no revenge it's only defense for their land. Stop gaslighting your own self, man, you're hurting yourself. There is no revenge there is only resistance!!! Are you mad.
Self defense should not be conflated with revenge. There is also a distinction to be made - around 'intent', hamas intended to kill as many innocent civilians as it could - this is not the intention of Israel.
Israel's been brutalising the Palestinians for decades, it's just a question of degrees. Stealing land, imprisonment without charge, destruction of crops, IDF supported pogroms of Palestinian villages, random executions of Palestinians by unaccountable so called 'settlers'. Now it's cranked up to kill everyone. Lock them in, cut off access to all resources and carpet bomb the Strip. It's like the Wharsaw ghetto on steroids. Disgraceful.@@johnbwill
All governments should be accountable for their actions , NO ONE should be above the law. To allow any government to abuse of their power, without criticism and accountability, that’s how tyrants are born.
Prof.Butler. You seem to down play the massacre Hamas inflicted on Israeli civilians Makes me wonder. How would you feel if Hamas terrorists barged into your house gun spraying your family. How would you feel if Hamas terrorists burned your whole family while alive? How would you feel if your little baby was murdered and then beheaded? How would you feel if your daugther was raped by Hamas terrorists? How would you feel if your relative pregnant woman was murdered then the terrorist cut her belly and take the fetus out? How dare you compare Israel to Hamas??? I would advise you to seek professional counsel. Unbelievable.
This is so heartwarming to hear. I think Israel has been taken by surprise by the worldwide support for the end of genocide in Gaza and the West Bank. Israel has irreversibly ruined their credibility and expended their moral capital. Israeli are inflicting a holocaust to the Palestinians. All lives matter. Love and prayers to all innocents caught in this horror and a big hope of a resolution for the Palestinians 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤
Palestinian lives only matter to people in the west and israel. Hamas uses their own people as human shields. They set up road blocks to prevent palestinians from leaving the area after israel warns them they plan on bombing the area. The only side tries to actually prevent palestinian deaths are the israels while palestine focuses their resources on complaining as opposed protecting it's people. The surrounding arab nations won't take a single refugee. Why do you think that is? You are the worst hypocrites
How you can have the gonads to talk about "Gods Work" tells us a lot about you vincent. Imaginary" Gods" are the cause of this horror! Your Christian God started all this mess in the first place. When one party comes armed with their Bible and a 2,000-year-old promise from THEIR IMAGINARY GOD, there is nothing to be discussed. The issue will only be settled on the field of battle with iron and rivers of blood. Thousands slaughtered in the name of imaginary GODs. As it has been done since man invented GOD's. There will be no winners. "Religion poisons everything" - Chrsitopher Hitchens
An excellent example of today’s academic idiocy. The massacre of 1400 people a day is not genocide but the killing of 5000 people, most of them terrorists, during 21 days it is genocide. The not so distinguished professor is not aware of the fact that the number of Palestinians ever since the establishment of Israel on 1948 had multiplied itself by at least 5 times and they keep crowding at the gates of our state fleeing from the backward retarded Arab states around us... I wonder where can I find her crashing remarks on the last Armenian ethnic cleansing just three months ago
And the 5000 is if you believe the numbers Hamas is putting out which no sane person should be believing. All the info coming from Gaza should be treated with very high skepticism.
In the USA & UK calling for ceasefire is against the law, you will labeled a terrorist if you want to save lives. It's against the law to have humanity in the West.
Израиль подвергся страшной и кровавой атаке террористов Хамас. Если Израиль не выстоит против террора- то завтра террористы придут к тебе убивать твоих детей. Завтра они убьют и сожгут твою семью.
То ли дело рашка - прямо идеал страны - ну да бомбит ежедневно Украину и убивает людей, оккупировала часть Грузии, и держит в страхе миллионы людей но зато не как запад.
It’s actually not as rare as you may think, because it is simply the unbiased human conclusion on the matter. It’s just that those with this opinion are being suppressed from sharing it- and those spouting the Zionist narrative are instead amplified artificially by the powers that be (in mass media, etc)
she is an open hamas terrorists' supporter and must go to Gaza herself to help palestinians. None of actions on providing any assistance towards palestinians to change the situation in Gaza for the better were taken by her. Only many empty words spoken by her.
God bless you sister judith butler for your voice and one could sense the difficultly in your expression and articulated words considering the challenges many are experiencing voicing similar concerns ... your strength strengthens me in the pursuit for justice and peace ... i am grateful to you and alike for your selflessness sacrifice and challenges around it ... thank you thank you thank you!! and of course democracynow you are also a diamond in the ruff and i want to inform that we see you and you shine bright!!!
Thank you so much for covering this story because it has been desperately needed. The west has had a very heavy have in the struggles between these different groups and still don’t understand.
STOP LYING ABOUT THE ISRAEL WAR!!! YOU KEEP SAYING THEY WERE ATTACKED ON 10 7!!! NOOOO THAT IS WHEN THEY ATTACK BEGAN!!! ISRAEL HAS HAD 7400 ROCKETS FIRED AT THEM SINCE OCT 7!!! YOU NAZIS LYING TO THE WORLD TO SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS. WHILE TERRORISTS DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY OF ISRAEL! LIKE ISRAEL IS SUPPOSED TO JUST SIT THERE AND HAVE ROCKETS AND MISSILES SHOT AT THEM WHILE THEY SIT BACK DO NOTHING!! EGYPT SHOULD HAVE ALLOWED EVACUATION AND ANY PEOPLE WHO REFUSE TO EVACUATE SO THEY CAN GET HAMAS ARE SHIELDING HAMAS! ONLY THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT! PALESTINIANS SHIELDING HAMAS ARE TERRORISTS HOW DARE THEY DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY BY ISRAEL AND DEMAND HAMAS BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO SHOOT ROCKETS AT ISRAEL AND HOW DARE YOU NOT TELL THE WORLD HOW MANY ROCKETS ARE FIRED INTO ISRAEL..YOUR HAMAS SUPPORTERS WITH YOUR DECEPTION BY OMISSIONS!7400 ROCKETS IF HIT THEIR TARGETS WOULD HAVE KILLED OVER MILLION PEOPLE!! YOU DONT MENTION THAT BECAUSE YOU SUPPORT HAMAS!
It is the most beautiful thing to see a human stand out from the herd and defy the society and everyone to say words of justice. As a palestinian, I salute every free virtuous israeli who respects humanity. From the river to the sea Palestine will be free 🇵🇸
STOP LYING ABOUT THE ISRAEL WAR!!! YOU KEEP SAYING THEY WERE ATTACKED ON 10 7!!! NOOOO THAT IS WHEN THEY ATTACK BEGAN!!! ISRAEL HAS HAD 7400 ROCKETS FIRED AT THEM SINCE OCT 7!!! YOU NAZIS LYING TO THE WORLD TO SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS. WHILE TERRORISTS DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY OF ISRAEL! LIKE ISRAEL IS SUPPOSED TO JUST SIT THERE AND HAVE ROCKETS AND MISSILES SHOT AT THEM WHILE THEY SIT BACK DO NOTHING!! EGYPT SHOULD HAVE ALLOWED EVACUATION AND ANY PEOPLE WHO REFUSE TO EVACUATE SO THEY CAN GET HAMAS ARE SHIELDING HAMAS! ONLY THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT! PALESTINIANS SHIELDING HAMAS ARE TERRORISTS HOW DARE THEY DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY BY ISRAEL AND DEMAND HAMAS BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO SHOOT ROCKETS AT ISRAEL AND HOW DARE YOU NOT TELL THE WORLD HOW MANY ROCKETS ARE FIRED INTO ISRAEL..YOUR HAMAS SUPPORTERS WITH YOUR DECEPTION BY OMISSIONS!7400 ROCKETS IF HIT THEIR TARGETS WOULD HAVE KILLED OVER MILLION PEOPLE!! YOU DONT MENTION THAT BECAUSE YOU SUPPORT HAMAS! THE MEDIA IS COMMITTING HOLOCAUST BY LYING TO THE WORLD AND HIDING WHAT IS BEING DONE TO ISRAEL! SEE ON MY CHANNEL THE VIDEOS I HAVE SHARED THAT THE MEDIA HAS HIDDEN FROM THE WORLD! PEOPLE LIVING IN BOMB SHELTERS THE CONSTANT FIRING ROCKETS INTO ISRAEL WHILE US WHITEHOUSE AND MEDIA LIE AND LIE AND LIE TO THE WORLD SAYING THEY WERE ONLY ATTACKED ON 1- 7 SO THEY CAN GARNER SYMPATHY FOR TERRORISTS!! NAZISM SPREAD INTO MILLIONS BY SUCH ACTS OF DECEPTION....GOD WILL PUNISH ALL THOSE WHO PARTICIPATE IN THIS DECEPTION AGAINST ISRAEL...
@@furgie49 I might not witness it in my life time but I assure you that's how it will end, especially with the geopolitical powers shifting now quite rapidly, without USA , Israel cannot maintain the conquest of Palestine. If you believe in religious myths, then yes, that might get you to the conclusion that they don't exist, stick with facts , they exist very much. Peace my friend 🇵🇸
Besides them, many Arab sources confirm the fact that the Holy Land was still Jewish by population and culture in spite of the Diaspora: ·In 985 c.e. the Arab writer Muqaddasi complained that in Jerusalem the large majority of the population were Jewish, and said that "the mosque is empty of worshippers..." . ·Ibn Khaldun, one of the most creditable Arab historians, in 1377 c.e. wrote: "Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel extended over 1400 years... It was the Jews who implanted the culture and customs of the permanent settlement". After 300 years of Arab rule in the Holy Land, Ibn Khaldun attested that Jewish culture and traditions were still dominant. By that time there was still no evidence of "Palestinian" roots or culture . ·The historian James Parker wrote: "During the first century after the Arab conquest [670-740 c.e.], the caliph and governors of Syria and the [Holy] Land ruled entirely over Christian and Jewish subjects. Apart from the Bedouin in the earliest days, the only Arabs west of the Jordan were the garrisons". Even though the Arabs ruled the Land from 640 c.e. to 1099 c.e., they never became the majority of the population. Most of the inhabitants were Christians (Assyrian and Armenian) and Jews.
@@juliafrances1632well I think they’re afab but not a woman…since they’re (legally) non-binary. Although as of 2020 Judith Butler said they use both they/them and she/her pronouns still.
It’s so hard to realize your own government can make you pay to commit genocide. I guess I thought most people at heart, would act to protect other people at the end of the day. But I guess I was wrong.
I don’t want to hear anyone use the Torah, the Gospels or the Quran to justify acts which are unequivocally condemned by the God we are supposed to serve
If a man murders someone because he hates that person, then the police have not only a right but a moral obligation to take that man into custody. If the man begins shooting at the police then the police have a right and a duty to themselves to kill the man in self defense. If that man, immediately following his murder of the original person, grabs his brother to be used as a human shield and is also innocent of any wrongdoing, the murderer says to the police, "go ahead and shoot at me, if you kill my brother trying to kill me it is your fault," that is an inaccurate portrayal of the actual ethics involved. Let's say the police have an expert rated sniper who they, unknown to the murderer, order to an occluded area. The sniper, following correct procedure, aims his rifle at the murderer's head. If the sniper misses, for whatever reason and kills the brother instead, the sniper is not morally responsible for the brother's death, the murderer is. He placed his brother in harm's way to protect himself. The same can be said if two men hold up a bank and take hostages when the police close in. If the police or a security guard, in an attempt to kill the two men, liberating their hostages, but instead kill one of those hostages, that death is one hundred percent the responsibility of the kidnappers. Hamas uses its own people as human shields, it places its weaponry and war infrastructure under schools, mosques and hospitals. Then it attacks Israeli civilians and hides behind its own civilians, waiting for a defensive attack from Israel, who strikes back at Hamas, doing everything in its power to prevent the death of Palestinians.
We need more voices like Professor Butler, the courage to speak out and the voice of wisdom, the voice of peace and most importantly the voice of Truth!
Be bold and talk about what happens in Palestine and the injustice, torture and bombing they witness. Our children and women are all in ruins, burning children alive. We've been living this life for over 75 years, but when we decided to fight back for freedom, they changed the facts and they call us terrorists, is this fair ترجمة : كن جريئا وتحدث عما يحدث في فلسطين وما تشهده من ظلم وتعذيب وقصف. أطفالنا ونسائنا جميعهم في حالة خراب يحرقون الأطفال أحياء. لقد عشنا هذه الحياة منذ أكثر من 75 عامًا، ولكن عندما قررنا القتال من أجل الحرية، غيروا الحقائق ووصفونا بالإرهابيين، هل هذا عدل ؟
The situation in Gaza is heartbreaking. 3000 children are killed by indiscriminate IDF bombing in last 18 days. 1800 children are still under rubbles. With no water and food how long will they survive?? I am totally speechless after watching the horrific Geneocidal situation in Gaza..
Most of the real Jewish people have talked against genocide and apartheid of Israel on Gaza because they are human being amd can realize the pain of Palestinians.
I’m so glad that our honest Jewish people like Amy Goodman raising their voice against genocide innocent civilians in Gaza . Thanks as none Palestinian Muslim wishing you all the happiness God bless you.
Palestinians are muslims, Christians and orthodox jews. Izreal are american secular pseudo jews calling themselves sons of zion
me too as muslime :D It's relieve to have people like her and you in our world
Years ago I read an article in the NYT Sunday magazine that was outlining some of the atrocities perpetuated by Israel against the Palestinians, but I remember the author of the piece saying that there are millions of Israelis who were in favor of a two state solution, but it was the Zionists in both Israel and the US who were against that solution. The ADL and other Zionists groups in the US have managed to control the narrative in the US, but I think that is coming to an end as they can't control social media...the youth will be their downfall.
I think there are more honest Jewish people it’s just that they are buying what our gov is saying, it’s hard to make people think otherwise if they are told they are at danger. Specially Hamas attack set them off. They are being told pro Palestine protest means death to all Jews and Israel. Honestly just like some Jews that want to wipe out all Palestinians I don’t doubt there are some Palestinians that believe the same but that’s not majority. And what majority pro Palestine is asking for is just the right to self govern without interference and give back the occupied land that was taken over in the last 75 years. The west literally thinks anything in Arabic means they want to blow them up 🤦🏻♂️.
What do you think of Mosab Yousef "Son of Hamas"? You prefer to see Palestinians continue to suffer?
This is heartbreaking.. where is humanity for one million children waiting for death
It's a tragedy, it's a genocide
We r praying n keep praying,
How man can be so stone hearted 😢😢
Their parents decided these kids have to be 'Shahids'
@@FarzanaBABOORALLY Population doesn't grow during genocide.
Ask HAMAS ffs!
@@kevinbeaumont8750 ohh really , then will u replace Hamas in fighting to get
back the Palestinians land??? I'm sure u can't do it , then it's better for u to keep ur mouth shut .!
The jews need to get rid of the government of Netanyahu and live in piece with the Palestinians
Why does not CNN give space to such wise voices and fair Jewish scholars?
Cause cnn is Zionist puppet
@@mohamedrabie3646🎯
Because CNN are pressured by Zionist to spread lies
Same reason why proud whites don’t get a voice. Deal with it
Cos they are zioned to the core
Up their dirt box
The sons of whres.
I hope the citizens of the USA are ready to say goodbye to our way of life. The participation in the Israeli genocide of Gaza is changing everything. The US will never recover from this in the eyes of the world.
We in US think more of ourselves, the rest of the world already is aware of it’s geo strategic maneuvering and is hated for that
Hamas invaded Israel. Hamas does not give AF about the Citizens of Gaza. Hamas is the aggressor.
Sadly the US has never recovered, in the eyes of the world, the moral ground lost with the post 9/11 invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan, and the torture in Guantanamo. What is happening now with Israel/ Gaza feels like just more of the same mistaken thinking on the part of the US.
We gave up on the US when they marched into Iraq and killed our families and humiliated our people. This is how we Iraqis felt when the world watched in silence. It’s happening again. People in the west should be worried about the fact that their “democracy” never actually reflects its people. It’s a dictatorship in disguise
Especially with our history!
What's going to change? These Europeans are standing with the Palestinian's oppressors because they have been doing the same. NOW the world is watching and seeing how that colonial mindset is destroying our everyday lives. 75 years!!! The West hypocrisy has no shame!
Stop Gaza genocide !!
There was once a time when no one was allowed to criticize Israel or dare say the word Zionist with out looking like a racist or conspiracist! Now the world is awake and can speak the truth! God always opens hearts and exposes the lies!
Or maybe antisemitism is just alive and well behind the screen of 'anti-Zionism'?
There was never any such time.
Lies such as "Hamas belongs to the Global Left" or "Hamas is not a terrorist group, but an armed liberation movement".
It's better to see it wider as nationalism because it puts the way that the Israel government operates in recent political situation all around the world - more and more governments deny responsibility and blame (fe immigrants), lack of worker law and rights, walls on borders, economical depravity, high cost of living, etc and of course status quo about corporations, capitalism and planet destruction
Maybe it should be discussed, rationalized and act against.
3 comments censored in this post. Many other contrary beliefs censored. "Democracy Now"
Judith Butler…. You are on the humanity side! Thank you for your efforts!
Islam is not on the side of humanity 😂
She actively supports ISIS agendas because of how naive and easy she is.
@@TheRandompaintExactly
Thank God your on the side of humanity! Are you able to channel your divine enlightenment to expedite a cease fire.Humsnity thanks you in advance!
Humanity rather .that other word was just terrorist slang.
My heart is so broken 🇵🇸🇵🇸😭😭💔💔
Who can stop this?!?!
I’m a time traveler I saw a young man that god chosen one he comes to earth wins the war gives Justine to Palestine but after that there will be jews man with one aye he will give to this earth a hell lots of people follow him thinking he is a god until Jesus come down Jesus not god by the way
Come back to this comment after it’s come and you will believe me
@@Nskm139 I’m not following?
ooooh, you poor thing
If hamas stops then so will Israel. Stop hamas and save lives. Problem is that hamas kills their own people. Not just with IEDs but also they buy weapons off the street that are Israel made and use them on their own people. Clever. Didn't Stalin use the same tactics?
My deepest condolences to the people of Israel and Palestine! I know that ordinary people never want war, it’s the politicians and their evil political games!
"ordinary people never want War"
Not True.The Extreme right does.Just look at those in the US Who want a civil war if Trump is held accountable for his crimes.
Some of these politicians even win Reelections ."Normal people" voted for them
People who believe in Islamic jihad believe in war.
Why people of "Israel" and Palestinians and "Palestine", for consistency purposes of the reference?
This is not politics. This is muslem terror
@irenenabizadeh6802: It's not a war, it's a genocide. The Israelis voted their politicians into power. There are plenty of 'ordinary people' among them and in the Diaspora who want even more barbarism in the form of a ground offensive.
Thank you for speaking up for a ceasefire.
Ceasefire now means more innocent dead later. Do you support that?
I don't get this. Ceasefire means Hamas can relax and prepare other attacks. It is crazy to me. Ceasefire is not a good option at all.
You can't ask for a ceasefire when Hamas is still holding hostages.
@AlexisWenberg you keep repeating genocide and collective punishment like a mantra. It is not Israel's fault Hamas does this. Hamas can simply stop doing it.
Israel is running a military operation against Hamas and is not actively targetting civilian population.
You throw around this "genocide" accusation why exactly?
Do you thing Alnivol should go to jail for it?
@AlexisWenberg
"Defend themselves” has become an ambiguous way of saying kill civilians.
I hear this point so often and I can’t believe how many people use it as justification for anything.
Are you talking about defenceless kids? Wake up Tom!
@@melatomic Can you at least try to make a coherent question?
I am pro-civilian. Full stop.
@melatomic yes, he's talking about how Israel has used US taxpayers money to slaughter 3000 children
I’m just an artificial intelligentsia bot navigating my way through the easy. Coherency is optional. Shalom.
@@melatomic😐WTF are you talking about?
Thank You Judith Butler. I read and admired your books. Now I admire You also as a human being with character and ethics
And vicioius antesemitism.
A terrorist supporter lol
Did German civilian lives matter in WWII?
3:46 this woman is awesome and shows what true Jewish honestly is about. Honest Jews believe no one in humanity should have to be subjected to genocide.
which is why the Jewish people gave Gaza land up but the Jews were attacked first and are justified to retaliate
@@belthool4934you lost your self to unknown
“She” doesn’t believe she’s a gender 😂
Jews cry before they are hit. Cry babies of the world. Your Zionist dream has turned into a nightmare
@@belthool4934they are living under a complex system of apartheid and occupation. I wouldn't call that 'living' when it's next to an army that thinks people like me are inferior and wants to steal my land.
UN Security Council Resolution No. 242, the Palestinian Arabs were unable to exercise their right to create their own state, which became a victim of Jewish extremism and the Arab defending their rights for the land. Any occupied, country has a right to defend itself using all possible ways .Stop blaming people of Palestine, stop intervention, stop the genocide, ceasefire NOW!
Stop relying on antisemitic narratives to inform you understanding of history.
The UN can come up with resolutions against Israel until the cows come home, because sadly the US will do what it has always done with each and every such previous resolutions. The US will simply veto the resolution, and in the garbage it will go.
Nice YT handle, dipshyt.
UN is an anti-Jewish organization financing terrorism...so yeah.
" To learn who rules over you, simply find out who you are not allowed to criticize. "
And the USA is clearly ruled by violent pro-Palestinian mobs.
Only people with hearts 💕 know the real genocide happening in Palestine 🇵🇸
Israel and its allies will have to face these war crimes they should not be allowed to get away with this.
Note the popularity of Hamas terrorists with democrat BLM representatives. Now consider the other main contingent of Hamas Boosters: foreigners, who, for reasons I can't understand, are in my country.
In the past few weeks, Muslims and Arabs have poured into the streets in nearly every U.S. city to celebrate the slaughter of Israelis, while wearing scarves, keffiyehs and other clown outfits and waving the flags of Palestine, Egypt, Algeria, Iraq, Lebanon, Morocco, Yemen, Turkey, Afghanistan, India, Pakistan, Nigeria, and on and on.
It's so obvious that these people don't belong here that the immediate reaction of a number of politicians was to demand that their visas be revoked.
Question: Why are we importing millions of people from lesser cultures who will inevitably despise and resent the West for its very success?
This isn't the old They hate us for our freedoms! Rather, it is simply an acknowledgment of the fact that the most common and destructive human emotion is jealousy. People will brag about being gluttons, prideful, greedy, angry, lustful and lazy. The only venal sin no one will cop to is envy. That's how insidious it is.
Consider the "open letter" from 33 Harvard student groups blaming Israelis for their own slaughter. In addition to about a dozen Muslim and Arab groups, the letter was signed by clubs for immigrants from various locales notable for their high levels of corruption and leprosy.
Freshly installed and deeply unimpressive democrat Harvard president Claudine Gay (daughter of Haitian immigrants) issued a kumbaya statement in response to the bloodthirsty student letter, expressing sadness about both the 1,500 slaughtered Israelis AND "the war in Israel and Gaza now underway."
At this, billionaire donors to the university finally began to notice the insanity they've been funding. A couple of Israeli billionaires, Idan and Batia Ofer, quit Harvard's Kennedy School of Government board in protest. Another Jewish billionaire, Bill Ackman, demanded the names of the students behind the letter. Gentile -- and Republican! -- Ken Griffin (cumulative gifts to Harvard: more than $500 million) also raised a ruckus. The same thing happened at other institutions of higher learning.
The gleeful cheering for the mass murder of Israelis is only the latest expression of hate by inferior cultures toward the superior culture of the West -- of which the donors are a shining example.
And how did democrat Gay become the president of Harvard in the first place? Obviously, it was a rigorous competition -- just as it was for democrat Kamala Harris, Supreme Court Justice democrat Ketanji Brown Jackson and democrat Sen. Laphonza Butler.
Gay's "historic" appointment gave Harvard its first black democrat president! (Who could've seen that coming?)
The shocked Harvard alums might not even be admitted today, with their cisgender white privilege. The college's admissions office describes its job as "antiracism work."
But when the exact same people who hate our country turned out to hate Israel, too, our clueless elites were gobsmacked. Gee, where'd that come from? We thought you liked us.
Of course barbarians hate Israel! Surrounded by enemies, Jews transformed an unforgiving desert into a first-rate civilization. Did anyone imagine the Holocaust would temper the bitter jealousy? That's like heterosexual white coeds claiming to be "binary" to earn woke street cred. You're still pretty, and they still hate you.
The conflict is far larger than a few hundred disaffected immigrants, "colonized" and "indigenous" people cheering mass murder by invading paragliders!X!X!
This is an endemic problem. Israel can't do much about the neighborhood, but why on Earth is the U.S. importing preposterous foreigners from third-rate cultures? The failure of their ancestors to create anything worthwhile, certainly compared to the stupendous accomplishments of the West, is too glaringly obvious. Inviting millions upon millions of them here, to gawk at our magnificent civilization, is a guarantee of perpetual strife and resentment.
Instead of trampling on the free speech rights of people who hate the West, how about avoiding the problem altogether by leaving them where they are? They'll like it! Vastly fewer "white supremacists" to oppress them. They can hate us all they want. Just do it from their own countries.
A military operation into a terrorist territory is not a genocide. Islamic culture is the only one that actively fosters militants. I am sorry for them but not doing anything is worse.
The whole world has been brainwashed.....where the aggressor is believed to be victim.
This is how satan operates.
Judith likely isnt and doesnt represent Jewish people. Shes a woke lefty
The head of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, speaking at a lecture at the Hudson Institute, said that Hamas and Russia are similar to each other.
Vladimir Putin wants to wipe Ukraine off the face of the earth. Hamas, which is backed by Iran, wants to wipe Israel off the map. Russia and Hamas are similar to each other. As President [Vladimir] Zelensky said, “the essence is the same.”
According to von der Leyen, Russia and Hamas deliberately target civilians, including children, to kill and take hostage. “This is a barbaric way of fighting,” the head of the European Commission emphasized. “And if this infection is not stopped, it could potentially spread from Europe through the Middle East and into the Indo-Pacific region.”
"We are all targets of the Palestinian Hamas militants and must not fall into the trap of allowing them to achieve their goal of creating a divide between Arab countries, Israel and the West and sparking a war of civilizations," Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said at a peace summit on Saturday. Middle East in Cairo.
@@Alnivol666 are you a pegan?
God bless her for speaking the truth! Brave woman
Bravery in the west means slaughter in the Islamic movements.
them** person** 😁
@@ScoiattoloVolante7she’s a woman, idc what delusions she has
@@ScoiattoloVolante7 I have heard of Butler but I didn't know they was non-binary. Peace v
lol, putting others down doesn't raise you any higher, it just shows people how lowly you truly are.@@vivienneb6199
Hamas is an armed resistance struggle, not a terrorist group? Has Butler read their charter?
🕊🤝🕊Thank you professor Butler for speaking up. What’s happening is beyond comprehension we all have a duty to stop this ethnic cleansing of Palestinians 🕊
🕊I hope more influential Jewish speak up & express
their outrage so that we put the pressure on all leaders to standup against the Genocide of Palestinians🕊⚖️🕊🕊
Shared
The world is so corrupted
What is happening is clearly beyond YOUR comprehension. Study some history.
Any person with any education and intelligence would call for an immediate cease fire
@@johnsmith7140
Yes, that is one of the goals. But if you dictate the terms like a bully, they may end up dying.
If you are a bully, you don't belong on any peace table.
We are calling to stop bombarding innocent people… and we already can loose job education and so on… when call for peace was called terrorism???? This days only…
Amy Goodman and team, THANK YOU for your journalism. Greetings from Austin, TX.
We are going to be punished by God if we keep silent and let the war continue...
Judith Butler thank you for speaking out the truth.
Your truth 😂
Your truth 😂
Butler and truth is a contradiction.
@@TheRandompaint Nope. The objective truth. The undeniable truth.
But wait, the truth is kryptonite for you Zi0nists.
The "TRUTH" is that 1,400 innocent civilians were murdered on 07OCT23 .....something Butler has chosen to completely ignore.
Why is it that EVERYONE who has ANY kind of argument against the current Israeli military action of bombing Gaza ....completely ignores the fact that the Palestinians (under the guise of "Hamas"), pushed over 3,000 buttons on 07OCT23, bombing Israel, attacked a music festival on foot and killed hundreds of innocent patrons, attacked on foot Israelis settlements killing more hundreds of innocent civilians in a manner that is in fact called ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS .....such as DECAPITATING BABIES. There are many more examples of ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS ....but the point has been made. Rather than just reading words, THINK ABOUT DECAPITATING BABIES. THINK ABOUT IT!!!!
WHY ARE THESE PEOPLE ARGUING THAT ISRAEL SHOULD STOP THE RETALIATORY RESPONSE ????
This is called RETALIATION ....which Israel has every right to RETALIATE .....WITHOUT QUESTION. Are these people thinking that Israel should have done NOTHING but just sit at home and watch TV?
Israel, within the first week instructed ALL Palestinians to vacate Gaza, very clearly warning that they were going to level Gaza. Plenty of notice .....yet most stayed.
Now this video brings in an "expert" with all sorts of "qualifications" and "titles" ......as if this is going to make any difference to the 1,400 Israelis that were murdered by PALESTINIANS on 07OCT23.
"Scholar" JUDITH BUTLER makes statements as if she is the authority and correct in anything and everything that comes out of her mouth .....when in fact she is NOT correct. What she says is nothing more than her OPINION ......allegedly supported by all her jargon of reasoning. At the 2:20 area, she uses the term "genocide" and brings in the U.S. A very weak and aloof statement.
Also at 4:50 the reference to the bombardment of civilians and "hospitals" .....which it has been made public that these Palestinian terrorists, who have even admitted publicly, have set up their headquarters UNDER these hospitals for the purpose hiding behind these "not-to-be-touched" areas ......like the COWARDS THEY ARE .....yet BUTLER mentions NOTHING about ALL THESE RELATED FACTS AND REALITIES.
BUTLER is about a USELESS in pretty well EVERYTHING she says by completely ignoring what these PALESTINIANS HAVE INITIATED AS OF 07OCT23, AND CONTINUE TO DO TO THIS VERY DAY. The hundreds of Israeli hostages taken and still held ....not mentioned at all. SERIOUSLY??? From the 5:45 mark, Butler goes into nothing by rhetorical drivel ....lots of words .....saying absolutely NOTHING. This is about "religious beliefs" .....commonly known as the "ROOT OF ALL EVIL" ....which is exactly what is happening right now ......and BUTLER completely ignores this fact ....along with many other facts. People/civilians try to get out of Gaza are being kept in Gaza by border guards. WHY???? What's this about "genocide"? Israel is NOT attacking West Bank .....so where does the word "genocide" fit in with Butler's gum-flapping???
ISRAEL HAS NO CHOICE BUT TO GO INTO GAZA AND ERADICATE EVERY ONE OF THESE PALESTINIAN TERRORISTS ......EVERY ONE.
I also have to add, Butler starts talking about the 75 year-old conflict that has never ended, supporting the Palestinians as a "society", etc., etc., .....and once again, COMPLETELY IGNORES the fact the fact that the Palestinians have been in conflict/WAR with ALL NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES through the last century. As this war, started by Palestinians continues, Netanyahu is garnering more and more support from the global community. It is only Palestinians who are now understanding that they are NOT going to get away with their actions.
.
It's not Muslim vs Jew. It's a matter of HUMANITY.
Salute All Truth Teller's and All Activists for Peace, Justice, Climate and Freedoms. 🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋🙋
Support of freedom has to be fight against Islamic jihad. Peace, climate and freedom don't influence them.
She was strangely silent on October 7th.
yes, in her mind the wrong victims
Judh butler is great scholar , and not raciest..
Thank you for being a good journalist and inviting professionals who dare to speak the truth! Other channels make me feel sick.
You live in a very small bubble.
STOP LYING ABOUT THE ISRAEL WAR!!! YOU KEEP SAYING THEY WERE ATTACKED ON 10 7!!! NOOOO THAT IS WHEN THEY ATTACK BEGAN!!! ISRAEL HAS HAD 7400 ROCKETS FIRED AT THEM SINCE OCT 7!!! YOU NAZIS LYING TO THE WORLD TO SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS. WHILE TERRORISTS DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY OF ISRAEL! LIKE ISRAEL IS SUPPOSED TO JUST SIT THERE AND HAVE ROCKETS AND MISSILES SHOT AT THEM WHILE THEY SIT BACK DO NOTHING!! EGYPT SHOULD HAVE ALLOWED EVACUATION AND ANY PEOPLE WHO REFUSE TO EVACUATE SO THEY CAN GET HAMAS ARE SHIELDING HAMAS! ONLY THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT! PALESTINIANS SHIELDING HAMAS ARE TERRORISTS HOW DARE THEY DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY BY ISRAEL AND DEMAND HAMAS BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO SHOOT ROCKETS AT ISRAEL AND HOW DARE YOU NOT TELL THE WORLD HOW MANY ROCKETS ARE FIRED INTO ISRAEL..YOUR HAMAS SUPPORTERS WITH YOUR DECEPTION BY OMISSIONS!7400 ROCKETS IF HIT THEIR TARGETS WOULD HAVE KILLED OVER MILLION PEOPLE!! YOU DONT MENTION THAT BECAUSE YOU SUPPORT HAMAS!
@@TheBlackB0Xyou live inside your own mind
@@rizwanuzzamanjyoti I live in reality, one that you hide from.
Woman moment
Praying for ALL the innocent on both sides. 🙏
Stupid
🙏
Why is it that EVERYONE who has ANY kind of argument against the current Israeli military action of bombing Gaza ....completely ignores the fact that the Palestinians (under the guise of "Hamas"), pushed over 3,000 buttons on 07OCT23, bombing Israel, attacked a music festival on foot and killed hundreds of innocent patrons, attacked on foot Israelis settlements killing more hundreds of innocent civilians in a manner that is in fact called ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS .....such as DECAPITATING BABIES. There are many more examples of ATROCITIES and MUTILATIONS ....but the point has been made. Rather than just reading words, THINK ABOUT DECAPITATING BABIES. THINK ABOUT IT!!!!
WHY ARE THESE PEOPLE ARGUING THAT ISRAEL SHOULD STOP THE RETALIATORY RESPONSE ????
This is called RETALIATION ....which Israel has every right to RETALIATE .....WITHOUT QUESTION. Are these people thinking that Israel should have done NOTHING but just sit at home and watch TV?
Israel, within the first week instructed ALL Palestinians to vacate Gaza, very clearly warning that they were going to level Gaza. Plenty of notice .....yet most stayed.
Now this video brings in an "expert" with all sorts of "qualifications" and "titles" ......as if this is going to make any difference to the 1,400 Israelis that were murdered by PALESTINIANS on 07OCT23.
"Scholar" JUDITH BUTLER makes statements as if she is the authority and correct in anything and everything that comes out of her mouth .....when in fact she is NOT correct. What she says is nothing more than her OPINION ......allegedly supported by all her jargon of reasoning. At the 2:20 area, she uses the term "genocide" and brings in the U.S. A very weak and aloof statement.
Also at 4:50 the reference to the bombardment of civilians and "hospitals" .....which it has been made public that these Palestinian terrorists, who have even admitted publicly, have set up their headquarters UNDER these hospitals for the purpose hiding behind these "not-to-be-touched" areas ......like the COWARDS THEY ARE .....yet BUTLER mentions NOTHING about ALL THESE RELATED FACTS AND REALITIES.
BUTLER is about a USELESS in pretty well EVERYTHING she says by completely ignoring what these PALESTINIANS HAVE INITIATED AS OF 07OCT23, AND CONTINUE TO DO TO THIS VERY DAY. The hundreds of Israeli hostages taken and still held ....not mentioned at all. SERIOUSLY??? From the 5:45 mark, Butler goes into nothing by rhetorical drivel ....lots of words .....saying absolutely NOTHING. This is about "religious beliefs" .....commonly known as the "ROOT OF ALL EVIL" ....which is exactly what is happening right now ......and BUTLER completely ignores this fact ....along with many other facts. People/civilians try to get out of Gaza are being kept in Gaza by border guards. WHY???? What's this about "genocide"? Israel is NOT attacking West Bank .....so where does the word "genocide" fit in with Butler's gum-flapping???
ISRAEL HAS NO CHOICE BUT TO GO INTO GAZA AND ERADICATE EVERY ONE OF THESE PALESTINIAN TERRORISTS ......EVERY ONE.
I also have to add, Butler starts talking about the 75 year-old conflict that has never ended, supporting the Palestinians as a "society", etc., etc., .....and once again, COMPLETELY IGNORES the fact the fact that the Palestinians have been in conflict/WAR with ALL NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES through the last century. As this war, started by Palestinians continues, Netanyahu is garnering more and more support from the global community. It is only Palestinians who are now understanding that they are NOT going to get away with their actions.
.
Imagine coming on tv and saying we really want to call this a genocide so weve changed the definition to fighting terrorists
Reinventing language in 5min and using it. That shows the viciousness!
right
This topic gets branded as so so complex. It is summarised here so simply by nothing other than basic empathy.
Peace to all.
It is not complex nor can it be reduced to "basic empathy". There is simmering anti-antesemitism that has been brought to a boil by many interested, hate-filled parties.
@@desertarisimmering antisemitism doesn’t have to equal the heinous murder of thousands of children. It is simple. Protect the innocent.
Why don't the Egyptians open the border? Answer, becuase they don't care, and they don't dare.
The Egyptian foreign minister stated last week that if westerners were so concerned about human rights, they should take in the Gazan people themselves. Chrarming. At least Egypt has a reason for being cautious, given what happened in Jordan when the country tried to do the same ( (Palestinians swiftly murdered Jordanians and tried to overthrow the King).
Hamas are even worse in blatantly using their pupulace as pawns and human shields. Talking about human rights while being naive about who we are dealing with helps no-one.
Respect to Ms Butler for championing humanity!
She advocates for poshumanism.
If she is questioning WHY the American Government is involved with Genicidal acts, I can turn in a laundry list going back in modern terms over 80 years..
What is wrong with the U.S.?
Nothing it is the rest of the world
The US is doing just what they've always done. A leopard never changes its spots.
@@albertmarsh1796I hope you’re being ironic!
Everything
AIPAC
Thank you much for calling for Peace as many of us are. Biden will not support us in this measure. I am saddened..
As someone who studied Dr. Butler in University, I am very proud to see them making this statement. Thank you.
Oooohh you misgendered THEM lol get it right or face the wall 😂
She is a self-hating Jew, in the same category as Norman Finkelstein and Noam Chomsky.
@@yvonnelee4385 oops I wasn’t aware. Edited it.
@@cara_rima I was just kidding idgaf lol
Who is "them"? Do you mean Butler?
The double standards are sickening for true. Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Would those be the double standards on the antisemitic left?
oh, they wouldn`t love you for that@@kevinbeaumont8750
Amy Goodman has always been my hero! She is the voice of defenseless and justice for all aspects that matters humanity!
They BEHEADED SHANI LOUK!!!!!😢
Strong, honest with moral and ethics woman for saying the true about the war crimes committed by Israel. She is a jews and said this a genocide and countries who provides intellectual, war material or financial support are complicit of the genocide.
Western moral ethics is an obstacle when you fight terror organizations. Genocide doesn't come along with the growing Palestinian population.
Stop being Naive!
There are many Jewish people around the world who are calling the bombardment of Gaza genocide.
What really impresses me about this interview is that Judith made it clear that everything Israel was already doing, prior to the attack by Hamas, was also genocide.
They
All comments censored - speaks for itself.
@@satiricgames2129 lol
Imagine me immigrating to ANY predominantly Muslim country and telling them how to run their political ideology, asking you to pay for my education and to support my crazy ideas from the west??. Moreover, me then protesting about not getting my way and creating a civil disobedience in the process? What do you think would happen to me? Honest question?
very well said and most of us would know the answer.
So if she defines Hamas as a resistance movement, then she would need to define the Haganah, the Irgun and the Stern Gang as resistance movements for their role in fighting the British. Right? What's good for the goose is good for the gander.
super
Well said Lady. God bless 🙏🙏
Untruthful doing will not create peace. I salute Professor Butler. God bless the whole world. Prayers for those injured and unjustified innocent people. Thanks for sharing this video.
There is no revenge it's only defense for their land. Stop gaslighting your own self, man, you're hurting yourself. There is no revenge there is only resistance!!! Are you mad.
Self defense should not be conflated with revenge. There is also a distinction to be made - around 'intent', hamas intended to kill as many innocent civilians as it could - this is not the intention of Israel.
Israel's been brutalising the Palestinians for decades, it's just a question of degrees. Stealing land, imprisonment without charge, destruction of crops, IDF supported pogroms of Palestinian villages, random executions of Palestinians by unaccountable so called 'settlers'. Now it's cranked up to kill everyone. Lock them in, cut off access to all resources and carpet bomb the Strip. It's like the Wharsaw ghetto on steroids. Disgraceful.@@johnbwill
You salute Butler- no doubt a Nazi salute.
Butler is a vicious antesemite.
No mention of hamas human shield tactics
How about lecturering on Gender troubles to Hamas, Mrs ,Butler?😅
All governments should be accountable for their actions , NO ONE should be above the law. To allow any government to abuse of their power, without criticism and accountability, that’s how tyrants are born.
And yet no one has been charged at ICC for Irak and Afghanistan.
Truer words haven't been said.
She must be from family of Prophet Joseph or his own brother Benjamin. We love you.
Prof.Butler. You seem to down play the massacre Hamas inflicted on Israeli civilians Makes me wonder. How would you feel if Hamas terrorists barged into your house gun spraying your family. How would you feel if Hamas terrorists burned your whole family while alive? How would you feel if your little baby was murdered and then beheaded? How would you feel if your daugther was raped by Hamas terrorists?
How would you feel if your relative pregnant woman was murdered then the terrorist cut her belly and take the fetus out? How dare you compare Israel to Hamas??? I would advise you to seek professional counsel. Unbelievable.
Thanks very much Judith butler
Its much far from genocide definition. She is so lazy for not fact checking the reality.
Looks like she watched too much tiktoks
What is the definition then?
I wish instead of introducing Butler's titles for that long, she was given more time to speak. But still very appreciated!!!
Judiths description of genocide sounds like Hamas's treatment of the Palestinian people.
well said
This is so heartwarming to hear. I think Israel has been taken by surprise by the worldwide support for the end of genocide in Gaza and the West Bank. Israel has irreversibly ruined their credibility and expended their moral capital. Israeli are inflicting a holocaust to the Palestinians. All lives matter. Love and prayers to all innocents caught in this horror and a big hope of a resolution for the Palestinians 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤
Yes free free palastine from L.GBTQ+
Everyone must listen to her and support her. Judith Butler ❤❤❤
Palestinian lives only matter to people in the west and israel. Hamas uses their own people as human shields. They set up road blocks to prevent palestinians from leaving the area after israel warns them they plan on bombing the area. The only side tries to actually prevent palestinian deaths are the israels while palestine focuses their resources on complaining as opposed protecting it's people. The surrounding arab nations won't take a single refugee. Why do you think that is?
You are the worst hypocrites
PAZ Y LIBERTAD PARA EL PUEBLO PALESTINO❤❤❤
PEACE AND FREEDOM FOR PALESTINIAN❤❤❤❤
Say no to war
love this interview. Continue the bring the facts Democracy Now.
Can someone please condemn Hamas? How hard is that to do?
You reap what you sow.
I certainly do. Google hamas charter article 7. Hamas is worse than ISIS.
you can`t expect this here
@@Berlinrevue Radical, morally and ethically blind is so so sheek in America and Europe.🤮
Why youtube ban Jackson hinkley for his support of Palestine
Amy and ,Democracy now. Thank you for your attention.
Thank you all for doing Gods work and reporting facts on all sides! I’d be lost without y’all 🙏🏿
How you can have the gonads to talk about "Gods Work" tells us a lot about you vincent.
Imaginary" Gods" are the cause of this horror!
Your Christian God started all this mess in the first place.
When one party comes armed with their Bible and a 2,000-year-old promise from THEIR IMAGINARY GOD, there is nothing to be discussed.
The issue will only be settled on the field of battle with iron and rivers of blood.
Thousands slaughtered in the name of imaginary GODs.
As it has been done since man invented GOD's.
There will be no winners.
"Religion poisons everything" - Chrsitopher Hitchens
You make a mockery of "God's work" .
@@desertari Would that be Zeus, Allah, Yahweh, or Thor my friend? There have been 1,000's of "Gods". All bringing man much misery!
Oh no no no no no- it is not God that brings misery- only mankind does that.@@DennisMerwood-xk8wp
Thanks for telling the truth...this is a genocide crime.
It almost feels like Hamas knew what they were doing. For a second people were once again sympathetic to Israel and then 💥
So Hamas is giving the orders in the Netanjahu Government?
Bless you for saying it as it is, Ms. Butler❤
One day Judith Butler will be right about something. Today is clearly not that day.
An excellent example of today’s academic idiocy. The massacre of 1400 people a day is not genocide but the killing of 5000 people, most of them terrorists, during 21 days it is genocide. The not so distinguished professor is not aware of the fact that the number of Palestinians ever since the establishment of Israel on 1948 had multiplied itself by at least 5 times and they keep crowding at the gates of our state fleeing from the backward retarded Arab states around us...
I wonder where can I find her crashing remarks on the last Armenian ethnic cleansing just three months ago
And the 5000 is if you believe the numbers Hamas is putting out which no sane person should be believing. All the info coming from Gaza should be treated with very high skepticism.
All good hearted Americans and European peoples please come out save human lives in Palestine Gaza also use social media to save palistin lives
"Gender studies scholar" is a contradiction.
so is the whole butler
Depriving children of bread and water is NOT self defense!
that`s a lie!
In the USA & UK calling for ceasefire is against the law, you will labeled a terrorist if you want to save lives. It's against the law to have humanity in the West.
Спасибо за поддержку и совесть!!!
Редкий случай в прогнившей в лицемерии западе
Я просто разочаровался в Западе. Ужас столько высокомерия и лицемерия. Тьфу тьфу тьфу
Израиль подвергся страшной и кровавой атаке террористов Хамас. Если Израиль не выстоит против террора- то завтра террористы придут к тебе убивать твоих детей. Завтра они убьют и сожгут твою семью.
То ли дело рашка - прямо идеал страны - ну да бомбит ежедневно Украину и убивает людей, оккупировала часть Грузии, и держит в страхе миллионы людей но зато не как запад.
It’s actually not as rare as you may think, because it is simply the unbiased human conclusion on the matter. It’s just that those with this opinion are being suppressed from sharing it- and those spouting the Zionist narrative are instead amplified artificially by the powers that be (in mass media, etc)
Yes, all lives are precious. "Do unto others what you want them to do for you."
I wish I could listen to Judith Butler for a longer interview.
Then you have a stronger stomach than I do.
@@desertari no, conscience
@@lazarus1672Butler has none, I agree.
she is an open hamas terrorists' supporter and must go to Gaza herself to help palestinians. None of actions on providing any assistance towards palestinians to change the situation in Gaza for the better were taken by her. Only many empty words spoken by her.
God bless you sister judith butler for your voice and one could sense the difficultly in your expression and articulated words considering the challenges many are experiencing voicing similar concerns ... your strength strengthens me in the pursuit for justice and peace ... i am grateful to you and alike for your selflessness sacrifice and challenges around it ... thank you thank you thank you!! and of course democracynow you are also a diamond in the ruff and i want to inform that we see you and you shine bright!!!
Naive.. You will die first once the jihad will take over.
Thank you so much for covering this story because it has been desperately needed. The west has had a very heavy have in the struggles between these different groups and still don’t understand.
STOP LYING ABOUT THE ISRAEL WAR!!! YOU KEEP SAYING THEY WERE ATTACKED ON 10 7!!! NOOOO THAT IS WHEN THEY ATTACK BEGAN!!! ISRAEL HAS HAD 7400 ROCKETS FIRED AT THEM SINCE OCT 7!!! YOU NAZIS LYING TO THE WORLD TO SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS. WHILE TERRORISTS DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY OF ISRAEL! LIKE ISRAEL IS SUPPOSED TO JUST SIT THERE AND HAVE ROCKETS AND MISSILES SHOT AT THEM WHILE THEY SIT BACK DO NOTHING!! EGYPT SHOULD HAVE ALLOWED EVACUATION AND ANY PEOPLE WHO REFUSE TO EVACUATE SO THEY CAN GET HAMAS ARE SHIELDING HAMAS! ONLY THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT! PALESTINIANS SHIELDING HAMAS ARE TERRORISTS HOW DARE THEY DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY BY ISRAEL AND DEMAND HAMAS BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO SHOOT ROCKETS AT ISRAEL AND HOW DARE YOU NOT TELL THE WORLD HOW MANY ROCKETS ARE FIRED INTO ISRAEL..YOUR HAMAS SUPPORTERS WITH YOUR DECEPTION BY OMISSIONS!7400 ROCKETS IF HIT THEIR TARGETS WOULD HAVE KILLED OVER MILLION PEOPLE!! YOU DONT MENTION THAT BECAUSE YOU SUPPORT HAMAS!
In Gaza more than 3,500 Child has been killed by the terror made by idf. Any religion has prohibited such things deeds. really shameful.
It is the most beautiful thing to see a human stand out from the herd and defy the society and everyone to say words of justice. As a palestinian, I salute every free virtuous israeli who respects humanity. From the river to the sea Palestine will be free 🇵🇸
STOP LYING ABOUT THE ISRAEL WAR!!! YOU KEEP SAYING THEY WERE ATTACKED ON 10 7!!! NOOOO THAT IS WHEN THEY ATTACK BEGAN!!! ISRAEL HAS HAD 7400 ROCKETS FIRED AT THEM SINCE OCT 7!!! YOU NAZIS LYING TO THE WORLD TO SUPPORT THE TERRORISTS. WHILE TERRORISTS DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY OF ISRAEL! LIKE ISRAEL IS SUPPOSED TO JUST SIT THERE AND HAVE ROCKETS AND MISSILES SHOT AT THEM WHILE THEY SIT BACK DO NOTHING!! EGYPT SHOULD HAVE ALLOWED EVACUATION AND ANY PEOPLE WHO REFUSE TO EVACUATE SO THEY CAN GET HAMAS ARE SHIELDING HAMAS! ONLY THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT! PALESTINIANS SHIELDING HAMAS ARE TERRORISTS HOW DARE THEY DEMAND CEASEFIRE ONLY BY ISRAEL AND DEMAND HAMAS BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO SHOOT ROCKETS AT ISRAEL AND HOW DARE YOU NOT TELL THE WORLD HOW MANY ROCKETS ARE FIRED INTO ISRAEL..YOUR HAMAS SUPPORTERS WITH YOUR DECEPTION BY OMISSIONS!7400 ROCKETS IF HIT THEIR TARGETS WOULD HAVE KILLED OVER MILLION PEOPLE!! YOU DONT MENTION THAT BECAUSE YOU SUPPORT HAMAS! THE MEDIA IS COMMITTING HOLOCAUST BY LYING TO THE WORLD AND HIDING WHAT IS BEING DONE TO ISRAEL! SEE ON MY CHANNEL THE VIDEOS I HAVE SHARED THAT THE MEDIA HAS HIDDEN FROM THE WORLD! PEOPLE LIVING IN BOMB SHELTERS THE CONSTANT FIRING ROCKETS INTO ISRAEL WHILE US WHITEHOUSE AND MEDIA LIE AND LIE AND LIE TO THE WORLD SAYING THEY WERE ONLY ATTACKED ON 1- 7 SO THEY CAN GARNER SYMPATHY FOR TERRORISTS!! NAZISM SPREAD INTO MILLIONS BY SUCH ACTS OF DECEPTION....GOD WILL PUNISH ALL THOSE WHO PARTICIPATE IN THIS DECEPTION AGAINST ISRAEL...
At last a gracious Palistinian even if Palistinians don't exist! Good for you buddy. Your ackember of the human race!
In your dreams!
@@furgie49 I might not witness it in my life time but I assure you that's how it will end, especially with the geopolitical powers shifting now quite rapidly, without USA , Israel cannot maintain the conquest of Palestine. If you believe in religious myths, then yes, that might get you to the conclusion that they don't exist, stick with facts , they exist very much. Peace my friend 🇵🇸
Besides them, many Arab sources confirm the fact that the Holy Land was still Jewish by population and culture in spite of the Diaspora:
·In 985 c.e. the Arab writer Muqaddasi complained that in Jerusalem the large majority of the population were Jewish, and said that "the mosque is empty of worshippers..." .
·Ibn Khaldun, one of the most creditable Arab historians, in 1377 c.e. wrote:
"Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel extended over 1400 years... It was the Jews who implanted the culture and customs of the permanent settlement".
After 300 years of Arab rule in the Holy Land, Ibn Khaldun attested that Jewish culture and traditions were still dominant. By that time there was still no evidence of "Palestinian" roots or culture .
·The historian James Parker wrote: "During the first century after the Arab conquest [670-740 c.e.], the caliph and governors of Syria and the [Holy] Land ruled entirely over Christian and Jewish subjects. Apart from the Bedouin in the earliest days, the only Arabs west of the Jordan were the garrisons".
Even though the Arabs ruled the Land from 640 c.e. to 1099 c.e., they never became the majority of the population. Most of the inhabitants were Christians (Assyrian and Armenian) and Jews.
May Allah bless Judith for her compassion towards humanity
"Their" compassion. They are not female.😊
@@juliafrances1632well I think they’re afab but not a woman…since they’re (legally) non-binary. Although as of 2020 Judith Butler said they use both they/them and she/her pronouns still.
Of course Allah will bless her- she is a Jew-hater.
Why does she stop at 75 years of violence? The violence has been there way longer than that.
It’s so hard to realize your own government can make you pay to commit genocide. I guess I thought most people at heart, would act to protect other people at the end of the day. But I guess I was wrong.
The beautiful and brilliant Judith Butler! Have been a fan of hers for a long time ❤
@@johnsmith7140 don't pontificate. She's voicing her support for human rights. The issue is support for PALESTINE 🇵🇸
@@johnsmith7140 I guess Nazisrael does 🤮🤡. Since you're the hamas expert what else you know about how they came into existence?????
A Feminist icon ✨
I admire her honesty
I don’t want to hear anyone use the Torah, the Gospels or the Quran to justify acts which are unequivocally condemned by the God we are supposed to serve
We have permission from our Creator to fight oppression. You have no say in this matter
@@Awaatif-k9tReligion is a plague.
If a man murders someone because he hates that person, then the police have not only a right but a moral obligation to take that man into custody. If the man begins shooting at the police then the police have a right and a duty to themselves to kill the man in self defense. If that man, immediately following his murder of the original person, grabs his brother to be used as a human shield and is also innocent of any wrongdoing, the murderer says to the police, "go ahead and shoot at me, if you kill my brother trying to kill me it is your fault," that is an inaccurate portrayal of the actual ethics involved.
Let's say the police have an expert rated sniper who they, unknown to the murderer, order to an occluded area. The sniper, following correct procedure, aims his rifle at the murderer's head. If the sniper misses, for whatever reason and kills the brother instead, the sniper is not morally responsible for the brother's death, the murderer is. He placed his brother in harm's way to protect himself.
The same can be said if two men hold up a bank and take hostages when the police close in. If the police or a security guard, in an attempt to kill the two men, liberating their hostages, but instead kill one of those hostages, that death is one hundred percent the responsibility of the kidnappers.
Hamas uses its own people as human shields, it places its weaponry and war infrastructure under schools, mosques and hospitals. Then it attacks Israeli civilians and hides behind its own civilians, waiting for a defensive attack from Israel, who strikes back at Hamas, doing everything in its power to prevent the death of Palestinians.
Thank you, no human can survive such alienation
Fighting for humanity is fighting Islamic terrror.
We need more voices like Professor Butler, the courage to speak out and the voice of wisdom, the voice of peace and most importantly the voice of Truth!
Be bold and talk about what happens in Palestine and the injustice, torture and bombing they witness. Our children and women are all in ruins, burning children alive. We've been living this life for over 75 years, but when we decided to fight back for freedom, they changed the facts and they call us terrorists, is this fair
ترجمة : كن جريئا وتحدث عما يحدث في فلسطين وما تشهده من ظلم وتعذيب وقصف. أطفالنا ونسائنا جميعهم في حالة خراب يحرقون الأطفال أحياء. لقد عشنا هذه الحياة منذ أكثر من 75 عامًا، ولكن عندما قررنا القتال من أجل الحرية، غيروا الحقائق ووصفونا بالإرهابيين، هل هذا عدل ؟
He who does not distinguish the degrees of evil will end up becoming the servant of evil. Think about it, Mrs. Butler
Eminent people like you should speak up all around the world 🌎.
pleeeze, better not...
Many people like Butler are spewing their hateful antesemitism.
Yeah the interviewer thought that Gazans are now Israeli’s responsibility. It’s not
thank you, judith butler. it's important to name things for what they are.
The situation in Gaza is heartbreaking. 3000 children are killed by indiscriminate IDF bombing in last 18 days. 1800 children are still under rubbles. With no water and food how long will they survive?? I am totally speechless after watching the horrific Geneocidal situation in Gaza..
EVERYONE’S LIFE MATTERS!
Most of the real Jewish people have talked against genocide and apartheid of Israel on Gaza because they are human being amd can realize the pain of Palestinians.
@user-lq4ei5sf6f: I'm puzzled. What are 'real Jewish people'?? Among the Jews, you're regarded as a 'self-hating' Jew if you're anti-Zionist.
Great interview. Thanks to Prof. Butler for sharing her views.