Bedrock: Fast Moss Based Bone Meal Farm 1.19
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- This is my new Bone Meal Farm, based on moss, that produces 5,300 bone meal profit per hour. It's currently the second fastest moss-based bone meal farm in Minecraft using just one source moss block - and the least laggy for the amount of bone meal you get. I’m able to run at least 6 in my local world with no lag, producing over 30k bone meal per hour! (but that is on a gaming PC)
**In current versions the moss can get stuck on the first hopper after it's washed off the platform. Simple fix seems to be to replace that hopper with ice**
Remember to stop the farm before leaving the area or logging out. The stone generators in the moss farm can produce cobblestone on reload if you don't do this. This is necessary to achieve the rates of this farm. If you forget and do get cobblestone, it's easy to manually clear out any cobblestone when you return to it.
Farm tested on Win10, Realms and BDS, and works on all Bedrock versions.
this farm has been featured by @Zap113 on Truly Bedrock. Check out his video here:: • Truly Bedrock Season 4...
if you need a slightly later game, but even faster farm (11.1k/h) check out my newer video: • (Broken in 1.20.40+) F...
Sorry that the video is so long - I wanted to do this build in survival because there are some areas of the farm that can be tricky to place if built in the wrong order.
Structura and World download - coordinates 296, 64, 232 (this includes 6 copies of the Moss Farm so you can test how many you could run at the same time on your device):
drive.google.c...
This farm must be chunk aligned, see:
Finding Chunk Borders: • Finding Chunk Borders ...
For moss mechanics see either:
@silentwisperer • Minecraft Bedrock: Aut... or
@ilmango • Easy Infinite Bone Meal
Items list for one copy of the farm:
5-6 stacks of building block (avoid: granite, diorite and andesite variants, stone, tuff, deepslate, dirt variants including: grass, podzol, mycelium, rooted dirt)
4 stacks glass
65 pistons
2 sticky pistons
10 dispensers
4 droppers
10 comparators
12 repeaters
5 target blocks
12 redstone torches
10 buttons
6 observers
12 chests
2 packed ice
12 stairs
5 ladder
2.5 stacks redstone dust
8 powered rails
1 moss block
18 composters
49 hoppers
9 water buckets
4 lava buckets
5 stacks of cheap items for hopper clock
1 stack bone meal
Credit to RavinMaddHatter for Structura. Documentation can be found here: github.com/Rav...
***In current versions the moss can get stuck on the first hopper after it's washed off the platform. Simple fix seems to be to replace that hopper with ice***
MCPE-41103
Thanks to silentwhisperer( I think), in 1.20.40 this may start generating cobblestone until it no longer works. The fix I have discovered seems to be to change the first repeater after the lever to the fastest setting. @Eggfur
I can also confirm that with the current clock of 2 ticks on the first repeater and 3 ticks on the second that the farm will mostly just produce cobble. I will try your setting. I fixed it by slowing things down a bit and put both repeaters on 4 ticks.
@@realtimeflies4679
I've tried changing the repeater timings but it still isn't working for me. Anything else I might need to change? @Eggfur
Finally got around to building this farm. Still works great. I figured out that instead of replacing the first hopper with ice you can just put a horizontal end rod over the hopper (put on the glass block next to the one with a button. Items no longer get stuck and end rods still allow for the water flow. I also needed moss blocks along with bone meal so I just added in a single item sorter. Works so well. Thank you for the great tutorial.
I have to say it took a bit of time to build but this produces loads if bonemeal. I ended up taking 6 composters out and replaced with hoppers then sent that line of hoppers to an auto sorting system to get some moss blocks carpets and trees from it also. Great job on the tutorial!!
Thanks! Good work with the adjustments. I might make a future video with a switch to go between bone meal and moss mode
how do you not have more subs the effort you put into your vids is amazing
Thanks! Slowly, slowly...
Now what this needs is a switch to shunt the moss off into storage instead of bonemeal. so you can farm the moss and the bonemeal both.
The bonemeal king is baaaaaaaack
Three quick questions!
1) Have you thought about a quadruple crimson nylium farm? I noticed that the c. nylium fungus growth happens in a 5x5 square so, accounting for the fact that the platform moves in two directions by one block, you'd need an 11x11 platform to get full yields in a quadrupled farm. As you know, this is within the piston push limit and might not make it hard to chunk align.
2) have you thought about pushing nylium fungus onto water rings to distribute it to the hopper lines that feed it to the composters? Would this reduce or increase lag?
3) if a nylium-based farm had a more frequent water flush, would that cut back on lag?
For nylium:
1) It's actually 7x7 where it grows, though more frequently in the centre than the edges. You'd get some loss of yield if you reduced to 5x5 to get 4 dispensers.
2) not sure what you mean by water rings, but see below.
3) yes, more frequent flushing would reduce lag at the expense of some bone meal. You can just reduce the items in the hopper clock, however...
c0g010 has come up with a new platform design that doesn't need flushing and doesn't have a big build up of items. It's really clever: ua-cam.com/video/S280dbGdZP4/v-deo.html.
It has similar overrall lag to the moss farm for the same outputs, but more consistent. On the other hand, it's worse for FPS
@@Eggfur
1) interesting, I'm pretty sure the wiki lies. Was I brainlessly posting Java info just then?
2) ah, didn't know that wasn't a proper technical term. It's a ring of packed ice with a circular flow of water on top, and hoppers on the outside edges. It can distribute items to a large number of hopper lines without suffering from a bottleneck. If you build them big enough they can process hundreds of thousands of items; I've used it in conjunction with a nether portal to operate a 5-piglin barter farm.
3) ooh! I'll check that out.
As gorgeous as your moss-based farm is, I'm obsessed with redstone that never breaks, so I want to see how far nylium can go. The better if farms are turned on by comparators so I never even have to touch them.
just finished building this and for such a complicated build it was a easy tutorial to follow along and the farm works perfect i now have more bonemeal than i know what to do with lol thanks
i also put this above my afk spot for my slime farm and iron farm theres no lag at all with 1 of these farms
How in God's name u don't have a ton more subscribers I don't know! Binge watching your content lately must say always in depth and explain what you are doing and always giving credit to others where it's due! Just started watching this one have been considering building silents in my world looking forward to seeing how they compare
This one is about 36% faster than silentwisperer's. I'm not sure about lag, but the minecarts in silentwisperer's will create a lot of lag. He also has 28 stone generator compared to my 20, but my clock runs faster, so it may end up being similar from a lag perspective, just his is slower overall. Because silent uses slower stone generators it might be more reload proof - that could be an advantage depending on how you want to use it. I've not tested though (or even watched all of his video)
@@Eggfur not to be a hater but it seems his rates are always exaggerated anyway I will start working on yours when I gather enough ice for golden helmets mob farm. Do u have any recommendations for an ice farm gonna test avomances design seems promising in that it after manual collection you can reset the water to all source blocks again
Hmm, some of his rates are. I don't know about ice farms sorry, but I thought the mechanics were different between bedrock and Java - to do with where ice can generate. Not up to speed though, but if you can find a bedrock one that would be better. Maybe try this one if you're able to use the world download for testing: ua-cam.com/video/yx5vDunCfTc/v-deo.html
Yeah that’s that’s fine what do do you think you should be there going ok lol lol yeah I don’t
I'm planning to use the bone meal to make bamboo for an auto smelter. The azaleas can be used for fuel so I'll filter those out instead of composting them (they're worth about 20x more smelts that way).
Okay, looks like sorting out the azaleas to use as fuel directly and composting everything else for bone meal to make bamboo is well worthwhile, with about 3.5x more smelts from one farm's output. I'll have to do more rate testing to get more precise measurements but the early results are very positive
Would it be more efficient to put less items in the hopper clock or add a few composters? I notice some of the items despawns before getting into the composters.
PS: I hope you never stop making videos! Your stuff is pure gold, you deserve so many more followers.
Hi Jay Lee. Thanks for the kind feedback! I'm wondering how you've measured if items are despawning? I confess I've not fully tested, but my assumption was that they got into the hoppers quickly enough - especially since a change to the size of an item stack resets the 5-minute despawn timer. That impacts them both as they clump up on the platform and as items are taken out of the stack by the hoppers.
@@Eggfur Just from observation, so I could be wrong. I started a timer right after a flush, then I waited and watched the next batch of items go into the stream and circle around the hoppers.
At the 5 minute mark, a bunch of stacks seemed to suddenly dissappear right as they passed over an ice block. I didnt seem like the next hopper picked them up because there was a variety of items floating, but the hopper was all moss blocks.
I'm on realms btw.
Hmm, interesting. I think the timer should extend over more than 5 minutes because of item clumping. I'll do some testing - but yes, more composters works solve it without impacting rates. Less time between flushes would reduce efficiency a bit
Thanks for another great build
I cannot for the life of me get the moss to spread to the stone, everything else seems to be working, it bonemeals the moss, stuff grows above it next to the piston, but the stone just won't convert
Love that you out the world download. I can't wait to build this. What does reload proof mean on the signs?
The nylium farm is safe to leave running all the time even if you leave the area and come back. That's reload proof. The moss farm needs to be switched off before you leave or you might have to clear out some cobblestone
@@Eggfur I've been wondering that about the nylium farm. It's been crashing my world because of the lag that's already at my current base and whenever I load it back, I'm always afraid something will break. Nice to know that I can just leave like that
thanks finally a tutorial u can follow along with
Can we have 1 brain and other modules running from one brain?
I have an request, could you make it so this bone meal farm, fed into a kelp generator (just bone meal kelp and hit it with an piston) to get a lot of kelp quickly, then this kelp is fed into multiple smokers, that then output their dried kelp into some chest, where you can craft dried kelp blocks, and refuel those smokers. Basically a manufacturing system for dried kelp. That WOULD BE AWESOME
I just built that entirely with shulker loader and unloaders to reduce the lag
Eggfur does it again
Subscribed. Does this work on 18.1?
Welcome! And yes, it does. There's a world download if you're able to use that on your device. You can give it a test run before you build.
yo eggfur can i make this only moss farm?
farms been working fine until about a week ago where cobblestone keeps forming inside the farm
the farm is chunk aligned and built block for block
my game does lag a lot while running 6 modules so is this the reason or is it something else
disregard the above message i set both repeaters for the main clock at 3 ticks each instead of 2 and 3
Thanks for coming back to me Jack. I wasn't ignoring you! Funnily enough, I think there has been a change in the latest release that can occasionally produce cobble. I'm looking into it over the next couple of days. It's quite rare though
Build it in v1.18.31 and it works very great!!!
How do i fix it if i forget to turn off the farm and reload the chunks?
Turn off the farm. Go to the hole in the middle of the pistons. Then you can either break any cobblestone directly from there (turn it back on to check it's all gone). This way, you'll also need to check all the hoppers above a composter and remove any cobble. Alternatively jump down, break any cobble you need. Pickit up. Then use a Moss block to pillar back up to get out.
@@Eggfur ive done this, but it's still producing cobble. I've chunk alligned the farm correctly, what else could be causing this?
Check the clock. You should have one repeater on two ticks, one on 3 ticks and the torch. Also check all the other repeaters really carefully. The timings do need to be precise
@@Eggfur which clock? Where do i find it
Next to the on/off lever off the farm
Very cool too op for me
Just built it I keep on getting cobble in the system
Hi, are you sure you got the chunk alignment right? It MUST be chunk aligned
@@Eggfur I believe so, I’ll double check
How did you get on checking? If you send me the coordinated at the corners of the build I'll happily do a double check for you. The timings do need to be precise as well, so double check your repeater ticks
@@Eggfur I figured it out, completely my fault, I had the repeater clock with the piston and observer one block too far out
Great, glad it's working!
Another excellent machine. Took maybe three hours to build, but the results are well worth the complexity.
I initially threw in a stack of bonemeal, it ate it all and I panicked for a second thinking "Oh no, where did it all go?" until somewhere a hidden clock went off and it suddenly started barfing out stacks of bonemeal. Thanks!
Nice! I have been waiting for this one. Great work. It is really nice that you took the time to make a farm the best you can make it, so it is both satisfying for you as well as for us. Cannot wait to build this farm in my worlds.
Do let me know how you get on with the build, pulimer!
@@Eggfur For a number of reasons it took me a while to get to the construction of the farm. The moss farm is really nice to build though, it is much simpler to build compared to the fungi farm. In retrospect, I should not have used wooden blocks as my building block of choice, but it helped me being extra precise with the placement of the glass. I have not used it too much, but the farm is, as almost expected, completely lagless. I could feel the lag a bit with the fungi farm, but you do not notice the moss farm working at all. Thanks again for the design.
Latest update seems to have broken this, at least on Xbox. I get lots of cobble.
What how come i didn't see this guys channel before
hey eggfur i know this is an older video, but i have a question. ive had this farm for a while now and never had any problems with it, but now whenever i leave the immediate area (which ive been able to before, ive just hung around within sim distance) it now teleports me randomly into walls. i have to try multiple times just to get back to turn it off. if i stand right next to it, no problems at all! im not sure if there was a recent update that changed lag mechanics(?) for this farm but ive made sure that all the other farms dont have moving entities before i run this one. thanks so much
The baddest bug on bedrock: bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-175206?focusedId=1280756&page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel#comment-1280756
MCPE-41103
Thanks to silentwhisperer( I think), in 1.20.40 this may start generating cobblestone until it no longer works. The fix I have discovered seems to be to change the first repeater after the lever to the fastest setting. @Eggfur
Thank you! I will put this and the Zolson012 one will be built in my testing world... when I find time.
Golden Helmet just did a cute Micro Crop Farm done with Villagers... he recommended your Bonemeal Farms because his farm needs 6k of Bonemeal an hour.
So, I rebuilt this thing is a new realm, it's going well but sometimes my app crashes, which isn't the problem. There isn't a problem really, I'm just wondering what you mean by it isn't reload proof. The only thing I've noticed that sometimes happen is that the stone turns to cobblestone in parts. But appart from that, is there anything else to fix?
No it's really about cobblestone, but the design makes it quite easy to fix. If you're extremely unlucky you might lose buckets from the dispensers, but that's really rare
@@Eggfur I knew I forgot something. Thank you, I was about to forget about the dispensers because it did happen to me once or twice
I’ve been working on a moss based bonemeal farm for weeks. Water logging the pistons, and using the overhead pistons to break the grass and azalea is genius. Excellent farm, and I love the survival building tutorial
Thank you!
I built this and it works great however is the hopper clock that controls the water supposed to have no on off switch?
No I left it running, since it doesn't cause any problems and it's silent anyway. If you want an off switch, you could add a lever to one of the solid blocks in the clock, but it's not necessary
Nice! I really liked redstone wizard's moss farm, but I haven't built it in survival yet (only creative). I'll be playing with your design tonight. 😀
I never did post that histogram I'd promised because I wanted my model to match the actually existing farms a little better, and then I got lost in a deep dive of code digging (which I'm not all that good at yet) and building various people's farms in creative. And my one-liner simulation script slowly grew into several hundred lines of various games mechanics.
...And then I got bored with it, forgot about it for a few days, and built a music disc farm instead. 😉
IIRC my too simplistic simulation had a skewness of ~0 and excess kurtosis of ~3-i.e. pretty normal looking. But it really did need to take into account *net* output and piston-to-dispenser timings, etc. 😅
I think his is an ilmango style design, right? I've seen a few like that including Firetrap's on TBA. They tend to be quite slow for their size, though the fact they tile is a nice touch
Just built this thing, what a beast. I linked your vid in my latest, well done
Hi Zap 113. Ooh, thank you!! Let me go watch your video
@@Eggfur always like to give credit for things and this tutorial is very well done
Hey dude, just wanted to say that your voting build really helped a lot for my bedrock tournament and I wanted to know if you’d like to join the staff team you probably won’t look at this comment like most youtubers but if your interested just reply to this comment and I’ll get back to you whenever I can! Thanks again tho
Haha, I don't get enough comments to need to ignore them yet! I'm glad you like it. Also thanks for the offer, but not for me...
@@Eggfur all good man but keep up the good work, I’ll soon get on the grinding too
i love your design :D
by the way, are world downloads possible on playstation? idk how to do it if at all
It should be possible to do with USB storage. But it's easy to do with Realms, Just upload from one device (eg phone, tablet, pc) and download to another (eg PS4, switch).
Excited to watch this later. You are the OG bone meal expert to me :)
Thanks! I really wasn't sure I'd be able to do anything new, since the java folk have had this mechanic for ages, but happy with how it's turned out
That a lot of bonemeal hehe ;P, nice comtraption my dude o/
Thanks!!!
this is great, thanks!
Everything is working except the water coming out of dispensers to clear the platform. When I first turn on the machine it will spit out the water once but after that it no longer will. Everything else working but that one feature. Water buckets are still in all dispensers with water inside them.
So I’ve figured out that the water is dispensing but it’s only dispensing once every 5 minutes or so, how do I adjust the timing on how often the water is dispensing?
One of the things that makes this farm so great is that we only flush the platform once every 4m16s. That means the farm can apply bonemeal again much quicker rather than waiting for the flush. That timing is controlled by the clock above the composters (where you placed 5 stacks of cheap items). You can make the flush more frequent by reducing the number of items, but it just slows the farm down.
Eggfur thank you for explaining, I was worried about items despawning but that makes sense. In that case…great tutorial and thank you again for responding
let's see you get 1000 subs before the end of the year!
I just found your channel and right away it's obvious that you belong in the "S" tier of technical Minecraft creators. Unfortunately UA-cam doesn't do enough to reward this kind of content
First!
Haha, my channel must be one of the easier ones to be first on :)
lol
Thanks for the tutorial and especially for the world and structura downloads. I'm curious how often it makes cobblestone if you relog without turning it off--will use the world download for some tests
It's fairly frequent, but easy to clear away. The problem would be that eventually it will stop being self sustaining and all the bone meal will get used up (unless you're good about clearing it). Better to turn it off I think.
Thanks for the information. Can the cobblestone problem be helped by slowing down some of the timings? I want the farm to start automatically whenever one of the downstream farms needs bonemeal, so it needs to be relog safe. Right now I use a nether sprout farm but it makes lag (as you said)
I didn't try because I wanted it fast. There are other designs out there for moss farms, but I've not seen one that's fully reload proof. Have you had a look at this: ua-cam.com/video/S280dbGdZP4/v-deo.html
In my testing it was very lag efficient, but I didn't really test for reload proof
@@Eggfur thanks, that's absolutely brilliant
Can i use cobblestone as the solid block?
Yes. Cobblestone is fine
Thanks for the build and video. Does it need to be above the floor by 6 blocks?
Thanks! Not really, though there's a chance that you could accidentally convert some blocks under the farm - unlikely though. I prefer it a bit up to make it easier to prevent mobs getting in
And done! Had a few mishaps but only my own failures to count properly!
What do you think of adding a thief allay to steal some moss away?
After using once or twice my buckets are now getting dispensed and aren't flushing out the moss how can I fix this
You mean they are no longer in the dispensers, or there's water on the platform?
@@Eggfur the buckets themselves dispense empty no water on the platform
@@Eggfur I believe I have it fixed for now but I'm still not sure what happened or why
Double check your timings. If the water is dispensed and one of the pistons comes down, it deleted the water. Then the next time it dispenses the empty bucket. That's why the farm turns off the top pistons when water is being dispensed
@@Eggfur ok thanks I left a comment on another vid but I have a few ideas for videos I'm draining a ocean monument in my world and if there's any way to automate it using flying machines on bedrock that would be nice and there's no ice farms from reliable UA-camrs since ice spawning changed
Thank you for putting in the work for this!
Oof, it took forever! Happy with the outcome though 😀
Good to see another video from you! Keep up the great work on all of your designs and tutorials!
Thank you atomic banana. Sorry that the video ended up being so long, but hopefully it's (one of) the best bone meal farms you can make
@@Eggfur, no worries on the length of the video. You did a good job describing the rates and lag benefits of this farm which eats up time. I've definitely seen others do less with more time.