Giovanna Casolla (Turandot), Piero Giuliacci (Calaf), Aurora Tirotta (Liu), Park Taihwan (Timur), Park Jeong Min (Ping), Pietro Picone (Pang), Francesco Pittari (Pong), Son Jae Hyung (Altoum), Kwon Seo Jung (Un mandarino); Marco Balderi (Conductor). Arts Center, Seoul, October/November 2013.
Piero had no business singing Calaf, he's a beautiful lyric tenor, in my opinion forced to sing heavier repertoire because he's a big guy. Huge mistake, and yes Giovanna is singing flat in the aria and beyond.
Dear Madam, the singer who sing is one of the most important singer of the last 30 years. She sing the role of Turandot from 1995 in every theatres of the world with succesfull and I don't think she is below pitch. Giovanna Casolla sing giving the best of herself donating in each performance of Turandot what Puccini wrote
Daniele, this is a GORGEOUS production which people are overlooking. I love people saying one of the most iconic Turandot's of ALL TIME is somehow not fit for the role! I know you just laugh about this, but I just want to say I love this video and only wish for the last few minutes! Bravo!
Daniele De Plano She has sung this role forever because she can. That is apparently enough. She also sings mezzo roles. One could wish her voice being a little more highly set. She is not totally comfortable on the highest notes as for example Lise Lindstrom, Erika Sunnegårdh or Irene Theorin.
@@draganvidic2039 si ,e molto ...cupa. She's very covered.this conserves & protects ,especially for these roles.Freni did the same thing ,with the position of the mouth.Perhaps ,should be ....a little bit brighter. But ,finally if it helps her emission of the sound. Milanov did the same ,but in the most perfect way ever. (Yesterday ,i was listening to all of her Tabarros.She sang many Giorgettas
30 years can make quite an impact on a voice. This is a good production and worth watching to enjoy it (the dark lighting design does suit the work quite well), but is far from being a great one. Apart from the missing ending (which Puccini didn't compose), my main regret that it's on UA-cam at only 360p - and a poor 360p as well.
She is wonderful! I wish she let the big notes last a bit longer in , In Questa Reggia. She had the power to give them a full sound! The questions were awesome! Her acting is good also!
I remember handing out flyers for the Turandot performances at the Palais theatre, St Kilda in Melbourne back in November 2004. At the time I was a backpacker looking to earn some cash and knew nothing about opera. I was handing out flyers outside Federation square and a posh old lady came up to me and asked who was putting it on. I looked at the front of the flyer and said "Puccini" This lady got really angry and said "he has been dead for nearly 100 years, you are not cultured!" And stormed off. Lesson learned there. I wasn't cultured and I should have had some knowledge about what I was handing out. I still have one of the leaflets! Is there any footage of the 2004 St Kilda performances?
오페라가 되게 어려운 건 줄 알았는데 해설과 여러 도움을 받으면 이렇게 재밌는 것이군. 도움을 주신 분들께 감사드립니다.
1:12:38 3막 '공주는 잠 못 이루고' - 칼라프왕자(T)
Nessus dorma! 아무도 잠들지 마라!
Giovanna Casolla (Turandot), Piero Giuliacci (Calaf), Aurora Tirotta (Liu), Park Taihwan (Timur), Park Jeong Min (Ping), Pietro Picone (Pang), Francesco Pittari (Pong), Son Jae Hyung (Altoum), Kwon Seo Jung (Un mandarino); Marco Balderi (Conductor).
Arts Center, Seoul, October/November 2013.
Piero had no business singing Calaf, he's a beautiful lyric tenor, in my opinion forced to sing heavier repertoire because he's a big guy. Huge mistake, and yes Giovanna is singing flat in the aria and beyond.
@@gayoperadude63 agree!
타임라인
1:16 시작 - 3페이지까지하고
2:53 7페이지 두번째줄로 넘어감
12:32 레터21 브릿지(악보에없음)
24:02 레터 42 Signore ascolta
26:19 레터43 Non piangere Liu (~133p첫번째 박자까지하고 29:39 합창들리는부분으로 넘어감 (138p 2번째 박자로)
50:11 레터 42 (합창없음)
1:01:15 레터 60 (p258~p264 두번째마디까지)
1:10:09 act3 한페이지만하고
1:12:33 p290의 밑에줄 두번째마디로
1:21:40 p330 4번째마디 픽업
1:40:32 p329 한페이지하고
와! 고대하던 투란도트를 드디어 보네요. 고맙습니다. 무엇을 얻든 대가는 치루는 법. 더구나 사랑에서랴!
네순도르마 정말 감동적입니다.. 하루에 한번씩은 꼭 듣는 것 같네요. 최고입니다.
Struck awe by Turandot, love Liu. This is the most lovely Liu I have seen.
Fine Production but watch Katia Riccarelli
It will never be forgotten.
CR and Opera? Hmmm 😂
Grazie per il elenco
Dear Madam, the singer who sing is one of the most important singer of the last 30 years. She sing the role of Turandot from 1995 in every theatres of the world with succesfull and I don't think she is below pitch. Giovanna Casolla sing giving the best of herself donating in each performance of Turandot what Puccini wrote
Daniele, this is a GORGEOUS production which people are overlooking. I love people saying one of the most iconic Turandot's of ALL TIME is somehow not fit for the role! I know you just laugh about this, but I just want to say I love this video and only wish for the last few minutes! Bravo!
Daniele De Plano She has sung this role forever because she can. That is apparently enough. She also sings mezzo roles. One could wish her voice being a little more highly set. She is not totally comfortable on the highest notes as for example Lise Lindstrom, Erika Sunnegårdh or Irene Theorin.
@@draganvidic2039 si ,e molto ...cupa.
She's very covered.this conserves & protects ,especially for these roles.Freni did the same thing ,with the position of the mouth.Perhaps ,should be ....a little bit brighter.
But ,finally if it helps her emission of the sound.
Milanov did the same ,but in the most perfect way ever.
(Yesterday ,i was listening to all of her Tabarros.She sang many Giorgettas
30 years can make quite an impact on a voice. This is a good production and worth watching to enjoy it (the dark lighting design does suit the work quite well), but is far from being a great one. Apart from the missing ending (which Puccini didn't compose), my main regret that it's on UA-cam at only 360p - and a poor 360p as well.
Dragan Vidic That bad? Too old etc. Arnold Bourbon Amaral
멋져요~ 감사합니다
50:10 투란도트 공주 테마
I costumi sono spettacolari e molto teatrali !!
Fantastic!
4:51 류 아리아
11:30 모리화 동기
26:33 울지마라 류
어째 설정상 절세미인이라는 투란도트 맡은 사람보다 칼리프왕자 하녀인 류 맡은 사람이 더 예뻐보인다.....
Wonderful performances. Too bad you missed the ending, I'm sorry.
Belíssima orquestração. Simplesmente emocionante.
1:12:45
Thanks bro.
샘 해밍턴이 살짝 보인...
MARAVILLOSOS
She is wonderful! I wish she let the big notes last a bit longer in , In Questa Reggia. She had the power to give them a full sound! The questions were awesome! Her acting is good also!
Agree. Maybe she is aged or she is tired.
I remember handing out flyers for the Turandot performances at the Palais theatre, St Kilda in Melbourne back in November 2004. At the time I was a backpacker looking to earn some cash and knew nothing about opera. I was handing out flyers outside Federation square and a posh old lady came up to me and asked who was putting it on. I looked at the front of the flyer and said "Puccini" This lady got really angry and said "he has been dead for nearly 100 years, you are not cultured!" And stormed off. Lesson learned there. I wasn't cultured and I should have had some knowledge about what I was handing out. I still have one of the leaflets! Is there any footage of the 2004 St Kilda performances?
You are forgiven
56:32 - 1:02:33 스핑크스도 수수께끼 1개만 냈는데, 3개는 너무 많잖아?!
the bbest is the chorus
... and the dancers
NO END. :-(
And why cut the finale of the opera? Boo
49:23
11:32
Wait what? Corea?
Act.1 1:15-31:13
Act.2 31:18 - 1:10:07
sn -2:58
4:55
6:10
8:05
Tri- 21:37
cut -7:05- 7:50
cut- 34:23-37:35
22:07
중요 28:27
류의 죽음 장면은 푸치니 자신의 레퀴엠...
얼마후 별세했지.
Marco is my best friend...
네순도르마만 듣다가 무슨내용의 오페라인지 궁금해서 보러옴 기대된당
스토리는 개막장이긴함 ㅋㅋ
@@세계3대이즈리얼 하긴..;
31:38 it has a weird rythm, different
AQ végső hangokat miért törölték ?
Does the tenor have to hook EVERY HIGH NOTE? And then still sing it flat???
30:21
1:02:28
1:05:20
1:08:11
i wish the lighting wasn't so dark.
오페라1년동안한번도본적없네요
역시 투란도트는 배역들이 동양인들이 잘 어울려
애초에 배경 자체가 중국이다 보니까
ㅇㅈ 투란도트는 동양인이 했으면
@@이하연-o9k 배역에 맞는 강렬한 스핀토나 드라마티코가 동양은 물론이거니와 서양에서도 흔치 않으니까요. 비르기트 닐슨이나 예전에 프랑코 제퍼렐리가 연출하고 제임스 레바인이 지휘한 메트로폴리탄 공연실황에서의 에바 마톤의 투란도트는 참으로 강렬했었던 투란도트였던 것으로 기억합니다.
Liu : szuper .
와우 권서경씨! 반갑네요 ㅎㅎ
Quando sei italiano e capisci tutto🇮🇹😂
Verissimo🤣🤣🇮🇹
아무도 잠들지 말라! 그의 이름을 알아내기 전 까진!
40:00
😂😂😂😂😂
이거솔직히
귀에 들어갔다가 나옴
2:19, GOSH I lol'd
투란도트만 보면 조반나 카솔라만나오네ㄷㄷ
푸치니 정말 천재다. 그러나 여기서 투란도트 공주는 돌싱 왕비? 너무 나이가 많다. 칼라프왕자도 돌싱 옥황상제같다. 둘이 서로 인물좀 있고 젊엇다면 정말 몰입 됐을것같네요^^
she hier is 68 anni wawwwwwwwwwww fatastic!!!!!!!!!!!! Giovanna Casolla !
그리고 몇일후에 나투란도트 하는뎁....
어린이 합창단에 내가있네
웃기네요 ㅋㅋ
저는 햇살 나무 중창단 이요
류만 보이네....ㅠㅠ
나의 이름은 칼라프입니다
으아닛 서경씨 여기서 뭐하세요????
위례중 ㅎㅇㅌ
that children chorus is not good.😥 It's不会看了。
Off with their heads !
Sure but still very cute.
Of course not. They're just children. 😂
She repeatedly sings below pitch in Questa Reggia. Ouch. Seems a terrific struggle. Wrong role.
Actually, she's just nearly 70 which is quite old for this role. She was one of the great Turandots.
Silfredo Serrano 🍷🙏🍷👴😱😨 that explains it my friend. That's called sadness. Arnold Bourbon Amaral
아니 아름답다던 공주가 뭐 저리 생겼냐? 류가 훨씬 예쁘구먼 역할 바꿔라
이게 별로인건 나뿐인가 ㅠㅠ 메트로폴리탄이 백배나은듯 ㅠㅠ 칼라프 시러 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
엄청난 남혐주의자 투란도트 공주께서 왕자들 죽이다가 임자 만난 스토리 ㅎㅎ
탐켄치
ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋ
칼라프가 너무 뚱뚱해서 놀람 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ
painful
Gyenge
아들이 아부지. 아니 할아버지 같은데... 집중이 되지 않습니다.
😂😂😂😂 Ma è uno scherzo 😅😅😅
そもそもこのテノールはピッチが悪いな
갑.툭.아.노
갑자기. 툭.아는.노래 나옴
어?갑자기 이노래가 나오넴ㅋㅋ
연출 최악.. 칼라프 최악.
?
댓글 최악 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
한국에서 이 정도면 감지덕지 해야죠. 확실히 유럽이나 미국을 따라갈 순 없지만
공주와 왕자는 좀 젊은 가수로 배역을 해야지....
늙은 공주와 왕자가 잘 어울리지 않는다....
She can't do it properly anymore.
One of the worst Turandot performances I ever heard...
Vasile Chisiu That bad? Arnold Bourbon Amaral
50:08
26:16
10:40
1:23:10
1:06:50
1:06:01
1:34:40
1:34:40
1:10:15
1:12:44