Bosch vs Purflux vs Starline - Oil Filter Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лип 2024
- In this episode we'll compare two well-known filter brands with a budget brand, to see just how much better are expensive products.
Patreon: www.patreon.com/user?alert=2
In this episode we'll test some oil filters:
Bosch P9192
Purflux L267D
Starline SF OF0045
Facebook:
/ sergiu.gabor.youtube
Instagram:
/ sergiu.gabor
Twitter:
/ gabor_sergiu
Patreon:
www.patreon.com/user?u=26494467
My email:
sergiu.gabor.yt@gmail.com
Don't forget to leave you comments below.
If you liked my videos, consider subscribing - Авто та транспорт
Thank you so much for this valuable review of some of the most common oil filters. It narrowed my choices down, since the speed of the oil flow matters to me.
Super video! Am ramas uimit de acuratetea si profesionalismul testelor. Felicitari!
Nice testing, way better than a lot of other oil filtertests
I'm new to this channel but I like the way you compare filters it's very friendly and nicely explained. You're now in my subscription list ;)
Wonderful way to test filters, amazing effort, thank you!
You have great videos, really enjoy your comparisons and how you branch out to all kinds of oil, even if we dont see them in the USA.
Salut, felicitari pentru modul de testare si video-uri. Sper sa vad in viitor si genul asta de teste pe filtrele de carburant. Doar o sugestie :)
I am a simple man. I see new video from Sergiu I hit like :))
Hiya! Thank you for the marvellous videos. You're probably the only person I know that has taken a more scientific approach the examination of oil filters, which is just fantastic. I'm just wondering would you ever do a video comparing this aftermarket ones to the OEM filters like you've done for oil?
Hi Rory and thanks for your appreciation! Actually, I'm filming that video right now. Should be ready next week. You can check out my social pages if you'd like to know what I'm working on for future videos.
Would love to see Hengst & Filtron added to the next oil filter test.
Hengst from what I know are good but I've used filtron oil filter and they are bad and not that cheap
Inc I’ve seen some reviews suggesting filtron are pretty good
@@froggy0162 filtron and wix
Made by Mann Hummel (Poland)
Awesome, insightful and helpful video. Thank you.
Thank you so much… Great video series… oil filter, air filter, motor filter… All the best from Germany
Ideal si mai concret era sa instalezi un al doilea filtru dupa cel principal ca sa ne putem da seama cate particule scapa primul filtru si cat de eficient este. Nu ar fi rau sa reiei acest test, promit ca fac cinste cu 2 filtre Purflux. Baftă in tot ceea ce faci!
Please test fuel filters!
Mann VS Hengst VS Mahle/Knecht VS Purflux VS Bosch
Thanks a lot
Thanks for the video and for doing this.
Felicitari ptr munca depusa.
Good testing. Very informative. New subscriber in the USA. I haven't seen the Purflux or Starlines here.
Wow great test!!!!
Like from Poland 🇵🇱
Foarte binevenit testul tau. Eu am folosit mult timp Mahle si knecht, dar pretul lor a crescut nejustificat in ultimul timp. As subscrie si eu altor cereri, daca in testul pentru filtre ar aparea si Champion, febi, filtron, blue print. Sunt filtre mai ieftine, dar poate ca au un comportament apropiat de cele premium, astfel ca putem avea o imagine completa a marcilor preponderente in piata filtrelor auto din Romania. Apreciez si salut efortul depus, obiectivitatea si generozitate in publicarea acestor teste.
Mulțumesc pentru apreciere. Ma bucur ca vă ajută si o sa mai urmeze si alte branduri.
Great job! I 100% agree with you on preconceptions, a lot of people just repeat stupidly what they hear with no scientific evidence.
I've just mounted Purflux L267 today :)
Super,
Ținând cont că în țara noastră carburanții sunt cam vai steaua lor, era interesant de văzut și un test pentru filtrele de motorina
Very very good job!!! Thanks a lot.
Genial testul tau! Am folosit mult timp filtre starline și au fost ok. Pentru prețul cerut , calitatea e foarte buna. Încearcă te rog dacă poți și filtre champion sau henghst.
super tare testul cu microscopul
Felicitari pentru munca depusa.
Super test, ca de obicei. Te rog din nou dacă ai cum sa prinzi în testele tale filtrele de la Nipparts, pt ca sunt cele mai ieftine la toate japonezele cât și la koreene. Avem 2 mașini în familie la care folosim filtrele astea, și as vrea sa știu dacă ar fi mai bine să le evit. Mulțumesc și spor în continuare.
Felicitări pentru video!!!
Eu oricum foloseam filtre Purflux și Mahle (knecht), dar acum am și dovada sa le arăt și prietenilor mei!
Succes în continuare!
Bravo !
Poate reușești sa faci și niște teste de viteză a încărcării in circuitul de ulei, inclusiv a trecerii prin filtru, a uleiurilor de diferite vâscozitati la rece. Folosind sistemul de pompare, dintr o baie de ulei ( nu sa fie prin cădere din sticla aceea, către pompă).
Always use thermal couple to measure temperature. Actually use at least 2 at different locations. Heating ovens are very inaccurate and the temperature inside is not the same at the different points. If possible - use a fan inside the oven. How many tests I had ruined by bad ovens...
You should use only ferrous metal particles and use magnet to check what is left in the oil after the test.
Also, the surface area and the flow rate are probably connected somehow to form the overall flowrate of the filter. If you run the pump for 200l and check the required time you will see that function. And probably the lower flowrate results for MANN from your test are not bad because of the bigger surface area.
Keep the good videos coming!
Is it possible to add in that table the Mahle, Valeo, and Japanparts results? Great video.
Loved the test!
Today I bought the filters for my car, and this video series was crucial in my decision: I went with Purflux.
Can you make a video comparing the following brands:
Meyle vs. Purflux vs. Bosch vs. Mann-Filter vs. Mahle
Meyle is the OEM of many filters for car manufacturers.
Purflux, in my opinion, is second best.
Bosch is good - but it sources their filters from other OEMs.
Mann-Filter sells many filters in Europe.
Mahle is best-known for other parts, but filters are available.
Cheers from Portugal!
Se poate și la filtre Delphi ? Se recomanda filtre de combustibil Delphi de la diverse persoane care recondiționează pompe de injecție.
Felicitări pentru munca depusa.
Acest material de 15 minute cit înseamnă că timp real de muncă în laborator?
I would love to see WIX vs. Bosch vs. VIC vs. Mann+Hummel comparisons.
nice job, fella!;)
Verry good job but what is the best ? Thank's
I used to put bosch filter for my vw touareg,,after this test for the hot weather same here in kuwait 🔥🔥i am going to replace it with mann filter 😅😅
Daca mai pui un filtru dupa filtrul care il testezi, poti sa vezi cate particule trec de filtru
Now I know why I have seen some OEM filters for Ferrari being purflux.
Poti sa imi spui unde gasedc sa cumpar filtrele purflux , dar cele cu materialul filtrant in zig zag ?
Ai putea să faci niste teste cu filtre de combustibil de tipul PU 936/2 , am avut multe neplăceri cu unele marci de filtre la capitolul rezistenta si cote de fabricatie mai mici sau mai mari se intepeneau si nu mai puteam să le scot decât prin distrugere sau erau mai largi cu 0,1,2mm si nu se amorsau .
Iti cer o mica lamurire vis-a-vis de o informatie data in video: Mahle si Knecht sunt aceeasi firma, adica is filtrele identice? Caci pe site-urile de profil(nu dau nume dar sunt cele uzuale), pentru masina mea, le-am gasit pe amble la vanzare.. si nu doar ca le difera pretul(cu un leu ce-i drept), dar si arata diferit in poza(care-i posibil sa nu fie cea reala).
Felicitări Sergiu încă o dată! Prin testul tău ai demonstrat ceea ce spun specialiștii, nu mai sunt filtre proaste pe piață! Pentru cineva care schimbă uleiul la 10000 km un filtru Starline poate fi o opțiune economică fără impact negativ asupra fiabilității motorului. Eu personal folosesc mai mult filtre Bosch deoarece am posibilitatea de a le cumpăra mai ieftin, mașina s-a comportat absolut la fel ca atunci când am folosit filtre Mann sau Mahle, fie diferențele sunt nesemnificative și fără impact, fie se vor manifesta la un kilometraj la care mașina va fi dată deja la casat.
Pe AliExpress (China), un filtru echivalent cu codul Mann, costă aproximativ 30lei ($6.80). Comand unul sa vad cum este.
@@SergiuGabor Bună idee. La un Vw în reprezentanță au folosit filtre Ufi made în China și Tunisia, le-am analizat până a catadicsit mecanicul să se apuce de treabă și am putut compara filtrul de aer cu unul Mann aflat în portbagaj. Îți spun sincer că Ufi era mai bine finisat decât Mann iar pâsla ce-l acoperea la Mann era mai scurtă și se trăgea într-o parte. Nu m-ar mira ca chinezii să ofere o surpriză, sper eu, plăcută.
UFI si SOFIMA sunt cam acelasi brand si vin in prima echipare, sau veneau la un moment dat, pe Ford Focus. Am schimbat si eu vreo 3 filtre de asatea si scria pe ele "made in China".
@@DanielluBc Sofima aparține lui Ufi, Filtron aparține lui Mann iar exemple sunt destule...ce să-i faci? Globalizarea. Am luat ultima dată Hengst la promoție și erau toate made în China. Dacă nu ar fi avut hârtia galben specific, plasticul puteai jura că e de la Ufi/Sofima.
Salut, nu prea am înțeles decizia finala care este cel mai bun? Knecht sau Bosch? Merci mult.
Wouldn't the filter with the thickest media keep the by pass valve open longer when the engine is cold...a better experiment would be to see how well cold oil flows through the filter and how long the by pass valve is open
Just bought a bosch filter and this one is made in france and it has the same zigzag shape as the purflux (french made). Coincidence?
Ar trebui să încerci și niște filtre full synthetic ca Wix XP sau Royal Purple (cred că e făcut de Champion) dacă sunt de cumpărat in România toate astea probabil folosesc media similară cu Donaldson Synteq XP.
Eu la filtru de ulei pun un mahnet pe filtru pt a retine spanu in filtru
I was waiting u to put a magnet after each filtration test say about 10 minutes of filtration and check for stuck iron powder . Play with the filtration duration too
So at the final, which filter is the best for cars with 10w60 oil?
I watched your other video, but in the other video you used 10w30.
Salut Sergiu
Te rog poți să îmi recomanzi cel mai bun filtru de ulei din perspectiva și experienta ta.
Am văzut toate videoclipurile despre filtre de ulei,dar inca nu sunt hotărât ce sa folosesc pt masina mea...mulțumesc și o zi frumoasa
j'utilise toujours Bosch et je n'ai jamais eu de problème avec la marque Bosch , cependant le filtre knecht a retenu toute mon attention !!!! ( je vidange ma voiture chaque 5000km ou 6 mois maximum ) ce n'est pas pour le prix d'un bidon d'huile et d'un filtre a huile que je vais me plaindre , mais je veux le meilleur car un véhicule coûte cher et car je suis perfectionniste , ce test était excellent et bien que j'ai confiance en Bosch depuis des années knecht a retenu toute mon attention
so for my family runaround deisel, a purflux filter with a synthetic oil should last a year between services? doing at most 3k miles a year?
Filtru Ulei pt 2l TDI Seat purflux sau mahle?
7:00 u put 2x more man filter = it burn less ... but good test 😃 purflux is the best
Starline is a LKQ product, probably made by Sędziszów Poland (same fonts)
Few days ago I was in a meeting in LKQ and they admitted the Starline filters are made in Poland by MANN+Hummel (Filtron) in Gostyń
They're "OE Quality" and produce OEM OE OES for several European brands, their brands are: Filtron, MANN, Hummel, WIX
Felicitari...in sfarsit putem sa urmarim si noi teste sa le intelegem...numai de la rusi sau polonezi fara traducere :( LIKE
Do you think brands use the same media for al the oil filters? I use verry thick oil in my cars 15w40, so i want the highest flow speed. But my cars use screw on filters. Not cartridge. I professionaly use purflux. But personally i use mann. But seeing this test i think i go back to purflux.
Next Hengst filters?
What the best oil filter
Esti beton. Multumim
Mulțumesc si eu!
Eu folosesc doar purflux
I was buying Purflux for years. It was original for Citroen / Peugeot and i often bought it for my other cars. But now times changed. Price went down by 3-4€ and suddenly on the box is no more Made in France.. its China. I quit with this manufacturer, if i want chinese filters i can get them way cheaper than 8€/piece. Im talking about my recent Purflux L442 filter for 3.0 HDi. So very nice test.. but the products and quality changes. I had similar experience with Lemforder, they were made in Slovakia.. now Malaysia or Spain, and they dont fit my car anymore. The dust cap breaks after instalation because of bad desing.
what the best?
Any measurements of particle size not filtered would be relevant.
Wait what, Purflux you had here was actually genuine VW/Audi filter? I am well aware that aftermarket and the one you can get from the dealer are the one and the same, but don't they usually remove all the logos from the aftermarket ones? And Bosch filters aren't always made in Germany, my cousin has Alfa Romeo and he always buys Bosch filters, and every single one of them was made in South Africa, however ones i get for my VW Jetta are indeed made in Germany. And i have to say there's no difference in quality no matter where they came from, at least not that i know of. Well, Bosch, Mann, Purflux, Mahle.. Can't go wrong, they were all, or still are, OE suppliers for VAG, BMW, Mercedes..
Knecht is the same as Mahle ?
Yes
Have you ever tested whether it's really worth it to purchase a Dooxi oil filter? I saw that the purchase page in the video should be this one：dooxi.com
I just clicked on their advertisement, and I was curious about that！
interesant... :)
Felicitări pentru clip, scrisul ar trebui puțin mai îngroșat, m-am chiorit puțin, altfel totul ok
Using purflux as standard in all my cars for years
Faci o treaba buna
starline is autokelly brand... with different manufactory same piece...
Purflux the best
who win ?
Knecht
Nice video, but the filter test can be more accurate if you measure the exact amount of powder added and then, after the run, examine whether the filtered oil is clean using a laboratory test.
Dont lose your time : technology filter paper of Purflux offer 42 % more area to filter anything.
It's the lonely filter beyond 30 or 40 other filters that can deliver this filter capacity and so it can be smaller than other and easier to install on a motor..
If you find FRAM filters, they use same tech.
De unde sti ca acel fitru a fost fabriacat intr-o anumita tara? Informatiile de pe pachet indica ultimul proces major de fabricatie , ambalarea .Un filtru a fost ambalat in Germania ,unul in Franta unul undeva ('comisia nu da numele vaporului') .
Daca suprafata de filtrare e mai mare atunci filtrul retine mai bine particulele ... pe viitor voi pune pe OM660 (799cmc) filtrul de ulei de 8-710G3 (92800cmc) ca atunci fitreaza retine foarte foarte binne particulele ,adica practic toate particulele .
Testul de filtrare e ambiguu pt primul filtru deoarece instalatia de testare nu a fost rodata . Timpii de testare nu sunt identici , rezulta ca nici cantitatea de ulei filtrata nu e identica dar se face comparatie . Pe bune?
Pacat de munca.
Purflux fleece is the best
Purflux sa fie? Filtrare grozava, suprafata mare de filtrare si grosime element filtrare relativ ok, nu?
Purflux sau Knecht. In opinia mea, sunt cele mai bune.
@@SergiuGabor , toate filtrele Mahle? Aer, combustibil, ulei, polen? Toate modele sunt cele mai bune? Sau doar anumite modele?
Eu pe masina mea (Ford) folosesc filtre originale (FORD sau PSA) pentru că sunt mai ieftine decăt mahle sau mann 😁.
Însă am studiat filtre stocker și filtron și sunt ok ca și construcție. Dacă ești din București îți pot arăta ce zic. 😊
Tx super
Knecht is the best
2:37 Volkswagen and Audi on this filter part LMAO
yes, purflux was original equipment for some versions of TDI engines
Unfortunately this test is nearly nothing.
The most iportant data of an oil or any kind of filter is the diameters of the microholes on the filter material. So the main function for the filter is to filt a bigger parts AND this parameter is nowhere in the test.
Sorry for my comment, but the most important data is still missing.
HENGST vs mahle vs knecht
Deci Purflux e nr 1 sau ma insel eu ?
Nu as putea spune ca e nr.1, mai degrabă cred ca e la egalitate cu Knecht pentru prima poziție.
@@SergiuGabor mai convins cu testele astea si am comandat Knecht toate filtrele :) impreuna cu uleiul Motul 8100 Xlean FE sper sa fie o gustarica buna pentru Peugeot-ul 508 al meu :))) ! mai asteptam video-uri de genul :)
Your tests are amazing. What happend to the channel, you stopped releasing videos?
Take it easy, Sergio is busy 😅
only Knecht/Mahle and Mann Filter
BUT THE FASTER IS FLOW-THE WORSE IS FILTRATION. ELEMENTRY PHYSICS. Wholes bigger so this means filtering is worse Also the better the flow -the worse performance in filtering later because of paper wholes will expand and will be torn to be bigger and bigger.
Until it gets worse you should already have made an oil change!
The two best filters are;
Mann made in Germany and Mahle made in Austria.
two best 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mahle is not Made in Austria anymore. Sadly they make them in China now.
fyi starline is made in bangladesh
Maybe you can test SCT Filters also. It is quite cheap in Germany and SCT is known as manufactor of Mannol Oils
SCT filter's not good!
Don't bye
Only Mann Hummel, Mahle, Knecht, Hengst, Bosch and Purflux!
Mannol Is good oil!
Ende
I rather use bosch most trusted brand
in the past Bosch had a good name, now they are all made crapp.
Purlflux is much higher quality made.
Bosch the best
Deci cel mai bun e Mahle .
E pt englezi clipul, nu? Sa se uite englezi!
Englejii
i dont like eastern soviet accents
Please make a video on mahle vs knecht vs hengest oil filter