Should Noncitizens Be Allowed To Vote In DC Elections?: Rules Committee Considers Law To Ban It
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
- The House Rules Committee considers pending financial legislation and a bill to ban noncitizens from voting in Washington, D.C., elections.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
Just how many countries in the world allow non-citizens, who are in their country illegally to vote ? ZERO
Most countries allow non citizens to vote in local elections
@@MikeW-dz7ij
You're lying!!
@@MikeW-dz7ijreally Where prove it
@@MikeW-dz7ij😂😂😂
@@mselle66 in most every country in Europe. Look it up
🇺🇸NOT A U.S. CITIZEN? HERE ILLEGALLY? UGH... HELL NO! HOW DISRESPECTFUL TO AMERICA & AMERICANS! WHY IS THIS EVEN A QUESTION🤷🤦
The constitution doesn’t have a problem with this so why do you?
It’s not racist, it’s common sense. Almost all other countries do not even consider allowing illegal people to stay in their countries, work and especially not having a say in their elections. This is ridiculous and dangerous.
hey frankie, do us a favor & go back to the cartoon world
@@MikeW-dz7ij
Sounds like you haven't
read the Constitution!
That has got to be a Democrat rule
NO ABSOLUTELY NOT.LEGAL CITIZENS ONLY.
The constitution disagrees with
that`s a local issue decided by the residents of DC... and it`s why our Revolutionary war was begun taxation without representation, sunshine
@@MikeW-dz7ij
You evidently lack
comprehensive skills
@@MikeW-dz7ij Only citizens are allowed to vote per the constitution, otherwise there is no reason for citizenship.
@@tommytbone9778 Nice try, but that ship wont sail..
the fact that this is brought up shows how far this country sucks
No. What a joke that question is. Is it not illegal for them to vote? What RIGHT do they have to vote?
Federal law bans noncitizens from voting in federal elections, including races for president, vice president, Senate or House of Representatives.
The 1996 law states that noncitizens who vote illegally will face a fine, imprisonment or both. Noncitizens who cast a ballot and get caught may also face deportation.
Not just no,
but HELL NO!!!
It should be illegal to even try to vote as a non citizen. No photo I’d, no vote.
The constitution says otherwise
@@Mike-hd7ko explain your analysis nimrod?
@@Vrie. what about the constitution do you not understand?
@@Mike-hd7ko The part which you don’t understand….
Are you not aware that they do have photo IDs and in some cases have been given Social Security cards, even though they are here illegally
No non-citizen should be allowed to vote at any level of government, local, state nor federal!!
And HOA only if legal...
Federal law bans noncitizens from voting in federal elections, including races for president, vice president, Senate or House of Representatives.
The 1996 law states that noncitizens who vote illegally will face a fine, imprisonment or both. Noncitizens who cast a ballot and get caught may also face deportation.
@@deborahplasencia1833 We're aware of that thank you. We're talking about the elections where non-citizens aren't banned and suggesting the only election a non-citizen should be allowed to vote in is an HOA election, and only if they are legal residents!
Anyone else serve our country and want their time and soul back?
I’d like my two uncles back. They died in our wars because they believed they had a country worth defending.
Me
After the planes went into the towers I filled out my application, got my references, and then had a talk with my mother: she said "We have always supported the military in this family so of course I'll support you and be proud of you, BUT do you trust this government not to betray you, and if they do well you be OK knowing you served your country and were then betrayed by it?
A lot of people make fun of those of us who "almost joined", but with 20/20 hindsight, we made the right decision!
With all my heart, thank you for your service, please know that in my civilian life I have always made every effort to do right by those of you who chose to wear the uniform, and I truly hope you "get your soul back", even if you can never get your time and your body back.
lol that’s a good way to put it brother!
Think about that a lot
A non-citizen should not be allowed to vote on anything
The constitution disagrees
@@Mike-hd7ko explain your analysis nimrod
@@Vrie. what about the constitution do you not understand?
@@Mike-hd7ko
You don't know the constitution....your just picking at people
@@Vrie. he could buy you books, send you to school BUT you`d spend it on bubble gum
I want a ballot for all my cats and dogs and farm animals
Good one! 😂
😂😂Lol
Hell no ! They can't speak ENGLISH for Pete's sake and you want them to vote ? NO!!!!
😂 can't read it either so who fills in the blank 😂😂😂😂 cheaters cheaters
The USA has never officially declared a national language.
what does 'speaking american english' have to do with having the right to vote?
The correct answer is no
How is this even a question???
It’s only a question for people who haven’t read the constitution
Wow I cannot believe this even a question. Fuck No!
Tourists can vote on the best burger in town but not vote on our government.
But non citizen residents can in local elections.
@@MikeW-dz7ij
I have a problem with that too. But I’m just a taxpayer who makes all the magic government stuff possible.
@merlesmith6794 Love this! Should be a tshirt....
No. This is a NO BRAINER!
No , just US citizen only.
Stupid question!!!! NO!
Sounds like this should be up to DC
@@MikeW-dz7ijSounds like the "democrats" should stop trying to interfere in elections, by "interfere" I mean cheat.
Amazing this is even a question. Why would a noncitizen be allowed to vote in any country?
Federal law bans noncitizens from voting in federal elections, including races for president, vice president, Senate or House of Representatives.
The 1996 law states that noncitizens who vote illegally will face a fine, imprisonment or both. Noncitizens who cast a ballot and get caught may also face deportation.
Absolutely not
Why?
People in DC shouldn’t have the same rights as everyone else?
@@MikeW-dz7ijbecause it's common sense that non-citizens should not vote
@@XiWinnie69who made you the gatekeeper of common sense?
@@XiWinnie69you don’t in DC should have the same rights as everyone else?
Nobody that is not a citizen should EVER be allowed to vote in the elections.
No illegal should be allowed to vote ....
Only American people
( ONLY American)
The constitution disagrees
@@Mike-hd7ko
No it don't
I'm reading it right now.
If you can tell me what part of the constitution
I will read it .
If not
It means your not from here
@@Mike-hd7ko
As a American
I vote legally as a American.
And voting Trump anyway.🇺🇲
@@Mike-hd7ko
Mike
Your a jerk
Absolutely not!!!
No to answer the title!
No
To bad for you
@@MikeW-dz7ijtoo bad for you that non-citizens can't vote😅. Womp womp
@@XiWinnie69actually they can and they have been for nearly a century
NO.
Why not? Shouldn’t DC get to decide for themselves
@@MikeW-dz7ij you think city of Moscow could decide non-citizens can vote? Or any other cities in this world? Maybe stop annoying others with brainless comments, bot.
@@XiWinnie69if you like Moscow better then you should move there lol
@@MikeW-dz7ijdc shouldn't be voting on anything, as the founders intended.
@@noneyabizz8337why?
Why is this even a question. The empire is crumbling
You need to be a citizen
The constitution disagrees
@@MikeW-dz7ij explain your analysis nimrod?
@@Vrie.read the constitution
@@Vrie. let me finish for ya, Padna... this subject is above the nimrods mental capabilities but maybe he can call up Hobba... the sexiest lawyer in New Jersey but it took brains to win the case for her perv client, rut row
@@MikeW-dz7ij how so kemosabby....
No !
Sounds like this should be up to people in DC no?
@@MikeW-dz7ij explain your analysis nimrod?
@@MikeW-dz7ij explain your analysis nimrod??
@@Vrie.the constitution. How’s that for an explanation
Why is this even a question?
Its political agenda again it seems yesterday conspiracy theory become today reality. Its seems it is really import of new voters.
I think that if if the immigrants that are Crossing into the United States are allowed to vote then we should also allow Israel to vote in the United States also along with other Allied countries
These are citizens of rival countries, not "non-citizens."
Of course they should not vote in our elections.
That should never be a question they should not vote.
No. Fuck no.
A G R E E
No!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Absolutely not, how absurd to even think or say that! I’m absolutely shocked how politicians and news media think about our country security!!!
Voting is a right for American citizens not for illegals. The fact that this is even a question shows the stupidity of those promoting this.
Voting always was and is right and privilege of citizen in every country that exist and existed before it actually was whole point of existence of concept of citizenship but here we are.
NO! Non citizens should NOT be allowed to vote. You are not a country if you allow anyone outside citizenship to vote. I've never heard anything so ridiclous in my life. No other country would allow this.
It is crazy that we even are having this conversation. No country in the world allows non-citizens to vote in elections. Only citizens should be allowed to vote, and voters should prove their ID with a government issued ID card (with picture) to prove their identity.
Hell no
What a dumb question!!! No citizens, no vote ,-- period
No! That's ridiculous.
Non citizens shouldn't be allowed to vote at all anywhere.
NO ! NO ! NO !
IT IS FOR THE CITIZENS !!
Why is this even a question? What country on earth allows non-citizens to vote? Who's the crazy person who asked this question?
this is insane
No. You got citizens who had felonies 20 years ago that are completely different people now who cant vote. Why in the world would this even sound like a good idea to anybody.
No none citizen-no illegal immigrants voting!!!! What kind of question is that?
Let's ask Iran China Saudi Arabia India all other countries that vote in elections, if they would allow none citizens to vote in their elections. The answer would be no!! This is the dumbest question!!!! What would make a crazy ask if non-citizens should be able to vote?!!!!
No one should be allow to vote unless you are a legal citizen of the U S A.
How do I get my mail in ballots from CHINA 😂😂😂😂
ABSOLUTELY NOT!
Hell no.
Wtf hell no
This is about cryto failures of privacy laws.
In that case everyone should just vote for other countries leaders as well itll be like betting at the casinos 😂😂😂😂
That makes no sense
Other countries leaders aren’t on the ballot 😂
@MikeW-dz7ij you can always write it a candidate.
You're not American.
@@noneyabizz8337 This is false.
@@Mike-hd7ko so, you chose not to recant or acknowledge your incorrect statement at all.
Class. Such class.
NO, NO, NO, ABSOLUTELY NOT!!!!
Well im lost .... why would you be able to vote in a country your not a part of ??? Whys this even being talked about ?
No. This is a ridiculous question.
That's a ridiculous question. Should I be allowed to go vote in an election in Italy? I don't think so.
Noncitizens NO vote! Americans only!
Marg, does this include Pelosi illegal dealings with insider trading???😮
HELL NO.WTF!!!!
They better 😤 not vote 😤!!!!!!!!!!!!!....
Bring back the pledge of allegiance in schools .....and more importantly start acting on it ...
stupid question
Of course not
AMERICA WILL NEVER ALLOW THAT EVER❤️🇺🇸❤️
not just no but HELL NO!!!
Thank you Mr. Roy for speaking up for Americans & Privacy failures. May 21, 2024
Hell no!
NO. Ban it already.
How the freak is this even a question ⁉️
No, hell no, absolutely not, under no circumstances!!! No No No
STUPID QUESTION!
Haven’t read the constitution eh?
NO! NO! NO!
SOMEHOW WE AS AMERICAS SHOULD SOMEHOW BE ABLE .
IF WE CAN GO ON 9THE AIR MAKE POSTERS SAYING
“A VOTE FO😢R “biding”
IS A VOTE FOR MAKING “AMERICA “
VENEZUELA
DO YOU WANT FREEDOM OR COMMUNISM communism?😢
NO WAY!!!!!
The constitution disagrees
@@Mike-hd7koyour crazy is starting to show, you may want to tuck that under!
@@karenkeck-chambers5111 You clearly haven't read the constitution
No agency shall have the right to make law
No, if you are not a citizen of the United states you can't vote. Recently we watched Washington part time citizens of congress work to change laws passed by the city because they didn't like them.
HELL NO👿👿👿
NO!!
Can I get a I told you so regarding where this was all going with their open border policies over the past few years but kept denying had anything to do with it?
these folk you speak of are here legally, sunshine... stop wasting your time watching foxytv and go to work
@@tommytbone9778 *illegaly crosses another nations sovereign borders* “they are here legally 🤡”
No they're being propped up by people who have no respect for the law. How on earth do you figure any of this is legal? Foxtv? I have a strong feeling you believe this is all normal bc u likely spend a bit of time on cnn, I could be wrong. Go to work? Yeh let me just go hop back into construction. I've said all along the only reason democrats are so shamelessly trying to usher in all the mass caravans is because their trying to dilute the informed vote. And look where were at now. I'd also stand in line for an I told ya so, but I have no expectations of ever seeing any honesty out of people defending this behavior
NO
Maxine waters gets paid to read someone else’s arguments 😂
No they shouldnt
They should not be used in any population value ether
Why the hell would they be?!?!?!?
This shouldn't even be considered at all..WTH!?
NO!
No they should not be aloud to vote in any elections. This has to be the dumbest question I've heard. Why don't you ask our veterans that. I have no problem with people coming here legally. And becoming citizens. Then they can vote. I think you have to ne a citizen for 3 years before you can legally vote. Does anyone have a answer on that
You cant complain about Russia interfering in our elections when you're advocating for foreign interference (non citizen vote)
NO!!!!!!
This would open up voting to anyone in the world - if they allowed non-citizens to vote.
First it will be a debate, then it will be done at local level, then state, then eventually federal, then everyone will act like it’s always been the case and will never be rolled back.
Non-Citizens are there to FOLLOW the LAW - NOT make the LAW PERIOD!!!!!
How much money has the Americans lost to our government that can spend money handover fast without any any guilt to the taxpayer
Absolutely No.
To what end!? Sending out ballots world wide. ???!
This non citizen voting is absolute insanity.
Absolutely not, why should they ?