The first one is raw emotion and nostalgic with hope in the future. The second one is filled with conviction because of past experience. They are both lovely
How can she be nostalgic and with hope for the future? That doesn't really make sense considering when the first performance takes place. Right? Explain?
man that 09 performance is just raaaaw, even though it was for a movie and technically “acting” it just has an incredibly real energy. nice that she’s embracing her old discography again, these songs are very nostalgic to many younger adults these days who are going through it, trying to find jobs etc. after a pandemic and mid a variety of crises. These performances really cheer us up- at least it dod for me 😊
I love how she’s not forcing strain on her vocals. Both seem effortless but the “New” Miley, post vocal cord surgery, still executes her notes within her comfort range without the strain & you can tell she is a seasoned professional. I’m sincerely happy for her. She’s doing better than ever & looks amazing. You can tell it’s the same singer, but a different tone yet it’s always right on point. She’s a living legend like her God mother & her sister is up & coming! Wishing them all the best in life & continued successful careers ❤
She’s only straining her voice at the end of the top video when she sings “wah hey yeahhh”. She was very much singing from her diaphragm, in the bottom video it’s just more chest voice.
@@blckbunbc i don’t think she can sing high that comfortably anymore bc of vocal damage and surgery and overall growing up. Bc woman’s voices also do get deeper as they age
we sure did!!! her vocals though!!! She is an inspiration I cant wait until she becomes a mother one day and show her children how much of an inspiration she is this song helped me get through 4 back surgeries and a deadly infection! This song motivated me!! God bless such talented artist she would be a great gospel singer!!
You can see that her voice has become deeper over the years too, and that's natural... (I love the bass performance), maybe the first one is better, it was right when she really debuted the song!
dunno. she looks like she got star fever. Now her song just sounds like she has no feelings anymore and all she cares about is how her ass looks while she's bending over and if her hair is messed up.
14 years later and still one of her best!! Love Miley! She went through all the stages of life and learnt along the way. Situations that were very public, sometimes very scrutinized but she became such a beautiful women inside out.
Nostalgia at its finest. I remember growing up watching Miley, demi , raven , Jamie lynn spears , the Jonas Brothers, the Sprouse twins and selena on the Disney Channel. She is beautiful and amazingly talented. ❤
@disappointment3090Exactly. Miley has a heavy southern accent that she hides to fit the "pop genre". During her Disney days the accent would make bold appearances on her show. This song itself is country pop, so it still falls within the genre. You can't accept every country song to sound like Carrie Underwood or Luke Bryan y'all. And I was talking specifically about Miley's twang, her enunciation.
Dude I was just thinking that! Like first "does being blonde ever make her feel like Hannah?" Then "does she have both colors because she feels like miley and Hannah!?"
I remember bawling my eyes out to this song at a very young age. My dad didn't understand until I told him about being bullied and how I eventually got over that mountain. I was 9 or 10 and I just started middle school when I was being bullied. This song will still have that much meaning to m.
Sorry you had to go through that, I was bullied myself but this song doesn't have meaning to me but it has meaning to somebody I know who used to be a close friend (we nearly dated but I wasn't over my ex so it wasn't to be), her friend died aged just 25 some years ago and she has sang it at a couple of social clubs we both go to in memory of her friend but it upsets her when she sings it.
I vividly remember her performing this at the Grammy’s (or VMA’s? Sorry) with an orchestra and just CRYING. It resonated so much then and does even more now❤
This song always gives me chills. I remember going to see the Hannah Montana movie with my mom when it came out, and she was not excited cus she thought the show was annoying lol. By the end though, she was sobbing when Miley sang this, and loved the movie so much we bought it when it came out on dvd, and watched it over and over. This woman and her music will always have a special place in my heart. ❤
She has really helped open my eyes to not judging people so much. You never know what they are going through and why they do what they do. Helped me focus more on my own actions and why I do them.
I'm proud of her! ❤ This 2024, she was honored by Disney as the Disney's Youngest Legend. She did made a big impact for kids. She never gave up on her dreams until she got it and kept working on it❤
I’m so happy people are giving her the credit she deserves. She’s always been so talented. She’s allowed to be herself and she’s progressed into a great beautiful bean 🥹👏🏼
As a Granna watching z Hannah Montana with my granddaughter, I’ve been pulling for Miley since day one! I loved her then and I love her now. I was worried about her for a while , but she is in a much better head space now! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@Liv2Pnt She said it was the stress from losing her Malibu home in the Californian fires and she had Reinke's endema hence the vocal cord surgery.Yeah her voice changed but she had to do intense vocal training too!
Y’all she smoked her fucking lungs out taking bong hits day and night…that’s why she sounds like someone who’s smoked a pack of cigarettes a day for 40 years 😂
At my kindergarten graduation, they had my entire class sing this song. We practiced it for weeks. I haven't really heard it since until now. It brings back so many feelings and memories.
It's so cool to see how her skills matured. She's not so concerned about hitting everything perfectly in the center of the pitch with flawless breath control and even power - she has much better control of tone color and command of breath. This performance was worlds more interesting and captivating.
How beautiful it is to see Miley's growth and grow together over these years. I had no idea this song was from 2009, in my head it was just a few years ago. This song is wonderful and it's great to hear it again and resignify it. ❤
“in 2019 she had to undergo surgery due to Reinke’s edema, a condition that causes vocal cords to swell with a build-up of gelatinous fluid, oftentimes caused by excessive and long-term smoking”. Her voice, singing and speaking, is lower now but still fabulous. She is great!
2009= innocence, hope and faith
2023= experience, wisdom and self worth
😂😂😂
Perfectly said. I thought the same.
Exactly 😊
wisdom and self worth.. lmao.. joke of the year
Lots of drugs as well
The first one is raw emotion and nostalgic with hope in the future. The second one is filled with conviction because of past experience. They are both lovely
How can she be nostalgic and with hope for the future? That doesn't really make sense considering when the first performance takes place. Right? Explain?
Наверное поэтому от первой версии становится на душе тепло, а от второй сжимается сердце и текут слезы
man that 09 performance is just raaaaw, even though it was for a movie and technically “acting” it just has an incredibly real energy. nice that she’s embracing her old discography again, these songs are very nostalgic to many younger adults these days who are going through it, trying to find jobs etc. after a pandemic and mid a variety of crises. These performances really cheer us up- at least it dod for me 😊
It dod for me too🥰
It's my PRECIOUS favourite from all of her songs...
Omg I loved this song so much that it lives rent free when someone mentions Hannah Montana ❤
@@munygulyamova4253 😅 noooo now I can never fix my typo
❤
I love how she’s not forcing strain on her vocals. Both seem effortless but the “New” Miley, post vocal cord surgery, still executes her notes within her comfort range without the strain & you can tell she is a seasoned professional. I’m sincerely happy for her. She’s doing better than ever & looks amazing. You can tell it’s the same singer, but a different tone yet it’s always right on point. She’s a living legend like her God mother & her sister is up & coming! Wishing them all the best in life & continued successful careers ❤
She’s only straining her voice at the end of the top video when she sings “wah hey yeahhh”. She was very much singing from her diaphragm, in the bottom video it’s just more chest voice.
miley is incredibly professional
Trace Cyrus is their older brother he was in the band metro station and he's still making music
@@blckbunbc i don’t think she can sing high that comfortably anymore bc of vocal damage and surgery and overall growing up. Bc woman’s voices also do get deeper as they age
@@lunarialoonatic dont know what you said before but I agree with this comment
No matter how old us 2000s kids are, Miley voice is still powerful and her song still touch our hearts 😭🌸
And they forever will
I’m a 90s kid, and even this song gets me.
90s kid and this songs hits. Either when I play it on guitar with someone covering it or just hearing Miley
We simply grew up with her.
we sure did!!! her vocals though!!! She is an inspiration I cant wait until she becomes a mother one day and show her children how much of an inspiration she is this song helped me get through 4 back surgeries and a deadly infection! This song motivated me!! God bless such talented artist she would be a great gospel singer!!
yepp
Well we couldn't grow against her ! now could we ? 😂
Nah she helped raise us!!!
@@TayTaeM yessss!!!!🙏🙏🙏🙏💜
You can feel the words really mean so much more to her now as she's gotten older 🥺
She really has grown
"Chops" in these years. There's a genuine, rich tone you only get with age.
Lol yeah her very hard climb to the top of the industry. Totally self made. Not like dolly parton's her god mother or something
@@kristingallo2158//whoooooosh
@@SpaceandGoats I think her voice sucked then and it's worse now.
I don't get that.. I feel she had more emotion in the original
I saw her live, and let me tell you that singing THIS song live broke all of us, there was singing and crying and screaming, and she was INSANE
Miley's growth in her music is truly inspiring. Her voice has evolved beautifully over the years.
She moves like Dolly Parton on stage now and I absolutely love it auntie taught her well
Dolly Parton is not her Aunt.
Dolly is her Godmother
@@Caleb_Mandrake872
Auntie doesn't necessarily mean aunt. It's actually used to address an older lady who you know pretty well.
That first chair violin GETTING it tho
Best part of the performance 😅
as a violin player, that was wayyy too little space to properly play it
It was beautiful to watch ❤
she saw her moment and took it!
Haha I was like girl chill. 😂😂😂
the way she was born to be a star... that voice AS A KID was and still is her same .. just different tones! She's an incredible vocalist
A wonderful vocalist indeed
miley is the best female vocalist of this generation
You can see that her voice has become deeper over the years too, and that's natural... (I love the bass performance), maybe the first one is better, it was right when she really debuted the song!
She was excellent and became a goddess, vocal-wise.
@@AndreMarques_k7it's also due to the vocal chord surgery she needed, especially with the smoke damage when her house burned down
2009 - her trying to believe, 2023 - her knowing and accepting the truth of the words
now that you mentioned it i feel so sad, happy and grateful for her
dunno. she looks like she got star fever.
Now her song just sounds like she has no feelings anymore and all she cares about is how her ass looks while she's bending over and if her hair is messed up.
Damn just like me in 2009
omg🥹
this comment is key
I'm always in tears when I listen to 'The Climb'. What a godly woman! 😭💓
"Godly"? 🤔
This song still gives me Goosebumps!!.. literally grew up with her songs,really happy for her❤
I cried through the whole performance
SAME
Why?
171717171717171717171717171771177
😂😂😂😂
almost cried as well, this brings me back so many memories
14 years later and still one of her best!! Love Miley! She went through all the stages of life and learnt along the way. Situations that were very public, sometimes very scrutinized but she became such a beautiful women inside out.
She has the same look in her eyes. The same joy. ♥️🥺
I was a teenager back then too and these kind of Songs are so so nostalgic to be 😢😢😢 i really loved Mileys voice. Very beautiful then and now
Nostalgia at its finest. I remember growing up watching Miley, demi , raven , Jamie lynn spears , the Jonas Brothers, the Sprouse twins and selena on the Disney Channel. She is beautiful and amazingly talented. ❤
*The twang is,* *was and forever will be*
*C O U N T R Y✨*
If that's country for you, please stay away from the keyboard.
@Disappointment true Reba is from Oklahoma but has a different accent than myself who grew up 40 mins away from her home town.
@@patrickalbrecht2385wanna get your balls kicked, Patrick?
@disappointment3090Exactly. Miley has a heavy southern accent that she hides to fit the "pop genre". During her Disney days the accent would make bold appearances on her show. This song itself is country pop, so it still falls within the genre. You can't accept every country song to sound like Carrie Underwood or Luke Bryan y'all. And I was talking specifically about Miley's twang, her enunciation.
I like that her hair in 2023 is both blonde and brunette. It's like she accepted her double life as miley and hannah.
😂😂😂
No 😂 it’s a thing she got from Debbie Harry 😂
She's just Miley, because that's her name, Hannah was a job...
Dude I was just thinking that! Like first "does being blonde ever make her feel like Hannah?" Then "does she have both colors because she feels like miley and Hannah!?"
She got the best of both worlds 😅
This song hits differently that we are all in the adulting stage ❤
She is so much more now. Refined, Mature, and Beautiful!
She used to be so beautiful. It must be a clone
I never get tired of this song!! It's completely amazing! and how she sings, is just awesome! Love Miley!
I remember bawling my eyes out to this song at a very young age. My dad didn't understand until I told him about being bullied and how I eventually got over that mountain. I was 9 or 10 and I just started middle school when I was being bullied. This song will still have that much meaning to m.
Sorry you had to go through that, I was bullied myself but this song doesn't have meaning to me but it has meaning to somebody I know who used to be a close friend (we nearly dated but I wasn't over my ex so it wasn't to be), her friend died aged just 25 some years ago and she has sang it at a couple of social clubs we both go to in memory of her friend but it upsets her when she sings it.
Her tones are so signature and I love them!!
I love this song. My favorite song of hers. So beautiful and always gets me emotional when I hear it. That violin was amazing!! 💙💙💙💙
Modern Miley gives me goosebumps
Sweet miley 🥺 im so blessed to have grown up with her and seen her in every era since hannah montana ❤
I vividly remember her performing this at the Grammy’s (or VMA’s? Sorry) with an orchestra and just CRYING. It resonated so much then and does even more now❤
I think it was at Obama's event
it was HM the movie
This song always gives me chills. I remember going to see the Hannah Montana movie with my mom when it came out, and she was not excited cus she thought the show was annoying lol. By the end though, she was sobbing when Miley sang this, and loved the movie so much we bought it when it came out on dvd, and watched it over and over. This woman and her music will always have a special place in my heart. ❤
I love that. That's a beautiful memory.
She has really helped open my eyes to not judging people so much. You never know what they are going through and why they do what they do. Helped me focus more on my own actions and why I do them.
I love her hand movements in time with her vocals! Such a beautiful performer
This song is nostalgic. I loved it as a teen.
She still has that same fire in her soul for music. Thanks to Billy Ray and Godmother Dolly
Kinda sucks that her and her dad apparently don’t talk anymore. Her dad is kinda creepy/weird and quiet now
@@thisbsuchadopekid Doesn't help that her dad rushed into an engagement with a lady around her age.
More like thanks to herself, Miley's doing things that are good for her, for her own soul and happiness, regardless of other people around her
Miley, a phenomenon, incredible❤
Even Miley herself can't top this 2009 masterpiece. And who else had the biggest crush on that guy?
Nah she definitely tops it way more vocal training and experience in
What is the guy real name?
@@nielleanne7549 Lucas Till 🥰
I don't he was mid but I love the songe and the movie
@@animationtvthrowback6152 That's great to know because I asked. 🥱
I'm proud of her! ❤ This 2024, she was honored by Disney as the Disney's Youngest Legend. She did made a big impact for kids. She never gave up on her dreams until she got it and kept working on it❤
I can't explain how Miley inspires me this so deeply.
I've always loved that song, but that new version is so much more! You can hear her feel the words. Just beautiful!
so nostalgic.❤ the grass was greener back in the day
I’m so happy people are giving her the credit she deserves. She’s always been so talented. She’s allowed to be herself and she’s progressed into a great beautiful bean 🥹👏🏼
As a Granna watching z Hannah Montana with my granddaughter, I’ve been pulling for Miley since day one! I loved her then and I love her now. I was worried about her for a while , but she is in a much better head space now! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Miley is EVERYTHING. I love her.
That song sure got me thru A LOT of shit. Love you Miley!!!!!
I love her voice more the older she gets. It has a rusty deepness to it... so good.
Yes, her voice has gotten better as she has matured.
She actually had to have a surgery on her vocal cords. That likely has alot to do with the change
@@rubthemagicbelly wasn't some of it smoke damage from when the wildfires took out her house, too? I thought I heard her say that in an interview.
@@Liv2Pnt She said it was the stress from losing her Malibu home in the Californian fires and she had Reinke's endema hence the vocal cord surgery.Yeah her voice changed but she had to do intense vocal training too!
Y’all she smoked her fucking lungs out taking bong hits day and night…that’s why she sounds like someone who’s smoked a pack of cigarettes a day for 40 years 😂
I love both performances. So different. But so cool sounding.
I used to cry to this song when I was younger still love it to this day 💕💕
This song has always been one of my favorites. 😍
STILL A BANGER. I cry on this song every time.
This Woman is Just in her Prime, so excited to watch Her Climb 🤩🤩🤩
woah her voice is so beautiful in the first one
Love the first one so much more. That innocence and beautiful voice.
Yeah, I agree. She shouldn't have got that vocal cord surgery :(
@@heavenandhello6629She had to get it because her vocal cords were damaged though.
My oldest daughter played this for me when she graduated high school. I had her when i was 21. I sobbed.
Love love this song. When I listen it's on repeat for days....love you miley.
Iconica ❤ ❤
the growth and maturity of her voice comes through in the second performance.
Love love both version! You can tell its her!! And Its one of her signature songs!!
I was raised by Miley songs and witnessing this how emotional she sang thing song makes me cry in the corner
Why does this make me sad and yet so happy at the same time?!
Beautiful song and beautiful inspiration to so many.
My inspirational song 🥺
cause 20's is really hard...
The 2023 performance gives me chills. The song is even better with life experience.
She’s so gorgeous, she deserves all the fan accts
She's come so far in her journey and I've never stopped loving her💜
She just keeps gettin better & better. God, she’s really grown into herself & that voice. So beautiful. That voice is amazeballs.
She was made by the heavens to be a singer. Beautiful performances.
You so beautiful woman to me Miley cyrus 💕🥰🥰🥰
Her live performances are insane.
I’ve only recently realized how much of her music I’ve been enjoying and it’s a lot of her stuff
That song still gives me the chills ❤ Miley is Lyfe
Love her voice
Your voice has matured beautifully! I love it ❤
It’s from severe smoke damage though, not just maturing. But yes, still beautiful
At my kindergarten graduation, they had my entire class sing this song. We practiced it for weeks. I haven't really heard it since until now. It brings back so many feelings and memories.
Miley Cyrus Your my number one amazing singer
Song still slaps ❤ Miley’s voice is perfection
The strings coming in are just 🔥
This hit in the feels
The deepness and humanity in her soul makes the remake much more heartfelt.
She has become one of my favorites
Such a beautiful song.... So beautifully written..so soulfully sung. Love it❤
Seriously slept on vocals. She just does it so effortlessly people never stop to go damn wtf would we hear if she really gave it her all!?!
I'm proud of her growth
Her voice will always be so iconic.
So effortless. Love you Miley ❤True star
This song has meant so much to me throughout the years, and hearing her sing it now, again, makes me fall apart 😭❤
I love that she sings this every year 😩
It's so cool to see how her skills matured. She's not so concerned about hitting everything perfectly in the center of the pitch with flawless breath control and even power - she has much better control of tone color and command of breath. This performance was worlds more interesting and captivating.
That violin always makes me feel so nostalgic
Growth in her voice. Awwn Miley
How beautiful it is to see Miley's growth and grow together over these years. I had no idea this song was from 2009, in my head it was just a few years ago. This song is wonderful and it's great to hear it again and resignify it. ❤
Get it Miley 😭🙌🏽
I feel like she's really embraced her deep voice :) and it's like it's coming from a deeper place too
She has matured so much, she is an absolute idol.
This is the first song that made me fall in love with Miley. So pure.
I'm so proud to see her growth. Like me, I know most people can also relate to her through her music.
“in 2019 she had to undergo surgery due to Reinke’s edema, a condition that causes vocal cords to swell with a build-up of gelatinous fluid, oftentimes caused by excessive and long-term smoking”. Her voice, singing and speaking, is lower now but still fabulous. She is great!
My beautiful girl ❤
It's insane how deep and lovely her voice is, it's matured so beautifully
She goes with her voice and is ceating so many special Versions of her Songs bc that :) just amazing !
This song always makes me cry ❤️